Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
Reserved On
: 24/03/2026
Pronounced On : 06/05/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/FIRST APPEAL NO. 1485 of 2018
With
CIVIL APPLICATION (FOR STAY) NO. 1 of 2018
In R/FIRST APPEAL NO. 1485 of 2018
FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE BHARGAV D. KARIA
and
HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE L. S. PIRZADA
==========================================================
Approved for Reporting
Yes
No
✓
==========================================================
HEIRS OF DECEASED RAMSHAKTI JIVANDAS & ORS.
Versus
HEIRS OF DECEASED BHALABHAI DAHYABHAI & ORS.
==========================================================
Appearance:
MR DC DAVE, SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH MR JIGAR P RAVAL(2008) for
the Appellant(s) No. 1.1,1.2
MR MAYUR RAJGURU(1198) for the Appellant(s) No. 1.1,1.2
VEDANT J RAJGURU(9375) for the Appellant(s) No. 1.1,1.2
DECEASED LITIGANT THROUGH LEGAL HEIRS/ REPRESENTATIVES for
the Defendant(s) No. 1.1
MR MEHUL SURESH SHAH, SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH MR MR VISHAL C
MEHTA(6152) for the Defendant(s) No. 3
NOTICE SERVED for the Defendant(s) No. 1.2,2.1,2.2
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE BHARGAV D. KARIA
and
HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE L. S. PIRZADA
CAV JUDGMENT
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
(PER : HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE BHARGAV D. KARIA)
1.Heard learned Senior Advocate Mr. Dhaval C.
Dave with learned advocate Mr. Jigar P. Raval
for
the
appellants
and
learned
Senior
Advocate Mr. Mehul Suresh Shah with learned
advocate
Mr.
Vishal
C.
Mehta
for
the
respondent no.3.
2.This
appeal
is
filed
by
the
original
plaintiffs being aggrieved by judgment and
order dated 22.03.2018 passed below Exhs.47
and 48 in Civil Suit No.1197 of 2017 by Court
No.17, City Civil Court, Ahmedabad allowing
the application under Order VII Rule 11 of
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (For short
“the Code”) for rejection of the plaint and
as a consequence thereof the decree is passed
below Exh.1 rejecting the suit.
C/FA/1485/2018
3.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
The
appellants
are
referred
to
as
the
plaintiffs and the respondents are referred
to
as
the
defendants
for
the
sake
of
case
are
that
the
convenience.
Facts:
4.Brief
facts
of
the
plaintiffs who are the legal heirs of late
Ramshakti Jivandas Sheth, instituted Regular
Civil Suit No.1197/2017 for declaration that
sale
deed
Serial
dated
No.13982
29.12.2010
with
the
registered
office
of
at
Sub-
Registrar, Ahmedabad-5, Narol is illegal.
5.It is the case of the plaintiffs that land
admeasuring 17300 sq. mtrs. of Survey No.111
and Survey No.111A situated at Village Narol,
District
Sub-District
Ahmedabad
along
with
land admeasuring 405 sq. mtrs of Pot Kharaba,
total land admeasuring 17705 sq. mtrs was of
the
ownership
of
defendant
no.1
late
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
Bhalabhai
Dahyabhai
and
thereafter
of
his
legal heirs defendant nos. 1/1 and defendant
no. 1/2, defendant no.2 – late Bimani, widow
of Ravjibhai
and thereafter her legal heirs
defendant no. 2/1 and defendant no.2/2.
6.During the pendency of the appeal, defendant
no.1/1- Bhupendrabhai Bhalabhai Patel expired
and
therefore,
his
legal
heirs
being
defendant nos. 1.1.1 to 1.1.4 were brought on
record.
Defendant
no.1.1.3-Nimesh
Bhupendrabhai Patel also expired during the
pendency
legal
of
heirs
the
appeal
being
and
1.1.3/1
therefore,
and
1.1.3/2
his
are
also brought on record.
7.It is the case of the plaintiffs that entire
land was purchased by the predecessor of the
defendants
by
registered
15.05.1959.
sale
deed
dated
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
8.It is the case of the plaintiffs that late
father
of
the
plaintiffs-
Sheth
Ramshakti
Jivandas along with the plaintiffs purchased
the land admeasuring 10346 sq. mtrs out of
the entire land (here-in-after referred to as
“the suit land”) along with right of passage
by
registered
agreement
to
sale
dated
14.05.1984 at the rate of Rs.16/- per sq mtr.
for total consideration of Rs.1,65,536/- and
had also paid 80% of the sale consideration
amounting
to
Rs.1,32,430/-
defendant
nos.
1/1,
1/2,
by
2/1
cheque
and
2/2
to
and
their predecessor and defendants had executed
irrevocable Power of Attorney, supplementary
agreement and affidavit to the effect that
vacant possession of the suit land was handed
over to the plaintiffs as owners. It is the
case of the plaintiffs that since 1984, the
plaintiffs are de facto owners of the suit
land. It is the case of the plaintiffs that
in the suit land, the plaintiffs had made
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
construction
and
started
a
company
“Subhang Process Mill Pvt. Ltd.”
named
registered
under the provisions of the Companies Act and
the name of the company of the plaintiffs is
shown in the Municipal records as an occupier
since 1986 and name of the plaintiffs are
shown as the owner in the Municipal records
for the taxation purpose.
