Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment delivered on: 28/02/2026
+
CM(M)-IPD 47/2025
INNOVATIVE DERMA CARE
.....Petitioner
versus
VARDHAMAN SKINCARE PVT LTD & ANR.
.....Respondents
Advocates who appeared in this case
For the Petitioner
:
Ms. Aastha Sharma, Mr. Pramod
Kumar Singh & Ms. Jahanvi Sharma,
Advocates.
For the Respondent
:
Mr. Ajay Amitabh Suman, Mr.
Shravan Kumar Bansal, Mr. Rishi
Bansal & Mr. Risabh Gupta,
Advocates for Respondent No. 2.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TEJAS KARIA
JUDGMENT
TEJAS KARIA, J
1.
The present Petition has been filed under Article 227 of the Constitution
of India, 1950 seeking setting aside of the order dated 21.11.2025
CM(M)-IPD 47/2025
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:00:42
(“Impugned Order”) passed by the learned District Judge (Commercial),
West District, Tis Hazari Courts, New Delhi (“Trial Court”) in CS(COMM)
No. 403/2019 (“Suit”) titled as ‘Innovative Derma Care v. Vardhaman Skin
Care Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.’, whereby the learned Trial Court dismissed an
application (“Subject Application”) filed by the Petitioner under Order XVI
Rule 1 read with Section 30 and Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908 (“CPC”) by way of which the Petitioner had sought permission of the
learned Trial Court to bring on record an additional list of witnesses.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND:
2.
The Petitioner claims in the present petition that it is engaged in the
business of marketing and selling skin care products under the Trade Mark
‘Clariwash’ (“Subject Mark”), which is owned by the Petitioner. In the
month of July 2018, the Petitioner discovered that the Respondents are
engaged in manufacturing and selling face wash products under the Subject
Mark. Accordingly, the Petitioner instituted the Suit before the learned Trial
Court.
3.
During the course of proceedings in the Suit, the learned Trial Court
vide order dated 10.09.2024 referred the matter to the Delhi Mediation Centre,
Tis Hazari. Thereafter, the Mediation proceedings did not culminate into any
resolution of the dispute between the Parties and the matter was referred back
to the learned Trial Court.
4.
The Petitioner moved an application under Order XIIIA of the CPC,
which was dismissed by the learned Trial Court vide order dated 04.02.2025.
Further, the learned Trial Court framed Issues in the Suit and adjourned the
same for filing of list of witnesses and the appointment of Local
CM(M)-IPD 47/2025
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:00:42
Commissioner. In view of the same, the Petitioner filed a list of witnesses on
10.02.2025, which sought to examine Mr. Rajesh Kumar Taneja, sole
proprietor of the Petitioner as PW-1.
5.
Vide order dated 11.02.2025, a Local Commissioner was appointed by
the learned Trial Court for recording of evidence. Subsequently, the Petitioner
filed an application before the learned Trial Court to examine three additional
witnesses under Order XVI Rule 1 of the CPC. Vide order dated 06.03.2025,
the learned Trial Court allowed the said application, thereby permitting the
Petitioner to examine three additional witnesses namely, Mr. Sunil Bhambhari
as PW-2, Mr. Shyam Sundaram as PW-3 and Mr. Vikas Chopra as PW-4.
6.
Thereafter, on 22.04.2025, the Petitioner moved the Subject
Application under Order XVI Rule 1 of the CPC to bring on record two
additional witnesses namely, Mr. Amit Chopra, proprietor of Mediwings as
PW-5 and Mr. Gulshan Kumar, proprietor of GM Medicine Centre as PW-6.
7.
Subsequently, the Petitioner preferred an application under Section 151
of the CPC seeking early hearing of the Subject Application. On 21.11.2025,
the said early hearing application was heard by the learned Trial Court and
vide the Impugned Order of even date, the Subject Application was dismissed
by the learned Trial Court.
8.
Being aggrieved by the Impugned Order, the present Petition has been
filed by the Petitioner.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER:
9.
