Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment Reserved on: 15.05.2026
Judgment delivered on: 14.08.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 15.08.2026
#
CNR No:
DLHC010689522024
+
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024, CRL.M.A. 30444/2024, CRL.M.A.
34529/2024, CRL.M.A. 34572/2024, CRL.M.A. 10414/2025,
CRL.M.A. 13173-13174/2025, CRL.M.A. 23305/2025
HARJEET SINGH MENDIRATTA
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mrs. Kajal Chandra, Mr. Dalip Singh,
Ms. Hatneimawi and Mr. Suyash
Swarup, Advs. for the Petitioner and
Ms. Kalpana
versus
STATE GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI
AND ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. T. Singhdev, Mr. Tanishq
Srivastava, Mr. Abhijit Chakravarty
and Ms. A. Hussain, Advs. for BCD
Mr. Pawanjit Singh Bindra, Sr. Adv.
with Mr. Ashish Garg and Mr.
Ashmeet Singh, Advs. for R-2 along
with R- 2 in person
Mr. Preet Pal Singh, Adv. for BCI
(through vc)
Ms. Chand Chopra, Amicus Curiae
with Mr. Punishk Handa, Adv.
Ms. Rupali Bandhopadhya, ASC
(Crl.) with Mr. Abhijeet Kumar, Adv.
for R-3 and R-4 with SI Rahul, P.S.
Malviya Nagar
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
%
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA
JUDGMENT
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J:
1.
The present proceedings arise out of W.P. (CRL.) No. 3144/2024,
instituted by the petitioner [i.e. Harjeet Singh Mendiratta] under Article 226
of the Constitution of India read with Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik
Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, seeking quashing of Complaint Case No.
463048/2016 [earlier number C.C. 1440/2007], titled ‘Sonia Mendiratta v.
Harjeet Singh Mendiratta’ [‘criminal complaint’], which was pending
before the Court of the learned Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate,
New Delhi, [‘ACMM’] as well as the consequential criminal proceedings
arising therefrom.
1.1.
This Court, vide order dated 06.03.2025, issued a show cause notice
to the filing advocate, Ms. Kalpana on learning that the petitioner had
deliberately suppressed the material fact of having filed an earlier petition
i.e., CRL.M.C. No. 3870/2012 before this Court seeking the identical relief
of quashing of the said criminal complaint. The said petition had been
dismissed vide order dated 18.12.2012. However, in the present petition
there was no disclosure of the earlier petition and its dismissal. To the
contrary there was a positive assertion in the mandatory disclosure
paragraph (i.e., number 46) that petitioner had not filed any similar petition
seeking quashing of the criminal complaint before this Court. The filing
advocate, Ms. Kalpana is the wife of the petitioner and had personal
knowledge of the earlier petition and its dismissal. In the prima facie opinion
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
of the Court, the suppression of the earlier petition was deliberate and
intended to interfere with the administration of justice. It also amounted to
professional misconduct by the filing advocate, who has a duty to verify the
correctness of the pleadings. The Court, accordingly, on 06.03.2025 called
upon the filing advocate, Ms. Kalpana to explain why proceedings under the
Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 [‘Act of 1971’] and disciplinary proceedings
before the Bar Council of Delhi ought not to be initiated against her.
1.2.
This Court was also apprised that suppression in the present petition
was not an isolated fact and there was documented history in Court orders
from 2018 to 2025 of persistent abuse of process by the petitioner and the
filing advocate, Ms. Kalpana, in the petitioner’s defense of the criminal
complaint. The record shows filing of multiple non-maintainable challenges
to the orders passed in the criminal complaint, multiple petitions seeking
transfer of the presiding officer, which were dismissed for lacking merit by
the petitioner aided by the filing advocate Kalpana, leading to passing of
strictures against the petitioner.
1.3.
Pending consideration of the aforesaid show cause notice dated
06.03.2025, this Court has been informed that the Complaint Case No.
463048/2016 has since been decided by the Ld. JMFC-02, South District,
Saket Courts, New Delhi, vide judgment dated 12.02.2026, who has
dismissed the complaint case by holding that respondent no. 2 (i.e., Sonia
Mendiratta) has failed to prove the case beyond reasonable doubt.
