Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on : 10th September 2026
Pronounced on : 17th September 2026
Uploaded on : 18th September 2026
%
+
MAC.APP. 439/2025 & CM APPL. 42103/2025
HITESH SINGH
.....Appellant
versus
RAVI
+
.....Respondent
MAC.APP. 443/2025,CM APPL. 42577/2025, CM APPL.
42578/2025 & CM APPL. 43199/2026
HITESH SINGH
.....Appellant
versus
SHASHI
+
.....Respondent
MAC.APP. 680/2025, CM APPL. 66432/2025 CM APPL.
66433/2025
HITESH SINGH
.....Appellant
versus
LILAWATI
.....Respondent
Appearance :
Mr. HGR Khattar & Mr. Gaurav Kumar
Advocates for appellant Hitesh Singh
Mr. Anil Pruthi, Ms. Rachna & Mr. Dinesh,
Advocates for respondents / claimants in all
three appeals.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:24:55
MAC.APP. 439/2025, MAC.APP 443/2025 & MAC.APP 680/2025
Page-1/17
ANISH DAYAL, J.
1.
These appeals have been filed by the owner of the offending
vehicle, which was involved in an accident that occurred on 23 rd April
2019 at about 03:30 a.m., when the offending vehicle collided with a
scooter being driven by one Ravi, on which Smt. Lilawati, his mother,
and Smt. Shashi, his sister, were riding as pillion riders. When they
reached in front of the Oberoi Maidens Hotel, they were hit by the
offending vehicle, i.e. bus bearing registration no. HR 69 C 5953, of which
the appellant is the registered owner.
2.
Three claim petitions were filed in respect of the injuries sustained
in the accident and were decided by the Tribunal, namely, MACT
No.955/2019,
in
case
of Sh.
Ravi,
whereby
compensation
of Rs.54,234/- along with interest @ 9% per annum was awarded; MACT
No.954/2019,
in
case
of Smt.
Shashi,
whereby
compensation
of Rs.14,10,589/- along with interest @ 9% per annum was awarded;
and MACT No.953/2019, in case of injured Smt. Lilawati, whereby
compensation of Rs.2,36,404/- along with interest @ 9% per annum was
awarded.
3.
FIR 78/2019 was registered at PS Civil Lines which resulted in a
charge-sheet being filed against the driver and owner of the offending
vehicle.
Submission of Counsels
4.
The owner, as confirmed by counsel for appellant, pleaded guilty in
the said proceedings. It is, however, stated by counsel that the plea of guilt
was entered to avoid further implication and the charge relating to
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:24:55
MAC.APP. 439/2025, MAC.APP 443/2025 & MAC.APP 680/2025
Page-2/17
possession of a duplicate insurance copy, which was allegedly not
genuine.
5.
Mr. H R Khattar, counsel for appellant, therefore, contends that the
mere fact that the accused pleaded guilty and was convicted cannot have
any bearing on the MACT proceedings, where the appellant is entitled to
contend that negligence on the part of the driver of the offending vehicle
was not proved.
6.
Mr. Anil Pruthi, Advocate, appears on behalf of claimants and has
instead relied upon the criminal proceedings as well as the evidence which
was placed before the MACT in this regard.
7.
In order to press his point regarding irrelevancy of the conviction,
Mr. Khattar relied upon the following judgments:
a.
N.K.V. Bros. (P) Ltd. v. M. Karumai Ammal, (1980) 3 SCC
457, where the Supreme Court stated “the plea that the criminal
case had ended in acquittal and, therefore, the civil suit must
follow suit was rejected rightly. The requirement of culpable
rashness under Section 304A IPC is more drastic than negligence
sufficient under the law of tort to create liability”.
b.
Mathew Alexander v. Mohd. Shafi, (2023) 13 SCC 510
which relied upon decision of Supreme Court in N.K.V. Bros.
(supra)
c.
Bimla Devi v. Himachal RTC, (2009) 13 SCC 530, to
observe that negligence has to be established on the touchstone of
preponderance of probabilities.
d.
