Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on : 22nd April 2026
Pronounced on : 18th May 2026
Uploaded on : 19th May 2026
%
+
MAC.APP. 608/2016
HDFC GENERAL INSURANCE CO LTD
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Rajeev M Roy, Mr. P
Srinivasan, Advocates.
versus
FAKIR CHAND & ORS
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. M.K Perwez, Advocate with
Respondent-in-person.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J.
1.
This appeal has been preferred against the judgment dated 20th May
2016 passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (‘MACT’), East
District, Karkardooma Courts, in MACT No. 413/2016, whereby the
Tribunal allowed the claim of injured/claimant and awarded compensation
of Rs.41,66,835/- along with interest @9% per annum from date of filing
of petition.
The Incident
2.
The accident occurred on 19th January 2014 at about 10:00 PM,
when claimant and his colleague were on picket duty and were checking
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
19:05:49
MAC.APP. 608/2016
1/24
vehicles and barricades put on road. During checking, claimant tried to
stop a Hyundai I-10 car bearing registration no. DL-4C-ND-3886 coming
from Geeta Colony Side at high speed. The driver without stopping dashed
the car into barricades and hit the claimant, who was standing near the
barricades. As a result of accident claimant sustained crush injuries on his
right leg along with multiple fractures. Claimant/injured was taken to
LNJP hospital and his right leg below knee was amputated, the injured was
later shifted to Max Hospital where he remained admitted from 21 st
January 2014 to 31st January 2014. FIR No. 42/14 was registered at PS
Geeta Colony under Sections 279/338 of the India Penal Code, 1860,
against driver of offending vehicle and subsequently chargesheet was filed
against the driver.
3.
As per the Disability Certificate annexed as Ex. PW1/3, physical
disability was assessed at 70% in relation to right lower limb. At the time
of accident, injured was 54 years of age and employed as Head Constable
with Delhi Police, due to retire on 31st December 2018.
Impugned Award
4.
As regards Issue no. 1, the Tribunal held that the lodging of the FIR
and the filing of the chargesheet were sufficient to establish negligence on
the part of the driver of the offending vehicle.
5.
As regards Issue no. 2 concerning the quantum of compensation, the
Tribunal assessed the functional disability at 70%, corresponding to the
physical disability assessed at 70% in relation to the right lower limb. The
salary of the claimant was assessed at Rs. 36,338/- after deduction of
income tax and travel allowance. However, no future prospects were
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
19:05:49
MAC.APP. 608/2016
2/24
granted to the claimant. The multiplier of ‘11’ was applied to compute an
amount of Rs. 33,37,631/- under the head of loss of future income.
Compensation of Rs. 3,00,000/- was awarded towards the non-pecuniary
heads of pain and suffering and loss of amenities of life. Further,
compensation of Rs. 1,10,000/- was awarded towards prosthesis, and Rs.
50,000/- was awarded towards future medical expenses for replacement
and maintenance of the prosthesis.
Submission of Counsel for Appellant
6.
Counsel for appellant submits that the Tribunal has erred in
assessing the functional disability of the injured at 70%. It is contended
that though the permanent physical disability in relation to the right lower
limb was assessed at 70% as per the Disability Certificate; the functional
disability could not have been taken as equivalent to physical disability.
According to counsel for appellant, having regard to the nature of
avocation and overall facts and circumstances of the case, the functional
disability ought to have been assessed at not more than 35%.
7.
Counsel for appellant further submits that the Tribunal has wrongly
awarded compensation towards loss of future income. It is contended that
the injured neither lost his employment nor suffered any diminution in
income on account of the accident. It is further submitted that the injured
continued in service till attaining the age of superannuation on 31 st
December 2018 and, therefore, no loss of future income can be stated to
have arisen due to the injuries sustained in the accident.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
19:05:49
MAC.APP. 608/2016
3/24
Analysis
8.
Considering that there is no issue is raised with respect to the finding
by the MACT on issue no.1 relating to causation, the only issues in dispute,
relate to the quantum of compensation.
Functional Disability
9.