9.It is also the case of the plaintiffs that
the plaintiffs are enjoying the possession of
the suit land for more than three decades
without any hindrance. It is the case of the
plaintiffs that formal registered sale deed
could not be executed due to some legal and
technical obstacles for a long time in spite
of
repeated
requests
defendants
and
plaintiffs
for
However,
assurance
being
their
made
to
the
predecessors
by
the
getting
was
NA
given
permission.
by
the
defendants that ownership rights were already
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
with the plaintiffs and therefore, there was
no need to worry in spite of the fact that
after the death of defendant nos. 1 and 2,
names
of
the
legal
heirs
were
mutated
in
record of rights. It is, therefore, the case
of the plaintiffs that as per section 53A of
the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 only the
sale deed was required to be executed by the
defendants, and the plaintiffs were ready and
willing to pay 20% balance amount of sale
consideration.
10.
It is the case of the plaintiffs that
when defendant no.3 published the notice in
the
newspaper
“Gujarat
Samachar”
Daily
on
24.06.2017 for obtaining a title clearance
certificate, it came to their knowledge that
the defendants in defiance of the registered
agreement to sale dated 14.05.1984 executed
two registered sale deeds on 29.12.2010 in
favour
of
defendant
no.3
-
Amrutbhai
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
Prabhudas Patel.
11.
The
plaintiffs,
therefore,
filed
their
objection for issuance of title clearance on
27.06.2017
public
and
01.07.2017
by
notice/clarification
“Gujarat
Samachar”
daily
publishing
in
a
newspaper
describing
their
ownership right over the suit land.
12.
The plaintiffs thereafter filed Regular
Civil
Suit
Court,
No.1197/2017
Ahmedabad
on
before
City
Civil
28.07.2017
for
declaration that the plaintiffs be declared
as owners of the suit land and further prayed
to set aside the sale deed dated 29.12.2010.
It is also prayed that permanent injunction
be granted against the defendants and their
servants,
agents
restraining
them
from
transferring the ownership right of the suit
land in favour of any third party.
C/FA/1485/2018
13.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
Defendant
no.3
–
Amrutbhai
Prabhubhai
Patel filed application Exh.48 under Order
VII Rule 11 of the Code for rejection of the
plaint on the ground of limitation as the
suit was filed on the basis of agreement to
sale dated 14.05.1984 in the year 2017 i.e.
almost after 30 years.
14.
Learned City Civil Court, Ahmedabad by
Judgment and Order dated 22.03.2018 allowed
the application Exh. 48 under Order VII Rule
of
the
Code.
It
was
observed
by
the
learned Judge that there is contradiction in
the
averments
registered
made
in
the
agreement
to
sale
plaint
at
and
Mark
4/1
wherein it is stated that possession was not
handed over to the plaintiffs and only at the
time
of
possession
execution
of
the
sale
was
handed
over.
to
be
deed,
It
was
further observed that entire document i.e.
agreement to sale at Mark-4/1 appears to be
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
very suspicious as on the last page of the
same,
many
signatures
appear
to
have
been
erased and that the possession of the suit
land
is
basis
claimed
of
by
the
plaintiffs
supplementary
on
agreement
the
for
possession which is executed on stamp paper
of Rs. 10/- on 09.05.1984.
15.
Learned Judge has also referred to the
Court
Commissioner’s
report
wherein
the
possession of the defendant no.3 was found at
the
suit
otherwise
land.
It
was
observed
the
plaintiffs
have
that
even
challenged
registered sale deed dated 29.12.2010 in the
year 2017 and therefore, the suit is time
barred and beyond the period of limitation.
Learned Judge as a consequence dismissed the
suit.
Being
aggrieved,
the
appellants-
plaintiffs have preferred this appeal.
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
Submissions of the appellants-plaintiffs:
16.
Learned
Senior
Advocate
Mr.
Dhaval
C.
Dave with learned advocate Mr. Jigar P. Raval
for the appellants-plaintiffs submitted that
judgement and order dated 22.03.2018 passed
by the learned Court in Regular Civil Suit
no. 1197 of 2017, whereby the learned Judge
has
dismissed
the
suit
appellants-plaintiffs
preferred
while
by
the
allowing
the
application filed by the original defendant
no. 3 under Order VII Rule 11 of the Code, is
a non-speaking order. It was submitted that
the learned trial Court has held that the
suit is barred by the provisions of Section
of
the
Section
Specific
of
Relief
the
Agricultural
Lands
reasons
or
grounds
learned
Trial
Bombay
Act,
Court
Act,
1948.
and
Tenancy
and
However,
no
are
provided
by
the
for
arriving
at
such
decision.
