Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CRR-2910-2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
CASE NO.: CRR-2910-2025
DATE OF DECISION: January 12, 2026
Harmit Singh
......Petitioner
Versus
State of Punjab and another
......Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY VASHISTH
Present:
Mr. Inderjit Sharma, Advocate,
for the petitioner.
Mr. Neeraj Madaan, Senior DAG, Punjab.
****
SANJAY VASHISTH, J.
1.
Aggrieved by the order dated 01.08.2024, passed by learned
Principal Magistrate, Juvenile Justice Board, Gurdaspur, as affirmed in
appeal by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Gurdaspur (Appellate
Court), vide judgment dated 18.10.2025, petitioner – Harmit Singh, who
is son of complainant/victim Narinderjit Kaur (since deceased), has
preferred the instant criminal revision petition under Section 401 Cr.P.C.
2.
Facts of the present case are that on the statement of
Narinderjit Kaur, FIR No. 85, dated 25.06.2020, under Section 307 IPC
(Section 302 IPC was added lateron), was registered at Police Station
Tibber, District Gurdaspur, against her daughter-in-law, namely,
Komalpreet Kaur (respondent No. 2 herein) with the allegations that
Komalpreet Kaur used to quarrel with the complainant over petty
domestic/household works.
Once such quarrel had taken place on
23.06.2020, when Harmit Singh (son of the complainant) was not present
PRASHANT KAPOOR
2026.01.16 16:22
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgement
CRR-2910-2025
in the home. When complainant asked her daughter-in-law as to why she
was abusing her, then Komalpreet Kaur replied that she would finish the
matter/disputes forever. Thereafter, when the complainant was lying on
bed in her room, at about 04.00 p.m., then Komalpreet Kaur poured
Kerosene oil and lit the fire, with an intention to kill the complainant.
She came out of the room and raised alarm ‘Maar-ditta, Maar-Ditta’, and
tried to save herself by pouring water using the bucket lying near the
hand pump. Komalpreet Kaur kept standing there and did not try to save
the complainant. All the neighbourers gathered there and meanwhile
daughter of complainant, namely, Paramjit Kaur and her husband Dildar
Singh also reached on the spot and shifted the complainant to the Civil
Hospital, Gurdaspur, for treatment. Later on she was referred for further
treatment to Guru Nanak Dev Hospital, Amritsar, on 24.06.2020.
Complainant – Narinderjit Kaur scummed to burn injuries
and died on 22.07.2020.
After recording of G.D. No. 21, dated
22.07.2020 (Annexure P-2), offence under Section 302 IPC was added in
the FIR.
3.
It is alleged that police conducted the investigation in a
defective and biased manner, and instead of filing report under Section
173 Cr.P.C. against the accused, submitted cancellation report, dated
30.12.2020 (Annexure P-3). Thereupon, petitioner filed an application
under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. (Annexure P-4), for directing the police to
conduct free, fair and impartial investigation.
Even the cancellation
report was rejected by the Court of learned Additional Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Gurdaspur, and ordered that the accused Komalpreet Kaur be
PRASHANT KAPOOR
2026.01.16 16:22
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgement
CRR-2910-2025
summoned to face trial under Section 302 IPC, vide order dated
08.02.2023 (Annexure P-5).
4.
Komalpreet Kaur was granted anticipatory bail by the Court
of learned Sessions Judge, Gurdaspur, vide order dated 04.10.2023
(Annexure P-6). Komalpreet Kaur also filed an application (Annexure P7) in the Court of Sessions Judge, Gurdaspur, for declaring her as minor
at the time of alleged occurrence i.e. 23.06.2020, by claiming her date of
birth as 04.06.2003, and that she was 17 years and 19 days old on the said
date.
The said application was opposed by the State by filing
reply (Annexure P-8). It was contended that accused was already major
at the time of occurrence as she was married with Harmit Singh on
attaining the age of majority, and there was no requirement for
determining her age. Her date of birth, as 04.06.2003, was also denied.
