Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
%
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Judgment reserved on: 14.08.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 19.08.2026
#
CNR No. DLHC011986042018
+
O.M.P. (COMM) 355/2018
HINDUSTAN CONSTRUCTION CO. LTD.
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Dayan Krishnan, Sr. Adv
with Mr. Anirudh Bakhru, Mr.
Shreedhar Kale, Mr. Rishi
Agrawala, Ms. Shruti Arora,
Mr. Rajat Sinha, Ms. Tarini
Khurana and Mr. Alekshendra
Sharma, Advs.
versus
NHPC LTD.
.....Respondent
Through:
Mr. Neeraj Malhotra, Sr. Adv.
with Mr. Aslam Ahmed, Mr.
Rohit Jain, Ms. Ankita Sharma,
Mr. Abhishek Dwivedi, Mr.
Nimesh, Ms. Rithika, Mr.
Zeeshan Haider & Ms. Sheila
Arora, Advs.
#
CNR No. DLHC010212342020
+
O.M.P. (COMM) 446/2020
NHPC LIMITED
.....Petitioner
Through:
Mr. Neeraj Malhotra, Sr. Adv.
with Mr. Aslam Ahmed, Mr.
Rohit Jain, Ms. Ankita Sharma,
Mr. Abhishek Dwivedi, Mr.
Nimesh, Ms. Rithika, Mr.
Zeeshan Haider & Ms. Sheila
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 355/2018 & 446/2020
13:11:35
Arora, Advs.
versus
HINDUSTAN CONSTRUCTION COMPANY LTD.
& ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Shivam Goel, Mr. Anil
Kumar Goyal, Ms. Ramya
Shivam Goel, Ms. Sanya
Sharma and Ms. Ishika Kanyal,
Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AVNEESH JHINGAN
JUDGMENT
1.
These cross petitions are filed under Section 34 of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (for short 'the Act') challenging
the arbitral award dated 09.04.2018 (for brevity 'the award') passed by
the majority of the arbitral tribunal (hereinafter „the tribunal‟).
Brief Facts
2.
For convenience, the facts are taken from O.M.P. (COMM)
446/2020. The petitioner/NHPC invited bids on 10.12.2004 for
construction of a diversion tunnel and associated civil works for the
231 MW Chamera III Hydroelectric Power Project on river Ravi,
Himachal Pradesh. The respondent/HCCL was the successful bidder
and the Letter of Acceptance (for short „LoA‟) was issued on
21.09.2005. The contract was executed between the parties on
17.10.2005
for
a
value
of
Rs.504,87,10,000/-
inclusive
of
unconditional rebate of 32.4 per cent. The work was to be completed
within fifty-two months i.e. by 20.01.2010.
2.1
HCCL during execution of the work by filing ten applications
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 355/2018 & 446/2020
13:11:35
sought extension of time (for short „EOT‟) on account of various
hindrances. From time to time the extensions were granted till
16.03.2012. HCCL completed the work on 16.03.2012.
2.2
During the extended period HCCL raised claims towards
additional costs. By letter dated 23.02.2011, HCCL claimed Rs.149.78
crores for the period from 21.01.2010 to 25.01.2011 and by letter
dated 22.08.2011, a further claim of Rs.65.19 crores was raised for the
period from 26.01.2011 to 31.07.2011.
2.3
Dispute arose between the parties regarding grant of EOT and
the claim for additional costs for the extended period of work. The
arbitration clause 67.3 of the General Conditions of the Contract (for
short „GCC‟) was invoked on 09.09.2011 at the instance of HCCL.
2.4
HCCL raised claims before the tribunal for determination of
EOT, refund of Rs.7.62 crores deducted towards liquidated damages,
interest on Rs.15.49 crores deducted towards milestones 7 & 8 and
additional costs incurred during the extended period. The claims
relating to EOT, refund of liquidated damages and interest thereon
were subsequently withdrawn. The claim for additional costs incurred
during the extended period from 21.01.2010 to 31.07.2011 initially
quantified at Rs.195,33,70,354/- was reduced to Rs.143,04,78,453/-.
