Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
CRP No. 1 of 2022 with
CRP No. 10 of 2022
Date of Decision: 29.09.2023
Helen Dkhar & Anr.
Vs.
Emily Synrem & 4 Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Mr. L. Khyriem, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. K.S. Kynjing, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. A.D. Syiem, Adv. (For R 2 & 3)
Mr. E. Lalsangluaia, Adv. (For R 4)
Mr. S. Sengupta, Addl. Sr. GA (For R 5)
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
COMMONJUDGMENT
1.
Two applications under Article 227 of the Constitution of India read
with Rule 36A of the Constitution of India read with the Rules for the
Administration of Justice and Police in the Khasi and Jaintia Hills, 1937 have
been preferred before this Court assailing the proceedings before the court of
the learned Assistant to the Deputy Commissioner(J), Shillong wherein the
impugned order dated 30.10.2017 passed in Misc. Case No. 90(T) of 2017,
order dated 22.10.2021 passed in Misc. Case No. 85(T) of 2021, order dated
16.12.2021 in Misc. Case No. 100(T) of 2021 and finally order dated
22.12.2021 passed in Misc. Case No. 105(T) of 2021 was assailed in CRP No.
1 of 2022.
2.
Another application assailing the judgment/order dated 04.03.2022
passed in FAO No. 8(T) of 2017 passed by the learned Additional Deputy
Commissioner(J),
Shillong
whereby
the
learned
Additional
Deputy
Commissioner(J) upon hearing the appeal filed by the petitioner herein
assailing the order dated 30.10.2017 in Misc. Case No. 90(T) of 2017 of the
learned Assistant to the Deputy Commissioner(J), the same having been
dismissed, was also preferred by the petitioners.
3.
This Court on examination of the two applications filed, finding that
the same subject matter is involved and is inter-connected, to the extent that
this Court while passing the order in one case, the same would also cover the
issues raised in the other case. It is, therefore, deemed expedient to take up
both the two cases and after hearing the parties, to pass a common order
therein.
4.
Heard Mr. L. Khyriem, learned counsel for the petitioners who has
submitted that the factual matrix of the petitioner’s case is that the deceased
father of the respondent No. 4 (L) Himadri Purkayastha being the sole owner
of a landed property measuring about 16,650 sq. ft. situated at Nongrim Road,
Laitumkhrah Shillong sold a portion of the said property to (L) Gilbert
Siangshai, the deceased husband of the petitioner No. 1, measuring about
11,187 sq. ft., who had then assumed title and possession of the same on
execution of a Sale Deed dated 04.06.1997.
5.
Out of the land measuring about 16,650 sq. ft. another portion of
about 5,563 sq. ft. was sold to the deceased husband of the petitioner No. 1 on
execution of a Sale Deed dated 17.11.2000. However, the said property being
under the possession of (L) Rana Purkayastha, the husband of the respondent
No. 1, the said land being under the possession of the respondents No. 1, 2
and 3 respectively, at the relevant point of time, (L) Himadri Purkayastha and
(L) Gilbert Siangshai had instituted a suit for recovery of possession from (L)
Rana Purkayastha being Title Suit No. 11(T) of 1997 (old)/Title Suit No.
224(T)/Eject T.S. No. 9(T) of 2013 (new). The same is still pending disposal
before the court of the learned Assistant to the Deputy Commission(J),
Shillong.
6.
On account of the fact that the Sale Deed dated 17.11.2000 executed
between (L) Himadri Purkayastha and (L) Gilbert Siangshai, pertaining to the
plot of land measuring about 5463 sq. ft. or so, the same being refused to be
registered by the Registrar, East Khasi Hills District, a Title Suit being T.S.
No. 39(T) of 2001 renumbered as T.S. No. 236(T) of 2013 was preferred
before the court of the learned Assistant to the Deputy Commissioner,
Shillong which is a suit under Section 77 of the Registration Act,1908 with a
prayer for direction to the Registrar, East Khasi Hills District, the proforma
respondent No. 5 herein to complete the registration formalities. This suit is
pending disposal before the trial court.
