Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 9th January, 2026.
Pronounced on: 10th March, 2026.
Uploaded on: 10th March, 2026.
+
W.P.(C) 7913/2018
INDERJEET SINGH SIDHU
.....Petitioner
Through:
versus
Mr. SN Kaul and Mr. Vinod Z., Advs.
UNION OF INDIA & ORS
Through:
.....Respondent
Ms. Anju Gupta & Mr. Bhuvan Goel,
Advs for UOI.
Mr. Saurabh Mishra, Mr. Abhinav
Pandey and Mr. Shrimay Mishra,
Advs. for R-2 to 4.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
JUDGMENT
SANJEEV NARULA, J.:
1.
This petition questions the legality of the “Unsatisfactory” grading
recorded in the Petitioner’s Annual Confidential Report1 for the year 20152016, and the decision communicated on 11th August, 2017 rejecting his
representation. The challenge is to the fairness and legality of the process by
which an adverse assessment was recorded, endorsed, and then defended by
the very authority whose endorsement was under challenge.
Facts
2.
The Petitioner joined EdCIL (India) Limited in August, 2008 as
General Manager (Civil & Procurement) and was subsequently redesignated as Chief General Manager. He asserts that his ACRs were
Digitally Signed
By:NITIN KAIN
19:39:57
W.P.(C) 7913/2018
consistently graded “Outstanding” or “Very Good” until the impugned year
2015-2016. He submits that for 2015-2016, targets were fixed at the
beginning of the year on 1st April, 2015 and were later revised and
supplemented on 23rd December, 2015, leaving an unworkable period for
completion. The Petitioner also relies on contemporaneous material to say
that the concerned division faced structural constraints, including shortage
of technical manpower and project-gestation characteristics, which were
placed before the management in writing.
3.
The Petitioner further asserts that during the relevant year he met with
an accident on official duty at Srinagar (Uttarakhand) on 28 th August, 2015,
underwent surgery on 16th September, 2015, and remained under medical
restriction for a substantial period.
4.
He resigned from service with effect from 20th June, 2016. His case is
that he had submitted the self-appraisal/ACR proforma on 30th May, 2016,
and the subsequent delay in finalisation of the ACR was attributable to the
Respondents.
5.
The Petitioner contends that he learnt of the “Unsatisfactory” grading
through RTI. He thereafter made representations, culminating in a
representation dated 13th July, 2017 addressed to the competent authority.
The rejection was communicated on 11th August, 2017. He also relies on a
further communication dated 4th September, 2017 indicating that the
Reviewing Authority and the Appellate Authority were treated as the same,
namely the Chairman and Managing Director.
Petitioner’s Submission
6.
Digitally Signed
By:NITIN KAIN
19:39:57
Petitioner raises the following grounds in support of the petition:
“ACR”
W.P.(C) 7913/2018
6.1.
The challenge is directed not at the merits of the performance
assessment but at the legality and fairness of the process culminating in the
“Unsatisfactory” grading for the year 2015-2016 and the rejection of the
Petitioner’s representation on 11th August, 2017. It is contended that the
process suffers from procedural irregularity and violation of principles of
natural justice.
6.2.
The Petitioner’s ACRs prior to 2015-2016 were consistently graded
“Outstanding”
or
“Very
Good”.
The
sudden
downgrading
to
“Unsatisfactory” is unsupported by any contemporaneous reasoning or
material on record.
6.3.
The targets for the relevant year were initially fixed on 1 st April, 2015
by the Reporting Officer and were subsequently revised on 23 rd December,
2015, when a substantial part of the year had already elapsed. This belated
revision rendered achievement of the revised targets impracticable.
6.4.
The alleged shortfall was attributed solely to him, even though the
targets were implemented through a team structure within the same vertical.
It is argued that other officials involved in the same activities were not
subjected to adverse grading.
6.5.