The tribunal awarded Rs.26,05,59,100/- towards on-site and headoffice overheads for the hindrance period along with interest at 6% per
annum while rejecting the claim for costs incurred during the extended
period. Hence, the present petitions.
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 355/2018 & 446/2020
13:11:35
Submissions of the Parties
3.
Learned Counsel for NHPC contends that the claim for
additional costs for the extended period was not payable and subclause 12.2 of the GCC provides for costs arising from an
unforeseeable physical obstruction. There was no breach on the part of
the NHPC which could make the NHPC liable for the costs claimed
by HCCL. It is submitted that HCCL having accepted the EOT on the
ground of unforeseen obstruction, has not put NHPC to notice in the
EOT applications that HCCL will claim additional costs for the
extended period and continued to execute the work even after
rejection of the claim. The submission is that the grant of EOT cannot
create an entitlement to costs for the entire extended period. Reliance
is on Jaiprakash Associates Ltd. v. NHPC Ltd., 2023 SCC OnLine
Del 3295, State of West Bengal v. Tapas Kumar Hazra, 2022 SCC
OnLine Cal 4663 and Morgan Securities & Credits Pvt. Ltd. v.
Samtel Display Systems Ltd., 2023 DHC 9041.
3.1
The grievance is that the tribunal after holding that HCCL was
not entitled to costs for the extended period, proceeded beyond the
provisions of the contract to award the claim on equity and in the
interest of justice. The submission is that the tribunal is a creature of
the contract and cannot impose an obligation not envisaged in the
contract. Reliance is on PSA Sical Terminals (P) Ltd. v. V.O.
Chidambranar Port Trust, (2023) 15 SCC 781, NHPC Ltd. v.
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 355/2018 & 446/2020
13:11:35
Jaiprakash Associates Ltd., 2023 DHC 3866, DMRC v. Kone
Elevators India (P) Ltd., 2021 SCC OnLine Del 5048 and Five-Star
Construction Pvt. Ltd. v. Orchid Infrastructure Developments Pvt.
Ltd., 2024 DHC 37-DB.
3.2
The submission is that the claim was awarded despite the
tribunal having recorded that the loss suffered due to overstay was not
proved by HCCL and that the Emden formula could only assist in
quantifying a loss and is not a replacement to prove the actual loss.
The argument is that this also applies to the claims for loss of profit,
overheads and supervision charges which require credible evidence of
the loss or of a specific opportunity lost due to prolongation. In the
absence of evidence adduced, the award of the claim based on a
formula or percentage basis is unsustainable. Reliance is on Bharat
Coking Coal Ltd. v. L.K. Ahuja, (2004) 5 SCC 109, State of
Rajasthan v. Ferro Concrete Construction (P) Ltd., (2009) 12 SCC
1, Unibros v. All India Radio, 2023 INSC 931 and Delhi Airport
Metro Express Pvt. Ltd. v. DMRC, (2022) 1 SCC 131.
3.3
The contention is that the tribunal interpreted clauses 6.4, 12.2,
40.2, 42.2 and 44.1 of the GCC and concluded that the claim for costs
during the extended period was not in consonance with the aforesaid
clauses. It is submitted that the interpretation of the contract is within
the domain of the arbitral tribunal and a possible view taken by the
tribunal cannot be interfered with under Section 34 of the Act.
Reliance is placed on McDermott International Inc. v. Burn
Standard Co. Ltd., (2006) 11 SCC 181, Steel Authority of India Ltd.
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 355/2018 & 446/2020
13:11:35
v. Gupta Brother Steel Tubes Ltd., (2009) 10 SCC 63, Sumitomo
Heavy Industries Ltd. v. ONGC Ltd., (2010) 11 SCC 296, MSK
Projects (I) (JV) Ltd. v. State of Rajasthan, (2011) 10 SCC 573,
Rashtriya Ispat Nigam Ltd. v. Dewan Chand Ram Saran, (2012) 5
SCC 306, Associate Builders v. Delhi Development Authority, 2014
SCC OnLine SC 937, Dyna Technologies Pvt. Ltd. (S) v. Crompton
Greaves Ltd. (S), (2019) 20 SCC 1, Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. v.
