Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
UKHC010176442025
2026:UHC:7067-DB
RESERVED JUDGMENT
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SHRI MANOJ KUMAR GUPTA
AND
HON’BLE SHRI JUSTICE SUBHASH UPADHYAY
SPECIAL APPEAL No. 356 OF 2025
1: Indramani
Versus
1: State Of Uttarakhand
2: Director Of Rehabilitation
3: Executive Engineer
4: Officer-In-Charge
5: Kushal Singh
6: Dheeraj Singh Rawat
7: THDC
--Appellant
…Respondents
Counsel for the appellant.
:
Mr. Pradeep Kumar Chauhan and Mr. B.S.
Kathayat, learned counsel.
Counsel for respondent nos. 1
to 4.
:
Mr. J.C. Pande, learned Standing Counsel
for the State of Uttarakhand.
Counsel for respondent no. 7.
:
Mr. Sandeep Kothari, learned counsel.
:
Mr. Rajendra Dobhal, learned Senior
Counsel
assisted
by
Mr.
Suryakant
Maithani, learned counsel.
Counsel
for
petitioner
WPMS/1854/2022.
in
JUDGMENT RESERVED : 04TH AUGUST, 2026
JUDGMENT DELIVERED : 11TH AUGUST, 2026
JUDGMENT : (per Hon’ble The Chief Justice Shri Manoj Kumar Gupta)
DELAY CONDONATION APPLICATION (IA No. 01/2025)
1.
The appeal is reported to be beyond time by 185
days. Counsel for the respondents have no objection to the
delay being condoned. Accordingly, the delay is condoned.
The application is allowed.
Office is directed to allot a
regular number to the instant appeal.
UKHC010176442025
2026:UHC:7067-DB
SPECIAL APPEAL NO. 356/2025
2.
The present intra-Court appeal is directed against
the common judgment and order dated 04.04.2025 passed
by the learned Single Judge in WPMS/441/2022, ‘Indramani
v. State of Uttarakhand and others’, & WPMS/1854/2022,
‘Hikmat Singh Panwar v. State of Uttarakhand and others’,
and order dated 30.10.2025 passed in review application
filed by the appellant.
3.
The controversy in the present appeal pertains to
the allotment of agricultural Plot No. E31, admeasuring 1/2
acre,
situated
at
Rehabilitation
Site-Nirmal
Block
A,
Pashulok, Rishikesh, under the Rehabilitation Scheme for the
oustees of the Tehri Dam Project.
4.
The appellant is an affected person/ oustee of
Village Biryani, Patti Gushai, District Tehri Garhwal under the
Tehri Dam Project. Pursuant to the Rehabilitation Scheme,
agricultural Plot No. 4, admeasuring 1800 sq. mtrs. and
residential Plot No. 4, admeasuring 200 sq. mtrs. at Patel
Nagar, Dehrakhas, Dehradun were allotted to him vide
allotment letter
dated
08.02.2013.
Subsequently,
by
Government Order dated 18.11.2013, the allotment was
cancelled on the ground that prior concurrence of the State
UKHC010176442025
2026:UHC:7067-DB
Government had not been obtained, although the land
belonged to the State Government.
5.
Petitioner
in
WPMS/1854/2022,
Hikmat
Singh
Panwar, is also an oustee of the Tehri Dam Project. He was
allotted residential Plot No. 16, admeasuring 200 sq. mtrs.,
and agricultural Plot No. 18, admeasuring 1/2 acre, on
08.02.2013. Subsequently, the allotment of his agricultural
Plot No. 18, admeasuring 1/2 acre, was also cancelled by
Government Order dated 18.11.2013.
Thus, the factual
position obtaining after the cancellation of the original
allotments was that, although both the appellant and Hikmat
Singh Panwar, being oustees, were entitled to rehabilitation,
the original allotments of the appellant stood cancelled in
respect of both agricultural and residential plots, and that of
Hikmat Singh Panwar, only in respect of the agricultural plot.
