Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:HHC:33243 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
Arb. Case No.20 of 2025
Reserved on: 24.07.2026
Pronounced on: 07.08.2026
Uploaded on: 10.08.2026
HPSEBL
.....Petitioner
Versus
M/s Hi-Tech Power System and another
Coram:
…..Respondents
The Hon'ble Mr. Justice G.S. Sandhawalia, Chief Justice.
Whether approved for reporting? Yes.
For the petitioner:
Ms. Sunita Sharma, Senior Advocate with
Ms. Hiaa Sharma and Ms. Harshita Dogra,
Advocates.
For the respondents:
Mr. H.S. Bhogal, Senior Advocate with
Mr. Satish Sharma and Ms. Srishti Verma,
Advocates.
G.S. Sandhawalia, Chief Justice.
The present petition has been filed under Section 11(4)
of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (hereinafter referred to
as ‘the Act’) by the petitioner-Board for appointment of an Arbitrator.
The dispute arose from the “Letter of Award for Supply of Material for
providing and execution of augmentation of Conductor (Existing
ACSR 6/1/4.72mm to 37/2.49mm) of 33KV Line from Girinagar to
Nahan on Turnkey basis in Operation Circle, HPSEBL.” The said
contract was stated to be awarded to the respondents by the
Superintending Engineer, Operation Circle, HPSEBL, Nahan, vide
Purchase Order No. OCN/DB-27/2009-11286-91 dated 07.01.2011
(Annexure P-2) for a sum of Rs. 1,15,56,704/-. Pursuant to clause
12.1 of the Contract, the stipulated time for completing the work was
three months from the date of the award.
2.
Similarly, “Letter of Award” for 'Survey, Design, Erection,
Testing, and Commissioning for the Augmentation of Conductor
(Existing ACSR 6/1/4.72mm to 37/2.49mm) of the 33kV Line from
Girinagar to Nahan under Electrical Sub-Division No.-II, Nahan on a
Turnkey basis in Operation Circle, HPSEBL, Nahan (Erection Part),
amounting to Rs. 19,91,739/-, was also awarded to the respondent
by the Superintending Engineer, Operation Circle, HPSEBL, vide
Award Letter No. OCN/DB-27/2009-11292-97 dated 07.01.2011
(Annexure P-2). Pursuant to clause 7.1 of the Contract, the
stipulated time for completing the work was three months from the
date of the award.
3.
The petitioner-Board stated that the material was
supplied to the respondents, who were asked to complete the work
vide a letter dated 17.08.2015. However, the work was not
completed even after a lapse of five years. Consequently, a final
notice dated 11.02.2016, was served by the Superintending
Engineer, Operation Circle, HPSEBL, Nahan. A meeting was
allegedly held with the Contractor/Firm on 02.03.2016, wherein the
respondents had ensured to start the work after 15.04.2016,
following the wheat harvest season. Eventually, the work was stated
to have been rescinded on 06.04.2018. Prior to this, the respondent
was informed that the work would be measured, and the results of
the measurement would be final and binding and because the
respondent did not join the measurement process, the petitionerBoard measured the work by forming a Joint Inspection Committee
vide a letter dated 31.03.2018. According to the joint measurement
report, the respondent had completed re-conductoring on only 4.664
km out of the 22.5 km across four patches between Do-Sarka and
Girinagar. Furthermore, the firm failed to return any unused material
or dismantled conductors.
4.
Resultantly, a fallback was made on clause 4.1 of the
Contract Agreement, titled 'Settlement of Disputes,' which provides
an arbitration clause and is appended as Annexure P-3. It was
specifically agreed between the parties that all differences or
disputes arising out of or touching upon the subject matter of the
Agreement shall be decided by the process of settlement and
arbitration as specified in clause 29 of the General Conditions of
Contract, in accordance with the provisions of the Indian Arbitration
and Conciliation Act, 1996.
5.
On 09.06.2023 (Annexure P-4), a notice was issued for
referring the matter to an independent arbitrator in terms of the said
clause. This notice mentioned an amount of Rs.1,15,56,704/- (supply
part only) and Rs.19,91,379/- (erection part only), along with the
award in question, and claimed Rs.96,66,354/- with a reference to
the alleged notice dated 29.01.2023.
6.
In pursuance to clause 25.1 of the work order and
clause 4.1 of the Contract Agreement dated 07.01.2011 containing
the arbitration clause, a second notice was sent on 14.08.2024
(Annexure P-5) for settlement of the dispute. In this notice, a sum of
Rs.96,66,354/- was stated to be recoverable from the respondents
as per the work award dated 07.01.2011 (Annexure P-2).
