Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
%
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Judgment reserved on: 24.02.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 19.05.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 19.05.2026
+
FAO(OS) (COMM) 212/2024 & CM APPL. 54328/2024
IRCON INTERNATIONAL LIMITED
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Suman Doval & Mr.
Lakshay Chaudhary, Advs.
versus
M/S. TANTIA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Sanjoy Bhaumik, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
JUDGMENT
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.:
1.
Through the present Appeal filed under Section 37 of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 19961 [hereinafter referred to as
‘A&C Act’], the Appellant assails the correctness of the judgment
dated 24.07.2024 [hereinafter referred to as ‘Impugned Judgment’]
passed by the learned Single Judge in OMP (COMM) 277/2021. The
said petition had been instituted under Section 34 [hereinafter referred
to as ‘Section 34 Petition’] of the A&C Act2, assailing the arbitral
award dated 23.01.2020 [hereinafter referred to as ‘the Award’]
rendered by the learned Sole Arbitrator [hereinafter referred to as ‘the
Arbitrator’]. By the Impugned Judgment, the learned Single Judge
declined interference and upheld the Award.
Section 37
Section 34
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
FAO(OS)(COMM) 212/2024
16:41:50
2.
The present Appeal is confined to Claim No.6 of the Award as
admitted by the learned Counsel representing the Appellant in the
Order dated 17.09.2024 of this Court. The Appellant submits that the
computation undertaken by the Arbitrator in respect of the said claim
suffers from patent illegality inasmuch as an amount relatable to
mobilization advance, which, according to the Appellant, stood
recovered/adjusted, has not been duly accounted for, thereby resulting
in an alleged excess award in favour of the Respondent. It is
contended that the learned Single Judge erred in declining interference
under Section 34 despite the aforesaid infirmity.
3.
Since the present proceedings arise under Section 37 against an
order refusing to set aside the Award, the scope of interference is
necessarily limited. The question that arises for consideration is
whether the learned Single Judge committed any error in declining to
interfere with the Award under Section 34, particularly when the
Appellant alleges that the amount awarded under Claim No.6 fails to
account for adjustment of mobilization advance, thereby resulting in
an excess payment in favour of the Respondent.
FACTUAL MATRIX:
4.
Before examining the rival submissions advanced on behalf of
the parties, it would be appropriate to briefly notice the factual
background giving rise to the present Appeal.
5.
The dispute between the parties arises out of a Contract
Agreement dated 07.12.2012 executed between the Appellant and the
Respondent for the execution of certain works. Differences having
arisen in relation to the execution of the contract and the financial
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
FAO(OS)(COMM) 212/2024
16:41:50
claims emanating therefrom, the dispute was referred to arbitration in
terms of the arbitration clause contained in the Contract Agreement.
6.
Pursuant thereto, the Arbitrator, Sh. Harpal Singh (Chief
Engineer, Headquarters, Northern Railways) was appointed to
adjudicate the disputes between the parties. The Respondent herein,
being the claimant before the Arbitrator, preferred its Statement of
Claims dated 11.05.2016, raising multiple claims against the
Appellant. The Appellant filed its Statement of Defence dated
03.10.2016, contesting the claims. The parties thereafter filed their
respective written submissions and led material in support of their
respective cases.
7.
Upon consideration of the pleadings, material on record and
submissions advanced on behalf of the parties, the Arbitrator rendered
the Award dated 23.01.2020, adjudicating the claims of the
Respondent and awarding a sum of Rs.4,80,37,967/- in its favour. The
Appellant, disputing the correctness of the computation, contended
that the Award granted an amount in excess of what was due and,
consequently, released only a partial sum of Rs.3,80,59,951/- to the
Respondent.
8.
Pertinently, it is recorded by the learned Single Judge in the
Impugned Judgment that the plea of adjustment of an amount of
Rs.93,01,410/-, sought to be urged in the Section 34 Petition by the
Appellant, had not been raised before the Arbitrator in the Statement
of Defence.
9.
