Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010583532012
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3327]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY,THE NINETEENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SREENIVASA REDDY
WRIT PETITION NO: 221/2012
Between:
Inthiyaz Khan Jeevan Khan
AND
Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. K MOHAN RAMI REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. THOOM SRINIVAS
2. V V SATISH
...PETITIONER
...RESPONDENT
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE K.SREENIVASA REDDY
WRIT PETITION No.221 of 2012
ORDER :
This Writ Petition is filed seeking to declare the
impugned Notification dated 19.12.2011 issued by the
respondent for distributorship of Rajiv Gandhi LPG Vitrak
(RGGLV) at Bandi Atmakur, Kurnool district, by changing
the category from Combined Category to Open Category in
continuation of the earlier Notification dated 30.3.2010, as
being illegal and arbitrary, and consequently set aside the
same by directing the respondent to proceed with the
selection as per the Combined Category.
2.
The facts, in brief, which led to filing of the present
Writ Petition are as follows.
(a) Petitioner is a physically challenged person.
Respondent issued a Notification dated 30.3.2010 inviting
applications for awarding distributorship under RGGLV at
Bandi
Atmakur,
Kurnool
district,
under
Combined
Category, under which defence personnel, para military/
police/government
personnel,
physically
handicapped
personnel, outstanding sports persons, are eligible to apply.
Since the petitioner is eligible, he submitted his application
for award of the said dealership on 29.4.2010.
The
respondent prepared the final list of selected candidates by
putting marks, wherein the petitioner secured 100% marks
since candidature of another person who applied along with
the petitioner was rejected. The respondent displayed the
final list on 18.8.2010 wherein petitioner alone was shown
as eligible, and the petitioner was informed that after field
verification of credentials, appointment orders would be
issued.
Thereafter,
the
respondent
served
a
letter
No.KNT:LPG: RGGLV(Bandi Atmakur), dated 21.1.2011 on
the petitioner informing that his candidature was cancelled
on the ground that during field verification of credentials, it
was observed that the original fixed deposit certificate was
taken after the date of the advertisement, but as per
Instruction
No.10.3
of
the
application
for
RGGLV
Distributorship selection, fixed deposits should have been
taken on or before the date of advertisement.
(b) It is stated that when the petitioner approached
the respondent and requested to consider his candidature
stating that due to inadvertence, the fixed deposit was
made after the date of advertisement, the respondent
informed that they were likely to issue another Notification
in continuation of the Notification dated 30.3.2010 and
advised him to submit his application pursuant thereto.
(c)
The
respondent
published
the
impugned
Notification dated 19.12.2011 inviting applications for
RGGLV Distributorship, wherein the category was changed
from Combined Category to Open Category.
(d) According to the petitioner, by virtue of change in
the category, there would be serious competition and he
would be deprived of his legitimate right to get the said
Distributorship. It is his grievance that he secured 100%
marks earlier, but for deposit of the amount after the
advertisement, his candidature was not considered, and
that if the category is notified as Combined Category, he
would be selected for the Dealership.
petitioner,
since
the
impugned
According to the
Notification
dated
19.12.2011 is in continuation of the earlier Notification
dated 30.3.2010, all the terms and conditions remain intact
and if the impugned Notification is allowed to stand,
manifest injustice would be caused to the petitioner.
Hence, the Writ Petition.
3.
Respondent filed counter affidavit admitting issuance
of Notification dated 30.3.2010 for RGGLV at Bandi
Atmakur location under Combined Category and rejection
of application of the petitioner therefor and contending inter
alia that the rejection order became final; that as there was
no qualified candidate for the aforesaid location pursuant
to the Notification dated 30.03.2010, the respondent readvertised the location; that petitioner himself accepted
that he deposited the amount after the advertisement date
which is in contravention of Instruction No.10.3 prescribed
in the application which stipulates that the fixed deposits
should
have
advertisement.