Ganesh Achar v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd., 2023
SCC OnLine Kar 1627 wherein the Single Judge of the Karnataka
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:24:55
MAC.APP. 439/2025, MAC.APP 443/2025 & MAC.APP 680/2025
Page-3/17
High Court observed that mere acceptance of guilt cannot, by
itself, be a ground for the MACT to arrive at a finding of
negligence in a claim petition under Section 166 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988, where the claimant is required to establish the
case on the basis of independent evidence.
e.
Divisional Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Raj
Kishore Jethy, 1997 SCC OnLine Ori 24, a decision by Single
Judge of the High Court of Orissa, wherein, in a case involving an
offending vehicle being driven by a minor, it was held that the
Tribunal had erred in fastening liability upon the insurance
company towards payment of no-fault compensation.
8.
Mr. Khattar further contends that, in their testimony, all three
injured claimants admitted that the scooter on which they were travelling
was being driven on the left side of the road and that they were tripleriding. It was also admitted that Ravi, who was driving the scooter, did not
possess a driving licence. It came out in the testimony that the scooter
belonged to the brother of Ravi. He, therefore, contends that negligence
ought to be fastened upon the owner of the scooter, who had handed over
the vehicle to his younger brother, Ravi, despite the latter not possessing
a driving licence, and that the owner of the scooter alone should be liable
to pay the compensation. For this proposition, he relies upon the decision
in New India Assurance Co Ltd. v. Bibi Nafisa, 2024 SCC OnLine Kar
15717 rendered by Single Judge of Karnataka High Court.
Analysis
9.
The decision in Bibi Nafisa (supra) however, is clearly
distinguishable. The case involved a two-wheeler which was being driven
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:24:55
MAC.APP. 439/2025, MAC.APP 443/2025 & MAC.APP 680/2025
Page-4/17
in a rash and negligent manner and had dashed against the deceased, who
sustained grievous injuries and subsequently succumbed thereto. The twowheeler was being driven by a 16-year-old boy who, being a minor, did
not possess a driving licence. The insurance company consequently
sought its exoneration from liability. The claimants, on the other hand,
pleaded that, at the very least, an order of pay and recovery could be
passed on the basis of the judgments of the Supreme Court.
10.
However, the Single Judge distinguished the judgment of pay and
recover on the ground that they concerned drivers who were majors but
did not possess valid driving licences, whereas the case before the Court
involved a minor. It was observed that a minor aged 16 years was not a
qualified person to apply for a driving licence and, therefore, the principle
of pay and recovery was not applicable. Liability for payment of
compensation was consequently fastened upon the owner of the
motorcycle, who had handed over the vehicle to the minor, and the award
of the Tribunal fastening liability upon the insurance company was set
aside. The facts in Bibi Nafisa (supra) are entirely different, as in that case
the offending vehicle itself was being driven by a minor. The decision of
the Karnataka High Court in Bibi Nafisa (supra) has already been
challenged before the Supreme Court in Special Leave Petition Nos.
27697-98, wherein notice has been issued as to why the insurance
company should not be directed to pay the compensation and recover the
same from the owner. The matter is presently pending.
11.
This Court does not resonate with the view taken by the Karnataka
High Court in this regard, in view of the various other judgments on the
subject. However, that is not the issue before this Court. The issue arising
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:24:55
MAC.APP. 439/2025, MAC.APP 443/2025 & MAC.APP 680/2025
Page-5/17
in the present case, on the basis of the submission of Mr. Khattar, is
materially different. Mr. Khattar appears to contend that the scooter being
driven by an unlicensed driver, ought to be treated as being solely
negligent and that the compensation ought consequently to be recovered
from the owner of the scooter, who was negligent in handing over the
vehicle to his younger brother.
12.
Firstly, this plea is untenable for the reason that the owner of the
scooter would be liable only if it is established that the driver of the scooter
was negligent and that such negligence contributed to the accident.
Secondly, no such case was established by the driver or owner of the
offending vehicle before the MACT, as no evidence was led by them.
13.
In any event, even if it were found that the driver of the scooter was
driving without a valid driving licence, that fact by itself would not lead
to a finding of contributory negligence unless the same is established by
cogent
evidence.
In
this
regard, Mr.
