Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:HHC:2729 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH,
SHIMLA
LPA No. 492 of 2024
Reserved on 25.11.2025
Pronounced on: 09.01.2026
Himachal Pradesh Electricity Board Ltd.
.....Appellant.
Versus
Kundan Hydro (Luni) Pvt. Ltd. & another
Coram:
…..Respondents.
The Hon'ble Mr. Justice G.S. Sandhawalia, Chief Justice.
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Jiya Lal Bhardwaj, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting? Yes.
For the Appellant :
Mr. Anand K.
Ganesan, Advocate
(through V.C.) with Mr. Shivom
Vashista and Ms. Shivani Verma,
Advocate.
For the respondents: Mr. Prithu Garg and Mr. Vaibhav
Chauhan, Advocates, for respondent
No.1.
Mr. Pranay Pratap Singh, Additional
Advocate
General, for respondent
No.2-State.
G.S. Sandhawalia, Chief Justice.
Challenge by the appellant-Himachal Pradesh
State Electricity Board Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as ‘the
appellant-Board’) in the instant Letters Patent Appeal, is to
the judgment dated 10.09.2024, rendered by the learned
Single Judge in CWP No.7177 of 2024, titled Kundan
Hydro (Luni) Private Limited vs. State of Himachal
Pradesh through its Addl. Chief Secretary (MPP &
Power) & anr., whereby the writ petition filed by the
petitioner-Kundan Hydro (Luni) Private Ltd-respondent No.1
herein
has
been
allowed
by
quashing
impugned
communication dated 16.07.2024 (Annexure P-13) holding
the Power Purchase Agreement (for short the "PPA") dated
31.05.2000 executed between appellant-Board and "SPML”
not binding upon it being unenforceable against it. The
appellant-Board was directed to execute a "PPA" with the
writ petitioner-Power Company in respect of the entire
Project capacity of 4.50 MW at the "HPERC Regulations2017"
determined
tariff
applicable
as
on
Scheduled
Commercial Operation Date of the Project in accordance
with law and complete all codal formalities in furtherance
thereof without unnecessary delay. In order to avoid loss of
electricity generated at the Project, it was ordered that till
the determination of tariff as on the date of commissioning
of the Project by the "HPERC Regulations-2017" in terms of
direction
supra,
permitted
by
the
the
petitioner-Hydro
respondents
to
sell
Company
the
was
electricity
generated from its Power Project to third parties after
adjusting the free power supply to the respondents in
accordance with law.
Reasoning of the learned Single Judge:
2.
The learned Single Judge had allowed the writ
petition primarily on the ground that the "PPA" dated
31.05.2000 (Annexure P-14) had been executed between
the Board and "SPML” and therefore was not binding upon
the petitioner and could not be enforced. The necessary
directions thus came to be issued to execute the "PPA" in
respect to the entire Project capacity of 4.50 MW at the
HPERC (Promotion of Generation from Renewable Energy
Sources and Terms & Conditions for Tariff Determination)
Regulations, 2017 as on Scheduled Commercial Operation
Date. It was further directed that the determination of tariff
shall be as on the date of commissioning of the Project by
the "HPERC Regulations-2017" in terms of direction No.(iii),
the petitioner was permitted by the respondents to sell the
electricity generated from its Power Project to third parties
after adjusting the free power supply to the respondents in
accordance with law.
3.
Principally, the reasons which weighed with the
learned Single Judge were that both the Implementation
Agreement (IA) and the "PPA" dated 31.05.2000 for the 3.00
MW was an agreement which provided specific terms for
execution of separate Agreement for purchase of power
generated which was to be done within three months. The
petitioner-Company was not a party to the said Agreement
and the assignment could only be done as per Article 15.10
by written Agreement and the petitioner was not a
successor to be bound by it and therefore have come into
the picture only later on 25.09.2004 (Annexure P-3) by
virtue of Tripatite Agreement executed by "SPML” and
respondent No.1-State. The separate "PPA" was required to
be executed which was not done and could not be held to
be binding upon the petitioner and the "PPA" dated
31.05.2000
was
binding
upon
the
petitioner.
respondent
No.2-HPSEBL
was
aware
of
the
The
legal
requirements of the separate Power Purchase Agreement
(PPA) with the new entity therefore, the rate of "PPA"
mentioned 20 years earlier could not be enforced upon the
petitioner.
4.
Resultantly, it has been held that the writ
petition was maintainable, as the action of respondent No.2
who is the present appellant was arbitrary enforcing the
third-party Agreement upon the petitioner. Accordingly,
reliance was placed upon the judgment of the Apex Court in
M.P. Power Management Company Limited, Jabalpur
Vs. Sky Power Southeast Solar India Private Limited
and Others (2023) 2 SCC 703 to come to the conclusion
that the prayer for defence of the alternative remedy under
Section 81(6) of the “The Electricity Act, 2003” would not be
justified.
5.
Resultantly, it has been held that there is an
abandonment of the "PPA" dated 31.05.2000 and "SPML”
had
been
petitioner‘s
permitted
locus
Supplementary
to
standi
execute
as
Implementation
such
the
Contract.
was
that
Agreement
The
a
new
(SIA)
was
executed by the petitioner and respondent No.1-State on
06.07.2024 (Annexure P-7), whereby the rights had been
transferred of the original Implementation Agreement (IA)
dated 31.05.2000 and the Supplementary Implementation
Agreement (SIA) dated 01.03.2008 (Annexure P-5) and
there was nothing mentioned in the said Agreement which
bound the petitioner with the "PPA" dated 31.05.2000.
6.
The new Electricity Act had come later in the
year 2003 and the earlier Power Purchase Agreement (PPA)
was executed when old electricity regime was in place
which was at the rate of 2.50/kWh. Therefore, the "HPERC
Regulations-2017"
would
not
be
fastened
upon
the
petitioner as the Agreement was executed 24 years ago
could not be held applicable in the given facts and
circumstances.
Background of the case:
7.
A brief summary of facts to the extent relevant,
necessary to appreciate the contentions of the parties and
for adjudication of this appeal, may be narrated as follows:
8.
The writ petitioner-respondent No. 1 herein is a
private limited company incorporated under the provisions
of the Companies Act, 1956 having its registered ofÏce at
Chimbalhaar Home Stay Chimbalhaar P.O. Geetapeeth,
Kangra, Palampur Himachal Pradesh and is the developer of
the 4.5 MW Luni Hydro Power Project situated at village
Lulani, P.O. Deol, Tehsil Baijnath District Kangra,H.P.