The Court of learned Sessions Judge, Gurdaspur, allowed
the application, vide order dated 20.02.2024 (Annexure P-9), and
directed the accused/respondent No. 2 to appear before the Juvenile
Justice Board, Gurdaspur, with direction to the concerned Board to
proceed with the trial.
5.
Order dated 20.02.2024 (Annexure P-9) was challenged by
the petitioner by filing CRR-1022-2024 before this Court (Punjab and
Haryana High Court), and the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court modified
the same, vide order dated 20.05.2024 (Annexure P-10), and directed that
Juvenile Justice Board to make necessary preliminary assessment in
accordance with the provisions of Section 15 of the Juvenile Justice
PRASHANT KAPOOR
2026.01.16 16:22
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgement
CRR-2910-2025
(Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015 (hereafter to be referred as
‘the Act’) and then pass appropriate order in accordance with law.
6.
In the interregnum, the APP for the State of Punjab had also
filed an application dated 04.05.2024 (Annexure P-11), under Section 15
read with Section 18 of the Act, before the learned Principal Magistrate,
Juvenile Justice Board, Gurdaspur, for treating the juvenile as adult and
the case be committed to the Sessions Court for trial.
After filing reply to the said application by respondent No. 2
and examining Dr. Sanjay Kumar, Clinical Psychologist, IMH, Amritsar
as EW-1 on 03.07.2024, learned Principal Magistrate, Juvenile Justice
Board, Gurdaspur, dismissed the application, vide impugned order dated
01.08.2024, and declared respondent No. 2 as juvenile, to be tried by the
Juvenile Justice Court, Gurdaspur. The observations made in para Nos. 4
to 8 of the impugned order dated 01.08.2024, are reproduced as under:“4.
I have heard Ld. APP for the State and Ld.
Defence Counsel on the application under Section 15 of
Juvenile Justice Act.
It is the prosecution version that deceased
Narinderjit Kaur has got recorded her statement that her
son Harmeet Singh got married to Komalpreet Kaur. From
the very inception, Komalpreet Kaur used to pick up quarrel
due to household work. On 02.06.2020, her son Harmeet
Singh had gone out for some work and she along with her
daughter-in-law Komalpreet Kaur were alone at home.
Komalpreet Kaur was habitual of picking up quarrels and
used to abuse her. On that day, complainant asked her as to
why she is abusing her and Komalpreet replied that today
she will put an end to the situation. Complainant went to her
room, She told all this to her daughter on phone. Her
daughter Paramjeet Kaur told that she will soon reach
there. At around 4:00 pm, her daughter-in-law poured oil
upon her with the intention to kill her and put her on fire.
She raised hue and cry. She went near the tap and put the
bucket of water upon herself. Neighbors gathered there on
hearing her hue and cry. Her daughter Paramjeet Kaur and
PRASHANT KAPOOR
2026.01.16 16:22
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgement
CRR-2910-2025
son-in-law Dildar Singh reached there and took her to the
hospital. Statement of witnesses recorded. After
investigation, report was presented against juvenile
Komalpreet Kaur under Section 307 1PC and later on, 302
IPC was added.
5.
As per Section (2)(33) of Juvenile Justice Act,
“heinous offences includes the offence for which the
minimum punishment under the Indian Penal Code (45 of
1860) or any other law for the time being in force is
imprisonment for seven years or more.” The minimum
punishment for the offence under Section 307 and 302 IPC
is not less than 7 years.
6.
As per Section 15 of the Juvenile Justice (Care
& Protection of Children) Act, 2015 (hereinafter referred as
Act), in case of heinous offence. alleged to have been
committed by child who has completed or its above age of
16 years, preliminary assessment is to be conducted with
regard to mental and physical capacity of juvenile to commit
such offence and ability to understand the consequences of
offence and circumstances in which he allegedly committed
the offence.
7.
