Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
LPA No.36 of 2026
Reserved on : 20.07.2026
Decided on : 24.07.2026
Uploaded on : 24.07.2026
...appellants.
HPSEBL and Anr.
Versus
Narender Kumar
…Respondent
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia, Chief Justice.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Bipin Chander Negi, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the appellants
:
Ms. Sunita Sharma, Sr. Advocate with Mr.
Aman Hansretta, Advocate.
For the respondent(s) :
Mr. Surender Sharma, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Sidharth Negi, Advocate.
Bipin Chander Negi, Judge
The present appeal has been preferred against the
impugned judgment dated 01.07.2025, passed in CWP
No.8150 of 2024, titled Narender Kumar versus HP
State Electricity Board Limited and another, vide which
the writ petition preferred by the present respondent, has
been allowed.
2.
The present appellants were the respondent in CWP
No.8150 of 2024, decided on 01.07.2025, wherefrom the
present appeal arises. The grievance raised therein by the writ
Whether the reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment? Yes
-2-
petitioner/present respondent was with respect to rejection of
a representation dated 02.05.2024 preferred by the writ
petitioner (Annexure P-3 page 85 of the paper book) vide
letter dated 30.05.2024 (Annexure P-4 page 86 of the present
paper book).
In the representation so filed, the writ
petitioner/present respondent had categorically asserted that
on revision of pay scales with effect from 01.01.2016, notified
vide office order No.1 dated 12.4.2022 (Annexure R-1 at page
105 of the paper book) the writ petitioner/present respondent
had exercised an option to come over to the revised pay scales
with effect from 01.01.2016 by a multiple factor of 2.59.
3.
Further, in the representation, it was categorically
asserted by the writ petitioner/present respondent that the
revised pay band was notified vide office order No.8 dated
08.07.2022 (Annexure R-V at page 130 of the paper book)for
some categories applicable with effect from 01.10.2012.After
issuance of the revised pay band, i.e., Annexure R-V, the writ
petitioner/present respondent contended that he failed to
exercise an option with respect to 15% hike from the date of
his promotion to the post of Senior Assistant on 01.05.2017
as, according to the writ petitioner/present respondent, the
-3-
order regarding revised pay band (Annexure R- V) was not in
his notice.
4.
As a consequence whereof, in the representation,
it has been submitted that juniors of the writ petitioner, who
had exercised option with respect to 15% hike as applicable
to them are drawing a higher salary. Hence, a consideration
of the case of the petitioner in the facts and circumstances
narrated
was
sought
in
order
to
enable
the
writ
petitioner/present respondent to exercise an option with
respect to 15% hike with effect from 01.05.2017, i.e., date of
promotion to the post of Senior Assistant.
5.
The aforesaid representation was rejected vide
letter dated 30.05.2024 (Annexure P-4 at page 86 of the paper
book). In the rejection, the reason for rejection cited was that
with respect to revised pay scale of employees with effect from
01.01.2016, vide office order bearing No. 1 dated 12.04.2022
(Annexure R -1, page 105 of the paper book) an opportunity
to exercise option had been given initially for two months in
terms of Clause 6 of Regulation dated 12.04.2022 (Annexure
R-1 page 105 of the paper book) and further extensions were
granted vide office order No.7 dated 08.06.2022, office order
No.10 dated 23.07.2022, and office order No.11 dated
-4-
15.09.2022 (collectively appended along with as Annexure-IV
from page 124 to 128 along with the reply filed by the present
appellants/respondents before the Writ Court). Besides the
aforesaid in the rejection letter it had been stated
that in
terms of order No.8 dated 08.07.2022 employees had been
given an opportunity to revise their option.
6.
In view thereof, it was submitted that time to
exercise option had been given up to 12.10.2022, which,
according to the present appellants/respondents before the
Writ Court, was sufficient time to exercise an option. In the
aforesaid backdrop, the representation (Annexure P-3 page 85
of the paper book) was rejected as having been submitted at
a belated stage.
7.
Heard counsel for the parties, perused the writ
record.
8.
The reasons contained in letter dated 30.05.2024
(Annexure P-4 page 86 of the present paper book) whereby
the representation preferred by the writ petitioner (Annexure
P-3 page 85 of the paper book) has been rejected needs to be
examined in light of the law laid down in Mohinder Singh Gill
v. Chief Election Commr., (1978) 1 SCC 405, relevant
extract whereof reads as under:
-5-
“8. The second equally relevant matter is that
when a statutory functionary makes an order
based on certain grounds, its validity must be
judged by the reasons so mentioned and cannot
be supplemented by fresh reasons in the shape
of affidavit or otherwise. Otherwise, an order bad
in the beginning may, by the time it comes to
court on account of a challenge, get validated by
additional grounds later brought out. We may
here draw attention to the observations of Bose,
J. in Gordhandas Bhanji:
“Public orders, publicly made, in exercise of a
statutory authority cannot be construed in the
light of explanations subsequently given by the
officer making the order of what he meant, or of
what was in his mind, or what he intended to do.
