Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3302 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE NINETEENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K. SARATH
WRIT PETITION NO: 39196 OF 2025
Between:
1. Hindustan Coca-Cola Beverages P\i,t Ltd, 44-69, Moula Ali, Hyderabad - 500
2. Hindustan Coca-Cola Beverages P!{ Ltd, Abul Fazal Road, Bengali Market,
New Delhi -1 10 001 , (Now at Unit Nos. 303 and 304, 3rd Floor, Baani
Address One, Golf Course Road, Sector- 56, Gurugram- 122011, Haryana)
Both are Rep. by its Cluster HR Head -Commercial Human Resources, Mr.
Manish Pruthi
...PETITIONERS
AND
Mr. G. Yadaiah, S/o Sri Jangaiah, Aged about 55 years R/o Flat No.13,
Tirumala Apartments Tirumamnagar, H.B. Colony, Moula-Ali Hyderabad - 500
2. The Appellate Authority under Section 4B(3) of the Telangana Shops &
Establishments Act, 1988-and-Deputy Commissioner of Labour, Ranga
Reddy T. Anjaiaj Karmika Sankshema Bhavan RTC X Roads, Hyderabad 500 020
3. The Authority under Section 48(1) of the Telangana Shops and
Establishments Act, 1988-and-Asst Commissioner of Labour, MedchalMalkajgiri District lntegrated District Office Complex Anthaipally Village,
Shameerpet Mandal Medchal-Malkajgiri District Telangana - 500 078
4. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary Labour, Employment,
Training & Factories (Lab) Department, Telangana Secretariat Hyderabad 500 022.
5. The Commissioner of Labour, State of Telangana T. Anjaiah Karmika
Sankshema Bhavan RTC X Roads, Hyderabad - 500 020
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 ot the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to a) Call for the records culminating in the impugned Order dated
1311012025 passed by the Respondent No.2 i.e., the Appellate Authority under
Section a8(3) of the Telangana Shops and Establishments Act, 1988-and- the
Deputy commissioner of Labour, Ranga Reddy at Hyderaba,l herein in l.A. No.2
of 2024 in S.A. No. 1 of 2024 in SE No.2 of 2018 b) cr ash the aforesaid
impugned order by issuance of a writ, more particularly one in the nature of a
writ of certiorari or any other appropriate writ, order r r Direction, while
declaring it as wholly perverse, erroneous, arbitrary, contrary' to raw and without
jurisdiction, and a) consequen y, direct the Learned Respor r ent No.2 to decide
the Second Appeal in S.A. No. 1 of 2024 on merits.
lA NO: 'l OF 2025
Petition under section 151 cpc praying that in the ci, rumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High courl nay be pleased ro
suspend the operation of the order dated 13t1ot2025 passerl cy ihe Respondent
No.2 i.e., the Appellate Au-thority under section 48(3) of il-r ierangana Shops
and Establishments Act, 1988-and-the Deputy commission,-. of Labiour, Ranga
Reddy at Hyderabad herein in l.A. No.2 of 2024 in s A. No. 1 tf 2024 in sg ruo.z
of 2018, pending disposal of the Writ petition.
lA NO: 1 OF 2026
WRIT PETITION NO: 39196 OF 2025
Between:
Mr. G. Yadaiah, S/o Sri Jangaiah, Aged about 55 years tt r Flat No.13,
Tirumala Apartments Tirumamnagar] H.B. Colony, Moulrr \li ffyaeiaLit _ SOO
...Petitioners
AND
2.