From the Order dated 20.02.2004 of the Court
of Sh. Rajinder Aggarwal, Ld. Sessions Judge, Gurdaspur,
and copy of Matriculation Examination Certificate cum
detailed Marks Sheet, it is clear that Komalpreet Kaur was
juvenile i.e. less than 18 years of age on the date of alleged
occurrence i.e. 23.06.2020 as her date of birth is
04.06.2003. Hence, also, it clearly indicates that
Komlapreet Kaur was married when she was below the age
of 18 years. The minimum age prescribed for marriage as
per law is 18 years. The purpose of setting the particular
age for a female for getting married is that till that age, it is
not expected that she is having the level of understanding as
required for running the matrimonial relations and
obligations. It is the version of the complainant herself that
Komalpreet used to pick up quarrel due to household work.
As such, it is clear that Komalpreet was made to do
household chores during her stay in her matrimonial home.
Also, from the statement of complainant herself, that
Komalpreet Kaur has said that she will put an end to the
situation on that day only, clearly implies that Kemalpreet
Kaur was also upset with the matter as going on between
her and her in-laws (mother-in-law). She was made to do all
the matrimonial obligations towards the matrimonial house
and her in-laws despite the fact that she was still under the
age of 18 years. Hence, it is obvious that a girl having a
tender age below the age of 18 years might not have been
PRASHANT KAPOOR
2026.01.16 16:22
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgement
CRR-2910-2025
able to discharge her matrimonial obligations put upon her
in such an early age. Hence, the circumstances in which she
was surviving was not very conducive towards her. She
cannot be expected to have a very rational thinking, in such
circumstances.
8.
One of the ground to be considered while
deciding the application under Section 15 of JJ Act, that the
circumstances in which the offence is alleged to have
committed is also to be considered. Hence, in the present
case, the circumstances in which juvenile is stated to have
committed the alleged act is very important as the girl below
the age of 18 years cannot be expected to keep a balance
and rationale thinking under the pressure of household
work. Although, the report of Psychologist reflects that she
was having IQ of 95 i.e. Average Intelligence and she is able
to understand the consequences of the offence. But, as
discussed above, the circumstances in which the alleged
offence has been committed putforth another side of
assessment of considering the circumstances in which the
alleged offence has been committed. A person of a good IQ
level can also lose a rationale thinking if put to face certain
circumstances beyond his capacity to be handled. Hence, it
cannot be concluded at this stage, that she could be tried as
an adult as she cannot be expected to have a rationale
thinking at the time of alleged offence. Section 15 of
Juvenile Justice Act deals with only heinous offence, but in
the present case, although the age of the Komalpreet Kaur
at the time of alleged occurrence is reflected to be between
16 and 18 years, but it does not comply with other
requirements of Section 15 of Juvenile Justice Act. Hence,
the application under Section 15 r.w. Section 18 of Juvenile
Justice Act 2015 is hereby dismissed.”
7.
Challenging
the
impugned
order
dated
01.08.2024,
petitioner earlier approached this Court by filing CRR-2243-2024, which
was disposed of by this Court vide order dated 10.09.2025 (Annexure P15), relegating the petitioner to file statutory appeal, under Section 101 of
the Act, within 02 weeks before the Court of Sessions. It was also
directed that such appeal would be decided within 04 weeks thereafter on
merits, in accordance with law, without adhering to the limitation part.
PRASHANT KAPOOR
2026.01.16 16:22
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgement
CRR-2910-2025
8.
Petitioner then filed an appeal, dated 20.09.2025 (Annexure
P-16), before the Court of Sessions, impugning the order dated
01.08.2024, passed by the learned Principal Magistrate, Juvenile Justice
Board, Gurdaspur, which has been dismissed by the learned Additional
Sessions Judge, Gurdaspur, vide impugned judgment dated 18.10.2025,
by observing as under:“7.
