Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
Cr. MP (M) No. 2972 of 2025
Reserved on: 16.01.2026
Date of Decision:23.01.2026
Irfan Mohd.
...Petitioner
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh
...Respondent
Coram
Hon’ble Mr Justice Rakesh Kainthla, Vacation Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the Petitioner
:
Mr
Peeyush
Verma,
Sr.
Advocate, with Mr Kush
Sharma, Advocate.
For the Respondent/State
:
Mr Prashant Sen,
Advocate General.
Deputy
Rakesh Kainthla, Vacation Judge
The petitioner has filed the present petition for
seeking regular bail in F.I.R. No. 145 of 2025, dated 01.07.2025,
registered in Police Station Paonta Sahib, District Sirmaur, H.P.,
for the commission of offences punishable under Sections 333,
109, 191(2), 191(3), 190, 115(2), 351(2) and 61(2) of Bharatiya
Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS).
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes.
2.
It has been asserted that the petitioner is innocent
and that he was falsely implicated because of political rivalry.
The allegations against the petitioner are false. The petitioner
was beaten, and he had sustained multiple injuries. The police
have filed the charge sheet, and no fruitful purpose would be
served by detaining the petitioner in custody; hence, it was
prayed that the present petition be allowed and the petitioner be
released on bail.
3.
The petition is opposed by filing a status report
asserting that the informant Harpal Chaudhary and Vikram were
present in the informant’s house on 01.07.2025. Vikram had met
with an accident, and his leg was plastered. His friend Surjeet,
Vaibhav,
Vishal,
Sunil
and
Anas
Khan
had
visited
the
informant’s house to inquire about Vikram’s well-being. All of
them were talking to each other. Five people armed with sticks
and an iron rod came to the house at 5:40 pm. They had covered
their faces. They gave beatings to the informant and other
persons. The informant party shouted for help, and the villagers
gathered on the spot. One person, who identified himself as
Irfan (the present petitioner), was apprehended.
The injured
were taken to the hospital for treatment. The police registered
the FIR and investigated the matter. Irfan revealed during the
investigation that Sandeep, Nigam, Adil, Ashu and Sohail Khan
were involved in the incident. Police arrested Sohail Khan. He
revealed during interrogation that he had handed over his
motorcycle bearing registration no. HP17C-0390 to Adil. Adil,
Irfan, Ashu, Sadakat, Sandeep and Nigam drove two motorcycles
to the spot. They returned at about 6:30 pm and revealed that
Irfan was apprehended on the spot. FIR No. 190/2023, dated
02.12.2023, is registered against the petitioner in Police Station
Kala Amb. As per the report of the medical officer, the injured
had sustained grievous injuries. The chargesheet was prepared
and presented before the learned Addl. Session Judge, Paonta
Sahib on 27.09.2025.
The petitioner would indulge in the
commission of similar offences and intimidate the witnesses, in
case of his release on bail. Hence, it was prayed that the present
petition be dismissed.
4.
I have heard Mr Peeyush Verma, learned Senior
Counsel, assisted by Mr Kush Sharma, Advocate, for the
petitioner and Mr Prashant Sen, learned Deputy Advocate
General, for the respondent/State.
5.
Mr Peeyush Verma, learned Senior Counsel, for the
petitioner, submitted that the petitioner is innocent and he was
falsely implicated. The police have filed the charge sheet, and no
fruitful purpose would be served by detaining the petitioner in
custody. The petitioner has roots in society, and he would abide
by the terms and conditions that the Court may impose. Mere
pendency of the criminal case is no reason to deny bail to a
person. He prayed that the present petition be allowed and the
petitioner be released on bail. He relied upon the judgments of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Union of India Vs. Mrityunjay
Kumar Singh @ Mrityunjay @ Sonu Singh (2024 INSC 404) and
Abhimanue Vs. State of Kerala (2025 INSC 1136) in support of his
submissions.
6.
Mr Prashant Sen, learned Dy. Advocate General, for
the respondent/State, submitted that the petitioner had earlier
filed a bail petition, which was dismissed by the Court, and the
subsequent bail petition only lies when there is a change in the
circumstances. The petitioner has failed to establish any change
in the circumstances; therefore, he prayed that the present
petition be dismissed.
7.
I have given considerable thought to the submissions
made at the bar and have gone through the records carefully.
8.