C/FA/1485/2018
17.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
Learned Senior Advocate Mr. Dave for the
appellants-plaintiffs
submitted
that
the
defendants have in collusion with each other
defrauded the plaintiffs and after concealing
relevant facts have got registered the sale
deed
in 2010 and
had the entries entered in
the revenue record after a considerably long
time for which no notice was served up on the
plaintiffs.
public
However,
notice
for
upon
title
publication
clearance
by
of
the
defendants in 2017, the plaintiffs came to
know about the sale deed executed in the year
2010. It was therefore submitted that, the
limitation
period
starts
only
upon
the
knowledge of publication of notice in 2017
and
not
from
date
of
registration
of
agreement to sale in 1984. It was therefore,
submitted that
the learned trial court has
committed an error in rejecting the plaint
under order VII
Rule 11 of the Code.
C/FA/1485/2018
18.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
It was submitted that no specific time
to perform the agreement was agreed between
the parties as the land was an agricultural
land
and
when
the
agreement
to
sale
was
signed in 1984, NA Certificate was required
in order to get the registered sale deed and
to
use
purpose.
the
suit
It
land
was
for
non-agricultural
submitted
that
the
predecessor of defendants signed the General
Power of Attorney in favour of the plaintiffs
on
14.05.1984
and
also
supplementary
agreement for possession was executed on the
same day in favour of the plaintiffs and as
such, the plaintiffs paid the 80%
amount of
sale consideration as agreed and got peaceful
and actual possession by the supplementary
agreement and also got receipt thereof. It
was
further
submitted
that
the
power
of
attorney and other documents of possession,
etc. are supported with affidavit signed by
late
Bhalabhai
Dahyabhai
in
favour
of
the
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
plaintiffs,
whereby
the
plaintiffs
were
absolute owner as per the provisions of the
Transfer
of
Property
Act,
and
the
defendants have neither right to possession
nor right to transfer or assign the suit land
in any manner.
19.
It was submitted that since 1984 i.e.
since registration of Agreement to Sale, the
appellants-plaintiffs were in possession of
the suit land and therefore, did not prefer
any litigation for execution of sale deed as
the respondents-defendants continued to give
oral assurances to the plaintiffs-appellants
that the
sale deed would be executed soon on
receipt of NA order.
20.
It was submitted that, the rights of the
plaintiffs-appellants
or
the
reliefs
as
claimed in the prayers of the plaint with
regards to declaration, possession, ownership
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
etc.
are
nowhere
related
to
any
of
the
clauses of Order VII Rule 11 of the Code and
the case of the plaintiffs-appellants could
not have been
rejected under Order VII
Rule
11 of the Code without going into the merits
of
the
matter
evidence
which
and
are
without
subject
appreciating
of
trial
and
cannot be decided at the stage of considering
application under
Order VII
Rule 11 of the
Code.
21.
It was submitted that section 34 of the
Specific Relief Act, 1963 would not bar the
suit as section 34 would only apply when the
plaintiffs-appellants
would
have
claimed
specific performance of agreement to sale,
whereas
in the facts of the case, section
53A of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882
would
be
applicable
as
the
plaintiffs-
appellants were already in possession of the
suit land since 1984. It was submitted that,
C/FA/1485/2018
as
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
per
section
53A,
where
any
person
contracts to transfer for consideration any
immoveable property by writing signed by him
or
on
his
behalf
from
which
the
terms
necessary to constitute the transfer can be
ascertained
with
reasonable
certainty,
and
the transferee has in part performance of the
contract, taken possession of the property or
any part thereof, or the transferee, being
already
in
possession
possession,
in
part
continues
performance
of
in
the
contract and has done some act in furtherance
of
the
contract,
and
the
transferee
has
performed or is willing to perform his part
of
the
contract,
or,
where
there
is
an
instrument of transfer, but the transfer has
not been completed in the manner prescribed
by the law for the time being in force, the
transferor or any person claiming under him
shall be debarred from enforcing against the
transferee and persons claiming under him any
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
right in respect of the property of which the
transferee
has
possession,
provided
by
taken
or
other
than
a
the
terms
of
continued
in
right
expressly
the
contract.
Therefore,
the
appellants-plaintiffs
are
entitled
have
decree
as
to
for
ownership
prayed in the plaint.
22.
Learned Senior Advocate Mr. Dave for the
appellants-plaintiffs
in
support
of
his
submissions placed reliance on the judgement
in
case
Versus
of
Daliben
Prajapati
Valjibhai
Kodarbhai
and
Others
Kachrabhai
and
Another reported in 2024 SCC OnLine SC 4105,
wherein the Hon’ble Apex Court has held that
while rejecting the plaint, when the question
arises
whether
the
plaintiffs
had
the
knowledge of the execution of the sale deed,
it could not be expected that the plaintiffs
must
fraud
have
given
meticulous
perpetuated
in
the
details
of
the
plaint
itself.
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
However, the Hon’ble Court further held in
the facts of the said case that the findings
of the High Court are primarily factual and
the High Court while rejecting the plaint,
seems to have got carried away by the fact
that the suit was filed by the plaintiff 13
years after the execution of the sale deed.
It
was
further
held
that
there
was
no
justification for the High Court in allowing
the application under Order VII Rule 11, on
issues
that
averments
in
were
not
evident
from
the
the
plaint
itself.
