Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 2nd February, 2026.
Uploaded on: 5th February, 2026.
+
W.P.(C) 787/2026
HITESH SOOD AND ANR
Through:
.....Petitioners
Ms. Gunjan Sinha Jain & Ms.
Muskaan Gopal, Adv.
versus
UNION OF INDIA THROUGH SECRETARY & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Sanjay Kumar Pathak, SC with
Mrs. K. Kaomudi Kiran Pathak, Mr.
Sunil Kumar Jha, Mr. Divakar Kapil,
and Miss. Joohu Kumari, Advs. for
Respondent No.2 & 4
Ms. Manika Tripathy SC for DDA
with Mr. Gautam Yadav, Advs.
Mr. Vikrant N Goyal, Ms. Laavanya
GP, Mr. Piyush Wadhwa, Mr. Yash
Basoya, Mr. Kunal Dixit, Advs. for
UOI
CORAM:
JUSTICE PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUSTICE MADHU JAIN
JUDGMENT
Prathiba M. Singh, J.
1.
This hearing has been done through hybrid mode.
CM APPL. 3899/2026 (Exemption)
2.
Allowed, subject to all just exceptions. The application is disposed of.
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
11:34:37
W.P.(C) 787/2026
W.P.(C) 787/2026
3.
The present petition is a clear example of the long and arduous journey
land owners have to undergo for obtaining compensation, when land is
acquired. The writ petition has been filed by the Petitioners under Articles 226
of the Constitution of India seeking the following prayers:
“a. Issue a Writ of Mandamus or any other
writ/order/direction to the Respondents to redetermine the compensation payable to the
Petitioner strictly in accordance with the directions
contained in the Order dated 27.07.2005 passed by
this Hon’ble Court in W.P. No. 587 of 1987; and/or
b. Declare that the Award dated 11.07.2005 is
unlawful and invalid; and/or
c. Declare that the Petitioners are entitled to
compensation as per the provisions of the Right to
Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land
Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act,
2013 and direct the Respondents to pay such
compensation, after determination under the Act,
2013; and/or
d. Award costs of the present petition, including
litigation costs borne by the Petitioner since 1987.
e. Pass such other order(s) as this Hon’ble Court
may deem fit in the interest of justice.”
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
4.
The subject matter of the present petition is a plot of 512 square yards
in Kharsa no. 21, Revenue Estate of Village Hamayunpur, Tehsil Mehrauli,
New Delhi (hereinafter, ‘the land’).
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
11:34:37
W.P.(C) 787/2026
5.
It is not in dispute that the land originally belonged to Mr. H.P. Sood,
who is the grandfather of Petitioner No.1-Hitesh Sood, Mr. Manjit, Mr. A.K.
Sood and Petitioner No. 2-Mrs. Jayant Gondal. The initial owners, Mr. H.P.
Sood, Mr Manjit, Mr. AK Sood are stated to have since passed away, as shown
in the table below:
S.no.
Name
Date of
death
6.
1.
Mr. H.P. Sood
19.11.1993
2.
Mr. Manjit
23.04.2003
3.
Mr. A.K. Sood
08.05.2003
A notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894
(hereinafter, ‘Act, 1894’) was issued on 3rd September, 1957. This was
followed by a declaration dated 4th January, 1969 under Section 6 of the Act,
1894 which was notified in the official gazette vide Notification No. F. 15(84)
57 L&H on 6th January, 1969.
7.
According to the Petitioners, the possession of the land was forcibly
taken and repeated representations had been filed by the predecessors of
Petitioner No.1 seeking declaration that the possession of the land having
been taken forcefully and the compensation having not being paid, the land
ought to revert to the Petitioners.
8.
The representations made by Petitioners’ predecessors were unheard.
This led to filing of the writ petition i.e., W.P.(C) 587/1987 titled H.P. Sood
v. UOI & Ors.. In W.P.(C) 587/1987, the prayer that was sought is as under:
“(a)
Issue a writ of mandamus, prohibition and
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
11:34:37
W.P.(C) 787/2026
certiorari or any other appropriate writ, order or
direction to the respondents either to assess the market
value of the land of the petitioner on the basis of
notifications issued earlier under sections 4 and 6 of
the Act (Annexures-P-II and P-III) or in case the said
notifications have lapsed by afflux of time as under the
Land Acquisition (Amendment) Act 1984, the
respondents be directed to issue fresh notifications
under sections 4 and 6 of the Act and announce award
in respect of the land of the petitioner bearing khasra
No. 21 min measuring 512 sq. yards situated in the
revenue estate of village Hamayun Pur, Tehsil
Mehrauli, Delhi;
(b) declare that the action of the respondents is in
violation of the fundamental rights guaranteed under
Articles 14 and 19 of the Constitution of India;
(c) such other appropriate writ, order or direction as
this Hon'ble Court may in the circumstances of the
case, deem fit and proper be issued;, and
(d) the costs of this petition may also be awarded in
favour of the petitioner and against the respondents.”
