Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
"
#
$
% #
&
!"
#
$
"
$
%
&"
Digitally signed
by VARSHA N
RASALKAR
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
"
"
&"
'
$
(
"
"
"
'
!
#
$
%
)
+
)
"
"
&
&
*
&
&
"
-2-
"
+
)
*
*
"
"
* "
,
"
- .
+
&
"
"
)
/
"
"
123 45626278 23 92:5; <= 615 456262785> 355?28@ 67
ABC31
7>;5>
;C65;
7D;=31556
E2;5
+
*
*
<5C>28@
4C335; <= >53478;586
885FB>5
6 23 615 GC35 79 615 456262785> 61C6 15 23 615
<B328533HC8 >532;28@ C6
C:C<B>C@2
D>26658 C :5665> 67 >53478;586
53478;586
7(
58BH5>C628@ 615
;56C2:3 79 615 GC35 >5@2365>5; C@C2836 615 456262785>
"B>3BC86 67 61C6 >53478;586
>5265>C628@ 615 G7865863
79 615 :5665> 36C628@ 61C6 615 456262785> D261 123 3B447>65>3
23 2862H2;C628@ 61>5C65828@ C8; 358;28@ D>78@ H533C@53
-3-
67 615 4B<:2G C8; CG628@ 28 @>7B43 C8; ;236B><28@ :CD C8;
7>;5> 28 615 E2::C@53
615 456262785> 28
*
(
58G5 C GC35 23 >5@2365>5; C@C2836
6C6278
CIC> "7:2G5
6C6278 28
* 97> 615 79958G53 4B8231C<:5 B8;5>
+ ( ( (
5G6278
(
* C8; (
>2H5
5G62783
>5C; D261
79 "
(
C35; 78 615 >5@236>C6278 79 615 G>2H5 C8; 92:28@
79 615 G1C>@5 31556 >53478;586
>5G7HH58;5;
456262785> 15>528
C
7 ( 8345G67> 79 "7:2G5
>7D;=
31556
C@C2836
C35; 78 D12G1 >53478;586
1C3
4C335; 615 7>;5> 28G:B;28@ 615 8CH5 79 615 456262785> <=
745828@ >7D;= 31556 C@C2836 12H 28 615 >5@2365> ;C65;
+
*
*
C3 615 456262785> DC3 28E7:E5; 28
>2H5
*
6 23 G78658;5; <= 615 G7B835: 97> 615 456262785>
61C6 615 456262785> 1C3 <558 CGAB2665; 28
7 ''
+
+ C>2328@ 7B6 79
'
>2H5
534265 D12G1
*
5332783
C35
* DC= <CG?
615 456262785>.3 8CH5 23
28G:B;5; 28 615 >7D;= 31556 C8; 15 23 3BHH785; 67 615
-4-
47:2G5
36C6278
D1C6375E5>
>;5>
62H5
C8;
C@C28
D2617B6
C8=
>5C378
2::5@C::= C8; G786>C>= 67 615 4>7E232783 79
' C8;
79 615
C>8C6C?C "7:2G5
C8BC:
6 23 C:37 G78658;5; 61C6 87 317D GCB35 8762G5 23 233B5;
C8; H5>5:= 78 615 <C323 79 C8 5C>:25> G>2H5 8BH<5> 615
8CH5 79 615 456262785> 23 28G:B;5; 28 615 >7D;= 31556
15>597>5
>53478;586
456262785>
HC;5
(
>54>53586C6278
97>
>5E25D28@
2H4B@85; 7>;5> C8; 67 ;5:565 123 8CH5 9>7H 615 >7D;=
31556 C3 15 1C3 <558 CGAB2665; 28 615 GC35 <C35; 78
D12G1
123 8CH5 DC3 28G:B;5; 28 615 >7D;= 31556
3CH5 1C3 876 <558 G7832;5>5; <= >53478;586
6 23 G78658;5; 61C6 D158 615 456262785> HC;5
C44:2GC6278 7> >54>53586C6278 615 >53478;586 CB617>26253
