Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
PIL No. 9 of 2017
Date of order: 28.08.2023
In Re suo motu custodial violence
and other matters relating to
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & ors
prison conditions
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner :
Dr. N. Mozika, Amicus Curiae with
Ms. S. Rumthao, Adv.
For the Respondents:
Mr. K. Khan, AAG
Mr. A.H. Kharwanlang, Addl.Sr.GA
Ms. S. Ain, GA
Ms. S. Laloo, GA
Mr. J.N. Rynjah, GA
Mr. S. Dey, Adv
Mr. K. Baruah, Adv
Ms. P. Agarwal, Adv (VC)
Mr. S.A. Sheikh, Adv.
Mr. A.H. Hazarika, Adv.
Mr. J. Shylla, Adv.
Mr. D. Dkhar, Adv.
i)Whether approved for
reporting in Law journals etc.:
Yes
ii)Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
This suo motu public interest litigation was initiated pursuant to a
direction issued by the Supreme Court in the judgment reported at (2017) 10
SCC 658 (Re-Inhuman conditions in 1382 prisons).
2.
Two aspects must be pointed out from the relevant judgment. The first
is that a distinction was sought to be made by the National Crime Records
Bureau between natural and unnatural deaths in custody. At paragraph 6 of
the judgment, the Supreme Court found the distinction to be unclear.
Secondly, on the issue of defining natural and unnatural deaths, the Supreme
Court went on to observe as follows at paragraph 9 of the report:
“9. On the issue of defining natural and unnatural deaths, the learned
Amicus Curiae drew our attention to the Guidelines on Investigating
Deaths in Custody issued by the International Committee of the Red
Cross (ICRC). According to ICRC, “death” is the irreversible
cessation of all vital functions, including brain activity. Death is
“natural” when it is caused solely by disease and/or the aging process.
It is “unnatural” when its causes are external, such as intentional
injury (homicide, suicide), negligence or unintentional injury (death
by accident). We have perused the guidelines provided by ICRC and
are of the view that these guidelines deserve consideration and
circulation by the Central Government and all the State
Governments.”
3.
After considering several reports, recommendations and suggestions
made from several quarters, certain directions were issued by the Supreme
Court in the relevant judgment at paragraph 58 and the various subPage 2 of 19
paragraphs thereunder. For the purpose of the present proceedings,
paragraph 58.1 of the report is relevant, as has been rightly pointed out on
behalf of the State:
“58.1. The Secretary General of this Court will transmit a copy of this
decision to the Registrar General of every High Court within one
week with a request to the Registrar General to place it before the
Chief Justice of the High Court. We request the Chief Justice of the
High Court to register a suo motu public interest petition with a view
to identifying the next of kin of the prisoners who have admittedly
died an unnatural death as revealed by NCRB during the period
between 2012 and 2015 and even thereafter, and award suitable
compensation, unless adequate compensation has already been
awarded.”
4.
In course of the present proceedings it has come to light that there
have been 53 custodial deaths in the State since 2012. Detailed reports have
been filed by the State indicating the likely causes of deaths in each case,
appending copies of the post-mortem and inquest reports, sometimes relying
on reports furnished by the forensic science laboratory or even the
histopathological reports and, finally, the findings of the magisterial inquiry,
albeit such inquiries being conducted by an Executive Magistrate in each
case. Notices pertaining to this matter have been issued on several occasions
and the next of kin of those who died in custody have been informed, except
in cases where the relevant inmate may have been from Bangladesh. It is
also the State’s submission that no person other than the 53 mentioned
herein died in custody in the State since 2012.
5.
The 53 cases of natural and unnatural deaths are as per the following
table:
Sl.
No.
1.
Age
Cause of death
Bulbin
Marbaniang
47 years
The
UTP
allegedly
collapsed and was
declared brought
dead at the Civil
Hospital.
2.
3.
Roy Sympli
Topo A. Marak
20 years
19 years
4.
5.
Alsin D. Sangma
Rajendra Ravi
Das
Balsan S. Marak
30 years
60 years
Witson M.
Sangma
Senuman S.
Marak
Rajiv Marak
35 years
Norbert
Malngiang
Sovraj Sonar
33 years
Allegedly found
dead in his sleep.
No
FSL
or
histopathological
examination
report.
Death by hanging.
32 years
Death
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
Name
20 years
19 years
25 years
Remarks
Since the State has not
been able to conclusively
establish the cause of
death, despite the burden
being on the State, this is
regarded as the case of
unnatural death.
