Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 17th August 2026
%
#
CNR No. DLHC010715762015
+
W.P.(C) 1665/2015
INDIAN OIL CORPORATION LTD.
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Saran Suri, Ms. Ruchi Jain and
Mr. Nagashree Sharma, Advocates.
versus
DELHI CANTONMENT BOARD
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Ankur Mishra, Advocate
(through VC)
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT BANSAL
AMIT BANSAL, J. (Oral)
1.
The present writ petition has been filed seeking the following reliefs:
“A. Call for the Records;
B. Issue writ of mandamus or other appropriate writ(s) quashing
assessment order dated 29.8.2014 passed by the respondent;
C. Issue writ of mandamus or other appropriate writ commanding the
respondent not to raise any demand upon the petitioner for the period
1995-96 and thereafter pursuant to assessment order dated 29.08.2014;
D. Issue writ of mandamus or other appropriate writ commanding the
respondent to determine the assessment in accordance with the
provisions of Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958;
E. Issue writ of mandamus or other appropriate writ quashing demand if
any raised by the respondent pursuance to the assessment order dated
29.8.2014;
F. Issue writ of mandamus or other appropriate writ quashing any
demand raised by the respondent not consistent with the provisions of
Digitally Signed
By:AANCHAL TAGGAR
19:22:50
W.P.(C) 1665/2015
Assessment List for the period in dispute;
G. Issue writ of mandamus or other appropriate writ quashing the
assessment list for the year 1996-97 which was authenticated on
30.3.1998 and”
2.
The grievance of the petitioner is that the respondent/Delhi
Cantonment Board (hereinafter ‘DCB’), by the impugned assessment order
dated 29th August 2014, illegally determined the rateable value of the
petitioner's Aviation Fuel Station at Rs. 1,77,49,299/-, retrospectively from
the year 1995–96 without following the prescribed statutory procedure.
3.
Brief facts necessary for deciding the present petition are as follows:
3.1.
The petitioner, Indian Oil Corporation Limited, is a Government
Company engaged in, inter alia, the storage and supply of aviation fuel
through an Aviation Fuel Station situated at Palam, Delhi Cantonment.
3.2.
The subject property comprises land which was given on license to
the petitioner by an Agreement dated 5th November 1962. The licence was
subsequently renewed in the year 1988.
3.3.
On 20th June, 1996, the respondent/DCB issued a notice to the
petitioner under Section 68 of the Cantonments Act, 1924, proposing the
assessment list for the triennial period 1995-96 to 1997-98 by fixing the
annual rateable value (hereinafter ‘ARV’) of the property at Rs.53,30,379/-.
Subsequently, by communication dated 2nd August, 1996, the respondent
revised the proposed ARV to Rs.44,93,698/-, purportedly on the basis of
rates communicated by the Defence Estate Officer.
3.4.
The petitioner filed detailed objections on 26th July, 1996, 28th
August, 1996 and 1st February, 1997, disputing the proposed assessment as
being contrary to the statutory provisions governing preparation and revision
Digitally Signed
By:AANCHAL TAGGAR
19:22:50
W.P.(C) 1665/2015
of assessment lists and also objecting to the methodology adopted for
determining ARV.
3.5.
Since no final speaking order came to be passed and demands
continued to be raised, the petitioner instituted W.P.(C) 7093/2000, which
was disposed of by this Court on 8th November, 2011, directing DCB to
reassess the petitioner’s liability and pass a reasoned order.
3.6.
Instead of granting a hearing, the respondent, vide reply dated 7th
February, 2014, informed the petitioner that objections filed by the
petitioner stood disposed of and ARV of Rs.53,30,739/- stood confirmed
from 31st March, 1996 onwards.
3.7.
Thereafter, the petitioner preferred W.P.(C) 3594/2014 challenging
the aforesaid reply dated 7th February 2014. The said petition was disposed
of on 9th July, 2014, directing DCB to afford a personal hearing and pass a
speaking order.
3.8.