Shree Ganesh Petroleum Rajgurunagar (2022) 4 SCC 463, South
East Asia Marine Engineering and Constructions Ltd. (SEAMEC
Ltd.) v. Oil India Ltd., (2020) 5 SCC 164, Uhl Power Company Ltd.
v. State of Himachal Pradesh, (2022) 4 SCC 116, Hughes
Communications India Pvt. Ltd. v. Imaging Solutions Pvt. Ltd., 2023
SCC OnLine Del 2351 and Delhi Transco Ltd. v. KEC International
Ltd., 2025 SCC OnLine Del 3736.
4.
Per contra, sub-clause 12.2 read with clauses 40.2, 42.2 and
44.1 of the GCC entitles HCCL to costs arising from hindrances
resulting in extension of the contract period. The contention is that
sub-clause 12.2 nowhere restricts the claim to the period of actual
hindrance and there is no temporal limitation on the costs which may
be added to the contract price on account of physical obstructions and
the consequential extension of the contract period. It is submitted that
every hindrance do not necessarily result in extension of the contract
period and restricting the claim to the hindrance period imposes a
restriction not envisaged by the contract. Reliance is on the decision of
this court in NHAI v. HCC Ltd., 2014 SCC OnLine Del 3507 wherein
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 355/2018 & 446/2020
13:11:35
a similar clause of the contract was interpreted to include costs
incurred during the period extended consequent to hindrance. This
was affirmed by the Division Bench in 2016 SCC OnLine Del 1144
and upheld by the Supreme Court by order dated 21.09.2023 in Civil
Appeal No.3593/2017. The decision in Union of India v. Rama
Construction Co., 2022 SCC OnLine Del 1016 is also relied in
support of the claim for costs incurred during the extended period.
Further reliance is on PSA Sical Terminals Pvt. Ltd. (supra) to
contend that an arbitral tribunal cannot rewrite the contract or impose
an obligation not provided for under the contract.
4.1
It is submitted that the tribunal held that NHPC acknowledged
the entitlement of HCCL and made payments for the costs during
performance of the contract. The tribunal further recorded a finding
that HCCL suffered loss and used the Emden formula for
quantification of the amount to be paid. It is argued that the amount
awarded was not merely founded on the principle of equity but
followed the provisions of the contract with quantification made by
reference to the contractual formula and the Central Water
Commission guidelines (for short „CWC‟). The submission is that
once the loss was established for determining a reasonable amount of
compensation, accepted yardsticks can be applied. Reliance is placed
on R.K. Jain v. Bharat Aluminium Co. Ltd. (BALCO), 2025 SCC
OnLine SC 2857, Bharat Heavy Electricals Ltd. v. Delkon India Pvt.
Ltd., 2026 SCC OnLine Del 482 and Cobra Instalaciones Y
Servicios, S.A. & Shyam Indus Power Solutions Pvt. Ltd. (J.V.) v.
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 355/2018 & 446/2020
13:11:35
Haryana Vidyut Prasaran Nigam Ltd. (HVPNL), 2024:DHC:2880DB to contend that where the loss is established but exact amount
cannot be determined, the tribunal can make a reasonable assessment
and use guesswork for quantification.
4.2
It is submitted that HCCL initially sought relief in respect of the
EOT and upon amendment of statement of claim (for short „SOC‟)
specifically sought additional time-related costs for the extended
period from 21.01.2010 to 31.07.2011. The contention is that the
tribunal having permitted HCCL to amend SOC to seek the costs erred
in rejecting the claim by restricting the contractual entitlement to the
period of actual hindrance instead of determining the claim on
evidentiary merits. It is submitted that HCCL by letters dated
23.02.2011 and 22.08.2011 specifically raised and quantified claims
for additional costs incurred during the extended period but the
tribunal failed to give effect to the correspondence while considering
the claim.
