Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:14943
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
A.B.A. No. 7264 of 2025
1. Indrajit Kr. Sethi, aged about 72 years, Son of Late Hiralal Sethi,
resident of Nilini Seth Road, Barabazar, Kolkata, P.O. & P.S.
Barabazar, District Kolkata, West Bengal.
2. Rajesh Sethi @ Rajesh Kumar Sethi, aged about 68 years, Son of
Late Hiralal Sthi, resident of Nilini Seth Road, Barabazar, Kolkata,
P.O. & P.S. Barabazar, District Kolkata, West Bengal
…
…
Petitioners
Versus
The State of Jharkhand
…
… Opposite Party
--CORAM :HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANUBHA RAWAT CHOUDHARY
--For the Petitioner
: Mr. Indrajit Sinha, Advocate
: Mr. Ankit Vishal, Advocate
: Mr. S. Ranjan, Advocate
For the Opp. Party-State : Mr. Sumeet Gadodia, Advocate
: Mr. Ritesh Kumar Gupta, Advocate
: Mr. Nillohit Choubey, Advocate
--11/14.05.2026
1.
Heard the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the parties.
2.
The petitioner No.1 namely Indrajit Kr. Sethi and petitioner
No.2 namely Rajesh Sethi @ Rajesh Kumar Sethi both S/o: Late
Hiralal Sethi are apprehending arrest in connection with A.C.B.
Hazaribagh P.S. Case No. 09 of 2025 for the offence registered under
Sections 120B, 409, 420, 467, 468, 471 of the Indian Penal Code and
Sections 13(2) read with Section 13(1)(c) and 13(1)(d) of the
Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (as amended in 2018), said to be
pending in the court of learned Special Judge, A.C.B. Hazaribagh.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioners has made the following
submissions:a) The petitioners have been falsely implicated in the present case
and at best it is a case of civil dispute.
b) As per the allegations, the property involved in the present case
are lease hold land (Khas Mahal Land) of government situated
in the District of Hazaribagh and for the purposes of renewal of
2026:JHHC:14943
lease in favour of the family members of the petitioners,
including the petitioners, an amount of Rs. 1 crore and odd has
already been deposited with the government and it is the
government who granted the required sanction for transfer of
the Khas Mahal Land.
c) He has further submitted that initially the property was standing
in the name of predecessor in interest of the petitioners as a
Khas Mahal lease property and it was also renewed and
thereafter the predecessor in interest transferred the property to
the deity and became the Sebayat and this was done after due
permission of the concerned authority. However, the said
transfer to Sebayat was cancelled by virtue of a registered deed
of the year 1951 and ultimately the lease under khas mahal was
renewed in the names of the successors of the original allottee.
d) Preliminary enquiry was started in the present case way back in
the year 2015 alleging wrongful transfer of the government land
(khas mahal land) and First Information Report was reinstituted
on 06.08.2025 and with the passage of time the gravity of
offence lost its seriousness in view of the fact that Rs.1.09 crore
and odd was deposited with the government as back as on
15.04.2010 for renewal of lease.
e) At best it could be a case of civil law, but no criminality is
involved in the present case as the required procedure was duly
followed.
f) The petitioners are senior citizens aged 72 years and 68 years
respectively and therefore, the prayer for anticipatory bail of
these petitioners stands on different footing altogether.
g) Learned counsel has also submitted that there is neither any
chance of absconding nor there is any chance of disposal of any
movable or immovable properties by the petitioners and there is
no need for any custodial interrogation of the petitioners.
2026:JHHC:14943
h) Learned counsel has submitted that the petitioners are the heirs
of the original lessee and they have acted as per their rights and
no criminal case is made out against the petitioners.
i) It has been further submitted that as per the counter affidavit
which was filed earlier, it was stated by the opposite party that
petitioners have been non-cooperative with the investigation
and for that purpose statement has been made in paragraph 30,
31 and 32 that the petitioners and co-accused persons have
given incorrect address in their anticipatory bail applications
and therefore, they have not co-operating with the investigation.