It is undisputed that the petitioner had earlier filed a
bail petition, which was registered as Cr.MP(M) No.2335 of 2025,
and was dismissed on 27.10.2025. It was held in the State of
Maharashtra. Captain Buddhikota Subha Rao (1989) Suppl. 2 SCC
605, that once a bail application has been dismissed, a
subsequent bail application can only be considered if there is a
change of circumstances. It was observed:
“Once that application was rejected, there was no question
of granting a similar prayer. That is virtually overruling the
earlier decision without there being a change in the fact
situation. And when we speak of change, we mean a
substantial one, which has a direct impact on the earlier
decision and not merely cosmetic changes, which are of
little or no consequence. 'Between the two orders, there was
a gap of only two days, and it is nobody's case that during
these two days, drastic changes had taken place,
necessitating the release of the respondent on bail. Judicial
discipline, propriety and comity demanded that the
impugned order should not have been passed, reversing all
earlier orders, including the one rendered by Puranik, J.,
only a couple of days before, in the absence of any
substantial change in the fact situation. In such cases, it is
necessary to act with restraint and circumspection so that
the process of the Court is not abused by a litigant and an
impression does not gain ground that the litigant has either
successfully avoided one judge or selected another to secure
an order which had hitherto eluded him.
9.
Similarly, it was held in Kalyan Chandra Sarkar v.
Rajesh Ranjan @ Pappu Yadav (2004) 7 SCC 528 that where an
earlier bail application has been rejected, the Court has to
consider the rejection of the earlier bail application and then
consider why the subsequent bail application should be allowed.
It was held:
“11. In regard to cases where earlier bail applications have
been rejected, there is a further onus on the court to
consider the subsequent application for grant of bail by
noticing the grounds on which earlier bail applications
have been rejected and after such consideration, if the
court is of the opinion that bail has to be granted then
the said court will have to give specific reasons why in
spite of such earlier rejection the subsequent bail
application should be granted.”
10.
A similar view was taken in State of T.N. v. S.A. Raja,
(2005) 8 SCC 380, wherein it was observed:
9. When a learned Single Judge of the same court had
denied bail to the respondent for certain reasons, and that
order was unsuccessfully challenged before the appellate
forum, without there being any major change of
circumstances, another fresh application should not have
been dealt with within a short span of time unless there
were valid grounds giving rise to a tenable case for bail. Of
course, the principles of res judicata are not applicable to
bail applications, but the repeated filing of bail
applications without there being any change of
circumstances would lead to bad precedents.”
11.
This position was reiterated in Prasad Shrikant
Purohit v. State of Maharashtra (2018) 11 SCC 458, wherein it was
observed:
“30. Before concluding, we must note that though an
accused has a right to make successive applications for
the grant of bail, the court entertaining such subsequent
bail applications has a duty to consider the reasons and
grounds on which the earlier bail applications were
rejected. In such cases, the court also has a duty to record
the fresh grounds, which persuade it to take a view
different from the one taken in the earlier applications.”
12.
It was held in Ajay Rajaram Hinge v. State of
Maharashtra, 2023 SCC OnLine Bom 1551, that a successive bail
application can be filed if there is a material change in the
circumstances, which means a change in the facts or the law. It
was observed:
“7. It needs to be noted that the right to file successive
bail applications accrues to the applicant only on the
existence of a material change in circumstances. The sine
qua non for filing subsequent bail applications is a
material change in circumstances. A material change in
circumstances settled by law is a change in the fact
situation or law that requires the earlier view to be
interfered with or where the earlier finding has become
obsolete. However, a change in circumstance has no
bearing on the salutary principle of judicial propriety that
successive bail application needs to be decided by the
same Judge on the merits, if available at the place of
sitting. There needs to be clarity between the power of a
judge to consider the application and a person's right
based on a material change in circumstances. A material
change in circumstance creates in a person accused of an
offence the right to file a fresh bail application. But the
power to decide such a subsequent application operates in
a completely different sphere, unconnected with the facts
of a case. Such power is based on the well-settled and
judicially recognized principle that if successive bail
applications on the same subject are permitted to be
disposed of by different Judges, there would be
conflicting orders, and the litigant would be pestering
every Judge till he gets an order to his liking resulting in
the credibility of the Court and the confidence of the other
side being put in issue and there would be wastage of
Court's time and that judicial discipline requires that such
matter must be placed before the same Judge, if he is
available, for orders. The satisfaction of material change
in circumstances needs to be adjudicated by the same
Judge who had earlier decided the application. Therefore,
the same Judge needs to adjudicate whether there is a
change in circumstance as claimed by the applicant,
which entitles him to file a subsequent bail application.”