M/s. Hindustan Coca-Cola Beverages pvt Ltd, 44-69, tv r ula Ali, Hyderabad _
500 040
M/s. Hindustan Coca-Cola Beverages pvt Ltd, Abul f azal Road, Bengali
Market, New Delhi -110 001,
(Now a! Unit Nos. 303 and 304,3rd Floor, Baani Addn:,s One, Golf Course
Road, Sector- 56, Gurugram- ,t_22011, Haryana) Both ar , R;p. by ,t; Cir;6;
HR Head -Commercial Human RGsoul"ui ffi -ni"nE'h pr rthi
Section 48(3) of the Tetar r ana Shops &
I!."-lpfSllqt:.euthoriv^under
EstaDttshments Act. 1988-and-Deputy Commissioner of i lbour, Ringa
Anjaiaj Karmika Sankshbmi enavJn RiCX-n: rOs,-rivdeijiad BS^OO^V^I
500 020
The Authority.under S^e_ction 48(1 ) of the Telangana Shcp ; and
Establishments Act, 1988-and-Asst Commissio-ner of Lai rur, Medchal_
M.alkajgiri District rntegrated District office compieinnflr ,ipdtty Vittage,
Shameerpet Mandat f\Iedchat-Matkajgiri OislriiiTelangar -r _ 5O0 078
5 The state of relanoana Rep by its principar secretary rbour,
:
Emproyment,
and Facto-ries (Labi De'p;rrm;n, 1"h-'.grr;-3€(-erariat Hyderabad _
Il*ryru
500 022.
J
The Commissioner of Labour, State of Telangana T. Anjaiah Karmika
Sankshema Bhavan RTC X Roads, Hyderab-d - 500 020
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
vacate the interim stay granted on 1911212025 and dismiss the writ petition.
Counsel for the Petitioners: SRI G.V.S. GANESH
Counsel for the Respondent No.1: SMT. P.K. KALYANI REPRESENTING FOR
SRI AMANCHARLA V. GOPALA RAO
Counsel for the Respondent No.2 to 5: GP FOR LABOUR
The Court made the following: ORDER
l
I
SK..I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF
TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE K.SAR.F.']H
WRIT PETITION No.39196 OF 2o2ti
DATE: L9.02.2o26
Between:
M/s Hindustan Coca-Cola I3everages Pvt Ltd and
another
Petitioner
I
AND
G.Yadaiah and thrce others
...R,:;pondents
ORDER:
This writ petition is filed questrr ning the
impunged order dated 13.10.2025 in I.A.No 2 of 2024
in S.A.No. I of 2024 in S.E.No.2 of 2018 pa;;ed by the
respondent No.2 i.e. the Appellatc Author.j y
under
Secton 4A (3) of the Telangana Sl ops and
Establishment Act, 1988, whcreby the petiti rners were
directed to deposit an amount of Rs. l,'.,- I ,49,229 / towards back wages in lavour o[ the respor r r:nt No. 1
2.
Heard Sri G.V.S.Ganesh, learned Cour sel for the
petitioner and Smt.P.K.Kalyani, learnec Counsel
;
SK, J
appearing for Sri Amancharla V.Gopa,la Rao, learned
Counsel for the respondent No. l.
3.
The learned Counsel for the petitioners submits
that the respondent No. t hercin, who .u,as worked as
Foreman(Forklift) in the petitioners, company and
promoted to the post ol Maintenance Supervisor in the
yeff, 2OOO, subsequently he was redesignated as
Executive-Maintenance. Whilc the respondent No. 1
was working as
Supervisor at Maintenance
Department, Moula-Ali Branch, Hyderabad, he was
terminated from services vidc proceedings dated
10.06.2008 on the ground that the respondent No.1
has violated the code of provisions reiating to
'business and financial records and dealing with
customers, suppliers and consumers by obtaining
forged quotations from thc vendors inappropriately.
4.
The learned Counsel for the petitioner-company
further submits that, being aggrieved by the
SK,.J
termination order, the respondent No. I filec petition
under Section 2-A (21 of Industria-l Dispute ! ct, 1947
(for short 'ID Act') vide I.D.No.190 of . 0O9 for
reinstatement into service with full back v', iges and
continuity of service and after hearing botli ;ides the
Labour Court dismissed the petition file: by the
respondent No. i
herein on 05.O1.2016 hol ling that
the respondent No.1 does not come with the .lefinition
o[ Workman'under Section 2(s) of the ID Ac:1
5.