of
the
been
on
or
before
the
date
of
the
It is further stated that as per Point No.18
Selection
Guidelines,
which
deals
with
‘Readvertisement of location’, it is clear that if no eligible
application is received or no applicant is left for draw, or
RGGLV is terminated after one year of commissioning, then
the location for RGGLV should be re-advertised. Further,
as per Point No.4 of the revision made in the Selection
Guidelines vide Industry Note dated 15.6.2010, it is clear
that the locations reserved under the CC category will be
re-advertised under ‘open category’ as per the Policy. It is
stated that the respondent strictly adhered to, the Selection
Guidelines for re-advertisement, and in the absence of any
challenge to the said Guidelines and in the absence of
infringement of any legal right of the petitioner, the Writ
Petition is not maintainable.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner contended that the
petitioner, who belongs to Physically challenged category,
applied in response to a Notification dated 30.3.2010
issued by the respondent for awarding distributorship
under RGGLV at Bandi Atmakur, Kurnool district, under
Combined Category; that under the Combined Category,
defence
personnel,
para
military/
police/government
personnel, physically handicapped personnel, outstanding
sports persons, are eligible to apply; that the petitioner
obtained 100% marks and was informed that he was
eligible, but vide intimation dated 21.1.2011, he was
informed that his candidature was cancelled on the ground
that original fixed deposit certificate was taken after the
date of the advertisement, as the same is contrary to
Instruction
No.10.3
of
the
application
for
RGGLV
Distributorship selection; that the deficiency pointed out by
the
respondent
inadvertent.
He
for
cancelling
submits
that
his
cancellation
since
the
is
impugned
Notification dated 19.12.2021 is in continuation of the
earlier Notification dated 30.3.2010, changing the category
from Combined Category to Open Category is not tenable,
and in such an event, the chances of petitioner getting the
Dealership are remote in view of heavy competition, and
hence, he prays to allow the Writ Petition
5.
Learned counsel for the respondent, while reiterating
the averments in the counter affidavit, contended that
during field verification of credentials, it came to light that
the petitioner obtained fixed deposit after the advertisement
date and the same is admitted by him; that the same is in
contravention of Instruction No.10.3 prescribed in the
application which prescribes that the fixed deposits should
have been on or before the date of the advertisement. He
further submits that since there was no eligible application,
the respondent re-advertised the same as per Point No.18 of
the Selection Guidelines; that as per Point No.4 of the
revision made in the Selection Guidelines vide Industry
Note dated 15.6.2010, the location, which is reserved under
the CC category, was re-advertised under ‘open category’ as
per the Policy; that the action of the respondent is strictly
in accordance with the Selection Guidelines, and in the
absence of any challenge to the Selection Guidelines, the
Writ Petition is not maintainable.
6.
Now, the point that arises for consideration in this
Writ Petition is whether the action of respondent in readvertising
the
Distributorship
of
RGGLV
at
Bandi
Atmakur, Kurnool district location under Open Category
under the impugned Notification dated 19.12.2011, is
sustainable, and whether there is infringement of any legal
or statutory right of the petitioner calling for interference of
this Court in exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India ?
7.
Pursuant to a Notification dated 30.3.2010 issued by
the respondent, inviting applications for award of Rajiv
Gandhi LPG Vitrak (RGGLV) at Bandi Atmakur, Kurnool
district location, the petitioner, who belongs to physically
challenged
category,
submitted
his
application
on
29.4.2010. The petitioner gave a declaration in the
application that if, on verification by the respondent, it is
found that the information given by him is incorrect/false/
misrepresented, then his candidate stands cancelled and
he would be declared ineligible for RGGLV. The respondent
displayed final list on 18.8.2010 wherein the petitioner
alone was shown as eligible provisionally.
8.
Admittedly, the petitioner was informed that after field
verification of his credentials, appointment order would be
issued to him. It is not in dispute that pursuant to field
verification of the credentials of the petitioner, it was found
that the petitioner produced a fixed deposit, which was
obtained after the date of the advertisement.
A perusal of
the material on record goes to show that Column No.10.3 of
the application deals with ‘Fixed Deposit/NSC/Shares/MF,
etc. ‘as on’ date of advertisement in the name of applicant
and members of ‘family unit’.
