Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment delivered on: 09.01.2026
+
C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 85/2021
HOLY COW FOUNDATION
.....Petitioner
versus
PATANJALI GRAMODYOG NYAS (TRUST)
AND ORS.
.....Respondents
Advocates who appeared in this case
For the Petitioner
:
Ms. Subhashree Sil, Mr. Kuber
Mahajan & Mr. Abhay Aren,
Advocates.
For the Respondents
:
Mr. Junaid Alam, Mr. Nishant Mahtta,
Mr. S. Nitin & Mr. Nitish Singh,
Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TEJAS KARIA
JUDGMENT
TEJAS KARIA, J
1.
This is a Rectification Petition under Section 57 of the Trade Marks
Act, 1999 (“Act”) for cancellation / removal / rectification of the registered
Trade Mark, ‘PATANJALI GONYLE FLOOR CLEANER’ /
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
19:11:41
C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 85/2021
’ (“Impugned Mark”) under Registration No.
‘
3094452 in Class 05 in the name of the Respondents from the Register of
Trade Marks (“Register”).
FACTUAL MATRIX
2.
The Petitioner is a non-governmental organization which aims at the
protection and promotion of the welfare of the indigenous cows in India. The
Petitioner assists the gaushalas / gausadans to reach a level of sustainability
where they can provide good lives to the animals with good management
practices.
3.
In the year 2013, the Petitioner, in its endeavor to make gaushalas self-
sustainable, developed a floor cleaning product derived from cow urine
(“Petitioner’s Goods”). The product was named as ‘GAUNYLE’
(“Petitioner’s Mark”) as it is a substitute to the standardly used phenyl, but
is made from cow urine.
4.
The Petitioner applied for, and obtained registration for the Petitioner’s
Mark. The Petitioner’s Mark was applied under Trade Mark Application No.
3133397 for the goods falling under Class 05. The details of the registration
of the Petitioner’s Mark is set out hereunder:
Mark
Number Application
GAUNYLE 3133397
User
Date
claimed
18.12.2015
12.12.2013
Class
Goods
Biodegradable
disinfectants
(phenyl),
Ayurvedic and medicinal
preparations, Antiseptic
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
19:11:41
C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 85/2021
and
antibacterial
preparations,
Germicides, preparations
and
substances
for
neutralizing, Controlling
or reducing allergens,
Medicated skin and hair
care
preparations,
Mosquito
repellent,
Toiletries, cosmetic.
5.
It came to the Petitioner’s attention from market sources that
Respondent No. 1 along with Respondent No. 2 are manufacturing and selling
floor cleaners, also made of cow urine, under the Impugned Mark. The
Petitioner issued a legal notice dated 14.01.2017 (“Legal Notice”) to the
Respondents inter alia calling upon the Respondents to cease and desist from
making any representations or claims by using the Impugned Mark in any
form. The Petitioner had brought to the notice of the Respondent that the
adoption sought to be made by the Respondent is identical to the Petitioner’s
Mark and that the same is being done with a clear intention of trading upon
the goodwill of the Petitioner.
6.
The Respondents issued a reply dated 15.03.2017 (“Reply”) to the
Legal Notice. In the Reply, the Respondents claimed to use the Impugned
Mark since 2011 and that the Impugned Mark is phonetically / visually
different from the Petitioner’s Mark. Further, the Respondents had filed Trade
Mark Applications Nos. 3094452 and 3037168 for the Impugned Mark under
Classes 05 and 03, respectively. Additionally, the Petitioner discovered that
the Impugned Mark had proceeded for registration on 29.12.2016.
7.
Being aggrieved by the registration of the Impugned Mark, the
Petitioner has filed the present Rectification Petition for cancellation /
rectification / removal of the Impugned Mark from the Register.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
19:11:41
C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 85/2021
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER:
8.
The learned Counsel for the Petitioner submitted that:
8.1.
The Impugned Mark deserves to be rectified by removing the
same from the Register on the grounds that the same was applied
for and registered without any sufficient cause and is,
accordingly, wrongly remaining on the Register, under Section
57 of the Act.
8.2.