7.
In the meantime, the respondents No. 1 (since deceased), 2 and 3
respectively had filed an application under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2 read with
Section 151 CPC seeking for grant of ad-interim injunction against the
petitioner No. 1 or any person or persons, agent or associates acting on her
behalf from erecting any gate at the main entrance of the path/approach road
towards the compound and house of the said applicants/respondents herein.
8.
The said application being numbered as Misc. Case No. 90(T) of
2017 was taken up for hearing by the learned Assistant to the Deputy
Commissioner (J), Shillong who, vide order dated 24.08.2017 was pleased to
pass an ad-interim injunction and has restrained the petitioner No. 1 or anyone
acting on her behalf from erecting or constructing any gate at the entrance of
such path.
9.
Again, after hearing the parties, the learned Assistant to the Deputy
Commissioner(J), Shillong has, vide order dated 30.10.2017 made the adinterim injunction order dated 24.08.2017 absolute till final disposal of the
suit.
10.
Being aggrieved by the order dated 30.10.2017 the petitioners herein
preferred an appeal before the court of the learned Additional Deputy
Commissioner(J), Shillong, the same being registered as FAO No. 8(T) of
2017. The lower appellate court on admission of the said appeal was pleased
to call for the records of Title Suit No. 236(T) of 2013 along with Misc. Case
No. 90(T) of 2017. This was done vide order dated 17.04.2018.
11.
During the pendency of the appeal that is, FAO No. 8(T) of 2017 the
respondents No. 1, 2 and 3 had filed an application under Order 39 Rule 2A
read with Section 151 CPC bringing to the notice of the court an alleged
violation of the order dated 24.08.2017 passed in Misc. Case No. 90(T) of
2017 by the petitioners. This petition was filed before the court of the learned
Assistant to the Deputy Commissioner(J), Shillong being registered as Misc.
Case No. 85(T) of 2021 arising out of Title Suit No. 236(T) of 2013 and Misc.
Case No. 90(T) of 2017.
12.
The learned Assistant to the Deputy Commissioner (J), Shillong vide
order dated 22.10.2021 in Misc. Case No. 85(T) of 2021 had, on the
appearance of the parties, passed an order restraining further construction of
the said gate. However, this order was also said to have been violated by the
petitioners herein/opposite parties for which, the respondents No. 1, 2 and 3
had filed another application being Misc. Case No. 100(T) of 2021 arising out
of Misc. Case No. 85 (T) of 2021 and the learned Assistant to the Deputy
Commissioner(J), Shillong vide order dated 16.12.2021 had again directed
that the petitioners herein are not to carry out any further construction in the
suit premises.
13.
The petitioners herein on coming to learn about the order dated
16.12.2021(supra) had raised the issue of jurisdiction, following which the
learned trial court had observed that no written objection or otherwise was
filed in this regard. Accordingly, an application filed on 20.12.2021 by the
petitioners was registered as Misc. Case No. 105(T) of 2021 raising the issue
of jurisdiction and objecting to the trial court taking up the hearing on Misc.
Case No. 85(T) of 2021.
14.
The learned Assistant to the Deputy Commissioner(J), Shillong had
then passed the order dated 21.12.2021 after hearing the parties in Misc. Case
No. 105(T) of 2021 and had, in effect dismissed the petition on the ground
that in the absence of any stay order explicitly passed by the appellate court,
the Misc. Case No. 85(T) of 2021 and Misc. Case No. 100(T) of 2021 cannot
be dismissed at that stage.
15.