Death by hanging Unnatural .
Long term drug Natural.
abuse, no external
injuries.
Death by hanging. Unnatural
Suffered
from Natural.
several ailments.
Torture.
Unnatural.
Dealt with in High Court
judgment of February 28,
2018 and paid Rs 15 lakh
as compensation.
Injuries revealing Unnatural
torture.
Death by hanging. Unnatural.
due
Unnatural since the State
has failed to demonstrate
to the contrary.
Unnatural.
to Unnatural since the State
12.
13.
Kleophast
Nongkhlaw
Satar Khan
29-32
years
54 years
14.
Tanbor Dkhar
29 years
15.
Lolin Sangma
67 years
16.
Shamol Ali
24 years
17.
Everlin Shadap
40 years
18.
Bablu T. Sangma
30 years
19.
Sudhir Magar
Thapa
47 years
20.
Skhembor
Kyndait
Dringli Roy
Rngaid
Tangkam N.
Marak
34 years
Toyanath Dahal
Sujen Marak
60 years
66 years
21.
22.
23.
24.
82 years
34 years
shock and brain has not been able to
haemorrhage.
indicate the cause of death.
Death by hanging. Unnatural.
Intracranial
haemorrhage.
Though
no
external injuries
detected.
No
cause of death
furnished by the
State.
Myocardial
infraction.
Though
no
external injuries.
FSL report not
produced.
No
proper cause of
death shown by
the State.
Chest
and
abdominal pain
was
in
Civil
Hospital
for
considerable time
before he died.
Pulmonary
and
hepatic lesions.
Paralysed
from
the
waist
onwards.
Long term drug
abuse.
Old age problems.
Natural.
Unnatural.
Unsubstantiated finding of
Executive
Magistrate
disregarded.
Natural.
Unnatural.
Unsubstantiated finding of
the Executive Magistrate
disregarded.
Natural.
Natural.
Was under long treatment.
Died of the ailments.
Natural.
Natural.
Natural.
Chronic
Natural.
alcoholism. Death
due to chronic
liver failure.
Cancer.
Natural.
Long history of Natural.
hypertension and
blood sugar.
25.
26.
Ajay Das
Toyom Sheikh
42 years
37 years
27.
Rilang Suting
34 years
28.
Haplin D.
Sangma
Dilwar Hussain
Meng Khongsngi
43 years
35 years
32 years
33.
Lakhvinder Singh
Saman M.
Sangma
Janet Jakai
34.
Raju Koch
23 years
35.
36.
Deumon Doley
Kloilan
Marbaniang
30 years
37 years
37.
38.
Madaini Moila
Salviang N.
Sangma
John Challam
41 years
22 years
29.
30.
31.
32.
39.
20 years
74 years
55 years
Not
indicated
40.
Noresh Koch
44 years
41.
42.
Nalchand Ali
Silbaline M.
Sangma
Bernard T.
Sangma
Borit D. Sangma
Wanlangki Dkhar
40 years
18 years
43.
44.
45.
34 years
30 years
17 years
Death by hanging.
Though several
external injuries
evident, it appears
to have been old.
Diagnosed with
cardiac
abnormality.
Long term drug
abuse.
Died due to heart
condition.
Death by hanging.
Age related
ailments.
Liver Cancer.
Death by hanging.
Unnatural.
Natural.
Poor heart
condition.
Cardio-vascular
insufficiency.
Cancer.
Respiratory
distress
and
Covid. Cancer of
tongue.
Death by hanging.
Death by hanging.
Natural.
Natural.
Natural
Unnatural.
Natural.
Natural.
Unnatural.
Natural.
Natural.
Natural.
Unnatural.
Unnatural.
Not indicated
Unnatural.
State accepts that
death was unnatural.
Several external Unnatural.
injuries. Death by
hanging.
Death by hanging. Unnatural.
Death by hanging. Unnatural.
Coronary artery
block.
Heart attack.
Cardiomyopathy
Natural.
Natural.
Natural.
this
46.
47.
48.
49.
50.
51.
52.
53.
6.
Banteilang Jyrwa
Nirupam Dhar
Hardik
Kharshiing
Rabi Sunar
Rakesh Singh
Rajput
Tebester Thabah
27 years
21 years
56 years
with pulmonary
oedema.
Death by hanging. Unnatural.