1.4.
However, looking at the deliberate misconduct of the filing advocate,
Ms. Kalpana and the petitioner, this Court deemed it appropriate to hear Ms.
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
Kalpana in her reply to the show cause dated 06.03.2025 and also deal with
the writ petition.
1.5.
The present judgment therefore deals with the issue that whether
filing advocate, Ms. Kalpana, who represented the petitioner in the subject
writ proceedings, who is also his spouse and Special Power of Attorney
[‘SPA’] holder, has rendered herself liable to proceedings under the Act of
1971, for wilful suppression, interference with the administration of justice
and whether a reference ought to be made to the Bar Council of Delhi
[‘BCD’] for initiating disciplinary proceedings into the misconduct of the
said advocate.
1.6.
This judgment also deals with the dismissal of the writ petition for the
wilful suppression.
I.
FACTS AND JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS
INITIATION OF CONTEMPT PROCEEDINGS
LEADING
TO
THE
2.
The dispute between the parties emanates from a long-standing family
dispute relating to property bearing G-23, Triveni Commercial Complex,
Sheikh Sarai, Phase-I, New Delhi [‘property’]. Following the death of the
petitioner’s mother, Late Smt. Trilochan Kaur on 14.11.2005 disputes arose
between the petitioner and respondent no. 2, petitioner’s sister, concerning
the ownership of the said property. The petitioner alleged that respondent
no. 2, in collusion with other family members, had executed fraudulent
relinquishment deeds and sought mutation of the property in her favour.
These disputes gave rise to multiple civil and criminal proceedings before
different judicial forums.
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
2.1.
On 23.05.2007, respondent no. 2 instituted proceedings under Section
156(3) Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 [‘CrPC’] before the learned
ACMM, New Delhi, which came to be registered as the subject criminal
complaint, alleging commission of offences under Sections 323, 341, 451,
506 and 509 of Indian Penal Code, 1860 [‘IPC’], in view of the complaints
dated 06.09.2006 and 21.03.2007. By order dated 05.06.2007, the learned
ACMM treated the application as a complaint under Section 200 of the
CrPC, and by a subsequent order dated 08.06.2007, summoned the
petitioner.
2.2.
On 01.10.2012, the petitioner instituted CRL.M.C. No. 3870/2012,
titled ‘Harjeet Singh Mendiratta v. State & Ors’. before the Co-ordinate
Bench of this Court seeking quashing of the aforesaid complaint case [C.C.
1440/2007] and the summoning order dated 08.06.2007. By judgment dated
18.12.2012, the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court dismissed the quashing
petition on the grounds of delay and laches.
The relief sought in CRL.M.C. No. 3870/2012, is identical with the
subject writ petition and the wilful suppression of this petition and its
dismissal has resulted in initiation of these contempt proceedings.
2.3.
Reverting to the proceedings in the criminal complaint, learned
ACMM dismissed the petitioner’s application seeking discharge vide order
dated 14.03.2018.
Thereafter, charges were framed on 03.04.2018.
2.4.
The petitioner filed Revision Petition No. 102/2018 before Special
Judge, NDPS South District, Saket impugning the order dated 03.04.2018.
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
This revision petition was dismissed vide order dated 01.05.2018.
Thus, the order framing charge had attained finality. Needless to state
that the order dated 14.03.2018 dismissing the application seeking discharge
had merged with the order directing framing of charges on 03.04.2018.
2.5.
The petitioner, without any legal basis, instituted another revision,
being Criminal Revision No. 165/2018, before the learned Special Judge
(PC Act), CBI-01, Saket Courts, New Delhi [‘Special Judge’], challenging
the initial order dated 14.03.2018. The petitioner, however, wilfully
suppressed the filing of earlier Revision Petition No. 102/2018 and the
dismissal order dated 01.05.2018, which led to upholding the order dated
03.04.2018.