Looking into the many orders passed by the learned Assistant to the
Deputy Commissioner(J), Shillong dated 30.10.2017, 22.10.2021, 16.12.2021
and 22.12.2021 the learned counsel for the petitioners has submitted that the
same was passed with material irregularity and beyond jurisdiction inasmuch
as when the initial order dated 30.10.2017 wherein the ad-interim injunction
order was made absolute while disposing of Misc. Case No. 90(T) of 2017
and such order being impugned and under appeal before the appellate court
for which all the relevant records from the trial court was called for, therefore,
without perusal of the relevant records the trial court could not have passed
the impugned orders as indicated above.
16.
In due course, the said appeal was heard by the learned Additional
Deputy Commissioner(J) and the same was disposed of vide the impugned
judgment/order
dated
04.03.2022,
rejecting
the
prayer
of
the
appellants/petitioners herein.
17.
The learned counsel for the petitioner has reiterated that the subject
matter of T.S. No. 236 (T) of 2013 pertains to the prayer to direct the
Registrar, East Khasi Hills District to cause registration of the said Sale Deed
executed on 17.11.2000 which suit is for an exclusive remedy and not a
comprehensive suit, since the same was a suit under Section 77 of the
Registration Act, 1908, thereby an application under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2,
CPC in itself is not maintainable.
18.
The learned Additional Deputy Commissioner(J) without looking
into this aspect of the matter as to the maintainability of the process by which
the impugned order dated 30.10.2017 was passed by the learned Assistant to
the Deputy Commissioner in an application under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2, has
rejected the appeal which renders the impugned judgment/order unsustainable
in law, submits the learned counsel.
19.
The learned counsel has again submitted that the learned lower
appellate court has failed to take note of the fact that the alleged dispute is
with regard to the proposed gate sought to be erected by the petitioners over
their land which is not in dispute or the subject matter of the suit that is, T.S.
No. 236(T) of 2013. In fact, the concerned respondents would not be deprived
of their right of free access of ingress and egress to their compound as the said
path is a common path used by the parties without any interruption.
20.
Yet another argument raised is that the learned courts below have
failed to appreciate the fact that the impugned orders were passed based on the
pleadings and documents put in by the respondents No. 1, 2 and 3 which are
not part of their pleadings in the title suit and has come to a finding that there
exists a 6 ft. wide approach road within the suit land. Since issues in the suit
have already been settled by the concerned court in the year 2002, the
respondents could not have been allowed to come with new pleadings after a
gap of about 16(sixteen) years or so. Therefore, the trial court or for that
matter, the learned lower appellant court ought not to have passed the
impugned order dated 30.10.2017 and the order dated 04.03.2022
respectively.
21.
In support of his case, the learned counsel has cited the following
authorities:
i.
Mathai Ouseph Panackal v. Joseph & Anr, AIR 1970 Ker 261,
para 8 & 9;
ii.
Hira Singh & Anr. v. Budh Singh & Ors.,1985, SCC Online
All 99, para 12 & 13
iii.
V.K. Thanikachalam v. Parameswari Ammal & 2 Ors.,
1997(II) CTC 746, para 13
iv.
Kalavakurti Venkata Subbaiah v. Bala Gurappagari Guruvi
Reddy, (1999) 7 SCC 114, Para 10 & 11
v.
Abdul Kalam Azad v. Ananthalakhmi, 2012 (2) MWN (Civil)
63, para 12
vi.
Iqbal Mohammed Bijili v. K. Arumugam & Ors, 2005 (3) CTC
420, para 28 & 29.
22.
In view of the submission made, the learned counsel has submitted
that the impugned orders dated 30.10.2017 and 04.03.2022 are patently illegal
and was passed without jurisdiction, the same are required to be set aside and
quashed.
23.
Per contra, Mr. K.S. Kynjing, learned Sr. counsel appearing for the
respondents No. 1, 2 and 3 has submitted that the order dated 30.10.2017
passed in Misc. Case No. 90(T) of 2017 was passed to preserve the nature of
the suit property from being wasted or damaged or alienated by restraining the
plaintiffs/petitioners herein to set up or to erect a gate within the said suit land.