The learned Counsel for the Petitioner advanced the following
submissions:
CM(M)-IPD 47/2025
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:00:42
9.1 The learned Trial Court failed to appreciate that under Order XVI
Rule 1A of the CPC, parties are at liberty to produce any witness
without applying for summons, and that no prior permission of the
Court is required when the witness is its own witness. The said
provision expressly allows parties to bring and examine its witness
directly.
9.2 The learned Trial Court has erred in dismissing the Petitioner’s
Application purely on the ground that the Suit is old and that the
Petitioner had earlier also added witnesses, as the said considerations
are irrelevant and had no nexus with the requirements provided for
under Order XVI Rule 1 of the CPC.
9.3 The Impugned Order suffers from a non-application of mind as the
learned Trial Court has failed to differentiate the spirit of Order XVI
Rule 1 and Order XVI Rule 1A of the CPC.
9.4 The learned Trial Court has completely ignored the binding law laid
down by the Supreme Court in Mange Ram v. Brij Mohan, (1983)
4 SCC 36. It is well-settled in law that a party cannot be shut out
from examining material witnesses merely based on technicalities or
delays.
9.5 The learned Trial Court has failed to appreciate that the Petitioner’s
evidence was still ongoing and was not closed when the Subject
Application was filed. The learned Trial Court has also not recorded
any finding of prejudice that may be caused to the Respondent if the
Petitioner is permitted to examine two additional witnesses.
CM(M)-IPD 47/2025
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:00:42
9.6 The learned Trial Court failed to consider that the earlier application
adding three witnesses was allowed upon judicial satisfaction of
necessity and, therefore, filing a subsequent application upon
emergence of further material cannot automatically be construed as
dilatory and that each application shall be construed on its own
merits.
9.7 The evidence of additional witnesses sought to be added in the
Subject Application, namely, Mr. Amit Chopra and Mr. Gulshan
Kumar, is necessary for the just adjudication of the Suit. Mr. Amit
Chopra could not be incorporated earlier in the list of witnesses on
account of his deteriorating health condition, which rendered him
medically unfit to appear before the learned Trial Court, however, he
is currently fit to appear before the learned Trial Court. Mr. Gulshan
Kumar could not be incorporated in the list of witnesses earlier as he
resides out of station and was unavailable due to his frequent travel
and work commitments.
10.
In view of the foregoing submissions, it is prayed that the present
Petition be allowed and the Impugned Order be set aside.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT NO. 2:
11.
The learned Counsel for Respondent No. 2 submitted that the stage of
Plaintiff’s evidence is over and that the addition of the two witnesses, as
sought in the Subject Application, is an attempt to derail the Suit proceedings
and constitutes dilatory tactics on the part of the Plaintiff.
12.
The learned Counsel for Respondent No. 2 submitted that the name of
the said witnesses, Mr. Amit Chopra and Mr. Gulshan Kumar, could have been
CM(M)-IPD 47/2025
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:00:42
added in the earlier lists of witnesses regardless of their deteriorating health
condition or work commitments. It is further submitted that there was no
medical document on record, which established the claim of deteriorating
health condition of Mr. Amit Chopra, due to which his name could not be
incorporated in the list of witnesses earlier.
13.
In view of the foregoing submissions, it was prayed that the present
Petition be dismissed and the Impugned Order be upheld.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS:
14.
Heard the learned Counsel for the Parties and perused the material
placed on record.
15.
It is the Petitioner’s case that the Subject Application ought to have
been allowed by the learned Trial Court, in accordance with Order XVI Rule
1A of the CPC, which is reproduced as under:
“1. List of witnesses and summons to witnesses.—
(1) On or before such date as the Court may appoint, and not later
than fifteen days after the date on which the issues are settled, the
parties shall present in Court a list of witnesses whom they propose
to call either to give evidence or to produce documents and obtain
summonses to such persons for their attendance in Court.
(2) A party desirous of obtaining any summons for the attendance of
any person shall file in Court an application stating therein the
purpose for which the witness is proposed to be summoned.
(3) The Court may, for reasons to be recorded, permit a party to call,
whether by summoning through Court or otherwise, any witness,
other than those whose names appear in the list referred to in subrule (1), if such party shows sufficient cause for the omission to
mention the name of such witness in the said list.