The Respondents were and continues to be clearly aware of the
Petitioner’s Mark. The Petitioner is the prior adopter and user of
the Petitioner’s Mark since 2013. The Impugned Mark was
applied for by Respondent No. 1 with a clear mala fide intention
to take advantage of the tremendous reputation of the Petitioner’s
Mark. Respondent No. 1 has applied for and registered the
Impugned Mark, which is identical to the Petitioner’s Mark. The
Impugned Mark has been registered for goods identical to those
under the Petitioner’s Mark, thereby only adding confusion and
deception amongst the consuming trade and public.
8.3.
The Impugned Mark under Trade Mark Application No. 3094452
dated 21.08.2015 under Class 05 is registered in the name of
Respondent No. 1 with claim of usage from 01.04.2015. The
details of the registration of the Impugned Mark are set out
hereunder:
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
19:11:41
C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 85/2021
TM No.
Trade Mark
Class
3094452
Class
Claim of
description
usage
Sanitary
Status
01.04.2015 Registered
Preparations
(PATANJALI
GONYLE
FLOOR CLEANER
Device Mark)
8.4.
Due to the immense beneficial properties of the Petitioner’s
Goods under the Petitioner’s Mark, the Union Cabinet Minister
has widely advocated its use not only for the general public, but
also on a large scale basis in the government offices in New
Delhi.
8.5.
After two years of commercial success of the Petitioner’s Goods,
the Respondents have subsequently adopted in 2015 a visually,
structurally and phonetically identical Impugned Mark for
identical goods i.e., floor cleaners made of cow urine, with that
of the Petitioner’s Mark, trading over the goodwill and reputation
of the Petitioner’s Mark. The Petitioner’s Mark and the
Impugned Mark are not only phonetically similar, but
phonetically identical.
8.6.
In Amritdhara Pharmacy v. Satya Deo Gupta, 1962 SCC
OnLine SC 13 and K.R. Chinna Krishan Chettiar v. Shri Ambal
and Co., Madras and Anr., (1969) 2 SCC 131, the Supreme
Court has restrained usage of ‘phonetically similar’ infringing
mark for causing deception and confusion amongst public.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
19:11:41
C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 85/2021
8.7.
The Respondents in a statement for a media article dated
31.12.2015 has claimed that out of its 100 products, only 5 have
cow urine in it. The products so named by the Respondents are:
(i) Godhan Ark; (ii) SanjivaniVati; (iii) Panchgavya Soap; (iv)
Kayakalp Oil; and (v) Shudhi Phenyal. Hence, on 31.12.2015,
the Respondents were not using the Impugned Mark for any of
its products that contain cow urine. The fact that the Respondents
have not provided any plausible explanation for adopting the
Impugned Mark for identical goods in 2015 when they already
had one floor cleaner product using cow urine under the brand
‘Shudhi Phenyal’ till 31.12.2015, reinforces the mala fide on part
of the Respondents.
8.8.
Renowned publishing houses in media articles while reporting in
respect to Impugned Mark, by mistake has written the spelling
as ‘GAUNYLE’ which is the Petitioner’s Mark, evincing actual
confusion amongst public which is giving impression that the
Respondents’ goods are being associated with the Petitioner’s
Mark.
8.9.
The continued existence of the Impugned Mark in the Register,
falls within the purview of the absolute ground of refusal of
registration under Sections 9(2)(a) and 11(1)(a) of the Act. This
Court has rectified registered Trade Marks on the ground of
being subsequent and phonetically similar to the prior Trade
Marks in several cases. The following Marks were held to be
similar:
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
19:11:41
C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 85/2021
a. ‘OTRINIR’ v. ‘OTRIVIN’ / ‘OTRINOZ’ – GSK Consumer
Healthcare S.A. v. Celebrity Biopharma Ltd., 2024 SCC
OnLine Del 2572
b. ‘PBROS’ (device mark) v. ‘FYBROS’ – Fybros Electric Pvt.