The learned Counsel for the petitioner company
further submits that aggrieved dismissa-I or ler dated
05.01.2016 in ID No.L9O of 2OO9, the rr spondent
No l hled appeal vide SE No.2 of 2O18 on th: lile of the
respondent No.3 and the salne was al ou,ed on
08.O1.2024 by setting aside the terminatior: .rrrier and
directed the petitioner company to rei I state the
respondent No.1 herein with full ba: < wages,
continuity of service and all other attendzr;r benefits.
l
I
J
SIi, J
Being aggrieved by the same, the petitioner company
Iiled Second Appeal under Section 48 (3) of the SE Act
before the respondent No.2 duly depositing
Rs.26,06,99O/- towards back-wages of the respondent
No.1 and the appeal rvas numbered as SA No' 1 of
2024.
6. The learned Counsel for the petitioner-company
further submits that the respondent No' 1 filed
I.A.No. I of 2024 in S.A.No' I of 2024 stating that he is
unemployed from the date of termination of his
services till date and as such he entitled to the
.payment of salary ftom 12.02.2024 i'e' date ol hling
the Second Appeal and also filed I'A No '2 ol 2024
stating the amount deposited by the petitioner
company is inadequate and claimed balance amount of
Rs.|,24,49,229 l- by adding 10%o increment to his iast
drawn monthly salary from 2008-2009 till 2023-24'
Despite the respondent No.1 gainfully employed
l
I
SIi, J
,/'
elsewhere, the respondent No.2 erroneous;. v, passed
impugned order directing the petitioner c(,1 rpany to
deyrosit the amount of Rs.1,24,49,229 l. towards
purported balance of back-wages within tvr r months
from the date of receipt of a copy of the r; rid order.
Being aggrieved by the same, the instant u,r t petition
is liled praying to set aside the impunged orc er passed
by the respondent No.2.
7.
The learned Counsel for the petitioner company
lurther submits that despite the petitionr: showing
that the respondent No. t himself clair r d in his
professional network profile that he
1:l
gainfully
employed elsewhere by filing relevant Link: lln profile
of the respondent No.1, the respondent N,r 2 rvithotrt
appreicting the said fact passed impungecl ,,rders and
requested to set aside the same
I
i
st,,l
8. The learned Counsel for the petitioner company
in support of his contentions, placed reliance on the
foilowing Judgments:
Bibhu Bhushan Deb og Vs. State of Assam,
represented bg the Labour Comtnisslonett
c
g.
Hindustan Zinc Ltd., Vs. Industrial Trlbunal
and another 2
The learned Counsel for the respondent No 1
basing on the counter submits that the respondent
No.
I after receiving the termination order submitted
his representation on
lA.O7 .2OOB denying the
allegations sating that the respondent No' 1 is no way
concerned with the placement of order and it is the job
of the supply chain department to validate the
authenticity of the vendor lies with the supply and
chain department. The petitioners have not issued anv
charge Memo or charge sheet and also not conducted
I
aty domestic enquiry before passing the termination
| 2024 SCC Online Gau 96O
, (2001) 10 scc 211
I
SK,.J
order. The respondent No. 1 was terminatec without
assigning any valid reasons and the responcent No.3
has rightly passed the orders setting aside he order
passed by the Labour Court and justified irL directing
the petitioner company to deposit the amounL
lO. The iearned Counsel for the respon. :nt No.1
submits that there was no dispute with repr rd to the
wages of Rs.17,066 /- paid to the responden No.1 as
on the date of his alleged termination. The petitioner
company has not placed any material L:fore the
respondent No.3 that the respondent lio. 1 was
discharging the managerial duties that fall vithin the
exempted categories under Section 73 (,t of tire
'l'elangana Shops and Establishment Act, 1988 (for
short 'the SE Act, 1988).
