The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
3. Secretary, Manipur Public Service Commission, Imphal, North A.O.C. …Respondents HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. SIDDHARTH MRIDUL HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE GOLMEI GAIPHULSHILLU KABUI For the appellant : Mr. A. Romenkumar, Sr. Advocate For the respondents : Mr. M. Devananda, Addl. AG Date of Judgment : 17-04-2024 Siddharth Mridul (C.J.), [1] The present appeal has been instituted by Smt. Heigrujam Pinky Devi assailing the impugned judgment and order dated 21-03-2024 passed in WP(C) No. 624 of 2023, whereby the learned Single Judge of this Court whilst dismissing the said writ petition concluded that the appellant was ineligible for the vacancy that arose between 2019-2020 for the post of Fishery Officer. WA No. 15 of 2024 [2] The facts as are relevant for the determination of the present appeal are elaborated as follows:— (i) The appellant was appointed on regular basis to the post of Fishery Inspector in the Directorate of Fisheries, Government of Manipur in order of merit w.e.f. 01-12-2016 vide order dated 01-12-2016. (ii) The appellant completed One Year Post Graduate Diploma in Inland Fisheries and Aquaculture Management (PGDIFI & AM) from May 2019 to April 2020. At this stage, it would be relevant to observe that the duration of the course was admittedly extended due to the Covid-19 pandemic. [3] The appellant’s case is that she is eligible for consideration for promotion to the po…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Suppl. DB Item No. 1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WA No. 15 of 2024
Smt. Heigrujam Pinky Devi, aged about 38 years, D/o H. Dilip
Kumar, W/o Birajit Singh Oinam of Singjamei Oinam Thingel,
P.O. & P.S. Singjamei of Imphal West District, Manipur –
795008, now working as Fishery Inspector in the Fishery
Department.
…Appellant
- Versus 1. The State of Manipur represented by the Secretary, Fishery,
Government of Manipur, Old Secretariat Complex, Imphal –
795001.
2. Director of Fisheries, Government of Manipur, Lamphelpat.
3. Secretary, Manipur Public Service Commission, Imphal,
North A.O.C.
…Respondents
B EF O R E
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. SIDDHARTH MRIDUL
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE GOLMEI GAIPHULSHILLU KABUI
For the appellant
: Mr. A. Romenkumar, Sr. Advocate
For the respondents
: Mr. M. Devananda, Addl. AG
Date of Judgment
: 17-04-2024
JUDGMENT
Siddharth Mridul (C.J.),
[1]
The present appeal has been instituted by Smt. Heigrujam Pinky
Devi assailing the impugned judgment and order dated 21-03-2024 passed
in WP(C) No. 624 of 2023, whereby the learned Single Judge of this Court
whilst dismissing the said writ petition concluded that the appellant was
ineligible for the vacancy that arose between 2019-2020 for the post of
Fishery Officer.
WA No. 15 of 2024
[2]
The facts as are relevant for the determination of the present
appeal are elaborated as follows:—
(i)
The appellant was appointed on regular basis to the post of Fishery
Inspector in the Directorate of Fisheries, Government of Manipur in
order of merit w.e.f. 01-12-2016 vide order dated 01-12-2016.
(ii)
The appellant completed One Year Post Graduate Diploma in
Inland Fisheries and Aquaculture Management (PGDIFI & AM)
from May 2019 to April 2020.
At this stage, it would be relevant to observe that the duration of the
course was admittedly extended due to the Covid-19 pandemic.
[3]
The appellant’s case is that she is eligible for consideration for
promotion to the post of Fishery Officer as stipulated by the Fishery
Department, Manipur (Fishery Officer) Recruitment Rules, 1996 (RR).
[4]
The appellant asserts that as per the RR she has already
completed three years regular service and successfully obtained the
requisite diploma, i.e. Post Graduate Diploma in Inland Fisheries and
Aquaculture Management.
[5]
On 04-09-2019, the Director, Fisheries notified the combined final
inter se seniority list of Fishery Inspectors/Fishery Instructors/Fishery
Extension Assistants as on 31-08-2019. The name of the appellant figured
at Serial No. 14 of the said seniority list.
[6]
It is observed, however, that, in the combined final seniority list of
Fishery Inspectors/Fishery Instructors/Fishery Extension Assistants in the
Directorate of Fisheries, Government of Manipur as on 31-08-2019, the
WA No. 15 of 2024
appellant was considered ineligible at the time of original DPC for not
possessing requisite Diploma or Certificate as prescribed in criteria 1 & 2 of
the existing RR.
[7]
The DPC conducted on 16-11-2020, therefore, did not consider
her case for promotion to the post of Fishery Officer.
[8]
Pursuant to the common judgment and order dated 03-02-2023
delivered by the Coordinate Bench of this Court in WA No. 111 of 2022, WA
No. 112 of 2022 and WA No. 115 of 2022, the appellant submitted a
representation to the respondents on 10-02-2023 for including her name for
consideration in the review DPC in terms of the directions contained therein.
[9]
The appellant’s name was, however, not included in the eligible
list of candidates for the review DPC conducted on 18-09-2023.