9.
During the pendency of W.P.(C) 587/1987, another preliminary
notification under Section 4 of the Act, 1894 for acquiring the same land, was
issued on 1st June, 2004. This was followed by a Notification under Section 6
of the Act, 1894 on 14th July, 2004, wherein Respondent invoked provisions
under Section 17 of the Act, 1894, on the ground of emergency and sought to
re-justify the acquisition of the land without tendering the mandatory 80%
compensation. It is relevant to point out that in terms of these notifications,
an award bearing no. 27/DC(S)/2005-06 dated 11th July, 2005 was passed by
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
11:34:37
W.P.(C) 787/2026
the LAC (hereinafter, ‘the award’). The total land holding which was sought
to be acquired was only 512 sq. yards (0-10) in Khasra no. 21 min. The
aforesaid notifications also came to be challenged by way of an amended
petition.
10.
Pursuant thereto, vide order dated 27th July, 2005 in W.P.(C) 587/1987
(hereinafter, ‘order dated 27th July, 2005’), the W.P.(C) 587/1987 was finally
disposed of in the following terms:
“A plot of land measuring 512 Sq. Yd. situate in
Khasra No. 21 min was notified for acquisition by the
respondents in terms of a preliminary notification
dated 3 September, 1957. A final declaration under
Section 6 of the Act followed and was published on
4th January, 1969. Possession of the property was,
according to the petitioner, taken over forcibly by
respondent No. 3 in the year 1976. An award
pursuant to the notifications mentioned above was not
however made within the statutory period of two
years even after Section 11A of the Act was
introduced in the year 1984. The legal effect of the
non-making of the award therefore was that the
notifications lapsed with the passage of time.
The petitioner had, in the above backdrop, filed the
present writ petition inter alia for a mandamus
directing the respondents to either assess the market
value of the land on the basis of the notification issued
by them or to issue fresh notifications for the
acquisition of the property. He had also prayed for a
declaration that the action of the respondents in
taking possession of the land without an award and
without payment of compensation was illegal..
During the pendency of the above petition, the
respondents issued another preliminary notification
on 1st June, 2004 followed by a declaration under
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
11:34:37
W.P.(C) 787/2026
Section 6 on 14th July, 2004. The respondents also
invoked the provisions of Section 17 on the ground
that there was an emergency and claimed to have retaken the possession of the land.
The petitioner had, in the meantime, filed an amended
petition in which he had confined his reliefs only to
the following:
a) to direct the respondents to give a plot
measuring around 512 Sq. Yds., to the petitioner
in as near proximity as feasible to the place
where the original place of land was located.
b) to pay proper compensation as determined by
this Hon'ble Court for the petitioner having been
deprived of using the said plot for his own
personal use since the year 1977 till date.
Appearing for the petitioner, Mr. Kalra strenuously
argued that the respondents had determined and
offered to pay a sum of Rs.1,72,725.95 only
representing 80% of the estimated compensation
determined by the Collector under Section 17(3A) of
the Act. Relying upon a Division Bench of this Court
in Smt. Krishna Kumari Uppal vs. Union of India &
Ors, WP(C) 768/2004 disposed of on 7th May. 2004,
the learned counsel argued that compensation
payable under Section 17(3A) supra could not in
terms of quantum be absurd or farcical. He urged that
this Court could, on the analogy of the said judgment,
determine proper compensation payable to the
petitioner and direct its release by the respondents
under Section 17(3A) of the Act. He also urged that
the petitioner had a claim for allotment of an
alternative site which the respondents had not
considered and that this Court could issue a direction
for the allotment of an alternative site in lieu of
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
11:34:37
W.P.(C) 787/2026
monetary compensation
On behalf of the respondents, it was on the other hand
submitted by Mr. Poddar that the amount determined
by the Collector on the basis of on estimate drawn
under Section 17(3A) was indeed inadequate and
therefore could not be supported by him. He
submitted that while the amount offered to the
petitioner may not, keeping in view the prevailing
market prices and the decision of this court, be a
reasonable estimate, this court ought not to embark
upon any process of determination of the
compensation itself. He urged that the determination
of compensation could be remitted back to the
Collector with such directions as the court may deem
fit. He submitted that in the event of the matter being
sent back, the Collector would have no difficulty in
estimating the compensation, afresh keeping in view,
the decision of this court in Krishna Kumari Uppal's
case referred to above, and other relevant
circumstances.
