Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
RSA-4471-2025 (O&M)
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
RSA-4471-2025 (O&M)
Reserved on:- 16.07.2026
Pronounced on: 24.07.2026
Date of uploading: 27.07.2026
Harwinder Singh through his LRs and Another
....Appellants
Versus
Gurjeet Singh and Ors.
...Respondents
CORAM:- HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE AMARJOT BHATTI
Present:-
Mr. S.S.Swaich, Advocate
Mr. Ishant Goyal, Advocate,
Ms. Deepika, Advocate and
Ms. Navjot Kaur, Advocate for the appellants.
*****
AMARJOT BHATTI, J.
1.
The appellants/defendants Harwinder Singh (now deceased)
through his LRs and Paramjit Kaur filed present Regular Second Appeal
against impugned judgment and decree dated 03.10.2025, passed by
learned Additional District Judge, SAS Nagar, Mohali vide which appeal
preferred by the appellants/defendants was dismissed and the judgment
and decree dated 16.01.2017, passed by learned Additional Civil Judge
(Senior Division), SAS Nagar, Mohali, granting the relief of recovery of
Rs.4,50,000/- along with interest as detailed therein, was upheld.
2.
As per the facts narrated in the plaint, plaintiff Gurjeet Singh
filed suit for possession by way of specific performance of agreement to
sell dated 13.08.2012, executed by defendant No.1 in his favour, with
regard to 01 kanal, 0 marla land bearing khasra No.21//1/2(2-9),
21//2/2(4-13),
SUNIL DEVI
2026.07.27 16:11
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
21//8/2(1-16),
21//9(8-0),
21//10(2-3),
21//12(6-2),
RSA-4471-2025 (O&M)
-2-
21//13/2(6-3), 21//26(1-2),kitte 8, total 32 kanal 8 marla, situated in village
Gudana, Tehsil and District Mohali for total sale consideration of Rs.10
lakhs. It is pleaded that defendant No.1, i.e. Harwinder Singh (deceased)
now represented through LRs, had received earnest money of
Rs.4,50,000/- and the date fixed for execution of sale deed was mutually
agreed as 13.02.2013. Later on, defendant No.1 - Harwinder Singh with
mala fide intention, executed transfer deed in favour of defendant No.2
(his mother Paramjit Kaur). The defendant No.2- Paramjit Kaur, further
transferred the property in favour of defendants No.3 to 19, as detailed
therein. The plaintiff claimed that he remained ready and willing to
perform his part of agreement to sell, but it was defendant No.1 who
resiled from the terms of said agreement to sell. The aforesaid transfer
deeds were also challenged as illegal, null and void, and the plaintiff
sought the relief of specific performance of agreement to sell, in alternate
suit for recovery and for declaration challenging the sale deed dated
24.08.2012 executed by defendant No.1 in favour of Paramjit Kaurdefendant No.2 and also suit for permanent injunction restraining the
defendants No.1 and 2, their servants or agents, from alienating the said
property by any means as detailed therein.
3.
Notice of suit was given to the defendants. The defendants
No.1 and 2 filed their joint written statement taking the stand that the suit
was not maintainable in the said form. The defendant No.1 denied the
execution of agreement to sell dated 13.08.2012 and it was claimed to be a
forged and fabricated document. He further denied to have received
Rs.4,50,000/- from the plaintiff. The defendant No.1 was addicted to
SUNIL DEVI
2026.07.27 16:11
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
RSA-4471-2025 (O&M)
-3-
alcohol and used to wander here and there and due to excessive use of
alcohol, he died at the age of 32 years only.
Defendant No.1 never
executed any registered sale deed in favour of his wife regarding 04 kanal
02 marlas of land.
All facts narrated in the plaint are denied. It is
submitted that plaintiff has filed a false suit and prayed for dismissal of the
same.
4.
Defendants No.7, 9, 11, 16, 17, and 18 filed their separate
written statement denying their knowledge of said agreement to sell
allegedly executed by defendant No.1 in favour of plaintiff. They were not
aware of the litigation going on between the plaintiff and defendants No.1
and 2. They were not party to the said agreement to sell. Plaintiff has no
cause of action against them. After raising additional objections regarding
maintainability of the suit and mis-joinder of parties, it is prayed that the
suit filed by the plaintiff deserves dismissal.
5.
From the pleadings of the parties, following issues were
framed by the Trial Court on 30.09.2016:1.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled for relief of specific
performance as prayed for? OPP
2.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to alternative relief of
recovery as prayed for? OPP
3.
Whether the sale deed was executed in favour of
defendant No.1 is illegal, null and void? OPP
4.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to permanent injunction
as prayed for? OPP
5.
Whether the suit of the plaintiff is not maintainable?
OPD
SUNIL DEVI
2026.07.27 16:11
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
RSA-4471-2025 (O&M)
-4-
6.
Whether the plaintiff has got no locus standi to file the
present suit? OPD
7.
6.
Relief.
