The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. Accordingly, the relief sought by the Appellant in the Writ Petition seeking direction to the Respondent-ONGC for appointment of the Appellant to JSA F-1 Post could not have been granted as rightly held by the learned Single Judge in the Impugned Judgment.
14. In view of the above, we entirely agree with the reasoning and findings of the learned Single Judge in the Impugned Judgment, whereby after considering the facts and circumstances of the present case and submissions made by the Parties, it has been held that the Appellant had no right of appointment as Ms. Kukshal did not resign from JSA F-1 Post upon her selection for E-1 Post since she continued to be employed with ONGC even after her appointment in the higher E-1 Post. As there was no resignation, the requirement of the appointment from the wait list was not triggered and, therefore, the Appellant was not entitled to the appointment as a matter of right although he was at the top of the wait list.
15. Accordingly, the Writ Petition was rightly dismissed by the learned Single Judge by way of the Impugned Judgment. Hence, no interference is required in the present Appeal. Accordingly, the present Appeal and the pending Application are hereby dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Date of Decision : 19.02.2026
LPA 789/2025 & CM APPL. 81565/2025
HIMANSHU CHAUBE
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Babul Kumar, Advocate.
Versus
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Anshuman, SPC with Mr. Rahul
Kumar Sharma, Advocate for UoI.
Mr. Abhishek Gupta, CGSC with Mr.
Kumar Kartikeya and Mr. Chanakya
Kene, Advocates for ONGC.
CORAM:
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TEJAS KARIA
TEJAS KARIA, J. (ORAL)
1.
This Letters Patent Appeal has been filed by the Appellant against the
Judgment and Order dated 15.10.2025 (“Impugned Judgment”) passed by
the learned Single Judge of this Court in W.P.(C) No. 10382/2025 (“Writ
Petition”), whereby the Writ Petition filed by the Appellant seeking a
direction to the Respondents to appoint him to the post of Junior Scientific
Assistant (Geophysics–S) (“JSA F-1 Post”) under Advertisement No.
2/2022 (R&P) was dismissed.
2.
The brief facts leading to the filing of the present Appeal are as under:
2.1.
The Respondent–Oil and Natural Gas Corporation (“ONGC”)
issued an Advertisement No. 2/2022 (R&P) dated 07.05.2022,
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:18:25
LPA 789/2025
inviting applications for various junior level non‑executive
posts, including one unreserved vacancy for the post of JSA F-1
in the Dehradun region.
2.2.
The Appellant applied pursuant to the Advertisement and was
issued an admit card to appear in the written examination held
on 28.07.2022 at Haldwani, District Nainital, Uttarakhand.
2.3.
The Appellant participated in the examination and secured
77.90 marks, obtaining second position in the merit list and
being placed as waiting list candidate no. 1. He was, thereafter,
called for document verification after qualifying the written
examination on 12.12.2022.
2.4.
The results were declared on 09.02.2023, which reflected the
selection of one Ms. Ankita Kukshal (“Ms. Kukshal”) against
the said vacancy, who joined the post of JSA F-1 at the
Dehradun Work Centre on 06.03.2023.
2.5.
Subsequently, Ms. Kukshal was selected for the post of
Graduate
Trainee
(Geophysicist)
(“E-1
Post”)
under
Advertisement No. 06/2022, which is an Executive level post,
based on GATE‑2022 scores and personal interview. She was
appointed to the said senior post at the Vadodara Work Centre
on 19.05.2023, before completion of her probation on the junior
post.
2.6.
According to the Appellant, once Ms. Kukshal was relieved
from the JSA F-1 Post, the vacancy stood revived, thereby
entitling the Appellant, being first in the waiting list, to
appointment against the said post. He relied upon ONGC’s
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:18:25
LPA 789/2025
Service Rules, particularly Clause 24(6), and office order dated
11.01.2019 (“Office Order”) to contend that where a selected
candidate resigns within the validity of the panel, the next
wait‑listed candidate must be appointed.
2.7.
