The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. Other than the aforesaid, once continuity of service had been awarded by the Labour Court and the same had attained finality, the respondent was definitely entitled to 50% back wages with effect from 2003, as has been held by the learned Single Judge. The case of the respondent was squarely covered by the judgment passed by Coordinate Division Bench in No.4228 of 2010, titled Ghanshyam Vs. HPSEBL and Anr., decided on 23.07.2010 (Annexure P-8).
17. Thus, we are of the considered view that the learned Single Judge has not erred in any manner in allowing the writ petition and we also do not find any plausible reason to take a different view. Therefore, the present appeal is dismissed being devoid of merit and the judgment passed by learned Single Judge is upheld. -10- The present appeal is disposed of in the aforesaid terms, so also the pending application(s), if any. (G.S. Sandhawalia) Chief Justice 09th April, 2026 (Gaurav Rawat) (Bipin Chander Negi) Judge
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
LPA No.35 of 2026
Reserved on : 06.04.2026
Decided on : 09.04.2026
Uploaded on : 09.04.2026
HPSEBL and Anr.
...Appellants.
Versus
Deep Ram
…Respondent.
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia, Chief Justice.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Bipin Chander Negi, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the appellants
:
Ms. Sunita Sharma, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Saurav Upadhay and Mr. Mohit,
Advocates.
Bipin Chander Negi, Judge
The present appeal has been preferred against the
impugned judgment dated 17.09.2025, passed by the learned
Single Judge in CWP No.2269 of 2023, titled Deep Ram
Vs. HPSEBL and Anr., whereby present appellants have been
directed to pay 50% wages to the present respondent in the
pay scale of Rs.2720-4775/- with effect from 15.09.2003 to
13.09.2009
and
full
wages
from
14.09.2009
in
the
corresponding revised scale.
2.
Brief facts giving rise to the case at hand are that
the respondent had been engaged by the appellant on a daily
Whether the reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment? Yes
-2-
wage basis as a Beldar on 21.08.1995. The respondent had
thereafter worked till 15.06.1996 without any break.
The
petitioner had completed 240 days in a calendar year. The
services of the respondent/petitioner were orally terminated
by appellant No.2 with effect from 15.06.1996 without
assigning any reason and without complying with the
mandatory provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act.
3.
In the aforesaid backdrop, the respondent along
with similarly situate submitted demand notices individually to
the Conciliation Officer, Solan.
thereof failed.
Conciliation proceedings
Finally, the below mentioned reference was
received in the Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour Court Shimla:“Whether the termination of services of S/Shri
Ranjeet Singh, S/o Chet Ram, Hari Singh, S/o
Shri Kami Ram, Narayan Singh, S/o Shri Bhoop
Singh, Rama Nand, S/o Shri Ddaya Ram, Om
Singh, S/o Shri Dewa Ram, Rajinder Singh S/o
Shri Bhoop Singh, Deep Ram, S/o Shri Budh
Ram, Khajan Singh, S/o Shri Kalu Ram w.e.f.
15.6.1996 after the completion of 240 days or
continuous service by the Executing Engineer, HP
State Electrical Board Division Rajgarh, District
Sirmaur, HP without complying the Section 25F/25N of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 is legal
and justified? If not, what relief of service
-3-
benefits and amount of compensation, the above
said eight workmen are entitled to?”
4.
pleadings.
In pursuance thereto, parties filed their respective
Based on the pleadings, following issues were
framed:1. Whether
the
termination of services of
petitioners by respondent No.1 w.e.f. 15.6.1996
is violative of Sections 25-F/25-N of the Industrial
Disputes Act, 1947? OPP….
2. Whether reference is not maintainable. OPR…
3. Whether the petition suffers from delay and
laches and if so its effect? OPR..
4. Whether the petitioners had obtained the job
as alleged? OPR…
5. Relief.
5.
Insofar as the respondent/petitioner is concerned,
the Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour Court, Shimla vide its
judgment dated 12.08.2008, held that since the respondent
had completed 240 working days in the calendar year
preceding his termination, as such the disengagement of the
respondent by appellant No.2 was in violation of Section 25-F
of the Industrial Disputes Act. Other than the aforesaid, the
petition filed by the respondent before the Industrial Tribunal
-4-
(Labour Court) was held to be maintainable, insofar as delay
and laches is concerned, by placing reliance on the judgment
of the Apex Court in Ajayab Singh Vs. Sirhind Cooperative
Marketing-cum-Processing Service Society Limited and
Anr. reported in (1999) 6 SC 82, wherein it was held that
there is no limitation under the Industrial Disputes Act. The
petition filed by the respondent before the Labour Court was
held to be not barred by delay and latches. On the issue of
abandonment raised by the appellants before the Labour
Court, since no evidence had been led by the appellants,
therefore, the same was decided against the appellants.
7.
Feeling aggrieved of the same, CWP No.2037 of
2008 was preferred by the present appellants. The same was
dismissed by the learned Single Judge of this Court on
16.08.2012.
Against the aforesaid dismissal, two LPAs
bearing No.43 and 44 of 2013 had been preferred. The same
were decided on 30.04.2014.
The appeal preferred by the
appellants was allowed on the ground that though limitation is
not applicable to a Reference made under the Industrial
Disputes Act, however, delay in raising an industrial dispute is
definitely an important circumstance, which the Labour Court
must keep in view at the time of exercise of discretion
-5-
irrespective of whether or not such objection has been raised
by the other side.
8.