In order to prove the case, the respondent No.1-plaintiff Gurjit
Singh examined himself as PW-1. He also examined Harjit Singh as PW2
and placed on record documents and closed his evidence.
7.
On the other hand, defendants did not examine any witness
inspite of availing numerous opportunities granted to them.
8.
After hearing the arguments advanced by learned counsel for
both the parties, the suit filed by the respondent No.1-plaintiff was partly
decreed and defendant No.1 was directed to make the payment of amount
in question i.e. Rs.4,50,000/- to the plaintiff with interest, at the rate of 9%
per annum from the date of filing of the suit till realization of the amount.
Feeling aggrieved of this judgment and decree, the
appellants/defendants No.1 & 2 have filed the appeal before the First
Appellate Court, which was also dismissed vide impugned judgment and
decree dated 03.10.2025. Thereafter, the present Regular Second Appeal
has been filed.
9.
Learned counsel for the appellants/defendants No.1 & 2,
argued that the judgment and decree passed by learned trial Court dated
16.01.2017 is not on sound footings. The findings given by learned trial
Court are perverse and liable to be set aside. Without appreciating the facts
and the evidence on record, learned First Appellate Court also wrongly
dismissed their appeal by passing impugned judgment and decree dated
03.10.2025. The respondent No.1/plaintiff, miserably failed to prove on
record the agreement to sell dated 13.08.2012 (Exhibit P-2), as well as
SUNIL DEVI
2026.07.27 16:11
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
RSA-4471-2025 (O&M)
-5-
receipt (Exhibit P-3). The findings given by the court below are beyond the
pleadings and have tried to make out totally a new case. There are no
pleadings from the side of plaintiff or defendants No.1 & 2 that there was
any loan transactions, nor any such evidence has been produced. The
learned trial Court has wrongly granted alternate relief for recovery of
Rs.4,50,000/- with interest in favour of respondent No.1/plaintiff by
treating it as loan transaction. It has come in the findings of learned trial
Court that plaintiff was not ready and willing to perform his part of
agreement to sell, nor he was ready with balance sale consideration.
Therefore, on that basis, suit filed by the plaintiff was liable to be
dismissed and the earnest money paid by the respondent No.1/plaintiff,
was liable to be forfeited in the terms of agreement to sell dated
13.08.2012 (Exhibit P-2). To support this argument, learned counsel for the
appellants referred to the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in
Civil Appeal No.5822 of 2025 titled K.R.Suresh vs. R.Poornima & Ors.,
2025(3) RCR (civil) 43 where in a suit for specific performance of
agreement to sell, it was observed that earnest money is a guarantee for
due performance of the contract and it can be forfeited in case of default by
the purchaser. Learned counsel for the appellants also referred to the
judgments passed by Coordinate Bench on this point in Shivjot
Developers and Builders Ltd. vs. Sarup Singh, 2025(2) RCR (Civil) 633
and Surjit Singh and Anr. vs. Shashi Bala and Ors., 2025 (4) RCR (Civil)
61.
The findings given by learned trial Court are selfcontradictory. In fact, defendant No.1-Harwinder Singh was addicted to
SUNIL DEVI
2026.07.27 16:11
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
RSA-4471-2025 (O&M)
-6-
alcohol. He never executed agreement to sell dated 13.08.2012 (Exhibit P2) in favour of respondent No.1/plaintiff, nor he received earnest money to
the tune of Rs.4,50,000/-. The agreement to sell and the receipt Exhibit P-2
and P-3 are result of fraud, forgery and fabrication. With these arguments,
the impugned judgment and decree dated 03.10.2025 passed by learned
Additional District Judge, SAS Nagar, Mohali, upholding the judgment
and decree dated 16.01.2017 passed by Additional Civil Judge (Senior
Division), SAS Nagar, Mohali, are liable to be set aside by accepting the
present appeal.
10.
I have considered the arguments and have gone through the
trial Court record carefully with the able assistance of learned counsel for
the appellants. Plaintiff- Gurjeet Singh filed suit for specific performance
of agreement to sell dated 13.08.2012 (Exhibit P-2), allegedly executed by
Harwinder Singh (deceased) now represented through LRs (appellant
No.1/defendant No.1 in the main case), regarding sale of 01 kanal, 0 marla
of land bearing khasra No.21//1/2(2-9), 21//2/2(4-13), 21//8/2(1-16),
21//9(8-0), 21//10(2-3), 21//12(6-2), 21//13/2(6-3), 21//26(1-2), kitte 8,
total 32 kanal 8 marla situated in village Gudana, Tehsil and District
Mohali for total sale consideration of Rs.10 lakhs, out of which the
plaintiff/Gurjeet Singh allegedly gave Rs.4,50,000/- towards earnest
money and the date fixed for execution of sale deed was 13.02.2013. It was
the plaintiff/Gurjeet Singh who filed the aforesaid suit on the basis of
agreement to sell dated 13.08.2012. Therefore, onus was heavily on the
plaintiff to prove his case. In order to discharge his onus, plaintiff/Gurjeet
Singh stepped into the witness box as PW-1 and he further examined Harjit
SUNIL DEVI
2026.07.27 16:11
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
RSA-4471-2025 (O&M)
-7-
Singh, one of the marginal witness as PW-2 and proved on record the
agreement to sell dated 13.08.2012 (Exhibit P-2) and endorsement/receipt
regarding payment of earnest money of Rs.4,50,000/- to Harwinder
Singh/purchaser, vide endorsement/receipt (Exhibit P-3). Copy of
Jamabandi of the property in question is Exhibit P-1. In order to rebut the
aforesaid evidence, the appellants/defendants No.1 & 2, failed to lead any
evidence on record. The appellants/defendants in their written statement
merely denied the execution of agreement to sell dated 13.08.2012
(Exhibit P-2), as well as receipt of Rs.4,50,000/- as earnest money, vide
endorsement/receipt (Exhibit P-3).
