Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
UKHC010082082023
2026:UHC:5087
Judgment Reserved on: 29.05.2026
Judgment Delivered on:19.06.2026
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE SUBHASH UPADHYAY
CIVIL REVISION NO.74 OF 2023
Hirdesh Sharma and Another
...Revisionists
Versus
Nazakat Ali Khan
Counsel for the revisionists
Counsel for the respondent
…Respondent.
:
:
Mr. B.D. Pande, learned counsel
Mr. M.S. Tyagi, learned Senior
Counsel assisted by Mr. Sunil
Chandra, learned counsel.
JUDGMENT: (per Mr. Subhash Upadhyay, J.)
The present civil revision under Section 25 of the
Provincial Small Causes Court Act has been filed against the
judgment and decree dated 10.05.2023 passed by the learned
Judge, Small Causes Court/ II Additional District Judge,
Haldwani, District Nainital in S.C.C. Suit No.20 of 2021,
“Nazakat Ali Khan Vs. Hirdesh Sharma and Another”. By the
said order, learned Judge, Small Causes Courts Act decreed
the suit of the respondent /plaintiff for arrears of rent,
damages and eviction.
2.
Learned counsel for the revisionists submits that a
suit for arrears of rent, damages and eviction was filed by the
plaintiff/respondent against the revisionists stating therein
that the plaintiff is the owner and landlord of House No.4-297
(at present House No.4-54) at Tanakpur Road, Haldwani
wherein the revisionists are occupying three rooms, kitchen
and washroom as tenant @ ₹600/- per month and the rent
UKHC010082082023
from 15.09.2015 to September, 2021 was due.
3.
2026:UHC:5087
The boundaries of the suit property as described in
the plaint were garden of the plaintiff in the east, road in the
west, house of the plaintiff in the north and in the south a
lane and, thereafter, the house of the plaintiff.
4.
As per the plaint, the father of the revisionists
Amarjeet Sharma S/o Buadutt Sharma was the original tenant
and after the death of Amarjeet Sharma the tenancy devolved
upon revisionist no.1 and the revisionist no.2, the son of
Amarjeet Sharma. The revisionist no.1 filed written statement
in the month of March 2022 wherein the relationship of
landlord-tenant was denied and it was contended that the
revisionists were never the tenant of the plaintiff.
5.
It was further averred that earlier a suit was filed by
the plaintiff against revisionist no.1 for eviction and arrears of
rent which was dismissed and the finding recorded in the
earlier suit that there was no relationship of landlord and
tenant between the plaintiff and revisionist no.1 has attained
finality in the Suit No.12 of 2004 deciced on 12.09.2015. It
was further stated in the written statement that the suit
property is on a nazool land which was given to Shri Achhan
Khan on lease and after his death his wife Chhunni Begum
used to collect rent from the predecessor of the revisionists.
After the death of Smt. Chhunni Begum the tenanted property
is under the Municipal Board, Haldwani. In the written
UKHC010082082023
2026:UHC:5087
statement, it was further stated that there is a dispute
between legal heirs of Acchan Khan and the plaintiff.
6.
In the evidence affidavit filed by the revisionist no.1
it was stated that the revisionists had vacated the suit
property and are residing in a different property purchased by
them from one Shri Ranjeet Singh. It was stated in the
evidence affidavit that earlier the electricity bill and water bill
were raised in the name of Ranjeet Singh and now the same
are being raised in the name of revisionist, as such, the
revisionists who had voluntarily vacated the suit property and
are now residing in a different property are no longer the
tenant in the suit property.
7.
The learned Trial Court, on the basis of the evidence
adduced before it, however, decreed the suit in favour of the
plaintiff/ respondent against which the present revision has
been preferred.
8.
Learned counsel for the revisionists assailing the
said order and in support of the revision filed before this Court
has summarized his submissions as hereunder:
1)
The revisionists had vacated the suit property
and are residing in a different property purchased
by them from Shri Ranjeet Singh.
2)
The revisionist’s predecessors were the tenant
in the suit property and revisionists were never the
tenant of plaintiff.
UKHC010082082023
3)
2026:UHC:5087
Suit No.12 of 2004 was filed earlier by the
plaintiff against the revisionist no.1 which was
dismissed
on
the
ground
that
there
was
no
relationship of tenant and landlord between the
plaintiff
and
revisionist
no.1,
as
such,
the
subsequent suit filed by the plaintiff was barred by
principle of res judicata.
4)
Though
in
the
written
statement,
the
revisionists had not stated that they had vacated
the suit property and are residing in a separate
property purchased from Ranjeet Singh, however, in
the evidence affidavit filed before the Court a
specific stand was taken to the effect that the
property was purchased by the revisionist no.1 from
Ranjeet Singh and the revisionists were residing in
the aforesaid property and not in the suit property.
5)
The documents filed before the Trial Court viz.
documents of purchase of property, photographs
and electricity bills were sufficient to prove that the
revisionist no.1 and his brother revisionist no.2 were
residing in a separate accommodation.
6)
The finding recorded by the learned Trial Court
that the revisionists were the tenant of the plaintiff
and were not residing in the property purchased
from Ranjeet Singh is totally perverse and is liable
UKHC010082082023
2026:UHC:5087
to be set aside.
9.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent
/plaintiff submitted that:
1)
The revisionists have changed their stand at
different
stages
of
the
case.
In
the
written
statement, there was no recital that the revisionist
no.1 had purchased the suit property and the
revisionists had only denied the relationship of
tenant and landlord.
2)
Though
the
stand
taken
in
the
evidence
affidavit (filed by revisionist no.1 on his behalf as
well as on behalf of revisionist no.2), in absence of
any
pleading
inadmissible,
in
the
however,
written
the
statement,
learned
Trial
was
Court
considered the evidence led by the revisionist no.1
and discarded the plea of the revisionists that they
had vacated the suit property and were residing in a
separate property purchased by Ranjeet Singh.