On behalf of the Delhi Development Authority, it was
contended that the prayer for allotment of an
alternative site was not supported by any legal
entitlement of the petitioner. It was urged that the
petitioner was entitled to demand and receive the
market value of The land determined in terms of
Section 23 of the Act and in case he was dissatisfied
with the determination of the collector, the issue
could be referred to the Civil Court under Section 18
for an appropriate adjudication of the matter. Relying
upon the Division Bench's decision of this court in
Udey Singh vs. Union of India & Ors. 112 (2004)
DLT 739 (DB), it was submitted that even if the
possession of the land in question had been taken
prior to the initiation and proper completion of the
acquisition proceedings, the same did not render the
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
11:34:37
W.P.(C) 787/2026
said proceedings illegal. The Collector could, in such
a situation, determine compensation payable to the
land owner and award damages considered just and
proper for wrongful occupation.
The prayer for allotment of an alternate plot of land
is de horse the provisions of the land Acquisition Act.
The Act does not envisage or oblige the acquiring
authority or the beneficiary to arrange or offer to the
owner an alternative site of the same or similar value.
It is a different matter altogether if the State
formulates a' scheme for rehabilitation of those
uprooted on account of the acquisition, and offers
assistance in the form of allotment of sites as a part
of such rehabilitation scheme. No such scheme has
been brought to our notice in the instant case. Even if
one were to assume that there is any such scheme, the
petitioner's remedies lies in invoking the same before
the authorities and persuading them to examine his
claim for an allotment.
In the absence of any legal obligation on the part of
the respondents to provide an alternative site, we
have no hesitation in rejecting the prayer for a
mandamus for making any such allotment.
Mr. Kalra however argued that the present is not a
simple case of acquisition but a case where
possession of the land held by the petitioner was
wrongfully taken from him. He submitted that the
wrongful occupation of the land could not be
legitimised by the respondents by initiating
acquisition proceedings nor could such acquisition
proceedings legalise post facto the possession of the
respondents over the same. The answer to that
submission is in our view provided by two decisions
of the Supreme Court in Union of India vs. Budh
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
11:34:37
W.P.(C) 787/2026
Singh & Ors. (1995) 6 SCC 233 and R.L. Jain (D)
by. LRs v. DDA & Ors. IT 2004 (3) SC 272. In the
later of the two decisions, the Supreme Court has,
while dealing with a similar situation, observed thus:
"In a case where the land owner is dis-possessed
prior to the issuance of preliminary notification
under Section 4(1) of the Act the government
merely takes possession of the land but the title
thereof continue to vest with the land owner. It is
fully open for the land owner to recover the
possession of his land by taking appropriate legal
proceedings. He is therefore only entitled to get
rent or damages for use and occupation for the
period the government retains possession of the
property. Where possession is taken prior to the
issuance of the preliminary notificatin, in our
opinion, it will be just and equitable that the
Collector may also determine the rent or
damages for use of the property to which the land
owner is entitled while determining the
compensation amount payable to the land owner
for the acquisition of the property. The provision
of section 48 of the Act lend support to such a
course of action. For delayed payment of such
amount appropriate interest at prevailing bank
rate may be awarded.”
In the light of the above authoritative
pronouncements and the view taken by the Division
Bench of this court in Udey Singh’s case (Supera), we
have no hesitation in holding that just because
possession of the land was taken in anticipation of
initiation or completion of the proceedings, the same
are not liable to be interfered with. Any such
proceedings cannot even be dubbed as mala fide
particularly when the law recognizes a proper
remedy for the owner in the form of damages to be
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
11:34:37
W.P.(C) 787/2026
awarded by the Collector for any such wrongful
occupation.