Pursuant thereto, the respondent/DCB passed the impugned
Assessment Order dated 29th August, 2014 whereby the ARV was fixed at
Rs.1,77,49,299/-.
4.
Aggrieved by the aforesaid impugned order, the present writ petition
has been filed. It is contended that although the respondent purported to
rectify only “arithmetical errors”, the impugned order completely altered the
basis and methodology of assessment after almost eighteen years, resulting
in enhancement of ARV without issuance of any fresh notice or affording
the petitioner an opportunity to object to the revised methodology. It is
averred that the respondent retrospectively amended the assessment list
without complying with the mandatory procedure prescribed under Sections
66 to 72 of the Cantonments Act, 1924 (Sections 75 to 81 under the
Digitally Signed
By:AANCHAL TAGGAR
19:22:50
W.P.(C) 1665/2015
Cantonments Act of 2006) relating to preparation, publication, consideration
of objections and authentication of the assessment list.
5.
Notice in the present writ petition was issued vide order dated 24th
February 2015.
6.
Vide order dated 24th February 2015, the operation of the impugned
order was stayed. The petitioner was directed to continue to pay the admitted
liability during the pendency of the writ petition on the basis of the principle
of cost of construction and cost of land as on the date of construction and
recovery of the balance amount was stayed.
7.
In the counter affidavit filed on behalf of the respondent/DCB, it is
stated that as follows:
i.
The present writ petition is not maintainable on account of an
alternate statutory remedy under the Cantonments Act, 2006.
ii.
The impugned assessment has been carried out in accordance with the
provisions of the Cantonments Act and the applicable Government
guidelines.
iii.
In compliance with the order dated 9th July 2014 passed by this Court
in W.P.(C) 3594/2014, a personal hearing was granted to the
petitioner and the objections raised by the representatives of the
petitioner were considered in detail. The assessment order dated 29th
August 2014 has been passed after consideration of the oral/written
submissions of the petitioner. The principles of natural justice have
been duly complied with by the respondent/DCB.
8.
Mr. Ankit Jain, senior counsel for the respondent, objects to the
maintainability of the present writ petition. The petitioner has bypassed the
statutory remedy of appeal as prescribed under Sections 93 and 96 of the
Digitally Signed
By:AANCHAL TAGGAR
19:22:50
W.P.(C) 1665/2015
Cantonments Act, 2006 (hereinafter ‘Act’), to escape the requirement of
mandatory pre-deposit of the property tax. He further submits that the
appropriate remedy for the petitioner would be to file a statutory appeal
before the Municipal Tax Tribunal.
9.
Mr. Suri, counsel for the petitioner, counters the aforesaid submission
by submitting that in the present case, in terms of the notice issued by the
respondent on 20th June, 1996, ARV was proposed at Rs. 53,30,739/-. He
further submits that vide communication dated 2nd August, 1996, the rateable
value was fixed at Rs. 44,44,698/-. However, the impugned assessment
order fixed the same arbitrarily at Rs.1,77,49,299/-. Without any further
notice under Section 76 or 79 of the Cantonments Act, 2006, seeking to
revise the said rateable value, the rateable value has been revised by the
respondent/DCB.
10.
I have heard counsel for the parties.
11.
The genesis of the dispute lies in the notice dated 20th June, 1996,
issued under Section 68(1) of the Cantonment Act, 1924, wherein the
assessment list for the year 1995-98 was proposed to be fixed at an ARV of
Rs.53,30,739.00 in respect of the subject property. Upon the petitioner
raising objections, ARV was worked out at Rs.44,43,698/- by the respondent
vide letter dated 2nd August 1996. However, by the impugned order dated
29th August 2014, the respondent has fixed the ARV at Rs. Rs.1,77,49,299/for the year 1995-96.
12.
