Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
C/SCA/11550/2026
(GJHC240622442026)
ORDER DATED: 07/10/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 11550 of 2026
==========================================================
I FIT SPORTS PVT. LTD.
Versus
KNOWLEDGE CONSORTIUM OF GUJARAT (KCG) & ORS.
==========================================================
Appearance:
MR.ADITYA J PANDYA(6991) for the Petitioner(s) No. 1
MS HETAL PATEL, AGP for the Respondent(s) No. 2
MR SUDHIR NANVATI, SENIOR ADVOCATE with
MR VANDAN K BAXI, ADVOCATE
MS FALAK SAWLANI, ADVOCATE for the Respondent(s) No. 3
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR. JUSTICE
MANASH RANJAN PATHAK
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE NIKHIL S. KARIEL
Date : 07/10/2026
ORAL ORDER
(PER : HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE NIKHIL S. KARIEL)
1.
Heard learned advocate Mr. Aaditya Pandya on behalf
of the petitioner, learned Assistant Government Pleader Ms.
Hetal Patel for respondent State, learned Senior Advocate
Mr. Sudhir Nanavati with learned advocate Mr. Vandan
Bakshi for M/s. Nanavati & Nanavati for newly joined
respondent No. 3.
2.
Learned Senior Advocate Mr. Nanavati would submit
that respondent No. 3 may be permitted to file vakalatnama
during course of the day. Permission as prayed for is
granted.
Registry
to
accept
the
vakalatnama
till
the
C/SCA/11550/2026
(GJHC240622442026)
ORDER DATED: 07/10/2026
08.10.2026.
3.
By way of this petition, the petitioner challenges a
decision of the respondent No. 1 of rejecting the bid of the
petitioner at the pre-qualifying stage, inter alia, on the
ground
that
Original
Equipment
Manufacturer
(OEM)
certificate as regards supporting the tender-specific conditions
for the product has not been produced.
4.
Having regard to the submissions made by learned
advocates and learned Senior Advocate for the respective
parties, to us it would appear that the issue is in a very
short compass. The issue in brief being that the respondent
No. 1, Knowledge Consortium of Gujarat, had floated a
tender on 18.04.2026, inter alia, calling upon interested
bidders to bid for a tender for supply of sports equipment.
The tender document, inter alia, contained a condition that
“OEM Authorization Certificate” should be produced by the
bidder for the product in question. It also appears that the
tender, very specifically states that the bidder's offer would
be rejected if certificates/documents sought in the bid
document, ATC and corrigendum, if any, is not uploaded. It
also appears that while three different corrigendums were
issued, the respondent No. 1 also published a consolidated
pre-qualification criteria and whereas Clause 8 of the prequalification criteria of the eligibility criteria, inter alia,
states
that
the
bidder
must
submit
tender-specific
Manufacturer’s Authorization Forms (MAF) for all items
quoted in the bid. It also states that the MAF shall serve as
the authorization from the OEM permitting the bidder to
C/SCA/11550/2026
(GJHC240622442026)
ORDER DATED: 07/10/2026
supply the specified items under the tender in question. The
explanation as regards the document to be attached as
inter alia, states that wherever an
authorized distributor or service provider has submitted his
bid, the authorization form/certificate from the OEM,
appropriate details, is to be furnished.
against
4.1
Clause
8,
It would also appear that the respondent No. 1, had
sought for certain clarifications from the petitioner and
whereas the clarifications were submitted by the petitioner
on 25.06.2026, more particularly documents as well as
screenshots, having been produced with the petition to
evidence the same. Ultimately, it would appear that at the
stage of technical evaluation, on 05.08.2026, the petitioner's
bid had been disqualified, inter alia, on the ground that the
petitioner had not fulfilled their pre-qualification criteria,
which
required
the
petitioner
to
submit
tender-specific
Manufacturer’s Authorization Forms (MAF) for all items
quoted in the bid, which has led to the present petition
being filed.
5.
While learned advocate Mr. Pandya would submit that
the issue is with regard to table tennis table, which is
manufactured by a brand named ‘Stiga’, and whereas
learned advocate would draw the attention of this Court to
an ITTF certificate dated 19.05.2026, whereby the table
tennis tables of Stiga brand has been approved by the ITTF.
Learned
advocate
would
further
draw
attention
to
a
document dated 19.12.2014 by M/s. Stiga Sports, inter alia,
authorizing one M/s. Cosco (India) Limited as the 'authorized
C/SCA/11550/2026
(GJHC240622442026)
ORDER DATED: 07/10/2026
sole agent' for Stiga branded products in India. Learned
advocate would also draw attention to a Manufacturer's
Authorization Form, dated 24.06.2026 issued by M/s. Cosco
(India) Limited, whereby, according to learned advocate,
M/s. Cosco (India) Limited has, inter alia, guaranteed that
the warrants offered for the goods and services and for the
items which have been mentioned in the tender shall be
honored by the manufacturer.