That leaves us with the only other question whether
the estimated compensation offered by the petitioner
is the instant case is indeed ridiculously low and
farcical for purposes of Section 17(3A). Mr.Poddar's
fair concession at the bar that it is indeed so relieves
us of the burden of giving any reason why the amount
offered is illusory. Mr.Poddar was candid in his
statement that the amount offered by the Collector
was wholly inadequate keeping in view the attendant
circumstances including the rate fixed by the
Government at the relevant point of time. That being
so, the Collector would have to re-examine and redetermine the estimated compensation payable to
the petitioner and tender 80% of the same to the
petitioner.
The respondent has along with the affidavit
submitted to this court a cheque dated 3 May, 2005
for a sum of Rs.1.72,725/-drawn in favour of the
Registrar General representing 80% of the
estimated compensation. Mr. Poddar submits that
the said cheque could be deemed cancelled so that a
fresh cheque for the consolidated amount due to the
petitioner can be issued within such period that this
court may deem fit. Is the circumstances, we dispose
of this petition with the following observations:
(a) The respondent Collector Land Acquisition shall
within two weeks from today, re-determine the
estimated compensation payable to the petitioner
taking into consideration the decision of this court
in WPC 768/2004 referred to earlier and the
Government rates fixed for land situate in the
vicinity.
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
11:34:37
W.P.(C) 787/2026
(b) Upon re-determination, 80% of the amount so
estimated shall be released in favour of the
petitioner forthwith.
(c) The Respondent Collector shall, in addition,
expedite making of the award and determine
compensation payable to the petitioner including
damages, if any, keeping in view the observations of
the Supreme Court in Budh Singh's and R.L. Jain's
case and the Division Bench of this Court in Udey
Singh's case (supra).
(d) Since the Collector has already issued a notice to
the petitioner inviting claims from him, we direct
that the petitioner shall file his claim within four
weeks from today falling which the Collector shall
be free to proceed with the determination of
compensation in the absence of the same.
No Costs.
Order dasti to all the parties.”
11.
In terms of the above order, the sum of Rs. 1,72, 725.95/- was offered
to the Petitioners in W.P.(C) 587/1987 as 80% of the estimated compensation.
The challenge by the Petitioners in W.P.(C) 587/1987 was that the quantum
of compensation was absurd and farcical. The prayer at that stage was even
for allotment of an alternate site. After considering the entire matter, the
Division Bench of this Court, at that time, had observed that the possession
of the land could not be disturbed and in so far as the compensation is
concerned, it was directed that Respondent No.-4 Land Acquisition Collector
(hereinafter, ‘LAC’) to re-determine the estimated compensation of the land
and tender 80% of the same to the Petitioner in W.P.(C) 587/1987. On the
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
11:34:37
W.P.(C) 787/2026
submission made by ld. Counsel for LAC, even the Cheque which was
deposited by Respondent No.3 in the present petition- Delhi Development
Authority (hereinafter, ‘DDA’) before the Court was deemed to be cancelled
so that a fresh cheque for the consolidated amount, after the re-determination
of compensation of the land, can be issued to the Petitioners in W.P.(C)
587/1987.
12.
Under these circumstances, the ultimate direction was for re-
determination of the estimated compensation of the land, based upon the
market rates.
13.
The arduous journey of the Petitioners ought to have ended here and
the LAC ought to have proceeded in accordance with order dated 27th July,
2005.
14.
However, from 2006 to 2019, despite repeated follow ups by the
Petitioners, the LAC did not conduct any re-determination of the
compensation of the land. The Petitioners had also filed an RTI Application
before the concerned Revenue Department for ascertaining the status of redetermination of compensation of the land, but no satisfactory response was
received by the Petitioners.
15.
The Petitioners then filed an application being C.M.8142/2020 in
W.P.(C) 587/1987, wherein, the Petitioners sought for an appropriate
direction to be passed to the Respondents to comply with the order dated 27 th
July, 2005. While the Court was considering the aforesaid application, reply
dated 4th July, 2023 was filed by LAC and a shocking fact came to the
knowledge of the Petitioners i.e., the passing of ‘the award’ bearing No.
27/DC/(S)/2005-2006 dated 11th July, 2005, awarding
a sum of Rs.
2,37,973.23/- for the land. The same was passed 16 days prior to the order
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
11:34:37
W.P.(C) 787/2026
dated 27th July, 2005.
16.