Emphasis is also placed on staff constraints during the year,
particularly transfer out of the Deputy Manager (Procurement), described as
a key team member, without replacement until year-end. Respondent No. 3’s
own endorsement in the self-appraisal records that the Key Result Areas2
assigned to “Shri Punit Seth, Deputy Manager (Procurement)” was not taken
into account due to his transfer out from the division. The Petitioner treats
this as a clear admission that deliverables were affected by staff movement
Digitally Signed
By:NITIN KAIN
19:39:57
W.P.(C) 7913/2018
and that the constraints were not a later invention.
6.6.
The Petitioner met with an accident while on official duty at Srinagar
(Uttarakhand) on 28th August, 2015, underwent surgery on 16 th September,
2015, and remained under medical restriction for a considerable period
thereafter, which affected his ability to oversee departmental work.
6.7.
Reliance is also placed on a contemporaneous note dated 29 th May,
2015 (Annexure R-1), originated by the Petitioner and routed through
Respondent No. 3 to Respondent No. 2, highlighting constraints faced by the
division and proposing a roadmap. It is argued that this demonstrates the
constraints were on record yet ignored.
6.8.
The ACR does not disclose any contemporaneous warning, advisory,
or mid-term assessment indicating dissatisfaction with the Petitioner’s
performance. Particular reliance is placed on the remark in the functional
performance segment stating that “Nothing is recorded here as the officer is
under relieving.”
6.9.
The adverse grading was not communicated within a reasonable time
and came to the Petitioner’s knowledge only through information obtained
under the Right to Information Act.
6.10. The representation against the adverse grading was decided by the
same authority who had endorsed the adverse remarks, namely the Chairman
and Managing Director. This violates the principle that a representation
against an adverse ACR entry must be considered by an authority higher,
like the Board of Directors, than the one who recorded or endorsed the entry.
Reliance is placed on Dev Dutt v. Union of India3 and Sukhdev Singh v.
Digitally Signed
By:NITIN KAIN
19:39:57
“KRA”
(2008) 8 SCC 725.
W.P.(C) 7913/2018
Union of India.4
6.11. The Petitioner also relies on the ACR Rules, 2008 and the
Government of India’s guiding instructions governing adverse remarks, to
contend that the representation ought to have been considered by an
authority superior to the Reviewing Authority.
Respondents’ Submissions
7.
The Respondents oppose the petition on the following grounds:
7.1.
The petition discloses no ground for interference under Articles
226/227. The appraisal was conducted in accordance with the prescribed
procedure and the applicable rules. The petition is essentially an attempt to
invite the writ court to sit in appeal over an assessment of performance,
which lies outside the permissible limits of judicial review.
7.2.
The Performance Management System adopted by EdCIL in line with
the guidelines of the Department of Public Enterprises. Under this system,
evaluation is based on measurable parameters comprising Functional
Performance Score and Competency Score, weighted at 69% and 31%
respectively.
7.3.
The Petitioner underperformed and failed to meet key targets or KRA
by a wide margin, with reference to parameters such as order book, project
revenue, and recovery of old debts. The letter dated 11 th August, 2017 is
relied upon as the communication of that conclusion while disposing of the
appeal.
7.4.
The Petitioner’s assertion that the targets were imposed unilaterally is
disputed. The KRAs for the year 2015–2016 were proposed by the Petitioner
himself on 23rd December, 2015, accepted by Respondent No. 3 on 1 st
Digitally Signed
By:NITIN KAIN
19:39:57
(2013) 9 SCC 566.
W.P.(C) 7913/2018
January, 2016, and approved by Respondent No. 2. On that footing, it is
urged that having set out and proceeded on those KRAs, the petitioner
cannot now resile and contend that the targets were unrealistic or unfair.
7.5.
The Petitioner did not raise any constraints or seek revision of targets
through the appraisal mechanism during the relevant period, nor did he
invoke any mid-term review process. He projected that matters were on
track until late, and the constraints now pleaded are, at best, belated.
7.6.