In the said Column, the
petitioner furnished information regarding a fixed deposit
bearing No.489138 for Rs.4,00,000/- standing in his name,
which is dated 28.4.2010 i.e. which is obtained ‘after’ the
date of the Notification 30.3.2010.
As per Instruction
No.10.3 of the application, the fixed deposits should have
been on or before the date of advertisement. On this
ground, which is found during field verification of the
credentials of the petitioner, the respondent, vide letter
dated
21.01.2011,
intimated
the
petitioner
that
his
candidature was rejected, as he failed to furnish the
information called for, in column No.10.3 of the application,
and the same was served on the petitioner on 28.1.2011.
In view of the same, admittedly, there is no eligible
applicant for award of RGGLV pursuant to the Notification
dated 30.3.2010.
9.
It is not in dispute that the allotment process of
RGGLV by the respondent-Corporation is governed by
‘Common
Selection
Guidelines
for
Public
Sector
Oil
Companies for selection of RGGLV’. As per Guideline No.18
of the Common Selection Guidelines for Public Sector Oil
Companies
for
selection
of
RGGLV,
if
no
eligible
application/s is received, or no applicant has qualified or
no applicant is left for draw, or RGGLV is terminated after
one year of commissioning, then the location for RGGLV
should be readvertised.
Further, as per the revised
Guidelines dated 15.6.2010 viz. ‘Industry Record Note on
Modification/Clarifications with regard to Selection Process
of RGGLV in the Manual for Selection of RGGLV-Revision
1’, OMCs were asked to re-advertise locations for which no
candidates were found, and the locations reserved under
the CC category will be readvertised under open category as
per the policy. Accordingly, following the said Guidelines,
the respondent re-advertised the location and gave the
impugned
Notification
dated
19.12.2011
issued
for
distributorship of RGGLV at Bandi Atmakur, Kurnool
district location, by changing the category from Combined
Category to Open Category. Therefore, the procedure
adopted by the respondent is strictly in accordance with the
Guidelines governing the field.
Admittedly, there is no
challenge to the validity or legal sustainability of the said
Guidelines or the revised Guidelines dated 15.6.2010.
10.
Further,
as
per
the
copy
of
the
postal
acknowledgement filed by the respondent along with the
counter affidavit, the letter dated 21.1.2011, intimating the
petitioner about cancellation of his candidature for not
having complied with Notification for RGGLV under item
No.10.3 of his application form, was served on the
petitioner on 28.1.2011.
In fact, the petitioner also
admitted the said lache, in his writ affidavit and stated that
he approached the respondent and requested to consider
his application, stating that it is due to inadvertence. In
the writ affidavit, it is also stated by the writ petitioner that
the respondent authorities informed him that they would
issue another Notification in continuation of the said
Notification dated 30.3.2010 as no eligible candidate was
found in response thereto.
So, the petitioner was aware of
the fact that his candidature was not considered and the
respondent was going to issue another Notification as per
the Guidelines.
Therefore, without availing the remedies
available to him under law within a reasonable time, the
petitioner waited till issuance of the next Notification and
thereafter approached this Court, after lapse of more than
11 months of receipt of the said letter, intimating rejection
of his application.
Therefore, apart from failure to furnish
relevant information as called for, in the application, there
are delay and laches on the part of the writ petitioner.
11.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court has no
hesitation to hold that the impugned action of the
respondent-respondent authorities is strictly in accordance
with the Guidelines governing the field, and there is no
infirmity.
In the absence of infringement of any legal,
statutory or constitutional right of the petitioner, the Writ
Petition is not maintainable.
12.
Accordingly, the Writ Petition is dismissed. No costs.
Miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, in the Writ Petition
shall stand closed.
(JUSTICE K.SREENIVASA REDDY)
DRK
19.02.2026
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE K.SREENIVASA REDDY
WRIT PETITION No.221 of 2012
19.02.2026
DRK
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review