In the reply to the application, dated 4th July, 2023, the LAC primarily
opposed the grant of relief on the ground that the Petitioners had approached
belatedly. Additionally, the LAC also informed the Court that the DDA had
taken possession of the Land on 6th August, 2004. The relevant portion of the
reply of the LAC is set out below:
“ [...]
9. That as per available records in the office of the
LAC, the land measuring 10 biswa (512 sq. Yards)
out of Khasra No. 21 min situated in village
Humayun Pur, Delhi was notified vide notification
dated 01.06.2004 issued under Section 4 and 17 of
the Land Acquisition Act, 1894(hereinafter referred
as “the Act”). Declaration under section 6 of the Act
was issued on 14.07.2004 along with notification
under Section 17 of the Act dated 14.07.2004. It is
submitted that notices under section 9 and 10 of the
Act were also issued to all the land owners and
interested persons. However, no compensation
claim was filed by the interested persons/owners.
Since no claim forcompensation was filed by the
interested persons despite notices under section 9
and 10 of the Act, the Land Acquisition Collector
(South)hadtaken cognizance of the indicative price
fixed for agricultural land as Rs. 15.70 Lakh per
Acre
as
conveyed
vide
letter
No.
F.9(20)/80/L&B/LA/6696 dated 09.08.2001 and
assessed the market value of the acquired land as on
date of notification under section 4 of the Act @
Rs.15.70 Lakh Per Acre. Since land was vacant, no
compensation for trees, walls and structures were
assessed. It has been mentioned in the Award itself
that Possession of land was taken by DDA on
06.08.2004. After completing all formalities the
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
11:34:37
W.P.(C) 787/2026
Land Acquisition Collector announced the Award
No. 27/DC/(S)/2005-2006 dated 11.07.2005 under
Section 11 of the Act. Truecopy of the Award No.
27/DC/(S)/2005-2006 dated 11.07.2005 is annexed
herewith as ANNEXURE R-4/1.
10. That it is submitted that inadvertently the fact
that award had already been announced on
11.07.2005 under Section 11 of the Act could not
be brought to the notice of this Hon’ble Court prior
to or at the time of hearing of the writ petition on
27.07.2005 when the same was disposed of on the
basis of the concessions made by the learned
counsel for the answering respondent which
concession apparently was given in ignorance of
the fact that the award in respect of the acquired
had already been passed by the land acquisition
collector.”
17.
Another aspect of the reply dated 4th July, 2023 was that the LAC
sought to resile from the statement made by the ld. Counsel for the LAC on
27th July, 2005, and took the position that the said statement was made in
ignorance of the fact that the Award had been passed.
18.
The said reply is, however, completely silent as to in what manner the
Award was communicated to the Petitioners and what steps have been taken
pursuant to the passing of the award.
19.
In application C.M.8142/2020, the Petitioners relied upon the
judgment of the Supreme Court in Indore Development Authority (LAPSE5 J.) v. Manoharlal, (2020) 8 SCC 129 to contend that irrespective of whether
the award is passed or not, in case possession of land is taken and no
compensation is paid to the Petitioners, the Petitioners are entitled to be paid
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
11:34:37
W.P.(C) 787/2026
higher compensation under the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency
in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (hereinafter,
‘the Act, 2013’).
20.
Thereafter, the application C.M.8142/2020 was disposed of by the
Court on 14th November, 2025, permitting the Petitioners to take recourse to
legal remedies and all right and contentions were left open. The copy of the
order dated 14th November, 2025 reads as under:
“1.Application is not pressed and as such stands
disposed of.
2. However, we reserve a right in favour of applicant to
prefer a fresh petition or take recourse to such legal
remedy as is permissible and available in law. All rights
and contentions shall remain open.
3. Order be uploaded on the website of tis Court.”
21.
Pursuant to the liberty granted by the Court in application
C.M.8142/2020, the present writ petition has been preferred by the
Petitioners.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PARTIES
22.
The submissions have been made by Ms. Gunjan Sinha Jain, ld Counsel
for the Petitioners and Mr. Sanjay Kumar Pathak, ld. Counsel for the
Respondent No.2 and 4- LAC.
23.