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
The assessment as per Section 15 of Juvenile
Justice Act is not a mechanical exercise but a crucial
determination of all the aspects including psychological,
social and emotional, while assessing child’s culpability
potential. It requires a holistic appraisal of entire material
placed before the board and circumstances in which offence
alleged has been committed. The child with average or high
IQ may lack emotion regulation under the stressful
environment more particularly when child is exposed to
socio-familial pressure, then it can temporarily impair his
or her rational Judgment. Further as per mandate of Section
15 of the JJ Act, it is four-fold test which is to be applied
while making assessment which includes (i) mental capacity
(ii) physical capacity (iii) understanding of the
consequences and (iv) circumstances of the alleged offence.
This principle is reiterated in “B.C.Thakur Vs. Master
Bholu & Anr” [2022 (7) SCC, 1 : Law Finder Doc Id #
2012149] in which Hon’ble Supreme Court explained that
at the time of preliminary assessment, social and emotional
environment must be considered and not just psychological
score.
8.
After considering the governing legal
framework, now to turn to the specific facts of the case in
hand. The age of the respondent No.2 at the time of alleged
commission of offence is not disputed and she was 17 years
19 days. It also emerges out from the record that respondent
No. 2 was married while she was below the legal age and
made exposure to house hold pressure. The Juvenile Justice
Board committed no illegality in concluding that respondent
No. 2 was lacking mature judgment at the time of alleged
offence as the mental psychology of child when put to
matrimonial responsibility at such a tender age can be well
perceivable. When child under 18 years of age, such as the
respondent No. 2 when put to house hold pressures, it
PRASHANT KAPOOR
2026.01.16 16:22
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgement
CRR-2910-2025
certaintly impaired rational judgment, as the child at such a
tender age cannot possess emotional or psychological
maturity of an adult. When at this age, child is subjected to
matrimonial responsibilities, it is understandable that the
child to undergo significant emotional distress and
household pressures. At this tender age, the child’s
personality and emotions are still developing making her
more vulnerable and forced her to anxiety, fear, confusion
and sense of helplessness and all these adversely affect the
child’s ability to think clearly and the alleged offence was
allegedly committed in these circumstances.
9.
Regarding the contention of learned counsel for
the appellant that learned Principal Magistrate, Juvenile
Justice Board erred in rejecting the mental health report.
Section 15 of JJAct enshrines a crucial fourfold test. It goes
beyond mechanical IQ score and situational factors
surrounding the child and the offence, are also crucial and
need to be considered. After going through the Section 15 of
the Act, it emerges out that the expert report is only one of
the several inputs and are not binding on the Board. The
function of the Board under Section 15 of the Juvenile
Justice Act is Judicial and not clinical. The board is
required to consider all aspects including psychological,
social and emotional, while assessing child’s culpability
potential. Learned Principal Magistrate, Juvenile Justice,
Board has given preference to socio emotional
circumstances over raw IQ findings which was well within
the jurisdiction of Learned Principal Magistrate, Juvenile
Justice Board as per the mandate of Section 15 of the
Juvenile Justice Act. It is also noteworthy, psychological
assessment by board has been made in the present case
nearly four years after the incident. Child’s cognitive state
at the time of offence (23.06.2020) not pointed out. Mental
health report dated 03.06.2024 does not indicate that any
scientific correlation or retrospective evaluation was
employed to assess respondent No.2’s mental and cognitive
state as on 23.06.2020.
10.
In the present case, it is not disputed that
respondent No.2 was married when she was less than 18
years of age and further, she was 17 years 19 days old at the
time of incident. At this formative age, the cognitive and
emotional faculties of a child are still developing when the
brain and emotions are still growing. It is hard for such a
tender years of child to think clearly and make good
decision, especially, when girl child gets married too early
as, she faces many problems like stress, pressure from family
and new responsibilities that are usually meant for adults.
All these things make it difficult for respondent No.2 like
PRASHANT KAPOOR
2026.01.16 16:22
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgement
CRR-2910-2025
child to understand the consequences of her actions. Thus
the observations/findings returned by learned JJ Board in
the impugned order in that regard does not suffer from any
illegality or perversity, thus calls for no interference in the
instant appeal.