Death by hanging. Unnatural.
Death by hanging. Unnatural.
32 years
45 years
Death by hanging. Unnatural.
Heart attack.
Natural.
40 years
Kitbor Kassar
Daphahsalonmi
Rupon
24 years
26 years
Several external Unnatural.
injuries.
Post mortem indicated
death might have been by
physical assault.
Death by hanging. Unnatural.
Death by hanging. Unnatural.
Thus, out of the 53 instances of custodial deaths in the State of
Meghalaya since the year 2012, a total of 25 cases are found to be due to
natural causes and the remaining 28 are found to be cases of unnatural
deaths.
7.
It must be recorded that the State has contested the cases of Bulbin
Marbaniang, Rajiv Marak, Tanbor Dkhar and Shamol Ali on the ground that
there is no material to suggest that any of the deaths in such cases was
unnatural, whether from any external injury or from the post-mortem report.
In addition, the State submits that the finding of the magisterial inquiry
would go to show that there was no foul play in any of the cases and the
persons may have died of natural causes.
8.
The basis for the assessment in the present case must be laid bare.
While the State has every right to arrest a person during an investigation,
subject to following the procedure established by law, or depriving a convict
of his liberty by reason of the sentence that he has suffered, when a citizen or
any other person is in the custody of the State, the State is responsible for his
well-being. If such person dies while in the State’s custody, unless the State
is able to affirmatively establish that the cause of death was natural, it will
be inferred that the person died an unnatural death.
9.
In each of the cases that the State has contested, the age of the
relevant under-trial or convict or the physical condition of the person did not
indicate that the death was due to natural causes. At the same time, no
external injury may have been discovered or anything apparent to suggest
that the person had been tortured or died as a consequence of any action by
the police or jail authorities. However, as indicated, if the State cannot
establish the cause of death while in custody, it would be inferred that it was
a case of unnatural death, particularly when the deceased is found to have
been healthy and too young to suffer such fate.
10.
In the Supreme Court judgment pursuant to which the present matter
has been taken up and considerable time expended to determine the number
of cases and cause of death in each case, the direction to the High Courts is
to award suitable compensation. The suitability of the compensation would
have two aspects: the compensation awarded as a measure of damages upon
a life being snatched long before death may have been due; and, the quantum
of compensation should be such that it would act as a deterrent since in a
civilised society there ought to be no unnatural death while in custody. The
compensation has to be both compensatory and punitive so as to act as a
deterrent.
11.
It appears that in June, 2021, the Haryana government notified rates of
compensation by making a classification on the basis of the cause of death
while in custody. The quantum of compensation was dependent on whether
the person died on account of a quarrel among inmates or due to torture by
officials or due to negligence or by suicide and the like. The relevant
notification also provided that if death occurred due to natural causes or
while trying to escape from the correctional home or from custody, no
compensation would be payable.
12.
By an order dated February 9, 2022, the National Human Rights
Commission merely noticed the Haryana notification of June 29, 2021, set
out the entirety thereof in its order of such date and requested the State
governments and Union Territories “to bring such a policy as framed by the
State of Haryana… by quantifying compensation on account of death of
prisoners…”
13.
There does not appear to be any independent application of the mind
of the Commission, despite the order dated February 9, 2022 bearing the
signature of all five members of such Commission. In any event, apart from
the fact that the order of such Commission may not be binding on this Court,
there is an independent mandate by virtue of the Supreme Court judgment of
2017 for the High Courts to fix suitable compensation. The “suitability”
factor has already been seen to consist of a component of sufficiency and
another which would act as punitive, for the combined lump-sum to prove to
be a deterrent.
14.
In tune with the Haryana notification and the rather perfunctory order
of the NHRC, the State has come up with a notification on similar lines. The
State also relies on a near-identical notification issued by the State of Tamil
Nadu on February 23, 2023.
15.
According to the State, it was following the report of the 273rd Law
Commission which required the States to legislate against death on account
of torture that the entire matter came to the limelight. The State submits that
since it is essentially a human rights issue and the national body has applied
its mind to endorse the notification and the quantum in each case as fixed by
the State of Haryana, the Court should let the matter rest as the State has
followed the same classification and quantification.
16.