4.3
HCCL relies upon the minority opinion wherein after
considering the relevant provisions of the contract and material on
record, the entitlement of HCCL to time-related costs was upheld. It is
submitted that the minority opinion can be relied upon to buttress the
challenge to the impugned award and the findings therein can be
considered by the Court under Section 34 of the Act. Reliance is on
the decision of the Supreme Court in Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran
Nigam Ltd. v. Navigant Technologies (P) Ltd., (2021) 7 SCC 657 to
fortify the contention that a party challenging an award can draw
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 355/2018 & 446/2020
13:11:35
support from the reasoning and findings in a dissenting opinion. It is
submitted that the minority opinion records that HCCL produced
contemporary records in support of claim including the auditor
certificates, books of accounts, labour registers, log books, equipment
invoices, monthly progress reports and vouchers and that witnesses
were examined. It is argued that NHPC failed to challenge the
material relied upon.
5.
Heard learned counsel for the parties at length.
6.
Before proceeding further, it would be apposite to reproduce the
following clauses of the GCC“Clause 1.1
Definitions and Interpretation
(g)(i) “cost” means all expenditure properly incurred or
to be incurred, whether on or off the Site, including
overhead and other charges properly allocable thereto
but does not include any allowance for profit.
Sub-clause 12.2
Not Foreseeable
Conditions
Physical
Obstructions
or
If, however, during the execution of the Works the
Contractor encounters physical obstructions or physical
conditions, other than climatic conditions on the Site,
which obstructions or conditions were, in his opinion,
not foreseeable by an experienced contractor, the
Contractor shall forthwith give notice thereof to the
Engineer, with a copy to the Employer. On receipt of
such notice, the Engineer shall, if in his opinion such
obstructions or conditions could not have been
reasonably foreseen by an experienced contractor, after
due consultation with the Employer and the Contractor,
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 355/2018 & 446/2020
13:11:35
determine:
(a) any extension of time to which the Contractor is
entitled under Clause 44, and
(b) the amount of any costs which may have been
incurred by the Contractor by reason of such
obstructions or conditions having been encountered,
which shall be added to the Contract Price,
and shall notify the Contractor accordingly, with a
copy to the Employer. Such determination shall take
account of any instruction which the Engineer may
issue to the Contractor in connection therewith, and
any proper and reasonable measures acceptable to the
Engineer which the Contractor may take in the absence
of specific instructions from the Engineer.
Clause 44.1
Extension of Time for Completion
In the event of:
(a) the amount or nature of extra or additional work,
(b) any cause of delay referred to in these Conditions,
(c) exceptionally adverse climatic conditions,
(d) any delay, impediment or prevention by the
Employer, or
(e) other special circumstances which may occur, other
than through a default of or breach of contract by the
Contractor or for which he is responsible,
being such as fairly to entitle the Contractor to an
extension of the Time for Completion of the Works, or
any Section or part thereof, the Engineer shall, after
due consultation with the Employer and the Contractor,
determine the amount of such extension and shall
notify the Contractor accordingly, with a copy to the
Employer.
Clause 44.2
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 355/2018 & 446/2020
13:11:35
Contractor to Provide Information and Detailed
Particulars
Provided that the Engineer is not bound to make any
determination unless the Contractor has
(a) within 28 days after such event has first arisen
notified the Engineer with a copy to the Employer, and
(b) within 28 days, or such other reasonable time as
may be agreed by the Engineer, after such notification
submitted to the Engineer detailed particulars of any
extension of time to which he may consider himself
entitled in order that such submission may be
investigated at the time.”
Analysis
7.
It would be apposite to mention that there is no dispute with
regard to the occurrence of the hindrance, grant of EOT and that
HCCL was paid for the work done during the extended period
including escalation costs.
8.
The tribunal first considered whether the delay was attributable
to NHPC. The communications inter se the parties and the letter
granting EOT dated 20.07.2013 whereby the time was extended from
21.01.2010 to 16.03.2012 were considered. It was also taken note of
that the EOT was granted under sub-clause 12.2 of the GCC for
unforeseeable obstructions. The conclusion was that there was no
breach of contract or failure or neglect on the part of NHPC in
carrying out the obligations to be undertaken by it.