11.
The appellant/defendant No.1 took the stand that since he was
addicted to liquor, therefore his signatures might have been taken on blank
papers. It was claimed that agreement to sell dated 13.08.2012 (Exhibit P2), receipt/endorsement (Exhibit P-3) are forged and fictitious documents.
In order to prove the aforesaid stand taken in the written statement, neither
Harwinder Singh/defendant No.1 nor his mother Paramjit Kaur/defendant
No.2 (appellants in the present case), ever stepped into the witness box.
Therefore, the evidence led by the plaintiff remained unrebutted. There is
sufficient evidence on record to prove the execution of agreement to sell
dated 13.08.2012 (Exhibit P-2), as well as endorsement/receipt (Exhibit P3), receipt of earnest money of Rs.4,50,000/- by Harwinder Singh.
The contents of judgment passed by learned Additional Civil
Judge (Senior Division), SAS Nagar Mohali in para No.12 indicate that
learned trial Court held that plaintiff/Gurjeet Singh never came present in
SUNIL DEVI
2026.07.27 16:11
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
RSA-4471-2025 (O&M)
-8-
the office of Sub-Registrar on the date fixed for the execution and
registration of sale deed on 13.02.2013. He did not serve any legal notice
to defendant No.1 (appellant in this case) to show his readiness and
willingness to perform his part of agreement to sell, nor he produced any
document to show that he was ready with balance sale consideration of
Rs.5,50,000/-. On that basis, the learned trial Court came to the conclusion
that it appeared to be a loan transaction and on that basis passed decree for
recovery of Rs.4,50,000/- along with interest as claimed therein.
12.
The aforesaid findings given by learned trial Court is not on
sound footings. As referred above, execution of agreement to sell dated
13.08.2012 (Exhibit P-2), as well as endorsement/receipt (Exhibit P-3), are
duly proved on record by plaintiff/Gurjeet Singh as PW-1 and Harjit Singh,
marginal witness as PW-2. The date fixed for the execution and
registration of sale deed was 13.02.2013. However, before the aforesaid
date fixed for the execution of sale deed, Harwinder Singh transferred the
property in favour of his mother Paramjit Kaur/defendant No. 2, by vasika
No.1927 dated 24.08.2012. Furthermore, appellant No.2/defendant No.2,
further transferred the property in favour of defendants No.3 to 19. Once
the property had already exchanged hands, there was no occasion for the
respondent/plaintiff Gurjeet Singh to appear in the office of Sub-Registrar
on 13.02.2013 or to produce evidence that he was ready with balance sale
consideration. The judgments relied upon by learned counsel representing
appellants in K.R.Suresh case (supra), Shivjot Developers and Builders
Ltd. case (supra) and Surjit Singh case (supra) are not applicable to the
facts of the present case. It was appellant/defendant No.1-Harwinder Singh
SUNIL DEVI
2026.07.27 16:11
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
RSA-4471-2025 (O&M)
-9-
(deceased) now represented through LRs, defeated the terms and
conditions of agreement to sell dated 13.08.2012. During the pendency of
this litigation, he admittedly expired in the year 2016.
13.
Considering the aforesaid factual position, the conclusion
arrived at by learned trial Court by passing a decree for recovery of
Rs.4,50,000/- along with interest at the rate of 9% per annum from the date
of filing of suit till realization, does not require any interference. The
aforesaid factual position was duly appreciated by learned Additional
District Judge, SAS Nagar, Mohali, in the impugned judgment dated
03.10.2025. Consequently, I do not find any valid reason to interfere in the
impugned judgment dated 03.10.2025 passed by learned Additional
District Judge, SAS Nagar, Mohali granting alternative relief of recovery
of earnest money with interest as detailed therein and the same is
accordingly upheld. Finding no merits in the present Regular Second
Appeal, the same is accordingly dismissed.
14.
Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, stand disposed
of accordingly as well.
24.07.2026
(AMARJOT BHATTI)
JUDGE
Sunil Devi
Whether speaking/reasoned:
Whether reportable:
SUNIL DEVI
2026.07.27 16:11
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review