Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
Cr.MP(M) No.2823 of 2025
a/w Cr.MP(M) No.2824/25
Decided on : 27.02.2026
1. Cr.MP(M) No.2823 of 2025
Aryan
...Petitioner
Versus
The State of HP
…Respondent.
2. Cr.MP(M) No.2824 of 2025
Hoshiyar Singh
...Petitioner
Versus
The State of HP
…Respondent.
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Bipin Chander Negi, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the petitioners
:
M/s Prem Chand Verma, Aakash Thakur and
Varun Thakur, Advocates.
For the respondent
:
Mr. Pranay Pratap Singh, Additional
Advocate
General,
for
the
respondent/State.
Bipin Chander Negi, Judge (Oral)
The present bail petitions have been filed under
Section 483 of the BNSS for grant of regular bail, in FIR No.14
of 2024, dated 21.03.2024, registered at Police Station,
Mcleodganj, District Kangra, H.P., under Sections 302, 323,
147 and 149 of the Indian Penal Code.
Whether the reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment? Yes
-2-
2.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties.
Perused the record and the status report.
3.
In the case at hand, a telephonic information was
received in Police Station Mcleodganj from the hospital that an
individual belonging to the State of Punjab has been brought
to the hospital and he has dead. On receiving the aforesaid
information,
the
police
rushed
to
the
Zonal
Hospital,
Dharamshala. The informant in the case at hand is one
Harmanpreet Singh, who got recorded his statement under
Section 154 Cr.PC. As per the informant on 20.03.2024, he
along with his elder brother Navdeep Singh, brother-in-law
Gagandeep Singh and their friend Sandeep Awan had come to
Mcleodganj in vehicle bearing No. PB-36H-7127.
4.
At Mcleodganj, they had stayed at hotel named OM
Palace at Bhagsunag. On 21.03.2024 for having breakfast,
they had gone Aryan Coffee Shop. When they were sitting
inside the coffee shop, the owner of the shop had asked them
to refrain from consuming alcohol in his coffee shop.
Informant along with others had informed the coffee shop
owner (Hoshiar Singh/bail petitioner in Cr.MP(M) No.2824/25)
that they would not be consuming alcohol in the morning.
-3-
5.
Upon this, an altercation took place inside the
coffee shop. While the altercation was taken place inside
coffee shop, the son of the coffee shop owner (Aryan/bail
petitioner in Cr.MP(M) No.2823/25) also arrived on the spot.
The father, son duo pushed the informant along with Navdeep,
Gagandeep and Sanjeev Avan outside the coffee shop. Once
they were outside the coffee shop, Hoshiar Singh owner of the
coffee shop loudly insinuated against the aforesaid four
individuals.
6.
On hearing Hoshiar Singh (bail petitioner), coffee
shop owner shouting at the aforesaid four individuals, his
relatives Ankush Kumar @ Garati, Ankush Kapoor, Kunal
Neharia @ Sagar, Vicky, taxi operator Raman Kumar @ Banta
and one Ajay Kumar rushed towards the coffee shop. Ajay
Kumar accused, Ankush Kumar @ Garati, Hoshiar Singh and
accused Aryan (both bail petitioners) got hold of deceased
Navdeep Singh outside the coffee shop
7.
The other individuals including Kunal Nehria @
Sagar started beating Harmanpreet Singh, Gagandeep Singh,
Sanjeev Ayan and pushed them towards rain shed, in the
ensuing scuffle.
As per the own case of the prosecution,
insofar as the scuffle with the deceased Navdeep Singh is
-4-
concerned, only Ankush Kumar @ Garati, Hoshiar Singh (bail
petitioner) and Aryan (bail petitioner) of the coffee shop owner
are said to have been involved.
8.
Investigation in the case at hand is complete.
Challan stands filed on 06.06.2024. No recoveries are to be
effected from the petitioner.
9.
The Supreme Court in Siddharam Satlingappa
Mhetre v. State of Maharashtra, (2011) 1 SCC 694 has
observed that personal liberty of an individual is a precious
fundamental right and should not be curtailed unless it is
imperative in the given facts and circumstances.
10.
No doubt, the allegations are serious but these are
mere allegations and at this stage, presumption of innocence
attaches to the accused. In Prabhakar Tewari v. State of
Uttar Pradesh and Another, (2020) 11 SCC 648, the
Supreme Court held that seriousness of allegations cannot be
the sole factor to deny bail to an accused. The same view was
taken by the Delhi High Court in Navendu Babbar v. State
of NCT of Delhi, 2020 SCC OnLine Del 2345, where it was
observed that the offence is no doubt grave and serious but
that cannot by itself be a factor to decline bail.