The
High
Court was also not justified in holding that
the limitation period commences from the date
of registration of the agreement of sale and
the judgment of the High Court was held to be
unsustainable. The Hon’ble Supreme court also
considered the decision in case of P.V. Guru
Raj Reddy v. P. Neeradha Reddy reported in
(2015) 8 SCC 331 wherein, Hon’ble Apex court
held that it is only if the averments in the
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
plaint ex facie do not disclose a cause of
action
or
appears
to
be
barred
plaint
can
be
rejected
and
the
claims
will
situations,
on
a
reading
thereof,
under
the
suit
any
law,
the
in
all
have
other
to
be
adjudicated during the course of the trial.
It was further held that the claim of the
plaintiffs with regard to the knowledge of
the essential facts giving rise to the cause
of action as pleaded in the plaint will have
to be accepted as correct at the stage of
consideration of the application under Order
VII Rule 11 of the Code,and the stand of the
defendants in the written statement would be
altogether irrelevant.
23.
It was submitted that the Hon’ble Apex
Court in case of Daliben Valjibhai and Others
(supra) also dealt with the decision in case
of
Chhotanben
v.
Kirtibhai
Jalkrushnabhai
Thakkar reported in (2018) 6 SCC 422 wherein
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
Hon’ble
Apex
Court
held
that
when
the
appellants-plaintiffs have asserted that the
suit
was
filed
immediately
knowledge
about
the
after
fraudulent
getting
sale
deed
executed by the defendants, by keeping them
in the dark about such execution, the issue
regarding the suit being barred by limitation
in the facts of the case, is a triable issue
and for which reason the plaint cannot be
rejected at the threshold in exercise of the
power under Order VII Rule 11(d) of the Code.
24.
Reliance
was
also
placed
on
the
judgment of Hon’ble Apex Court in case of
Urvashiben & Anr. V/S. Krishnakant Manuprasad
Trivedi reported in (2019) 13 SCC 372.
25.
Reliance was placed on the judgment of
Apex Court in case of Sucha Singh Sodhi (D)
thr.
L.Rs.
Vs.
Baldev
Raj
Walia
and
Ors.
reported in AIR 2018 SC 2241, to submit that
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
as per Order II Rule 2 of the Code, every
suit shall include the whole of the claim
which the Plaintiff is entitled to make in
respect
of
the
cause
of
action,
but
a
Plaintiff may relinquish any portion of his
claim in order to bring the suit within the
jurisdiction of any Court. It was therefore,
submitted in the facts of the present case
that
the
claim
plaintiffs
with
have
regards
relinquished
to
the
his
specific
performance of agreement to sale, which as
per learned Senior Advocate Mr. Dave can be
made in a subsequent suit or even in the
present suit by way of an amendment. It was
therefore, prayed that the impugned Judgement
and orders are liable to be set aside and
trial court may continue with the trial.
Submissions of the Respondents:
26.
Shah
learned Senior Advocate Mr. Mehul Suresh
with
learned
advocate
Mr.
Vishal
C.
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
Mehta
for
the
respondents-defendants
submitted that the suit filed by appellantsplaintiffs was filed after
execution
of
registered
33 years from the
Agreement
to
sale
dated 14.05.1984 and therefore, the suit is
suffering from limitation and is hopelessly
time barred. It was submitted that nothing is
placed on record by the appellants-plaintiffs
to
show
reasonable
grounds
for
delay
from
1984 till 2017 when civil suit was filed. It
was submitted that the averments made in the
plaint are absolutely vague with regards to
what
happened
documents
or
after
till
prima
facie
as
evidences
no
are
produced on record or no specific averments
of
dates
have
been
mentioned
by
the
plaintiffs as to what notices were issued or
follow-ups have been made by the plaintiffs
after agreement to sale in 1984 or as to when
the defendants have given oral assurances. It
was further submitted that if it is assumed
C/FA/1485/2018
that
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
appellants-plaintiffs
made
regular
requests to the defendants for execution of
sale
deed,
it
becomes
obvious
that
the
appellants were in knowledge of the alleged
breach of agreement to sale and therefore,
the period of limitation would start from the
date when the appellants first came to know
about the said alleged breach or when the
first
request
for
execution
sale
deed
was
made and therefore as per section 9 of the
Limitation Act, 1963 limitation period that
has once begun to run, cannot stop due to
subsequent disability or inability and legal
actions cannot be delayed indefinitely due to
obstacles.
27.
It was submitted that the plaint does
not disclose any cause of action as the only
basis
for
declaration
of
title
rights
as
prayed by the appellants-plaintiffs in the
plaint is agreement to sale of 1984 coupled
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
with
the
claim
of
having
continuous
possession of the suit land, however, it is
an accepted principle that merely being party
to
agreement
ownership
28.
It
to
sale
would
not
confer
rights.
was
further
submitted
that
the
plaintiffs have disputed the registered sale
deed of the defendants and have asked for
declaration
and
injunction.