9.
The tribunal dealt with the claim of additional costs incurred by
HCCL during the extended period from 21.01.2010 to 31.07.2011.
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 355/2018 & 446/2020
13:11:35
The definitions of contract price and costs and the following subclauses of the GCC were considered:
10.
Clauses of the GCC
Title
6.4
Delays and Cost of Delay
of Drawings
12.2
Not Foreseeable Physical
Obstructions or Conditions
42.2
Failure to Give Possession
44.2
Contractor to Provide
Notification and Detailed
Particulars
44.3
Interim Determination of
Extension
53.1
Notice of Claims
53.2
Contemporary Records
53.4
Failure to comply
53.5
Payment of claims
It was concluded that the claim of costs during the extended
period was not permissible under the clauses of the contract and that
HCCL was entitled to claim additional costs for the hindrance period.
The tribunal held that the clauses provided that a claim for additional
payment should be supported by contemporaneous records but HCCL
failed to produce it. It was noted that HCCL was paid for the work
done during the extended period and also the escalation charges.
11.
The tribunal inferred that according to HCCL the claim for
additional costs was also to be made for the hindrance period. The first
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 355/2018 & 446/2020
13:11:35
and the second requests by HCCL for EOT were relied upon wherein
the claim of Rs.14 crores for the hindrance period was made and not
for the extended period. The engineer in-charge under sub-clause 12.2
of the GCC approved a claim of Rs.3.67 crores and it was accepted by
HCCL in lieu of the expenses incurred during the hindrance period. It
was held that HCCL by its conduct had waived the right to claim
additional costs for the extended period. The tribunal deduced that
HCCL was estopped from claiming additional costs for executing the
work during the extended period.
12.
The tribunal held that sub-clause 12.2 of the GCC is not
applicable to the extended period of the contract but provides for
claiming costs during the hindrance period. Despite holding that under
sub-clause 12.2 of the GCC, HCCL could not claim off-site and onsite costs incurred during the extended period, the tribunal proceeded
to deal with the claim on the premise that HCCL was entitled to such
costs.
13.
The sub-clause 12.2 of GCC deals with unforeseeable physical
obstructions or conditions not foreseeable by an experienced
contractor. It provides that in case the contractor during the execution
of the work faces a physical obstruction or condition on the site other
than the climatic conditions, a notice shall be issued to the engineer
with a copy to the employer. The engineer if so opines that the
obstructions or conditions could not have been reasonably foreseen
shall determine after consultation with the employer: (a) the time to be
extended as per the entitlement of the contractor under clause 44 and
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 355/2018 & 446/2020
13:11:35
(b) add to the contract price the cost that may have been incurred by
the contractor consequent to obstructions or conditions. The
determination shall be notified to the contractor accordingly, with a
copy to the employer.
14.
The only possible interpretation of sub-clause 12.2 is that the
EOT, costs incurred due to unforeseeable physical obstruction or
condition at the site are to be determined by the engineer after
consultation with the employer. The use of word „may‟ in subparagraph 12.2(b) is in relation to costs which might or might not have
been incurred for the reason of such obstruction or condition and gives
no leverage that the costs incurred are not to be proved.
15.
The financial statements relied upon by HCCL along with the
auditor certificate were found to be unreliable. It was held that the
actual expenses incurred during the extended period were not proved,
yet the tribunal proceeded on equity basis to quantify the overhead
costs and supervision charges. Relying upon clause 52.1 of the
Conditions of Particular Application (for short „COPA‟) and para 3.5
of the CWC guidelines the tribunal awarded 20% of the prime cost for
the period of hindrance.
16.
Despite holding that under sub-clause 12.2 of the GCC the
claim for costs incurred during the extended period is not
maintainable, the tribunal relying upon clauses of COPA and CWC
guidelines proceeded to quantify the costs incurred when there was no
occasion for doing so.
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 355/2018 & 446/2020
13:11:35
17.