Pruthi places
reliance
upon Saraswati Palariya v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd., 2018 SCC
OnLine SC 3988, wherein the Supreme Court held that the finding of
contributory negligence recorded by the High Court merely on the ground
that the deceased was driving the vehicle without a driving licence was
unsustainable. Driving without a driving licence may expose a person to
other liabilities, but no inference of contributory negligence can be drawn
on that basis alone. This principle has also been followed by a Coordinate
Bench of this Court in Saleem Ahmed v. Jaipal, 2024:DHC:9760. The
Court, therefore, has to examine whether negligence on the part of the
offending vehicle was established from the facts and circumstances of the
present case.
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:24:55
MAC.APP. 439/2025, MAC.APP 443/2025 & MAC.APP 680/2025
Page-6/17
14.
It is an admitted position that neither the owner nor the driver chose
to testify before the MACT, only a written statement was filed. It is noted
that the MACT had given an opportunity for respondents' evidence on 24th
February 2025. On 19th March 2025, the counsel stated that the respondent
no.1 was not in contact with him and he tried to reach out but he has not
been contacted nor has appeared before the Tribunal. Respondent no.1
was, therefore, proceed ex parte and the respondents' evidence was closed.
No steps were taken by the respondent/driver/owner to approach the
MACT in order to led evidence nor has any explanation been given by the
counsel for appellant.
15.
On the issue of negligence, whether the same has been established
or not, the following aspects are required to be noted. The site plan is
extracted below for reference:
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:24:55
MAC.APP. 439/2025, MAC.APP 443/2025 & MAC.APP 680/2025
Page-7/17
16.
It can be seen from the site plan that, in front of the Oberoi Maidens
Hotel, the collision took place at point A, which is situated on the extreme
left side of the road. This would indicate that the scooter was being driven
on the extreme left side of the road and cannot, therefore, be faulted
considering its position on the road being as per rules of road usage. It is
not a case where the scooter was being driven on the right side / middle of
the road, or in the fast lane. For the bus to collide with the scooter, which,
in any event, could not possibly have been travelling at a high speed,
considering that three persons were riding on it, clearly points towards
negligence on the part of the bus driver.
17.
Moreover, the mechanical inspection report of the scooter records
damage to its right side, whereas the mechanical inspection report of the
bus records damage to its left side. This clearly indicates that the bus was
on the right side of the scooter at the time of the collision. None of these
circumstances suggest any negligence on the part of the scooter driver. On
the contrary, they support the conclusion that the bus driver was at fault.
Apart from this, the submission of Mr. Pruthi also assumes relevance,
though it cannot by itself be determinative, that appellant had chosen to
plead guilty in the criminal proceedings and had not contested the said
proceedings.
Contributory Negligence
18.
This Court has considered the Supreme Court’s decision in Mohd.
Siddique v. National Insurance Co. Ltd., (2020) 3 SCC 57 where it was
held that triple riding a motorcycle, does not by itself makes a person
guilty of contributory negligence but only guilty of violation of law. There
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:24:55
MAC.APP. 439/2025, MAC.APP 443/2025 & MAC.APP 680/2025
Page-8/17
has to be a causal connection between the violation and the accident. The
relevant paragraph of judgment is extracted as under:
“12. But the above reason, in our view, is flawed. The
fact that the deceased was riding on a motorcycle along
with the driver and another, may not, by itself, without
anything more, make him guilty of contributory
negligence. At the most, it would make him guilty of
being a party to the violation of the law. Section 128 of
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, imposes a restriction on
the driver of a two-wheeled motorcycle, not to carry
more than one person on the motorcycle. Section 194C, inserted by Amendment Act 32 of 2019, prescribes a
penalty for violation of safety measures for motorcycle
drivers and pillion riders. Therefore, the fact that a
person was a pillion rider on a motorcycle along with
the driver and one more person on the pillion, may be a
violation of the law. But such violation by itself, without
anything more, cannot lead to a finding of contributory
negligence, unless it is established that his very act of
riding along with two others, contributed either to the
accident or to the impact of the accident upon the
victim. There must either be a causal connection
between the violation and the accident or a causal
connection between the violation and the impact of the
accident upon the victim. It may so happen at times, that
the accident could have been averted or the injuries
sustained could have been of a lesser degree, if there
had been no violation of the law by the victim. What
could otherwise have resulted in a simple injury, might
have resulted in a grievous injury or even death due to
the violation of the law by the victim. It is in such cases,
where, but for the violation of the law, either the
accident could have been averted or the impact could
have been minimised, that the principle of contributory
negligence could be invoked. It is not the case of the
insurer that the accident itself occurred as a result of
three persons riding on a motorcycle. It is not even the
case of the insurer that the accident would have been
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:24:55
MAC.APP. 439/2025, MAC.APP 443/2025 & MAC.APP 680/2025
Page-9/17
averted, if three persons were not riding on the
motorcycle. The fact that the motorcycle was hit by the
car from behind, is admitted. Interestingly, the finding
recorded by the Tribunal that the deceased was wearing
a helmet and that the deceased was knocked down after
the car hit the motorcycle from behind, are all not
assailed. Therefore, the finding of the High Court that 2
persons on the pillion of the motorcycle, could have
added to the imbalance, is nothing but presumptuous
and is not based either upon pleading or upon the
evidence on record. Nothing was extracted from PW 3
to the effect that 2 persons on the pillion added to the
imbalance.