However,
no
specific performance of agreement to sale is
prayed
plaint.
the
for
the
It was
Specific
by
the
plaintiffs
in
the
submitted that section 34 of
Relief
Act,1963
provides
for
discretion of the Court as to declaration of
status or right of any person entitled to any
legal character, or to any right as to any
property, who may institute a suit against
any person denying, or interested to deny,
his title to such character or right, and the
Court may in its discretion make therein a
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
declaration that he is so entitled, and the
plaintiffs need not in such suit ask for any
further relief. However, proviso to section
34 provides that no Court shall make any such
declaration where the plaintiffs, being able
to
seek
further
declaration
of
relief
title,
than
omits
to
a
mere
do
so.
Therefore, as per Section 34 of the Specific
Relief Act,1963 in the present case as the
plaintiffs, being able to seek further relief
than a mere declaration of title, has omitted
to
do
so,
the
under Order VII
29.
suit
was
rightly
dismissed
Rule 11(d) of Code.
Reliance was placed on the decision of
Hon’ble Apex Court in case of Vasantha (Dead)
Thr. LR. V/s. Rajalakshmi @ Rajam thr. LRs in
Civil Appeal No. 3854 of 2014
wherein it is
held that the purpose behind the inclusion of
the
proviso
to
section
multiplicity
of
the
was
to
proceedings.
prevent
It
was
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
further
expounded
that
a
mere
declaratory
decree remains non-executable in most cases
and
if
suit
does
not
pray
performance/consequential
for
relief,
specific
the
suit
cannot be maintainable and therefore being
barred by law liable to be dismissed.
30.
Reliance
was
also
placed
on
the
decision of Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of
Umadevi v/s. Anand Kumar reported in 2025 (0)
AIJEL SC 75007,
wherein order passed by the
Trial court rejecting plaint under Order VII
Rule 11 of the Code was upheld by the Apex
Court when no cause of action for filing suit
was disclosed by the plaintiffs in the plaint
as
the
plaintiffs
failed
to
address
the
crucial question of when they became aware of
the registered sale deeds of suit property
and whether if they had prior knowledge of
the sale deeds, they failed to specify the
exact date of such knowledge.
C/FA/1485/2018
31.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
Reliance
was
also
placed
upon
the
decision of Apex Court in case of Shri Mukund
Bhavan Trust & Ors. v. Shrimant Chhatrapati
Udayan Raje Pratapsinh Maharaj Bhonsle & Anr.
reported
in
SCC
OnLine
SC
to
substantiate the contention that the suit was
barred by limitation.
32.
Learned
Senior
Advocate
Mr.
Shah
further contended that, as held by Apex Court
in case of Khatri Hotels Pvt. Ltd. vs. Union
of India reported in (2011) 9 SCC 12, the use
of the word 'first’ between the words 'sue'
and 'accrues' in Article 58 of the Limitation
Act,163 would mean that if a suit is based on
multiple
causes
of
action,
the
period
of
limitation will begin to run from the date
when the right to sue first accrue. That is,
if
there
are
successive
violations
of
the
right, it would not give rise to a fresh
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
cause action, and the suit will be liable to
be dismissed, if it is beyond the period of
limitation
counted
from
the
date
when
the
right to sue first accrued. It was therefore,
submitted
first
that
right
in
to
the
facts
of
the
case,
sue
would
arise
after
completion to three years in 1987 from the
dated of agreement to sale dated 14.05.1984.
33.
Reliance
was
also
placed
upon
the
decision of Apex Court in case of Padhiyar
Prahladji
Chenaji
(Deceased)
Through
L.R.S
Versus Maniben Jagmalbhai (Deceased) Through
LRS
reported
wherein
it
in
(0)
AIJEL-SC
68485
was
held
that
when
main
the
reliefs sought by the plaintiffs in the suit
were
cancellation
declaration,
injunction
the
of
the
sale
deed
prayer
of
permanent
restraining
defendant
No.1
and
from
disturbing possession can be said to be a
consequential relief. Therefore, the title to
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
the property was the basis of the relief of
possession, if that be so, the relief for
permanent
injunction
can
be
said
to
be
a
consequential relief and not a substantive
relief. Therefore, once the plaintiffs have
failed
to
get
any
substantive
relief
of
cancellation of the sale deed and failed to
get
any
declaratory
relief,
relief
of
injunction can be said to be a consequential
relief
and
permanent
therefore,
injunction
the
must
prayer
fail
and
for
the
plaintiffs cannot be said to be in lawful
possession
land,
i.e.
the
possession of the plaintiffs would
be
"not
law",
the
legal
or
plaintiffs
of
the
suit
authorised
by
the
would
be
entitled
not
to
any
for
the
and
the
relief of permanent injunction.
Analysis:
34.
Heard
parties
the
and
learned
perused
advocates
the
plaint
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
documents annexed with the plaint. On perusal
of
the
plaint,
determination
following
points
for
are
formulated
for
learned
trial
has
consideration:
1)
Whether
erred
in
the
law
in
allowing
the
Judge
application
under Order VII Rule 11 of the Code without
assigning
any
reason
for
holding
that
the
suit is barred by the provisions of section
of
the
Specific
Relief
Act,1963
and
section
of
Bombay
Tenancy
and
the
Agricultural Lands Act, 1948?