Ltd. v. Mukesh Singh & Anr., 2023 SCC OnLine Del 2948
c. ‘NJBROS’ v. ‘FYBROS’ – Fybros Electric (P) Ltd. v. Vasu
Dev Gupta Trading as Vasu Electronics, 2023 SCC OnLine
Del 3179
8.10. Under Section 34 of the Act, rights of the prior user (Petitioner)
would take precedence over subsequent registration of the
Respondents. Due to the non-substantive clause of the Section
34 of the Act therefore, Section 34 of the Act needs to be read
with Sections 9(2)(a) and Section 11(1)(a) of the Act (under
which the Petitioner is seeking rectification of the Impugned
Mark), including the definition of ‘earlier trademark’ as provided
as the explanation to Section 11(4) of the Act. The following
judgments were relied upon while making the above submission:
a. S. Syed Mohideen v. P. Sulochana Bai, (2016) 2 SCC 683
b. Neon Laboratories Ltd. v. Medical Technologies Ltd. and
Ors., (2016) 2 SCC 672
c. Inder Raj Sahni Proprietor M/s Sahni Cosmetics v. Neha
Herbals Private Limited and Another, 2025 SCC OnLine
Del 3341
8.11. In Kia Wang v. Registrar of Trademarks and Anr., 2023 SCC
OnLine Del 5844, this Court held that even though the
petitioner’s mark therein did not qualify as ‘earlier mark’ under
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
19:11:41
C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 85/2021
Section 11 of the Act, due to prior usage of the petitioner, the
impugned mark therein was rectified by the Co-ordinate Bench
of this Court.
8.12. The Respondents have filed the Trade Mark Application No.
3469185 for the Impugned Mark on the basis of which the
Respondents have claimed to be prior user only on 30.01.2017
with false claim of usage since 2008. The Respondents have
failed to file a single document of proof of usage of the Impugned
Mark prior to 2013 leaving apart proof of usage since 2008.
8.13. Accordingly, the present Rectification Petition be allowed and
the registration of the Impugned Mark shall be removed from the
Register.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENTS
9.
The learned Counsel for the Respondents submitted that:
9.1.
Respondent No. 1, Patanjali Gramodyog Nyas, was established
on 05.01.2011, for the development of small scale and cottage
industries of villages. Respondent No. 1 was established with the
objective to establish village industry at the local level by using
available resources in the village in consonance with mutual
knowledge to convert art and skill into an industry.
9.2.
Respondent No. 1 maintains an active online presence.
Information pertaining to Respondent No. 1, their brands and
products is readily accessible via their official website at
http://patanjaligamodhyognyas.com/. Respondent No. 1 is also
active in promoting its products through various media platforms
such as Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter in addition to the
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
19:11:41
C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 85/2021
traditional forms of advertisement and publicity such as print
media and word of mouth.
9.3.
Respondent No. 2, Patanjali Ayurved Limited, is a company duly
incorporated and registered under the Companies Act, 1956 on
13.01.2006 with the vision of fostering rural and urban
development by synthesizing the power of yoga and ayurved.
Respondent No. 2 offers a gamut of goods in the market
including but not limited to ayurvedic medicines and natural
personal care, health, and food products as well as associated
services. Information pertaining to Respondent No. 2, their
brands and products is readily accessible via their official
website
at
http://patanjaliayuwed.org/
and
https://www.patanjaliayuwed.net/.
9.4.
Respondent No. 2’s market reputation can be further gauged
from their pan-India sales figures. The sales turnover of
Respondent No. 2’s business for the Financial Year (“FY”) 20202021 was ₹ 9,783 crores. Respondent No. 2 expends significant
capital and labor each year towards promotion and advertisement
of its goods and services throughout India. The advertisement
and sales promotional expenditure incurred by Respondent No.
2 for FY 2021-2022 was ₹ 31,048 lakhs.
9.5.
The goods under the Impugned Mark have significant sale
figures as can be seen from the sales turnover for FY 2023-2024,
that was ₹ 68,45,473/-. In order to establish goodwill in a product
under a particular mark, it is essential to substantiate the claim
through documentary evidence such as sale figures of the goods
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
19:11:41
C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 85/2021
sold under the mark, along with the expenditure incurred on
advertisement and promotion. Such documents must be duly
verified by a Chartered Accountant; otherwise, they are
inadmissible and lack evidentiary value. Reliance was placed
upon the decision in Brihan Karan Sugar Syndicate Private
Limited v. Yashwantrao Mohite Krushna Sahakari Sakhar
Karkhana, (2024) 2 SCC 577.
9.6.
The Impugned Mark has been coined by Respondent No. 2 and
Respondent No. 2 is the first adopter and user of the Impugned
Mark using it since the year 2008. Respondent No. 2 is the
registered proprietor of the Impugned Mark and its variants and
formatives under Classes 03, 05, 21 and 35. Respondent No. 1 is
the registered proprietor of the Impugned Mark under Trade
Mark Application No. 3153827 under Class 01.
9.7.