Reliance in this regard can be placed on the judgment of Supreme
Court in Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar (2011) 1 SCC 343, wherein it was
held that the Tribunal must assess not merely the extent of permanent
disability but its actual impact on the claimant’s earning capacity, which
may differ from the medical percentage of disability. This requires
evaluating the claimant’s pre-accident vocation, the functions affected,
and whether livelihood can still be earned despite the disability. The Court
emphasised that disability and loss of earning capacity are distinct
concepts, except in cases where evidence shows they coincide. Relevant
paragraphs are extracted as under:
“11. What requires to be assessed by the
Tribunal is the effect of the permanent disability
on the earning capacity of the injured; and after
assessing the loss of earning capacity in terms of
a percentage of the income, it has to be quantified
in terms of money, to arrive at the future loss of
earnings (by applying the standard multiplier
method used to determine loss of dependency).
We may however note that in some cases, on
appreciation of evidence and assessment, the
Tribunal may find that the percentage of loss of
earning capacity as a result of the permanent
disability, is approximately the same as the
percentage of permanent disability in which
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
19:05:49
MAC.APP. 608/2016
4/24
case, of course, the Tribunal will adopt the said
percentage for determination of compensation.
(See for example, the decisions of this Court
in Arvind Kumar Mishra v. New India Assurance
Co. Ltd. [(2010) 10 SCC 254 : (2010) 3 SCC
(Cri) 1258 : (2010) 10 Scale 298] and Yadava
Kumar v. National Insurance Co. Ltd. [(2010)
10 SCC 341 : (2010) 3 SCC (Cri) 1285 : (2010)
8 Scale 567] )
12. Therefore, the Tribunal has to first decide
whether there is any permanent disability and, if
so, the extent of such permanent disability. This
means that the Tribunal should consider and
decide with reference to the evidence:
(i) whether the disablement is permanent or
temporary;
(ii) if the disablement is permanent, whether it is
permanent total disablement or permanent
partial disablement;
(iii) if the disablement percentage is expressed
with reference to any specific limb, then the effect
of such disablement of the limb on the functioning
of the entire body, that is, the permanent
disability suffered by the person.
If the Tribunal concludes that there is no
permanent disability then there is no question of
proceeding further and determining the loss of
future earning capacity. But if the Tribunal
concludes that there is permanent disability then
it will proceed to ascertain its extent. After the
Tribunal ascertains the actual extent of
permanent disability of the claimant based on the
medical evidence, it has to determine whether
such permanent disability has affected or will
affect his earning capacity.
13. Ascertainment of the effect of the permanent
disability on the actual earning capacity involves
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
19:05:49
MAC.APP. 608/2016
5/24
three steps. The Tribunal has to first ascertain
what activities the claimant could carry on in
spite of the permanent disability and what he
could not do as a result of the permanent
disability (this is also relevant for awarding
compensation under the head of loss of amenities
of life). The second step is to ascertain his
avocation, profession and nature of work before
the accident, as also his age. The third step is to
find out whether (i) the claimant is totally
disabled from earning any kind of livelihood, or
(ii) whether in spite of the permanent disability,
the claimant could still effectively carry on the
activities and functions, which he was earlier
carrying on, or (iii) whether he was prevented or
restricted from discharging his previous
activities and functions, but could carry on some
other or lesser scale of activities and functions so
that he continues to earn or can continue to earn
his livelihood.”
(emphasis added)
10.
In the present case, applying the principles laid down in Raj Kumar
v. Ajay Kumar (supra), this Court is required to assess the effect of the
permanent disability on claimant’s earning capacity and not merely adopt
the medical percentage of disability. Claimant, at the time of accident, was
aged about 54 years and was serving as a Head Constable with Delhi
Police. The Disability Certificate records 70% permanent physical
disability in relation to the right lower limb on account of below-knee
amputation. The nature of duties discharged by a police officer,
particularly one serving in the field, cannot be equated with a sedentary
occupation. The duties attached to the post necessarily require mobility
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
19:05:49
MAC.APP. 608/2016
6/24
and prolonged standing to carry out duties such as checking of vehicles,
and maintenance of public order. In these circumstances, the amputation
suffered by the claimant has undoubtedly resulted in serious restriction of
his functional ability insofar as discharge of his official duties. No doubt
he may be relegated to a desk job but he would have been seriously
disadvantaged over his colleagues leading to loss of promotional
opportunities and normal mobility
11.
In view of the vocation of injured, the Tribunal is not amiss in
assessing functional disability at 70% and the same does not warrant any
interference by this Court.
