Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:3388
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
LPA No. 25 of 2026
Date of Decision: 08.01.2026
____________________________________________________
Himachal Pradesh State Electricity Board Limited
...Appellant
Versus
Ashok Kumar
…Respondent
____________________________________________________
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice G.S. Sandhawalia, Chief Justice
Hon'ble Mr. Justice Jiya Lal Bhardwaj, Judge
Whether approved for reporting? 1
For the appellant:
Ms. Sunita Sharma, Senior Advocate
with Mr. Dhananjay Sharma, Advocate
Jiya Lal Bhardwaj, Judge
By way of present appeal, appellant-Board has laid
challenge to the judgment dated 18.08.2025, passed by the
learned Single Judge in CWP No. 16351 of 2024, titled, Ashok
Kumar vs. HPSEBL, whereby, the petition preferred by
respondent-writ petitioner has been allowed and the impugned
order dated 18.08.2023 (Annexure P-6) issued by the appellantBoard has been quashed, with a further direction to the appellantBoard to not affect any recovery from the pension of the writ
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2026:HHC:3388
petitioner and the amount recovered prior to passing the judgment
be refunded to him.
2.
The main grouse by the appellant-Board in the
present appeal is that the respondent-writ petitioner was
inadvertently granted the benefit of promotional increments again,
whereas, his pay ought to have been protected under the
Himachal
Pradesh
State
Electricity
Board
(Revised
pay)
Regulations, 2009, read with Office Order No.3 dated 16.08.2012,
applicable w.e.f. 01.01.2006. The learned Single Judge has not
considered the matter in right perspective and thus, the judgment
passed by him deserves to be quashed.
3.
The facts which emerge from the judgment under
challenge are that the writ petitioner was appointed as
Superintendent (Non-Gazetted) on 17.10.1990 and now retired
from the post of Senior Accounts Officer on 31.03.2012. When the
writ petitioner was in service, the members of Himachal Pradesh
State
Electricity
Board,
Supervisory
Accounts
Services
Association had filed the original application before the erstwhile
Himachal Pradesh State Administrative Tribunal claiming therein
that the appellant-Board may be directed to grant time bound
promotional scales to its members on completion of 9/16 years of
2026:HHC:3388
service from the date of their joining the induction post of SAS
Superintendent(NG) with all consequential benefits and to pay
arrears along with interest @18% p.a. The writ-petitioner was one
of its members. The said original application was subsequently
transferred to this Court in the year 2019 and was registered as
CWPOA No. 3782 of 2019.
4.
The learned Single Judge vide judgment dated
27.08.2021, had allowed CWPOA No. 3782 of 2019 and the
communication dated 03.07.2001 issued by the appellant-Board
was quashed and set aside and the appellant-Board was directed
to grant all those members of the association the benefit of time
bound promotional scale on completion of 9/16 years of service,
who
were
eligible
and
left
out
as
a
consequence
of
communication issued by the appellant-Board from the date of
their eligibility and further pay them the arrears along with interest
@ 7% per annum.
5.
The appellant-Board feeling aggrieved by the said
judgment passed by the learned Single judge had preferred the
appeal which came to be registered as LPA No. 30 of 2022, titled,
the Himachal Pradesh State Electricity Board versus HPSEB
Supervisory Accounts Services Associations and another.
2026:HHC:3388
However, the said appeal preferred by the appellant-Board was
dismissed by the Division Bench of this Court vide judgment dated
23.04.2022.
6.
Despite dismissal of the appeal, the appellant-Board
did not comply with the directions given by the learned Single
Judge which were affirmed by the Division Bench. The Contempt
Petition was instituted by the association which was registered as
COPC No.78 of 2022. However, during the pendency of the
contempt proceedings, the appellant-Board had implemented the
directions and revised the pay of the petitioner and fixed his pay
at ₹42,090/- per month as evident from perusal of (Annexure P-5),
appended with the writ petition.
7.
However, later on the appellant-Board on the basis of
the observations raised by the Accounts Officer of the appellantBoard issued the said office order (Annexure P-6), whereby the
pay of the writ petitioner was re-fixed as ₹39,720/-, who stood
retired as Senior Accounts Officer on 31.03.2012. Not only this,
the appellant-Board also passed an order to effect recovery of an
amount of ₹86,707/-, from the writ petitioner as evident from
(Annexure P-7), appended with the writ petition.
8.
The writ petitioner feeling aggrieved by the aforesaid
2026:HHC:3388
orders, whereby, his pension was reduced after re-fixing his pay
and further to make recovery against him filed a writ petition and
prayed that the office order dated 18.08.2023, whereby his pay
has been reduced after 11 years of his retirement and further
subsequent recovery ordered to effect from him may be quashed
and set aside.
9.
The learned Single Judge vide judgment under
challenge has allowed the said petition preferred by the writ
petitioner on the premise that once the appellant-Board itself had
re-fixed the pay of the petitioner in compliance of the directions
contained in CWPOA No. 3782 of 2019 and filed compliance
affidavit in contempt petition stating therein that pay of the writ
petitioner has been re-fixed as ₹42,090/-, the same cannot be
permitted to be recovered after the retirement of the writ petitioner
who stands superannuated on 31.03.2012. Reliance has been
placed upon the judgment passed by the Supreme Court in State
of Punjab and Others vs. Rafiq Masih (White Washer) and
Others, (2015) 4 SCC 334 and the relevant para of the judgment
is reproduced hereinbelow:“18. It is not possible to postulate all situations of hardship
which would govern employees on the issue of recovery,
where payments have mistakenly been made by the
employer, in excess of their entitlement. Be that as it may,
based on the decisions referred to hereinabove, we may, as
2026:HHC:3388
a ready reference, summarise the following few situations,
wherein recoveries by the employers, would be
impermissible in law:
(i) Recovery from the employees belonging to Class
III and Class IV service (or Group C and Group D
service).