The same being passed under the relevant provision of Order 39 Rule 1 and 2,
there is no irregularity or illegality or even lack of jurisdiction exercised by
the trial court while passing the orders in question.
24.
In the same breath, the learned Sr. counsel has also raised the issue of
maintainability of these applications by submitting that the exercise of power
under Article 227 of the Constitution, may be necessary only if it is shown
that grave injustice has been done to a party since under Article 227, the High
Court is not supposed to interfere into any order passed by a subordinate court
or by a tribunal even if there are some defects therein, the power principally
being limited only to issues of want of jurisdiction, errors of law, perverse
findings, gross violation of natural justice or if any grave injustice has been
done. In support of this contention, the case of Chamnur Ali & Ors v. Loknath
Upadhaya, (2022) 4 Gauhati Law Reports, 678, para 5 as well as the case of
Ouseph Mathai & Ors v. V.M. Abdul Khadir, AIR 2002 SC 110, para 8 & 10
was cited.
25.
Going on to deal with the facts and circumstances of the case
between the parties, the learned Sr. counsel has submitted that the history of
the suit land dates back to the year 1934, when on 22.12.1034, (L) Nishi
Sekhar Purkayastha and (L) Chandra Sekhar Purkayastha, both brothers
jointly purchased a plot of land measuring about 14,110 sq. ft. from one
Ramola Bose. On 16.10.1946, the adjacent land measuring about 2500 sq. ft.
was also purchased from Ka Kyndong Mawrie in the name of (L) Chandra
Sekhar Purkayastha as the Karta of the family.
26.
Out of the total plot of land measuring about 16,650 sq. ft., a portion
of the same was sold by (L) Himadri Purkayastha, the son of (L) Chandra
Sekhar Purkayastha to (L) Gilbert Siangshai vide Sale Deed dated 04.06.1997.
However, on the southern part of the original land sold by Mrs. Bimola Bose,
the area is 135 ft., whereas on the said sale deed dated 04.06.1997, the area
shown is 129 ft., the approach road of about 6 ft. was therefore, not included
in the said Sale Deed dated 04.06.1997 as it is the entrance to the residence of
the respondents No. 1, 2 & 3 from the Laitumkhrah main road which at its end
measures about 10 ft.
27.
The learned Sr. counsel has further submitted that the said approach
road has been used by the respondents No. 1, 2 & 3 and their family members
for the last two decades and the intention of the petitioners to erect or
construct a gate at the entrance of the same would put the suit property in
danger and would cause damage to it as well as it would disturb the right of
way for egress and ingress of the respondents No. 1, 2 & 3 to their property.
To maintain status quo and to preserve the suit property, it is imperative that a
formal order from the court is required so as to prevent the petitioners to dig
the earth and to install the said gate at the said place.
28.
In this regard, the learned Sr. counsel has submitted that even Manik
Purkayastha, the grandson of (L) Chandra Sekhar Purkayastha, while
deposing as P.W. -1 in the said Eject Title Suit No. 9(T) of 2013 had admitted
to the existence of the said approach road from the Laitumkhrah main road
toward the suit property.
29.
It is the further submission of the learned Sr. counsel that the
impugned order dated 30.10.2017 and the dismissal of the appeal vide order
dated 04.03.2022 have been passed by the respective courts whereby by
applying the principles of Order 39 Rule 1 & 2 CPC, peace and harmony may
be maintained between the parties till disposal of the suit. The same are
therefore, justified and may not be disturbed by this Court.
30.
In support of his contention, the learned Sr. counsel has referred to
the following cases:
i.
Dr. Ashis Ranjan Das v. Rajendra Nath Mullick, AIR 1982 Cal
529, para 28;
ii.
Liberty Sales Services v. Jakki Mull & Sons, 1997 SCC Online
Del 220;
iii.
Tofiz Uddin v. Eusob Ali & Ors, (2020) 4 GLR 678 and
iv.