Since the present Appeal is confined to Claim No.6 of the
Award, the justification of the said claim as provided in the Statement
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
FAO(OS)(COMM) 212/2024
16:41:50
of Claim, the reasoning adopted by the Arbitrator while allowing the
claim, and the outcome thereof are noticed hereinbelow for ready
reference:
“Claim 6: Payment of illegally en-cashed Performance Bank
Guarantee
The Claimant would like to state that a Performance Bank Guarantee
was provided to the Respondent as per condition of the Contract,
which was encashed by the Respondent. The contract could not be
performed due various reasons not attributial to the Claimant for with
time extension without imposition of Liquidated damages was granted
by the Respondent form time to time. Even the reciprocal promises of
giving possession of site to the Claimant by the Respondent could not
be complied by the Respondent even on the date of termination and
even today. So question of non-performance by the claimant is
baseless and encashment of Performance Bank Guarantee is a
unilateral decision of the respondent which is challengeable. Learned
Arbitrator is prayed to adjudicate the matter.”
***
“CLAIM NO. 6
REASONS FOR AWARD:- As deliberated in above paras, the
termination of the contract was wrongful, illegal and arbitrary due to
the occurrence of earthquake in Nepal which also led to declaration
of National Emergency, severely affected the citizens. Tender
categorically stipulates that in the event of occurrence of a force
majeure event, neither party shall be entitled to terminate the contract
in respect of non-performance or delay in performance. Hence, claim
amount of Rs.1,90,86,595/- is reasonable and payable.”
***
Claim No.
Nature of Claim
Findings of the Tribunal
Claim
relating
to
encashment/recovery
under the Performance
Bank Guarantee (‘PBG’)
Rs.1,90,86,595/Amount
awarded in favour of the
Respondent, rejecting the
Appellant’s justification for
such encashment
10.
It is relevant to note that under the Award, the Arbitrator also
dealt with Claim No.7, which pertained to mobilization advance and
its recovery/adjustment. The Arbitrator recorded that the mobilization
advance extended by the Appellant stood secured and was subject to
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
FAO(OS)(COMM) 212/2024
16:41:50
recoveries effected during the execution of the works, including
through running account bills as well as encashment of the PBG. The
reasons of the Arbitrator for awarding Claim No.7 are reproduced
hereinbelow for ready reference:
“CLAIM NO.7
REASONS FOR AWARD:- The Bank Guarantee amounting to
Rs.1,09,95,254/- was lying with the Respondent out of which an
amount of Rs.1,00,89.966/- was recovered by the Respondent from the
IPCs/RA-Bills during execution of work upto RA-16 and the interest
thereon was also recovered.
The balance to be recovered by the Respondent was only
Rs.9,06,104/- plus interest Rs./-, totalling Rs./-. However, the
Respondent has encashed the entire amount of Mobilization Advance
Bank Guarantee of Rs.1,09,95,254/- and thus, an amount of
Rs.99,81,401/- is liable to be refunded to the Claimant.
Thus, Claimant is entitled to the refund of Rs.99,81,317/- on this
account as per claim.”
11.
Subsequent to the Award, the Appellant filed an application
under Section 33 of the A&C Act3 seeking modification/rectification
of the Award on the ground of alleged computational errors. By way
of a supplementary award dated 20.08.2020, certain modifications
came to be made. However, the said supplementary award was
assailed in OMP (COMM) 593/2020 and, by judgment dated
13.04.2021, the same was set aside.
12.
Aggrieved by the Award dated 23.01.2020, the Appellant
instituted the Section 34 Petition being OMP (COMM) 277/2021
before this Court, inter alia, seeking modification of the Award in
respect of certain claims, including Claim Nos.6 and 12. The
Respondent filed its reply thereto, opposing the challenge.
Section 33
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
FAO(OS)(COMM) 212/2024
16:41:50
13.
The learned Single Judge, vide the Impugned Judgment dated
24.07.2024, declined to interfere with the Award and dismissed the
Section 34 Petition, inter alia, holding that:
i.
The findings returned by the Arbitrator on Claim No.6
were based on a plausible interpretation of the contractual
provisions, including the applicability of the force majeure
clause, and did not suffer from perversity or arbitrariness
warranting interference under Section 34.
ii.
The challenge was confined to quantum and not to the
underlying liability.
iii.
The Arbitrator had proceeded on the basis that the
termination of the contract by the Appellant was wrongful, and
consequently, invocation of the PBG was impermissible; these
findings, including those relating to force majeure, were not
under challenge.
iv.