Public orders made by public authorities are
meant to have public effect and are intended to
affect the actings and conduct of those to whom
they are addressed and must be construed
objectively with reference to the language used
in the order itself.”
Orders are not like old wine becoming better as
they grow older.
9.
The Revised Pay Regulations of 2022 are dated
12.04.2022 (Annexure R-1, page 105 of the paper book). As
per the same, in terms of Clause 6 contained therein, an
employee was to exercise an option within a period of two
-6-
months from the date of issuance of these Regulations. In the
case at hand, the writ petitioner/present respondent had
exercised an option for pay fixation by a factor of 2.59. The
option
so
exercised
has
been
placed
on
record
as
Annexure R-2 (page 119 of the paper book), the same is dated
09.05.2022. Hence, from the same, it is evident that within a
period of two months from the issuance of Revised Pay
Regulations, 2022, dated 12.04.2022 (Annexure R-1), the writ
petitioner/present respondent had exercised his option in
terms of the aforesaid Regulations.
10.
Time for exercise of option in terms of order No.1
dated 12.04.2022 (Annexure R-I) was extended up to
12.08.2022,
vide
office
order
No.7
dated
08.06.2022
(Annexure R-IV at page 124 of the paper book). Thereafter an
Office Order No.10 dated 23.07.2022 (Annexure R-IV, page
126 of the paper book) was issued in continuation of Office
Order No.8 dated 08.07.2022 (Annexure R-V, at page 130 of
the
paper
book)
whereby
employees
were
given
an
opportunity to revise their option up to 12.08.2022 as notified
vide office order No.7 dated 08.06.2022. Other than the
aforesaid, in continuation of Office Order No.10, dated
23.07.2022 vide Office Order No.11 dated 15.09.2022
-7-
(Annexure R-IV, page 128 of the paper book), time for
exercising the option consequent upon Order No.8 dated
08.07.2022 (Annexure R-V, at page 130 of the paper book)
was further extended up to 12.10.2022.
11.
Order No.8 dated 08.07.2022 (Annexure R-V, at
page 130 of the paper book) mentioned in Office Order No.10,
dated 23.07.2022 and Office Order No.11 dated 15.09.2022
as correctly pointed out by the learned single judge has
nothing to do with Revised Pay Regulations, 2022, notified
vide Office Order No.1, dated 12.04.2022 (Annexure R-1). The
aforesaid extension of time, vide office order No.7 dated
08.06.2022 up to 12.08.2022 (Annexure R-IV at page 124 of
the paper book), Office Order No.10 dated 23.07.2022
(Annexure R-IV, page 126 of the paper book) and Office Order
No.11 dated 15.09.2022 (Annexure R-IV, page 126 of the
paper book) to exercise the option pertained to the Revised
Pay Regulations, 2022, notified vide Office Order No.1, dated
12.04.2022 (Annexure R-1). They had nothing to do with
Office Order dated 13.04.2022 (Annexure R-III, page 121 of
the paper book) which spoke of a 15% enhancement. Findings
so returned by the learned Single Judge cannot be faulted
-8-
with, and hence call for no interference in the appeal in this
respect.
12.
The appellants/respondents in the writ petition had
issued an Office Order dated 13.04.2022 (Annexure R-III,
page 121 of the paper book). A perusal of Clause 3 thereof
categorically reflects that in cases where an employee had
been placed in a higher pay scale between 01.01.2016 and the
date of notification pertaining to the Revised Pay Regulations,
2022 (Annexure R-1) on account of promotion, the employee
would have an option to switch over to the revised pay
structure from the date of such promotion. In terms of the
said Office Order, an employee could opt for a minimum
increase of 15% over and above the formulation of existing
basic pay + nominal dearness allowance calculated at the rate
of 113% in accordance with the instructions contained in the
Office
Order.
In
terms
of
the
said
order
necessary
amendments in the relevant rules were required to be got
done. No amended rules made in pursuance of Office Order
dated 13.04.2022 (Annexure R-III, page 121 of the paper
book) have been placed on record.
13.
The appellants/respondents before the Writ Court,
vide Office Order No.8 dated 08.07.2022 (Annexure R-V at
-9-
page 130 of the paper book), revised the pay band of its
employees with effect from 01.10.2012. In terms thereof, pay
was to be re-fixed with effect from 01.10.2012 to 31.12.2015
notionally, as per the revised pay structure contained therein;
however, 50% of the total arrears were to be given for the
period from 01.01.2016 to 12.04.2022.
14.