3)
The finding of fact recorded by the Trial Court,
on the basis of the evidence adduced, led to the
conclusion that the revisionists were the tenant in
the suit property and the tenancy was inherited by
them through their predecessors.
4)
In the earlier suit filed by the plaintiff against
the revisionist no.1 stating that the revisionist no.1
UKHC010082082023
2026:UHC:5087
was a tenant in one room set, the revisionist no.1
had taken a stand that he is residing in the three
room set (suit property) with his father who is the
tenant and, as such, the Trial Court had recorded a
finding and decided the suit by observing that
respondent no.1 was not a tenant and was residing
with his father in the three room set, however, after
the death of Shri Amarjeet Sharma, the revisionists
resided in the suit property and inherited the
tenancy. Thus, the subsequent suit is not barred by
principle of res judicata and the said issue was dealt
with by the learned Trial Court.
5)
In case the revisionists were disputing the title
of
the
plaintiff
in
the
suit
property
then
an
appropriate application under Section 23 of the
Small Cause Court Act could have been filed by
them, however, the revisionists have made only bald
allegations in the written statement disputing the
title of the plaintiff in the suit property.
6)
The question of title of the plaintiff with respect
to the suit property could be examined incidentally
and the contention of the revisionists in the written
statement that the property was a nazool property
and there was dispute between the legal heirs of
Acchan Khan was dealt with by the learned Trial
UKHC010082082023
2026:UHC:5087
Court, on the basis of the judgment passed by this
High Court in misc. writ petition WPMS No.3375 of
2019 and it was held that the plaintiff is the
owner/landlord of the suit property, on the basis of
the Will executed by Smt. Chhuni Begum w/o Late
Shri Acchan Khan.
10.
Heard learned counsel for the revisionists and the
plaintiff /respondent and perused the record.
11.
Learned Trial Court for adjuciation of the suit had
framed the following issues:
“1- D;k çLrqr okn ds jsl&tqfMdkVk ds fl)kUr ls ckf/kr gS\
2- D;k oknh o çfroknhx.k ds e/; Hkou Lokeh o fdjk;snkj ds lEcU/k LFkkfir pys vk jgs gS]
tSlk fd oknh }kjk dgk x;k gS\ ;fn gk¡a rks çHkko\
3- D;k çfroknhx.k ç'uxr lEifÙk ij 600@& :i;k çfrekg dh nj ls fdjk;snkj vkckn pys
vkrs gSa\
4- D;k çfroknh }kjk oknh ds yS.My‚MZ ds LoRo gksus ls bUdkj fd;k x;k gS] ftlls Hkh og
ç'uxr lEifÙk ls csn[ky gksus ;ksX; gS\
5- D;k çfroknh }kjk oknh dks fnukad 15-09-2015 ls flrEcj 2021 rd dk fdjk;k vnk ugha
fd;k x;k] ftl dkj.k og ç'uxr lEifÙk ls csn[ky gksus ;ksX; gSA
6- D;k uksfVl fnukafdr 02-09-2021 dh çkfIr ds ,d ekg ds mijkUr çfroknh ç'uxr lEifÙk
ls csn[ky gksus ;ksX; gSA
7- vuqrks"k\”
12.
The facts which are not in dispute in the present
case are that:
1)
The revisionists in the written statement had
not taken a plea that the tenanted premises was
vacated and they were residing in a separate house
purchased from Ranjeet Singh. The said stand was
taken for the first time in the evidence affidavit.
2)
The revisionist no.1 in the earlier Suit No.12 of
2004 filed by the plaintiff had taken a stand that he
is residing with his father who is a tenant of the
UKHC010082082023
2026:UHC:5087
plaintiff.
3)
The revisionists in the written statement had
claimed that the suit property is on nazool land and
was given on lease to Achhan Khan and after his
death his wife Smt. Chhunni Begum used to collect
rent from the predecessors of the revisionist.
4)
In the evidence affidavit filed by the revisionist
no.1 on his behalf and on behalf of revisionist no.2 a
stand was taken that revisionists are residing in a
separate house purchased from Ranjeet Singh and
the tenanted portion was in possession of the
revisionists till 2016 and the same was vacated
thereafter in the year 2016 itself. It was also
admitted that the predecessors of the revisionists
were residing in the tenanted portion since 1947.
13.
Learned Trial Court, on the basis of the evidence
adduced before it, decided Issue No.1 to 4 and held that the
suit was not barred by the principle of res judicata and the
relationship of landlord and tenant was established between
the plaintiff and the revisionists.
14.
With regard to the finding that there exists a
relationship of tenant and landlord between the parties, the
learned Trial Court reached to the said conclusion on the basis
of the fact that in the earlier Suit No.12 of 2004 the revisionist
no.1 was said to be a tenant of one room and therein the
UKHC010082082023
2026:UHC:5087
revisionist no.1 had taken a stand that he is residing with his
father in three room set as his son and not as a separate
tenant.
15.
The learned Trial Court in Suit No.12 of 2004, as
such, concluded that the relationship of tenant and landlord
between the revisionist no.1 and plaintiff on the one room set
alleged to be in the tenanted occupation of revisionist no.1
was not established. After the death of the father of revisionist
no.1, the tenancy was inherited by him from his father
Amrjeet
Sharma,
who
was
also
impleaded,
as
party/
respondent no.2 in the earlier Suit No.12 of 2004.
16.
Learned Trial Court also took note of the fact that in
the written statement filed in Suit No.12 of 2004 the father of
the revisionists Shri Amarjeet Sharma and the revisionist no.1
had admitted that there exists a relationship of tenant and
landlord between Shri Amarjeet Sharma and the plaintiff.