The aforesaid course adopted by the respondent suffers from manifest
infirmity. If the respondent intended to enhance the ARV beyond the figure
of Rs.53,30,739.00, it was incumbent upon the respondent to issue a fresh
notice setting out the proposed enhancement and the basis on which such
Digitally Signed
By:AANCHAL TAGGAR
19:22:50
W.P.(C) 1665/2015
enhancement was sought to be made. The requirement of notice is intended
to afford the assessee an effective opportunity to object to both the basis and
the quantum of the proposed assessment. In the present case, no such notice
proposing an ARV of Rs.1,77,49,299/- was issued to the petitioner.
13.
A reference may be made to Section 79 of the Cantonments Act,
2006, which is set out below:
“79. Amendment of assessment list.—(1) The Chief Executive Officer
may after obtaining the approval of President Cantonment Board amend
the assessment list at any time—
(a) …
(b) …
(c) by altering the assessment on any property which has been
erroneously valued or assessed through fraud, accident or mistake
whether on the part of administration or assessee; or
(d) by revaluing or re-assessing any property the value of which has been
increased; or
(e) …
Provided that no person shall by reason of any such amendment
become liable to pay any tax or increase of tax in respect of any period
prior to the commencement of the year in which the assessment is
made.
(2) Before making any amendment under sub-section (1) the Chief
Executive Officer shall give to any person affected by the amendment,
notice of not less than one month that he proposes to make the
amendment.
(3) Any person interested in any such amendment may tender an
objection to the Chief Executive Officer in writing before the time fixed
in the notice, and shall be allowed an opportunity of being heard in
support of the same in person or by authorised agent.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
14.
A reading of the aforesaid provision empowers the Chief Executive
Officer, with the approval of the President, Cantonment Board, to amend the
Digitally Signed
By:AANCHAL TAGGAR
19:22:50
W.P.(C) 1665/2015
assessment list, inter alia, where a property has been erroneously valued or
assessed through fraud, accident or mistake or where the value of a property
has increased. However, the proviso to Section 79(1) expressly stipulates
that no person shall, by reason of such amendment, become liable to pay any
tax or increase of tax in respect of any period prior to the commencement of
the year in which the assessment is made. Further, sub-sections (2) and (3)
mandate that, before effecting any such amendment, the person affected is to
be given notice of not less than one month of the proposed amendment and
an opportunity to tender objections and to be heard in support thereof. The
statutory scheme, therefore, does not permit an enhancement of the
assessment without prior notice of the proposed enhancement.
15.
The respondent passed the impugned assessment order and a perusal
thereof would reveal that instead of maintaining the assessment as proposed
by way of notice dated 20th June, 1996 at an ARV of Rs.53,30,739/- the
respondent suo moto enhanced ARV to Rs. 1,77,49,799/- without giving
fresh notice. Since the notice was for the proposed rateable value of
Rs.53,30,739/- the respondent could not have enhanced the assessment to
Rs. 1,77,49,799/-.
16.
It is relevant to note the position taken by the respondent in the earlier
round of litigation before this Court in W.P.(C) 7093/2000, which was
disposed of vide judgment dated 8th November, 2011. Paragraph 20 of the
said judgment is set out below:
“20. Learned counsel for the petitioner points out, and in my view
correctly so, that the said notices fixing dates for personal hearing were
of no avail as the respondent had already passed the order of assessment
on 16.09.1996 after giving the basis on which the respondent had made
the assessment. The categorical stand of the respondent was that the
proposed assessment to the tune of Rs.44,43,698/- has been worked out
Digitally Signed
By:AANCHAL TAGGAR
19:22:50
W.P.(C) 1665/2015
correctly. The admitted position is that there is no other assessment
order passed by the respondent which may have been communicated to
the petitioner or which may have been existing on the respondent's file.”
[Emphasis Supplied.]
17.
Thus, the stand taken by the respondent before this Court in the earlier
round was that the assessment at Rs.44,43,698/- had been correctly worked
out. The subsequent proceedings were required to be undertaken pursuant to
the directions of this Court for reassessment of the petitioner’s liability, after
granting an opportunity of hearing and passing a reasoned order. However,
this would not enable the respondent to unilaterally enhance the ARV from
what was stated in the notice under Section 68(1) of the Cantonment Act,
1924.