11.
In view of the discussion made herein above,
this Court finds no illegality or perversity in the impugned
order dated 01.08.2024 passed by learned Principal
Magistrate Juvenile Justice, Board dismissing the
application under Section 15 read with Section 18 of the
Juvenile Justice Act. The impugned order is reasoned and
legally sustainable. Accordingly, instant is hereby
dismissed.”
9.
Mr. Inderjit Sharma, learned counsel for the petitioner
argued that learned Courts below have erred while passing the impugned
order/judgment and have not taken into account the fact that respondent
No. 2 has committed a heinous crime. She has been ordered to be tried
as a juvenile on the ground that she was made to do all the matrimonial
obligations while she was under the age of 18 years. On the contrary, at
the time of occurrence, i.e. 23.06.2020, the age of respondent No.
2/accused was 17 years and 19 days, and she committed the offence with
an intention to kill her mother-in-law. In these days, a person of such age
group cannot be said to be unaware of the consequences of such heinous
crime, punishable under Section 302 IPC.
Learned counsel for the petitioner further argues that as per
report dated 03.06.2024 (Annexure P-13), which was submitted by the
Director, Institute of Mental Health, Government Mental Hospital,
Amritsar, it is established that in the present case the juvenile has the
ability to understand the consequences of the alleged offence, and she
had mental and physical capacity to commit such crime. This material
piece of evidence has been overlooked firstly by learned Principal
PRASHANT KAPOOR
2026.01.16 16:22
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgement
CRR-2910-2025
Magistrate, Juvenile Justice Board, Gurdaspur, and then by the learned
lower Appellate Court. Thus, prays for setting aside of the impugned
order dated 01.08.2024, as well as the impugned judgment dated
18.10.2025, passed by learned Courts below.
10.
I have heard learned counsel for the petitioner and also
minutely gone through the material available on record.
11.
As per version of the FIR, the marriage of the petitioner –
Harmit Singh and juvenile/accused Komalpreet Kaur (respondent No. 2)
was solemnized about two and half years ago from the date of occurrence
i.e. 23.06.2020, i.e. somewhere in the mid of 2017. It is also an admitted
fact that the age of juvenile/accused at the time of occurrence was 17
years and 19 days. Meaning thereby, at the time of her marriage she was
even less than 15 years of age. It is beyond shadow of doubt, because, at
such a tender age, the cognitive and emotional faculties of a child are still
at developing stage and no child of such age would be in a position to
take proper and correct/appropriate decisions, independently.
It has also come on record that preliminary assessment in the
present case has been delayed by nearly 04 years after the occurrence and
by that time the juvenile/accused had attained the age of majority. Thus,
her current mental capacity could not reflect the state of mind at the time
of occurrence of alleged offence.
Furthermore, it has been rightly observed by the learned
Appellate Court that assessment under Section 15 of the Act is not merely
a mechanical exercise but a crucial determination of all the aspects viz.
PRASHANT KAPOOR
2026.01.16 16:22
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgement
CRR-2910-2025
Psychological, social and emotional, while assessing child’s culpability
potential.
When the narrative of factual matrix of the present case are
considered in totality, this Court finds no illegality or perversity in the
impugned order dated 01.08.2024, passed by learned Principal
Magistrate, Juvenile Justice Board, Gurdaspur, as affirmed in appeal also
by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Gurdaspur, by passing a
detailed and well reasoned judgment dated 18.10.2025.
Thus, no
interference by this Court in exercise of revisional jurisdiction is
warranted.
12.
As a sequel of the above discussion, while upholding the
impugned order dated 01.08.2024, and the impugned judgment dated
18.10.2025, the present criminal revision petition is dismissed, being
devoid of any merit.
(SANJAY VASHISTH)
JUDGE
January 12, 2026
Pkapoor
Whether Speaking/Reasoned
YES/NO
Whether Reportable
YES/NO
PRASHANT KAPOOR
2026.01.16 16:22
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgement
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review