(4) Subject to the provisions of sub-rule (2), summonses referred to in
this rule may be obtained by the parties on an application to the Court
CM(M)-IPD 47/2025
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:00:42
or to such officer as may be appointed by the [Court in this behalf
within five days of presenting the list of witnesses under sub-rule (1).]
1A. Production of witnesses without summons.—
Subject to the provisions of sub-rule (3) of rule 1, any party to the suit
may, without applying for summons under rule 1, bring any witness
to give evidence or to produce documents.”
16.
The learned Counsel for the Petitioner has primarily placed reliance on
the decision in Mange Ram (Supra), the relevant portion of which is extracted
hereunder:
“7. The neat question of law is: where a party to a proceeding does
not wish to have the assistance of the court for the purpose of
procuring the attendance of a witness or witnesses, could he be denied
the privilege of examining witnesses kept present by him on the date
fixed for recording his evidence, on the sole ground that the names of
the witnesses and the gist of evidence have not been set out in the list
which may or ought to have been filed in compliance with Order 16,
Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure?
8. Sub-rule (1) of Rule 1 of Order 16 casts an obligation on every
party to a proceeding to present a list of witnesses whom it proposes
to call either to give evidence or to produce documents and obtain
summonses to such persons for their attendance in court. Sub-rule (2)
requires that the parties seeking the assistance of the court for
procuring the attendance of a witness must make an application
stating therein the purpose for which the witness is proposed to be
summoned. Sub-rule (3) confers a discretion on the court to permit a
party to summon through court or otherwise any witness other than
those whose names appear in the list submitted in sub-rule (1), if such
party shows sufficient cause for the omission to mention the name of
such witness in the said list. Rule 1-A in its amended form in force
since 1977 enables a party to bring any witness to give evidence or to
produce documents but this enabling provision is subject to the
provision contained in sub-rule (3) of Rule 1 of Order XVI. If a
reference to Rule 22 of the High Court Rules is recalled at this stage,
it merely re-enacts sub-rule (1) and sub-rule (2) of Rule 1 of Order
XVI.
9. If the requirements of these provisions are conjointly read and
properly analysed, it clearly transpires that the obligation to supply
CM(M)-IPD 47/2025
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:00:42
the list as well as the gist of the evidence of each witness whose name
is entered in the list has to be carried out in respect of those witnesses
for procuring whose attendance the party needs the assistance of the
court. When a summons is issued by the court for procuring the
presence of a witness, it has certain consequences in law. If the
summon is served and the person served fails to comply with the same,
certain consequences in law ensue as provided in Rule 10 of Order
16. The consequence is that where the witness summoned either to
give evidence or to produce documents fails to attend or to produce
the documents in compliance with such summons, the court on being
satisfied of the service as provided therein and is further satisfied that
the person has without lawful excuse failed to honour the summons,
the court may issue a proclamation requiring him to attend to give
evidence or to produce the document at a time and place to be named
therein; and a copy of such proclamation shall be affixed in the
manner therein provided. Simultaneously, the court may, in its
discretion, issue a warrant, either with or without bail, for the arrest
of such person, and may make an order for the attachment of his
property for such amount as it thinks fit. Even if thereafter the witness
fails to appear, the court may impose upon him such fine not
exceeding five hundred rupees as it thinks fit, having regard to his
condition in life and all the circumstances of the case, and may order
his property, or any part, thereof, to be attached and sold as provided
in Rule 12 of Order XVI. In view of this legal consequence ensuing
from the issuance of a summons by the court and failure to comply
with the same, the scheme of Rules 1, 1-A of Order 16 and Rule 22 of
the Rules framed by the High Court clearly envisaged filing of a list
only in respect of witnesses whom the parties desire to examine and
procure presence with the assistance of the court. There, however,
remains an area where if the party to a proceeding does not desire
the assistance of the court for procuring the presence of a witness,
obviously the party can produce such witness on the date of hearing
and the court cannot decline to examine the witness unless the court
proposes to act under the proviso to sub-section (1) of Section 87 of
the ‘1951 Act’ which enables the court for reasons to be recorded in
writing, to refuse to examine any witness or witnesses if it is of the