The Respondents have superior right over the Impugned Mark
under both the statute and common law being the prior user and
registered proprietor of the same using it since 2008. The
Petitioner is the subsequent adopter and user of the Petitioner’s
Mark claiming user since 2013. The Petitioner is also the
subsequent applicant of the Trade Mark Application No.
3133397 applied on 18.12.2015.
9.8.
Section 11 of the Act applies only where the disputed Mark is
used subsequent to an earlier Trade Mark. The common thread
running through Sections 11(1) and 11(2) of the Act is that both
provisions require the identity or similarity of the impugned
mark with an earlier Trade Mark. Once it is established that the
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
19:11:41
C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 85/2021
petitioner is not an earlier trade mark by way of registration of
trade mark application, the applicability of Section 11 of the Act
stands extinguished and becomes infructuous. Reliance was
placed in the decision of Kia Wang (supra) while making the
above submission.
9.9.
The Impugned Mark includes the Respondents’ House Mark,
‘PATANJALI’ which has been declared as a well-known Mark
by the Registrar of Trade Marks. Thus, usage of the Impugned
Mark will not cause confusion or deception among the public,
consumers, and members of the trade as to origin of the goods.
Dissimilarity between the Marks may even be established
through the presence of the company’s name or house mark on
the packaging along with the impugned mark. The Respondents’
House Mark is well-known; therefore, any suffix, prefix, or even
conjunction with the Respondents’ well-known House Mark,
‘PATANJALI’ is more than sufficient to demonstrate that the
Impugned Mark is distinct and disparate from that of the
Petitioner’s Mark. Reliance was placed on the following
decisions while making the above submission:
a. Valvoline Cummins Limited v. Apar Industries Limited,
2013 SCC OnLine Del 6414
b. MESO Pvt. Ltd., Mumbai v. Liberty Shoes Ltd., Haryana
and Another, 2019 SCC OnLine Bom 1506
9.10. The Petitioner’s Goods under the Petitioner’s Mark under Class
05 are for biodegradable disinfectants (phenyl), ayurvedic and
medicinal preparations, antiseptic and antibacterial preparations,
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
19:11:41
C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 85/2021
germicides, preparations, and substances for neutralizing,
controlling, or reducing allergens, medicated skin and hair care
preparations, mosquito repellent, toiletries, cosmetic. The goods
of the Respondents under the Impugned Mark under Class 05 is
for sanitary preparations. Hence, there is no possibility of
confusion or deception as the rival goods themselves are entirely
different.
9.11. The Petitioner filed some sales invoices to substantiate their user
of the Petitioner’s Mark from 2013. An Invoice No. 669 dated
25.07.2016, whereas the invoices both prior and subsequent to
Invoice No. 669 i.e., Invoice Nos. 666, 681 and 693 are of the
year 2014. Thus, it is clear from the inconsistency of dates in the
order of numbered invoices, that the said invoices are forged and
fabricated. The user claimed by the Petitioner is false and
Petitioner’s act of submitting such forged and fabricated invoices
as evidence to substantiate their user before this Court amounts
to criminal contempt and is punishable under Section 12 of the
Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, and such intentional submission
of false evidence by the Petitioner is also punishable under
Section 193 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860. Hence, the
evidences provided by the Petitioner to substantiate their user
cannot be relied upon and cannot be considered for the just and
proper adjudication of the present Petition.
9.12. A passing off action shall not lie in the absence of proof of
goodwill and reputation subsisting in the goods or services of the
plaintiff. Where one party passes off its goods as those of
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
19:11:41
C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 85/2021
another, the law infers deceit in Trade Mark matters unless the
mark be unregistered; yet, prior honest user legitimises the
defendant’s conduct, rendering its actions legitimate and bona
fide. Reliance was placed upon the following judgments, while
making the above submission:
a. Khadi and Village Industries Commission v. Girdhar
Industries and Another, 2023 SCC OnLine Del 8446
b. Kaviraj
Pandit
Durga
Dutt
Sharma
v.
Navratna
Pharmaceutical, 1964 SCC OnLine SC 14
c. FDC Limited v. Faraway Foods Pvt. Ltd., 2021 SCC OnLine
Del 1539
d. Cadila Health Care Ltd. v. Cadila Pharmaceuticals Ltd.,
(2001) 5 SCC 73
9.13. In view of the above, it was submitted that the present
Rectification Petition be dismissed and let the registration of the
Impugned Mark, continue to remain on the Register.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS
10.