The plea of adjustment of an amount of Rs.93,01,410/-,
now sought to be urged by the Appellant, had not been raised
before the Arbitrator in the statement of defence, and could not
be permitted to be raised for the first time in proceedings under
Section 34.
v.
Permitting the Appellant to rely upon contentions raised
in the Section 33 proceedings would amount to circumventing
the effect of the judgment dated 13.04.2021, which was
impermissible in law.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
FAO(OS)(COMM) 212/2024
16:41:50
14.
Aggrieved by the dismissal of the Section 34 Petition, the
Appellant has preferred the present Appeal under Section 37. During
the course of proceedings, the Appellant has confined the challenge
only to Claim No.6 of the Award.
15.
It is in this backdrop that, vide order dated 17.09.2024, this
Court directed the Respondent to file an affidavit clarifying whether
the mobilization advance extended by the Appellant had been duly
adjusted. The relevant extract of the said order is reproduced
hereinbelow for ready reference:
“ORDER Dated 17.09.2024
.........
6. According to the appellant, there were two (02) "computational
errors" in the impugned award concerning Claim No.6 and Claim No.
12.
7. We may note that at the very outset, Mr. Suman Doval, learned
counsel, who appears on behalf of the appellant, on the instructions,
says that the appeal is restricted only to Claim No.6
7.1 The statement of Mr. Doval is taken on record.
………
11. We may note that Claim No.6 concerns wrongful encashment of
performance of bank guarantee.
11.1 The record discloses that qua this claim, the respondent has been
awarded Rs.1,90,86,595/-.
12. According to the appellant, since the mobilization advance was
adjusted, the amount awarded under Claim No.6 should have been
frozen at Rs.97,85,184/-.
12.1 Towards mobilization advance, the adjustment that the appellant
claimed was that of Rs.93,01,410/-.
13. To be noted, the learned Single Judge refrained from interfering
with the award in view of the law laid down by the Supreme Court in
Project Director, NHAI v. M. Hakeem & Anr. (2021) 9 SCC 1.
14. The respondent, up until this stage, has not answered as to
whether mobilization advance, which was extended by the appellant,
was adjusted against the final bill.
14.1 We would like the respondent to file an affidavit in this behalf.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
FAO(OS)(COMM) 212/2024
16:41:50
15. The moot question that will arise for consideration, perhaps, if
the appellant is right would be: Can the respondent receive more
than what is due to it?
.........”
(Emphasis Supplied)
16.
Pursuant thereto, an affidavit has been filed on behalf of the
Respondent stating, inter alia, that the mobilization advance stood
fully recovered/adjusted, including through encashment of the PBG as
well as recoveries effected during the execution of the works, and that
the Award had been computed after taking the same into account.
17.
In the aforesaid backdrop, we proceed to notice the submissions
advanced on behalf of the parties.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES:
18.
Heard learned Counsel for the parties at length and, with their
able assistance, perused the material placed on record.
19.
Learned Counsel representing the Appellant, while contending
that the amount awarded under Claim No.6 has not been
correspondingly reduced, resulting in duplication and permitting the
Respondent to receive more than what is due, has submitted as under:
i.
A perusal of the Award would show that the Arbitrator
has failed to account for an amount of Rs.93,01,410/-, which had
already been recovered/adjusted by the Appellant towards
mobilization advance, thereby resulting in an inflated award.
ii.
The findings recorded by the Arbitrator under Claim
No.7 demonstrate that recoveries towards mobilization advance
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
FAO(OS)(COMM) 212/2024
16:41:50
had already been effected, including through running account
bills and encashment of the PBG.
iii.
The Respondent, even in its affidavit filed pursuant to the
order dated 17.09.2024, has failed to clearly demonstrate that the
said amount stands duly accounted for in the computation of the
Award.
20.
Per contra, learned Counsel for the Respondent has made the
following submissions:
i.
The scope of interference under Section 37 is extremely
limited and does not permit re-appreciation of evidence.
ii.
The challenge raised by the Appellant is confined to
quantum, and the findings of the Arbitrator on liability, including
wrongful termination and applicability of force majeure, have
attained finality.
iii.
The plea of adjustment of Rs.93,01,410/- was never
raised before the Arbitrator and cannot be permitted to be urged
for the first time in proceedings under Section 34 or in the
present Appeal.
iv.