Another aspect is that the tribunal having held that HCCL failed
to prove the expenses incurred and that the Emden Formula cannot be
relied upon, proceeded to quantify the costs incurred by relying upon
the clauses of COPA and CWC guidelines. The parties were not
confronted with the clauses of COPA and CWC guidelines and the
award is vitiated for being violative of principles of natural justice and
Section 24(3) of the Act. Section 24(3) of the Act is reproduced.
“Section 24(3) All statements, documents or other
information supplied to, or applications made to the
arbitral tribunal by one party shall be communicated to
the other party, and any expert report or evidentiary
document on which the arbitral tribunal may rely in
making its decision shall be communicated to the
parties.”
18.
The
Supreme
Court
in
Ssangyong
Engineering
and
Construction Company Ltd v. NHAI, (2019) 15 SCC 131 held that
reliance upon material obtained behind the back of a party without
affording an opportunity to rebut it, is a ground available under
Section 34(2)(a)(iii) of the Act to challenge the award. The relevant
para is reproduced below:
“41. What is important to note is that a decision which is
perverse, as understood in paras 31 and 32 of Associate
Builders [Associate Builders v. DDA, (2015) 3 SCC 49:
(2015) 2 SCC (Civ) 204], while no longer being a ground
for challenge under “public policy of India”, would
certainly amount to a patent illegality appearing on the
face of the award. Thus, a finding based on no evidence at
all or an award which ignores vital evidence in arriving at
its decision would be perverse and liable to be set aside on
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 355/2018 & 446/2020
13:11:35
the ground of patent illegality. Additionally, a finding
based on documents taken behind the back of the parties
by the arbitrator would also qualify as a decision based on
no evidence inasmuch as such decision is not based on
evidence led by the parties, and therefore, would also have
to be characterised as perverse.
***
***
***
***
51. Sections 18, 24(3) and 26 are important pointers to
what is contained in the ground of challenge mentioned in
Section 34(2)(a)(iii). Under Section 18, each party is to be
given a full opportunity to present its case. Under Section
24(3), all statements, documents, or other information
supplied by one party to the Arbitral Tribunal shall be
communicated to the other party, and any expert report or
document on which the Arbitral Tribunal relies in making
its decision shall be communicated to the parties. Section
26 is an important pointer to the fact that when an expert's
report is relied upon by an Arbitral Tribunal, the said
report, and all documents, goods, or other property in the
possession of the expert, with which he was provided in
order to prepare his report, must first be made available to
any party who requests for these things. Secondly, once the
report is arrived at, if requested, parties have to be given an
opportunity to put questions to him and to present their
own expert witnesses in order to testify on the points at
issue.
52. Under the rubric of a party being otherwise unable to
present its case, the standard textbooks on the subject have
stated that where materials are taken behind the back of the
parties by the Tribunal, on which the parties have had no
opportunity to comment, the ground under Section
34(2)(a)(iii) would be made out.”
(emphasis supplied)
19.
The impugned award has contradictions. The tribunal held that
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 355/2018 & 446/2020
13:11:35
HCCL was not entitled to claim costs incurred during the extended
period yet proceeded in the interest of justice to deal with the issue
and ultimately awarded the costs on equity basis.
20.
It is trite law that an arbitral tribunal is bound by the terms
agreed between the parties and cannot invoke equity in a commercial
transaction to travel beyond the terms and conditions of the contract.
The tribunal is to act within the four corners of the clauses agreed
between the parties even if these appear to be unfair to the tribunal and
the equities cannot be balanced. Reference in this regard be made to
the following decisions:
20.1 The Supreme Court in PSA Sical Terminals (P) Ltd. (supra)
held:
“89. It has been held that an Arbitral Tribunal is not a
court of law. Its orders are not judicial orders. Its
functions are not judicial functions. It cannot exercise
its powers ex debito justitiae. It has been held that the
jurisdiction of the arbitrator being confined to the four
corners of the agreement, he can only pass such an
order which may be the subject-matter of reference.”