13. Therefore, in the absence of any evidence to show
that the wrongful act on the part of the deceased victim
contributed either to the accident or to the nature of the
injuries sustained, the victim could not have been held
guilty of contributory negligence. Hence, the reduction
of 10% towards contributory negligence, is clearly
unjustified and the same has to be set aside.”
(emphasis supplied)
19.
For contributory negligence to be established, the same must first
be specifically alleged and thereafter proved. In the present case, however,
neither the driver nor the owner took any such position before the MACT,
nor did they lead any evidence whatsoever in support thereof.
20.
On the issue of contributory negligence arising from the victim not
possessing a valid driving licence, this Court in Reliance General
Insurance Co. Ltd v Smt. Kusum and Ors. 2026:DHC:6915 has
considered the said issue. The relevant paragraph of the judgment, which
traverses the law on the subject, is extracted below:
“9. As regards the issue of contributory negligence and
whether victim not having a DL can be ground of
attributing contributory negligence, the following
judgments can be relied upon:
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:24:55
MAC.APP. 439/2025, MAC.APP 443/2025 & MAC.APP 680/2025
Page-10/17
(i)
Sudhir Kumar Rana v. Surinder Singh, (2008) 12
SCC 436, wherein the Supreme Court while
deciding the issue of contributory negligence of a
minor, who did not possess driving license, held as
under:
“9. If a person drives a vehicle without a
licence, he commits an offence. The same, by
itself, in our opinion, may not lead to a finding
of negligence as regards the accident. It has
been held by the courts below that it was the
driver of the mini truck who was driving rashly
and negligently. It is one thing to say that the
appellant was not possessing any licence but no
finding of fact has been arrived at that he was
driving the two-wheeler rashly and negligently.
If he was not driving rashly and negligently
which contributed to the accident, we fail to see
as to how, only because he was not having a
licence, he would be held to be guilty of
contributory negligence.
10. The matter might have been different if by
reason of his rash and negligent driving, the
accident had taken place.”
(emphasis supplied)
(ii) Dinesh Kumar v. National Insurance Co. Ltd.,
(2018) 1 SCC 750, relied on the judgment of
Sudhir Kumar Rana (supra) and held as under:
“7. Once the finding that there was
contributory negligence on the part of the
appellant is held to be without any basis, the
second aspect which weighed both with the
Tribunal and the High Court, that the appellant
had not produced the driving licence, would be
of no relevance. This aspect has been
considered in a judgment of this Court
in Sudhir
Kumar [Sudhir
Kumar
Rana v. Surinder Singh, (2008) 12 SCC 436 :
(2009) 1 SCC (Cri) 443] where it was held as
follows : (SCC p. 439, paras 9-10)
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:24:55
MAC.APP. 439/2025, MAC.APP 443/2025 & MAC.APP 680/2025
Page-11/17
…
8. In view of the above position, we are of the
view that the deduction of forty per cent which
was made on the ground of contributory
negligence is without any basis. Accordingly,
we direct that the appellant shall be entitled to
an additional amount of Rs 4.60 lakhs which
was wrongly disallowed.”