The present Rectification Petition has been filed for the Marks in
question being the Impugned Mark, ‘PATANJALI GONYLE FLOOR
CLEANER’ / ‘
’ and the Petitioner’s Mark,
‘GAUNYLE’.
11.
The Petitioner submitted that it is the prior adopter and continuous user
of the Petitioner’s Mark since 2013, and that the Impugned Mark was applied
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
19:11:41
C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 85/2021
for by the Respondents with mala fide intention to capitalize upon the
tremendous reputation and goodwill accrued to the Petitioner’s Mark. It was
submitted by the Petitioner that the Impugned Mark is visually, structurally
and phonetically identical to the Petitioner’s Mark, both Marks covering
identical goods, namely floor cleaners manufactured from cow urine, thereby
causing confusion and deception amongst the consuming public.
12.
The Petitioner further submitted that media reports have erroneously
referred to the Respondents’ goods as ‘GAUNYLE’, evincing actual
confusion in the marketplace and association with the Petitioner’s Mark. The
Respondents’ belated claim of usage since 2008 remains wholly
unsubstantiated, with no documentary evidence adduced to prove user prior
to 2013.
13.
The Respondents asserted superior rights as prior adopters and
continuous users of the Impugned Mark since 2008, antecedent to the
Petitioner’s user from 2013, and as registered proprietors across Classes 03,
05, 21 and 35. The prominent presence of the well-known House Mark
‘PATANJALI’ in the Impugned Mark constitutes a decisive distinguishing
feature precluding any likelihood of confusion. Further, the rival goods are
distinct, the Petitioner’s Goods under the Petitioner’s Mark encompassing
biodegradable disinfectants, ayurvedic preparations and cosmetics, whereas
the Impugned Mark covers sanitary preparations alone.
14.
The Respondents impeached the Petitioner’s evidence of user, drawing
attention to Invoice No. 669 dated 25.07.2016 appearing between
consecutively numbered invoices 666, 681 and 693 dated 2014, evidencing
manifest fabrication.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
19:11:41
C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 85/2021
15.
In view of the above submissions made by the Parties and given that
the Petitioner’s Mark and the Impugned Mark are registered in the same class
and also trade channels and the consumers base being identical, the following
issues arise for consideration in the present Petition:
i.
Whether the Petitioner has established prior adoption and user of the
Petitioner’s Mark?
ii.
Whether the Impugned Mark is identical or deceptively similar to
the Petitioner’s Mark so as to cause confusion or deception amongst
consumers?
iii.
Whether the registration of the Impugned Mark is liable to be
rectified under Section 57 read with Sections 9(2)(a) and 11(1)(a) of
the Act?
16.
It is trite law that Trade Marks are source identifiers and allow the
proprietors to establish the trust and develop goodwill with consistent use and
providing quality of services or goods. The interest of an average consumer
has to be protected by eliminating any likelihood of confusion or deception.
On a holistic comparison, if the Marks are found to be similar and likely to
cause confusion in the minds of an average consumer having imperfect
recollection, the Mark that is adopted subsequently has to be injuncted and /
or rectified depending on the facts of each case.
17.
The question of prior adoption and user is pivotal to the determination
of rights in a Trade Mark dispute. It is a well-settled principle of law that
priority in adoption confers superior rights, and a subsequent user cannot
claim precedence over a prior user merely on the strength of registration.
18.
In the present case, the Petitioner claims user of the Petitioner’s Mark
since 12.12.2013, whereas the Respondents assert usage of the Impugned
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
19:11:41
C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 85/2021
Mark since 2008. The burden of proving prior user lies squarely upon the
party claiming such user. Upon examination of the evidence on record, this
Court finds that the Petitioner has failed to discharge this burden satisfactorily.
The invoices submitted by the Petitioner to substantiate user from 2013 suffer
from material inconsistencies that cast serious doubt upon their authenticity.
As submitted by the Respondents, Invoice No. 669 is dated 25.07.2016,
whereas invoices bearing consecutive numbers both prior and subsequent
thereto are dated 2014. The suspicious nature of the Petitioner’s documentary
evidence undermines the entirety of its case regarding prior user.
19.
Per contra, the Respondents have consistently maintained that they
have been using the Impugned Mark since 2008. While the Petitioner has
attempted to cast doubt on this assertion by referring to a media article dated
31.12.2015, this Court notes that absence of mention in a media report cannot
constitute conclusive proof of a non-user.