The learned counsel has also referred to the order passed by this
Court on 07.05.2026 wherein the arguments of learned counsel
for Anti-Corruption Bureau (ACB) was recorded with respect to
incorrect address and also the submission that the the petitioners
had gone traceless and the notices under section 35(3) of
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita could not be served.
j) Learned counsel for the petitioners has submitted that on
07.05.2026 the matter was adjourned at the request of the
learned counsel for ACB to file supplementary counter-affidavit
bringing on record the documents/materials to show that the
ACB had made attempt to trace out the petitioners at the given
address and they were unable to find them out and also the fact
that the notices were sent and they returned unserved. It was
also open to the petitioners to file supporting documents to
show that the address disclosed by the petitioners in the
anticipatory bail application is correct.
k) Learned counsel then referred to the supplementary affidavit
filed in this case which is dated 12.05.2026 and has submitted
that in the document annexed to the supplementary affidavit the
address of the petitioners including in the Aadhar Card has
shown as “S/o: Hira Lal Sethi, 70, NALINI SETT ROAD,
Barabazar, Kolkata, Barabazar, West Bengal, 700007”. A copy
of electricity bill in connection with the said premises has also
2026:JHHC:14943
been annexed. On the basis of supplementary affidavit, it is
alleged that the statement made by the opposite party in their
counter affidavit that the petitioners have given incorrect
address in their anticipatory bail application is itself not true.
l) The learned counsel has then referred to the judgment passed by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court reported in (2017) 5 SCC 218
[Manoranjana Sinh @ Gupta vs. Central Bureau of
Investigation] dealing with grant of bail to Saradha chit fund
scam and has submitted that the principle for grant of bail has
been enumerated in paragraph 16 of the judgment wherein it has
been held that while considering grant of bail deprivation of
liberty must be considered a punishment unless it is required to
ensure that an accused person would stand his trial when called
upon and that every man is deemed to be innocent until duly
tried and found guilty. It has also been held that detention in
custody of undertrial prisoners for an indefinite period would
amount to violation of Article 21 of the Constitution.
m) Learned counsel has then referred to the judgment passed by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court reported in (2020) 5 SCC 1 [Sushila
Aggarwal and Others vs. State (NCT of Delhi) and Another]
and has referred to paragraph 52 of the said judgment and has
submitted that the principles to be considered for grant of
anticipatory bail has been laid down therein. It has been held
that while the power of granting anticipatory bail is
not ordinary, at the same time, its use is not confined to
exceptional cases. It has been held 52.7 as under: 52.7. There is no “inexorable rule” that anticipatory bail
cannot be granted unless the applicant is the target of mala
fides. There are several relevant considerations to be
factored in, by the court, while considering whether to
grant or refuse anticipatory bail. Nature and seriousness of
the proposed charges, the context of the events likely to lead
to the making of the charges, a reasonable possibility of the
accused's presence not being secured during trial; a
reasonable apprehension that the witnesses might be
2026:JHHC:14943
tampered with, and “the larger interests of the public or the
State” are some of the considerations. A person seeking
relief (of anticipatory bail) continues to be a man presumed
to be innocent. …………………..
n) Learned counsel has submitted that in view of the aforesaid
facts and circumstances the petitioners may be enlarged on bail
and they are ready to appear before the authority on any date
and time as may be fixed by this Court for the purposes of
investigation.
o) The learned counsel for the petitioners has also referred to the
order of Hon’ble Supreme Court passed on 25th March, 2026 in
Special Leave Petition (Crl.) No. 2797 of 2026 [Sudhir Kumar
Singh vs. The State of Jharkhand], who was the power of
attorney holder of the petitioners, and has submitted that his
anticipatory bail application was rejected by this Court in
A.B.A. No. 5781 of 2025 vide order dated 20.01.2026 and
before the Hon’ble Supreme Court one interim order dated
18.02.2026 was passed whereby the petitioner of the said case
has been directed to co-operate with the investigation and
ultimately when he co-operated with the investigation, the
interim relief granted by the Hon’ble Supreme Court was
confirmed and the appeal was allowed. Learned counsel has
submitted another co-accused namely Bijay Pratap Singh, who
was also the power of attorney holder was taken into custody.
His anticipatory bail was also rejected by this Court in A.B.A.
No.5781 of 2025 and subsequently he was arrested and his
regular bail application was considered and rejected by this
court. However, he has been enlarged on bail by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court.
4.
Learned counsel for the ACB while opposing the prayer has
submitted that –
I.
Sufficient material has already been placed on record to show
the complicity of the petitioners in the alleged offence. It has
been submitted that it is not a case of pure civil dispute rather
2026:JHHC:14943
the entire sequence of events as mentioned in the counter
affidavit, which is based on materials collected, would reveal
that the petitioners are to be prosecuted.
II.
Initially khas mahal lease was granted in favour of Ganpat Rai
Sarawgi. In the year 1941, Ganpat Rai Sarawgi by an indenture
of settlement settled the same in favour of deity “Sri Sri
Mahavir Ji” and declared himself to be the Sebayat and this was
done after due permission from the competent authority which
was accorded way back in the year 1948 and the lease was valid
up to 1978. In the meantime, Ganpat Rai Sarawgi died and his
two sons namely Panna Lal Sethi and Hira Lal Sethi assumed
the role of sebayat and an application was filed by Panna Lal
Sethi for renewal of lease scheduled to be expired in the year
1978.