9.
the
Apparently, for the purpose of development of
said
project,
executed
between
an
Implementation
the
State
of
Agreement
Himachal
was
Pradesh-
respondent No. 2 herein and "SPML” on 31.05.2000 for
execution of Luni Hydro Electric Project (hereinafter referred
to as the"LHEP") of 3.00 MW capacity. On the very same
day i.e. 31.05.2000 a "PPA" was also separately executed
between “SPML” & appellant-Board for sale and purchase of
power generated from LHEP (3.00 MW) at tariff of Rs. 2.50
per Killowatt hour (in short "kWh"). The “SPML” incorporated
a generating Company by the name and style of ‘M/s Luni
Power Company (P) Ltd.writ petitioner-respondent No.1
herein and requested the State of Himachal Pradesh to
transfer/assign all assets, liabilities, obligations, privileges
and benefits of the Project under the Implementation
Agreement dated 31.05.2000 to M/s Luni Power Company
(P) Ltd. (for short referred to as the "LPC"). The State
accepted this request and a Tripartite Agreement was
executed on 25.09.2004 (Annexure P-3) between “SPML”,
State and LPC whereby all assets, liabilities, obligations,
privileges and benefits of “SPML” under the Implementation
Agreement dated 31.05.2000 were transferred to LPC. The
LPC by conducting further investigations had enhanced the
capacity of the Project to 4.50 MW. A revised TechnoEconomic Clearance for the enhanced capacity of the
Project was accorded by the appellant-Board on 20.03.2007
(Annexure P-4).
10.
Thereafter
a
Supplementary
Implementation
Agreement (for short referred to as the "SIA") was executed
between the State of Himachal Pradesh & the new Project
Developer-LPC on 01.03.2008 (Annexure P-5). The said
agreement also contained the terms & conditions for
implementing the Project having revised capacity of 4.50
MW. Thereafter a "PPA" was also required to be executed
between
appellant-Board
and
LPC
pursuant
for
the
execution of SIA on 01.03.2008 but this agreement could
not be drawn and executed.
11.
It appears that the LPC faced financial crises
during the year 2019 due to which Corporate Insolvency
Proceedings were initiated against it. Resultantly, the
matter was decided by the National Company Law Tribunal
on 19.04.2022, approving the takeover of corporate debtor LPC as per resolution plan submitted by M/s Kundan Care
Products Limited, resulting in revival of the respondent-
Company.
Thereafter
there
was
total
change
in
the
management of the company. Appellants herein consented
to transfer all assets, liabilities etc. incurred by LPC out of
SIA dated 01.03.2008 to M/s Kundan Hydro (Luni) Private
Limited under new management. All share holders of LPC
were released from their obligations under the previous
Implementation Agreement dated 31.05.2000.
12.
Thereafter
a
Supplementary
Implementation
Agreement (SIA) was executed between State of Himachal
Pradesh and the Kundan Hydro Luni Pvt. Ltd. on 06.07.2024
(Annexure P-7) incorporating the terms & conditions
pursuant to change in the management of the Hydro
company containing therein revised Project milestones. The
Scheduled Commercial Operation Date of the Project (for
short
the
08.07.2024
"SCOD")
was
(Annexure
revised
P-11),
to
the
31.08.2024.
Hydro
On
Company
requested the appellant-Board to execute a "PPA" with it for
purchase of power in respect of LHEP 4.50 MW in
accordance with State's notification dated 15.05.2018 read
with the provisions of Swaran Jayanti Energy Policy, 2021
and
also
informed
that
the
Project
was
ready
commissioning followed by a reminder dated 10.07.2024.
for
13.
Resultantly, appellant-Board, vide ofÏce letter
dated 16.07.2024, informed that a "PPA" already existed
between “SPML” and the Board for 3.00 MW capacity at
tariff of Rs. 2.50/kWh and Hydro Company would be bound
by it. It was further informed by the appellant-Board, that
the Supplementary "PPA" was required to be executed
between the hydro company and the appellant-Board only
for incorporating change in the name of the Company,
amendment in the Project capacity and for inclusion of
composite tariff for the revised capacity of the Project from
3.00 MW to 4.50 MW while keeping the binding nature of
the “PPA” dated 31.05.2000 intact for 3.00 MW Capacity. As
per this communication, the “PPA” so executed, was to be
filed along with joint petition before the Himachal Pradesh
Electricity Regulatory Commission (HPERC) for its approval.
14.
The said OfÏce letter dated 16.07.2024 was
followed by corrigendum issued by appellant-Board on
31.07.2024, whereby certain errors which have crept-in in
the ofÏce letter dated 16.07.2024 were corrected. For
issuing this direction, the appellant-Board brought into play
the Regulation No. 17(3) of the HPERC (Promotion of
Generation from Renewable Energy Sources and Terms &
Conditions for Tariff Determination) Regulations, 2017
(hereinafter referred to as the "HPERC Regulations-2017" for
short).
15.
The petitioner-Hydro company felt aggrieved
against the decision of appellant-Board as communicated to
it under letter dated 16.07.2024 and filed the writ petition
with the following prayers:
"i. That the Impugned Letter dated 16.07.2024
issued by respondent No. 2 be set aside/quashed.
ii. That the impugned PPA dated 31.05.2000
between respondent No. 2 and SPML be declared as
non-est and not binding upon the Petitioner.
iii. That Respondent No. 2 be restrained from
seeking to enforce the impugned PPA against the
Petitioner/Project.
iv. That the Respondent No. 2 be directed to
execute a Power Purchase Agreement with the
Petitioner in respect of the entire Project capacity of
4.5 MW, at the HPERC determined tariffs applicable
as on the date of commissioning of the Project, in
accordance with law.
v. That the Respondents be directed to not treat the
delay in execution of the PPA between the
Petitioner and the Respondent No. 2 as a
delay/default on the Petitioner's part."
16.
The learned Single Judge allowed the said writ
petition by a detailed judgment dated 10th September,
2024, and granted the reliefs to the petitioner-Hydro
Company as mentioned supra. It is against the said reliefs
granted to the Petitioner-Hydro Company, the AppellantBoard has felt aggrieved and filed the instant appeal on the
grounds taken in the memo of appeal.