20.
Furthermore, the Respondents filed their Trade Mark Application No.
3094452 on 21.08.2015, whereas the Petitioner filed its Trade Mark
Application No. 3133397 on 18.12.2015. Even if one were to disregard the
respective claims of user and rely solely on the application dates, the
Respondents would have priority. In these circumstances, this Court finds that
the Petitioner has not established prior adoption and user of the Petitioner’s
Mark vis-à-vis the Impugned Mark.
21.
The Petitioner submitted that the Impugned Mark is phonetically,
visually, and structurally identical to the Petitioner’s Mark, thereby causing
confusion and deception amongst consumers. The Petitioner relies upon the
judgments in Amritdhara Pharmacy (supra) and K.R. Chinna Krishan
Chettiar (supra) to support this contention. It is correct that phonetic
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
19:11:41
C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 85/2021
similarity is an important factor in determining likelihood of confusion.
However, the assessment of similarity must be undertaken holistically, taking
into account the visual, phonetic, and conceptual aspects of the Marks, as well
as the surrounding circumstances, including the presence of House Marks and
the nature of the goods.
22.
In the present case, while there may be some phonetic similarity
between ‘GAUNYLE’ and ‘GONYLE’, this Court cannot overlook the
critical distinguishing feature of the Impugned Mark, namely, the prominent
presence of the well-known House Mark, ‘PATANJALI’. The Impugned Mark
reads as ‘PATANJALI GONYLE FLOOR CLEANER’ and is a Device Mark,
whereas the Petitioner’s Mark is the Word Mark, ‘GAUNYLE’. The
Respondents’ well-known House Mark, ‘PATANJALI’ has been declared a
well-known Mark and enjoys substantial goodwill and reputation in the
market. The presence of this distinctive and well-known House Mark serves
as a powerful differentiating factor that would immediately identify the goods
as emanating from the Respondents. Consumers are likely to associate the
goods primarily with ‘PATANJALI’ rather than focusing solely on the
descriptive element ‘GONYLE’.
23.
The Respondents have strenuously contended that their House Mark,
‘PATANJALI’, having been declared a well-known Mark by the Registrar of
Trade Marks and enjoying substantial goodwill and reputation in the market,
serves as a powerful differentiating factor, and that consumers are likely to
associate the goods primarily with ‘PATANJALI’ rather than focusing on the
element ‘GONYLE’. It is settled position that the presence of a well-known
House Mark may, in certain circumstances, serve as a distinguishing feature.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
19:11:41
C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 85/2021
24.
In Cadila Health Care Ltd. (supra), the Supreme Court held that the
test of comparison is whether the mark as a whole is similar, and one must
consider the overall impression that the mark creates. The Supreme Court
further observed that where the goods bear the manufacturer’s name, the
possibility of confusion is greatly reduced.
25.
Applying the Cadila Health Care Ltd. (supra) principle to the facts of
the present case, this Court is of the view that the overall impression created
by the Impugned Mark, with its prominent well-known House Mark,
‘PATANJALI’, is sufficiently distinct from the Petitioner’s Mark. An average
consumer of ordinary intelligence and imperfect recollection would not
confuse the two marks when considered as a whole.
26.
Rectification under Section 57 read with Sections 9(2)(a) and 11(1)(a)
of the Act enables any aggrieved person to apply for rectification of the
Register on various grounds, including those specified in Sections 9 and 11 of
the Act. The Petitioner seeks rectification on the ground that the Impugned
Mark should not have been registered as it is identical or deceptively similar
to the Petitioner’s Mark under Section 11(1)(a) of the Act. Section 11(1)(a) of
the Act provides that a trade mark shall not be registered if, because of its
identity with an earlier trade mark and similarity of goods or services covered
by the trade mark, there exists a likelihood of confusion on the part of the
public.
27.
In the present case, the Petitioner’s Mark, though applied for
registration on 18.12.2015, which is subsequent to the Respondents’
registration dated 21.08.2015, claims user from 12.12.2013. The Petitioner
seeks to invoke Section 34 of the Act, which protects the rights of the prior
user, and contends that Section 34 of the Act must be read with Sections
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
19:11:41
C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 85/2021
9(2)(a) and 11(1)(a) of the Act. Section 34 of the Act is a non-obstante
provision that protects the rights of a prior user even against a registered
proprietor. However, the applicability of Section 34 of the Act is predicated
upon proof of continuous prior use from a date earlier than the opponent’s use
or registration, whichever is earlier.
