Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~4 to 7
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of decision: 17th July 2026
+
MAC.APP. 765/2013
HDFC ERGO GENERAL INSURANCE CO LTD
.....Appellant
versus
SMT UMRAWATI & ORS
+
.....Respondents
MAC.APP. 643/2015 & CM APPL. 14902/2015
HDFC ERGO GENERAL INSURANCE CO LTD
.....Appellant
versus
SONA DEVI & ORS
+
.....Respondents
MAC.APP. 645/2015 & CM APPL. 14913/2015 & CM APPL.
7823-7825/2026
HDFC ERGO GENERAL INSURANCE CO LTD .....Appellant
versus
POLICE RAM & ORS
.....Respondents
+
MAC.APP. 646/2015&CM APPL. 14916/2015
HDFC ERGO GENERAL INSURANCE CO LTD
.....Appellant
versus
BHAGMANI DEVI & ORS
.....Respondents
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR MAC.APP. 765/2013 & connected appeals
16:13:45
Appearance
:Ms. Suman Bagga & Ms. Mouli Sharma,
Advocates for Insurance Co.
Mr. S.N. Parashar & Mr. Ritik Singh, Advs. for
claimants.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J (ORAL)
1.
This common judgment shall dispose of the above-captioned four
appeals filed by the insurance company assailing the award dated 12th
May
whereby
the
Motor
Accident
Claims
Tribunal
(‘MACT/Tribunal’) denied the insurance company the right to recover
the awarded amount from the driver and owner of the offending vehicle.
2.
The accident in question occurred on 19th October 2009 when
Siyaram (now deceased), along with his colleagues Tarakeshwar Ram
(since deceased), Dharam Nath Ram (since deceased), and Polish/Police
Ram (injured-claimant) were going to Ghaziabad from the factory of
M/s. Sandeep Metal Udyog, located in Faridabad in an Eicher Canter,
after loading aluminium plates. All these four persons were working in
the factory as labourers with M/s. Sandeep Metal Udyog. The goods
belonged to their employer and the owner of the offending vehicle, M/s.
Sandeep Metal Udyog. The Canter was being driven by the driver
Deepak Kumar.
3.
It is alleged that the three deceased and the injured, in respect of
whom claims have been filed, were travelling in the rear body of the
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR MAC.APP. 765/2013 & connected appeals
16:13:45
truck along with the loaded aluminium plates. They had repeatedly
cautioned the driver not to drive the vehicle carelessly, rashly and
negligently. However, the driver apparently paid no heed to their
warnings. When he suddenly applied the brakes, the aluminium plates
fell on the four people travelling in the rear body of the truck. As a
result, Siyaram and Tarakeshwar Ram died on the spot, while Dharam
Nath Ram died during the treatment, and Police/Polish Ram sustained
grievous injuries.
4.
MAC.APP. 765/2013 has been filed challenging the award passed
by the MACT in Suit No. 819/2010, instituted by the legal
representatives of deceased Siyaram, whereby compensation of Rs.
6,88,655/-, along with interest @ 9% per annum, was awarded in favour
of the claimants vide judgment dated 30th March 2013.
5.
MAC.APP. 643/2015 has been filed against the award passed in
MACT Case No. 02/13/10, instituted by the legal representatives of
deceased Dharam Nath Ram, whereby compensation of Rs. 6,58,290/-,
along with interest @ 9% per annum, was awarded in favour of the
claimants vide award dated 12th May 2015.
6.
MAC.APP. 645/2015 has been filed against the award passed in
MACT Case No. 03/13/10, instituted by the injured Police/Polish Ram,
whereby compensation of Rs. 12,33,900/-, along with interest @ 9% per
annum, was awarded by the MACT vide judgment dated 12th May 2015.
7.
MAC.APP. 646/2015 has been filed against the award passed in
MACT Case No. 01/13/10, instituted by the legal representatives of
deceased Tarakeshwar Ram, whereby compensation of Rs. 7,59,000/Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR MAC.APP. 765/2013 & connected appeals
16:13:45
[Rs. 7,79,000 - 20,000 in view of the admission of PW1 that she was
paid Rs. 20,000/- towards funeral expenses], along with interest @ 9%
per annum, was awarded in favour of the claimants vide judgment dated
12th May 2015.
8.
Vide order dated 23rd August 2013, this Court, while hearing the
appeal in MAC.APP. 765/2013, directed the Insurance Company to
deposit the entire compensation amount along with accrued interest by
the insurance company before the Registrar General of this Court and
directed release of 70%, in terms of directions in the MACT’s award.
9.
In MAC.APP. 643/2015, MAC.APP. 645/2015 and MAC.APP.