The Appellant sought information from the ONGC under the
Right to Information Act, 2005 seeking clarification regarding
the rules governing operation of the waiting list. In response,
the Respondent-ONGC informed that the names of candidates
from the waiting list are released only in the event a selected
candidate fails to join, resigns, or is declared medically unfit. It
was further clarified that the waiting list or panel remains valid
for a period of six months from the date of declaration of
results, extendable by another six months with the approval of
the Competent Authority. The trigger for calling a candidate in
the waiting list arises only upon cancellation of the initial
appointment offer or acceptance of resignation by the
competent authority, and only if the panel continues to remain
valid. The Appellant contended that Ms. Kukshal’s relieving
amounted to resignation, thereby triggering consideration of the
waiting list.
2.8.
Thereafter, the Appellant made several representations to the
Respondent-ONGC seeking appointment to the revived vacancy
but reportedly received no response.
2.9.
As no appointment was offered to him, the Appellant filed the
Writ Petition before this Court seeking a writ of mandamus to
direct the Respondent-ONGC to appoint him to JSA F-1 Post.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:18:25
LPA 789/2025
2.10. The Respondent-ONGC filed a Counter Affidavit explaining
that the vacancy did not fall within the contingencies that
permit operation of the waiting list. The Appellant, thereafter,
filed a Rejoinder reiterating his claim.
2.11. The learned Single Judge, after hearing the parties, dismissed
the Writ Petition vide the Impugned Judgment, holding that
Ms. Kukshal’s case was one of appointment to a higher post and
not resignation from service; therefore, the waiting list could
not be operated.
2.12. Being aggrieved by the Impugned Judgment, the Appellant has
preferred the present Appeal.
3.
We have heard the learned Counsel for the Parties.
4.
The learned Counsel for the Appellant submitted that the learned
Single Judge in the Impugned Judgment has failed to consider that Ms.
Kakshal joined ONGC on 06.03.2023 on the JSA F-1 Post, but subsequently
left the post within 2.5 months to accept the E-1 Post under a separate
recruitment process (Advertisement No. 6/2022), which created a vacancy in
the JSA F-1 Post and the same amounted to resignation of the selected
candidate.
5.
It was further submitted that as per ONGC Office Order, a candidate
from the waiting list must be appointed in case of four circumstances, which
are:
i.
Failure to join;
ii.
Reluctance;
iii.
Refusal; or
iv.
Resignation
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:18:25
LPA 789/2025
by the selected candidate. It was submitted that once Ms. Kakshal moved to
the E-1 Post, she ceased to hold JSA F-1 Post as her exit amounted to
resignation under the service law, which triggered the operation of the
waiting list.
6.
The learned Counsel for the Appellant submitted that ONGC wrongly
treated the vacation of the post by Ms. Kukshal as ‘not a resignation’,
thereby resulting in denial of legitimate appointment to the Appellant. It was
submitted that the learned Single Judge wrongly accepted the submissions of
ONGC by failing to appreciate that JSA F-1 Post stood vacated in fact and
in law, which triggered the Appellant’s vested right to be considered.
7.
It was submitted that the learned Single Judge misinterpreted the
Office Order issued by ONGC and overlooked the fact that the selected
candidate withdrew from the JSA F-1 Post as Ms. Kukshal’s appointment to
the higher E-1 Post could not amount to an internal movement / transfer. It
was submitted that as per the settled service rules, joining a new post by
direct recruitment results in technical resignation from the earlier post and
the employee cannot hold lien over the previous post or hold two substantive
posts simultaneously. Further, the selected candidate was still on probation
in the JSA F-1 Post and there is no material on record to show that the
movement to a higher post during the period of probation was permissible.
8.
The learned Counsel for the Appellant submitted that ONGC’s own
service rules provide that resignation becomes effective only upon
acceptance and formal relieving. The fact that Ms. Kukshal was relieved
from the JSA F-1 Post to join the even post establishes that the vacancy was
revived and should have been filled from the waiting list. It was submitted
that the selected candidate was incorrectly classified as ‘not having
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:18:25
LPA 789/2025
resigned’ resulting in wrongful rejection of the Appellant’s appointment
from the waiting list by misapplying the service for principles.
9.