Vide
Office
Order
No.10
dated
23.07.2022
(Annexure R-IV, page 126 of the paper book) issued in
continuation of Office Order No.8 dated 08.07.2022 (Annexure
R-V, at page 130 of the paper book) employees were given an
opportunity to revise their option within the extended period
as notified vide Office Order No.7 dated 08.06.2022 (Annexure
R-IV, at page 124 of the paper book), wherein time had been
extended to exercise the option up to 12.08.2022 in pursuance
of the Revised Pay Regulations, 2022, notified vide Office
Order No.1 dated 12.04.2022 (Annexure R-1, page 105 of the
paper book). Similarly Office Order No.11 dated 15.09.2022
(Annexure R-IV, page 126 of the paper book) had been issued
extending time to exercise the option up to 12.10.2022.
15.
Hereinabove,
in
Office
Order
No.8
dated
08.07.2022 (Annexure R-V at page 130 of the paper book),
Office Order No.10 dated 23.07.2022 (Annexure R-IV, page
-10-
126 of the paper book) issued in continuation of Office Order
No.8 dated 08.07.2022 (Annexure R-V, at page 130 of the
paper book) and Office Order No.11 dated 15.09.2022
(Annexure R-IV, page 126 of the paper book) conspicuous by
absence is a mention of the Office Order dated 13.04.2022
(Annexure R-III, page 121 of the paper book), whereby the
option of a 15% hike with effect from the date of promotion if
any, made between 01.01.2016 and 12.04.2022, i.e., the date
of issuance of Office Order No.1, Revised Pay Regulations,
2022 had been granted.
16.
In the case at hand, it is an admitted position that
the writ petitioner/present respondent had been promoted to
the post of Senior Assistant on 01.03.2017. Hence, in the case
at hand, the writ petitioner/present respondent satisfied the
condition specified in Clause 3 of Office Order dated
13.04.2022 (Annexure R-III, at page 121 of the paper book),
whereby, in order to be eligible to avail the benefits of the said
Office Order, the employee should have been promoted
between 01.01.2016 and 12.04.2022 (i.e., issuance of Office
Order No. 1 pertaining to the Revised Pay Regulations, 2022).
17.
In the aforesaid backdrop, the learned Single Judge
has correctly come to the conclusion that, qua the issuance of
-11-
Office Order dated 13.04.2022, the writ petitioner/present
respondent was not aware, as the writ petitioner/present
respondent was posted in the field. It was only when the writ
petitioner/present respondent was posted at Headquarters in
January 2023 that the writ petitioner became aware of the
disparity in his pay vis-à-vis his juniors, which warranted
further scrutiny by the writ petitioner and on a further inquiry
made by the writ petitioner/present respondent it transpired
that the aforesaid pay disparity was attributable to the option
exercised by his juniors in terms of Office Order dated
13.04.2022.
It
is
in
the
said
background
that
the
representation dated 02-05-2024 i.e Annexure P-3 was made
by the writ petitioner.
18.
The Office Order dated 13.04.2022 (Annexure R-3,
Page 121 of the paper book) pertains to financial aspects and
has serious implications towards the monthly salary of the writ
petitioner/present respondent.
Merely stating that the said
letter was in the public domain, i.e., on the website of the
respondents,
was
not
enough
to
dispense
with
the
requirement of bringing it to the notice of the government
employee for whose benefit it had been issued.
Since the
order dated 13.04.2022 had serious financial implications for
-12-
the writ petitioner/present respondent, merely displaying it on
the website of the respondents would not discharge the
burden of publishing it through an accepted, reasonable mode.
The learned Single Judge has, therefore, correctly concluded
that in filing the writ petition wherefrom the impugned
judgement arises, there was no delay on the part of the writ
petitioner/present respondent as it was only filed once the writ
petitioner became aware of Office Order dated 13.04.2022.
19.
by the
In this respect, reliance has been correctly placed
learned
Single Judge
on
the judgment
dated
24.04.2025, passed in CWP No. 1558 of 2024, titled Satish
Kumar vs. State of H.P. & Ors. Reference can also be
gainfully made to Harla vs. State of Rajasthan AIR(1951)
SC 936. The relevant text whereof is reproduced hereinbelow:
“Natural justice requires that before a law can
become operative it must be promulgated or
published.
It
must
be
broadcast
in
some
recognisable way so that all men may know what
it is; or, at the very least, there must be some
special rule or regulation or customary channel
by or through which such knowledge can be
acquired with the exercise of due and reasonable
diligence. The thought that a decision reached in
the secret recesses of a chamber to which the
public have no access and to which even their
-13-
accredited representatives have no access and of
which they can normally know nothing, can
nevertheless
affect
their
lives,
liberty
and
property by the mere passing of a Resolution
without anything more is abhorrent to civilised
man. It shocks his conscience. In the absence
therefore of any law, rule, regulation or custom,
we hold that a law cannot come into being in this
way.
Promulgation
or
publication
of
some
reasonable sort is essential.”
20.
For the aforesaid reasons and those given in the
impugned judgement the present appeal is dismissed being
devoid of any merit. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if
any stands disposed of.
(G.S. Sandhawalia)
Chief Justice
24th July, 2026
(Gaurav Rawat)
(Bipin Chander Negi)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review