7B@16 67 1CE5 CGG5465; 615 >54>53586C6278 C8; 4>7E2;5;
C8 7447>6B826= 67 615 456262785> 67 4B6 97>61 123 GC35 79
615>5 <528@ 87 C::5@C6278 79 G>2H28C: GC353 458;28@ C@C2836
12H C8; 61C6 28G:B3278 79 123 8CH5 C8; G78628B28@ 123
-5-
8CH5 28 615
7D;=
5@2365> 23 E27:C62E5 79 615
4>28G24:53 79 8C6B>C: JB362G5 28G:B;28@ 123 45>378C: :2<5>6=
*
6 23 C:37 G78658;5; 61C6 28 34265 79 615
456262785> <528@ CGAB2665; 28 615 GC35 61C6 DC3 92:5;
C@C2836 12H C8; ;534265 615 >54>53586C6278 <528@ HC;5
615 456262785>.3 8CH5 23 876 36>BG? 799 9>7H 615 >5@2365> 79
>7D;253 615>5<= GCB328@ B867:; 1C>;3124 C8; E27:C6278 79
123 9B8;CH586C: >2@16 79 9>55 H7E5H586 C8; 123 :2<5>6=
+
6 23 C:37 G78658;5; <= 615 :5C>85; G7B835: 61C6
>53478;5863 1CE5 876 97::7D5; 615 85G533C>= @B2;5:2853
:C2; ;7D8 <= 6123
7B>6 28 615 GC35 79
>547>65; 28
15>597>5 15 G78658;3 61C6 2H4:2GC628@ 615
456262785> C8; >5@2365>28@ 123 8CH5 28 615 >7D;= 31556 23
2::5@C: C8; E27:C62E5 79 4>28G24:53 79 8C6B>C: JB362G5
58G5
615 8CH5 79 615 456262785> >5AB2>53 67 <5 >5H7E5; C8;
G7835AB586:= 615 3C2; 7>;5> <5 ABC315;
456262785> 23 45>97>G5; 67 C44>7CG1 6123
D>26 JB>23;2G6278
58G5
7B>6 28E7?28@ 615
-6-
'
:5C>85;
;E7GC65
>54>5358628@
;;26278C:
>53478;586
6C65
7E5>8H586
C;H263
CGAB266C: 79 615 456262785> 28 615 C97>53C2; G>2H28C: GC35
C8; 78 E5>292GC6278 C8; C965> 6C?28@ 2836>BG62783 3B<H263
61C6 615 456262785>.3 8CH5 23 362:: G78628B28@ 28 615 >7D;=
31556 <B6 615 8CH5 79 615 456262785> DC3 28G:B;5; 28 615
7D;=
5@2365> 4>27> 67 CGAB266C: C8; C:37 AB536278
79 97::7D28@ 615 @B2;5:2853 :C2; ;7D8 <= 615
58G1 79 6123
7 7>;28C65
7B>6 28 615 GC35 79
#3B4>C% D7B:; 876 C>235 97> 615 >5C378 61C6 28G:B3278 79 615
8CH5 79 615 456262785> 28 615
67 615 3C2; JB;@H586
6152> <585926
7D;=
5@2365> 23 4>27>
58G5 615 3CH5 D2:: 876 58B>5 67
GG7>;28@:= 15 355?3 67 ;23H233 615 45626278
1CE5 15C>; :5C>85; G7B835: 97> 615 456262785>
C8; :5C>85;
;;26278C:
7E5>8H586
;E7GC65 97> 615
6C65
6 23 C 9B8;CH586C: >B:5 79 :CD 61C6 D158 C
45>378 23 2H4:2GC65; C3 C >7D;= 315565> <= 28G:B;28@ 123
8CH5 28 615 :236 79 >7D;= 31556 615 78B3 23 B478 615
6C65
67 97::7D 615 ;B5 4>7G5;B>5 G7865H4:C65; B8;5> 615
-7-
>5:5EC86 >B:53 C8; >5@B:C62783
C>8C6C?C "7:2G5
8 615 4>53586 GC35 615
C8BC: H7>5 345G292GC::= 615
7D;253 HC286C285; 28 7>;5>
5@2365> 79
D12G1 ;5C:3 D261