17.
Further the revisionists in the evidence affidavit had
submitted that they were residing in the suit property since
1947 though a stand was taken that the revisionists had
vacated the property in 2016. The learned Trial Court took
into consideration the fact that the revisionists had changed
its stand at every stage as in the written statement it was
stated that the suit property is on the nazool land; in the
evidence affidavit it was stated that the property was
purchased by revisionists from Ranjeet Singh; and again a
UKHC010082082023
2026:UHC:5087
stand was taken that the suit property was vacated in 2016.
The findings recorded by the learned Trial Court in paragraph
nos.30 to 37 of the judgment reads as under:
“30-
vc pwafd ;g fufoZokn rF; gS fd oknh }kjk iz'uxr lEifRr ds ,d dejs
ds ckcr iwoZ esa ,d [kQhQk okn la[;k 12@2004 ;ksftr fd;k x;k Fkk] ftlesa
izfroknh la0 1 ân;s'k 'kekZ vkSj mlds firk Lo0 vejthr 'kekZ }kjk viuk
tokcnkok nkf[ky dj bl ckr dks Lohdkjk Fkk fd iz'uxr lEifRr ij vejthr
'kekZ 600@& :i;k izfrekg dh nj ls fdjk;snkj vkckn pys vkrs gS tks fd
fopkj.k U;k;ky; }kjk ekuk x;k vkSj r; ik;k x;k fd fuxjkuh esa Hkh ;g fu.kZ;
;Fkkor jgk] ftlls vc izfroknhx.k ij ,LVksIiy dk fl)kUr ykxw gksrk gSA ,sls
esa vc bl okn esa izfroknhx.k }kjk mijksDr rF; ls bUdkj djus dk vFkZ ;gh gS
fd og fdjk;snkjh dh lEifRr ij ;su&dsu&izdkjs.k dCtk cuk;s j[kuk pkgrs gSa]
ftldh iqf"V muds }kjk bl okn esa nkf[ky tokcnkos ,oa lk{; 'kiFk i= ls Hkh
gksrh gSA
31- mijksDr okn esa izfroknhx.k igys vius tokcnkos esa ;g dFku ysdj
mifLFkr gq, fd iz'uxr lEifRr vPNu [kku dh Fkh vkSj mudh e`R;q ds mijkUr
;g lEifRr mudh iRuh NqUuh csxe dh gqbZ] ysfdu mudh e`R;q ds mijkUr]
D;ksafd ;g lEifRr utwy lEifRr Fkh] blfy;s mRrjk[k.M ljdkj dh gqbZA blds
mijkUr izfroknhx.k vius lk{; 'kiFk i= esa iqu% u;s dFkuksa ds lkFk mifLFkr
gq,] gkykafd i{kdkj vius nkos o tokcnkos ds dFkuksa ls ckgj tkdj lk{; ugha
ns ldrs gSaA blfy;s oSls rks izfroknhx.k ds dFku iBuh; ugh gSa] ijUrq U;k; dh
n`f"V U;k;ky; izfroknhx.k ds mu dFkuksa dk Hkh mYys[k ;gkW djuk U;k;ksfpr
ikrh gSA
32- izfroknhx.k ds lk{; 'kiFk i= esa dgs x;s dFkuksa ds vuqlkj ;g lEifRr
jathr flag dh Fkh vkSj ogh bldk igys fctyh ikuh dk fcy tek djrs Fks vkSj
tc mUgksus jathr flag ls bdjkjukes ds rgr eycs lfgr ;g lEifRr [kjhn yh
rks og bl lEifRr ds ekfyd gq,A vkxs pydj muds }kjk dqN QksVksxzkQ dkxt
la[;k 33x@3 yxk;r 5 nkf[ky fd;s gSa] tks fd izfroknhx.k ds vuqlkj oknh dh
iz'uxr lEifRr o mudh dCts okyh lEifRr] tks fd vyx&vyx gS] ds gSaA
izfroknhx.k ds }kjk bu QksVksxzkQl ds ek/;e ls ;g dgus dk iz;kl fd;k x;k
fd jathr flag dh lEifRr vkSj vPNu [kku dh lEifRr nksuksa vyx&vyx gSa vkSj
og yksx jathr flag ds lEifRr ij jg jgs gsSa rFkk muds }kjk vPNu [kku dh
lEifRr dk dCtk igys gh oknh dks lkSi fn;k FkkA
33- loZizFke ;fn izfroknhx.k }kjk iz'uxr lEifRr dk dCtk oknh dks ns
fn;k Fkk rks muds }kjk vius tokcnkos esa ;gh dFku ysdj vkus pkfg, Fks] ysfdu
izfroknhx.k us vius tokcnkos esa rks ,sls dksbZ dFku gh ugha fd;s rFkk vius
lk{; 'kiFk i= esa bl ckr dk dgha [kqyklk fd;k fd mUgksus oknh dks mldh
lEifRr dk dCtk dc ns fn;k FkkA blds vfrfjDr nkf[ky QksVksxzkQ dks lkfcr