The submission on behalf of ld. Counsel for the Petitioners is that
pursuant to order dated 27th July, 2005, the alleged compensation which was
deposited, already stood cancelled. It is also submitted that though the
acquisition of the land dates back to 1969 and possession was taken forcibly,
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
11:34:37
W.P.(C) 787/2026
no compensation has been paid to the Petitioners. Additionally, ld. Counsel
also places reliance upon the decision of the Supreme Court in Indore
Development (Supra) to argue that the Petitioners are entitled to
determination of compensation under the Act, 2013.
24.
Further, ld. Counsel for the Petitioners also places reliance upon
Section 24 of the Act , 2013 and Section 12(2) Act, 1894.
25.
On the other hand, Mr. Pathak, ld. Counsel submits that the present
petition is highly belated. It is also submitted that the ld. Counsel who made
the statement on 27th July, 2005, that the cheque ought to be deemed to have
been cancelled, made the statement without any instruction from the LAC. It
is submitted that the same was due to inter-departmental miscommunication
and such instructions were not given to the ld. Counsel then.
26.
He further submits that the stand of the LAC when the order dated 27 th
July, 2005 was passed, was in ignorance of the award which had been passed.
27.
Upon a query from the Court, as to what steps did the LAC take to seek
recall of the order dated 27th July, 2005, the clear stand of the LAC is that no
application was filed seeking recall. However, it is submitted that in the reply
dated 4th July, 2023, the relevant facts were brought to the notice of the Court
as also the Petitioners.
28.
It is also the submission of ld. Counsel, that the Petitioners came to
know of the award, when they inspected the award file, in 2019 and no steps
were taken after the order dated 27th July, 2005 was passed. In terms of
paragraph (d) of the order dated 27th July, 2005 the Petitioner had to file a
claim before a Collector, which the Petitioner failed to do. It is submitted that
it is only in 2019, by filing a RTI application that the whole matter is
attempted to be reactivated.
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
11:34:37
W.P.(C) 787/2026
29.
Finally, it is submitted that the non-communication of the award would
not vitiate the award under Section 12(2) of the Act, 1894 and that award
cannot be deemed to have been cancelled.
30.
However, ld. Counsel for the Petitioner, at this juncture, submits that
the order dated 27th July, 2005 is clear that if the claims are not filed, the
Collector is at liberty to proceed with the determination of the compensation.
Thus, the position as of today is that the possession of the land has been taken
and no compensation has been paid.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS
31.
The Court has heard ld. Counsels for the parties and considered the
matter. The short question in the present petition is whether the Petitioners
have been paid compensation for the land acquired in 1969. The simple
answer is NO.
32.
The Petitioners, having not received any compensation whatsoever for
more than 55 years, cannot be made to run from pillar to post anymore. The
LAC, initially, did not pay any compensation at all to the Petitioners when the
first Notification was issued. Thereafter for whatever reasons it had to invoke
the emergency provisions under Section 17 of the Act, 1894 to issue fresh
notifications.
33.
At that stage, when the matter was considered by the Division Bench
on 27th July, 2005, the factum of passing of the award was not told to the
Court.
34.
Even if it is presumed that the ld. Counsel appearing was not aware of
the award which was passed, the LAC had a bounden duty to file an
application seeking recall of the order dated 27th July, 2005 or for placing the
correct facts before the Court, which it did not do for more than 15 years.
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
11:34:37
W.P.(C) 787/2026
35.
It is only after several years, the Petitioners filed an application in 2020,
after being unsuccessful in having re-determination of the compensation of
the land, and moved an application. The LAC in its reply dated 4th July, 2023
was filed, disclosed the award. Even if it is presumed that the Petitioners came
to know of the Award in 2019, when they inspected the file, the same cannot
justify the LAC’s non-communication of the Award to the Court and
thereafter to the Petitioners.
36.
Be that as it may, no one’s property can be acquired without payment
of compensation. The possession of the land has been taken. The purported
cheque which was deposited earlier with the Court, clearly stood cancelled
and the LAC was well aware of this position. However, the LAC made no
effort whatsoever to either re-determine the compensation of the land or pay
the compensation as per the award.
37.
The provisions of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in
Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013, are absolutely
clear. Section 24 of Act, 2013 reads as under:
“24. Land acquisition process under Act No. 1 of 1894
shall be deemed to have lapsed in certain cases.
(1) Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act, in
any case of land acquisition proceedings initiated under
the Land Acquisition Act, 1894,-(a) where no award under section 11 of the said Land
Acquisition Act has been made, then, all provisions of
this Act relating to the determination of compensation
shall apply; or
(b) where an award under said section 11 has been
made, then such proceedings shall continue under the
provisions of the said Land Acquisition Act, as if the said
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
11:34:37
W.P.(C) 787/2026
Act has not been repealed.
