Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 28th September, 2026
Uploaded on: 29th September, 2026
#
CNR No. DLHC011107512025
+
CONT.APP.(C) 23/2026 & CM APPL. 67137/2026, CM APPL.
67138/2026, CM APPL. 67139/2026, CM APPL.67140/2026, CM
APPL. 67141/2026
I. K. SAINI
.....Appellant
Through:
versus
K. N. JHA ORS
Through:
Appellant in person.
.....Respondents
Ms. Avni Singh (Panel Counsel for
GNCTD) along with Ms. Harshita Raj
(Adv)
CORAM:
JUSTICE PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUSTICE DINESH BHATT
Prathiba M. Singh, J. (Oral)
1.
This hearing has been done through hybrid mode.
2.
The present appeal has been filed by the Appellant under Section 19(1)
of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, inter alia, assailing the impugned orders
dated 19th May, 2022, 26th July, 2023, 1st April, 2024, and 7th February, 2025
in CONT.CAS(C) 37/2019.
3.
The prayer of the Appellant in the present petition is that a ration card
was issued by the Food and Supplies Department in favour of one Mrs.
Premshila and her son – Mr. Achal Kumar, by indulging in certain forgery.
4.
According to the Appellant, the said beneficiaries are having certain
disputes with the Appellant, where they are stated to be relying on the said
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:16:17
CONT.APP.(C) 23/2026
ration card and claiming rights therefrom.
5.
The Appellant had approached the Public Grievances Commission,
which had passed an order on 20th February, 2009, where the case was closed
with the following observations:
“This case was transferred as a grievance case after
hearing of appeal before Chairman, PGC.
The complainant had sought an enquiry
regarding issue of ration card to Mrs. Prem Shella Saini
on the address H.No. A-70, NDSE-II, New Delhi on
29.6.01 by FSO Circle 9. It was alleged that Mrs. Saini
had got issued ration card fraudulently on the above
address by showing herself as wife of Shri. R.K. Saini,
son of Somnath Saini, owner of House No. A-70, NDSEII, New Delhi. She had produced NOC from Somnath
Saini, the owner in the year of whereas Shri Saini had
expired in 1984. The complainant further alleged that
Mrs. Prem Shila Saini had obtained succession
certificate from Court of law to debt and securities Of
late Shri Rajender Kumar Saini by misrepresenting and
showing herself as wife of R.K. Saini in the food card
issued by FSO circle No.9.
Proceedings of the hearing:
According to report of AC/Vigilance Mrs. Prem Sheila
Saini had applied for ration card vide diary No. 921
dated 29.6.01 and she had also submitted a copy of
electricity bill by the name of Sh. Somnath Saini. There
was NOC from the landlord on the back of the
application form. The report also states that the
complainant’s father is involved in a civil litigation with
Mrs. Prem Sheila Saini and wants to drag the
Department in support of his case claiming that Mrs.
Saini had obtained the ration card in a fraudulent
manner. The contention of the Department is that the
Department issues ration card to anyone for drawal of
FSA only based on the required documents which Mrs.
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:16:17
CONT.APP.(C) 23/2026
Saini had furnished at the time of application. FSO
Circle 9 has however been advised to keep all the
relevant records pertaining to ration card No. 004491
Regn. No. 1894, …. No. 5636 issued to Mrs. Prem Sheila
Saini in safe custody of the Circle so that Department is
able to produce the actual records to any agency/Court
of law, if required in future.
The main point for concern in the case is
regarding submission of NOC from Somnath Saini by
Mrs. Prem Sheila Saini at the time of application for
issue of ration card in 2001. Whereas Somnath Saini
had expired in the year 1984. This is an issue which
has to be investigated on the basis of supporting
documents and contentions from petitioner’s side. The
nature of fraud of forgery therefore required
independent investigation by Police for which the
applicant has to move a proper petition supporting his
contentions. The applicant is advised to make his
further submissions to the Hon’ble Court or Police in
the above context in view of above report of the
Department.
The case will be treated as closed in the
Commission. ”
6.
Thereafter, the matter culminated in the order dated 21st February, 2018
passed by the Division Bench of this Court in LPA 738/2017 titled ‘IK Saini
v. The Department of Food and Supplies & Ors.’, wherein the Court had
directed as under:
“The appellant who appears in person states that he
would not press this appeal if this Court were to direct
the respondents to consider his complaint dated 6 th
May, 2014, in accordance with law.
The appeal is accordingly dismissed as not
pressed with a direction to the concerned respondents
to consider and take appropriate action on the said
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:16:17
CONT.APP.(C) 23/2026
complaint of the appellant; as may be warranted in
law, under intimation to the appellant.”
7.
In terms thereof, the Court dismissed the aforesaid appeal, with the
direction that the Respondents take appropriate action on the complaint of the
Appellant dated 6th May, 2014.
8.
However, the grievance of the Appellant is that no action has been
taken pursuant to the order dated 21st February, 2018. Therefore, the
Appellant had filed a contempt petition being CONT.CASE 37/2019 titled
‘I.K.Sahni v. K.N.Jha & Ors.’ assailing the said order.