ugha djk;k x;k fd ;g fookfnr Hkou ds gks] cfYd cgl ds nkSjku Hkh fookfnr
Hkou vkSj vius Hkou dh iqrkbZ ds jax dks ysdj cgl dh x;h vkSj U;k;ky; dks
nksuksa lEifRr vyx&vyx gksuk crk;k x;k] tcfd bl ekeys esa nks vyx&vyx
fcfYMx gksus dk dksbZ fookn izfroknhx.k }kjk iwoZ esa mBk;k gh ugh x;k vkSj vc
Hkh bl rjg ds lk{; ls vius dFkuksa dks lkfcr djus dk iz;kl fd;k x;k] tks
fd drbZ Hkh lk{; esa iBuh; nLrkost ugha gSA
34- blds vfrfjDr izfroknhx.k }kjk mijksDr okn esa lwph lcwr 33x ls
33x@2 lEcfU/kr cgh uEcj ,oa fctyh] ikuh ds fcy o la;kstu vkfn ds izi=
dkxt la[;k 33x@6 yxk;r 25 nkf[ky fd;s x;s gSa tks fd izfroknh la0&1
ân;s'k 'kekZ vkSj jathr flag ds uke gSA bu lc ds ckcr~ U;k;ky; dk er gS fd
cgh uEcj vPNu [kku ls lEcfU/kr izi= gS] ftl ij izfroknhx.k ds vuqlkj
iz'uxr lEifRr dk fooj.k bl lEifRr ls esy ugha [kkrk gSA bl ij oknh }kjk
UKHC010082082023
2026:UHC:5087
Li"V fd;k x;k fd vPNu [kku ds ikl ml txg vkSj Hkh lEifRr ekStwn gS rFkk
bl lEifRr esa ckn esa fuekZ.k bR;kfn Hkh gqvk gSA ,sls esa izfroknhx.k ds rdZ
vk/kkjghu gks tkrs gSaA
35- tgkW rd fctyh ikuh bR;kfn ds fcy dk iz'u gS] bl ij U;k;ky; dk
er gS fd fctyh o ikuh ds la;kstu ds vk/kkj ij fdlh Hkh O;fDr dks lEifRr
dk ekfyd ugha ekuk tk ldrk gSA blfy;s nkf[ky fctyh o ikuh ds fcy dh
QksVksizfr;kas dk dksbZ ykHk izfroknhx.k dks ugha fn;k tk ldrk gSA gkykafd Lo;a
izfroknhx.k vkxs ;g dgdj pys vk jgs gSa fd iz'uxr lEifRr o ftl lEifRr
esa og jg jgs gSa] og i`Fkd&i`Fkd gSaA ,sls easa izfroknhx.k }kjk vius gh dFkuksa ds
foijhr tkdj dFku fd;s tk jgs gSaA
36- izfroknhx.k ds vuqlkj muds }kjk ;g lEifRr jathr flag ls dz; dh x;h
gS] ftlds ckcr mlds }kjk lwph lcwr 51x ls ,d QksVks o viathd`r bdjkjukek
nkf[ky fd;k x;k g]S ftlds izfroknhx.k }kjk lkfcr Hkh ugh djk;k x;k gSA
blds vfrfjDr izfroknhx.k }kjk cgl esa bl rF; dks U;k;ky; }kjk iwNus ij
Hkh Li"V ugha fd;k x;k fd iz”uxr lEifRr ds ekfyd jathr flag dSls gq,A
nkf[ky bdjkjukek viathd`r vfHkys[k gS] ftls lkfcr djus rd dk iz;kl
izfroknhx.k }kjk ugha fd;k x;k gSA ,sls esa Li"V iznf'kZr gksrk gS fd izfroknhx.k
csgn pkykdh ls ckj&ckj vius dFkuksa dks cny jgs gSa vkSj feF;k lk{; ,df=r
dj i=koyh esa nkf[ky dj jgs gSaA
37- mijksDr okn esa ,d rjQ izfroknhx.k iwoZ [kQhQk okn la[;k 12@2004
esa oknh dks iz”uxr lEifRr dk ekfyd gksuk ,oa vius firk vejthr 'kekZ dks
bl lEifRr ij 600@&:i;k izfrekg dh nj ls fdjk;snkj gksuk Lohdkj dj pqds
gSa vkSj muds }kjk bl rF; dks Hkh Lohdkj fd;k x;k fd og yksx vius firk ds
lkFk mudk ifjokj gksus dh gSfl;r ij iz'uxr lEifRr ij fuokl dj jgs gSa]
ftlls Li"V gS fd Lo0 vejthr 'kekZ dh e`R;q ds mijkUr izfroknhx.k dks crkSj
okfjlku bl lEifRr dh fdjk;snkjh izkIr gqbZ gSA"
18.
With regard to the fact that the property was a
nazool land the learned Trial Court took into consideration the
registered sale deed filed by the plaintiff of the year 1935 of
Late Achhan Khan and the order passed by the High Court of
Uttarakhand in WPMS No.3375 of 2019 which was paper
no.52-C/2. The learned Trial Court also took into consideration
the statement of Jayant Kumar, DW-2 an employee of the
Nagar Nigam and DW-3 Chandan Singh an employee of the
PWD Department.
19.