(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section
(1), in case of land acquisition proceedings initiated
under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (1 of 1894), where
an award under the said section 11 has been made five
years or more prior to the commencement of this Act but
the physical possession of the land has not been taken
or the compensation has not been paid the said
proceedings shall be deemed to have lapsed and the
appropriate Government, if it so chooses, shall initiate
the proceedings of such land acquisition afresh in
accordance with the provisions of this Act:
Provided that where an award has been made and
compensation in respect of a majority of land holdings
has not been deposited in the account of the
beneficiaries, then, all beneficiaries specified in the
notification for acquisition under section 4 of the said
Land Acquisition Act, shall be entitled to
compensation in accordance with the provisions of this
Act.”
38.
Section 24 of the Act, 2013 has been conclusively interpreted by the
Supreme Court in Indore Development (supra), where the Supreme Court has
observed as under:
“189. The fundamental consideration is that the proviso
cannot supersede the main provision of Section 24(1)(b)
and destroy it. The function of the proviso is to except
out the pressing provisions to which it is attached. In
case possession has been taken, but only a few
beneficiaries have been paid, there is no lapse. Even if
nobody has been paid, there is no lapse once possession
has been taken. In case compensation has not been
deposited with respect to the majority of the holdings,
there is no lapse, but higher compensation to all the
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
11:34:37
W.P.(C) 787/2026
beneficiaries has to follow. The provision provides
equal treatment to all, not only to a few— and, in effect,
is similar to Section 28-A of the 1894 Act—in case the
obligation to pay or deposit has not been discharged
and there is no arrangement of money to discharge the
obligation either by paying or depositing in the
Reference Court and, if permissible, in the treasury.
Section 24(2) saves land which has been vested in the
State, once award has been passed and possession of
land. However, in case compensation has not been
deposited with respect to majority of landowners, in
any given award, all beneficiaries have to be paid
higher compensation under the new Act.
190. It was urged that section 24(1) and 24(2) deal with
different subjects. It was submitted that Section 24(1)
deals with compensation, whereas section 24(2) deals
with the lapsing of the acquisition. We are unable to
accept the submission. Section 24(2) also deals with
payment of compensation and taking of possession.
Section 24(1)(a) is concerning a situation where no
award has been made, higher compensation under the
new Act to follow. In section 24(1)(b) where the award
is made (at the time of coming into force of the new
Act) further proceedings would be under the new law;
subject to Section 24(2), the provisions of the Act of
1894 would apply to such an award. Thus, the main
part of section 24(2) deals with payment of
compensation; also the proviso which provides for
higher compensation to be paid to all is in the context
of section 24(2) and cannot be lifted and added to
Section 24(1)(b) in the aforesaid circumstances. What
would be the majority of the landholdings has to be
seen in the context, what has been acquired in the case
of a single plot being acquired, and in case
compensation has not been deposited with respect to
that, it will constitute the majority. The majority does
not depend upon the number of holdings acquired, but
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
11:34:37
W.P.(C) 787/2026
what constitutes the majority as per the acquired area
under the notification.”
39.
In terms of the judgment in Indore Development (supra) and since the
notification in the present case relates to the entire land i.e., 512 square yards
itself, the present is a case which would be covered for the purpose of higher
compensation in terms of the Act of 2013.
40.
Insofar as the initial cheque deposited before this Court, which was
treated as cancelled is concerned, it was submitted by ld. Counsel for the LAC,
that the same occurred due to an inter-departmental miscommunication and
that no such instructions had been given to the Counsel. However, this
submission would be of no avail today. In terms of paragraph 202 and 203 of
Indore Development (supra), the Supreme Court has elaborated on the
meaning of the word ‘paid’. Additionally, in terms of paragraph 205 of
Indore Development (supra), it has been stated that paid in terms of Section
24(2) of the Act, 2013 would not include in its ambit the expression deposited
in Court in terms of Section 31(1) of the Act, 1894. The relevant paragraphs
reads as under:
“202. Section 24(2) deals with the expression where
compensation has not been paid. It would mean that it
has not been tendered for payment under section 31(1).