17.
It was the admitted case of the parties that Luni
Hydro Electric Project (LHEP) with 3.00 MW capacity was
allotted to "SPML”. An Implementation Agreement for
execution of the said Project was thereafter executed
between
State
of
Himachal
Pradesh
and
“SPML”
on
31.05.2000. A separate "PPA" was entered into between
appellant-Board & “SPML” whereby after adjusting free
power, the balance energy was to be sold to the appellantBoard
@
Rs.2.50/kWh.
Since
the
“SPML”
could
not
implement the Project, the Luni Power Company Pvt. Ltd.
came into picture under a Tripartite Agreement executed on
25.09.2004. A Supplementary Implementation Agreement
was executed with it by the State of Himachal Pradesh on
01.03.2008. After undertaking investigations, the capacity
of the Project was enhanced by Luni Power Company to 4.50
MW. Subsequently, Luni Power Company faced financial
crunches and matter went upto National Company Law
Tribunal. Resultantly, the order was passed by the National
Company Law Tribunal on 19.04.2022, and Management of
the company underwent absolute and complete change and
new management had taken the reins of the management
of
the
Company.
A
Supplementary
Implementation
Agreement for the LHEP 4.50 MW was stated to be executed
by
the
State
with
the
Hydro
Company
(under
new
management) on 06.07.2024.
18.
When the Project was ready for commissioning,
the dispute arose only with respect to the rate at which its
generated electricity is to be sold/purchased. The appellantBoard had directed the Hydro Company on 16.07.2024 to
abide by the rate agreed between erstwhile “SPML” &
appellant-Board under the "PPA" dated 31.05.2000 for LHEP
3.00 MW and to execute a Supplementary Power Purchase
Agreement for revised capacity of 4.50 MW in terms of
Regulation 17(3) of the HPERC (Promotion of Generation
from Renewable Energy Sources and Terms & Conditions for
Tariff Determination) Regulations, 2017, which was not
acceptable to the Hydro Company. According to Hydro
Company, it cannot be bound down to sell electricity to
appellant-Board at the then rate mentioned in the "PPA"
executed on 31.05.2000 between appellant-Board and the
original Project Developer.
19.
The stand of the appellant-Board before the
learned Single Judge was that as communicated by them in
the letter dated 16.07.2024 is that “PPA” for LHEP 3.00 MW
already existed. The aforesaid “PPA” for LHEP (3.00 MW)
was executed on 31.05.2000, in terms of the “PPA” dated
31.05.2000, and Hydro Company is bound to sell power to
appellant-Board @ Rs. 2.50/kWh. Though the supplementary
“PPA” was required to be executed between the appellantBoard and the Hydro Company, but that was required only
to reflect the change in the Company's name, amendment
in the Project capacity and inclusion of composite tariff for
the revised Project capacity of 4.50 MW as per provisions of
Regulation No. 17 (3) of the "HPERC Regulations-2017". The
composite tariff has to be worked out on normative basis for
the net sale-able energy corresponding to the enhanced
capacity of the Project. Meaning thereby, the stand of
appellant-Board was that tariff for original 3.00 MW capacity
of LHEP shall remain Rs. 2.50/kWh in terms of “PPA” dated
31.05.2000. For enhanced capacity of 1.50 MW, the tariff
will be governed by provisions of the "HPERC Regulations2017".
20.
According to the Hydro Company, it was not
privy to the “PPA” executed on 31.05.2000 between the
appellant-Board and the “SPML”. It is stated that the
aforesaid
“PPA”
cannot
be
superimposed
upon
the
petitioner. The Hydro Company is under no obligation to sell
its generated electricity to the appellant-Board at the rate
determined 24 years ago (on 31.05.2000). The aforesaid
“PPA” dated 31.05.2000 has to be construed as abandoned
by its executants as it was never acted upon for more than
two decades. Further, the Hydro Company, is stated to be
ready and willing to file joint petition for determination of
tariff for the Project capacity (4.50 MW) as a whole as on
date of commissioning of the Project before the "HPERC
Regulations-2017", without being bound by the “PPA” or the
tariff determined in that “PPA” executed on 31.05.2000
between the appellant-Board and the “SPML”. According to
the Hydro Company, in case appellant-Board is not ready to
purchase electricity from it in accordance with the rate to be
determined
by
"HPERC
Regulations-2017",
as
on
the
Scheduled Commercial Operation Date, then it be permitted
to sell electricity to third parties in accordance with law.
Arguments of counsel for the appellant:21.
The arguments which was raised by counsel for
the appellant in order to dispel the reasoning of the learned
Single Judge which was primarily on the principle of the
alternative remedy which the learned Single Judge had dealt
with, on the ground that the Electricity Act, 2003 was a
exhaustive legislation and the remedy under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India cannot be entertained.
The
contention is that once the benefits and privileges of the
Implementation Agreement dated 31.05.2000 and the
subsequently "PPA" of even date in favour of the "SPML” are
sought to be enforced for the revised capacity of 4.50 MW,
it amounts to the Writ Court as such for re-writing the terms
of the rate of the purchase of power by issuing necessary
directions at the present rates determined as in the
Scheduled Commercial Operation Date which would be
beyond the purview of the Writ Court while exercising its
power of mandamus as such.
22.
Reliance is placed upon the two judgments of the
Apex Court in State of Himachal Pradesh and Another
Vs. JSW Hydro Energy Limited and Others 2025 SCC
OnLine SC 1460 and KKK Hydro Power Limited Vs.
Himachal Pradesh State Electricity Board Limited and
Others 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1847 to contend that the
function of the State Commission including the price at
which electricity is duly procured from the generating
companies or licensees is a specialized job. It was the case
of the petitioner themselves that they requested vide
communication dated 08.07.2024 (Annexure P-11) to give
a suitable date for signing "PPA" in respect of the 4.5 MW
project to the appellant-Board which had been followed up
on 10.07.2024 and it was on the basis of the second
Supplementary Implementation Agreement (SIA) executed
by the petitioner-Company on 06.07.2024 (Annexure P-7)
that the Project as such was complete and ready for
commissioning.
It is thus submitted that the letter dated
16.07.2024 (Annexure P-13) was in consonance with the
earlier Agreements entered into.