B.F. Varghese v. Joseph Thomas, AIR 1957 Travancore10
Cochin 286.
31.
Mr. S. Sengupta, learned Addl. Sr. GA appearing on behalf of the
proforma respondent No. 5/Registrar has submitted that as far as the Registrar
is concerned, since it has been brought to the notice of this authority that there
is a dispute as regard the proposed land for which the sale deed in question is
to be registered, therefore, the same could not be registered unless the matter
is resolved by way of a decree from a court of competent jurisdiction.
32.
The proforma respondent No. 4 has appeared through learned
counsel, Mr. E. Lalsangluaia, who has, however refrained from making any
submission on the merits of these petitions.
33.
It may be mentioned that during the pendency of these proceedings,
the respondent No. 1, Emily Synrem has expired on 26.08.2022. The fact of
her death was brought on record by way of an affidavit wherein the copy of
the Death Certificate dated 13.09.2022 was produced. This fact was also
corroborated by the petitioners herein.
34.
However, since there are three principal respondents in these two
cases, the respondent No. 2 and 3 respectively being the sons of the deceased
respondent No. 1, therefore, no application or prayer for substitution was
made. Accordingly, the matter as far as the deceased respondent No. 1 is
concerned has abated.
35.
This Court has carefully considered the arguments of the parties
herein and has come to understand that the main dispute between the relevant
parties is with regard to a path/approach road measuring about 6 ft. wide
which adjoin the Laitumkhrah main road to the property of the petitioners and
continuing towards another property, measuring about 5,563 sq. ft., which is
now under the possession of the respondents No. 2 and 3 and which property
is the subject matter of Title Suit No. 236 of 2013 and Title Suit No. 224 of
2012 as records would show.
36.
During the pendency of the abovementioned Title Suits, the
petitioners during the process of erection of a gate over the said 6 ft. wide
land, the respondents No. 1 (since deceased), 2 and 3 had raised objection to
the same and has accordingly approached the court of the learned Assistant to
the Deputy Commissioner(J), Shillong before which court the said
aforementioned Title Suits are pending by way of a miscellaneous application
being registered as Misc. Case No. 90(T) of 2017 seeking injunction as
provided under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2 CPC.
37.
As detailed herein above, the said Misc. Case No. 90(T) of 2017 was
finally disposed of vide order dated 30.10.2017 making the ad-interim
injunction passed earlier in the case absolute. Upon which against such order
an appeal was filed by the petitioners herein before the court of the learned
Additional Deputy Commissioner (J), Shillong in FAO No. 8(T) of 2017.
38.
It is also the case of the relevant respondents that in spite of the order
dated 30.10.2017 the petitioners have violated the same prompting the
respondents to file a number of miscellaneous applications before the trial
court upon which relevant orders and directions have been passed, such orders
as indicated above, are also assailed herein.
39.
The FAO No. 8(T) of 2017 was finally disposed of vide order dated
04.03.2022 rejecting the prayer made by the petitioners herein and upholding
the impugned order passed by the trial court which has again prompted the
petitioners to prefer the relevant application before this Court under Article
227 of the Constitution of India read with Rule 36A of the Rules for the
Administration of Justice and Police in the Khasi and Jaintia Hills, 1937.
40.
What is noticed by this Court at the threshold is that in a suit to cause
registration of the sale deed by the Registrar, East Khasi Hills District,
Shillong, purportedly executed by (L) Himadri Purkayastha and (L) Gilbert
Siangshai, an application under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2 CPC has been preferred
by the relevant respondents herein.
41.
As has been submitted by the learned counsel for the petitioners, the
suit filed under Section 77 of the Registration Act, 1908 is for exclusive
remedy pertaining only to the prayer to cause registration of the said sale deed
and as such the only relief the plaintiff therein can get is one of a decree
directing registration of the said sale deed. This has been observed in the case
of Hira Singh (supra) at paras 12 and 13 and is now also commonly
understood that the relief for injunction sought for in the suit is outside the
purview of an action under Section 77 of the Registration Act.