-5-
11.
No doubt, the allegations against the applicants are
serious but there is merit in the contention that the applicants
have been incarcerated since 22.03.2024. In Prabhakar
Tewari (supra), the Supreme Court has held that gravity of
the offence cannot be the sole basis for denial of bail. In
Supreme Court Legal Aid Committee Representing
Undertrial Prisoners v. Union of India and Others,
(1994) 6 SCC 731, the Supreme Court held that undertrials
cannot be detained in jail indefinitely pending trial. In State
of Rajasthan, Jaipur v. Balchand alias Baliay, (1977) 4
SCC 308, the Supreme Court held as under :“2. The basic rule may perhaps be tersely put
as bail, not jail, except where there are
circumstances
suggestive
of
fleeing
from
justice or thwarting the course of justice or
creating
other
troubles
in
the
shape
of
repeating offences or intimidating witnesses
and the like, by the petitioner who seeks
enlargement on bail from the Court. We do not
intend to be exhaustive but only illustrative.”
12.
In Puneet Rana v. State NCT of Delhi, SLP
(Crl.) No. 1882/2022, decided on 19.05.2022, the Supreme
Court granted bail to the Petitioner charged for offences
punishable under Sections 302/356/379/323/506/34 IPC
-6-
looking to the fact that material witnesses had been examined
and 23 more witnesses were remaining to be examined and
there was no likelihood of trial being completed soon. In
Praveen Rathore v. State of Rajasthan and Another,
2023 SCC OnLine SC 1268, the Supreme Court granted bail
to the accused charged under Sections 302/120B IPC
considering the long custody of four and half years and the
possibility that the trial was not likely to conclude soon and
relevant passage is as follows:“5. It is not in dispute that the petitioner, by
now, has undergone more than four and a half
years' of sentence. The prosecution intends to
examine 76 witnesses, out of whom 53 have
already deposed. All the crucial witnesses have
already been examined. The instant case was
adjourned on few occasions to enable the
prosecution to examine Chauthmal Kashyap
and Manohar Rathore, who were stated to be
the vital witnesses. Their deposition is also
complete.”
16.
It is argued that speedy trial is guaranteed to an
accused under the Constitution of India and it would be unfair
if Applicant continues under incarceration awaiting the
conclusion of trial which is going to take years from now
looking at the number of witnesses remaining to be examined
-7-
on behalf of the prosecution. In Mukesh Kumar v. State of
Rajasthan and Anr., Special Leave to Appeal (Crl.) No.
11714/2022, decided on 15.02.2023, the Supreme Court
granted bail to the Petitioner on the ground that he had been
in custody for more than 14 months and since crucial
witnesses had been examined, there was no likelihood of
tampering with evidence.
17.
In the case at hand, there are total 36 prosecution
witnesses. Out of which, 15 witnesses were examined and 8
witnesses have to be examined on 30/31.03.2026. Conclusion
of trial would take some time.
18.
In Sanjay Chandra v. Central Bureau of
Investigation, (2012) 1 SCC 40, the Supreme Court
observed that object of bail is to secure appearance of the
accused person at his trial and to receive punishment if
convicted and is neither punitive nor preventive.
19.
In Sanjay Chandra (supra), the Supreme Court
observed as under:“21. In bail applications, generally, it has been
laid down from the earliest times that the
object of bail is to secure the appearance of the
accused person at his trial by reasonable
amount of bail. The object of bail is neither
punitive nor preventative. Deprivation of liberty
-8-
must be considered a punishment, unless it is
required to ensure that an accused person will
stand his trial when called upon. The courts
owe more than verbal respect to the principle
that punishment begins after conviction, and
that every man is deemed to be innocent until
duly tried and duly found guilty.
22. From the earliest times, it was appreciated
that detention in custody pending completion
of trial could be a cause of great hardship. From
time to time, necessity demands that some
unconvicted persons should be held in custody
pending trial to secure their attendance at the
trial but in such cases, “necessity” is the
operative test. In this country, it would be quite
contrary to the concept of personal liberty
enshrined in the Constitution that any person
should be punished in respect of any matter,
upon which, he has not been convicted or that
in any circumstances, he should be deprived of
his liberty upon only the belief that he will
tamper with the witnesses if left at liberty, save
in the most extraordinary circumstances.
23. Apart from the question of prevention being
the object of refusal of bail, one must not lose
sight of the fact that any imprisonment before
conviction has a substantial punitive content
and it would be improper for any court to refuse
bail as a mark of disapproval of former conduct
whether the accused has been convicted for it
or not or to refuse bail to an unconvicted
person for the purpose of giving him a taste of
imprisonment as a lesson.”