The predecessor-in-
interest of the petitioner and it itself was agitating for its
rights as per the "PPA" executed earlier on 31.05.2000 for
the capacity of 3.00 MW at the tariff of Rs.2.50 per KWh.
The composite tariff that had to be worked out and the
petitioner had been put to notice that the joint petition had
to be filed alongwith a supplementary “PPA” seeking
approval of the "HPERC" for the amendment of the capacity
change in the name of the company to the tune of the
composite tariff and therefore, the learned Single Judge was
not justified in issuing directions executing the "PPA" of 4.50
MW as per the "HPERC Regulations-2017" determined tariff
applicable on the Scheduled Commercial Operation Date.
Arguments of counsel for the respondents:23.
Counsel
for
the
respondents-original
writ
petitioner on the other hand has relied upon the policy in
place dated 15.05.2018 (Annexure P-8), whereby the
Mandatory Purchase of Power by DISCOM of the entire
power generated from the projects having capacity upto 10
MW is to be purchased by HPSEBL at the HPERC determined
tariff and which had to be applicable to the projects which
had been commissioned after the said notification. The tariff
had to be determined with respect to date of achieving
Commercial Operation Date (COD) of the project instead of
the date of signing of Implementation Agreement (IA).
24.
Accordingly, it is contended that there is a policy
(Annexure P-10) in place and since the "PPA" dated
31.05.2000 was only with the initial Company "SPML” and
there was no privy of Contract, while placing reliance upon
Clauses 15.3, 15.10 & 15.18 of the Agreement. It was
submitted that the assignment had to be done by the
mutual Agreement between the parties and the Agreement
was intended for the benefit of the parties and would not be
applicable to the third-party as per Clause 15.3.
The
Tripartite Agreement under Clause 15.18 having not been
entered into had led to the filing of the writ petition as there
was a valid cause of action, which was striking down of
letter dated 16.07.2024 (Annexure P-13) and seeking
directions to execute the "PPA" in respect of the entire
Project capacity of 4.50 MW at the prevalent rates i.e. the
date of commissioning of the Project.
The delay in the
execution of the "PPA" was not on account of the default on
the petitioner’s part.
25.
Resultantly, it was argued that the agreement
dated 01.03.2008 (Annexure P-5) was only an agreement
between the Government of Himachal Pradesh and M/S Luni
Power Company, Private Limited, whereby the revised
Techno-Economic Clearance of the Project for the capacity
had been given and the revision had been taken from 3 MW
to 4.50 MW and the Power Purchase/Wheeling Agreement(s)
was to be signed between the M/S Luni Power Company,
Private Limited and Board/concerned party (ies) as per
Clauses 12.1 and 14.10 of the said agreement.
26.
The judgments relied upon are stated to be not
applicable as there was no issue of tariff fixation and the
action was totally and manifestly arbitrary as the petitioner
was not a party to the Agreements. Earlier Agreements
cannot be enforced to sell power at the rate of Rs.2.5 per
MW.
Accordingly, it is contended that it was a well
reasoned order and did not warrant interference.
Our Reasoning to decide the said issue:27.
As noticed, the prayer of the petitioner is for
quashing of the letter dated 16.07.2024 (Annexure P-13)
on the premise that the earlier "PPA" dated 31.05.2000
(Annexure
unenforceable
P-14)
is
against
not
it
not
binding
being
upon
a
it
signatory.
being
The
directions were sought for executing of fresh Power
Purchase Agreement in respect of the entire Project
capacity
of
4.5
that
the
"HPERC
Regulations-2017"
determined tariffs from the date of the commissioning of the
Project. The prayer is now based on the ground that there
is a policy of the State which makes it mandatory for the
Board to purchase the power from the Projects and having
capacity upto 10 MW and the same would be applicable to
the Projects should be commissioned after the notification.
The relevant part of the said notification reads as under:-
“2. Mandatory Purchase of Power by DISCOM
The provisions as contained in Hydro Power Policy,
2006 at Sr. No.3.1(i) of Chapter-IV and subsequent
amendments issued from time to time, is amended
to the extent that the entire power generated from
the projects having capacity upto 10 MW will
mandatorily be purchased by HPSEBL at the HPERC
determined tariff. The same shall be applicable to
the projects which shall be commissioned after this
notification.
3. Exemption in Open Access Charges
The provisions as contained in Hydro Power Policy,
2006 at Sr. No.3.1(ii) of Chapter-IV and subsequent
amendments issued from time to time is amended
to the extent and for Projects above 5 MW and upto
25 MW is added as Sr. No.(xxxix) under Chapter-V
that no open access charges for the use of intraState transmission network shall be payable by
hydro projects having capacity upto 25 MW which
shall be commissioned after this notification.
(B) Amendments in the Hydro Power Policy,
2006 by adding new Clause/provision
1. Tariff Determination.
A new provision is incorporated under Chapter-IV at
Sr. No.3.1(xi) and Chapter-V at Sr. No. (xL) of the
Hydro Power Policy, 2006 that the tariff shall be
determined by HPERC with respect to date of
achieving COD of the project instead of the date of
signing of IA. However, this condition shall be
applicable only if Project is completed within the
stipulated time period as approved in Technical
Concurrence (TC) after achieving the zero date
except force majeure conditions or reasons not
attributable to the developers.”
28.
It is not disputed that the directions have to be
issued by way of a writ of mandamus and there has to be
statutory duty or right which can be enforced by the Writ
Court and it is in such circumstances “one has to lift the
veil” as to whether the learned Single Judge had any
jurisdiction as such to issue the necessary directions
especially contained in relief of Clause 7(iii) directing to
execute the "PPA" in respect of the entire Project capacity of
4.5 MW of the "HPERC Regulations-2017" determined tariff
and Scheduled Commercial Operation Date.
It is also not
beyond the anvil of doubt that the petitioner’s predecessorin-interest was initially the "SPML” and then M/s Luni Power
Company Private Limited on the basis of the Implementation
Agreement (IA) dated 31.05.2000 and the subsequent "PPA"
dated 31.05.2000 got certain rights to run the Project both
in the State and thereafter “SPML” having entered into
Power Purchase Agreement with the Electricity Board,
wherein the tariff for the Net Saleable Energy and then had
been fixed at the rate of Rs.2.50 per Kilowatt which was the
fixed term with the rate and not to be changed due to any
reasons as per Clause 6.2. The said Clause reads as under:“6.2 TARIFF FOR NET SALEABLE ENERGY:The Board shall pay for the Net Saleable Energy
delivered by the Company to the Board at the
Interconnection Point at a fixed rate of Rs.2.50
(Rupees two and paise fifty) per Kilowatt hour. This
rate is firm and fixed and shall not be changed due
to any reason whatsoever.”