42.
It is reiterated that a suit under Section 77 of the Registration Act has
to be confined only to the claim for registration of the document, which
proposition of law is evident in the case of Mathai Ouseph Panackal(supra)
referred to by the petitioners. In the case of the petitioners, the suit pertains to
prayer for causing registration of the said Sale Deed dated 17.11.2000. All the
cases cited by the petitioners also centers on the issue pertaining to Section 77
of the Registration Act, which issue has been dealt with herein accordingly.
43.
It is also a fact that the relevant respondents have preferred the
application for injunction under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2 CPC in the suit being
T.S. No. 236(T) of 2013 which is a suit filed under Section 77 of the
Registration Act. Now, on the question as to whether a defendant can move an
injunction against the plaintiff without filing a counter claim to seek relief
against the action of a plaintiff in the suit which though not related to the
cause of action raised in the plaint, but which, according to the defendant is
detrimental to the cause of the defendant, the Hon’ble High Court of
Karnataka in the case of Suganda Bai v. Sulu Bai & Ors., AIR 1975
Karnataka 137 has answered such a query, which in the respectful opinion of
this Court, the principle enunciated therein would also be applicable to the
pertinent issue raised in these petitions. The judgment in its entirety is found
relevant and merits reproduction herein below as:
“1. This revision preferred by the plaintiff arises out of an application
made by defendant 1 for temporary injunction restraining the plaintiff
from interfering with her alleged possession of the suit properties.
2. The plaintiff brought a suit in the Court of the Munsiff at Aland for
a permanent injunction restraining the defendants from interfering
with her possession. The cause of action as stated in the plaint is that
the defendants began to interfere with the plaintiff’s possession in the
year 1970. After the suit was filed, the plaintiff did not ask for any
temporary injunction. In the year 1973, defendant 1 made an
application under Order XXXIX, Rules 1 and 2, read with Section 151,
Code of Civil Procedure, for grant of a temporary injunction
restraining the plaintiff from interfering with the defendants'
possession of the suit property. That application was allowed by the
trial Court and the said order was confirmed by the appeallate Court.
It is against the said order of the Court below that this revision
petition has been filed.
3. Now the principles, under which a defendant may seek and obtain
an order of temporary injunction against the plaintiff, are stated in
Collision v. Warren, (1901) 1 Ch 812 where Buckley, J., after
referring to a number of earlier decisions of the English Courts,
quoted Lopes, LJ, in (1824) 2 Ch 541 at p. 545:"The question is this - whether the defendant can move for an
injunction against the plaintiff without filing a counter-claim or
issuing a writ in a cross-action. In my opinion, he can in some
cases, but only in cases where the defendant's claim to relief arises
out of the plaintiffs cause of action, or is incidental to it."
Buckley, J., also referred to the decision of Davey, L.J., in the same
case wherein it is stated thus:"In my opinion, it must be relating to or arising out of the relief
sought in the action which, is before the Court, and that any other
injunction cannot properly be granted in the action."
The principles stated in the above decision have been followed by
this Court and it is only in cases where the defendants' claim to
relief arises out of the plaintiff’s cause of action or is incidental to it
that he can ask for a temporary injunction against the plaintiff.
4. In the instant case, the cause of action for the plaintiffs suit, as
stated earlier arose in the year 1970, whereas the cause of action for
the defendants arose in the year 1973. The two causes of action are
different. Therefore, the courts below were wholly in error in granting
temporary injunction prayed for by defendant 1.
5. For the reasons stated above, I allow this revision petition, reverse
the orders of the Courts below and dismiss defendant-1's application,
with costs throughout.
Petition allowed.”
44.