Though the word 'paid' amounts to a completed event
however once payment of compensation has been
offered/tendered under section 31(1), the acquiring
authority cannot be penalized for non-payment as the
amount has remained unpaid due to refusal to accept,
by the landowner and Collector is prevented from
making the payment. Thus, the word 'paid' used in
section 24(2) cannot be said to include within its ken
'deposit' under section 31(2). For that special
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
11:34:37
W.P.(C) 787/2026
provision has been carved out in the proviso to section
24(2), which deals with the amount to be deposited in
the account of beneficiaries. Two different expressions
have been used in section 24. In the main part of
section 24, the word 'paid' and in its proviso 'deposited'
have been used.
203. The consequence of non-deposit of the amount has
been dealt with in section 34 of the 1894 Act. As per
section 24(2), if the amount has not been paid nor
possession has been taken, it provides for lapse.
Whereas the proviso indicates amount has not been
deposited with respect to a majority of landholdings in
a case initiated under the Act of 1894 for 5 years or
more. The period of five years need not have been
specified in the proviso as it is part of section 24(2) and
has to be read with it, particularly in view of the colon
and placement by the legislature as held above. Two
different
consequences
of
non-deposit
of
compensation are: (i) higher compensation in a case
where possession has been taken, payment has been
made to some and amount has not been deposited with
respect to majority of the holdings,
(ii) in case there is no lapse, the beneficiaries would be
entitled to interest as envisaged under section 34 from
the date of taking possession at the rate of 9% per
annum for the first year and after that @ 15% per
annum.
xxx
205. The word “paid” in Section 31(1) to the
landowner cannot include in its ambit the expression
“deposited” in court. Deposit cannot be said to be
payment made to landowners. Deposit is on being
prevented from payment. However, in case there is a
tender of the amount that is to mean amount is made
available to the landowner that would be a discharge of
the obligation to make the payment and in that event
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
11:34:37
W.P.(C) 787/2026
such a person cannot be penalised for the default in
making the payment. In default to deposit in court, the
liability is to make the payment of interest under Section
34 of the 1894 Act. Sections 32 and 33 (which had been
relied upon by the landowners' counsel to say that
valuable rights inhere, in the event of deposit with court,
thus making deposit under Section 31 mandatory)
provide for investing amounts in the government
securities, or seeking alternative lands, in lieu of
compensation, etc. Such deposits, cannot fetch higher
interest than the 15% contemplated under Section 34,
which is in pari materia with Section 80 of the 2013 Act.
Section 34 is in pari materia with Section 80 of the 2013
Act in which also the similar rate of interest has been
specified. Even if the amount is not deposited in
Reference Court nor with the treasury as against the
name of the person interested who is entitled to receive
it, if Collector has been prevented to make the payment
due to exigencies provided in Section 31(2), interest is
to be paid. However, in case the deposit is made without
tendering it to the person interested, the liability to pay
the interest under Section 34, shall continue. Even
assuming deposit in the Reference Court is taken to be
mandatory, in that case too interest has to follow as
specified in Section 34. However, acquisition
proceeding cannot lapse due to non-deposit.”
41.
Moreover, even the cheque which was deposited was merely for a sum
of Rs. 1,72,725/-, which constituted 80% of the estimated compensation.
Thus, the deposit of the said cheque cannot amount to payment of full
compensation.
42.
Thus, in view of the fact that no compensation has been paid and the
LAC was directed to re-determine the compensation in terms of the order
dated 27th July, 2005, the clock cannot be put back to presume that the amount
which was deposited by way a cheque, ought to be considered as the
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
11:34:37
W.P.(C) 787/2026
compensation for the Petitioners. To do so would be wholly contrary to law
and manifestly inequitable, as it would disentitle the Petitioners for a fair
compensation under the Act, 2013.
43.
Under the circumstances, this Court is of the opinion that the
compensation for the land deserves to be re-determined in accordance with
the directions contained in order dated 27th July, 2005 read along with the
provisions of the Act, 2013.
44.
The re-determination of the compensation of the land shall be done by
the LAC, within a period of three months from this order. Upon such redetermination, the compensation shall be released to the Petitioners within six
months, thereafter.
45.
The present petition is disposed of in these terms. Pending applications,
if any, are also disposed of.
46.
List for compliance on 18th May, 2026.
PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUDGE
MADHU JAIN
JUDGE
FEBRUARY 02, 2026
ys/dj/sm
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
11:34:37
W.P.(C) 787/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review