On the allegation of staff shortage, the Respondents rely on the
Petitioner’s own listing of subordinates in the APAR, which included a
Deputy General Manager, Advisor (Civil), Building Maintenance Engineer,
and Executive Assistant. The Deputy Manager (Procurement) was not
shown as a subordinate. Therefore that the staff shortage plea is plainly an
afterthought.
7.7.
Performance appraisal is individual and role-specific. The Petitioner,
being the head of the vertical, cannot rely on collective responsibility to
explain shortfalls in performance.
7.8.
ACRs are assessed year-wise based on performance during the
relevant period. Past gradings have no bearing on the assessment for a
subsequent year.
7.9.
The Petitioner’s medical records reflect a history of a twisting injury
to the left knee. The attribution of that injury to official duties is disputed.
Even so, EdCIL bore the medical expenses and regularised the petitioner’s
attendance for the relevant period.
7.10. The interval between the Reporting Authority’s assessment dated 30th
May, 2016 and the Reviewing Authority’s assessment dated 9th January,
2017 is explained on the ground that the Reviewing Authority reviews the
Digitally Signed
By:NITIN KAIN
19:39:57
W.P.(C) 7913/2018
ACRs of officers under his control together, once they are ready, to ensure
uniform assessment and application of the bell-curve approach prescribed
under the DPE guidelines.
7.11. The Petitioner resigned from service on 20th June, 2016 before the
appraisal cycle could be carried through to completion in the usual
administrative sequence. In that backdrop, the ACR was not communicated
through the routine channel; it was furnished to him later only upon his
request under the RTI Act.
7.12. Under EdCIL’s HR policy, the Chairman and Managing Director is
designated as the Reviewing and Accepting Authority, and also as the
Appellate Authority, for executives in the relevant grade. This allocation
tracks the DPE-linked administrative model adopted for CPSEs and, by
itself, does not offend principles of natural justice.
Analysis and findings:
8.
Performance appraisal is, in the first instance, an administrative and
managerial assessment. While exercising writ jurisdiction, the court does not
turn an appraisal into an appellate exercise on comparative merit.
Interference is warranted where the process is tainted by mala fides,
manifest arbitrariness, non-application of mind, breach of governing norms,
or a denial of fair procedure. This judicial discipline, consistently affirmed
by the Supreme Court, dictates that while the merits of the evaluation are
beyond judicial review, the ‘recording,’ and ‘communication’ regarding an
appraisal must strictly adhere to the minimum standards of transparency and
fairness.5
9.
Digitally Signed
By:NITIN KAIN
19:39:57
The controversy, therefore, falls to be examined on two distinct
W.P.(C) 7913/2018
planes. The first is procedural fairness: whether the grading that operated to
the employee’s prejudice was communicated within a reasonable time,
whether a meaningful opportunity to represent was afforded, and whether
the representation was decided by an authority that could, in fact, grant
effective redress. The second is rationality: whether the appraisal, read as a
whole, discloses an intelligible basis for the grading, or whether it presents a
conclusion without a discernible evaluative foundation. The court’s remit is
confined to these questions. It does not extend to substituting its own view
of performance for that of the reporting hierarchy.
10.
The legal position on communication of APAR entries and
consideration of representations is settled. In Dev Dutt, the Supreme Court
addressed a familiar unfairness in appraisal systems. The officer had been
graded “Good” for 1993-1994. Though not adverse in form, that grading fell
short of the benchmark of “Very Good” prescribed for promotion, and
therefore operated to his prejudice. However, the entry had not been
communicated, with the result that he was denied a meaningful opportunity
to seek review or upgradation, despite the career consequence. In these
circumstances, the Court articulated two connected requirements of fairness.
First, transparency. Every entry in the APAR that bears upon an employee’s
prospects must be communicated within a reasonable time, even if the
governing instructions do not treat it as “adverse”, because “Article 14 will
override all rules or government orders.” Secondly, the remedy must be real.