(emphasis supplied)
(iii) Saraswati Palariya v. New India Assurance Co.
Ltd., 2018 SCC OnLine SC 3988, the Supreme
Court held as under:
“5. The finding of the High Court of
contributory negligence on the ground that the
deceased was driving the vehicle without a
driving license is equally unsustainable.
Driving without a valid driving license may
expose the claimant(s) to other liabilities but no
inference of contributory negligence can be
arrived on that basis.”
(emphasis supplied)
(iv)
Srikrishna Kanta Singh v The Oriental Insurance
Co. Ltd. & Ors. 2025 INSC 394, wherein the
Supreme Court while deciding the case of a
scooter driver only possessing a learner license
relied on the judgment of Sudhir Kumar Rana
(supra) and held as under:
“13. Sudhir Kumar Rana v. Surinder Singh was
a case in which the claimant, a minor of 17½
years, met with an accident while riding a two
wheeler, which collided with a mini truck.
Holding that ordinarily, negligence is only a
question of fact, it was found that when a person
drives a vehicle without a licence, he commits an
offence, which by itself cannot lead to a finding
of negligence, leading to or as regards, the
accident. Having found the trailer to be driven
rashly and negligently, we do not think that the
mere fact that the driver of the scooter had only
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:24:55
MAC.APP. 439/2025, MAC.APP 443/2025 & MAC.APP 680/2025
Page-12/17
a learners licence would necessarily lead to a
conclusion of contributory negligence on the part
of the scooter driver.”
(emphasis supplied)
(v) Mohd. Sabuddin v. Mohd. Zakir, 2024 SCC
OnLine Del 7159, a Coordinate Bench of this
Court noted as under:
“41. This Court has perused the record and found
that no driving licence or insurance of the
claimant's vehicle were placed on record.
Therefore, applying the aforementioned case
laws Mohd. Siddique v. National Insurance Co.
Ltd. as well as Sudhir Kumar Rana v. Surinder
Singh, this Court is of the view that mere absence of
driving licence and vehicular insurance does not
amount to contributory negligence on the part of the
claimant despite being a punishable offence under
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 as the same has no
impact on the accident and the grievous injuries
caused to the claimant.”
(emphasis supplied)
10. It is also noted that Sudhir Kumar Rana (supra) and
Saraswati Palariya (supra) have consistently been
followed by this Court as well as by other High Courts
in a catena of judgments namely, National Insurance
Co. Ltd. v. Sushila, 2019 SCC OnLine Del 10045;
Mohd. Sabuddin (supra); Saleem Ahmad v. Jaypal,
2024:DHC:976; United India Insurance Company Ltd.
v Smt. Sobhana & Ors., 2026:DHC:1653; Shivegowda
v. Nanjeshgowda, 2025 SCC OnLine Kar 14720; and,
Jacob v Santo K.T. & Ors. 2026:KER:28270.
11. Having considered the aforesaid judgments, the
legal position that emerges is that contributory
negligence cannot be inferred merely from the violation
of a statutory requirement by the victim. The essential
requirement is to establish a causal connection between
the act or omission attributed to the victim and either
the occurrence of the accident or the nature and extent
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:24:55
MAC.APP. 439/2025, MAC.APP 443/2025 & MAC.APP 680/2025
Page-13/17
of the injuries suffered. The burden of establishing such
contributory negligence lies upon the party alleging it,
and such finding must be supported by cogent evidence
rather than conjecture or presumption. Thus, the mere
absence of a driving licence, possession of an invalid or
learner’s licence, or any other violation of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988, may constitute a statutory
infraction, but cannot, by itself, justify a deduction from
compensation.”
(emphasis supplied)
21.
Moreover, in the same judgment, the Court had culled out the
principles as regards contributory negligence which are also extracted
below for ease of reference:
“15. The following principles as regards contributory
negligence can be culled out from the aforementioned
judgments:
I.
Contributory negligence requires proof of
negligence on the part of the victim which has
materially contributed to the accident or the
resulting injury.