9.
Vide order dated 26th July, 2023, the CONT.CASE 37/2019 was
rejected with the liberty to the Petitioner to avail legal remedies in accordance
with law. The relevant portion of the said order is as under:
“[...]2. The operative portion of the order dated
21.02.2018 reads as under:
"The appeal is accordingly dismissed as not
pressed with a direction to the concerned
respondents to consider and take appropriate
action on the said complaint of the appellant;
as may be warranted in law, under intimation
to the appellant."
3. It is stated by the petitioner who appears in person
that the order of 21.02.2018 has not been complied with
in letter, spirit and intent.
4. Mr. Vashisht, learned ASC has drawn my attention to
the counter affidavit, wherein it has been stated that
"11. It is humbly and most respectfully
submitted that in view of the directions of this
Hon’ble Court contained in the Order dated
21.02.2018, investigations with regard to the
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:16:17
CONT.APP.(C) 23/2026
above said documents was undertaken by the
Answering Respondent and in a meeting
convened in the Chamber of Commissioner of
Food Supplies on 11.10.2018, the Petitioner
was duly informed of the result of the said
investigations/inquiry Vide Letter dated
20.12.2010, this fact was also duly
communicated to the Petitioner. A copy of the
said Letter dated 20.12.2018 is annexed
herewith and marked as Annexure SA-l."
5. The letter of 20.12.2018 states that the record is not
traceable as the same is old.
6. In this view of the matter, there is no intentional and
malafide violation of the order of this Court.
7. However, the petitioner is at liberty to avail all his
legal rights in accordance with law for his
grievances.”
10.
Pursuant thereto, a review petition being REVIEW PET. 152/2023 was
also filed against the order dated order dated 26 th July, 2023 in which the
Court vide order dated 1st April, 2024 observed as under:
“REVIEW PET. 152/2023
1. The petitioner has filed the instant review petition
under Order XLVII read with Section 151 of the CPC
seeking review of the order dated 19th May, 2022.
2. Petitioner appearing-in-person submitted that this
Court had allowed the adjournment request made by the
petitioner, vide the impugned order dated 19th May,
2022, however, the reasons stated in the impugned order
have been wrongly recorded by the Predecessor Bench
of this Court.
3. It is submitted that in the impugned order, it has been
recorded that the petitioner had moved an adjournment
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:16:17
CONT.APP.(C) 23/2026
slip on the ground that the main counsel is not well and
is not in a position to attend the Court proceedings,
however, the said ground is wrong since the petitioner’s
request for adjournment was different than what has
been recorded in the impugned order.
4. It is further submitted that on 17th May, 2022, the
petitioner had to visit High Court of Calcutta to appear
in another case and due to the same, he could not attend
the proceedings before this Court on 19th May, 2022,
therefore, he had requested for the adjournment on the
said ground.
5. It is submitted that instead of recording the above
stated reason, the Predecessor Bench of this Court had
wrongly recorded the ground for adjournment and
hence, it is prayed that the impugned order may
reviewed in light of the foregoing submissions
6. Per Contra the learned counsel appearing on behalf
of the respondents vehemently opposed the instant
petition submitting to the effect that the petitioner has
been unable to make out any case for the review of the
impugned order and the instant petition is merely an
abuse of the process of law.
7. It is therefore submitted that the present petition,
being devoid of any merits, may be dismissed.
8. Heard the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
parties and perused the record.
9. It is the case of the petitioner that the Predecessor
Bench of this Court had wrongly recorded the reasons
of adjournment in the impugned order. The petitioner
has pleaded before this Court that in the impugned
order, it has been recorded that he had moved an
adjournment slip on the ground that the main counsel is
not well and is not in a position to attend the Court
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:16:17
CONT.APP.(C) 23/2026
proceedings, however, the actual ground for
adjournment was that the petitioner was occupied in
pursuing another case before the High Court of
Calcutta on 17th May, 2022 and therefore, could not
appear in the proceedings held on 19th May, 2022
before the Predecessor Bench of this Court. Hence, the
petitioner prays that the exact reason may be recorded.
10. This Court is of the view that the power of review is
exercised in cases where there is an error apparent on
the face of the record and only in such an event the order
or judgment can be corrected or set aside.
11. For a High Court to exercise its power of review
there must be an error/mistake apparent on the face of
the record. An error which is highlighted by way of
reasoning to such effect is not an error apparent on the
face of it and hence, jurisdiction under review may not
be exercised. The High Court is conferred with powers
of review which is distinct from that of an appellate
forum. The said power is neither the inherent power of
this Court, nor is the review a means for covert appeal.
12. As far as the facts of the instant review petition is
concerned, the petitioner has not been able to make out
a case for review and hence, the said contentions
cannot be entertained under the review jurisdiction of
this Court. The submissions advanced by the petitioner
are trivial in nature and do not make out a case for
want of review.