6.
In
the
year
2021,
the
appellant
filed
WPMS/1492/2021 before this Court, alleging that one
Chattar Singh, also an oustee of Tehri Dam Project, had
been granted a dual allotment of Plot No. E31, Rehabilitation
Site-Nirmal Block A, Pashulok, Rishikesh and, therefore, it
ought to be cancelled and the plot be allotted to him. The
writ petition was disposed of by this Court by order dated
UKHC010176442025
2026:UHC:7067-DB
02.08.2021, directing the Rehabilitation Director to consider
and decide the representation of the appellant dated
01.02.2021, after affording an opportunity of hearing to the
heirs of late Chattar Singh, who had died by then.
7.
It appears that, even before the representation
filed by the appellant could be taken up for consideration by
the Rehabilitation Director, his name was included in the
lottery conducted on 06.08.2021 for allotment of plots to the
oustees of the Tehri Dam Project.
agricultural
Plot
No.
300,
In the said exercise,
admeasuring
acres,
and
residential Plot No. 89, admeasuring 200 sq. mtrs., situated
at Rehabilitation Site, Pathri Bagh-3 (West) Haridwar, were
allotted in his favour.
8.
On 23.02.2022, pursuant to the order dated
02.08.2021 in WPMS/1492/2021, the Rehabilitation Director
decided the representation of the appellant, after issuing
notice to the heirs of Chattar Singh.
The Rehabilitation
Director found that Chattar Singh had obtained a dual
allotment
of
Plot
No.
E31,
admeasuring
1/2
acre,
Rehabilitation Site-Nirmal Block A, Pashulok, Rishikesh, by
misleading the Department and, accordingly, cancelled the
said allotment.
However, taking note of the fact that the
UKHC010176442025
2026:UHC:7067-DB
appellant
had
already
been
allotted
agricultural
and
residential plots in the lottery conducted on 06.08.2021, the
Rehabilitation Director declined to accept the representation
of the appellant in respect of allotment of Plot No. E31.
Aggrieved thereby, the appellant filed the writ petition,
which has been decided by learned Single Judge by the
impugned judgment and order.
9.
Hikmat Singh Panwar had also approached this
Court by filing WPMS/571/2022, though he did not challenge
therein the order of cancellation of his allotment. The said
writ
petition
was
dismissed
on
29.03.2022.
Feeling
aggrieved thereby, Hikmat Singh Panwar filed Special Appeal
No. 66/2022, which was allowed on 19.04.2022, with a
direction to the respondents to reconsider his claim for
allotment of an agricultural plot, his earlier allotment having
been cancelled by order dated 18.11.2013. In compliance of
the order passed in the special appeal, the respondents
considered the representation of Hikmat Singh Panwar and
observed that his claim would be subject to the decision in
pending WPMS/441/2022, filed by the appellant herein.
Hikmat Singh Panwar, feeling aggrieved by order dated
24.04.2022, filed WPMS/1854/2022, which was also decided
UKHC010176442025
2026:UHC:7067-DB
by the learned Single Judge, along with the writ petition filed
by the appellant.
10.
Thus, by the time the matter once again came
before this Court at the instance of the appellant and Hikmat
Singh Panwar through their separate writ petitions, the
factual position was as follows :
(a)
The appellant had been allotted agricultural
Plot No. 300, admeasuring 2 acres and residential
Plot No. 89, admeasuring 200 sq. mtrs., situated
at
Rehabilitation
Site,
Pathri
Bagh-3
(West)
Haridwar.
(ii)
Hikmat Singh Panwar continued to have the
original allotment of residential Plot No. 16,
admeasuring 200 sq. mtrs., but had not been
allotted any agricultural plot in lieu of cancellation
of agricultural Plot No. 18, vide order dated
18.11.2013.
11.
Although, both writ petitions were decided by a
common order, the learned Single Judge first considered the
claim of the appellant in paragraph nos. 5 to 13.