20.2 In Indian Oil Corpn. Ltd. v. Shree Ganesh Petroleum, (2022)
4 SCC 463 held:
“43. An Arbitral Tribunal being a creature of contract,
is bound to act in terms of the contract under which it
is constituted. An award can be said to be patently
illegal where the Arbitral Tribunal has failed to act in
terms of the contract or has ignored the specific terms
of a contract.”
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 355/2018 & 446/2020
13:11:35
20.3 In State of Chhattisgarh v. SAL Udyog (P) Ltd., (2022) 2 SCC
275 held:
“26. ………. We are, therefore, of the view that failure
on the part of the learned sole arbitrator to decide in
accordance with the terms of the contract governing the
parties, would certainly attract the “patent illegality
ground”, as the said oversight amounts to gross
contravention of Section 28(3) of the 1996 Act, that
enjoins the Arbitral Tribunal to take into account the
terms of the contract while making an award. The said
“patent illegality” is not only apparent on the face of
the award, it goes to the very root of the matter and
deserves interference……….”
20.4 In Bharat Coking Coal Ltd. v. Annapurna Construction,
(2003) 8 SCC 154 held:
“22. There lies a clear distinction between an error
within the jurisdiction and error in excess of
jurisdiction. Thus, the role of the arbitrator is to
arbitrate within the terms of the contract. He has no
power apart from what the parties have given him
under the contract. If he has travelled beyond the
contract, he would be acting without jurisdiction,
whereas if he has remained inside the parameters of the
contract, his award cannot be questioned on the ground
that it contains an error apparent on the face of the
record.”
20.5 The Division Bench of this court in Five Star Construction (P)
Ltd. v. Orchid Infrastructure Developers (supra) held:
“30. .....The learned arbitrator's conclusions could have
been based only on the claims raised by the parties. An
arbitrator cannot award an amount that he may feel is
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 355/2018 & 446/2020
13:11:35
just to a party in the interest of justice, when there is no
specific claim in that regard. The learned arbitrator
thus, has exceeded his mandate and jurisdiction by
awarding a sum of Rs 4,33,877.”
(emphasis supplied)
21.
It is recorded in the impugned award that no claim for
additional costs incurred during the hindrance period was made.
Paragraph 53 of the award is quoted below:
“53. Since the parties were not ad idem on the
construction of the clauses, we have analyzed the
clauses and are of the opinion that the Claimant is not
entitled to claim the said additional costs during the
extended period but it is entitled to the additional costs
during the hindrance period, which unfortunately it has
failed to claim.”
The tribunal categorically held that HCCL was not entitled to claim
additional costs during the extended period and that HCCL failed to
make a claim for additional costs during the hindrance period. Despite
this finding, the tribunal awarded Rs.26,05,59,100/- towards on-site
and head-office overheads for the hindrance period along with VAT
and labour cess thereon. The tribunal granted relief for a claim not
raised before it. The award travels beyond the scope of submissions
made before the tribunal and falls within the teeth of Section
34(2)(a)(iv) of the Act which reads as under:
“Section 34(2)(a)(iv) —the arbitral award deals with a
dispute not contemplated by or not falling within the
terms of the submission to arbitration, or it contains
decisions on matters beyond the scope of the submission
to arbitration:
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 355/2018 & 446/2020
13:11:35
Provided that, if the decisions on matters submitted to
arbitration can be separated from those not so submitted,
only that part of the arbitral award which contains
decisions on matters not submitted to arbitration may be
set aside; or”
22.
The impugned award has contradiction, travels beyond the
clauses of the contract, ignores the relevant clauses of the contract,
suffers from patent illegality and is unsustainable.
23.
Having held that the impugned award is liable to be set aside,
the other grounds raised by the learned counsel for the parties need not
be dilated upon.
24.
In view of the above discussion, the impugned award is set
aside.
25.
The petitions under Section 34 of the Act are accordingly
disposed of.
AVNEESH JHINGAN, J
AUGUST 19, 2026
‘JK’
Reportable:-Yes
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 355/2018 & 446/2020
13:11:35
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review