28.
The Petitioner has failed to establish prior user of the Petitioner’s Mark
vis-à-vis the Respondents. The documentary evidence adduced by the
Petitioner is tainted with inconsistencies that raise questions about its
authenticity. In contrast, the Respondents have consistently claimed user since
2008, which predates the Petitioner’s claimed user from 2013. Furthermore,
even if the Petitioner had established prior user, the Court would still need to
be satisfied that the Impugned Mark is identical or deceptively similar to the
Petitioner’s Mark and that there exists a likelihood of confusion.
29.
As discussed above, the presence of the well-known House Mark,
‘PATANJALI’ in the Impugned Mark serves as a powerful distinguishing
feature that negates any likelihood of confusion. The Petitioner has also
sought to invoke Section 9(2)(a) of the Act, which provides that a trade mark
shall not be registered if it is of such nature as to deceive the public or cause
confusion. However, for the reasons discussed above, this Court finds that the
Impugned Mark does not fall foul of this provision. The overall impression
created by the Impugned Mark, viewed holistically with its well-known
House Mark, ‘PATANJALI’ is sufficiently distinct from the Petitioner’s Mark.
30.
Additionally, the Respondents have submitted that the goods covered
under the rival Marks are different. The Petitioner’s Mark covers a wide range
of goods including biodegradable disinfectants (phenyl), ayurvedic and
medicinal preparations, antiseptic and antibacterial preparations, germicides,
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
19:11:41
C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 85/2021
medicated skin and hair care preparations, mosquito repellent, toiletries, and
cosmetics. On the other hand, the Impugned Mark is registered for sanitary
preparations. While both goods may broadly fall under the category of
cleaning products, the specific descriptions suggest different market segments
and uses, which further reduces the likelihood of confusion.
31.
The submission of the Respondents in respect to the invoices with
chronologically impossible dates raises grave concerns about the integrity of
the evidence presented. Furthermore, the Respondents are the registered
proprietors of the Impugned Mark not just in Class 05, but also under Classes
03, 21 and 35. The Respondents have invested substantial resources in
building their brand around the ‘PATANJALI’ House Mark. The grant of the
relief sought by the Petitioner would cause significant prejudice to the
Respondents, who have been using and developing their brand in good faith.
32.
The Petitioner applied for registration of the Petitioner’s Mark on
18.12.2015, which is subsequent to the Respondents’ registration dated
21.08.2015. The Petitioner was thus, on notice of the Respondents’ prior
application at the time of filing its own application. Despite this knowledge,
the Petitioner proceeded with its application without filing any opposition at
the appropriate stage. The Petitioner cannot now seek to rectify the Register
after the Respondents have obtained registration and invested in their brand.
CONCLUSION
33.
For the reasons stated above, the Petitioner has failed to establish prior
adoption and user of the Petitioner’s Mark vis-à-vis the Respondents’ use of
the Impugned Mark. The documentary evidence adduced by the Petitioner is
unreliable and suffers from material inconsistencies that cast serious doubt
about its authenticity.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
19:11:41
C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 85/2021
34.
The Impugned Mark, when viewed holistically with the prominent
‘PATANJALI’ House Mark, is not identical or deceptively similar to the
Petitioner’s Mark so as to cause confusion or deception amongst consumers
of average intelligence and imperfect recollection.
35.
The Petitioner has not made out a case for rectification of the Register
under Section 57 read with Sections 9(2)(a) and 11(1)(a) of the Act. In light
of the aforesaid findings, the present Rectification Petition is devoid of merit.
36.
The registration of the Impugned Mark bearing Registration No.
3094452 in Class 05 in the name of the Respondents is valid and subsisting,
and there is no justification for cancelling / removing / rectifying the same
from the Register.
37.
The Impugned Mark ‘PATANJALI GONYLE FLOOR CLEANER’ /
‘
’ bearing Registration No. 3094452 in Class 05 shall
continue to remain on the Register of Trade Marks.
38.
The Rectification Petition stands dismissed. No order as to costs.
TEJAS KARIA, J
JANUARY 9, 2026
‘N’
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
19:11:41
C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 85/2021
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review