Other than the aforesaid, the Division Bench which
decided the LPAs, was of the view that question as to whether
the petitioner had worked for more than 240 days or not, had
not been gone into, therefore, re-engagement ordered by the
Labour Court was held to be unjustified.
In the aforesaid
backdrop, the Award dated 12.08.2008, in Reference No.151
of 2001, titled Narayan Singh and Ors. Vs. The HPSEBL and
Ors. (Wherein the respondent was one of the petitioners) was
quashed and set aside and the matter was remanded back to
the Tribunal for a fresh adjudication.
9.
Post-remand on 02.06.2014, the Reference No.151
of 2001
previously instituted on 09.08.2001, was re-
registered.
The same was decided on 14.08.2014.
On
remand, the Labour Court post consideration of the material
on record, concluded that the respondent/petitioner had
completed more than 240 working days in a calendar year
preceding his termination.
Further it was held that the
provisions of Section 25F of the Industrial Disputes Act had
not been complied with as neither one month notice had been
-6-
issued to the respondent in writing nor in lieu of such notice
wages for the period of notice had been paid, hence, the
disengagement of the respondent was held to be illegal and
unjustified. On the issue of delay, it was held that there was
no delay on the part of the respondent in raising the claim in
the case at hand.
The plea of abandonment raised by the
present appellants was found to be bereft of any merit, as it
remained unsubstantiated.
10.
The respondent was held entitled to be reinstated
in service, forthwith with seniority, continuity from the date of
his illegal retrenchment i.e. 15.6.1996, along with back wages
@ 50%.
11.
In the aforesaid backdrop, respondent was given
work charge status on the post of T-Mate on 16.07.2015.
Thereafter, he was brought on the regular cadre of T-Mate on
19.03.2018.
12.
In the case at hand the respondent had joined as a
Beldar on daily wage basis on 21.08.1995, and had been
illegally terminated on 15.06.1996. Moreso keeping in view
the judgment of the Labour Court dated 14.08.2014, whereby
the respondent had been granted seniority with continuity
-7-
along with back wages at the rate of 50% from the date of
illegal retrenchment i.e. 15.06.1996, the respondent claimed
to have completed 8 years of service on 21.08.2003, hence,
claimed regularization/conferment of work charge status from
the said date, in view of the regularization policy along with
all regular consequential benefits.
13.
In the aforesaid facts and attending circumstances,
the respondent preferred an Original Application with the
erstwhile Tribunal bearing OA No.3400 of 2018 seeking
direction
of
21.08.2003
regularization/work
as
per
the
charge
status
from
Regularization
Policy
dated
08.07.1999. The aforesaid OA was disposed of by the learned
Tribunal on 12.03.2019 with a direction to the appellants to
extend
the
benefits
of
CWP
No.4228
of
2010,
titled
Ghanshyam Vs. HPSEBL, to the petitioner being similarly
situate.
14.
In pursuance to the aforesaid direction of the
erstwhile
Tribunal,
an
office
order
dated
12.07.2019
(Annexure P-9) was passed by the appellants, whereby the
work charge status was granted to the respondent w.e.f.
15.09.2003 to 15.07.2015 on a notional basis.
In the
-8-
aforesaid backdrop, petition bearing CWP No.2269 of 2023,
titled Deep Ram Vs. HPSEBL and Anr. was filed by the
present respondent, wherein the main grievance of the
respondent was that the benefit of the Award dated
14.08.2014, in the matter of continuity of service had not been
granted while considering the claim of the respondent for
conferment of work charge status, especially when the
Industrial Tribunal had granted continuity of service in the
Award dated 14.08.2014 and since the Award had become
final, therefore, the respondent was entitled to count his
service for the purpose of conferment of work charge status.
In this respect attention is invited to a judgment of a
Coordinate Division Bench, passed in CWP No.4228 of 2010,
titled Ghanshyam Vs. HPSEBL and Anr., decided on
23.07.2010, wherein the period for which the workmen had
been kept out of work, had been ordered to be counted on
account of continuity in service, granted by the Industrial
Tribunal.
15.
The contention of “No Work No Pay” has been
correctly rejected by the learned Single Judge in the facts of
the case at hand. In this respect, it would be appropriate to
refer to the authoritative pronouncement of the Apex Court in
-9-
Union of India and Ors. Vs. K.V. Jankiraman and Others
(1991) 4 SCC 109. The relevant extract reads as follow:“25………The normal rule of “no work no pay” is
not applicable to cases such as the present one
where the employee although he is willing to work
is kept away from work by the authorities for no
fault of his……….”
16.
Other than the aforesaid, once continuity of service
had been awarded by the Labour Court and the same had
attained finality, the respondent was definitely entitled to 50%
back wages with effect from 2003, as has been held by the
learned Single Judge.
The case of the respondent was
squarely covered by the judgment passed by Coordinate
Division
Bench
in
CWP
No.4228
of
2010,
titled
Ghanshyam Vs. HPSEBL and Anr., decided on 23.07.2010
(Annexure P-8).
17.
Thus, we are of the considered view that the
learned Single Judge has not erred in any manner in allowing
the writ petition and we also do not find any plausible reason
to take a different view.
Therefore, the present appeal is
dismissed being devoid of merit and the judgment passed by
learned Single Judge is upheld.
-10-
The present appeal is disposed of in the aforesaid
terms, so also the pending application(s), if any.
(G.S. Sandhawalia)
Chief Justice
09th April, 2026
(Gaurav Rawat)
(Bipin Chander Negi)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review