Multiplier
12.
On the issue of multiplier which ought to be granted to the injured
who continued as a Head Constable, the law is well settled that, for an
injured person in public sector job, who would retire on superannuation,
post-retirement loss of income must be computed by applying a multiplier
of ‘9’, considering retirement at 60 years of age. In this regard reliance
may be made decisions of this Court in Desh Raj Singh Gautam v. Sunil
Kumar & Ors. 2016:DHC:4159, Rajbir Singh v. National Insurance
Company Ltd. & Ors. 2024:DHC:9034.
13.
This Court in Desh Raj Singh Gautam v. Sunil Kumar (supra)
noted as under:
“4. It is noted that the tribunal awarded lumpsum
amount of ₹2 Lakh on account of loss of future
income due to disability. This was not a correct
approach. Admittedly, the claimant was a
regular employee of MTNL. It is conceded by the
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
19:05:49
MAC.APP. 608/2016
7/24
counsel representing him that he would continue
in service till he attains the age of 60 years and,
thus, there would be no loss of income till that
stage. However, the loss of income post
retirement will have to be appropriately
computed. Since the retirement would occur at
the age of 60 years, it had to be calculated with
the multiplier of 9. Computed thus, the loss of
future earnings on account of disability to the
extent of 25% would come to (₹19,000 x 25/100
x 12 x 9) ₹5,13,000/-. Since the tribunal had
awarded only lupmsum of ₹2 Lakh, the award
deserves to be enhanced by ₹3,13,000/-. Ordered
accordingly. Needless to say, it shall carry
interest as levied by the tribunal.”
(emphasis added)
14.
In 2024, the coordinate Bench of this Court in Rajbir Singh v.
National Insurance Company Ltd & Ors.(supra), analysed this well and
adverted to previous decisions and stated as under:
“12. However, the main question is whether he is
entitled to Loss of future earning Capacity on
account of Permanent Disability of 40% of right
lower limb suffered by him. There is no denying
that any Permanent Disability suffered by an
injured, results in his reduced earning capacity
or impacts his career progression, and he needs
to be compensated. The pertinent aspect is
whether this Court can take note of his limitation
in getting a job post his retirement, as has been
claimed by the Appellant. He has placed reliance
on TATA AIG General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs.
Dipanjan Ghosh & Ors. MAC.APP.44/2014
decided by this Court on 02.03.2016; United
India Insurance Company Limited vs. Zile Singh
& Ors. MAC.APPEAL No.861/2010 decided by
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
19:05:49
MAC.APP. 608/2016
8/24
this Court on 27.09.2017; Desh Raj Singh
Gautam vs. Sunil Kumar and Ors.
MAC.APP.632/2007 decided by this Court on
20.05.2016; Kale Ram vs. Ajay & Ors.
MAC.APP.615/2013 decided by this Court on
18.11.2022 and Anita A. Pathak vs. Raj Bahadur
& Ors. MAC. APP.466/2010 along with
MAC.APP.451/2010,
MAC.APP.459/2010,
MAC.APP.454/2010,
MAC.APP.455/2010,
MAC.APP.456/2010 and MAC.APP.464/2010
decided on 15.02.2012, wherein this Court has
considered that any Permanent Disability
suffered by the injured may not impact his
financial capacity immediately, but would
definitely have an impact post his retirement and
he may not be able to take up a job after postretirement.
13. In the judgments relied upon by the
Appellant, while being cognizant that the injured
was in the employment and had not suffered any
salary loss, but it was considered that he may
suffer some impediment in getting a job in future
post his retirement which is generally at the age
of 60 years, 30% enhancement of the current
salary was then taken to calculate the
compensation.
14. In the present case, though the injured has
not adduced any evidence about the age till
which he would continue in service in DAV
School or that his disability would prevent him
from taking up any job in future, but on the basis
of the legal precedents, it is held that on his
retirement, which is normally at the age of 60
years, he may not be able to take up a job post
retirement.
15. The income of the Appellant has been shown
as Rs.17,899/- which is rounded off to
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
19:05:49
MAC.APP. 608/2016
9/24
Rs.18,000/- and 30% is added to his salary
towards his future increase in his salary.
Multiplier of 9 is taken in accordance with the
retirement age of 60 Years.”
(emphasis added)
15.