2) Whether the plaintiffs can be said to have
knowledge only on publication of the public
notice by the defendants in the year 2017
about the sale deed executed in the year 2010
and
limitation
period
would
publication of notice in 2017?
start
only
on
C/FA/1485/2018
3)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
Whether the plaintiffs prove that full
amount as agreed was paid and peaceful actual
possession
by
the
supplementary
possession
agreement was handed over along with General
Power of Attorney dated 14.05.1984 as per the
affidavit
of
late
Bhalabhai
Dahyabhai
in
favour of the plaintiffs?
4)
Whether the provisions of section 53A of
the
Transfer
applicable
of
in
Property
facts
of
the
Act,
is
case
and
not
section 34 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963?
5)
Whether agreement to sale is barred by
section
of
the
Bombay
Tenancy
and
Agricultural Lands Act, 1948 as no permission
was obtained for the purchase of agricultural
land
by
the
plaintiffs
who
are
non
agriculturists?
6) Whether there is any cause of action to
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
file a suit in the year 2017 for declaration
and permanent injunction without prayer for
specific performance of the agreement to sale
dated 14.05.1984?
7)
Whether the plaintiffs were entitled to
raise the claim of specific performance of
agreement to sale by way of amendment or not?
35.
Considering the facts of the case which
are not in dispute between the parties, the
suit was filed after more than 33 years from
the execution of the agreement to sale dated
14.05.1984. Therefore, prima facie the suit
is barred by law of limitation being time
barred.
36.
The contention raised on behalf of the
appellants-plaintiffs is that the claim of
the plaintiffs for specific performance of
the agreement to sale can be relinquished as
C/FA/1485/2018
the
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
plaintiffs
have
also
invoked
the
provisions of section 53A of the Transfer of
Property
Act,
as
there
is
part
performance of the contract of agreement to
sale
and
possession
supplementary
agreement
for
entered into in the year 1984 and
only sale deed was to be executed.
However,
the
in
averments
made
in
the
plaint
this
respect are absolutely vague as nothing is
disclosed as to what happened between 1984
and 2017 and no documents are also placed on
record with the plaint in that regard.
37.
There are no specific averments of any
date mentioned by the plaintiffs as to what
follow
up
actions
had
been
taken
after
execution of the agreement to sale in the
year 1984.
38.
On perusal of the documents placed along
with the plaint, it also emerges that the
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
averments made in the plaint regarding the
possession
of
the
plaintiffs
is
also
not
corroborated by any document.
39.
It
also
regarding
appears
oral
that
the
assurance
given
averments
by
the
defendants are also only in the nature of
clever drafting as even if it is assumed that
the
appellants-plaintiffs
had
made
regular
requests to the defendants for execution of
the sale deed, it becomes obvious that the
appellants-plaintiffs
were
in
knowledge
of
alleged breach of agreement to sale in the
year
and
therefore,
the
period
of
limitation would start when the plaintiffs
first came to know about the alleged breach
when
they
requested
for
execution
of
agreement to sale.
40.
On perusal of cause of action narrated
in the plaint, same does not disclose any
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
cause
as
only
basis
for
declaration
of
ownership rights as prayed by the plaintiffs
in the plaint is agreement to sale of 1984
coupled with the assertion of having been in
continuous
possession
of
the
suit
land.
However, it is a trite law that merely being
party
to
the
agreement
to
sale
would
not
confer ownership rights upon the plaintiffs.
41.
Provisions of section 34 of the Specific
Relief Act, 1963 provides for discretion of
the
Court
as
to
declaration
of
status
or
right of any person entitled to any legal
character,
or
to
any
right
as
to
any
property, who may institute a suit against
any person denying, or interested to deny,
his
title
However,
to
there
such
character
is
prayer
no
or
for
right.
specific
performance of the agreement to sale by the
plaintiffs in the plaint.
In absence of such
prayer, as per proviso to section 34,
no
C/FA/1485/2018
Court
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
shall
make
any
such
declaration
of
title of the plaintiffs and the plaintiffs
have failed to seek declaration of title and
in the facts of the case the plaintiffs have
failed
to
seek
further
relief
except
mere
declaration of title and therefore, the suit
was rightly dismissed under Order VII Rule
11(d) of the Code by the trial Court.
42.
The
Hon’ble
Apex
Court
in
case
of
Vasantha (Dead) Thr. LR. V/s. Rajalakshmi @
Rajam thr. LRs (supra), has held that the
purpose behind the inclusion of the proviso
to section 34 was to prevent multiplicity of
proceedings
and
mere
declaratory
decree
remains non-executable in most cases if no
prayer is made for specific performance or
consequential
relief
and
such
suit
is
not
case
of
maintainable being barred by law.
43.
The
Hon’ble
Apex
Court
in
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
Umadevi
v/s.
considering
Anand
the
Kumar(supra),
decision
in
case
after
of
Suraj
Lamp Industries Pvt. Ltd v. State of Haryana
and another reported in (2012) 1
SCC 656 and
decision in case of Shri Mukund Bhavan Trust
and ors. v. Shrimant Chhatrapati Udayan Raje
Pratapsinh Maharaj Bhonsle & Anr. reported in
2024 0 SCC OnLine SC 3844 and decision in
case of Madanuri Sri Rama Chandra Murthy v.