In the context of the issues raised in these petitions, while on the
subject, it would be again useful to refer to the aforementioned judgment and
to note that the relevant observations in this regard goes along the line that a
defendant may move for an injunction against the plaintiff where the
defendant’s claim to relief arises out of the plaintiff’s cause of action or is
incidental to it. Any other injunction cannot be properly granted if the same is
not relatable to the relief claimed in the suit. In fact, the authorities cited by
the relevant respondents in this regard also speaks of the same principle of
law, that is, that the defendant can prefer an application for injunction in a suit
where the plaintiff’s cause of action is incidental to the relief claimed.
However, the respondents failed to notice that in the case in hand as observed
above, the claim is to cause registration of the said Sale Deed dated
17.11.2000. Nothing in the pleadings of the parties is mentioned about the 6
ft. path or road. Therefore, there is no nexus between the claim made in the
suit and the alleged proposed erection of the gate within the said 6 ft. path or
road.
45.
Now, coming to the question of maintainability of these petitions as
far as applicability of Article 227 of the Constitution is concerned, what has to
be understood is that the High Court while exercising its power under Article
227, the same is supervisory in nature. Superintendence over all subordinate
courts and tribunals within its jurisdiction in this regard is exercised both
administratively and judicially as is warranted. One of the main concerns
while exercising this power is to ensure that the subordinate courts and
tribunals are functioning within the limits of their authority.
46.
Be that as it may, in a given situation, the High Court in appropriate
cases can convert petitions or applications, especially one under Section 115
CPC into an application under Article 227. In this regard, the case of Col. Anil
Kak (Retd.) v. Municipal Corpn. Indore & Ors., (2005) 12 SCC 734, paras 1
and 2 is worthy of mention inasmuch as the same would somewhat be similar
to the question raised herein. The relevant paras reads as follows:
“1. These two petitions arise from the claim for an interim injunction
by the petitioner before us in a suit filed by him. The suit was for a
permanent injunction restraining the respondents, the defendants in
the suit, from interfering with the possession of the suit land allegedly
held by the petitioner including the school buildings constructed
thereon and not to demolish or take any steps for removal of the
constructions. An interim injunction along the same lines to enure
during the suit was sought. That application was opposed.
Respondent 3, in turn sought an injunction restraining the petitioner
plaintiff from putting up any construction outside an area of 16,000
sq ft. The trial court granted an interim injunction in favour of the
petitioner but confined it to an area of 16,000 sq ft and the
construction thereon and also restrained him from putting up any
construction outside it but included in the plaint schedule. The
petitioner appealed against those orders and the Additional District
Judge allowed the appeals and modifying the order of injunction
granted by the trial court, made the injunction operative in respect of
the entire plaint schedule property and the structures thereon. The
respondents originally filed a revision invoking Section 115 of the
Code of Civil Procedure (for short “the Code”) before the High
Court challenging the order of the first appellate court. In view of a
decision rendered by the High Court that no revision under Section
115 of the Code could be entertained against an order of injunction
since the order was purely interlocutory in nature, the respondents
herein sought a conversion of their revision into a petition under
Article 227 of the Constitution. This prayer was allowed by the High
Court which decided to treat the proceedings as one under Article
227 of the Constitution. It is challenging that order that the petitioner
before us has filed Special Leave Petition(C) No.11771 of 2003.
Proceeding on the merits thereafter, the High Court modified the
order of the first appellate court and restored the order of the trial
court and thereby confined the interim order of injunction to an area
of 16,000 sq ft and the structures thereon. Feeling aggrieved by this
modification, the petitioner before us, the plaintiff in the suit, has
filed SLP(C) No.11940 of 2003. Since both the matters arise from the
same proceedings, they are taken up together for final disposal.
SLP(C) No.11771 of 2003
2. All that the High Court has done is to treat the petition filed before
it under Section 115 of the Code as a proceeding initiated under
Article 227 of the Constitution. The respondents had filed the
revision originally and during the pendency of that revision the High
Court appears to have taken a view that an order in an appeal
arising from a proceeding under Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 of the Code,
could not be challenged under Section 115 of the Code since the
order was in the nature of an interlocutory order. In such a situation,
in our view, the High Court rightly decided to permit the revision
petitioners before it, to convert the same as a proceeding under
Article 227 of the Constitution. After all, the court could have done it
on its own, even without a motion in that behalf by the petitioner. We
see absolutely no ground to interfere with the said order on the
grounds raised in this special leave petition. Hence, this special leave
petition is dismissed.”