13.
Therefore, the present bail petition can only be
considered on the basis of the change in the circumstances, and
it is not permissible to review the order passed by the Court.
14.
The Court had earlier held in the bail petition that
there was sufficient material to connect the petitioner with the
commission of the crime. His plea that he was beaten by the
villagers and was falsely implicated was prima facie not
acceptable, and he was not entitled to bail.
considerations have not changed.
All these
15.
It was submitted that a charge sheet has been filed,
and this is a change in circumstance. This submission cannot be
accepted. It was laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Virupakshappa Gouda v. State of Karnataka, (2017) 5 SCC 406:
(2017) 2 SCC (Cri) 542: 2017 SCC OnLine SC 295 that the filing of a
charge sheet does not amount to a change in circumstances. It
was observed:
“12. On a perusal of the order passed by the learned trial
Judge, we find that he has been swayed by the fact that
when a charge sheet is filed, it amounts to a change of
circumstance. Needless to say, the filing of the charge
sheet does not in any manner lessen the allegations made
by the prosecution. On the contrary, filing of the charge
sheet establishes that after due investigation, the
investigating agency, having found materials, has placed
the charge sheet for the trial of the accused persons.”
16.
It was submitted that the plea taken by the petitioner
that he had acted in the right of his private defence is highly
probable. This plea has already been found to be not established
by the Court in the earlier petition and cannot be adjudicated
afresh in the present case. It was laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in State of M.P. v. Kajad, (2001) 7 SCC 673: 2001
SCC (Cri) 1520: 2001 SCC OnLine SC 1070 that it is impermissible
to review the earlier order of bail in the subsequent bail petition,
and the Court can only consider the change in circumstances. It
was observed on page 676:
8. It has further to be noted that the factum of the
rejection of his earlier bail application bearing
Miscellaneous Case No. 2052 of 2000 on 5-6-2000 has
not been denied by the respondent. It is true that
successive bail applications are permissible under the
changed circumstances. But without the change in the
circumstances, the second application would be deemed
to be seeking review of the earlier judgment, which is not
permissible under criminal law, as has been held by this
Court in Hari Singh Mann v. Harbhajan Singh Bajwa
[(2001) 1 SCC 169: 2001 SCC (Cri) 113] and various other
judgments.
17.
Therefore, it is impermissible to review the earlier
order passed by this Court.
18.
The burden of proving that the case of the accused
comes with the exception is upon him as per Section 108 of
Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023. Thus, the proof of the
exception is a matter of trial and cannot be adjudicated based on
the FIR registered after the registration of the present FIR.
19.
It was submitted that the criminal antecedents are
not sufficient to deny bail to a person. The submission will not
help the petitioner. This Court dealt with the relevance of
criminal antecedents while granting bail in Champa vs. State of
H.P.: 2025:HHC:28899 and held that the criminal antecedents
would disentitle an accused from the concession of bail,
especially when an FIR was registered against the accused
related to the commission of a similar offence. This judgment
was unsuccessfully assailed before the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in SLP (Criminal) 19120 of 2025 titled Champa Devi vs. State of H.P.,
decided on 27.11.2025. Therefore, the relevance of criminal
antecedents cannot be ignored, and the petitioner’s criminal
antecedents would disentitle him from concessions of bail.
20.
In Abhimanue (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court
held that mere criminal antecedents cannot be used to deny bail
to a person who has made out a case for the grant of bail, and
when the period of incarceration justified the grant of bail. In the
present case, the petitioner has failed to make out a case for the
grant of bail, and the cited judgment will not help him.
21.
In Mrityunjay Kumar Singh @ Mrityunjay @ Sonu
Singh (Supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court found that the High
Court had rightly granted bail, and mere criminal antecedents
were not sufficient to deny bail to the person. In the present
case, there is sufficient material on record to connect the
petitioner to the commission of the crime, and in view of the
judgment in Champa (supra), it is not permissible to grant bail
to the petitioner because of the criminal antecedents of the
petitioner; hence, the cited judgment will not help the
petitioner.
22.
No other point was urged.
23.
In view of the above, the present petition fails, and
the same is dismissed.
24.
The observation made hereinbefore shall remain
confined to the disposal of the instant petition and will have no
bearing, whatsoever, on the merits of the case.
23rd January, 2026
(Gaurav Rawat)
(Rakesh Kainthla)
Vacation Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review