A representation must be considered objectively by an authority capable of
affording effective redress. The same principles were reaffirmed in Sukhdev
Singh, where the Supreme Court reiterated that every entry in the ACR must
Digitally Signed
By:NITIN KAIN
19:39:57
State of U.P. v. Yamuna Shankar Misra (1997) 4 SCC 7.
W.P.(C) 7913/2018
be communicated within a reasonable time to enable the officer to make a
representation for its upgradation.
11.
The Petitioner’s central complaint is not a quibble over a few marks.
He asserts that the Reviewing Authority, i.e., the CMD endorsed an adverse
functional grading and that his representation assailing that endorsement was
again decided under the CMD’s authority. That contention attracts a settled
principle: no one should be a judge in their own cause. In service
jurisprudence, its application is practical rather than rhetorical. If the very
authority that has authored or endorsed the adverse assessment also decides
the representation against it, the exercise becomes structurally vulnerable
even if no personal bias is alleged. The Supreme Court in Dev Dutt used the
memorable expression that such a remedy risk becoming “an appeal from
Caesar to Caesar”. That expression captures not a suspicion of individual
officers, but a systemic concern for impartiality and public confidence.
12.
The record does not disclose any scrutiny of the petitioner’s
representation by an authority independent of the CMD. Where the CMD
functions both as the Reviewing or Accepting Authority and as the authority
deciding the grievance against that very review, the safeguard of a
representation risks becoming illusionary rather than real. In such a
structure, fairness calls for one of three correctives: a review at a higher
institutional level, a mechanism insulated from the earlier endorsement, or
Board-level consideration so that the scrutiny is not dominated by the prior
conclusion. No such independent application of mind is demonstrated on the
present record.
13.
The Respondents seek to meet the objection of “same authority” by
relying on CPSE practice and EdCIL’s HR policy, under which the CMD
Digitally Signed
By:NITIN KAIN
19:39:57
W.P.(C) 7913/2018
acts as Reviewing or Accepting Authority and also as the Appellate
Authority for executives in the relevant grade. That submission may explain
how the organisation has arranged its hierarchy. It does not, however,
conclude the legal enquiry. Administrative convenience cannot dilute the
minimum discipline of fair process. The Supreme Court in Dev Dutt and
Sukhdev Singh treated communication of the appraisal entry and
consideration of a representation as safeguards with substance, not ritual. A
remedy that returns to the very authority which has already endorsed the
impugned assessment is vulnerable to the concern articulated in Dev Dutt.
Unless the record shows demonstrably independent consideration, supported
by reasons that engage with the grievance, the arrangement falls foul of the
requirement that State action affecting civil consequences must be fair,
transparent, and meaningfully reviewable under Article 14.
14.
The second procedural infirmity concerns communication. The
Respondents say that the Petitioner resigned with effect from 20th June, 2016
and, therefore, the ACR could not be communicated. The Petitioner says he
submitted self-appraisal on 30th May, 2016 and the process thereafter was
for the Respondents to complete within their prescribed timelines, and that
he ultimately learnt of the grading through RTI. On either version, the
position remains that the adverse entry carried consequences beyond the
Petitioner’s tenure in EdCIL. An adverse APAR, particularly an
“Unsatisfactory” grading, does not lose its sting because the officer has
moved on. It can affect future employment, empanelment, selection
processes, and even reputation in professional settings. That reality is
precisely why Dev Dutt insists on timely communication and an effective
opportunity to represent.
Digitally Signed
By:NITIN KAIN
19:39:57
W.P.(C) 7913/2018
15.
The explanation that adverse entries are not supplied suo motu and are
given only under RTI cannot be accepted the Supreme Court’s insistence
that such entries must be communicated as a matter of fairness. An RTI
route cannot be treated as a substitute for a duty to communicate. Nor is it
persuasive to place the burden on the officer to “ensure” the ACR process is
completed before relieving. Performance appraisal is an internal
administrative process, controlled by the employer’s service rules. The
obligation to complete it within the prescribed time, and to communicate its
outcome in a manner consistent with law, rests primarily with the employer.