47.
In any case, even if the relevant respondents would insist that the
impugned orders are appealable, the fact that the provision of Rule 36A of the
Rules for the Administration of Justice and Police in the Khasi and Jaintia
Hills, 1937 has been resorted to, these petitions would have been maintainable
as this provision allows appeal against orders passed by the Additional Deputy
Commissioner under the said Rules.
48.
This Court has also noticed that there is a Title Suit No. 27 (T) of
2017 said to have been instituted by the relevant respondents herein before the
competent court, which assertion was also made by the learned Sr. counsel for
the relevant respondents and the same duly noted by the trial court in the order
dated 30.10.2017 in Misc. Case No. 90(T) of 2017. Copy of the said Title Suit
No. 27(T) of 2017 is annexed with the petition in CRP No. 1 of 2022 as
Annexure 12. On perusal of the same, it is seen that the subject matter of the
suit is the said 6 ft. portion of the land which forms part of the said path/road
leading from the Laitumkhrah Main Road toward the land of the parties which
is in dispute. The plaintiff therein who is the deceased respondent No. 1 herein
has sought for a decree inter alia, that the said approach road/path is the right
of way for the plaintiff/respondent No. 1 and her family members for egress
and
ingress
towards
their
house
and
property
and
that
the
defendants/petitioners herein are injuncted from obstructing the peaceful
movement and right of way for egress and ingress thereto.
49.
An application under Order 39 Rule 1 & 2 read with Section 151
CPC was also preferred by the petitioner/respondent No. 1 before the trial
court
seeking
ad-interim
injunction
to
restrain
the
opposite
parties/defendants/petitioners herein from interfering with the right of way for
egress and ingress of the petitioner therein and the same was registered as
Misc. Case No. 98(T) of 2017 in T.S. No. 27 (T) of 2017.
50.
It is the considered opinion of this Court that the proper remedy for
the relevant respondents to agitate the matter and to seek adequate relief as far
as their grievance over the said 6 ft. land is concerned would be to pursue the
same in the said T.S. No. 27 (T) of 2017 and Misc. Case No. 98(T) of 2017.
Pursuing it in T.S. No. 236 (T) of 2013 by preferring the Misc. Case No. 90(T)
of 2017 is not the proper platform or forum.
51.
The action of the learned trial court in passing the order dated
30.10.2017 in Misc. Case No 90(T) of 2017 as well as the subsequent order
dated 22.10.2021 passed in Misc. Case No. 85(T) of 2021, order dated
16.12.2021 in Misc. Case No. 100(T) of 2021 and finally order dated
22.12.2021 passed in Misc. Case No. 105(T) of 2021 can be said to have been
orders passed irregularly and illegally and without jurisdiction by not taking
into account the fact that the relevant records were not before the trial court
when such petitions were filed by the parties.
52.
The impugned judgment/order dated 04.03.2022 passed in FAO No.
8(T) of 2017 passed by the learned Additional Deputy Commissioner(J),
Shillong could not have been passed since the order under appeal has been
passed without jurisdiction which has escaped the notice of the first appellate
court and therefore, by extension, the order passed in the appeal has also been
passed without jurisdiction.
53.
In view of the observations made above, this Court finds that the
impugned orders in both the two sets of petitions have been passed by the
concerned court without jurisdiction and the same are liable to be set aside
and quashed which is done so herein. The prayer made in these petitions is
accordingly allowed.
54.
Let the lower courts records called for by this Court be returned.
55.
Petitions disposed of. No costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
29.09.2023
“Tiprilynti–PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review