Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of decision: 11.02.2026
+
O.M.P. (COMM) 251/2018
INDIA YAMAHA MOTOR PRIVATE
LIMITED
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Arpit Dwivedi and Mr.
Manmeet Singh Nagpal, Advs.
versus
M/S MILLENIUM AUTOMOBILES
AND ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Rajesh Banati, Mr. Ashish
Sareen, Mr. Adil Asghar, Mr.
Aditya Mishra and Mr. Ankit
Banati, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AVNEESH JHINGAN
AVNEESH JHINGAN, J. (ORAL)
1.
This petition is filed under Section 34 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 (in short „the Act‟) against the award dated
30.10.2015 whereby the claim filed by the petitioner and counterclaim filed by the respondents were dismissed.
2.
The petitioner is a private limited company engaged in the
manufacturing of two wheeler vehicles. The respondents were given
dealership by M/s Yamaha Motor India Private Limited and M/s
Yamaha Motor India Sales Private Limited and entered into an
agreement dated 10.10.2005. The business was transferred to M/s
India Yamaha Motor Private Limited by M/s Yamaha Motor India
Private Limited and M/s Yamaha Motor India Sales Private Limited
Signed By:HONEY O.M.P. (COMM) 251/2018
ARORA
16:15:39
and the right to recover the amount due vested with the petitioner.
There was a dispute between the parties and arbitration was invoked
by the petitioner. The objection raised by the respondents that there
was no arbitration clause was rejected by the arbitrator and is not
under challenge.
2.1
The petitioner relying upon a computer generated statement of
accounts claimed that an amount of Rs.53,64,415/- was due but the
respondents filed a counter-claim of Rs.73,50,570/-. The claim of the
petitioner was dismissed for failure to prove that the amount was due.
The counter-claim was dismissed as time barred.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner contends that the statement of
accounts was admitted by the respondents and there was no question
of proving it. Clause 19 of the Dealership Agreement is relied upon to
contend that on failure to object to the statement of accounts within
fifteen days of receipt, the amount due as per statement was deemed to
be admitted. The cross-examination of the witness of the respondents,
Mr. Rakesh Kumar is pressed into service to substantiate the
admission of the statement of accounts.
3.1
Lastly, it is contended that the veracity of the statement of
ICICI Bank produced by the respondents was not decided by the
arbitrator and the award is perverse.
4.
Learned counsel for the respondents defends the impugned
award and refutes the contention of admission of the statement of
accounts. The argument is that the arbitrator after considering the facts
and the evidence adduced has rightly rejected the claim of the
petitioner.
Signed By:HONEY O.M.P. (COMM) 251/2018
ARORA
16:15:39
5.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record
with their able assistance. Albeit, written submissions have been filed
by the parties but after arguing the matter at length the written
submissions are not being pressed. Along with the written submission
the petitioner attached documents which were not before the arbitrator
and on 09.07.2025 learned counsel for the petitioner made a statement
that the documents attached alongwith the written submission shall
not be relied upon. No contention other than those noted above has
been pressed.
6.
The scope of interference under Section 34 of the Act is well
defined. The court can interfere only on the grounds mentioned
therein. Reference in this regard be made to the following judgments
of the Supreme Court:6.1
The Supreme Court in Ramesh Kumar Jain vs. Bharat
Aluminium Company Limited 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2857 held as
under:
“28. The bare perusal of section 34 mandates a narrow
lens of supervisory jurisdiction to set aside the arbitral
award strictly on the grounds and parameters
enumerated in sub-section (2) & (3) thereof. The
interference is permitted where the award is found to
be in contravention to public policy of India; is
contrary to the fundamental policy of Indian Law; or
offends the most basic notions of morality or justice.
Hence, a plain and purposive reading of the section 34
makes it abundantly clear that the scope of interference
by a judicial body is extremely narrow. It is a settled
proposition of law as has been constantly observed by
this court and we reiterate, the courts exercising
jurisdiction under section 34 do not sit in appeal over
Signed By:HONEY O.M.P. (COMM) 251/2018
ARORA
16:15:39
the arbitral award hence they are not expected to
examine the legality, reasonableness or correctness of
findings on facts or law unless they come under any of
grounds mandated in the said provision. In ONGC
Limited. v. Saw Pipes Limited14, this court held that an
award can be set aside under Section 34 on the
following grounds:“(a) contravention of fundamental
policy of Indian law; or (b) the interest of India; or (c)
justice or morality, or (d) in addition, if it is patently
illegal.”
6.2
In Consolidated Construction Consortium Limited Vs.
Software Technology Parks of India (2025) 7 SCC 757 it was held
as under:
“46. Scope of Section 34 of the 1996 Act is now well
crystallized by a plethora of judgments of this Court.
Section 34 is not in the nature of an appellate
provision. It provides for setting aside an arbitral award
that too only on very limited grounds i.e. as those
contained in Sub-sections (2) and (2-A) of Section 34.
It is the only remedy for setting aside an arbitral award.