This Court has previously taken a similar view in its judgment in
Govind Singh Mauni v. Tej Bhan & Ors. 2026:DHC:1020. In this view
of the matter, this Court is not inclined to accept the argument of counsel
for appellant that no loss of future income should be awarded.
Accordingly, in light of the decision of this Court in Govind Singh Mauni
(supra) the multiplier of ‘9’ would be applicable as opposed to ‘11’ applied
by the Tribunal.
Future Prospect
16.
In fact, this Court in its assessment in Govind Singh Mauni (supra),
considered the issue of loss of potentiality to earn post-retirement for
which compensation must be taken into account. The relevant paragraphs
are extracted as under:
“18. The essential principle follows from the
House of Lords’ decision in Ball v. William
Hunts and Sons (supra) which is highlighted in
the following extract in National Insurance Co.
Ltd. v. Rajbir Singh & Ors (supra):
“There is also an opinion of the House of
lords that may be relevant to understand
this concept. Ball v. William Hunts and
Sons Limited, (1912) AC 496, was the
case of a workman, who was blinded in
one eye. The defect was not visible and
he was to have appearance as two eyed
man. He had come to such a disability
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
19:05:49
MAC.APP. 608/2016
10/24
status when he had sustained an
employment injury in which the defective
eye had to be removed with the
consequences that he could not get
employment though physically he was as
well as before. The House of Lords held
that the incapacity of work included
inability to work, or in other words, there
is incapacity for work when a man has
physical defect which makes his working
unsaleable in any market reasonably
accessible to him. Applying the same
logic, a person who has suffered an
injury may not come by immediate loss if
he is retained in the same employment
and does not lose his job, but in his own
saleability elsewhere as a fresh recruit to
a new employer, he may come by a
serious handicap. That shall come by a
serious handicap. That shall be a
justification enough to provide for
compensation in such types of cases.”
(emphasis added)
…
28. In Ball v. William Hunt & Sons Ltd. (supra),
the focus was placed on ‘marketability of labour’
rather than mere wage continuity. This reasoning
was expressly approved by the United States
Supreme Court in New York Central Railroad
Co. v. Bianc; American Knife Co. v. Sweeting,
1919 SCC OnLine US SC 210, while upholding
the validity of compensation for serious
disfigurement under the New York Workmen’s
Compensation Law. The U.S. Supreme Court
observed that serious physical disfigurement may
reasonably and adversely affect a person’s
ability to obtain or retain employment, and relied
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
19:05:49
MAC.APP. 608/2016
11/24
upon the reasoning in Ball v. William Hunt &
Sons Ltd., (supra), to underscore that diminished
employability constitutes a legitimate basis for
compensation, independent of immediate loss of
earning power.
29. Although Ball v. William Hunt & Sons Ltd.
(supra), and the American Knife Co. (supra)
decision arose in the context of workmen’s
compensation statutes, the underlying principle
is fully consonant with Indian Supreme Court
jurisprudence under the Motor Vehicles Act. The
Act mandates the award of “just compensation”
under Section 168, which, as emphasised in
National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi,
(2017) 16 SCC 680 and Sarla Verma v. DTC,
(2009) 6 SCC 121, must be fair, realistic and
proximate to the actual loss suffered. Once
functional disability affecting earning capacity is
established, compensation must be assessed
using the multiplier method, irrespective of the
fact that the claimant may have continued in
service or received increments post-accident.
30. The denial of compensation for loss of future
earning capacity solely on the ground that the
claimant continues in employment or has not
suffered immediate wage loss would be
inconsistent with settled Supreme Court
jurisprudence. The law recognises that economic
vulnerability, reduced employability, and
diminished labour-market acceptability and
inability to secure employment are real and
compensable consequences of permanent
disability. Comparative jurisprudence, including
Ball v. William Hunt & Sons Ltd. (supra) as
approved by the U.S. Supreme Court, reinforces
this understanding and supports a principled,
forward-looking assessment of loss of earning
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
19:05:49
MAC.APP. 608/2016
12/24
capacity in motor accident claims.
31. The essence of compensation is to give
reparation to an injured who has suffered great
impairment in his functionality due to the
negligence of the offending vehicle and the
respondents. It would be, therefore, imperative
that just and reasonable compensation is
provided.