The Appellant had sought to raise the said plea in
proceedings under Section 33. However, the supplementary
award passed thereon has been set aside by this Court by
judgment dated 13.04.2021, which has attained finality.
v.
The mobilization advance stood duly adjusted and
accounted for, as is evident from the Award, including the
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
FAO(OS)(COMM) 212/2024
16:41:50
findings under Claim No.7, as well as from the affidavit filed by
the Respondent.
21.
Learned Counsel for the parties have not made any other
submissions.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS:
22.
This Court has considered the submissions advanced by learned
Counsel for the parties.
23.
At the outset, it would be apposite to delineate the scope of
interference in an Appeal under Section 37. It is well-settled that the
jurisdiction of the appellate court under Section 37 is circumscribed
and does not extend beyond the parameters laid down under Section
34.
24.
The Supreme Court in MMTC Ltd. v. Vedanta Ltd.4 has held
that while exercising jurisdiction under Section 37, the Court cannot
undertake an independent assessment of the merits of the arbitral
award and is only required to examine whether the court exercising
jurisdiction under Section 34 has acted within the confines of the
provision.
25.
Similarly, in Punjab State Civil Supplies Corpn. Ltd. v.
Sanman Rice Mills5, it has been held that the appellate court, while
exercising powers under Section 37, does not sit in Appeal over the
arbitral award and cannot re-appreciate the evidence. The scope of
interference is confined to examining whether the court under Section
(2019) 4 SCC 163
2024 SCC OnLine SC 2632
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
FAO(OS)(COMM) 212/2024
16:41:50
34 has either exceeded its jurisdiction or failed to exercise jurisdiction
vested in it.
26.
Further, a three-judge Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
UHL Power Co. Limited v. State of Himachal Pradesh6 has reiterated
that the jurisdiction under Section 37 is even more circumscribed than
that under Section 34, and the appellate court must exercise restraint
and cannot substitute its own view for that of the Tribunal.
27.
The principle that the Court does not sit in Appeal over the
findings of the Tribunal has also been emphasized in McDermott
International Inc. v. Burn Standard Co. Ltd. & Ors.7, wherein it has
been observed that the role of the Court is supervisory in nature and
intervention is warranted only in limited circumstances such as patent
illegality, violation of natural justice, or jurisdictional error.
28.
The Courts have adopted the same consistent view in a catena
of decisions, a few of which may be adverted to, namely, Vedanta
Ltd. v. Shenzhen Shandong Nuclear Power Construction Co. Ltd.8;
ONGC Ltd. Western Geco International Ltd.9; Numaligarh Refinery
Ltd. v. Daelim Industrial Co. Ltd.10; Tata Hydro-Electric Power
Supply Co. Ltd. v. Union of India11; Ssangyong Engg. &
Construction Co. Ltd. v. NHAI12; and, NHAI v. M. Hakeem13.
(2022) 4 SCC 116
(2006) 11 SCC 181
(2019) 11 SCC 465
(2014) 9 SCC 263
(2007) 8 SCC 466
(2003) 4 SCC 172
(2019) 15 SCC 131
(2021) 9 SCC 1
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
FAO(OS)(COMM) 212/2024
16:41:50
29.
Thus, it is well-settled that an Appeal under Section 37 is not an
avenue for re-appreciation of evidence or re-evaluation of factual
findings. The enquiry is limited to examining whether the learned
Court under Section 34 has applied the correct legal principles and
whether the Award suffers from any infirmity falling within the
limited grounds of interference recognized under the A&C Act.
30.
Tested on the aforesaid principles, the contentions advanced on
behalf of the Appellant are required to be examined.
31.
The limited grievance of the Appellant is that while awarding a
sum of Rs.1,90,86,595/- under Claim No.6, the Arbitrator failed to
account for an amount of Rs.93,01,410/- which, according to the
Appellant, stood recovered/adjusted towards mobilization advance,
thereby resulting in an excess award in favour of the Respondent.
32.
At the outset, it is required to be noted that Claim No.6 pertains
to the encashment of the PBG and the entitlement of the Respondent
to refund thereof. The Arbitrator has returned a finding that the
termination of the contract by the Appellant was wrongful, illegal and
arbitrary, and that the circumstances constituted a force majeure event
within the meaning of the contract. On this basis, it has been held that
the invocation and encashment of the PBG was impermissible,
thereby entitling the Respondent to reimbursement of the amount
recovered.