In
paragraph no. 11, the learned Single Judge noted that the
principal grievance of the appellant was that agricultural Plot
UKHC010176442025
2026:UHC:7067-DB
No. 300, admeasuring 2 acre allotted to him was not
suitable for agricultural purposes.
The said grievance was
based on a report of Deputy Revenue Officer dated
15.07.2023, according to which, the agricultural plot allotted
to the appellant was in three parts and not fit for cultivation.
In the present appeal, the reports of the authorities dated
12.09.2025 and 08.10.2025 on the same aspect have also
been filed.
12.
In the same paragraph, the learned Single Judge
has also noticed the appellant’s claim for allotment of Plot
No. E31 in his favour in exchange of Plot No. 330. The claim
for exchange was based on an Office Memorandum dated
10.07.2003, which is as follows :
“1- ik=rk lwph v/kksgLrk{kjh ds vuqeksnu ds mijkUr vf/k’kklh
vfHk;Urk fuekZ.k [k.M yks-fu-fo-] ubZ fVgjh }kjk fuxZr dh tk;sxhA
2vkoaVu ls iwoZ ik=rk ds dzekadksa dks iquZfu/kkZj.k lacaf/kr xzke
iz/kku dh lgefr ls fd;k tk ldrk gSA ijUrq vkoaVu fu/kkZfjr ofj;rk
dze esa gh fd;k tk;sxkA
3mi jktLo vf/kdkjh] _f”kds’k }kjk lacaf/kr vf/k’kklh vfHk;Urk ls
lgefr ysdj vkoaVu laca/kh vkns’k tkjh fd;s tk;saxsA”
13.
While considering the appellant’s claim based upon
the Office Memorandum dated 10.07.2003, the learned
Single Judge has observed that an exchange could be
permitted only with the consent of Executive Engineer,
which was lacking in the instant case.
UKHC010176442025
2026:UHC:7067-DB
14.
Independent of the reasoning given by the learned
Single Judge, we find that, although paragraph no. 2 permits
interchange of allotments with the consent of the Gram
Pradhan, it does not confer any indefeasible right in favour
of any allottee to claim any particular plot.
Therefore, we
find no illegality in the view taken by the learned Single
Judge, declining to accept the claim of the appellant for
exchange of Plot No. 330 allotted in his favour with Plot No.
E31.
15.
The other contention of the appellant that Plot No.
330 was not suitable for agricultural purposes, it appears
from the order of the learned Single Judge that, with a view
to resolving the said issue, the learned Single Judge heard
Rehabilitation Director through video conferencing.
The
Rehabilitation Director stated before the learned Single
Judge that the agricultural land allotted to the appellant
would be made suitable for agricultural purposes in all
respects, with the assistance of the officials of the THDC,
and further undertook to complete the exercise within the
stipulated time.
Taking notice of the statement of the
Rehabilitation Director, the learned Single Judge directed
that the agricultural Plot No. 330 allotted to the appellant be
UKHC010176442025
2026:UHC:7067-DB
made suitable in all respects within six weeks and that,
thereafter, possession thereof be handed over to the
appellant.
16.
Having issued the aforesaid direction in favour of
the appellant, the learned Single Judge proceeded to
consider the case of Hikmat Singh Panwar from paragraph
no. 14 onwards.