[10]
The appellant instituted the subject writ petition seeking a writ of
mandamus directing the official respondents to include her name in the list
of candidates for the said review DPC, as well as to quash and set aside the
proposal dated 18-08-2023 for holding review DPC; as being contrary and
violative of the RR of Fishery Officer as well as the said judgment and order
of the Coordinate Bench dated 03-02-2023 (supra).
[11]
On behalf of the appellant, it was vehemently urged before the
learned Single Judge that the appellant had completed three years of regular
service in the feeder cadre of Fishery Inspector and had successfully
completed the Diploma course conducted during the period May 2019 to
April 2020, and as such, possessed all the requisite qualifications for
promotion to the post of Fishery Officer in terms of the subject RR.
WA No. 15 of 2024
[12]
Per contra, Mr. M. Devananda, learned Addl. Advocate General,
had asserted that on the bare perusal of the marksheet dated 20-09-2021
and the certificate dated 28-08-2023 issued by the ICAR-Central Institute of
Fisheries Education, Kolkata Centre, it was evident that the appellant has
successfully completed the requisite One Year Post Graduate Diploma only
on 20-09-2021 and as such was not eligible to be considered by the review
DPC for the vacancy for the post of Fishery Officer which arose in the year
2019-20.
[13]
The learned Single Judge vide impugned judgment and order
dated 21-03-2024 held as follows:—
“[21]
Admittedly, the petitioner completed the Diploma in
Fishery for the course May 2019 to April 2020 on 20.9.2021, as
the course was extended due to pandemic. Later on, the Institute
clarified that she completed the course of May 2019 to April 2020.
In any case, the petitioner completed the Diploma in April 2020.
However, as per OM dated 15.5.2014 and for the vacancies
arising during the period from 2019 to 2020, the petitioner should
possess the eligibility criteria between the period from 1st April
2019 to 31st March 2020. Since the petitioner completed the
Diploma in April 2020 as per Annexure A-8, she is not eligible for
the vacancy arose in the year 2019-2020. This Court is of the
considered view that the petitioner was rightly not sent for
considering in the Review DPC. However, it is clarified that the
petitioner will be eligible for subsequent vacancies in the post
Fishery Officer.”
[14]
Mr. A. Romenkumar, learned senior counsel appearing on behalf
of the appellant, invites our attention to the subject RR to urge that the
requirement for the post of Fishery Officer in the Fishery Department,
WA No. 15 of 2024
Manipur is the possessing of Diploma with three years regular service in the
grade of Fishery Inspector. Learned senior counsel would then urge that
the OM dated 15-05-2014 and in particular, clause 4.3 thereof, leaves no
manner of doubt that the crucial date for determining the eligibility of Officers
for promotion would be as per the applicable RRs of the Service/Post
proposed and if the said subject RRs is silent; the crucial date for this
purpose would be 1st October. In other words, the case of the appellant is
that having successfully obtained One Year Post Graduate Diploma for the
period May 2019 to April 2020 in “Inland Fisheries and Aquaculture
Management”, she was eligible to be considered by the review DPC for the
next higher post of Fishery Officer.
[15]
On the contrary, Mr. M. Devananda, learned Addl. Advocate
General for the State of Manipur would reiterate the arguments canvassed
before the learned Single Judge to the effect that since the appellant has
completed the course only on 20-09-2021 as borne out from her marksheet
as well as the certificate dated 28-08-2023 issued by the ICAR-Central
Institute of Fisheries Education, Kolkata Centre, she is not eligible for the
vacancy for the post of Fishery Officer that arose in the year 2019-2020.
[16]
Although our attention has been invited to the findings arrived at
by the learned Single Judge to buttress the argument that the solitary ground
on which the appellant was non-suited was that she was required to possess
the eligibility criteria between the period 1st April 2019 to 31st March 2020
and since she completed the Diploma only in April 2020, she was not eligible
for the vacancy that arose in the year 2019-2020; and consequently, the
State without having assailed the impugned order cannot be heard to urge
WA No. 15 of 2024
the ground elucidated hereinabove; we are of the view that the case of the
appellant must stand on its own legs.
[17]
Owing to the circumstance that the One Year Post Graduate
Diploma Course for the period May 2019 to April 2020 in “Inland Fisheries
and Aquaculture Management” from ICAR-Central Institute of Fisheries
Education, Kolkata Centre was unfortunately delayed on account of the
prevalent COVID-19 pandemic, the qualification obtained by the appellant
axiomatically was effective only from 20-09-2021, the day on which the
marksheet was admittedly issued and could not relate back to March 2020
or even October 2020 as urged on behalf of the appellant by placing reliance
on clause 4.3 of the OM.
[18]
In view of the foregoing, we find ourselves in agreement with the
conclusion arrived at by the learned Single Judge, that the appellant was not
eligible for the vacancy that arose for the post of Fishery Officer in the year
2019-2020; however, we come to the same conclusion in view of the reason
expressed hereinabove by addition in the impugned judgement and order
dated 21-03-2024, the appeal is accordingly dismissed.
JUDGE
CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Victoria
signed
NINGOM Digitally
by NINGOMBAM
VICTORIA
BAM
Date: 2024.04.22
VICTORIA 14:40:26 +05'30'
WA No. 15 of 2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review