12367>= 315563 C8; >7D;= 315563 C8; 58>7::H586 7>
>5@236>C6278 79 45>3783 28 615 3C2; 31556 97> >5@2365> 97>
G78628B7B3 H78267>28@ <= 615 47:2G5 CB617>26253
97::7D5;
6C8;28@
79 >7D;253
>;5>
23 876
;5C:3 D261 >5@236>C6278
15 ;592826278 4>7E2;5; 23 61C6 C >7D;= HC= <5
;59285; C3 C @B8;C C8; 28G:B;53 C 177:2@C8
67B@1
EC@C<78; 7> C8= 45>378 D17 23 ;C8@5>7B3 67 4B<:2G 45CG5
C8; 6>C8AB2:26=
15>5 C>5 HC8= 97>H3 79 >7D;23H D12G1
C>5 ;53G>2<5; 615>528 C8; 615 4>7G533 C8; 4>7G5;B>5
G7865H4:C65; 67 <5 HC286C285; 28 ;2995>586 4C>63 8CH5:=
"C>6
"C>6
C8; "C>6
D12G1 @7E5>8 615 HC28658C8G5
79 C >5@2365> C8; 615 8CH53 79 615 >7D;253 28 6152>
>5345G62E5 4C>63
6 23 615 ;B6= C8; 7<:2@C6278 GC36 B478
615 >53478;5863 D12G1 23 876 746278C: 67 97::7D 615 ;B5
4>7G5;B>5 G7865H4:C65; B8;5> 615 36C8;28@ 7>;5>3 79 615
C>8C6C?C "7:2G5
C8BC:
D12:5 5865>28@ 615 8CH5 79 C
-8-
45>378
>7D;=
31556
C8;
615>5
C>5
G5>6C28
4>7G5;B>53 67 <5 HC8;C67>2:= 97::7D5; <597>5 5865>28@ 615
8CH53
3 G78658;5; <= :5C>85; G7B835: 97> 615 456262785>
615 4>7G533 C8; 4>7G5;B>5 C3 G7865H4:C65; B8;5> 615
36C8;28@
>;5>
79 615
C>8C6C?C "7:2G5
C8BC:
1C3 876 <558 97::7D5; C8; 87 7447>6B826= DC3 @2E58 67 615
456262785> 67 92:5 123 >54:= 7> 5F4:C8C6278 97> >5H7E28@ 123
8CH5 28 615
7D;=
5@2365> C8; H5>5:= <5GCB35 15
DC3 28E7:E5; 28 G>2H28C: GC35 28 D12G1 C:37 615 456262785>
1C3 <558 CGAB2665; 28 615 =5C>
'
6 23 C:37 G78658;5;
61C6 617B@1 615 456262785> 1C3 HC;5 >54>53586C6278 67 615
>53478;586 CB617>26253 C965> 615 CGAB266C: 78
(
615 >54>53586C6278 1C3 876 <558 G7832;5>5; C8; 5E58 C965>
615 CGAB266C: 15 1C3 <558 3BHH785; 67 615 JB>23;2G6278C:
47:2G5 36C6278 97> B885G533C>= 2865>>7@C6278 D158 615>5 23
87 GC35 458;28@ C@C2836 12H
6 D7B:; <5 >5:5EC86 67 5F6>CG6 4C>C@>C41
79 615 JB;@H586 79
2E23278
!"
58G1 79 6123
"
+
7B>6 28 615 GC35
-9-
>547>65; 28 #$
%&&
'
(
D15>528 615
2E23278
58G1 ;5C:6 D261 32H2:C> 3B<J5G6 HC665> D12G1 >5C;3 C3
B8;5>
!
"
#
#
%
&'(
$
#
)
$
#
%
)
* )
$
&'(
#
+
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
#
)
)
)
)
,
)
#
-
K
6C8;28@
C8BC:
>;5>
C>8C6C?C "7:2G5
' 23 5F6>CG65; <5:7D
&'( . / 0
#
)
)
- 10 -
.2/
3+
/
!
,
/ 6
#
)
)
#
/
)
/
!
)
)
,
)
+
+
)
))
/*
,
,
/
,
/
.7/ 6
#
#9
)
;
%
:
.</ . / %
&&
)
#
)
)
)
. / %
)
)
=
8"
:
)
#
)
. / %
)
>% #
>
+
- 11 -
.'/
$
+* #
)
$
#
.?/ %
)
)
!