Upon noticing that he is also an oustee,
and had not been allotted any agricultural plot in lieu of the
earlier allotment, which stood cancelled, the learned Single
Judge directed the Department to allot Plot No. E31 in his
favour. The relevant observations and directions, in respect
of the appellant, as contained in paragraph no. 13, and in
respect of Hikmat Singh Panwar, as contained in paragraph
nos. 24 to 26, are extracted below :
“13. The Director Rehabilitation Mayur Dixit joined the
proceeding through V.C. and apprise to this court that in
fact the land allotted to the petitioner Indramani i.e. Plot
No. 330 having an area of 2 acre is suitable for agriculture
purposes, but taking into consideration the report of the
Deputy Revenue Officer dated 15.07.2023 the land will be
made suitable for agriculture purposes from all corner with
the assistance of the officials of the THDC and this entire
exercise will be completed within six weeks. The
suggestion as given by the Director Rehabilitation for the
purposes of resolving this dispute is really appreciable. In
such an eventuality, the instant writ petition filed by
Indramani is disposed of finally with the direction to the
Director Rehabilitation to make Plot No. 330 measuring 2
acre for agriculture purpose by taking assistance of the
District Administration, Revenue Officials as well as
Officials of the THDC. After completing the entire exercise
within six weeks the Director, Rehabilitation will give the
peaceful possession of Plot No. 330 to the petitioner after
UKHC010176442025
2026:UHC:7067-DB
measuring the land to ascertain that the area would not be
less than two acre.
24. Now, since the Director Rehabilitation fairly suggest
that the Plot No. E 31, which was earlier allotted to Chatar
Singh is vacant and can be allotted to the petitioner Mr.
Hikmat Singh Panwar.
25. Learned senior counsel Mr. Rajendra Dobhal, who
appears for “Hikmat Singh Panwar” fairly accepts the
suggestion of the Director and submits that the petitioner
is ready to accept Plot No. E 31.
26. On this, the Director Rehabilitation submits that the
possession of Plot No. E 31 shall be handed over to
petitioner Hikmat Singh Panwar within 15 days from
today.”
17.
Thus, having addressed and resolved the claim of
both the parties, the learned Single Judge, in the concluding
paragraph, has observed as follows :
“27. Since, now the issue as raised by both the
petitioners, who are the displaced person has been
resolved in view of the observation and directions as
above. Accordingly, the present writ petition is disposed of
finally.”
18.
Thereafter, the appellant filed a review application
before the learned Single Judge alleging that Hikmat Singh
Panwar had already transferred agricultural Plot No. 18
originally allotted to him, by a registered sale deed dated
14.02.2013 in favour of Naveen Uniyal, s/o Paripurnanand
Uniyal and Sawan Singh, s/o Kalam Singh, and the said fact
was actively concealed by him, and that had the said fact
been disclosed, no relief would have been granted to him.
19.
The review application was opposed by Hikmat
Singh Panwar, contending that, since the allotment of
UKHC010176442025
2026:UHC:7067-DB
agricultural Plot No. 18 in his favour had been cancelled on
18.11.2013, the land stood re-vested in THDC and its
possession had also remained with THDC. Consequently,
according to him, the sale deed executed by him had
become null and void. In the aforesaid circumstances, the
parties themselves treated the sale as null and void and the
entire sale consideration was returned to the vendee,
Naveen Uniyal. It was also contended on behalf of Hikmat
Singh Panwar that the appellant, Indramani, who had
originally been allotted Plot No. 4, admeasuring 200 sq.
mtrs., at Patel Nagar, Dehrakhas, Dehradun, had similarly
sold his plot also, though allotment of the said plot was
subsequently cancelled.
20.
The learned Single Judge, therefore, directed
THDC to clarify the factual position.
In compliance of the
said direction, a compliance affidavit was filed by the
Rehabilitation
Director,
wherein
he
also
stated
that
Indramani had sold residential Plot No. 4, admeasuring 200
sq. mtrs., to one Sarita Pandey vide sale deed dated
06.03.2013.
It further appears from the order-sheet that,
on basis of instructions received from THDC, learned counsel
appearing on its behalf informed the Court that the
possession of agricultural Plot No. 18, initially allotted to
UKHC010176442025
2026:UHC:7067-DB
Hikmat Singh Panwar, pursuant to the cancellation of the
said allotment, had remained with THDC, and thus the sale
deed between Hikmat Singh Panwar and Naveen Uniyal had
become ineffective.
21.
The learned Single Judge, taking note of the stand
of THDC that sale deed executed by Hikmat Singh Panwar in
favour of Naveen Uniyal was a nullity in the eyes of law and
the possession of the land had remained with THDC,
rejected the review application.