Furthermore, the Chief Engineer (Project)-cum-Arbitrator, Vidyut
Bhawan, Shimla, was nominated as the arbitrator, and the
respondents' consent was sought accordingly. Thereafter, the
petition came to be filed on 23.12.2024.
7.
The reply was filed by the respondent, who asserted that
the claim preferred by the petitioner is a dead claim and was not
liable to be referred to arbitration. The answering respondents had
failed to execute the work after 24.03.2012, thus, the cause of
action, if any, arose to the petitioner on 24.03.2012. The present
petition, having been filed in November 2024, was hopelessly time-
barred, and the first notice invoking arbitration, alleged to have been
issued on 09.06.2023, was ex-facie beyond the period of limitation.
Furthermore, the respondents denied being privy to any minutes of
the meeting allegedly held on 02.03.2016, whereby they had
supposedly undertaken to complete the work, and they also denied
receiving the letter dated 29.01.2018, by which a final show-cause
notice was allegedly served upon them. However, the letter
rescinding the work was also stated not to be received by the
respondents. In such circumstances, it has been held out that of
clause 19 of the Contract was not enforceable under the law existing
as of this date, which dictates that a party to a Contract is not eligible
to unilaterally nominate an arbitrator.
8.
The petitioner has filed a replication to the reply
submitted by the respondents, referencing correspondences dated
06.08.2013 and 17.08.2015, which have not yet been placed on
record. The petitioner had been served a notice invoking arbitration
on 09.06.2023, but the respondents failed to concur with the
appointment of an arbitrator and the three-year limitation period
prescribed under Article 137 of the Limitation Act, 1963, commenced
from the date of such failure. Since the present petition was filed in
November 2024, it was well within the prescribed limitation period.
An averment was made in the replication that the work had
commenced after the meeting held on 02.03.2016 and therefore,
limitation does not stand in the way. Furthermore, the question of
limitation, being a mixed question of fact and law, ought to be
adjudicated by the Arbitral Tribunal upon the appreciation of
evidence led by the parties. On the merits, it was averred that the
respondents reportedly completed only 4.664 km of the total 22.5 km
of work. The remaining material, worth crores of rupees, was neither
utilized for the project nor returned to the petitioner. Additionally, the
dismantled conductor was misappropriated by the respondents,
establishing their liability to pay an amount of Rs.1,04,50,112/- to the
petitioner.
9.
Counsel for the petitioner-Board has placed reliance
upon the judgments passed by the Apex Court in Vidya Drolia and
Others Vs. Durga Trading Corporation (2021) 2 SCC 1 and SBI
General Insurance Company Limited v. Krish Spinning (2024) 12
SCC 1, and contends that the order passed in the suo motu writ
petition extending the COVID-19 limitation period by the Apex Court
would be applicable and the period from 15.03.2020 till 28.02.2022
should be excluded for the purposes of prescribed limitation.
10.
Reliance was also placed upon the judgment passed by
the Apex Court in Aditya Khaitan Vs. IL and FS Financial
Services Limited in Civil Appeal Nos.6411-6488 of 2023 (2023)
INSC 867, wherein the Apex Court as such had allowed the appeals
permitted the written statements to be taken on record after
excluding the COVID period.
11.
Counsel for the respondents, on the other hand, has
submitted that no such averments were made in the petition and
argued that this contention should not be accepted, as the petitioner
must first establish what steps were taken after the Contract was
rescinded. Notably, an intervening period of over two years elapsed
after 06.04.2018, before the Apex Court had passed its order on
10.01.2022. Even after that order, no action was taken for nearly a
year until the alleged show-cause notice was issued on 29.01.2023,
which has also not been appended to the petition. Furthermore, it is
submitted that the only document on record is the first notice dated
09.06.2023, which itself fails to mention that the petitioner was
prevented from availing of remedies in accordance with the law.
12.
Counsel for the respondents has placed reliance upon
the judgment of the three-judge Bench of the Apex Court in Elfit
Arabia and Another Vs. Concept Hotel Barons Limited and
Others (2024) SCC OnLine SC 1739, wherein it was held that the
Court must ‘cut the deadwood’ by refraining from appointing an
arbitrator when claims are ex facie time-barred and dead, or where
no subsisting dispute exists. It is submitted that in the said case, the
notices invoking arbitration dated 04.07.2022 and 27.10.2022 were
issued eleven years after the cause of action originally arose in
2011. Consequently, the claims are well beyond the prescribed
limitation period of three years. It is further submitted that the
principles established in Vidya Drolia’s case (supra) were duly
considered and followed by the Apex Court in the aforementioned
judgment.
13.