The finding recorded by the learned Trial Court in
paragraph nos.38 to 48 of the order reads as under:
“38-
izfroknhx.k }kjk vius tokcnkos esa oknh ds ekfydkuk gd ls bUdkj dj
bl lEifRr dks ljdkj dh lEifRr gksuk crk;k gSA bl ij U;k;ky; ;g Li"V
UKHC010082082023
2026:UHC:5087
djuk vko';d ikrh gS fd oknh }kjk iz'uxr lEifRr [kqnkcD'k dh gksuk crk;k
x;k Fkk] ftlls vPNu [kku }kjk ;g lEifRr o"kZ 1935 esa dz; dh x;h Fkh vkSj
mudh e`R;q ds mijkUr ;g lEifRr mudh iRuh NqUuh nsoh dks izkIr gqbZA oknh
}kjk vius dFkuksa ds leFkZu esa 1935 dh jftLVªh dh lR; izfrfyfi dkxt la[;k
49x@2 yxk;r 6 i=koyh esa nkf[ky dh x;h gSaA ,sls ess oknh }kjk vius dFkuksa
dks fo'oluh; lk{; ls( tks fd ,d jftLVMZ nLrkost gS vkSj o"kZ 1935 dk gS(
ls fl) fd;k x;k gS] ftls i`Fkd ls lkfcr djus dh vko';drk ugha gSA
39- blds vfrfjDr ;gkW ij ;g Hkh egRoiw.kZ rF; gS fd vPNu [kku dh e`R;q
ds ckn mlds HkkbZ xqPNu [kku ds cPPkksa us NqUuh csxe ds fo:) vPNu [kku dh
lEifRr ds ckcr~ flfoy o jsoU;w ds dbZ eqdnes fd;sA NqUuh csxe bu lHkh
eqdneksa esa vPNu [kku dh lEifRr dh ekfyd gksuk ik;h x;h] ftls ekuuh;
mRrjk[k.M mPp U;k;ky; }kjk Hkh fjV fiVh'ku ¼,e@,l½ ua0 3375@2019 esa
ekuk x;k] ftldh izfr i=koyh esa lwph lcwr 52x@2 yxk;r 31 ekStwn gSaA
40- blds mijkUr iz'uxr lEifRr ij NqUuh csxe dh olh;r ds vk/kkj ij
oknh dk uke ntZ gqvk] ftlds ckcr udy [krkSuh 52x@40 yxk;r 41] oknh
}kjk nkf[ky dh x;h gSA blds vfrfjDr i=koyh esa uxj ikfydk easa Hkh oknh
dk uke iz'uxr lEifRr esa crkSj ekfyd pyk vkrk gS] ftlds ckcr u dsoy
uxjikfydk ds x`g dj fu/kkZj.k dh izfr 9x o mldh jlhn 10x i=koyh ij
nkf[ky dh x;h gS] cfYd oknh }kjk Lo;a iwoZ esa [kQhQk okn la[;k 12@2004 ds
fu.kZ; dh izfr ,oa uxj ikfydk dh dj fu/kkZj.k dh izfr o"kZ 2006&11 dh lR;
izfrfyfi lwph lcwr 26x ls 26@2 yxk;r 8 nkf[ky dh gSaA
41- oknh }kjk vius dFkuksa dks vius c;ku o lk{; ds ek/;e ls fl) fd;k
x;k gS tcfd izfroknhx.k }kjk gj txg vius c;kuksa o dFkuksa dks cnyk x;k
gSA izfroknhx.k }kjk ân;s'k 'kekZ dks Mh0MCY;w0&1 dss :i esa ijhf{kr djk;k
x;k] ftlesa mlds }kjk ;g dFku fd;k x;k fd&ftl Hkou esa og jg jgk gS
mlesa o"kZ 2016 ls iwoZ mldk uke ntZ ugha gS mls ml le; dh fLFkfr Kkr ugha
gS rFkk o"kZ 2016 ds mijkUr uxjikfydk esa jksd ds dkj.k mldk uke ntZ ugha
gqvkA oknh }kjk vuqfpr rjhds ls viuk uke uxjikfydk esa ntZ djk fy;k x;k
gSA mls iz'uxr lEifRr esa crkSj fdjk;snkj ntZ gksus dh igys dksbZ tkudkjh ugha
FkhA
42- bl izdkj bl xokg dks ;g iw.kZ tkudkjh pyh vkrh gS fd iz'uxr
lEifRr ij oknh dk uke crkSj ekfyd rFkk mlds o mlds firk dk uke crkSj
fdjk;snkj ntZ pyk vkrk gS] ysfdu ckotwn blds] mlds }kjk dksbZ dk;Zokgh u
fd;k tkuk rFkk iwoZ [kQhQk okn easa bl lEifRr ij vius firk dks 600@&
:i;k izfrekg dh nj ls fdjk;snkj Lohdkjuk] izfroknhx.k ds mijksDr okn ds
dFkuksa ds fo:) tkrk gS vkSj blls izfroknhx.k ds bl izdkj ds dFkuksa ls Li"V
iznf'kZr gksrk gS fd izfroknhx.k U;k;ky; esa LoPN gkFkksa ls mifLFkr ugha gq, gSaA
43- izfroknhx.k }kjk t;ar dqekj xokg tks fd uxj fuxe esa dk;Zjr gS] dks
crkSj Mh0MCY;w0&2 izLrqr fd;k x;k ftlesa xokg }kjk eq[; ijh{kk esa gh ;g
dFku fd;k x;k fd&oknh dk uke iz'uxr lEifRr ds ckcr 17 dejs ntZ
vfHkys[k gksus dh ckr dgrs gq, oknh dk uke ntZ gksus dh ckr dghA
44- blds vfrfjDr ftjg esa bl xokg us Li"V dFku fd;k fd& mls o"kZ
2006 ls o"kZ 2011 rFkk o"kZ 2016 ls o"kZ 2021 ds eVdh jftLVj dh tkudkjh
ugha gS mlus ekSds ij Hkou ugha ns[kkA og o"kZ 2006 ls o"kZ 2011 ls lEcfU/kr
eVdh jftLVj U;k;ky; eas ysdj ugh vk;k gSA mls bl ckr dh tkudkjh ugha gS
fd vejthr 'kekZ vFkok muds iq= ân;s'k 'kekZ o dey 'kekZ ds uke eksgYyk
Vudiqj jksM ds fdlh edku ds uke dj fu/kkZj.k uxj fuxe }kjk fd;k x;k gksA
45- bl izdkj bl xokg ds c;ku izfroknhx.k dks fdlh izdkj dk dksbZ ykHk
ugha igqapkrs gSa] cfYd blds c;ku ls oknh ds gh dFkuksa dks cy feyrk gSA
46-
blh izdkj izfroknhx.k }kjk Mh0MCY;w0&3 pUnu flag fltokyh dks
UKHC010082082023
2026:UHC:5087
ijhf{kr djk;k x;k tks fd ih0MCY;w0Mh0 foHkkx esa dk;Zjr gSa] us viuh eq[;
ijh{kk esa ;g dFku fd;k fd&utwy jftLVj la[;k 9 tks og vius lkFk yk;k gS]
esa vPNu [kku] utkdr [kku o NqUuh csxe esa ls fdlh ds uke ij dksbZ Hkh
lEifRr vafdr ugha gSA
47- bl xokg ls tc ftjg dh x;h rks mlus Li"V c;ku fn;k fd&;g
jftLVj o"kZ 1934 ls igys dk gS blds ckn ls bl jftLVj esa vkt fnu rd