22.
Before
this
Court,
learned
counsel
for
the
appellant has advanced three submissions, namely :
(a)
Hikmat Singh Panwar had not approached the
writ court with clean hands, as he had concealed
the fact of execution of sale deed of Plot No. 18
originally allotted to him, in favour to Naveen
Uniyal.
It is, therefore, contended that the
learned Single Judge, on such fact being brought
to its notice by way of review application, erred in
rejecting the same.
Learned counsel for the
appellant has also drawn the attention of the Court
towards a suit instituted by Hikmat Singh Panwar
(Original Suit No. 76/2025), wherein it is alleged,
UKHC010176442025
2026:UHC:7067-DB
in paragraph no. 5, that he had agreed to transfer
the newly allotted plot to the same vendee, i.e.
Naveen Uniyal, although the relief sought in the
suit is for cancellation of the sale deed dated
14.02.2013.
(b) Agricultural Plot No. 330, allotted in favour of
the appellant, is not fit for cultivation.
Despite
various reports of the authorities to the said effect,
the learned Single Judge erred in declining the
appellant’s request for exchange of Plot No. E31.
(c)
The direction issued by learned Single Judge,
for allotment of Plot No. E31 in favour of Hikmat
Singh Panwar, without subjecting the said plot to
the lottery system, is not valid.
23.
On the other hand, the learned counsel for Hikmat
Singh Panwar submitted that, since the original allotment of
agricultural Plot No. 18 in favour of Hikmat Singh Panwar
was cancelled on 18.11.2013 and possession was taken back
by the THDC and the title in the land re-vested with the
State Government, therefore, the sale deed executed by
Hikmat Singh Panwar, in respect of the said plot, was
rendered null and void. The sale consideration for the said
UKHC010176442025
2026:UHC:7067-DB
land paid by the vendee was duly returned to him.
An
affidavit to the said effect has already been filed by Hikmat
Singh Panwar, as well as by the vendee, namely Naveen
Uniyal
in
the
present
proceedings.
It is,
therefore,
submitted that non-disclosure of the execution of the said
sale deed was of no consequence and could not, in any
manner, have affected the ultimate outcome of the writ
petition.
As regards the suit filed in the year 2025, it is
submitted that the same was filed for cancellation of the sale
deed so that the document does not create any confusion.
It is further submitted that there is no prohibition against
the sale of plot allotted under the rehabilitation scheme, and
therefore even if Hikmat Singh Panwar intends to transfer
the recently allotted plot in favour of any person, the same
has no bearing on the merits of the present case.
It is
further submitted that agricultural Plot No. 330 had already
been allotted to the appellant and his grievance that it was
not fit for cultivation has already been addressed by the
learned Single Judge.
Lastly, it is submitted that since
Hikmat Singh Panwar had not been allotted any agricultural
plot, though entitled to the same, therefore, the learned
Single Judge rightly directed for allotment of Plot No. E31 in
favour of Hikmat Singh Panwar.
UKHC010176442025
2026:UHC:7067-DB
24.
We have considered the rival submissions and
perused the material on record.
25.
The main emphasis of the learned counsel for the
appellant is on the fact that Hikmat Singh Panwar had not
disclosed
about
the
execution
of
sale
deed
dated
14.02.2013, in respect of agricultural Plot No. 18, in favour
of Naveen Uniyal.
However, the said contention does not
have any force.
It is undisputed that the allotment of
agricultural Plot No. 18 in favour of Hikmat Singh Panwar
was subsequently cancelled on 18.11.2013.
The learned
Single Judge has taken note of the stand of Hikmat Singh
Panwar that, upon cancellation of allotment, the possession
and title of the said plot remained with the THDC and the
sale deed executed by Hikmat Singh Panwar was rendered
null and void. The THDC had clarified its stand before the
learned Single Judge that possession of the said plot had
remained with it.
Consequently, the execution of the sale
deed was not a material fact having any bearing upon the
entitlement of Hikmat Singh Panwar to rehabilitation.