16.
Turning to the substance of the record, it is not necessary, in writ
jurisdiction, to undertake meticulous review of each KRA. What is
necessary is to see whether the assessment and its confirmation reflect
application of mind to the relevant case put forward by the officer. Here, the
Petitioner’s case is that targets were revised on 23 rd December, 2015 after
the year had substantially progressed; that staff constraints, including
transfer out of a key officer without replacement, impaired deliverables; that
a serious knee injury on official duty with surgery on 16th September, 2015
materially affected his ability to discharge duties for a period; and that a
contemporaneous note dated 29th May, 2015 placed constraints and a road
map on record. The Petitioner also relies on the remark in the functional
performance segment stating, “Nothing is recorded here as the officer is
under
relieving”,
and
contrasts
that
with
the
harshness
of
an
“Unsatisfactory” grading. The Respondents contest these grounds, including
on the basis that the Petitioner himself submitted KRAs on 23rd December,
2015 and did not record constraints in the APAR.
17.
Digitally Signed
By:NITIN KAIN
19:39:57
This contested factual terrain makes one point clear: the
W.P.(C) 7913/2018
representation was not capable of being rejected by a cryptic, non-speaking
communication. Where a representation raises specific grounds supported by
contemporaneous documents, the decision must reflect that those grounds
were examined. The impugned communication dated 11 th August, 2017 does
not disclose such examination. The deficiency is not cosmetic. It goes to the
heart of whether the remedy was real.
18.
The cumulative outcome is this. The process leading to rejection of
the representation suffers from foundational infirmities: first, the
representation was disposed of without a reasoned consideration of the
grounds raised; second, the arrangement by which the same authority that
endorsed the adverse assessment also adjudicated the challenge to it offends
the requirement of an effective and impartial remedy as explained in Dev
Dutt and reiterated in Sukhdev Singh. The circumstances relating to the
delayed communication of the entry, and the fact that the Petitioner became
aware of it only through the RTI route, further accentuate the procedural
unfairness in the appraisal process. These go to the fairness of the decisionmaking process.
19.
For these reasons, the impugned communication dated 11 th August,
2017 cannot be sustained. The appropriate course is to restore the
representation for independent consideration, and to require a speaking
decision dealing with the Petitioner’s grounds.
20.
For the reasons recorded above, the writ petition succeeds to the
extent indicated with the following directions:
20.1. The communication dated 11th August, 2017, is set aside.
20.2. The Petitioner’s representation dated 13th July, 2017 is restored for
fresh consideration. The reconsideration shall be undertaken by an authority
Digitally Signed
By:NITIN KAIN
19:39:57
W.P.(C) 7913/2018
higher than the authority that reviewed/endorsed the adverse entry, or by an
institutional mechanism of constituting a Board which is demonstrably
insulated from the earlier endorsement. The decision shall be reasoned, shall
deal with the specific grounds raised by the Petitioner, and shall be
communicated to the Petitioner within a period of eight weeks from today.
20.3 Subject to the outcome of such reconsideration, the impugned grading
and all consequential action founded upon it shall abide by the decision so
taken. If the competent authority, upon reconsideration, forms the view that
the grading warrants no interference, brief reasons disclosing application of
mind shall be recorded. If the grading is modified, the consequential record
shall be corrected and all attendant service consequences shall follow in
accordance with law.
21.
It is clarified that this Court has not adjudicated upon the merits of the
Petitioner’s performance appraisal. All contentions on merits, including the
Respondents’ reliance on objective scoring under applicable guidelines, are
left open to be considered by the competent authority/mechanism in
accordance with law.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
MARCH 10, 2026/ng
Digitally Signed
By:NITIN KAIN
19:39:57
W.P.(C) 7913/2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review