11. The learned Counsel for the responJ:nt No. I
lurther submitted that the petitioner cor: pany filed
S.4No. I ot 2024 without complying the orrl:rs passed
I
SK..I
by the respondent No.3 and without stay application,
deposited only ar amount of Rs.26,06,99O1- towards
part compliance the order and the petitioner company
has to deposit balance amount
L2. The learned Counsel for the responde nt No. i
further submits that petitioner company hled counter
af{idavit in I.A.No.2 of 2025 before the respondent No.2
stating that the respondent No.1 was gainfully
employed during the pendency o[ the proceedings and
in view of the same the respondent No.1 is not entitled
for back wages or monthly wages during the pendency
of the second appeal, without proper evidence. The
respondent No.2 allowed the I.A.No.2 ol 2025 directing
the petitioner company to deposit the balance amount
of Rs. I,24,49,229/- within two months, however, the
petitioner company without complying the said order
hled the instant writ petition and there are no merlts
in the requested to dismiss the writ petition.
\.
SK, J
13. After hearing both sides and on pen sing the
record, this Court is of the considered vier'r that the
respondent No. t has worked as Supervisor,' ixecutive
in the Maintenance Department of the p etitionercompany and he was terminated on the allr gation of
violation of code of provision on 1O.06.2008. \ggrieved
by the termination orders, the respondent "lo. 1 hled
petition under Section 2-A (21 of I.D Act 1947 lor
reinstatement with full back wages, corr inuity of
service and other attendant charges vide Lt) No.190 of
2O0O and the Labour Court dismissed th: same on
05.01.2016. Aggrieved by the said dismjr sal order,
the respondent No. 1 filed appeal vide SE N: 2 of 20i8
on the file of the respondent No.3 ald the same was
allowed on O8.01.2O24 by setting aside the -,'rmination
orders dated 10.06.2018 and directed the petitionercompany to reinstate the rr:spondent No. with lull
back r\rages, continuity of service and all other
atte ndant benefits
t
Aggrieved by the said rrders, the
I
SK..J
petitioner-company filed Second Appeal before the
respondent No.2 under Section a8(3) of the TSSE Act,
1988 vide SA No.l ol 2024 duly depositing an amount
of Rs.26,06,990/- towards back wages of the
respondent No. 1.
Thereafter, the respondent No.
liied I.A.No.2 of 2024 in S.A.No.l of 2024 stating that
the amount deposited by the petitioner company is
inadequate and claimed balance
Rs.1,24,49,229 l-
amount ol
by calculating increment @ lO%
every year from 2OO8-09 to 2023-24. The respondent
No.2 whiie a,llowing the I.A.No.2 of 2024 directed the
petitioner company to deposit an amount of
Rs.\,24,49,229 l- towards balarrce back wages within
two (2) months from the date of receipt of a copy of the
said order and the same is impugned order.
L4. There is no dispute with regard to the last drawn
salar5r of the respondent i.e. Rs. 17,066/- per month.
The respondent No.1 filed I.A.No.2 ol 2024 claiming
I
SK. J
increment (&) lO% every year from the termi ration and
the respondent No.2 allowed the said l.A.
15. The contention of the petitioner comf)i .ny is that
the annual increments have to be a r decl after
satisfactory completion of service for : ..ery year.
Without there being the respondent No. I rn service,
the question of granting incrr:ment @ lOo/o r: 'ery year is
contrar5r to the Rules. On this aspect, thr Judgment
relied on by the learned Counsel for the t:,'titioner in
Bibhu Bhushan Deb Rog Vs. State of Asl am (supra
1). The relevant portion of the said Jud;: rtent reads
as under:
"2O. In the case of Andhra Pradesh State .\ xtd Transport
Corporation (A.P.S.R.'l'.C.) u. Abdul Koreem (supt( I, the Supreme
Court held that it uould be ncongntous to :;1 ggest that an
emptoqee, hauinq been hetd guitty and remair.< d absent from
dutg for a long time, continued to earn increme t s though there
ls no pogme.nt of wages for the penod of absen<:e:.