Its
non-disclosure, therefore, does not affect the ultimate
outcome of the case.
UKHC010176442025
2026:UHC:7067-DB
26.
The second contention of the appellant was with
regard to the unsuitability of Plot No. 330 allotted in favour
of the appellant. In the present proceedings, having regard
to the said grievance, this Court by order dated 10.03.2026,
required the learned State Counsel to clarify the said aspect.
On basis of the said direction, learned State Counsel, after
obtaining instructions from Rehabilitation Director, Tehri
Garhwal, on the subsequent date clarified that the plot
allotted to the appellant was not, in fact, in three portions as
alleged, but adjacent to each other, except for the fact that
a canal and a metal road passes through the said land. On
the same date, this Court also noted the contention of the
appellant that one portion of the plot was at a lower
elevation.
Having
regard
to the
said
grievance
the
Rehabilitation Director was directed to take positive steps to
resolve the issue. The order dated 12.03.2026 is as follows:
“1. Mr. Pradeep
petitioner.
Kumar,
learned
counsel
for
the
2.
Mr. J. C .Pande, learned Standing Counsel for the
State/respondent nos.1 to 4.
3.
Mr. Rajendra Dobhal, learned Senior Counsel,
assisted by Mr. Suryakant Maithani and Mr. Shubhang
Dobhal, learned counsel for the respondent nos. 5 & 6.
4.
Ms. Ananya Jain, learned counsel holding brief of Mr.
Sandeep Kothari, learned counsel for respondent
no.7/T.H.D.C.
5.
Learned State counsel has placed on record the
instructions received from Director, Rehabilitation, Tehri
Garhwal, wherein the stand taken is that the three portions
of land allotted to the appellant are in fact, adjacent to
UKHC010176442025
2026:UHC:7067-DB
each other except a canal and a metal road passing
between the land.
6.
Learned counsel of the appellant has invited our
attention towards
reports dated 08.10.2025
and
12.09.2025 and relying on the same, it is contended that
after the alleged levelling of the plot, one portion is still 3.5
feet below the level of the road and at the time of
inspection by officials of the T.H.D.C., water logging of 1.5
feet was found at the site. He submits that the report
categorically states that the water from adjoining plots
gets accumulated over said portion of the plot and
consequently it is not suitable for agricultural operations.
7.
The Director, Rehabilitation appeared through Video
Conferencing during course of hearing of the writ petition
by learned Single Judge. It seems that at the time of
hearing of the writ petition, he assured the Court that the
plot allotted to the appellant would be made suitable in all
respects, but we observe that the water logging still
persists. The object of allotting land to the oustees is to
rehabilitate them and, therefore, it is bounden duty of the
State to ensure that the land which is allotted is suitable
for the purpose for which allotment has been made. This
indeed was also the undertaking extended by the Director,
Rehabilitation before the learned Single Judge.
8.
We direct the Director, Rehabilitation to ensure that
the issue is resolved by taking positive steps in this regard
within two weeks and apprise the Court of the steps taken
by him in this behalf.
9.
List on 02.04.2026.
10. Learned State counsel shall communicate the instant
order to the Director, Rehabilitation for necessary
compliance.”
27.
Pursuant
to
the
aforesaid
direction,
the
Rehabilitation Director filed a compliance affidavit, and in
which he stated that the agricultural plot allotted to the
appellant had been made cultivable by levelling and applying
fertilizer, and in doing so, the department had incurred an
expense of Rs. 20 Lakhs.
Copy of the Measurement Book
and Soil Test Report of the plot have been filed by him,
along with his affidavit, in support of the said stand.