646/2015 vide order dated 19th August 2015, this Court directed the
Insurance Company to deposit the entire awarded compensation and
further directed the release of 50% to the claimants.
10.
Ms. Suman Bagga, counsel for the insurance company, contends
that the insurance company has duly complied with the orders passed by
this Court. She further submits that the insurance company does not
dispute the quantum of compensation awarded to the claimants. The only
grievance raised in the present appeals is with respect to the denial of
recovery rights against the owner and driver of the offending vehicle.
11.
The award, in paragraph 20, records that the vehicle was insured
for one driver and two passengers. The insurance company raised the
defence that the expression ‘two passengers’ would include only those
travelling in the cabin of the vehicle and not persons travelling in the rear
body of the truck. It is contended that although recovery rights were
specifically pleaded, the same were rejected by the MACT on the basis
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR MAC.APP. 765/2013 & connected appeals
16:13:45
that there was no cross-examination on the point that the
deceased/injured were travelling in the body of the truck.
12.
In this regard, Ms. Bagga has invited the attention of this Court to
the testimony of the injured claimant, Police/Polish Ram, who deposed
that the Eicher Canter was being driven by Deepak Kumar at a very high
speed, in a rash and negligent manner, and in a zigzag manner. He
further stated that he and his co-travelers repeatedly cautioned the driver
not to drive in such a manner, but the driver paid no heed to their
warnings. He further deposed that when the Eicher Canter reached
Faridabad, the driver suddenly applied the brakes, due to which the
loaded aluminium plates fell down over him and his co-passengers, who
were all sitting in the body of the canter.
13.
Ms. Bagga contends that, in view of this clear admission made by
the injured claimant, who was also an eyewitness to the accident, the
question of cross-examination did not arise and, therefore,
the
observations and findings of the MACT rejecting the insurer's plea on
the ground of absence of cross-examination are untenable.
14.
Notably, no one appeared on behalf of the driver and the owner
before this Court. It is recorded in the order dated 10th February 2014 in
MAC.APP. 765/2013 and orders dated 15th October 2015 in MAC.APP.
643/2015, MAC.APP. 645/2015 and MAC.APP. 646/2015, that the
vakalatnamas were filed on behalf of the driver and owner. However,
despite entering appearance through counsel, they have not participated
in the proceedings thereafter.
15.
Mr. Ajay Sharma appeared before the MACT on behalf of M/s
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR MAC.APP. 765/2013 & connected appeals
16:13:45
Sandeep Metal Udyog and also placed on record his evidence by way of
affidavit, wherein he had stated that all four persons were employees of
the company and were covered under the Employees' Insurance Scheme.
However, he did not state whether they were travelling in the cabin of
the vehicle or whether they were not travelling in the body of the vehicle
and therefore, would not be covered under the insurance policy.
16.
Mr. Ajay Sharma was not cross-examined by the insurance
company on this aspect. In this regard, Ms. Suman Bagga submits that no
such cross-examination was necessary, as there was no assertion in the
affidavit contrary to the specific defence already taken by the insurance
company. She has invited the attention of the Court to the written
statement filed by the insurance company, wherein it was specifically
pleaded that the deceased and the injured were gratuitous passengers and
that the risk pertaining to such passengers was not covered under the
insurance policy.
17.
In support of her submissions, she places reliance on the decision
of the Supreme Court in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Baljit Kaur,
(2004) 2 SCC 1, wherein the Supreme Court held that the liability of the
insurer does not extend to gratuitous passengers travelling in a goods
vehicle. For ease of reference, relevant paragraphs are extracted as
under:
“10. The material portion of the provision contained
in Section 147 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, as
amended by the Motor Vehicles (Amendment) Act,
1994 reads as follows:
“147. Requirements of policies and limits
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR MAC.APP. 765/2013 & connected appeals
16:13:45
of liability.—(1) In order to comply with
the requirements of this Chapter, a policy
of insurance must be a policy which—
(a) ***
(b) insures the person or classes of
persons specified in the policy to the
extent specified in sub-section (2)—
(i) against any liability which may be
incurred by him in respect of the death of
or bodily injury to any person, including
owner of the goods or his authorized
representative carried in the vehicle or
damage to any property of a third party
caused by or arising out of the use of the
vehicle in a public place;
(ii) ***”
***
17. By reason of the 1994 amendment what was
added is “including owner of the goods or his
authorised representative carried in the vehicle”.