32. The Constitutional Bench of the Supreme
Court in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay
Sethi, (2017) 16 SCC 680 emphasised that “just
compensation” under Section 168 of MV Act
must rest on fairness, reasonableness and equity,
avoiding both windfall gains and inadequate
awards. The assessment must be grounded in
proven age and income, followed by application
of the appropriate multiplier as standardised in
Sarla Verma v. DTC, (2009) 6 SCC 121 and
affirmed in Reshma Kumari v. Madan Mohan,
(2013) 9 SCC 65. The Court stressed pragmatic
and uniform computation, including future
prospects, to ensure proximity to real loss…
…
34. Applying the core mantra of aligning
‘proximity to reality’ in assessment of just
compensation, in this Court’s opinion, the
compensation in the present case needs to be
reworked. If, therefore, the income is taken as
Rs.29,519/-, considering that it is admitted by
counsels for the parties that the same ought to
have been the net income, applying a 30%
increase for future prospects would be the
appropriate approach. This would suitably
accommodate future prospects post retirement
and career progression through better
employment.”
(emphasis added)
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
19:05:49
MAC.APP. 608/2016
13/24
17.
In light of the aforesaid judgment, future prospects at 15% should
be granted since the injured was 54 years of age at the time of accident for
calculation of loss of future income.
Prosthetic Limb
18.
The Tribunal has awarded Rs. 1,10,000/- for one prosthetic limb and
Rs. 50,000/- has been awarded towards future medical expenses for repairs
and change in prosthesis. Even though no specific plea with regard to the
enhancement of compensation on account of a prosthetic limb has been
raised by respondent/claimant, this Court is duty-bound to award just
compensation, irrespective of whether the same has been specifically
pleaded, in terms of the principle laid down by the Supreme Court in
Ningamma v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd. (2009) 13 SCC 710. Upon
perusal of the impugned award, it is noted that the MACT has awarded
compensation only towards one prosthetic limb, which does not align with
the law laid down by the Supreme Court in Mohd. Sabeer v. U.P. SRTC,
(2023) 20 SCC 774.
19.
In Mohd. Sabeer v. U.P. SRTC (supra) it was provided that
prosthetic needs to be changed five to six years and, therefore, considering
that injured is 54 years of age at the date of the accident and taking the
potential life expectancy up to 70 years, would require prosthetic for
approximately another 16 years. Using that basis of calculation, at least
three replacements would be required by him, if the claimant choses to
take a prosthetic. The cost of the prosthetic has been noted by in the
impugned award as Rs. 1,10,000/-, with annual maintenance cost at
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
19:05:49
MAC.APP. 608/2016
14/24
Rs.15,000/- to Rs.20,000/- basis the testimony of PW-4/Anshul Sengar,
Senior Associate M/s Ottobock Healthcare India Pvt. Ltd.
20.
On this basis, the amount for three possible replacements of the
prosthetic along with annual maintenance cost will have to be granted to
the injured/claimant.
Pain and Suffering
21.
Further, no specific pleadings have been advanced with regard to
enhancement of compensation under the heads of pain and suffering and
loss of amenities of life. However, upon perusal of the impugned award, it
is noted that the lumpsum compensation of Rs. 3,00,000/- awarded under
the aforesaid heads does not align with the principles governing grant of
just compensation. The Supreme Court, in Ningamma v. United India
Insurance Co. Ltd (supra) has held that the Court is duty-bound to award
just compensation irrespective of the specific pleadings advanced by the
parties in that regard.
22.
Therefore, as regards compensation for non-pecuniary damages,
reliance may be placed on the judgment of the Supreme Court in K.S.
Muralidhar v. R. Subbulakshmi and Anr. 2024 SCC Online SC 3385,
wherein it was observed that ‘pain and suffering’ cannot be captured by
any fixed definition, drawing on legal, medical, and philosophical sources
to emphasize its deeply subjective and life-altering nature. It recognised
that translating such profound human loss into money is an inherently
artificial exercise, yet courts must ensure fairness, consistency, and
sensitivity to the victim’s lifelong deprivation. Relevant paragraphs are
extracted as under:
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
19:05:49
MAC.APP. 608/2016
15/24
“13. While acknowledging that ‘pain and suffering’,
as a concept escapes definition, we may only refer to
certain authorities, scholarly as also judicial wherein
attempts have been made to set down the contours
thereof.