29.
It is not disputed that “SPML” had further entered
into Tripartite Agreement dated 25.09.2004 (Annexure P3) with M/s Luni Power Company Private Limited and the
Government of Himachal Pradesh for transferring/assigning
all the assets, obligations and liabilities and Luni Power
Company had agreed and it would be bound by all the
assets, liabilities and obligations of the projects and the
terms and conditions specified in the Implementation
Agreement
dated
31.05.2000
executed
Government and the second party.
between
the
The Luni Power
Company had agreed to perform the Implementation
Agreement as if they were the original party of the aforesaid
Implementation Agreement in place of the second party.
The “SPML” had been relieved from its obligations on the
signing of the said Contract. The said Clauses reads as
under:“NOW THIS AGREEMENT WITNESSED AS
UNDER AMONG THE PARTIES HERETO AS
FOLLOWS:
(i) That the Government hereby grants its consent
to transfer/assign all the assets, liabilities,
obligations, privileges and benefits of the project by
the second party to the third party arising out of the
Implementation Agreement 31st May, 2000 with the
unequivocal acceptance of third party of all the
assets, rights, liabilities, obligations, privileges and
benefits
arising
out
of
above
mentioned
Implementation Agreement dated 31st May, 2000.
Unless otherwise permitted by the Government,
this consent is subject to the condition that the
third party shall ensure that the second party
continues to hold minimum 51% of its equity upto
two years after COD of the project. If at a later date
it comes to the notice of the Government that this
condition has been violated then it shall have the
right to terminate the Implementation Agreement
dated 31st May, 2000, after affording due
opportunity to the third party and also to forfeit the
security furnished by the third party as per sub-
clause 4.3 of the Implementation Agreement, and
the project with all its capital and infrastructural
assets shall vest with the Government.
(ii)
That the Government hereby releases the
second party of all the obligations under the
Implementation Agreement dated 31.05.2000
mentioned above and agrees to be bound to the
third party in terms thereof.
(iii) That the third party hereby agrees that it shall
be bound and liable for all the liabilities, obligations
and execution of the project on the terms and
conditions
specified
in
the
Implementation
Agreement dated 31st May, 2000 to the
Government.
(iv)
All the terms and conditions of the
Implementation Agreement signed on 31st May,
2000 shall remain the same save and except as
provided herein above and wherever expression of
“Company” “Generating Company” or second party
appear in the Implementation Agreement dated 31 st
May, 2000, the same shall be read, construed,
mean and deemed to be referred to as the third
party.
(v) That the third party agrees to perform the
Implementation Agreement 31st May, 2000 as if
they were the original party of aforesaid
Implementation Agreement dated 31st May, 2000 in
place of second party.
(vi) That the third party has established its Head
OfÏce in H.P. and has undertaken to establish its
Regd. OfÏce in HP within Six months from the
signing of this Agreement. In the event of failure to
do so, this Tripartite Agreement (TPA) shall stand
cancelled.”
30.
Thereafter, it is only on account of financial
exigencies as such that the petitioner has come into picture
and got the rights as such in view of the order passed by
the National Company Law Tribunal Chandigarh Bench
(NCLT)
dated
19.04.2022
(Annexure
P-6)
that
the
resolution plan of the petitioner as such was approved by
the Committee of Creditors under Section 30(6) of the Code
read with Regulation 39 of the CIRP Regulations, 2016. The
earlier moratorium order by the adjudicating authority dated
23.12.2019 ceased to have effect.
The writ petition thus
was filed on the basis of the said order and therefore all the
rights and liabilities as such have come landed in the lap of
the original writ petitioner and he now cannot take the plea
as such that it is not bound by the eariler Agreement
entered by the predecessor-in-interest namely M/s Luni
Power Company (P) Ltd.
31.
As per Section 86(b) of the Electricity Act, 2003,
the functions of the State Electricity Commission are to
regulate electricity purchase and procurement process of
distribution licensees including the price at which electricity
is to be procured and to determine the tariff. Section 86(1)
(a) & (b) of the said Act reads as under:“86. Functions of State Commission.-(1) The
State Commission shall discharge the following
functions, namely:(a) determine the tariff for generation, supply,
transmission and wheeling of electricity, wholesale,
bulk or retail, as the case may be, within the State:
Provided that where open access has been
permitted to a category of consumers under
Section 42, the State Commission shall determine
only the wheeling charges and surcharge thereon, if
any, for the said category of consumers;
(b) regulate electricity purchase and procurement
process of distribution licensees including the price
at which electricity shall be procured from the
generating companies or licensees or from other
sources through agreements for purchase of power
for distribution and supply within the State;
32.
It is not disputed that the petitioners itself by
virtue of their communication dated 08.07.2024 referred to
the
Supplementary
Implementation
Agreement
dated
06.07.2024 (Annexure P-7) which was between the
Government of Himachal Pradesh and Kundan Hydro Luni
Power Company Limited and which gave reference to the
earlier Implementation Agreement dated 31.05.2000 and
the
Supplementary
Implementation
Agreement
dated
01.03.2008 (Annexure P-5) and the State Government had
given its consent to transfer and assign all the assets and
liabilities which had been incurred by Kundan Hydro Luni
Power Company Limited, while noting the order dated
19.04.2022 of NCLT and the fact that the Techno-Economic
Clearance had been revised for 4.50 on 20.03.2007 during
the intervening period. The relevant part reads as under:“NOW
THIS
SUPPLEMENTARY
IMPLEMENTATION AGREEMENT WITNESSED AS
UNDER AMONG THE PARTIES HERE TO AS
FOLLOWS:(i) That the First Party hereby grants its consent to
transfer/assign all the assets, liabilities, obligations,
privileges, NOC’s and the benefits of the project
incurred by M/s Luni Power Company Private
Limited to the Second Party, arising out of the
Implementation
Agreement
(IA)
signed
on
31.05.2000 & Supplementary Implementation
Agreement (SIA) dated 01.03.2008 with the
unequivocal acceptance of the Second Party to
accept and take over all the assets, rights,
liabilities, obligations, privileges and benefits
arising out of above mentioned Implementation
Agreement (IA) and Supplementary Implementation
Agreement (SIA).