33.
The aforesaid findings on liability, including the applicability of
the force majeure clause and the illegality of invocation of the PBG,
have not been assailed by the Appellant. As noticed in the Impugned
Judgment, the challenge is confined only to the quantum of the
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
FAO(OS)(COMM) 212/2024
16:41:50
amount awarded and not to the underlying liability. In the absence of
any challenge to these foundational findings, the entitlement of the
Respondent to refund under Claim No.6 stands concluded.
34.
The principal contention advanced by the Appellant rests on the
alleged non-consideration of the adjustment of a sum of
Rs.93,01,410/-. The reliance placed on the findings returned under
Claim No.7, however, is misplaced and does not advance the
Appellant’s case.
35.
Claim No.7 pertains to the grant and recovery/adjustment of
mobilization advance, whereas Claim No.6 concerns the legality of
invocation and encashment of the PBG. The two claims operate in
distinct and independent spheres and have been adjudicated by the
Arbitrator on their own merits. The findings rendered under Claim
No.7, therefore, cannot be read in a manner so as to dilute or unsettle
the determination under Claim No.6, save to the limited extent of
verifying whether the aspect of adjustment has, in fact, been duly
accounted for.
36.
At the same time, the findings under Claim No.7 assume
relevance to the limited extent of examining the Appellant’s
contention regarding alleged non-adjustment. A perusal of the Award
shows that the Arbitrator has taken into account the recoveries
effected towards mobilization advance, including encashment of the
PBG as well as recoveries made during execution of the works
through running account bills.
37.
This position stands further clarified by the affidavit filed by the
Respondent pursuant to the order dated 17.09.2024, wherein it has
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
FAO(OS)(COMM) 212/2024
16:41:50
been specifically stated that against the mobilization advance, a Bank
Guarantee of Rs.1,09,95,254/- was furnished and encashed, and in
addition thereto, a sum of Rs.1,00,89,066/- was recovered during the
course of execution of the works upto the 16th RA Bill. It has further
been affirmed that the awarded amount has been computed after
adjusting the entire mobilization advance along with interest, as
reflected in the Award, particularly under Claim No.7.
38.
In view of the aforesaid, the apprehension expressed by the
Appellant, namely, that the Respondent is receiving more than what is
due on account of non-adjustment of mobilization advance, does not
merit acceptance. The material on record, including the Award read
with the affidavit of the Respondent, indicates that the aspect of
recovery/adjustment of mobilization advance was duly taken into
consideration by the Arbitrator.
39.
The submission of the Appellant that the aforesaid does not
conclusively establish the adjustment, in essence, invites this Court to
undertake a re-examination of the computation and reconciliation of
accounts between the parties. Such an exercise is clearly beyond the
scope of interference under Sections 34 and 37, which does not permit
a fresh factual determination on matters not raised or adjudicated in
the arbitral proceedings.
40.
In the absence of any cogent material on record to demonstrate
that the Award is vitiated by patent illegality on account of duplication
or non-adjustment, the contention advanced by the Appellant cannot
be sustained. The plea, in essence, rests on a speculative apprehension
rather than any demonstrable error apparent on the face of the Award,
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
FAO(OS)(COMM) 212/2024
16:41:50
and therefore does not meet the threshold warranting interference
under the limited jurisdiction of Sections 34 and 37.
41.
In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court has examined
the computational objection as raised by the Appellant and has found
no merit in the same. Once the said contention stands negated on the
basis of the material available on record, it is not necessary for this
Court to enter upon the larger question as to whether a fresh factual
plea, not urged before the learned Arbitrator, can be permitted to be
raised for the first time in proceedings under Sections 34 or 37.
CONCLUSION:
42.
This Court is, therefore, of the considered view that no case of
patent illegality, perversity, or jurisdictional error has been made out
so as to warrant interference with the Award or the Impugned
Judgment. The reasoning adopted by the learned Single Judge is in
consonance agrees with the settled principles governing the scope of
interference under Section 34 and calls for no interference.
43.
The present Appeal is accordingly dismissed. The pending
application stands closed.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J.
MAY 19, 2026
s.godara/shah
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
FAO(OS)(COMM) 212/2024
16:41:50
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review