13.1 The entry recording the term ‘pain and suffering’
in P. Ramanatha Iyer's Advanced Law Lexicon reads
as under:—
“Pain and suffering. The term ‘Pain and
suffering’ mean physical discomfort and distress
and include mental and emotional trauma for
which damages can be recovered in an accident
claim.
This expression has become almost a term of art,
used without making fine distinction between pain
and suffering. Pain and suffering which a person
undergoes cannot be measured in terms of money
by any mathematical calculation. Hence the
Court awards a sum which is in the nature of a
conventional award [Mediana, The, [1900] A.C.
113, 116]”
…
13.5 In determining non-pecuniary damages, the
artificial nature of computing compensation has been
highlighted in Heil v. Rankin, as referred to
in Attorney General of St. Helenav. AB as under:—
“23. This principle of ‘full compensation’ applies
to pecuniary and non-pecuniary damage alike.
But, as Dickson J indicated in the passage cited
from his judgment in Andrews v. Grand & Toy
Alberta Ltd., 83 DLR (3d) 452, 475-476, this
statement immediately raises a problem in a
situation where what is in issue is what the
appropriate level of ‘full compensation’ for nonpecuniary injury is when the compensation has to
be expressed in pecuniary terms. There is no
simple formula for converting the pain and
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
19:05:49
MAC.APP. 608/2016
16/24
suffering, the loss of function, the loss of amenity
and disability which an injured person has
sustained, into monetary terms. Any process of
conversion must be essentially artificial. Lord
Pearce expressed it well in H West & Son
Ltd. v. Shephard, [1964] A.C. 326 when he said:
‘The court has to perform the difficult and
artificial task of converting into monetary
damages the physical injury and deprivation
and pain and to give judgment for what it
considers to be a reasonable sum. It does not
look beyond the judgment to the spending of
the damages.’
24. The last part of this statement is undoubtedly
right. The injured person may not even be in a
position to enjoy the damages he receives because of
the injury which he has sustained. Lord Clyde
recognised this in Wells v. Wells, [1999] A.C. 345,
394H when he said:‘One clear principle is that what
the successful plaintiff will in the event actually do
with the award is irrelevant.”
…
14. In respect of ‘pain and suffering’ in cases where
disability suffered is at 100%, we may notice a few
decisions of this Court:—
14.1 In R.D Hattangadi v. Pest Control (India) (P)
Ltd. It was observed:
“17. The claim under Sl. No. 16 for ‘pain and
suffering’ and for loss of amenities of life under
Sl. No. 17, are claims for non-pecuniary loss. The
appellant has claimed lump sum amount of Rs.
3,00,000 each under the two heads. The High
Court has allowed Rs. 1,00,000 against the claims
of Rs. 6,00,000. When compensation is to be
awarded for ‘pain and suffering’ and loss of
amenity of life, the special circumstances of the
claimant have to be taken into account including
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
19:05:49
MAC.APP. 608/2016
17/24
23.
his age, the unusual deprivation he has suffered,
the effect thereof on his future life. The amount of
compensation for non-pecuniary loss is not easy
to determine but the award must reflect that
different circumstances have been taken into
consideration. According to us, as the appellant
was an advocate having good practice in different
courts and as because of the accident he has been
crippled and can move only on wheelchair, the
High Court should have allowed an amount of Rs.
1,50,000 in respect of claim for ‘pain and
suffering’ and Rs. 1,50,000 in respect of loss of
amenities of life. We direct payment of Rs.
3,00,000 (Rupees three lakhs only) against the
claim of Rs. 6,00,000 under the heads “‘pain and
suffering’” and “Loss of amenities of life”.