III.
At the time of renewal an attempt was made to get the lease
renewed/transferred in favour of individual names i.e. Panna
Lal Sethi and Hira Lal Sethi instead of in the name of deity and
in support of that a deed of 1951 which was the alleged deed of
cancellation of the trust/settlement executed by Ganpat Rai
Sarawgi in 1941. The said deed of the year 1951 itself was
forged and fabricated document and even otherwise such
document which was unilaterally executed was not permissible
that too without the permission of the Deputy Commissionercum-District Magistrate and therefore, such deed have no value
in the eye of law.
IV.
However, in the application for renewal of lease, the authorized
official recorded that the lease be renewed in the name of deity
and there was no provision under Khas mahal land to transfer
the land in the favour of individual names of sebayat and the
lease deed was renewed for further period of 30 years, up till
2008 and annual rent was also fixed in the name of deity which
was paid up to 31.03.2008 and the name of Hira Lal Sethi and
Panna Lal Sethi were entered as in the capacity of sebayats.
2026:JHHC:14943
V.
In the year 1992-93 an application was filed seeking permission
to transfer 40 decimal of land out of 2.75 acres in favour of one
Sheo Bachan Singh and four others and ultimately a Transfer
Permission Case No. 29 of 1992-93 vide order dated 01.07.2000
an application seeking permission for grant of transfer was
rejected and a direction was also given for resumption of the
entire land.
VI.
4 persons were substituted as Sebayats in the government
record, whose details have been mentioned in paragraph 20 of
the counter affidavit, and out of them two persons were the
present two petitioners.
VII.
Against the aforesaid order dated 01.07.2000 by which the
petition seeking transfer was rejected and land was directed to
be resumed, a writ petition was filed being CWJC No. 4200 of
2000. However, this Court vide judgment dated 26.07.2005 held
that Successor-in-interest or any person who took the charge of
sebayats have no right to transfer the land in favour of any other
person and refusal to grant permission for transfer of leasehold
land was upheld. However, the order to resume the leasehold
property was set aside.
VIII.
Further, since the lease was expiring in the year 2008, an
application was made for renewal of lease by Basanti Kumari
Sethi, which was registered as Case No. 85 of 2007-08 and
prayer was made for renewal of lease for the period from
01.04.2008 to 31.03.2038 and despite the fact that the lease was
standing in the name of the deity, a proposal was moved in the
file for substituting the original sebayat with the surviving
sebayat.
IX.
The allegation is that the file was moved only for the purpose of
substitution of names of sebayats, but the government official,
in connivance with the sebayats and on the basis of alleged
cancellation deed of the year 1951, proposed to delete the name
of the lessee “Sri Sri Mahavir Ji” from Register-II and substitute
2026:JHHC:14943
the same in Register-II in favour of individual names of
sebayats in the individual capacity and the proposal was given
to the Khas Mahal Officer on 08.12.2008 to the Additional
Collector and the Deputy Commissioner on 08.12.2008 and on
the same date the approval was granted on the said proposal.
X.
Further allegation is that in the aforesaid manner, the lease hold
property which was standing in the name of the deity was
permitted to be converted into individual lease in favour of the
Sebayats and this was done inspite of the earlier order passed by
this Court in writ jurisdiction and by further manipulating the
register II. Thereby, the property standing in the name of deity
was manipulated to be in the name of the sebayats in the
individual capacity.
XI.
Further the allegation is that the proposal has made thereafter
through the power of attorney holder namely Vijay Pratap
Singh and Sudhir Pratap Singh for transfer of 2.2289 acres of
land in favour of 23 persons whose details have been mentioned
in the counter affidavit and on that basis transfer permission
case No. 1 of 2009-10 was registered and one Binod Chandra
Jha in connivance with sebayats and the power of attorney
holder namely Vijay Pratap Singh and Sudhir Pratap Singh
forwarded the file for transfer of land and ultimately the Deputy
Commissioner granted the approval on 04.09.2009 in favour of
23 individuals.
Thus the sebayats in connivance with the
government official misappropriated the property of deity
which in turn was khas mahal property and converted the same
initially in their own name and then transferred the same in
favour of 23 individual through the power of attorney holders.
5.
So far as the conduct of the petitioners are concerned, as per the
initial counter affidavit it was alleged that the petitioners had given
incorrect address and even during the course of investigation it was
found that the address was incorrect and so far as Basanti Kumari
2026:JHHC:14943
Sethi is concerned, during investigation it revealed that she died
almost 10 years back but the same was not yet confirmed.
6.