UKHC010176442025
2026:UHC:7067-DB
Further,
in
paragraph
no.
of
the
affidavit,
the
Rehabilitation Director has also given clarification in respect
of the appellant’s contention that agricultural Plot No. 330 is
not situated at the same elevation, which is as follows :
“6. That on 17.03.2026, the departmental officials again
conducted a field inspection of Agricultural Plot No. 330 in
compliance of the Order dated 12.03.2026 of the Hon'ble
High Court. In the Report, it is mentioned that presently no
water-logging has been observed on the plot. All
Agricultural Plots in the area, including Agricultural Plot No.
330, are 3-3.5 feet below the Road and are situated at
same elevation, wherein wheat is being cultivated, except
for the plot in question. In this connection, photographs of
the Plot in question obtained from Google Maps Satellite
are being annexed as Annexure No.-2 to this affidavit.
The departmental report also states that during the
rainy season, water from the nearby forest seeps into
Agricultural Plot No. 330 and surrounding plots. However,
wheat cultivation is presently taking place on all other plots
adjacent to Agricultural Plot No. 330. Furthermore, the
elevation of Agricultural Plot No. 330 cannot be further
increased, as doing so would lower the other plots and
cause them to become waterlogged. True/ correct typed
version/ copy of the Report dated 17.03.2026 along with
Google
Map satellite image of the site in question is being annexed
as Annexure No.-3 to this affidavit.”
28.
It has also been stated that, even after the
aforesaid exercise taken by the THDC, if the appellant is still
not satisfied with the allotment of Plot No. 330 in his favour,
the following options are available with him :“(i) The name of the petitioner could be included in the
upcoming lottery for the allotment of Agricultural Plot.
However, the department presently has only 10
Agricultural Plots available for allotment at various
Rehabilitation Sites, for which the land at Pratitnagar is
only 1.25 bighas (1024 square meters). The number of
eligible displaced persons to be allocated agricultural plot is
16. Due to the limited availability of plots, it is not possible
to allot agricultural land to all eligible displaced persons.
UKHC010176442025
2026:UHC:7067-DB
(ii) Due to the unavailability of land, the existing Collateral
Damage Policy provides for a grant of Rs. 74.40 lakh in lieu
of land. Eligible displaced persons who are unable to obtain
agricultural land through the lottery will be considered for a
grant of Rs. 74.40 lakh as under this Policy.”
29.
After going through the compliance affidavit filed
by the THDC, we are satisfied that the grievance of the
appellant that Plot No. 330 is not cultivable no more
survives.
If still the appellant is not satisfied with the
allotment of Plot No. 330 in his favour, the options given by
THDC, as extracted hereinabove, are available to him, which
he is free to avail.
30.
As regards the third contention that the writ court
exceeded its power in directing allotment of Plot No. E31 in
favour of Hikmat Singh Panwar, without resorting to the
process of lottery, this Court once again reiterates that the
direction was issued in view of the peculiar facts of the case,
and in an attempt to satisfy both the parties, and thereby
give a quietus to the dispute.
31.
Further, we are informed that the order of the
learned Single Judge, directing allotment of Plot No. E31 in
favour of Hikmat Singh Panwar, has already been complied
with
by
the
THDC
by
issuing
allotment
order
dated
15.04.2025, and possession of the said plot was handed
UKHC010176442025
2026:UHC:7067-DB
over to Hikmat Singh Panwar on 15.04.2025. In view of the
said fact also, we find no good ground to interfere with the
order of the learned Single Judge.
32.
Accordingly, the appeal is dismissed.
33.
All pending applications also stand disposed of
accordingly.
______________________
MANOJ KUMAR GUPTA, C.J.
___________________
SUBHASH UPADHYAY, J.
Dt: 11th August, 2026
Rahul
RAHUL
PRAJAPATI
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND,
ou=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND,
2.5.4.20=aa4fa3bee6691397758b14516ed3e66e6
1bf4c848741983ed8c39e4145cf1dab,
postalCode=263001, st=UTTARAKHAND,
serialNumber=303B55CC3063D34AC45BF8A192F
CAD15C390A1AAD7B39857D2540AE4C28A4898,
cn=RAHUL PRAJAPATI
Date: 2026.08.11 14:22:24 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review