14.2 This Judgment was recently referred to by this
Court in Sidram v. United India Insurance Company
Ltd reference was also made to Karnataka
SRTC v. Mahadeva Shetty (irrespective of the
percentage of disability incurred, the observations
are instructive), wherein it was observed:
“18. A person not only suffers injuries on account
of accident but also suffers in mind and body on
account of the accident through out his life and a
feeling is developed that his no more a normal
man and cannot enjoy the amenities of life as
another normal person can. While fixing
compensation for pain and suffering as also for
loss of amenities, features like his age, marital
status and unusual deprivation he has undertaken
in his life have to be reckoned…”
(emphasis added)
In light of the observations of the Supreme Court noted above, this
Court is of the opinion that, considering this is a case of amputation below
knee, the grant of lump sum Rs. 3,00,000/- towards pain and suffering and
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
19:05:49
MAC.APP. 608/2016
18/24
loss of amenities of life is inadequate. The Supreme Court has consistently
adopted a liberal and realistic approach in such cases, as is evident from
the judgment in Mohd. Sabeer v. U.P. SRTC (supra), wherein, in a similar
situation involving amputation below the knee, the Supreme Court
awarded Rs. 2,00,000/- each towards pain and suffering, disfigurement and
loss of amenities of life. The Supreme Court observed as under:
“Non-pecuniary compensation
24… this Court is of the opinion that the
compensation provided by the High Court for nonpecuniary heads is inadequate.
25. In R.D. Hattangadi v. Pest Control (India) (P)
Ltd. [R.D. Hattangadi v. Pest Control (India) (P)
Ltd., (1995) 1 SCC 551 : 1995 SCC (Cri) 250] dealing
with the different heads of compensation in injury
cases this Court held that : (SCC p. 556, para 9)
“9. Broadly speaking while fixing the amount of
compensation payable to a victim of an accident,
the damages have to be assessed separately as
pecuniary damages and special damages.
Pecuniary damages are those which the victim
has actually incurred and which are capable of
being calculated in terms of money; whereas nonpecuniary damages are those which are
incapable of being assessed by arithmetical
calculations. In order to appreciate two concepts
pecuniary damages may include expenses
incurred by the claimant : (i) medical attendance;
(ii) loss of earning of profit up to the date of trial;
(iii) other material loss. So far as non-pecuniary
damages are concerned, they may include : (i)
damages for mental and physical shock, pain and
suffering, already suffered or likely to be suffered
in the future; (ii) damages to compensate for the
loss of amenities of life which may include a
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
19:05:49
MAC.APP. 608/2016
19/24
variety of matters i.e. on account of injury the
claimant may not be able to walk, run or sit; (iii)
damages for the loss of expectation of life i.e. on
account of injury the normal longevity of the
person
concerned
is
shortened;
(iv)
inconvenience,
hardship,
discomfort,
disappointment, frustration and mental stress in
life.”
26. In light of the above decision of this Court and the
facts and circumstances of the case at hand, the
compensation to be awarded is as follows:
I. Compensation for pain and suffering — Rs
2,00,000
II. Compensation for loss of amenities of life —
Rs 2,00,000
III.
Compensation
for
disability
and
disfigurement — Rs 2,00,000
Conclusion
…
28. It is almost universally seen that persons from
marginalised backgrounds often face an additional
layer of discrimination due to bodily disabilities. This
is because persons from marginalised sections of the
society already face severe discrimination due to a
lack of social capital, and a new disability more often
than not compounds to such discrimination. In such
circumstances, to preserve the essence of justice, it
becomes the duty of the Court to at the very least
restore the claimant as best as possible to the position
he was in before the occurrence of the disability, and
to do so must award compensation in a liberal
manner.
29. While no material compensation can completely
negate the trauma and suffering that the injured and
his family faces, the law only knows the language of
monetary compensation in such cases. It then
becomes the duty of the court to translate the
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
19:05:49
MAC.APP. 608/2016
20/24
provisions of monetary compensation into a
fabrication that helps the injured and his family in
coping with their loss.”
(emphasis supplied)
24.
Considering the observations of the Supreme Court and the fact that
the present case involves amputation, the compensation awarded towards
pain and suffering, and loss of amenities of life is inadequate; therefore,
Rs. 2,00,000/- each is awarded under heads of pain and suffering and loss
of amenities of life; the same would be in line with the principle of just
compensation.
25.
The revised computation is as under:
S.no Heads of Compensation
Awarded by
Awarded by the
tribunal
Court
Pecuniary Loss
1.
Medicine Bills (A)
Rs. 28,500/-
Rs. 28,500/-
2.
Expenditure on special diet (B)
Rs. 10,000/-
Rs. 10,000/-
3.
Expenditure of conveyance (C) Rs. 10,000/-
Rs. 10,000/-
4.
Attendant Charges (D)
Rs. 10,000/-
Rs. 10,000/-
5.
Income of injured per month Rs. 36,338/-
Rs. 36,338/-
(E)
6.