An arbitral award is not liable to be interfered with
only on the ground that the award is illegal or is
erroneous in law which would require re-appraisal of
the evidence adduced before the arbitral tribunal. If
two views are possible, there is no scope for the court
to re-appraise the evidence and to take the view other
than the one taken by the arbitrator. The view taken by
the arbitral tribunal is ordinarily to be accepted and
allowed to prevail. Thus, the scope of interference in
arbitral matters is only confined to the extent envisaged
Under Section 34 of the Act. The court exercising
powers Under Section 34 has perforce to limit its
jurisdiction within the four corners of Section 34. It
cannot travel beyond Section 34. Thus, proceedings
Under Section 34 are summary in nature and not like a
full-fledged civil suit or a civil appeal. The award as
Signed By:HONEY O.M.P. (COMM) 251/2018
ARORA
16:15:39
such cannot be touched unless it is contrary to the
substantive provisions of law or Section 34 of the 1996
Act or the terms of the agreement.”
7.
The claim of the petitioner was based upon a computer
generated statement of accounts. It is not the case set by the petitioner
that the statement of accounts was admitted in the statement of
defence filed by the respondents, reliance is on the cross-examination
of the witness of the respondents, Mr. Rakesh Kumar to prove the
admission. There cannot be quarrel with the proposition that the
petitioner has to stand on its own legs to substantiate the claim and
cannot solely rely upon the weaknesses in the evidence of the
respondents. The questions posed in cross-examination relied upon are
reproduced:
“Q18. Is it correct that you were accessing your
day to day Statement of Account maintained by
Claimant by logging your login Id and password
provided by claimant?
Ans. I had no online access of Statement of
Account as I was not provided login Id and
password by claimant.
Q20. Did you ever lodge any complaint with
Claimant while pointing any specific inconsistency
in Statement of Account received by you by
referring to a particular Statement of Account related
to a certain period?
Ans. Yes, whenever the officers of the claimant
company used to visit my office, I pointed out to
them that benefit of credit notes have not been given
to the Respondent. I also visited Delhi office of the
Claimant and pointed out that benefit of credit notes
have not been given to the Respondent.
Signed By:HONEY O.M.P. (COMM) 251/2018
ARORA
16:15:39
Q23. Have you ever written any letter to claimant
regarding credit notes payable to you while referring
your visit to Delhi Office of Claimant?
Ans. I verbally reminded officials of Claimant but I
do not remember whether I wrote any such letter.”
8.
From the cross-examination reproduced above it is evident that
there was no admission by the witness of the amount due shown in the
statement of accounts.
9.
Before proceeding further, it would be relevant to reproduce
clause 19 of the Dealership Agreement:
“19. Reconciliation of Accounts
The DEALER should reconcile his account of
payments and stocks with YMI and YMS as
required from time to time. YMI and YMS shall, at
the end of each fiscal year issue a statement of
account to the DEALER. In the event the DEALER
does not dispute the amounts stated in such
statement of account, within fifteen (15) days of the
receipt of such statement of account, the sums
reflected therein shall be construed to be acceptable
and binding upon the DEALER. It is further agreed
that in the event the DEALER is required to issue
any sales tax, or other tax forms, or declarations, to
YMI and YMS for the previous year, in accordance
with the statement of account such forms, or
declarations, shall be issued within sixty (60) days of
the said statement of account being accepted and in
case of any failure by the DEALER to do so, the
sums due and payable on account of such non
submission shall become a liability of the DEALER,
as if no. benefit pursuant to the said
forms/declarations, was available, and the sums due
shall become immediately payable.”
Signed By:HONEY O.M.P. (COMM) 251/2018
ARORA
16:15:39
10.
Clause 19 provides that the petitioner shall at the end of the
fiscal year issue a statement of the accounts to the dealer. Failure of
the respondents to dispute the amount stated therein within fifteen
days of receipt of the statement of accounts shall be construed to be
acceptance. No evidence was produced to show that the statement of
accounts at the end of the fiscal year 2008-2009 was issued to the
respondents. Reliance is on a statement produced as Annexure P-6
before the arbitrator which is for the period 01.10.2005 to 23.12.2008
and not an annual statement at the end of the fiscal year 2008-09.
11.
The arbitrator rightly rejected the claim of the petitioner based
on a self serving computer generated statement of accounts. It was
considered that the entries in the statement of accounts were not
supported by the bills. The eight entries dated 21.02.2006 were in
respect of “amount paid towards overdue invoice” but neither the
invoice number was mentioned in the statement of accounts nor these
invoices were produced.
12.
The veracity of the statement of accounts was dented by the
bank statement of ICICI Bank produced by the respondents. There
was no entry of Rs.10,24,474/- in bank statement which was shown in
the statement of accounts to be debited in the account maintained with
ICICI Bank. The contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner
that the bank statement produced was not proved by the respondents
and that on this account the award needs to be set aside, is ill-founded.
The petitioner failed to substantiate the claim filed and the bank
statement produced was to show that the statement of accounts is not
reliable. There was no explanation by the petitioner of the entry of
Signed By:HONEY O.M.P. (COMM) 251/2018
ARORA
16:15:39
Rs.10,24,474/- in the statement of accounts and not finding mention in
the bank statement.
13.
The award passed by the arbitrator suffers from no factual or
legal error much less perversity and calls for no interference under
Section 34 of the Act.
14.
The petition is dismissed.
AVNEESH JHINGAN, J
FEBRUARY 11, 2026/Pa
Reportable:- Yes
Signed By:HONEY O.M.P. (COMM) 251/2018
ARORA
16:15:39
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review