dksbZ u;s bUnzkt ntZ ugha fd;s x;s gSA utwy jftLVj esa ek= tehau dk fooj.k
gSA ml ij fufeZr Hkouksa dk dksbZ fooj.k ugha gSA mls ekywe gS fd utwy Hkwfe;ksa
dh Hkh jftLVªh cSukek jftLVªkj dk;kZy; esa gqvk djrh FkhA
48- ,sls esa ;g Li"V gks tkrk gS fd izfroknhx.k us csgn pkykdh ls o"kZ 1934
ls iwoZ ds jftLVj dks xokg ds ek/;e ls U;k;ky; esa lkfcr djk;k] tcfd
iz'uxr lEifRr o"kZ 1935 esa fodz; dh x;h Fkh vkSj mlds mijkUr gLrkUrfjr
gksdj varr% oknh ds uke ntZ gqbZ tks fd oknh }kjk iw.kZr% fl) fd;k x;k gSA
izfroknhx.k }kjk uxj fuxe gY}kuh ls lwpuk dk vf/kdkj ds rgr lwpuk pkgh
x;h Fkh] ysfdu nkf[ky lwpuk vLi"V gS] D;kasfd [kqnk cD'k }kjk rks ;g lEifRr
1935 esa gh fodz; dj nh x;h Fkh] blfy;s izfroknhx.k }kjk nkf[ky ;g lwpuk
dsoy U;k;ky; dk /;ku HkVdkus ds fy;s nkf[ky dh gS] tks fd Li"V iznf'kZr
gksrk gSA”
20.
The issue with regard to the locus and title of the
plaintiff with regard to the suit property could be considered
as merely incidental in issue and not directly and substantially.
The Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Dr. Ranbir Singh Vs.
Asharfi Lal 1995 (6) SCC 580 held that the question of title
may
be
examined
incidentally
but
cannot
be
decided
conclusively in an eviction suit and it was held in paragraph
no.9 of the said judgment as follows:
“9. It may be pointed out that it is well-settled law that the
question of title of the property is not germane for decision of
the eviction suit. In a case where a plaintiff institutes a suit for
eviction of his tenant based on the relationship of the landlord
and tenant, the scope of the suit is very much limited in which
a question of title cannot be gone into because the suit of the
plaintiff would be dismissed even if he succeeds in proving his
title but fails to establish the privity of contract of tenancy. In a
suit for eviction based on such relationship the Court has only
to decide whether the defendant is the tenant of the plaintiff or
not, though the question of title if disputed, may incidentally be
gone into, in connection with the primary question for
determining the main question about the relationship between
the litigating parties. In LIC v. India Automobiles & Co. [(1990)
4 SCC 286] (SCC pp. 300-02, para 21) this Court had an
occasion to deal with similar controversy. In the said decision
this Court observed that in a suit for eviction between the
UKHC010082082023
2026:UHC:5087
landlord and tenant, the Court will take only a prima facie
decision on the collateral issue as to whether the applicant was
landlord. If the Court finds existence of relationship of landlord
and tenant between the parties it will have to pass a decree in
accordance with law. It has been further observed that all that
the Court has to do is to satisfy itself that the person seeking
eviction is a landlord, who has prima facie right to receive the
rent of the property in question. In order to decide whether
denial of landlord's title by the tenant is bona fide the Court
may have to go into tenant's contention on the issue but the
Court is not to decide the question of title finally as the Court
has to see whether the tenant's denial of title of the landlord is
bona fide in the circumstances of the case.”
21.
Thus, the finding of fact recorded by the learned
Trial Court on the question as to whether the plaintiff was the
owner /landlord of the property and the relationship of tenant
and
landlord
existed
between
the
revisionists
and
the
respondent are based on proper appreciation of facts and
cannot be termed to be perverse.
22.
The other finding recorded by the learned Trial Court
that the suit was not barred by principle of res judicata is also
based on proper appreciation of the evidence placed before it
and cannot be termed to be perverse.
23.
Learned counsel for the revisionists had argued that
the finding recorded by the learned Trial Court that the
revisionists were residing in the suit property and were not
residing in a separate property purchased by them from Shri
Ranjeet Singh is perverse. He submitted that the agreement
to sell, other evidence and the photographs enclosed were
sufficient to demonstrate that the revisionist was residing in a
separate property other than the suit property.
24.