:
)
. / @
)
#
)
#
)
$
.A/
#
)
)
)
)
)
)
"
)
*
)
)
.(/ $
"
*
#
)
#
#
:
)
)
"
)
*
* $
#
#
. &/
)
#
)
#
#
)
)
- 12 -
.
/ @
#
+
$
!
8:8
)
)
$
!
. 2/ @
+
8:8
@
)
!
$
. 7/ %
8:8
)
!
)
)
)
+* #
. </
$
)
+
)
)
)
. '/ B
!
C
./
)
#
!
)
- 13 -
. /
))
)
2(<
4 .
/,
. /
#
!
(2 . / .)/ .1/
(?7
. /
D
#
. #/ 0
!
) #
C
&A . /
,
.#/ 0
& 4
.# / 0
&4
.# / 0
,
)
# / EC
'?
#
#
)
D
''
!
. C/ 0
(?7,
'&( 6
# +
. ?/ E#
)
E
"
:
)
)
#
+
)
+ +
#
)
)
!
)
+
.
/ @
#
$
)
)
"
#
#
. A/
)
)
&?
- 14 -
3+
/
%
2/ %
)
7/ 5
)
)
</ %
)
'/
?/ $
F
/%
A/
!
. (/ 6
)
)
#
)
)
#
!
(
)
7 7>;28C65
-
58G1 79 6123
7B>6 28 615 GC35
#3B4>C% 1C3 :C2; ;7D8 @B2;5:2853
D12G1 C>5 67 <5 97::7D5; D12:5 >5@2365>28@ 615 8CH5 79 C
45>378 28 615
7D;=
5@2365> D12G1 5E58 4>27> 67
615 3C2; JB;@H586 DC3 C HC8;C65 97> 615 >53478;5863 67
1CE5 97::7D5; 36>2G6:= 28 CGG7>;C8G5 67 615 36C8;28@ 7>;5>
79 615
C>8C6C?C "7:2G5
C8BC:
D12G1 28 H=
- 15 -
7428278
G7832;5>28@ 615 9CG63 C8; G2>GBH36C8G5 79 615
4>53586 GC35 1C3 876 <558 97::7D5; C8; 5E58 C965> 615
CGAB266C:
456262785>
C8;
5E58
C965>
>54>53586C6278 @2E58 <= 615 456262785> 97> >5H7E28@ 123
8CH5 9>7H 615
7D;=
5@2365>
615>5 23 87
>5347835 7> >54:= 7> CG6278 <= 615 >53478;5863 28
>5H7E28@ 123 8CH5
8 E25D 79 878 G7H4:2C8G5 79 615 4>7G5;B>5
G7865H4:C65;
B8;5>
C>8C6C?C "7:2G5
36C8;28@
7>;5>
C8BC: C8; 878 G7832;5>C6278 79 615
>54>53586C6278 @2E58 <= 615 456262785> 4B>3BC86 67 123
CGAB266C: 6123
7B>6 23 79 615 7428278 61C6 615 456262785>
1C3 HC;5 7B6 C EC:2; GC35 67 G7832;5> 9CE7B>C<:=
GG7>;28@:=
4C33 615 97::7D28@
15 )>26 "5626278 23
2H4B@85;
))
7>;5>
>5@C>;28@ 745828@
;C65;
7D;=
+
*
5@2365> 28
- 16 -
8CH5
456262785>
7D;=31556
>53478;586
<5C>28@
* 4C335; <=
23 15>5<= ABC315;
15 >53478;5863 C>5 15>5<= ;2>5G65; 67
>5H7E5 615 8CH5 79 615 456262785> 9>7H 615
7D;=
5@2365> HC286C285; <= 615H
D26128 C 45>27; 79 97B> D55?3 9>7H 615 ;C65
79 >5G5246 79 G5>62925; G74= 79 615 7>;5>
2E
2<5>6=
17D5E5>
>53478;586
>535>E5;
6C65 67 4>7G55; 28 CGG7>;C8G5
D261 :CD C@C2836 615 456262785> 29 C6 C:: C8=
GC35 23 HC;5 7B6 C8; D12:5 ;728@ 37 615=
31C:: 36>2G6:= 97::7D 615 @B2;5:2853 :C2; ;7D8
<= 6123
7B>6 28 615 GC35 79
>547>65; 28
'(
%
&
$
"
+
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review