Reliance was also placed upon the judgment passed by
the undersigned on 03.07.2026 in Arb. Case No. 167 of 2025, titled
as Shashi Sharma Vs. The State of Himachal Pradesh and
Others. In that case, notice was issued five and a half years after
the cause of action arose, long after the dispute had died, as the
contractor had done nothing for eight years. It was held therein that
merely serving a notice on 22.03.2024 to claim an outstanding
amount or raise a bill would not give a fresh cause of action to the
petitioner.
14.
The above pleaded facts would go on to show that
apparently after the issuance of the work Award on 07.01.2011 and
the alleged rescinding on 06.04.2018, there was total inactivity on
the part of the petitioner-Board. No notice has been placed on record
to provide material evidence of any meeting or for the resumption of
work. This is despite the petitioner's averment that a consensus was
reached for the respondent to restart the work in April 2016,
pursuant to an alleged meeting held on 02.03.2016, in the chamber
of the Superintending Engineer, Operation Circle, HPSEBL, Nahan.
Notably, nothing has been placed on record to show that the minutes
of any such meeting were signed by the respondents. Furthermore,
the notice dated 28.03.2013, allegedly issued in compliance with the
minutes of that meeting, has also not been produced. It is thus
apparent that while the dispute had been festering since 2016, the
contract was only rescinded on 06.04.2018. Ultimately, no efforts
were made by the petitioner-Board for referring the matter to
arbitration or to serve the necessary notice for the appointment of an
arbitrator.
15.
The first notice having been served on 09.06.2023, is far
beyond the applicable limitation period. This period is to be
calculated from the apparent abandonment of the work on
17.08.2015. Indeed, the Petitioner's own case is that the
Superintending Engineer had asked them by holding a meeting and
had issued a letter demanding the immediate completion of the work
on 02.03.2016.
Thus, it is apparent that despite awarding the
Contract in 2011 for a six-year period, the work remained
incomplete, which was to be completed in a period of three (3)
months. The petitioner-Board took no active steps to raise a dispute
or enforce a settlement through the appointment of an Arbitrator.
Merely delaying the rescinding of the Contract until 06.04.2018 does
not extend a period of limitation that had already long expired.
16.
The legal notice thus served on 09.06.2023 (Annexure
P-4), claiming the amount of Rs.96,66,354/- for the first time, at this
stage, would not as such extend the period of limitation. The
argument raised that the limitation period should be counted from
06.04.2018, is also without any basis under the peculiar facts and
circumstances of the case. Furthermore, the benefit of an extension
on account of the intervening COVID-19 period would not be
applicable to the present petitioner-Board. This is because the initial
order extending the limitation period took effect on 15.03.2020, by
which time the three-year limitation period had already been expired
and no active steps could have been taken. As noticed above, the
alleged promise to restart the work was made after 15.04.2016, and
therefore, falling back on the judgment passed by the Apex Court
would not help the petitioner-Board.
17.
In Vidya Droli’s case (supra), it has been held that the
Court, at the referral stage, can interfere only when it is manifested
that the claims are ex facie time-barred and dead, or there is no
subsisting dispute, and all other cases should be referred to the
Arbitral Tribunal for a decision on merits. The restricted and limited
review is to check and protect parties from being forced to arbitrate
when the matter is demonstrably “non-arbitrable” and to cut off the
deadwood.
18.
The said view has been consistently followed in the
judgments passed by the Apex Court in Bharat Sanchar Nigam
Limited and Another Vs. M/s. Nortel Networks India Private
Limited (2021) 5 SCC 798 and also in Civil Appeal No. 4320 of
2026, titled as State of West Bengal and Others Vs. M/s. B.B.M.
Enterprises, dated 09.04.2026, wherein the order of the High Court
which had restored a dead dispute after a period of twenty years,
was set-aside.
19.
In such circumstances, the judgment passed by the
Apex Court in Aditya Khaitan’s case (supra) is not applicable as
such, wherein it has been held that in the commercial suit, the 30days period for filing a written statement had expired on 08.03.2020,
and it was noticed that on 06.06.2020, the further condonable period
of 90 days also expired. In these circumstances, the appeal had
been allowed while extending the limitation period on account of the
orders passed earlier by the Apex Court. The said judgment thus
would not be of any help to the petitioner-Board, in view of the
discussions made above.
20.
Resultantly, the present petition is dismissed on account
of the total inaction and negligence on the part of the petitionerBoard. No effective steps were taken to serve even the basic notice
required to initiate the arbitration proceedings at the earliest. The
petitioner-Board thus cannot take advantage of its own inaction.
Furthermore, this Court lacks jurisdiction to appoint an Arbitrator or
to seek recovery of an amount that has long been barred by
limitation.
21.
Pending miscellaneous application(s) if any, shall also
stand disposed of.
(G.S. Sandhawalia)
Chief Justice
7th August, 2026
(Munish Thakur)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review