The learned Counsel for the Respondents submitted that Ms. Kukshal
had applied for JSA F-1 Post as well as E-1 Post. The interview for E-1 Post
was held on 18.01.2023 prior to the result date for JSA F-1 Post on
09.02.2023. Ms. Kukshal got selected in JSA F-1 Post and joined ONGC at
Dehradun on 06.03.2023 and, thereafter, the result of E-1 Post was declared
on 15.04.2023 and she got appointed to the higher post on 19.05.2023. As
Ms. Kukshal had joined and saturated JSA F-1 Post and then got selected to
the higher E-1 Post, while already employed in ONGC at a lower post, she
was not considered to have resigned from JSA F-1 Post as her joining date
was considered as 06.03.2023, when she joined the JSA F-1 Post. Since, the
vacancy for the position of JSA F-1 Post was not on account of failure /
reluctance / refusal / resignation, the waiting list could not be invoked by
ONGC for appointment of the Appellant at JSA F-1 Post.
10.
In view of the above submissions, the learned Single Judge in the
Impugned Judgment has held that the case of Ms. Kukshal was not one of
resignation as she joined the higher post subsequent to joining the junior
post in ONGC. The Impugned Judgment also has held that the wait list lost
the significance as soon as the number of advertised posts were filled up as
the name appearing in the waiting list did not give rise to an indefeasible
right of appointment. The learned Single Judge in the Impugned Judgment
has relied upon the decision of the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in Dr.
Shashi Bhushan v. University of Delhi & Anr., (2025) SCC OnLine Del
1319, which held that the selected candidate has no right to appointment as
the selection only confers a right of consideration for appointment. It was
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:18:25
LPA 789/2025
held that if the vacancy arises after the appointment has been made, the
waiting list ceases to operate in absence of any rule to the contrary.
11.
In the present case, the Office Order issued by ONGC provides that
the candidate in the waiting list can be considered only in event of failure /
reluctance / refusal of the selected candidate to join or resignation and in no
other circumstances, the wait list can be utilized for filling up of future
vacancies arising out of any reason whatsoever.
12.
As Ms. Kukshal was appointed to the higher E-1 Post after joining the
junior JSA F-1 Post, none of the circumstances as specified in the Office
Order issued by ONGC had arisen. The argument of the Appellant that by
appointment of Ms. Kukshal to E-1 Post, she vacated JSA F-1 Post resulting
in technical resignation from JSA F-1 Post cannot be accepted as there was
no resignation or relieving of Ms. Kukshal by ONGC from JSA F-1 Post and
her date of appointment for E-1 Post was treated as same as when she joined
JSA F-1 Post. Therefore, it cannot be treated as a case of resignation from
JSA F-1 Post triggering the requirement to appoint from the wait list.
Accordingly, the Appellant had no vested right of appointment since none of
the conditions for appointment from the wait list was fulfilled as specified in
the Office Order issued by ONGC, which is relied upon by the Appellant
himself.
13.
Accordingly, the relief sought by the Appellant in the Writ Petition
seeking direction to the Respondent-ONGC for appointment of the
Appellant to JSA F-1 Post could not have been granted as rightly held by the
learned Single Judge in the Impugned Judgment.
14.
In view of the above, we entirely agree with the reasoning and
findings of the learned Single Judge in the Impugned Judgment, whereby
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:18:25
LPA 789/2025
after considering the facts and circumstances of the present case and
submissions made by the Parties, it has been held that the Appellant had no
right of appointment as Ms. Kukshal did not resign from JSA F-1 Post upon
her selection for E-1 Post since she continued to be employed with ONGC
even after her appointment in the higher E-1 Post. As there was no
resignation, the requirement of the appointment from the wait list was not
triggered and, therefore, the Appellant was not entitled to the appointment as
a matter of right although he was at the top of the wait list.
15.
Accordingly, the Writ Petition was rightly dismissed by the learned
Single Judge by way of the Impugned Judgment. Hence, no interference is
required in the present Appeal. Accordingly, the present Appeal and the
pending Application are hereby dismissed. There shall be no order as to
costs.
TEJAS KARIA, J
DEVENDRA KUMAR UPADHYAYA, CJ
FEBRUARY 19, 2026
ap
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:18:25
LPA 789/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review