It is the further contention of the State that, ordinarily, when the next
of kin of a person who has died in custody accuses the State of any foul play,
a civil action for damages would have to be brought; though, in certain
extraordinary situations, even the writ court has entertained such a plea and
has awarded compensation. According to the State, since the relatives of the
persons who had died in custody do not have to undertake the trouble of
making a claim and proving the same in Court, the quantum of
compensation as declared by the State should be found to be adequate
enough. The State also submits that considering that public money is
involved, the Court should not allow for greater compensation as the State’s
resources in such regard are limited.
17.
For a start, the classification introduced by the Haryana notification,
which has been endorsed without any comment by the NHRC, does not
appeal. Such classification begs a question as to why a certain amount
should be paid for death suffered due to a fight breaking out among the
inmates in a correctional home and death suffered by hanging to which an
under-trial prisoner is pushed by how he is tortured or treated while in
custody.
18.
More importantly, it is the quantification in the Haryana model which
appears to be unconscionable to this Court. In the judgment of the year 2018
delivered by this Court in WP (C) No.213 of 2014 (Smti. Meena S. Marak v.
State of Meghalaya), upon finding that the death of the 18-year-old in that
case was due to the brutality indulged in by the State police, an amount of
Rs.15 lakh was awarded as compensation. The State has accepted such
amount and it is the undeniable position that the total amount has been paid.
19.
Thus, once such standard has already been set in the State, of the
award of compensation of Rs.15 lakh for an 18-year-old dying as a result of
police brutality while in custody, five years down the line there is no good
reason for reducing the quantum. In any event, the State accepts that it has
made the payment without questioning the quantum. In the State coming up
with the notification providing for a lesser amount based on the Haryana
model, it appears that the amount of Rs.7.5 lakh as maximum as suggested
by the State may not hurt the State as much as paying the compensation of
Rs.15 lakh may have. Thus, the maximum quantum proposed by the State by
its notification of Rs.7.5 lakh would be an amount that the State would be
agreeable to pay without any questions asked.
20.
The State says that to the extent that the amount of compensation has
been paid to the next of kin of the relevant victims and the families have not
complained, the Court should not enhance the quantum. It is also the State’s
refrain that there has been no express plea by the relatives of the victims or
even by Amicus Curiae appointed in the matter for enhancement of the
compensation over and above what has been indicated by the State in its
notification.
21.
As to the suitability and sufficiency of the compensation, the initial
discussion will hold good for the State’s objection, irrespective of whether
any person has indicated any grievance against the amounts specified in the
State’s notification. Compensation has both to be adequate for the families
of the victims and to act as a deterrent so that the State and its officials
remain in check. The quantum indicated by the State in its notification
reveals the amount that the State is comfortable paying. If the State is
comfortable paying an amount it almost amounts to endorsing its
wrongdoing and perpetuating the same rather than paving the way for there
being no unnatural death while in custody.
22.
For the above cases, the State should ensure all payments are made to
the next of kin upon due identification and verification within the next six
months. That period is set as an outside limit. If the next of kin are available
and make any demand immediately, the State should ensure that the amounts
due are paid within the next three months. As to the amounts that are not
collected, whether on account of the next of kin not being interested or not
being aware, the State will, after waiting for a reasonable period when no
claimant is identified, invest the money in the Cancer Department of Civil
Hospital at Shillong as indicated hereafter. At all times, the Secretary in the
Department of Health will remain liable to furnish appropriate accounts in
respect of the compensation awarded or the compensation made over to the
Cancer Department of the Shillong Civil Hospital.
23.
It is made clear that the compensation due in terms of this order in
respect of the past cases and future cases will be in addition to any insurance
or other entitlement and not in derogation thereof.
24.
A death in custody is a slur on a civilised State and completely
unacceptable. Ideally, there should be no death, except due to natural causes,
while in custody. Of course, the natural causes are beyond the control of the
State and convicts serving long sentences may also have age-related
problems which may lead to their death. But it is particularly distressing to
note the number of deaths of under-trial prisoners as the investigating
agency uses third-degree methods to get information from the arrested
person rather than go out in the field and investigate the matter. Oftentimes,
the excesses indulged in by the State through its police personnel result in
admissions, which may be inaccurate, but which are made to stave off or
delay the further torture. If police brutalities and inhuman treatment of
persons in custody have to be arrested, the compensation for custodial death
has to be pegged at a level where the State will bleed to make the payment;
not what the State is happy to pay off.
25.