This Court had considered the finding recorded by
UKHC010082082023
2026:UHC:5087
the learned Trial Court on the said aspects which are as
follows:
“32-
izfroknhx.k ds lk{; 'kiFk i= esa dgs x;s dFkuksa ds vuqlkj ;g lEifRr
jathr flag dh Fkh vkSj ogh bldk igys fctyh ikuh dk fcy tek djrs Fks vkSj
tc mUgksus jathr flag ls bdjkjukes ds rgr eycs lfgr ;g lEifRr [kjhn yh
rks og bl lEifRr ds ekfyd gq,A vkxs pydj muds }kjk dqN QksVksxzkQ dkxt
la[;k 33x@3 yxk;r 5 nkf[ky fd;s gSa] tks fd izfroknhx.k ds vuqlkj oknh dh
iz'uxr lEifRr o mudh dCts okyh lEifRr] tks fd vyx&vyx gS] ds gSaA
izfroknhx.k ds }kjk bu QksVksxzkQl ds ek/;e ls ;g dgus dk iz;kl fd;k x;k
fd jathr flag dh lEifRr vkSj vPNu [kku dh lEifRr nksuksa vyx&vyx gSa vkSj
og yksx jathr flag ds lEifRr ij jg jgs gsSa rFkk muds }kjk vPNu [kku dh
lEifRr dk dCtk igys gh oknh dks lkSi fn;k FkkA
33- loZizFke ;fn izfroknhx.k }kjk iz'uxr lEifRr dk dCtk oknh dks ns
fn;k Fkk rks muds }kjk vius tokcnkos esa ;gh dFku ysdj vkus pkfg, Fks] ysfdu
izfroknhx.k us vius tokcnkos esa rks ,sls dksbZ dFku gh ugha fd;s rFkk vius
lk{; 'kiFk i= esa bl ckr dk dgha [kqyklk fd;k fd mUgksus oknh dks mldh
lEifRr dk dCtk dc ns fn;k FkkA blds vfrfjDr nkf[ky QksVksxzkQ dks lkfcr
ugha djk;k x;k fd ;g fookfnr Hkou ds gks] cfYd cgl ds nkSjku Hkh fookfnr
Hkou vkSj vius Hkou dh iqrkbZ ds jax dks ysdj cgl dh x;h vkSj U;k;ky; dks
nksuksa lEifRr vyx&vyx gksuk crk;k x;k] tcfd bl ekeys esa nks vyx&vyx
fcfYMx gksus dk dksbZ fookn izfroknhx.k }kjk iwoZ esa mBk;k gh ugh x;k vkSj vc
Hkh bl rjg ds lk{; ls vius dFkuksa dks lkfcr djus dk iz;kl fd;k x;k] tks
fd drbZ Hkh lk{; esa iBuh; nLrkost ugha gSA
34- blds vfrfjDr izfroknhx.k }kjk mijksDr okn esa lwph lcwr 33x ls
33x@2 lEcfU/kr cgh uEcj ,oa fctyh] ikuh ds fcy o la;kstu vkfn ds izi=
dkxt la[;k 33x@6 yxk;r 25 nkf[ky fd;s x;s gSa tks fd izfroknh la0&1
ân;s'k 'kekZ vkSj jathr flag ds uke gSA bu lc ds ckcr~ U;k;ky; dk er gS fd
cgh uEcj vPNu [kku ls lEcfU/kr izi= gS] ftl ij izfroknhx.k ds vuqlkj
iz'uxr lEifRr dk fooj.k bl lEifRr ls esy ugha [kkrk gSA bl ij oknh }kjk
Li"V fd;k x;k fd vPNu [kku ds ikl ml txg vkSj Hkh lEifRr ekStwn gS rFkk
bl lEifRr esa ckn esa fuekZ.k bR;kfn Hkh gqvk gSA ,sls esa izfroknhx.k ds rdZ
vk/kkjghu gks tkrs gSaA
35- tgkW rd fctyh ikuh bR;kfn ds fcy dk iz'u gS] bl ij U;k;ky; dk
er gS fd fctyh o ikuh ds la;kstu ds vk/kkj ij fdlh Hkh O;fDr dks lEifRr
dk ekfyd ugha ekuk tk ldrk gSA blfy;s nkf[ky fctyh o ikuh ds fcy dh
QksVksizfr;kas dk dksbZ ykHk izfroknhx.k dks ugha fn;k tk ldrk gSA gkykafd Lo;a
izfroknhx.k vkxs ;g dgdj pys vk jgs gSa fd iz'uxr lEifRr o ftl lEifRr
esa og jg jgs gSa] og i`Fkd&i`Fkd gSaA ,sls easa izfroknhx.k }kjk vius gh dFkuksa ds
foijhr tkdj dFku fd;s tk jgs gSaA
36- izfroknhx.k ds vuqlkj muds }kjk ;g lEifRr jathr flag ls dz; dh x;h
gS] ftlds ckcr mlds }kjk lwph lcwr 51x ls ,d QksVks o viathd`r bdjkjukek
nkf[ky fd;k x;k g]S ftlds izfroknhx.k }kjk lkfcr Hkh ugh djk;k x;k gSA
blds vfrfjDr izfroknhx.k }kjk cgl esa bl rF; dks U;k;ky; }kjk iwNus ij
Hkh Li"V ugha fd;k x;k fd iz”uxr lEifRr ds ekfyd jathr flag dSls gq,A
nkf[ky bdjkjukek viathd`r vfHkys[k gS] ftls lkfcr djus rd dk iz;kl
izfroknhx.k }kjk ugha fd;k x;k gSA ,sls esa Li"V iznf'kZr gksrk gS fd izfroknhx.k
csgn pkykdh ls ckj&ckj vius dFkuksa dks cny jgs gSa vkSj feF;k lk{; ,df=r
dj i=koyh esa nkf[ky dj jgs gSaA”
UKHC010082082023
25.
2026:UHC:5087
This Court has also considered the copy of the
unregistered agreement filed by the revisionist no.1 before
the learned Trial Court which reveals that there was no
boundary mentioned in the said agreement.