(ii) The First Party hereby releases old shareholders
of M/s Luni Power Company Private Limited of all
the
obligations
under
the
Implementation
Agreement signed on 31.05.2000 & Supplementary
Implementation Agreement dated 01.03.2008 as
mentioned above and agrees to bind Second Party
in terms thereof.
(iii) That the Second Party hereby agrees that it
shall be bound and liable for all the liabilities,
obligations and operation, maintenance of project
on the terms & conditions as specified in the
Implementation Agreement signed on 31.05.2000 &
Supplementary Implementation Agreement dated
01.03.2008 to the First Party.”
33.
Thus, all the rights and liabilities as such of the
petitioner company arose from the earlier Implementation
Agreements dated 31.05.2000, the "PPA" of even date
(Annexure P-14) and the Tripartite Agreement dated
25.09.2004 and it would not lie in their mouth to say that
they are not bound by the earlier terms, merely, because
period of more than 24 years have expired. The petitioner
company as such could not be now permitted to wriggle out,
if it is still interested in running the project.
34.
The Board only had in pursuance of their request
dated 8th and 10th July, 2024 which is again based on the
agreement dated 06.07.2024 had requested that the
composite tariff has now to be determined for the entire
capacity of Luni Power Company Limited 4.5 MW and
therefore a draft joint petition be filed before the Electricity
Commission.
35.
The Board had fallen back on Regulation 17 in
the letter dated 16.07.2024 (Annexure P-13) of the
‘Capacity Enhancement’ of HPERC (Promotion of Generation
from Renewable Energy Sources and Terms & Conditions for
Tariff Determination) Regulations, 2017. The same reads as
under:“17. Capacity enhancement.1) Where, after the allotment of the original
project, the capacity of a small hydro project is
enhanced, with the approval of the State
Government, the tariff for sale of net saleable
energy from such projects, shall be governed
by the relevant provisions of sub-regulations
(2) to (8), as applicable.
2) xxxxxxxxx
3) Where, prior to commencement of Himachal
Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission
(Promotion of Generation from the Renewable
Energy Sources and Terms and Conditions for
Tariff Determination) Regulations, 2017:(a) in relation to the original capacity of the
project or a part thereof.- (i) either
synchronization of the same with the Grid has
taken place at least once, or (ii) a joint petition
for the approval of PPA for purchase/sale of net
saleable energy has been filed before the
Commission, or (iii) the PPA for the
sale/purchase of net saleable energy from the
same, whether under REC mechanism or on
long term basis has been signed by the
developer of the concerned project with the
Distribution Licensee; and
(b) in relation to the additional capacity of the
project or a part thereof.- (i) neither any
synchronization of the same, with the Gird has
taken place even once, nor (ii) any joint
petition for approval of any PPA (or
supplementary PPA), in relation for such
additional/enhanced capacity, whether under
REC mechanism or long term basis has been
filed before the Commission, nor (iii) any PPA,
or
supplementary
PPA
for
such
additional/enhanced capacity has been signed
by the developer of the concerned project with
the
distribution
licensee
for
such
additional/enhanced capacity;
the tariff for the net saleable energy in relation
to the original capacity shall be determined as
per the provisions of Himachal Pradesh
Electricity Regulatory Commission (Promotion
of Generation from the Renewable Energy
Sources and Terms and Conditions for Tariff
Determination) Regulations, 2012 and the
same for the additional capacity shall be
determined as per the provisions of Himachal
Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission
(Promotion of Generation from the Renewable
Energy Sources and Terms and Conditions for
Tariff Determination) Regulations, 2017 as
applicable on the date on which the joint
petition for approval of PPA in relation to the
additional capacity/enhanced capacity is filed
before the Commission or on the date on which
such additional capacity, or a part thereof, is
synchronized with the grid for the first time,
whichever is earlier.
4) xxxxxxxxx
5)
Where different sets of Commission’s
regulations as per sub-regulation 3 of this
regulation, or different sets of provisions/norms
of Himachal Pradesh Electricity Regulatory
Commission (Promotion of Generation from the
Renewable Energy Sources and Terms and
Conditions
for
Tariff
Determination)
Regulations, 2017 as per the provisions under
Sub Regulations (4) of this regulation, are
applicable for the net saleable energy
corresponding to the original capacity and for
the additional capacity, a composite rate shall
be worked out on normative basis, for the net
saleable energy corresponding to the enhanced
capacity, as follows, namely:(i) the generic levellised tariff applicable for
the net saleable energy in relation to the
original capacity as per the sub regulation (3)
or sub section (4) as applicable, shall be
considered for the net saleable energy in
relation to the annual energy generation
corresponding to 75% dependable year as per
the Detailed Project Report for the original
capacity, irrespective of the date of signing of
the power purchase agreement for the original
capacity:
(ii) for the net saleable energy in relation to
the annual incremental energy generation due
to enhancement of capacity i.e. the annual
additional energy generation which is expected
to take place in the 75% dependable year as
per the detailed project report for the
enhanced capacity, the generic levellised tariff
applicable for the net saleable energy in
relation to the additional capacity as per the
provisions of 9 sub-regulation (3) or subregulation (4), of this regulation, as applicable,
shall be considered:
Provided that the tariffs considered for the
respective energy quantums as per clauses (i)
and (ii) of this sub-regulation shall be governed
by the respective associated terms and
conditions as per the respective power
purchased agreements and the applicable
provisions for respective capacities:”
36.
This aspect apparently skipped the notice of the
learned Single Judge while allowing the writ petition.
It is
thus apparent that the Writ Court has taken over the
exercise as such of tariff determination which falls within
the
exclusive
domain
of
the
Electricity
Regulation
Commission and therefore an error of law has occurred
while issuance of the necessary directions. It is not for this
Court to substitute its opinion as to whether the petitioners
have to sell power at what rate and therefore the fixation of
tariff by the learned Single Judge was not justified. The
Project having not seen the light of the day and not being
commissioned for all these years, it was an exercise which
was
to
be
determined
by
the
Electricity
Regulatory
Commission rather than forcing the Board as such to enter
into an Agreement at the prevalent rates and re-fixing the
terms of the Contract as such. It was beyond the purview of
the Writ Court on the ground by granting relief 7(iii) that the
action was arbitrary and would thus be an exercise by which
the power of the Commission has been taken over and the
directions have been issued by the Writ Court which is not
permissible.