Future prospects @ 15% (F)
Nil
Rs. 5,451/-
7.
Loss of income (E) x 8=(G)
Rs. 2,90,704/-
Rs. 2,90,704/-
8.
Functional disability (H)
70%
70%
9.
Multiplier (I)
10.
Loss of future income
Rs. 33,57,631/-
Rs. 31,59,248/-
Rs. 50,000/-
Part
[(E+F) x 12 x H x I]= J
11.
Future Medical Expenses
of
annual
maintenance
for
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
19:05:49
MAC.APP. 608/2016
21/24
prosthetic
12.
Cost of Prosthetic Limb
Rs. 1,10,000/-
Given Separately
Rs. 2,00,000/-
Non-pecuniary loss
13.
Pain and suffering (K)
Rs. 3,00,000/-
14.
Loss of Amenities of Life (M)
Part of pain and Rs. 2,00,000/suffering
15.
Total
Rs. 41,66,835/-
Rs. 39,08,452/-
16.
Interest
9%
9%
Rs. 1,10,000/-
Rs. 1,10,000/- x
Cost of Artificial Limb
17.
Cost of Prosthetic Limb (A)
3= 3,30,000/18.
Annual Maintenance (B)
Nil
Rs.15,000/- x 15=
Rs. 2,25,000/-
19.
Total Cost Towards Artificial Rs. 1,10,000/-
Rs. 5,55,000/-
Limb
Directions
26.
Accordingly, the compensation granted towards artificial limb and
annual maintenance is enhanced by Rs.4,45,000/-. The aforesaid amount
for the prosthetic limb and annual maintenance will be deposited by the
Insurance Company within a period of four weeks before the Registrar
General of this Court, which will be kept in an interest-bearing fixed
deposit, the same will be disbursed to the claimant only on production of
original invoice/purchase document issued by authorized seller of
prosthetic limb. Further, cost towards annual maintenance shall also be
disbursed on production of invoice. If any amounts remain unutilized, the
Insurance Company will be entitled to withdraw the same along with
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
19:05:49
MAC.APP. 608/2016
22/24
accrued interest.
27.
It is pertinent to note that the accident occurred in the year 2014, at
which time the injured was 54 years of age. At present, the injured would
have attained the age of approximately 66 years. It is clarified that in the
event the injured/claimant has incurred any expenditure towards
procurement, replacement, or maintenance of the prosthetic limb during
the pendency of the proceedings over the last 12 years, the same shall be
reimbursed upon production of the original invoice/purchase document
issued by an authorized seller or dealer. In case the injured/ claimant is
unable to produce the aforementioned documents, the amount awarded
towards prosthetic limb, along with accrued interest, if any, remains
unutilized, the Insurance Company shall be at liberty to withdraw the
same.
28.
The compensation for pecuniary and non-pecuniary loss is reduced
by Rs. 2,58,383/-.
29.
This Court vide order dated 22nd August 2016 directed appellant to
deposit 50% of the award amount along with 9% interest per annum from
the date of filing of the petition with UCO Bank, Delhi High Court Branch,
subject to deposit of the amount there has been stay on the operation of the
impugned award. Further, it was directed that 10% of the said amount
deposited shall be released to claimant in his savings bank account and the
balance 90% shall be kept in 9 fixed deposits of 10% each for 1 year, 2
years, 3 years, 4 years, 5 years, 6 years, 7 years, 8 years and 9 years.
Further, vide order dated 11th February 2022, an additional amount of Rs.
5,00,000/- was released to the claimant from the FDRs.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
19:05:49
MAC.APP. 608/2016
23/24
30.
The Insurance Company is directed to deposit the balance amount
as per revised compensation along with accrued interest before the
Registrar General of this Court within a period of four weeks. The amount
deposited shall be released to the claimant in terms of the directions passed
by the Tribunal in the impugned award.
31.
The appeal is disposed of in above terms. Pending application, if
any, are rendered infructuous.
32.
A copy of the judgment be sent to the concerned bank for
compliance.
33.
Statutory deposit, if any, be refunded to appellant/Insurance
Company, only if the order of deposit has been complied with.
34.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
(ANISH DAYAL)
JUDGE
May 18, 2026/ak/zb
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
19:05:49
MAC.APP. 608/2016
24/24
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review