Copy of the said
agreement which was filed before the learned Trial Court
reads as under:
Þbdjkjukek @ lEifRr dz;ukek
eSa fd ân;s’k 'kekZ] iq= LoxhZ; Jh vejthr 'kekZ] fuoklh rudiqj jksM] okMZ u0&4] gY}kuh] ftyk
uSuhrky dk gWaw vkSj bl bdjkjukes @ lEifRr dz;ukes dk çFke i{k gw¡ rFkk vki Jh jUthr flag]
iq= Lo0 bZ'oj flag] fuoklh eksaxk] iatkc ds gSa rFkk bl bdjkjukes @ lEifRr dz;ukes esa f}rh;
i{k gSaA
f}rh; i{k dk ,d cgqr iq'rSuh edku Vudiqj jksM] okMZ u0&4] gY}kuh] tuin uSuhrky esa fLFkr
gSA ftl edku dks vki çFke i{k ân;s’k 'kekZ }kjk ekg vçSy] 2014 esa eqc0& 9]75]000@& :i;s
e; eky eyqck ds dz; dj fy;k x;k gSA mDr edku tks fd 35x45 oxZ fQV ij cuk gqvk gS rFkk
cgqr iqjkuk fufeZr gS mDr bdjkjukes e/;s edku dh eqck0&5]00]000@& #i;s izFke i{k }kjk f}rh;
i{k edku Lokeh dks udn vnk dj nh x;h gS rFkk ’ks"k /kujkf’k eqck0&4]75]000@& #i;k fnukad
21-04-2016 dks udn vnk dj fn;k x;k gSA
vc mä edku ls lacfU?kr çFke i{k ls f}rh; i{k us dksbZ ysuk&nsuk 'ks"k ugha jg x;k gS rFkk
mDr edku dk dCtk çFke i{k dks ekSds ij ns fn;k x;k gSA blfy, ;g bdjkjukek@dz;ukek
vkt fnukad 21-04-2016 dks rgjhj :c: xokgku ds dj fn;k x;k gS rkfd lun jgs o oDr
t:jr dke vk ldsA
g0 izFke i{k dszrk
g0 f}rh; i{k edku fodzsrk
xokgA 1) ihrkEcj nRr fogkjh
2) ';ke fcgkjh yky d’;e
R/o jktiqjk gky fuoklh uSuhrky”
26.
The
said
agreement,
admittedly,
was
an
unregistered agreement wherein there was no boundaries of
the alleged house purchased by the revisionist no.1 from
Ranjeet Singh. The said unregistered agreement was not
admissible in evidence. The learned Trial Court thus rightly
concluded that the revisionists failed to prove that the
photographs enclosed by them were of different building and
in absence of any such stand taken in the written statement
the said evidence was not trustworthy. Here it would be
UKHC010082082023
2026:UHC:5087
apposite to take into consideration the view taken by the
Hon’ble Apex Court that any amount of proof offered without
pleadings is generally of no relevance. The Hon’ble Apex Court
in the case of Shivshankara Vs. H.P. Vedavyasa Char,
(2023) 13 SCC 1 in para 64 has held as hereunder:
64. In the decision in Duggi Veera Venkata Gopala
Satyanarayana v. Sakala
Veera
Raghavaiah [Duggi
Veera
Venkata Gopala Satyanarayana v. Sakala Veera Raghavaiah,
(1987) 1 SCC 254] this Court agreed with the observation
made in the earlier decision in Hasmat Rai v. Raghunath
Prasad [Hasmat Rai v. Raghunath Prasad, (1981) 3 SCC 103]
that any amount of proof offered without pleadings is generally
of
no
relevance.
In Duggi
Veera
Venkata
Gopala
Satyanarayana [Duggi
Veera
Venkata
Gopala
Satyanarayana v. Sakala Veera Raghavaiah, (1987) 1 SCC 254]
with respect to the aforesaid observations in Hasmat
Rai [Hasmat Rai v. Raghunath Prasad, (1981) 3 SCC 103] this
Court held, “we respectfully agree with the above statement of
law and reiterate the same”. Further, it is also relevant to refer
to para 85.6 of the decision in Union of India v. Ibrahim
Uddin [Union of India v. Ibrahim Uddin, (2012) 8 SCC 148 :
(2012) 4 SCC (Civ) 362] , which reads thus : (Ibrahim Uddin
case [Union of India v. Ibrahim Uddin, (2012) 8 SCC 148 :
(2012) 4 SCC (Civ) 362] , SCC p. 182)
“85.6. The court cannot travel beyond the pleadings as no
party can lead the evidence on an issue/point not raised in
the pleadings and in case, such evidence has been adduced
or a finding of fact has been recorded by the court, it is just
to be ignored. Though it may be a different case where in
spite of specific pleadings, a particular issue is not framed
and the parties having full knowledge of the issue in
controversy lead the evidence and the court records a
finding on it.”
27.
Thus, the finding recorded by the learned Trial Court
that the revisionists failed to prove that they were residing in
a separate property purchased by Ranjeet Singh cannot be
said to be perverse.
28.
This Court has also considered the finding recorded
by the learned trial Court with respect to issue no.5 and 6
wherein the learned Trial Court on the basis of the evidence
UKHC010082082023
2026:UHC:5087
adduced has recorded a finding that the notice dated
02.09.2021 was received by the revisionst and he was in
default of payment of rent. The said finding recorded by the
learned Trial Court does not suffer from any material
irregularity and in absence of any cogent evidence by the
revisionists this Court is in agreement with the reasoning
given by the Trial Court on the said issue.
29.
Thus, looking into the entire findings recorded by
the learned Trial Court, this Court is of the firm opinion that
there is no perversity in the order passed by the learned Trial
Court.
30.
In view of the above, the revision fails and the same
is, accordingly, dismissed.
31.
As a sequel thereto, the miscellaneous applications,
if any pending, shall stand closed.
___________________
SUBHASH UPADHYAY, J.
Dt:19.06.2026
Sukhbant
SUKHBA
NT SINGH
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND,
ou=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND,
2.5.4.20=71978f9c61bfde0ba69967c787b1764
ea7bc7dd129a8a6380d49b1885e628615,
postalCode=263001, st=UTTARAKHAND,
serialNumber=2D8B71B8D8E345F6B7F95B1D
D4FB4BEBD2B7D72C42261361AED33172F152
148D, cn=SUKHBANT SINGH
Date: 2026.06.19 14:01:39 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review