The liability of the owner of the vehicle to insure it
compulsorily, thus, by reason of the aforementioned
amendment included only the owner of the goods or
his authorised representative carried in the vehicle
besides the third parties. The intention of
Parliament, therefore, could not have been that the
words “any person” occurring in Section 147 would
cover all persons who were travelling in a goods
carriage in any capacity whatsoever. If such was the
intention, there was no necessity of Parliament to
carry out an amendment inasmuch as the expression
“any person” contained in sub-clause (i) of clause
(b) of sub-section (1) of Section 147 would have
included the owner of the goods or his authorised
representative besides the passengers who are
gratuitous or otherwise.
***
20. It is, therefore, manifest that in spite of the
amendment of 1994, the effect of the provision
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR MAC.APP. 765/2013 & connected appeals
16:13:45
contained in Section 147 with respect to persons
other than the owner of the goods or his authorized
representative remains the same. Although the
owner of the goods or his authorized representative
would now be covered by the policy of insurance in
respect of a goods vehicle, it was not the intention of
the legislature to provide for the liability of the
insurer with respect to passengers, especially
gratuitous passengers, who were neither
contemplated at the time the contract of insurance
was entered into, nor was any premium paid to the
extent of the benefit of insurance to such category of
people.
21. The upshot of the aforementioned discussions is
that instead and in place of the insurer the owner of
the vehicle shall be liable to satisfy the decree. The
question, however, would be as to whether keeping
in view the fact that the law was not clear so long
such a direction would be fair and equitable. We do
not think so. We, therefore, clarify the legal position
which shall have prospective effect. The Tribunal as
also the High Court had proceeded in terms of the
decision of this Court in Satpal Singh [(2000) 1 SCC
237 : 2000 SCC (Cri) 130] . The said decision has
been overruled only in Asha Rani [(2003) 2 SCC
223 : 2003 SCC (Cri) 493] . We, therefore, are of
the opinion that the interest of justice will be
subserved if the appellant herein is directed to
satisfy the awarded amount in favour of the
claimant, if not already satisfied, and recover the
same from the owner of the vehicle. For the purpose
of such recovery, it would not be necessary for the
insurer to file a separate suit but it may initiate a
proceeding before the executing court as if the
dispute between the insurer and the owner was the
subject-matter of determination before the Tribunal
and the issue is decided against the owner and in
favour of the insurer. We have issued the
aforementioned directions having regard to the
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR MAC.APP. 765/2013 & connected appeals
16:13:45
scope and purport of Section 168 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988, in terms whereof, it is not only
entitled to determine the amount of claim as put
forth by the claimant for recovery thereof from the
insurer, owner or driver of the vehicle jointly or
severally but also the dispute between the insurer on
the one hand and the owner or driver of the vehicle
involved in the accident inasmuch as can be
resolved by the Tribunal in such a proceeding.”
(emphasis added)
Conclusion
18.
In view of the position, as taken by the Supreme Court, this Court
is of the opinion, there is no evidence establishing that the deceased and
injured were travelling in a capacity covered under the insurance policy
or that they fell within the category of owners of goods or their
authorised representatives. Therefore, the insurer cannot be fastened with
liability for the claims arising from the death and injuries of gratuitous
passengers.
19.
Accordingly, these appeals are disposed of with the direction that
there shall be a ‘right of recovery’ with the insurance company qua the
owner of the offending vehicle.
20.
Considering that these appeals have remained pending since 2013
and that the period of the fixed deposits directed by the learned MACT
has already expired, the balance amount of compensation, along with the
accrued interest thereon, shall be released to the claimants in a lump sum
in terms of the apportionment directed in the impugned awards passed by
the MACT.
21.
It has been brought to the notice of this Court that the injured
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR MAC.APP. 765/2013 & connected appeals
16:13:45
claimant, Police/Polish Ram, has since expired and that his legal
representatives have been brought on record in terms of the amended
memo of parties filed on 05th August 2025. Accordingly, the
compensation amount in MAC.APP. 645/2013 shall be released to the
legal representatives of the deceased Police/Polish Ram in equal shares.
22.
The Registry shall transfer/remit the amounts into designated
accounts of the legal heirs. Details whereof shall be provided with proofs
of identity to the Registry, by the counsel for claimants.
23.
All these appeals are disposed of accordingly in above terms.
24.
Pending applications, if any, are rendered infructuous.
25.
Date of 25th September 2026, fixed earlier, stands cancelled.
26.
Statutory deposit, if any, shall be refunded to appellate/Insurance
Company only upon deposit of the enhanced amount along with the
accrued interest.
27.
Judgement be uploaded on the website of this Court.
(ANISH DAYAL)
JUDGE
JULY 17, 2026/sm/bp
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR MAC.APP. 765/2013 & connected appeals
16:13:45
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review