Syed Jalal reported in (2017) 13 SCC 174 as
well
as
decision
Arvindbhai
in
Kalyanji
case
of
Dahiben
v.
Bhanusali
reported
in
(2020) 7 SCC 366, has held that considering
the ratios of such decisions when the trial
Court has come to the conclusion that the
suit
filed
by
the
plaintiffs
was
a
meaningless litigation as it did not disclose
a proper cause of action and the suit would
be barred by limitation.
44.
In the facts of the case also, no cause
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
of action for filing the suit is disclosed by
the plaintiffs as the plaintiffs have failed
to address the crucial question as to when
they became aware of the registered sale deed
executed in the year 2010 of the suit land
and whether they had prior knowledge of the
sale
deeds
as
the
exact
date
of
such
knowledge is not disclosed and only reliance
is placed on public notice issued in the year
2017 to bring the suit within the limitation.
45.
The Hon’be Apex Court in case of Shri
Mukund
Bhavan
Chhatrapati
Trust
Udayan
&
Raje
Ors.
v.
Pratapsinh
Shrimant
Maharaj
Bhonsle & Anr.(supra) in facts of the said
case has held that the reliefs sought in the
suit
were
barred
by
limitation
as
per
Articles 58 and 59 of the Limitation Act,
and
plaint,
it
hopelessly
upon
was
meaningful
evident
barred
by
reading
of
the
the
suit
was
limitation.
It
was
that
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
clarified
by
the
Hon’ble
Apex
Court
that
Article 58 provides a three year limitation
period from when right to sue first accrues
whereas Article 59 similarly prescribes three
years for cancellation or setting aside an
instrument.
It
was
also
held
that
as
per
section 3 of the Transfer of Property Act,
the
registered
documents
provide
notice
therefore,
in
constructive
and
facts of the present case, the
executed
in
the
year
the
sale deed
has
remained
unchallenged by the plaintiffs and therefore,
action of challenging the same in the year
has
timely
become
action
untenable
and
failure
due
to
lack
to
assert
of
right
within the prescribed period.
46.
The
Hon’be
Apex
Court
in
case
of
Padhiyar Prahladji Chenaji (Deceased) Through
L.R.S
Versus
Maniben
Through LRS(supra)
Jagmalbhai
(Deceased)
has held as under:
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
“11. From the impugned judgment and order
passed by the High Court, it appears that the
High Court has not properly appreciated the
distinction between a substantive relief and a
consequential relief. The High Court has
observed that in the instant case the relief of
permanent injunction can be said to be a
substantive relief, which is clearly an erroneous
view. It is to be noted that the main reliefs
sought by the plaintiff in the suit were
cancellation of the sale deed and declaration
and the prayer of permanent injunction
restraining defendant No.1 from disturbing her
possession can be said to be a consequential
relief. Therefore, the title to the property was
the basis of the relief of possession. If that be
so, in the present case, the relief for permanent
injunction can be said to be a consequential
relief and not a substantive relief as observed
and held by the High Court. Therefore, once the
plaintiff has failed to get any substantive relief
of cancellation of the sale deed and failed to get
any declaratory relief, and as observed
hereinabove, relief of injunction can be said to
be a consequential relief.
Therefore, the prayer for permanent injunction
must fail. In the instant case as the plaintiff
cannot be said to be in lawful possession of the
suit land, i.e., the possession of the plaintiff is
"not legal or authorised by the law", the plaintiff
shall not be entitled to any permanent
injunction.”
47.
Applying the above ratio in facts of
the present case, title to the suit land was
made the basis of the relief of possession
and if that be so, in facts of the case,
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
relief for permanent injunction can be said
to
be
consequential
relief
and
not
a
substantive relief. Therefore, prayers made
in
the
plaint
permanent
cannot
be
granted
injunction
as
the
regarding
main
relief
sought by the plaintiffs in the suit were for
cancellation of the sale deed and declaration
of title and the title of ownership of the
plaintiffs
qua
upon
cancellation
the
the
suit
land
of
would
the
depend
sale
deed
executed in favour of the defendant no.3 and
therefore, the plaintiffs cannot be said to
be in lawful possession of the suit land as
the possession of the plaintiffs would not be
legal or authorised by law.
48.
The
provision
of
section
53A
of
the
Transfer of Property Act, 1882 would not be
applicable in the facts of the case as it
appears from the record that the plaintiffs
have sought protection of the possession of
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
the suit land on the ground that possession
was handed over pursuant to the supplementary
agreement
their
dated
14.05.1984
continued
and
therefore,
possession
deserves
of
the
does
not
protection.
However,
section
Transfer
Property
Act,
of
53A
confer ownership or any enforceable title but
only protects the possession of a transferee
who
has
acted
in
part
performance
of
the
that
the
contract.
49.
It
is
by
now
well
settled
provision of section 53A operates only as a
shield and not as a sword which can be used
as
a
defense
cannot
be
to
resist
invoked
as
dispossession
a
basis
to
but
assert
ownership or to seek affirmative relief such
as
specific
performance
or
declaration
of
title. The plaintiffs, therefore, cannot rely
upon
section
action
for
53A
in
support
enforcement
of
any
of
cause
of
contractual
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
right
as
per
the
settled
legal
position.