27, In the case of Brijpal Singh (supra), tlrc SuS.r :me Court lrcLd
that a workman can proceed under Section 33C(.') ontg after the
I
I
Tibunal has adjudicated on a complaint maa( uncLer Sectton
334 or untler a reference under Section 10C, I ctt Llrc order of
:
,€
.-;efl
SK, .]
dismissal tuos rtot justified and has reinstated the uorkntan'
Further, in the case oJ Punjab Beuerages Put. Ltd. u Suresh
Chand, (1978) 2 SCC 144, the Supreme CourT has held that the
nght to the money tuhich is sought to be calanlated or to the
benefit which is souglLt to be computed must be an existing one,
tttat is to say alreadg adpdicated upon or prouided for ond must
aise in the course of and nt relation to the ielationship betueen
the Industiol uorkman and his emploger. The Supreme Courl
further hetd that it is not competent to the Labour Coufl
exercising juisdictton und.er Section 33C(2), to arrogate to itse{
the functions of an industrial tibunal and entertatn a cLaim
uthich is not based on an eisting right' but which mag
appropnotetA be mad.e Lhe subiect matter of an industial
dispuLe in a reference under Section 10 of the Act"'
16. The finding of the above Judgment squarely apply
to the facts of the instant case. The respondent No'2
passed impugned orders calculating the increment @
1O7o every year before finalization of Second Appeal'
The respondent No.1 is entitled to receive undisputed
last drawn salary of Rs. 17,C,66 l- per month, without
any increment.
In view of the same, the imPugned
order passed by the respondent No'2 is liable to be
modihed.
I
I
1'>
SIi,.
17. In view o[ the above hnding, the writ l etition is
disposed of by modifying the impunged orr er dated
13.1O.2025 passed by the respondent No.2 jr I.A.No.2
of '2024 in S.A.No. I of 2024 in Str No.2 of 2C B, with a
direction to the petitioner company to d:tosit the
amount by calculating the last drawn salt -r of the
respondent No.1 @ Rs.l7,066/- per montr, from
10.06.2008 to 08.Ot.2024 i.e. for LB7 months,
without increments (4) lO%, within four (4) v,, reks from
the date of receipt of a copy of this or- [er, after
deducting the amount already deposited. N< order as
to costs.
Miscelleineous petitions, if any penct ng in this
'*,rit petition, shall stand closed.
S(l,.P.PONNA KRTSHNA
ASIS STANT REGISTRAR
/ :a)
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To,
The Appellate Authoritv under Section 4B(3) of the Tere r gana
shops &
Estabtishments Acr, 1988-and-oeputv colniniiiii,."iilr
_abour, Ranqa
Anjaiaj Karmika sankshbma srravJn
lS^o9y
;Jji, rjvjEi.*ilo _
500 020
The Authority under Section ag(1) of the Telangana Sh:
rs and
F.stablishments Act, 1 988-and-Asit qolnmisii;"";;;f-1,, rour, MedchatMalkaisiri District I nteorated Disrrict offi ae
ii rlpirrv' Viriabl,
Shameerpet Ma ndat Medchat-Matkajgiri-Distrtli'i"irriij, ra 500 078
The Pri ncipa I Secreta rv La bo u r, e m fiioymeni, irainln g'
ra cio riei'(La o I
D^epartment, The State of Tetangani, f"i;g;;;-S;;iet
rnat Hyderabad - 500
022.
I
RiCxl
C;;pdn,
r
4. The Commissioner of La-bour, State of Telangana T. Anjaiah Karmika
Sankshema Bhavan RTC X Roads, Hyderab;d - S00 010
5. One CC to SRI G.V.S. GANESH Advcicate tOpUCl
6. One CC to SRt AMANCHARLA V. cOpALA RAO,hdvocate IOPUCI
T Two CCs to GP FOR LABOUR, High Court for the Srate of i6tang#a. tOUTl
B. Two CD Copies
BN
PMK
\
,V
HIGH COURT
DATED:1910212026
o 3r
\
oC)
\
ORDER
rTDi
t
rc rr'3i
WP.No.39196 of 2025
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
)
t
I
I
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review