(ii) Recovery from the retired employees, or the
employees who are due to retire within one year, of
the order of recovery.
(iii) Recovery from the employees, when the excess
payment has been made for a period in excess of five
years, before the order of recovery is issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has
wrongfully been required to discharge duties of a
higher post, and has been paid accordingly, even
though he should have rightfully been required to
work against an inferior post.
(v) In any other case, where the court arrives at the
conclusion, that recovery if made from the employer,
would be iniquitous or harsh or arbitrary to such an
extent, as would far outweigh the equitable balance of
the employer's right to recover."
10.
It has been held by the learned Single Judge that as
per the dictum of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the aforesaid
judgment, any step of reduction in the pay scale and recovery
from a Government employee would tantamount to a punitive
action, because same has drastic civil and evil consequences and
as such the same is bad, especially when such recovery is being
affected after a long period.
11.
The learned Single Judge also placed reliance on the
judgment of Hon’ble Apex Court in case titled as Thomas Daniel
vs. State of Kerala and Others, 2022 SCC OnLine SC 536 and
held that the State cannot recover excess amount paid to the ex-
2026:HHC:3388
employee after the delay of 10 years.
12.
Feeling aggrieved by the judgment passed by the
learned Single Judge, the appellant-Board has laid challenge to
the same that once the writ petitioner had already been granted
the
benefit
of
Time
Bound
Promotional
Scales,
it
was
inadvertently re-fixed vide Office Orders dated 02.08.2022 and
15.11.2022 on account of Time Bound Promotional Scales in
accordance with the judgment of this Court in CWPOA No. 3782
of 2019 which has upheld in LPA No. 30 of 2022.
13.
We have heard learned counsel for the appellant-
Board and perused the record carefully.
14.
It is not in dispute that the writ petitioner was granted
the benefit in terms of the judgment dated 27.08.2021 passed in
CWPOA No. 3782 of 2019, that too, after the institution of the
contempt proceedings by the members of the association, in
which the writ petitioner was one of its members. It is also not in
dispute that the writ petitioner had retired from service on
31.03.2012, and when he was in service, the petition was
instituted by the association for the grant of the benefits which
were granted by the learned Single Judge on 27.08.2021. It is
also not in dispute that the appeal preferred by the appellant-
2026:HHC:3388
Board against the judgment passed by the learned Single Judge
in CWPOA No. 3782 of 2019 was affirmed.
15.
The appellant-Board issued office orders dated
15.11.2022 (Annexure P-5), whereby, the benefit of the judgment
passed by the learned Single Judge was granted to the writ
petitioner and his pay was fixed at ₹42,090/-. Thereafter, without
issuing any show cause notice, the appellant-Board simply on the
basis of the observations raised by the Accounts Officer had
issued (Annexure P-6), whereby, the pay of the writ petitioner was
reduced to ₹39,720/-, and thereafter vide Annexure P-7 had
started making recovery of ₹86,707/-.
16.
The writ petitioner who was agitating his grievances in
the Writ Court, in the earlier round of litigation was held entitled to
the grant of the benefit of Time Bound Promotional Scales on
completion of 9/16 years of service and in compliance of the said
directions, the appellant-Board had issued the office order on
15.11.2022, when the pay of the writ petitioner was fixed as
₹42,090/-. Once the judgment passed by the learned Single
Judge had attained finality and thereafter the pay of the writ
petitioner was re-fixed, the plea now raised by the appellantBoard that the pay of the writ petitioner was inadvertently re-fixed
2026:HHC:3388
cannot be countenanced for the simple reason that in case the
writ petitioner was already granted the said benefit, there was no
question to agitate the matter further in the appeal by the
appellant-Board. Not only this, the benefits in terms of the
judgment passed by the learned Single Judge in the earlier round
of litigation had been extended to the writ petitioner, and the
appellant-Bard had portrayed before this Court in the contempt
proceedings that they have complied with the directions and the
notices issued against the officers were discharged.
17.
It is settled law that any order which has civil or evil
consequences, the least which is expected of an employer is to
hear the affected employee before passing any order. In the
present case admittedly, no notice had ever been issued before
passing the impugned order which was quashed and further since
the writ petitioner had retired on 31.03.2012, there was no
justification to make any recovery from him under the guise that
the writ petitioner was already extended the benefits. Had it been
so, the appellant-Board could not have implemented the judgment
passed in the earlier round of litigation.
18.
It is not the case of the appellant-Board that the writ
petitioner had ever made a mis-representation for receipt of
2026:HHC:3388
amount and once it is not so, the order of reducing his pay and
further effecting recovery of the amount is not justified and the
plea raised by the appellant-Board that the pay of the writ
petitioner was inadvertently re-fixed in compliance of the
directions given in the writ petition cannot be countenanced.
19.
The learned Single Judge has succinctly dealt with
the issue and has come to the right conclusion that the appellantBoard cannot be permitted to effect recovery the amount from the
writ petitioner and further his pay cannot be reduced, which will
adversely affect his pension.
20.
Resultantly, we are of the considered view that the
judgment under challenge does not warrant any interference and
the same was passed on correct apprehension of facts and law.
Hence, the appeal being devoid of merits is rejected and the
judgment passed by the learned Single Judge is affirmed.
However, no orders as to cost. Pending applications, if any, also
stand disposed of.
(G.S. Sandhawalia)
Chief Justice
08th January, 2026
(Anurag)
(Jiya Lal Bhardwaj)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review