5.1
Referring to the above documents, learned advocate
would submit that M/s. Cosco (India) Limited being the
agent of M/s. Stiga Sports, the authorization form tendered
by M/s. Cosco (India) Limited could not have been ignored
by the respondents. Learned advocate would also submit that
probably, the petitioner's bid was much lower than the bid
of the respondent No. 2 even after the reverse auction and
whereas
under
such
circumstances,
this
Court
should
intervene.
6.
As against the same, the present petition has been
vehemently objected to by learned Assistant Government
Pleader Ms. Hetal Patel. Learned AGP would draw the
attention of this Court to the Manufacturer's Authorization
Form (MAF) submitted by M/s. Cosco (India) Limited dated
24.06.2026. Learned AGP would draw attention to the word
"The manufacturer, M/s. Cosco" and would submit that that
term which has been emphasized by learned AGP is the term
with which the said certificate starts. Learned AGP would
submit that as such, M/s. Cosco (India) Limited claims to be
a sole agent for M/s. Stiga yet, the said certificate, is very
C/SCA/11550/2026
(GJHC240622442026)
ORDER DATED: 07/10/2026
conspicuous by the fact that neither the word "agent" nor
the word "Stiga" is mentioned in the entire certificate and
whereas M/s. Cosco (India) Limited has claimed to be the
manufacturer, which it is not.
6.1
Learned
AGP
would
also
submit
that
while
the
certificate was in respect of a table tennis table, yet the
term "table tennis" has also not been mentioned in the said
certificate. Learned AGP would submit that M/s. Cosco
(India) Limited, masquerading as a manufacturer and not as
an agent, the said certificate was not considered to be a
valid OEM authorization certificate and whereas under such
circumstances, the bid of the petitioner had rightly been
canceled.
7.
Learned Senior Advocate Mr. Nanavati for respondent
No.
i.e.
the
successful
bidder
would
support
the
submissions made by learned AGP and would further submit
that the respondent No. 2, having participated in the tender
and having been having successfully been the lowest bidder
in the reverse auction, the petitioner is trying to prejudice
this Court by stating that the petitioner is the lowest bidder,
more particularly, when his price bid had not been opened
at all. Thus submitting, learned Senior Advocate would
request this Court not to consider the petition.
8.
Heard learned counsel for the respective parties and
perused the documents on record and whereas, we are in
complete agreement with the submissions made by learned
AGP Ms. Patel. Having perused the document, authorization
C/SCA/11550/2026
(GJHC240622442026)
ORDER DATED: 07/10/2026
certificate issued dated 24.06.2026, we are of the opinion
that the said certificate could not be termed as an original
equipment manufacturer's authorization certificate as required
in the tender document. We have also noticed that M/s.
Cosco
(India)
Limited
has
claimed
itself
to
be
the
manufacturer, which it is not. It is neither the case of the
petitioner that M/s. Cosco (India) Limited has been licensed
to produce the table tennis tables on behalf of M/s. Stiga in
India, nor it is the case of M/s. Cosco (India) Limited that it
has any such license. The only claim on behalf of the
petitioner being that M/s. Cosco (India) Limited is the sole
authorized agent for M/s. Stiga and whereas, as pointed out
rightly by learned AGP, neither the term "agent" nor the
word "Stiga" is found in the entire certificate. An ambiguous
certificate,
which
does
not
specifically
mention
the
requirements of the tender issuing authority and based upon
such a document, which was mandatorily required to be
uploaded, the bid of the petitioner being rejected and
whereas to us it does not seem that the respondent No. 1
has committed any error in doing so.
9.
At this stage, we also notice that the document dated
24.06.2026 claims itself to be "Manufacturer's Authorization
Form (MAF)". As noticed hereinabove, the only case of the
petitioner being that M/s. Cosco (India) Limited was the sole
agent on behalf of M/s. Stiga and whereas either the
Manufacturer's Authorization Form should have been by M/s.
Stiga or M/s. Cosco (India) Limited should have stated that it
is undertaking to indemnify the petitioner on behalf of M/s.
Stiga. A Manufacturer's Authorization Form by M/s. Cosco
C/SCA/11550/2026
(GJHC240622442026)
ORDER DATED: 07/10/2026
(India) Limited, who is not a manufacturer and being a mere
agent, would not have sufficed the purpose. We are of the
opinion that even if M/s. Cosco (India) Limited would have
stated the words "agent" and the word "Stiga" in the
certificate, the very fact that it has given a Manufacturer's
Authorization
Form,
more
particularly,
not
being
the
manufacturer, itself would be a sufficient ground for the
respondents to have disqualified the present petitioner.
10.
Having regard to the above, to us it would appear that
the petitioner had not complied with a mandatory clause of
the Tender, i.e. produce the OEM authorization and/or the
Manufacturer's Authorization Form (MAF). The mandatory
nature of the document not being questionable, to us it
would appear that the respondents authority was completely
justified in having disqualified at the pre-bid stage itself.
11.
Under such circumstances, in our considered opinion,
no fault could be found with the action taken by the
respondents. Hence, the present petition fails and the same
is disposed of as rejected. Interim relief, if any, stands
vacated.
(MANASH RANJAN PATHAK,ACJ)
(NIKHIL S. KARIEL,J)
SHRIJIT PILLAI
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review