-9-
In Kalyan Chandra Sarkar v. Rajesh Ranjan
20.
alias pappu yadav and Another, (2004) 7 SCC 528, the
Supreme Court observed that though at the stage of granting
bail
detailed
examination
of
evidence
and
elaborate
documentation of the merits of the case need not be
undertaken, there is a need to undertake an exercise of
looking into the circumstances and factors such as nature of
accusation, severity of punishment in case of conviction,
nature of supporting evidence, reasonable apprehension of
tampering with evidence or apprehension of threat to the
complainant and prima facie satisfaction of the Court, in
support of the charge.
In this backdrop, only for a limited
purpose of deciding these bail petitions, the Court has
examined the testimonies of eye-witnesses recorded in the
case at hand.
21.
Hence, after going through the material available
on record and considering the overall facts and circumstances
of the case, this Court finds that the present is a fit case where
judicial discretion to admit the petitioners on bail is required
to
be
exercised
in
their
favour.
Accordingly,
the
bail
applications are allowed and it is ordered that the petitioners,
-10-
who have been arrested by the police, in FIR No.14 of 2024,
dated
21.03.2024,
registered
at
Police
Station,
Mcleodganj, District Kangra, H.P., under Sections 302,
323, 147 and 149 of the Indian Penal Code, shall be
forthwith released on bail, subject to their furnishing personal
bonds to the tune of Rs.1,00,000/- [Rupees one lac each] with
one local surety each in the like amount, to the satisfaction of
learned trial Court. This bail order is subject, however, to the
following conditions:-.
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
(v)
(vi)
Petitioners shall attend the trial Court on each and
every date of hearing and if prevented by any reason
to do so, seek exemption from appearance by filing
appropriate application;
Petitioners shall not tamper with the evidence or
hamper the investigation
in
any
manner
whatsoever;
Petitioners will not leave India without prior
permission of the Court;
Petitioners shall not make any inducement, threat or
promise, directly or indirectly, to the victim and
Investigating Officer or any person acquainted with
the facts of the case to dissuade him/her from
disclosing such facts to the Court or any Police
Officer;
Petitioners shall inform the Station House Officer of
the concerned police station about their place of
residence during bail and trial. Any change in the
same shall also be communicated within two weeks
thereafter. Petitioners shall furnish details of their
Aadhar Cards, Telephone Numbers, Emails, PAN
Cards, Bank Account Numbers, if any; &
It is made clear that in case petitioners are arraigned
as an accused, in future, in any FIR, then their bail is
liable to be cancelled. It is open for the Investigating
Agency to move appropriate application in that
regard.
-11-
22.
Needless to say that the Investigating agency shall
be at liberty to move this Court for cancellation of the bail, if
any of the aforesaid conditions are violated by the petitioners.
23.
Be it stated that any expression of opinion given in
this order does not mean an expression of opinion on the
merits of the case and the trial Court will not be influenced by
any observations made therein.
24.
The Registry is directed to forward a soft copy of
the bail order to the Superintendent, District Jail Kangra,
District Kangra, H.P., through email, with a direction to enter
the date of grant of bail in the e-prison software.
25.
In case, the petitioners are not released within a
period of seven days from the date of grant of bail, the
Superintendent, , District Jail Kangra, District Kangra, H.P. is
directed to inform this fact to the Secretary, DLSA, Kangra.
The Superintendent, District Jail Kangra, District Kangra, H.P.,
is further directed that if the petitioners fail to furnish the bail
bonds, as per the order passed by this Court, within a period
of one month from today, the said fact be submitted to this
Court.
26.
The petitions stand accordingly disposed of. A copy
of this order be sent to the Superintendent, District Jail
-12-
Kangra, District Kangra, H.P. and the learned trial Court by
FASTER.
27.
A downloaded copy of this order shall be accepted
by the learned Trial Court while accepting the bail bonds from
the petitioner and in case, said Court intends to ascertain the
veracity of the downloaded copy of the order presented to it,
same may be ascertained from the official website of this
Court.
27th February, 2026
(Gaurav Rawat)
GAURAV
SINGH
DN: C=IN, O=HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL
PRADESH SHIMLA,
Phone=b615aae6b839bd7695619d205a064
9faa3f10ee78fd5fc7d356ef93266e0ead9,
PostalCode=171001, S=Himachal Pradesh,
SERIALNUMBER=97f5851e94d1ce4a9d9b2
419311e660ac9051e6298a507d8e42c11fe7
7a95002, CN=GAURAV SINGH
Reason: I am the author of this document
Location:
Date: 2026-02-27 18:35:23
(Bipin Chander Negi)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review