At any rate, there is no room to apply the strict liability theory when it
comes to a death of a person in the custody of the State. The State’s liability
in such regard is absolute and unless it demonstrates to the satisfaction of the
Court that the death was due to natural causes, the Court may reasonably
infer otherwise and hold the State liable. The State ought also to be liable for
the actions of its officers and employees. It is possible that in several cases
exuberant officials would go beyond the call of duty or the SOP in place. In
such cases, the State will remain liable for the acts and conduct of its
officials, but the State will also be free to proceed against such officials and
even extract the compensation that it has to pay from such officials in
accordance with law. Though the classification indicated in the Haryana
notification and as has been mindlessly adopted by the State appears to be
abhorrent and obnoxious, there should be some other form of classification
based on a precedent therefor in our jurisprudence. In respect of motor
accident claims, there is a classification of the quantum of compensation
payable based on the age of the victim. Accordingly, it is deemed fit and
proper to classify the victims who have died in custody into three categories,
namely, below 30; between 30 and 45; and, above 45.
26.
Since the judgment of this Court in Smti. Meena S. Marak has already
established the quantum, the sum of Rs.15 lakh may be taken as the
compensation payable for death in custody to the next of kin of a person age
below 30. For victims in the age-group of 30 to 45, the quantum of
compensation should be Rs.12 lakh and for those above 45 years, it should
be Rs.10 lakh. There is an element of subjectivity in arriving at such ballpark
figures; however, when it comes to assessment of damages or quantification
of compensation, there is an element of guesstimation that is always
indulged in.
27.
Accordingly, the compensation agreed to be paid by the State in the
notification dated December 15, 2022 is found to be inadequate and the
relevant notification is set aside. For the period till date in case of any
unnatural death while in custody, the next and kin of the victim will be
entitled to a sum of Rs.15 lakh if the victim was below 30 years of age as on
the date of death; a sum of Rs.12 lakh if the victim was below the age of 45
years but above the age of 30 years as on the date of death and, a sum of
Rs.10 lakh if the victim was above 45 years of age as on the date of death.
28.
It is recorded that the quantum of compensation found suitable in the
present case is based on the compensation usually declared upon a major
accident or natural calamity taking place. A comparable amount was also
directed to be paid to families of covid victims by the Supreme Court.
29.
All the next of kin of the aforesaid persons indicated in the chart who
suffered unnatural deaths would be entitled to compensation at the rates
indicated hereinabove. It is more than likely that in several cases, because of
the heinous offences committed or alleged to have been committed by the
relevant persons, their next of kin may not be interested in contesting the
proceedings or even collecting the compensation upon the death of the
relevant person. In such cases, the State will be obliged to put in the money
into the Cancer Department of the Civil Hospital in Shillong for the purpose
of augmentation of equipment at such fledgling facility. The Secretary in the
Department of Health will be responsible to ensure that the money is
disbursed by the State and, upon the next of kin of the deceased victim not
being available or willing to accept the payment, the money is immediately
made over to the Cancer Department of the Civil Hospital in Shillong.
30.
The amounts of Rs.15 lakh, Rs.12 lakh and Rs.10 lakh in the three
categories as indicated herein will hold good till the end of the year 2024,
whereupon they will stand increased by Rs.1.5 lakh at the highest level and
by Rs.1 lakh each at the two other levels for the next period of three years.
The quantum of compensation should be enhanced every three years so that
it is sufficient damages for the next of kin and the deterrent factor is also
maintained to the same degree.
31.
It is made clear that the compensation will be payable only in cases of
unnatural death, irrespective of the cause of death. In cases of natural death
in custody, no compensation would be payable at all. As to cases where the
State suggests that the injuries suffered which caused death were in course of
the person in custody trying to escape, the determination of the cause would
be by an appropriate court in accordance with law.
32.
Since all the matters pertaining to the deaths in custody in the State
from 2012 till date have been covered, the present proceedings are closed. It
will be open to individuals or even to the Court, on its own, to institute
further proceedings on similar lines to ensure that compensation is paid and
the payment acts as a deterrent on the State.
33.
The Court expresses its gratitude to Dr. N. Mozika, who was
appointed as Amicus Curiae in the matter. It may also be recorded that
Counsel for the State, despite the interest of the State, has been fair in
ensuring that an appropriate order is made to provide for sufficient
compensation to persons who died of unnatural causes while in custody.
34.
PIL No.9 of 2017 is closed.
35.
There will be no order as to costs.
(H. S. Thangkhiew)
Judge
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
28.08.2023
“Lam DR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review