It is also submitted that the then Deputy Commissioner, who
had granted the permission for transfer in the name of individual
persons was Vinay Kumar Choubey who is also a co-accused in the
present case.
7.
It has been further submitted that pursuant to the last order a
supplementary counter affidavit has been filed in this case wherein the
opposite party has stated that on the one hand the address as shown in
the anticipatory bail application is itself incomplete inasmuch as the
house number was not disclosed in the address which is said to be
situated at Barabazar, Kolkata and the area comprises of huge
population of approximately 1 lakh. The complete address was also
not disclosed in the anticipatory bail application filed before the
learned court.
8.
It has also been stated that on 25.09.2025 one Sub-Inspector
was appointed to visit their house in the District Hazaribagh and they
were informed that the petitioners were not residing. The address
mentioned in the anticipatory bail application was sought to be
confirmed by physical verification. Thereafter another sub inspector
and constable was deputed to personally verify the correct address of
the petitioners, but could not ascertain. Further, they got information
from the Technical Cell that house number was 70 and consequently,
two persons visited to house No.70, but during inquiry it revealed that
the petitioners had left their house on 04.10.2025 by saying that they
are going to Chennai and upon further input received from technical
cell, the last location of petitioner No.1 was revealed which was
shown to be M. Rajkrishan Trading Private Limited Basat Street,
Kolkata (West Bengal) situated near the aforesaid house of the
petitioners and upon approach the petitioners were not found at this
address also. Consequently, the notice was pasted on the Main
Entrance Gate of the residential house of the petitioners situated at
House No. 70, 2nd Floor, Basak Street, Barabazar Kolkata and on the
2026:JHHC:14943
aforesaid basis, it has been alleged that the petitioners are avoiding to
co-operate with the investigation and the address furnished in the
anticipatory bail application is incomplete/incorrect.
9.
After hearing the learned counsel for the parties and
considering the facts and circumstances of this case, this Court finds
that enough material has been collected against the petitioners to show
that the petitioners converted the Khas Mahal property which was
belonging to the deity in their individual names inspite of the fact that
the order of the High Court in CWJC No. 4200 of 2000 challenging
the order dated 01.07.2000 refusing to grant permission for transfer of
land was upheld by this court. It further appears that the government
records, particularly Register-II, was also tempered to substitute the
name of the deity by name of the sebayats in their individual capacity.
This was followed by a proposal for grant of permission to transfer by
individual persons, who were actually sebayats of the deity, and
permission for transfer was granted in favour of 23 persons. In the
meantime, the petitioners were acting through the power of attorney
holders namely Vijay Pratap Singh and Sudhir Pratap Singh and
ultimately the Khas Mahal government property, which belonged to
the deity by way of lease was transferred in favour of 23 persons by
individual persons and not in the capacity of sebayats.
10.
This Court is of the view that the aforesaid allegation are quite
serious and sufficient materials have been collected against the
petitioners and accordingly the petitioners are not entitled for
anticipatory bail by this Court.
11.
This is over and above the fact that the address which has been
disclosed before this Court is itself incomplete. Non-mentioning of
the house number in a thickly populated place has a serious bearing
and the opposite party could trace the house number only with the
help of technical cell. The materials placed on record by ACB reveal
that they have been making serious attempt to trace out the petitioners,
but initially they were not traced out on the given address and then
through the Technical Cell they got the house number and at the house
2026:JHHC:14943
the petitioners were not found. Subsequently another address of
petitioners was found out through technical cell and at the other
address also the petitioners were not present. The conduct of the
petitioners reveal that they have conducted themselves in such a
manner that they remained traceless for quite some time and avoided
participation in the investigation of the case. This is over and above
the aforesaid fact that much material has been collected against the
petitioners disentitling them from the privilege of anticipatory bail.
12.
So far as the bail /anticipatory bail granted to the power of
attorney holders are concerned, their case stand on different footing
as it appears from the sequence of events, as placed by the learned
counsel for the opposite party that the power of attorney holders
entered into picture much after the permission for transfer was granted
and certainly their entry into the affairs was much after passing of the
earlier order dated 01.07.2000 refusing permission to transfer was
upheld by the High Court in the aforesaid writ petition vide order
dated 26.07.2005 and order of resumption of land of the deity was setaside . At this, the learned counsel for the opposite party has submitted
that the power of attorney is of the year 2009 (executed on 02nd
February, 2009).
13.
Accordingly, this anticipatory bail application was dismissed.
14.
Let a copy of this order be communicated to the court
concerned through ‘FAX/E-mail’.
(Anubha Rawat Choudhary, J.)
14.05.2026
Rakesh/Uploaded on:-16.05.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review