37.
Keeping in view the law laid down in JSW Hydro
Energy Limited case (supra), wherein the question was
framed about the maintainability of the writ petition and
reference was made to the earlier decision in Jaipur Vidyut
Vitran Nigam Ltd., and Others Vs. MB Power (M.P.)
Ltd., and Others (2024) 8 SCC 513 and it has been held
that the statutory Regulatory Authority has been entrusted
to discharge the function to deal with tariff determination
within the exclusive domain, while interfering with the order
of this Court. The relevant paragraphs reads as under:34. The above principles are also reflected in a
recent decision of this Court in Jaipur Vidyut Vitran
Nigam Ltd. v. MB Power (M.P.) Ltd. Here, the High
Court exercised writ jurisdiction and directed
distribution companies to procure power from
bidders, who are generating companies, at the
prices quoted in their bids till the requisite
quantum of power was procured. Allowing the
appeal of the distribution companies, this Court
held that the High Court was not Justified in
entertaining the writ petition as the Electricity Act
is an exhaustive code and all issues dealing with
electricity must be considered by the expert
bodies,
i.e.,
the
Regulatory
Commissions
constituted under the Act. The relevant portion is
extracted hereinbelow:
"128. We find that the High Court was not justified
in entertaining the petition. The Constitution Bench
of this Court in PTC has held that the Electricity Act
is an exhaustive code on all matters concerning
electricity. Under the Electricity Act, all issues
dealing with electricity have to be considered by
the authorities constituted under the said Act. As
held by the Constitution Bench of this Court, the
State Electricity Commission and the learned
APTEL have ample powers to adjudicate in the
matters with regard to electricity. Not only that,
these Tribunals are tribunals consisting of experts
having vast experience in the field of electricity. As
such, we find that the High Court erred in directly
entertaining the writ petition when Respondent 1
i.e. the writ petitioner before the High Court had an
adequate alternate remedy of approaching the
State Electricity Commission.
129. This Court in Reliance Infrastructure Ltd. v.
State of Maharashtra has held that while exercising
its power of judicial review, the Court can step in
where a case of manifest unreasonableness or
arbitrariness is made out.
130. In the present case, there is not even an
allegation with regard to that effect. In such
circumstances, recourse to a petition under Article
226 of the Constitution of India in the availability of
efÏcacious alternate remedy under a statute, which
is a complete code in itself, in our view, was not
justified."
(emphasis supplied)
35. Grant of Relief by the High Court : Applying
these legal principles, we will now analyse whether
the High Court could have granted relief of aligning
the Implementation Agreement with the CERC
Regulations, 2019 by exercising writ jurisdiction.
The High Court proceeded on the basis that: (i) the
appellant-State is a deemed licensee; (ii) the CERC
Regulations, 2019 are relevant not only for
determination of tariff but also for other purposes
and are binding on the appellant-State; and (iii) the
13% cap on free power supply under Note 3,
Regulation 55 has the effect of overriding the free
power supply clause in the Implementation
Agreement since a similar clause in the PPA and
PSAs stands overridden as per the CERC's order
dated 17.03.2022.
36. On the first aspect of whether the appellantState is a deemed licensee, it is clear from the
impugned order that the High Court has only cited
the statutory provisions on licensing but has neither
delved into this issue nor arrived at any express
conclusion regarding the same. This is perhaps
because the parties did not raise or argue the issue
before it. However, before us, respondent no. 1
strongly contends that the appellant-State is a
deemed licensee, and the appellant has disputed
the same.
37. We are of the opinion that this issue need not
be determined on merits, but is relevant to show
respondent no. 1's conduct in taking contrary
positions by filing the writ petition. On the one
hand, it is claiming that the appellant being a
deemed licensee is a regulated entity under the
Electricity Act. The sequitur of this would be that
the appellant, and its contractual rights and
liabilities, are subject to the CERC's regulatory
jurisdiction. However, respondent no. 1 never
sought relief against the appellant-State before the
CERC, as we have indicated above, and instead
filed a writ petition. Considering the contradictory
positions of respondent no. 1, it cannot be allowed
to approbate and reprobate, or blow hot and cold at
the same time to secure relief under the law.
38. The second aspect pertains to the interpretation
of CERC Regulations, 2019 by the High Court. We
have already dealt with the interpretation of the
Regulations hereinabove, and will presently deal
with the same in the context of maintainability of
the writ petition. Under the Electricity Act, the
statutory regulator has been entrusted with
discharging the function of tariff determination,
including making regulations for the purpose and
interpreting the same. Constitutional courts must
enable the regulator to comprehensively regulate
all aspects of the sector such that remedies are not
fragmented and certain issues are not left outside
the regulator's domain. The regulator has the
expertise, specialisation, and institutional memory
to conduct such an interpretative exercise to
further the objective of the regulatory regime and
systematically lay down legal principles. In this
light, the High Court should not have entered into
the domain of interpreting these Regulations which
deal with tariff determination, as the same falls
within the exclusive domain of the CERC. The
Electricity Act itself provides the appellate
mechanisms by establishing a specialised and
permanent tribunal, namely the APTEL, and an
appeal before this Court, against the CERC's orders.
In view of the existence of a statutory regulatory
forum, the High Court should not have entertained
the writ petition by interpreting the CERC
Regulations, 2019.
39. Equally, we are of the opinion that the High
Court incorrectly relied on the CERC's order dated
17.03.2022 to grant relief to respondent no. 1. As
explained above, the CERC's order only deals with
the PPA and PSAS despite taking note of Article 5.1
of the Implementation Agreement. Upon reading
the order, it is clear that its effect is not that of
restraining respondent no. 1 from supplying free
power beyond 13%. Hence, it does not in any way
adversely affect or prejudice the-contractual rights
of the appellant-State. Hence, the High Court could
not have proceeded on the basis of this order to
grant the relief of modifying the Implementation
Agreement.