Reliance placed on behalf of plaintiffs on
section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act,
to
sustain
possession
is
primary
claim
barred
by
the
claim
legally
for
or
protect
untenable
specific
limitation,
the
once
the
performance
therefore,
plea
is
for
protection of possession under section 53A
would not be available.
50.
Reliance placed by the learned advocate
for the plaintiffs on the decision of Hon’ble
Apex Court in case of Daliben Valjibhai and
Others Versus Prajapati Kodarbhai Kachrabhai
and Another (supra) would be of no help in
view of the findings of fact recorded by the
trial Court coupled with the averments made
in the plaint and the documents placed on
record
in
support
particularly
in
of
such
absence
of
averments,
date
of
more
actual
knowledge of the execution of the sale deed
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
in 2010 not being disclosed by the plaintiffs
and only averments are made in respect of
acquiring
the
date
of
knowledge
on
publication of notice in the year 2017 which
is nothing but clever drafting of the plaint.
51.
In the present case, reading the plaint
as a whole and the proceedings on the basis
of
averments
trial
therein
has
rightly
Court
made
as
correct,
come
to
the
the
conclusion that suit is barred by limitation
considering the averments made in the plaint
which ex-facie do not disclose a cause of
action and reading thereof, the
suit appears
to be barred under law of limitation.
52.
Reliance placed on decision in case of
Urvashiben & Anr. V/S. Krishnakant Manuprasad
Trivedi(supra)
is
also
not
applicable
in
facts of the case as Hon’ble Apex Court has
held
that
for
deciding
whether
the
plaint
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
deserves to be rejected only averments stated
in
the
plaint
have
to
Referring
to
Article
Act,1963,
the
Hon’ble
Apex
be
considered.
the
Limitation
of
Court
has
held
that when the date is fixed for performance,
limitation is three years from such date. If
no such date is fixed, the period of three
years is to be computed from the date when
the plaintiff has notice of refusal. In the
facts of the present case merely because the
plaintiffs have made averments that he came
to know about execution of the sale deed of
2010 in the year 2017 in the plaint from the
date of publishing the public notice would
not be applicable as it is nothing but a
clever drafting in view of the averments made
in
the
agreement
for
sale
executed
on
14.05.1984 wherein it is stipulated that it
is for the plaintiffs to obtain the requisite
NA permission for transfer of land.
C/FA/1485/2018
53.
It
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
is
also
supplementary
pertinent
agreement
to
for
note
that
possession
was
executed on 09.05.1984 whereas agreement for
sale
was
executed
on
thereafter
no
averments
plaintiffs
of
any
execution
of
the
14.05.1984
are
efforts
made
and
by
the
being
made
for
sale
deed
for
more
than
decision
in
case
of
Sucha
three decades.
54.
Similarly,
Singh Sodhi (D) thr. L.Rs. Vs. Baldev Raj
Walia
and
Ors.(supra)
would
also
be
not
applicable in the facts of the present case
as the issue of applicability of Order II
Rule 2 of the Code regarding the claim made
by the plaintiffs and right of plaintiffs to
relinquish any portion of the claim to bring
the suit within the jurisdiction of the Court
would not be applicable in absence of the
averments
made
in
the
plaint
bringing
the
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
suit within the period of limitation.
55.
The contention raised on behalf of the
plaintiffs that suit can be filed subject to
obtaining permission under section 63 of the
Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act,
1948 is not required to be considered at this
stage in view of the fact that the suit is
barred by limitation.
Conclusion:
56.
Having
considered
the
pleadings,
documents and reliefs sought in the plaint,
we are of the opinion that the trial Court
has not committed any error as no cause of
action has been stated by the plaintiffs as
the suit is based on agreement to sale dated
14.05.1984 whereas the suit is filed in the
year 2017, therefore, the suit is time-barred
by
limitation
under
Article
of
the
Limitation Act as the right to seek specific
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
performance accrued in the year 1984 when the
agreement was executed or at least in 2013 as
the sale deed in favour of the defendant was
executed in the year 2010.
57.
As the sale deed executed in 2010 was a
registered
are
deemed
public
document,
to
had
have
the
the
plaintiffs
constructive
notice of the execution of such sale deed,
hence
the
trial
Court
has
rightly
not
considered the plea of lack of knowledge or
date of knowledge in the year 2017 when the
public
notice
for
title
clearance
was
issued.
58.
The cause of action as pleaded is in the
nature of clever drafting being artificial
and illusionary inasmuch as vague averments
are made and allowing such suit to proceed
would amount to permitting the abuse of the
judicial
process.
The
trial
Court
has
C/FA/1485/2018
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 06/05/2026
therefore, rightly rejected the plaint under
Order
VII
Rule
Procedure,
1908.
dismissed.
No
Application
of
Appeal
order
also
the
as
stands
Code
is
to
of
Civil
accordingly
cost.
disposed
Civil
of
accordingly.
(BHARGAV D. KARIA, J)
(L. S. PIRZADA, J)
RAGHUNATH R NAIR
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review