opinion that the evidence of such witness or witnesses is not material
for the decision of the petition or that the party tendering such witness
or witnesses is doing so on frivolous grounds or with a view to delay
the proceedings. It, therefore, unquestionably transpires that the
obligation to supply the list of witnesses within the time prescribed
CM(M)-IPD 47/2025
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:00:42
under sub-rule (1) of Rule 1 of Order 16 is in respect of witnesses to
procure whose presence the assistance of the court is necessary. And
this ought to be so because the court wants to be satisfied about the
necessity and relevance of the evidence of such witness whose
presence will be procured with the assistance of the court. This not
only explains the necessity of setting out the names of witnesses in the
list but also the gist of evidence of each witness. If mere omission to
mention the name of a witness in the list envisaged by sub-rule (1) of
Rule 1 of Order 16 would enable the court to decline to examine such
witness, Rule 1-A of Order 16 would not have omitted to mention that
only those witnesses kept present could be examined whose names are
mentioned in the list envisaged by sub-rule (1) and who can be
produced without the assistance of the court. Viewed from this angle,
Rule 1-A becomes wholly redundant. If it is obligatory upon the party
to mention the names of all witnesses irrespective of the fact whether
some or all of them are to be summoned and even the names of those
whom the party desires to produce without the assistance of the court
are also required to be mentioned in the list on the pain that they may
not be permitted to be examined, Rule 1-A would have given a clear
legislative exposition in that behalf and the marginal note of Rule 1A clearly negatives this suggestion. Marginal note of Rule 1-A reads
as ‘Production of witnesses without summons’ and the rule proceeds
to enable a party to bring any witness to give evidence or to produce
documents without applying for summons under Rule 1. If it was
implicit in Rule 1-A that it only enables the party to examine only
those witnesses whose names are mentioned in the list filed under subrule (1) of Rule 1 whom the party would produce before the court
without the assistance of the court, it was not necessary to provide in
Rule 1-A that the party may bring any witness to give evidence or to
produce documents without applying for summons under Rule 1. Rule
1-A of Order 16 clearly brings to surface the two situations in which
the two rules operate. Where the party wants the assistance of the
court to procure presence of a witness on being summoned through
the court, it is obligatory on the party to file the list with the gist of
evidence of witness in the court as directed by sub-rule (1) of Rule 1
and make an application as provided by sub-rule (2) of Rule 1. But
where the party would be in a position to produce its witnesses
without the assistance of the court, it can do so under Rule 1-A of
Order 16 irrespective of the fact whether the name of such witness is
mentioned in the list or not.
CM(M)-IPD 47/2025
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:00:42
10. It was, however, contended that Rule 1-A is subject to sub-rule (3)
of Rule 1 and therefore, the court must ascertain how far sub-rule (3)
would carve out an exception to the enabling provision contained in
Rule 1-A. There is no inner contradiction between sub-rule (1) of Rule
1 and Rule 1-A of Order XVI. Sub-rule (3) of Rule 1 of Order 16
confers a wider jurisdiction on the court to cater to a situation where
the party has failed to name the witness in the list and yet the party is
unable to produce him or her on his own under Rule 1-A and in such
a situation the party of necessity has to seek the assistance of the court
under sub-rule (3) to procure the presence of the witness and the court
may if it is satisfied that the party has sufficient cause for the omission
to mention the name of such witness in the list filed under sub-rule (1)
of Rule 1, still extend its assistance for procuring the presence of such
a witness by issuing a summons through the court or otherwise which
ordinarily the court would not extend for procuring the attendance of
a witness whose name is not shown in the list. Therefore, sub-rule (3)
of Rule 1 and Rule 1-A operate in two different areas and cater to two
different situations.”
17.
Perusal of the above quoted extract in Mange Ram (supra) makes it
clear that the enabling provision contained in Order XVI Rule 1A of the CPC
is subject to Order XVI Rule 1(3) and, therefore, in order to procure the
presence of a witness, the Court has to be satisfied that a party has sufficient
cause for the omission to mention the name of such witness in the list filed
under Order XVI Rule 1(1). Therefore, the Petitioner ought to have satisfied
the learned Trial Court that there was sufficient cause for the omission of the
names of the witnesses sought to be included by way of the Subject
Application, in the earlier lists of witnesses.