40. In view of the above reasons, we hold that CERC
Regulations, 2019 do not prohibit respondent no. 1
from supplying free power beyond 13% to the
appellant-State,
and
the
Implementation
Agreement does not stand overridden by the
operation of these Regulations. Further, a writ
petition before the High Court for aligning the
Implementation
Agreement
with
the
CERC
Regulations, 2019 and the CERC's order dated
17.03.2022 is not maintainable. Once respondent
no. 1's prayer for relief was rejected by the CERC
and it specifically held only the PPA and PSAs to
stand overridden, which finding was not further
appealed, it would not be open for respondent no. 1
to seek modification of the Implementation
Agreement by way of a writ petition before the High
Court.
38.
The judgment was delivered recently only on
16.07.2025 and therefore, the learned Single Judge did not
have the benefit of the said judgment. Another judgment
arising from this Court in KKK Hydro Power Limited case
(supra) also while dealing with the issue of tariff fixation at
the rate of Rs.2.87 and 2.95 per kWh and while dealing with
the Appellate Tribunals order has held that while referring to
Section 86(1) (b) of the ‘Act’ that the fixing of the price of
purchase
of
electricity
is
not
a
matter
of
private
negotiations and Agreements between the generating
company and a distribution licensees, while upholding the
order of the Appellate Tribunal the Apex Court had come to
the conclusion that it required no determination for the 3
Megawatts Hydel Power Projects but only for the additional
1.9 Megawatts was required to be re-determined.
39.
In Ramayana Ispat Private Limited and
another Vs. State of Rajasthan & Others (2025) 8 SCC
747, the statutory scheme of the Electricity Act, 2003 and
the regulations framed by the State Commission were held
to be facilitating intra-Sate transmissions and wheeling of
electricity
and
for
maintaining
disciplines
in
power
scheduling and ensuring that consumers do not gain unfair
advantage by evading scheduling norms and for equitable
treatment of all market participants while safeguarding the
integrity of the power grid.
The relevant part reads as
under:“67. Furthermore, the 2003 Act, envisages a
balance between the rights of open access
consumers and the operational concerns of the
power sector. The 2016 Regulations, while
imposing certain conditions, do not outright
deny open access but ensure that its
implementation is equitable and does not
jeopardise grid discipline.
Open access
remains available to consumers who comply
with
regulatory
prerequisites,
including
scheduling
obligations
and
financial
commitments. Thus, the appellant’s assertion
that their right to open access is foreclosed is
misplaced.
The 2016 Regulations are
consistent with the legislative intent of the
2003 Act, ensuring that open access is
exercised in a manner that does not
compromise system stability, fairness, or
economic viability. Therefore, the regulatory
framework does not foreclose open access but
rather operationalises it within reasonable
constraints essential for sustaining the
electricity sector.
68. The statutory scheme under the 2003 Act
mandates that regulations framed by State
Commissions must serve the larger public
interest. The respondents have successfully
established that the impugned Regulations
serve this purpose by ensuring equitable
treatment of all market participants while
safeguarding the integrity of the power grid.
69. RERC derives its authority from the 2003
Act, which vests in it the power to frame
regulations governing open access, scheduling,
and penalties. Section 86(1)(c) of the 2003 Act
specifically empowers State Commissions to
facilitate intra-State transmission and wheeling
of electricity.
Furthermore, Section 181
empowers the Commission to make regulations
consistent with the 2003 Act and its objectives.
The impugned Regulations have been framed
in exercise of these statutory powers. The
requirement for scheduling, imposition of
penalties, and limits on drawal are not arbitrary
but are measures falling within the regulatory
ambit of the Commission to ensure grid
stability and fair competition. The 2003 Act
envisions a structured and fair mechanism for
open access while ensuring that market
participants do not engage in practices
detrimental to the larger consumer base.
Moreover, under Section 42 of the 2003 Act,
the State Commission has the mandate to
regulate open access in distribution and specify
the charges and conditions applicable. The
respondents have demonstrated that these
conditions are necessary for maintaining
discipline in power scheduling and ensuring
that open access consumers do not gain an
unfair advantage over other consumers by
evading scheduling norms or penalties.
70. The Jodhpur Bench in common order dated
29-8-2016, which has been challenged before
us in Civil Appeals Nos.7965 and 7966 of 2019,
has rightly upheld the validity of the 2016
Regulations holding that any inconvenience
caused or even some hardship faced by the
captive power generators shall not make the
Regulations illegal. The High Court also rightly
pointed out that the appellants have failed to
establish that the impugned Regulations are in
contravention of their rights protected under
Part III or any other provision of the
Constitution of India or that the Regulations
have been enacted without having the
competence to do so or they are manifestly
arbitrary or unreasonable. It has been rightly
held by the High Court that the 2016
Regulations are in consonance with the objects
of the 2003 Act and have been framed as per
the competence available under Section 181
read with Section 42 of the 2003 Act.”
40.
It is thus, apparent that the learned Single Judge
has mis-directed itself by choosing to decide the issue on
merits and also rejected the plea of alternate remedy on the
ground that there was an arbitrary action as such.
The
Board as such had only recommended that the matter
should
be
placed
before
the
Electricity
Regulatory
Commission, keeping in view the power as such of the
Commission to fix the tariff and once the Regulations had
come into force, it was for the Commission to see as to what
would be the rate of the tariff to be fixed between the Board
and the petitioner under the policy dated 15.05.2018 which
makes it mandatory for the Board to purchase the electricity
from Projects below 10 MW.
41.
Therefore, the judgment passed by the learned
Single Judge is not liable to be upheld and the appeal is
liable to be allowed. Accordingly, we set aside the judgment
dated 10.09.2024 and relegate the parties to its alternate
remedy
as
16.07.2024.
suggested
by
the
appellant-Board
dated
Needless to say, it is for the Regulatory
Commission as such to fix the tariff as such, keeping in
mind all the relevant parameters and the fact that project
has been hanging fire since the year 2000.
Neither the
Board nor the State or the petitioners can be prejudiced on
account of the 25 years having been passed and the
interest as such would have to be adjudicated, keeping in
mind this aspect by the expert body.
42.
The appeal stands disposed of accordingly, as
indicated hereinabove, along with pending miscellaneous
applications, if any.
(G.S. Sandhawalia)
Chief Justice
(Jiya Lal Bhardwaj)
Judge
9th January, 2026
(C.M. Thakur/Munish Thakur)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review