18.
In the subsequent proceedings, the petitioner was admittedly afforded
a personal hearing, after which the impugned order was passed. The material
circumstance which cannot be lost sight of is that the respondent had
categorically maintained, in the earlier proceedings before this Court, that
the ARV of Rs.44,43,698/- had been correctly worked out.
19.
To be noted, immediately prior to the passing of the impugned
Assessment Order, the respondent’s own stand was that the property stood
assessed at an ARV of Rs.53,30,739/- with effect from 1995-96. In this
regard, a reference may be made to the communication dated 7th February,
2014 sent by the respondent in response to the legal notice issued by the
petitioner:
“10. That, as such, the property is assessed to tax at annual rateable
value of Rs. 53 lakh 30,739 from the year 1995-96 onwards. You are
liable to pay tax on the said value from the aforesaid year until date.”
Digitally Signed
By:AANCHAL TAGGAR
19:22:50
W.P.(C) 1665/2015
20.
In the impugned Assessment Order, however, the respondent has
departed from the aforesaid position and has determined the ARV at
Rs.1,77,49,299/-, which is more than three times the figure proposed in the
notice under Section 68(1) of the Cantonment Act, 1924.
21.
The respondent's contention that the impugned order merely rectifies
an “arithmetical error” does not explain the substantial enhancement in the
ARV or the change in the methodology adopted for arriving at the valuation.
The petitioner has specifically contended that the aforesaid enhancement
was not a mere correction of an arithmetical error. According to the
petitioner, the respondent has adopted a substantially different methodology
for determining the value of the land and, on that basis, arrived at the
enhanced ARV.
22.
As regards the respondent’s submission with respect to the
maintainability of the present writ petition, it is a settled position that the
existence of an alternate remedy is not an absolute bar to the maintainability
of a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. Reference in
this regard may be made to the judgment dated 3rd September, 2021 passed
by the Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No. 5121/2021 titled ‘The Assistant
Commissioner of State Tax v. Commercial Steel Limited’. The relevant
extract from the said judgment is set out below:
“11. The respondent had a statutory remedy under section 107. Instead
of availing of the remedy, the respondent instituted a petition under
Article 226. The existence of an alternate remedy is not an absolute bar
to the maintainability of a writ petition under Article 226 of the
Constitution. But a writ petition can be entertained in exceptional
circumstances where there is:
Digitally Signed
By:AANCHAL TAGGAR
19:22:50
W.P.(C) 1665/2015
(i) a breach of fundamental rights;
(ii) a violation of the principles of natural justice;
(iii) an excess of jurisdiction; or
(iv) a challenge to the vires of the statute or delegated legislation.”
[Emphasis Supplied.]
23.
A reference may also be made to the judgment of this Court in
Ramditti Jiwandaram Narang Public Charitable Trust v. Municipal
Corporation of Delhi1 wherein it was held that the existence of a statutory
appeal would not necessarily preclude exercise of the extraordinary
jurisdiction of this Court where the legal correctness and jurisdictional
validity of the assessment itself is under challenge.
24.
In the present case, as discussed above, the impugned assessment
order has been passed clearly without jurisdiction as the ARV has been
enhanced without giving any notice to the petitioner, which is against the
mandate of the statute and in violation of the principles of natural justice.
25.
Accordingly, the impugned assessment order dated 29th August, 2014
is hereby quashed. Consequently, any demand raised by the respondent upon
the petitioner pursuant to the impugned assessment order shall cease to have
effect and shall not be enforced by the respondent.
26.
It would be open for the respondent to pass a fresh Assessment Order
for the period in question in accordance with law and after giving hearing to
the petitioner.
AMIT BANSAL, J
AUGUST 17, 2026
at
2004 SCC OnLine Del 264.
Digitally Signed
By:AANCHAL TAGGAR
19:22:50
W.P.(C) 1665/2015
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review