II. The
determination
of
contributory
negligence is essentially dependent upon the facts
and circumstances of each case. The relevant test
is whether, by exercising reasonable care, the
victim could have avoided the consequences of the
negligence which caused the accident.
III. A mere violation of law by the victim does
not, by itself, constitute contributory negligence.
There must be a causal connection between such
violation and either the occurrence of the accident
or the impact/injury suffered by the victim.
IV. The burden of establishing contributory
negligence lies upon the party alleging it. Such
negligence must be established by cogent material
demonstrating that an act or omission attributable
to the claimant/victim materially contributed to the
accident or the injury suffered.
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:24:55
MAC.APP. 439/2025, MAC.APP 443/2025 & MAC.APP 680/2025
Page-14/17
V. The mere absence, invalidity, nonproduction of a driving licence, or possession of
only a learner’s licence, by itself, do not constitute
contributory negligence. Such violation may entail
statutory consequences, but a finding of
contributory negligence can be made only where it
is established by cogent evidence that such
violation has a causal connection with the
occurrence of the accident or the injuries suffered
by the victim.
VI. Where negligence is attributable to both
parties, the Court may apportion the loss between
them in such proportion as is just and equitable.
However, such apportionment necessarily
presupposes a finding of contributory negligence
on the part of the claimant; in its absence, no
deduction from compensation is warranted.”
(emphasis supplied)
22.
In view of the position of law as noted above, the plea of the
Insurance Company on the issue of contributory negligence is
unsustainable.
Compensation for Medical Expenses
23.
In MACT No. 953/2019, Smt. Lilawati was awarded compensation
of Rs. 3,000/- towards medical expenses. In MACT No. 954/2019, Smt.
Shashi was awarded Rs. 5,000/- towards medical expenses, while in
MACT No. 955/2019, Sh. Ravi was awarded Rs. 2,000/- under the same
head. The MACT has noted, in all three cases, that no medical bills or
other documents evidencing the expenditure incurred towards treatment
were placed on record. The MACT, nevertheless, observed that injured
persons may not always preserve or produce bills relating to their
treatment and, accordingly, awarded nominal amounts towards medical
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:24:55
MAC.APP. 439/2025, MAC.APP 443/2025 & MAC.APP 680/2025
Page-15/17
expenses, having regard to the injuries suffered by the respective
claimants.
24.
In the case of Smt. Lilawati, the MACT has recorded that she
suffered grievous injuries. It is, therefore, reasonable to assume that some
expenditure would have been incurred towards her treatment and
medicines. The award of a nominal sum of Rs. 3,000/- towards medical
expenses, in the facts and circumstances of the case, cannot be said to be
excessive or unreasonable. Similarly, Sh. Ravi suffered simple injuries, as
recorded in the MACT award, and the award of Rs. 2,000/-towards
medical expenses is also a reasonable and nominal amount. In the case
of Smt. Shashi, who sustained 25% functional disability, the MACT
awarded Rs. 5,000/- towards medical expenses. Having regard to the
nature and extent of the injuries suffered, the said amount is also
reasonable and does not warrant interference by this Court. The nominal
amounts awarded by the MACT towards medical expenses are, thus,
consistent with the principles of just and reasonable compensation.
Directions
25.
Since these appeals are dismissed, the compensation as awarded by
the MACT, along with accrued interest thereon, if not already deposited,
shall be deposited before the MACT within a period of four weeks from
the date of this judgment. The compensation, along with accrued interest,
shall thereafter be released to the claimants in all three appeals in
accordance with the scheme set out by the MACT in the impugned award.
26.
Accordingly, the appeals are dismissed.
27.
Pending applications, if any, are rendered infructuous.
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:24:55
MAC.APP. 439/2025, MAC.APP 443/2025 & MAC.APP 680/2025
Page-16/17
28.
Statutory deposit be refunded to appellant/Insurance Company,
only if the order of deposit has been complied with.
29.
A copy of this judgment be sent to the concerned bank for
information and compliance.
30.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
ANISH DAYAL
(JUDGE)
SEPTEMBER 17, 2026/sm/zb
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:24:55
MAC.APP. 439/2025, MAC.APP 443/2025 & MAC.APP 680/2025
Page-17/17
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review