13. In light of the same, this Court is of the view that
the instant review petition is meritless as the same is
merely an attempt to abuse the process of law and
misuses the remedies available to the petitioner. The
present review petition is utterly unnecessary and in
light of the same, it is liable to be dismissed.
14. Accordingly, the instant review petition along with
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:16:17
CONT.APP.(C) 23/2026
the pending applications, if any, stands dismissed.”
11.
In terms of the above, the review petition was dismissed as the Court
had noted that no grounds for review are made out. The Appellant had also
preferred a further review petition being REVIEW PET. 354/2023, which
was also rejected vide order dated 7th February, 2025 in the following terms:
“[...] 11. In this view of the matter, there is no
intentional and malafide violation of the order dated
21.02.2018, as alleged by the petitioner. Hence,the
Cont.Cas(C) No.37/2019 was disposed of by this
Court vide the order dated 26.07.2023 and the
operative paragraphs of the said order read as:"5. The letter of 20.12.2018 states that the
record is not traceable as the same is old.
6. In this view of the matter, there is no
intentional and mala fide violation of the order
of this Court.
7. However, the petitioner is at liberty to avail
all his legal rights in accordance with law for
his grievances.
8. With this liberty, the contempt petition is
disposed of "
12. The petitioner has not drawn my attention to any
change in the circumstances of the present case.
13. Therefore, in my considered analysis, no grounds
for review are made out in the present petition.
14. For the said reasons, I am of the view that the
impugned order is well reasoned and does not require
any interference.
15. Hence, the review petition is dismissed and is
disposed of accordingly.
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:16:17
CONT.APP.(C) 23/2026
12.
In this appeal the challenge is to the various orders passed in the
Contempt petition. The Court has heard the ld. Counsels for the Appellant and
the Respondent.
13.
The foremost issue that arises for consideration is whether the present
appeal under Section 19 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 would be
maintainable or not.
14.
In ‘Midnapore Peoples’ Coop. Bank Ltd. v. Chunilal Nanda (2006) 5
SCC 399, the Court has clearly held that appeals under Section 19 of the
Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 would be maintainable only in respect of orders
punishing for contempt. The relevant portion is set out below:
“11. The position emerging from these decisions, in
regard to appeals against orders in contempt
proceedings may be summarised thus:
I. An appeal under Section 19 is maintainable only
against an order or decision of the High Court
passed in exercise of its jurisdiction to punish for
contempt, that is, an order imposing punishment for
contempt.
II. Neither an order declining to initiate proceedings
for contempt, nor an order initiating proceedings for
contempt nor an order dropping the proceedings for
contempt nor an order acquitting or exonerating the
contemnor, is appealable under Section 19 of the CC
Act. In special circumstances, they may be open to
challenge under Article 136 of the Constitution.
III. In a proceeding for contempt, the High Court can
decide whether any contempt of court has been
committed, and if so, what should be the punishment
and matters incidental thereto. In such a proceeding,
it is not appropriate to adjudicate or decide any issue
relating to the merits of the dispute between the
parties.
IV. Any direction issued or decision made by the High
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:16:17
CONT.APP.(C) 23/2026
Court on the merits of a dispute between the parties,
will not be in the exercise of “jurisdiction to punish
for contempt” and, therefore, not appealable under
Section 19 of the CC Act. The only exception is where
such direction or decision is incidental to or
inextricably connected with the order punishing for
contempt, in which event the appeal under Section 19
of the Act, can also encompass the incidental or
inextricably connected directions.
V. If the High Court, for whatsoever reason, decides
an issue or makes any direction, relating to the merits
of the dispute between the parties, in a contempt
proceedings, the aggrieved person is not without
remedy. Such an order is open to challenge in an
intra-court appeal (if the order was of a learned
Single Judge and there is a provision for an intracourt appeal), or by seeking special leave to appeal
under Article 136 of the Constitution of India (in
other cases).
The first point is answered accordingly.”
15.
The above judgment has been followed by this Court in
CONT.APP.(C) 23/2025 titled ‘RK Sharma v. Sh. Amarjeet Singh’ and
recently in CONT.APP.(C) 6/2026 titled ‘Tribhuwan Singh & Ors. v. Shri
Chetan Prakash Jain and Anr.
16.
In the present case, there is no finding of contempt, nor any punishment
meted out in respect of any contempt.
17.
In view of the decision of the Supreme Court in Midnapore Peoples'
Coop. Bank Ltd. v. Chunilal Nanda, (2006) 5 SCC 399, and the other
decisions mentioned above, the present appeal is not maintainable.
18.
In the opinion of this Court, if any ration card has been issued based on
a forgery, instead of pursuing a writ petition, the Appellant may be welladvised to avail his remedies in accordance with law, by filing a civil suit.
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:16:17
CONT.APP.(C) 23/2026
19.
The appeal is disposed of in these terms. All pending applications are
also disposed of.
PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUDGE
DINESH BHATT
JUDGE
SEPTEMBER 28, 2026
Rahul/sm
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:16:17
CONT.APP.(C) 23/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review