18.
In the present case, the Petitioner contends that the names of Mr. Amit
Chopra and Mr. Gulshan Kumar were not added in the list of witnesses earlier
as Mr. Amit Chopra was suffering from poor health and Mr. Gulshan Kumar
CM(M)-IPD 47/2025
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:00:42
resides out of station and had work commitments, due to which they would
be unable to give evidence as witnesses.
19.
The learned Trial Court in the Impugned Order dismissed the Subject
Application filed by the Petitioner and held as under:
“Heard.
The case in hand is the oldest pending case in this Court.
In respect of the case in hand, the issues were framed vide
order dated 04.02.2025 and in terms of the order dated 11.02.2025,
the Court Commissioner so appointed for recording of evidence was
expected to conclude the evidence of both parties within two months
reckoned from the date of order i.e. 11.02.2025. However, the case is
still lingering on at the stage of Plaintiff Evidence itself.
Admittedly, the Plaintiff had initially asserted and intended to
examine only one witness in support of its case i.e. the Proprietor
himself. However, later on, an application u/o XVI rule 1 CPC (along
with two more applications) was filed for seeking permission to add
the names of three more witnesses as the Plaintiff Witnesses. The said
earlier application was though opposed by the Defendant, yet, it was
disposed of as allowed vide detailed order dated 06.03.2025. Thus, as
a matter of fact, the number of witnesses on behalf of the Plaintiff rose
from 1 to 4; as was initially intended to.
Again, the Plaintiff has approached the Court with another
similar application seeking addition of two more witnesses as the
Plaintiff Witnesses. The case in hand being the oldest pending matter
and also in the light of afore-reflections, no ground for grant of any
further leverage is made out. It appears that it is the Plaintiff himself
who has been lingering on his case. No one had stopped him from
inserting the names of as much witnesses as were desired to be
examined in support of his case. He reflected his intention that he
would be examining himself as the ‘sole witness’ in support of his
case. After a while, he further intended to add three more persons as
witnesses. The same was also allowed. Again, the leverage is being
sought without assigning any cogent reason. Accordingly, the
application in hand is hereby disposed of as dismissed.”
CM(M)-IPD 47/2025
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:00:42
20.
Perusal of the Impugned Order reveals the learned Trial Court’s
apprehension that the Petitioner itself was trying to delay the proceedings in
the Suit and that there was no pressing reason for the Petitioner for not
including the names of the witnesses sought to be included by way of the
Subject Application, in the earlier lists of witnesses.
21.
Having considered the contentions of the Parties and the reasoning of
the learned Trial Court in the Impugned Order, this Court is of the view that
the Petitioner has not been able to make out a case for allowing the present
Petition for the following reasons:
22.
Firstly, the cause shown by the Petitioner for not including the names
of the witnesses sought to be included by way of the Subject Application, i.e.,
deteriorating health condition and work commitments, is unfounded as the
perusal of the material placed on record does not establish the same. There is
no documentary evidence on record to support such averment made by the
Petitioner.
23.
Secondly, in any event, the names of the witnesses sought to be
included by way of the Subject Application, could have been included in the
earlier lists of witnesses even if the said witnesses were not in condition to
give evidence on an immediate basis.
24.
Lastly, the Suit was pending before the learned Trial Court for a period
of around 6 years and the learned Trial Court was correct in observing that the
Petitioner himself was responsible for lingering on the proceedings in the Suit
as the Petitioner after filing an initial list of one witness, had already filed
another application for inclusion of three more witnesses, which was allowed
by the learned Trial Court.
CM(M)-IPD 47/2025
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:00:42
25.
In view of the above, the Petitioner has failed to justify any sufficient
cause for the omission of the names of the witnesses sought to be included
through the Subject Application, in the earlier list of witnesses filed under
Order XVI Rule 1(1) of the CPC.
26.
Accordingly, there is no infirmity with the Impugned Order passed by
the learned Trial Court and no interference is warranted with the Impugned
Order. As a result, the present Petition stands dismissed.
TEJAS KARIA, J
FEBRUARY 28, 2026
St
CM(M)-IPD 47/2025
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:00:42
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review