By order dated 10.07.2018, the learned Special Judge dismissed
Criminal Revision No. 165/2018 with costs of Rs. 20,000/- after recording
that the petitioner had failed to disclose dismissal of the earlier revision
petition 102/2018. Although the Court noticed the suppression, it refrained
from initiating contempt proceedings and adopted a lenient approach, at the
request of the petitioner. The relevant paragraphs of the order dated
10.07.2018 read as under: “5……. The factum of the said order on charge having already been
challenged by filing of the revision petition and dismissal of the said
revision petition, having not been disclosed in the revision petition
filed before this court, per-se amounts to contempt, besides the fact
that filing of another revision petition against the same order is not
maintainable and challenge to framing of charge in isolation is not
permissible.
6. Though this court finds the submission obnoxious that merely the
framing of charge has been challenged without challenging the order
on charge in the instant revision petition, while it is noted that the
petition challenging the order on charge has already been dismissed,
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
however, this court is not inclined to proceed further with the
contempt application accepting the plea of counsel for petitioner to
take lenient view, but in these circumstances, revision petition stands
dismissed with cost of Rs. 20,000/-, half of which shall be deposited
in the Legal Aid.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
2.6.
Thereafter, learned ACMM vide order dated 19.12.2022 dismissed the
petitioner’s application seeking dropping of proceedings concerning the
complaint dated 06.09.2006 and clubbing the two incidents dated
03.09.2006 and 17.03.2007 under Section 219 of Cr.P.C.
The petitioner instituted yet another revision challenging the aforesaid
order dated 19.12.2022. The said revision being Criminal Revision No.
95/2023 was pursued by Ms. Kalpana being a counsel for the
revisionist/petitioner. The Revision Petition was dismissed on 18.03.2023 by
the learned Principal District & Sessions Judge, South District, Saket Courts,
who recorded that the petitioner had, in all, filed seven (7) revision petitions
in the same complaint case and held the proceedings to be an abuse of the
process of law. The relevant paragraph of the order dated 18.03.2023 reads
as under: “7 As noticed above, petitioner has already filed about 7 revision
petitions before Sessions court. Challenge to framing of charge has
already failed previously. Seeking the same relief by moving an
application for dropping of proceedings and carrying it further to the
revisional court is an absolute misuse of the process of law;
especially when the petitioner has stated in the revision petition itself
that this argument was also raised at the stage of challenge to framing
of charge.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
2.7.
Thereafter, the petitioner, undeterred, instituted a transfer petition
before the learned Principal District & Sessions Judge, South District, Saket
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
Courts, seeking transfer of the complaint case [‘C.C. 1440/2007’] from the
Court of the learned ACMM. The transfer petition was dismissed by the
learned District Judge vide order dated 27.07.2024.
The petitioner challenged the aforesaid order dated 27.07.2024 before
the High Court in Cr. M.C. 6487/2024 along with the filing advocate, Ms.
Kalpana. The High Court by its order dated 21.08.2024 dismissed the
petition and observed that the prayer seeking transfer was intended to
exercise undue pressure on the Judge hearing the criminal complaint. The
relevant paras of the order dated 21.08.2024 read as under: “8. A perusal of the abovementioned table shows that the Petitioner
has filed transfer petitions seeking transfer of cases from the Court of
five different judges. It cannot be said that every judge, against whom
transfer petitions were filed by the Petitioner, is biased against the
Petitioner.
…….
16. Mere perception of suspicion or apprehension of bias is not
sufficient to entertain a plea of transfer. A perusal of the grounds
raised by the Petitioner for transfer of the case or in the present
Petition, does not show that the Judge overseeing the proceedings was
biased in any manner against the Petitioner. This Court is of the
opinion that the present Petition is only a method to put pressure
on the Judge hearing the case of the Petitioner. This Court cannot
ignore the fact that Order transferring a case from one Court to
another or from one Judge to another casts an aspersion on the Judge
and on his/her reputation. Withdrawing cases from a Judge on mere
allegations of biasness without there being a reasonable belief will be
prejudicial to the independence of judiciary. Learned Principal District
and Sessions Judge is the best person to take a decision as to whether
the case should be transferred or not and after looking into the facts
and circumstances of the present case, the conduct of the Petitioner,
the allegations made by the Petitioner and the Order sheets of the
Magistrate Court, the learned Principal District and Sessions Judge
has come to the conclusion that the Magistrate is not acting in a biased
manner and the apprehension of biasness claimed by the Petitioner is
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
completely unwarranted.
17. In view of the above, this Court, while sitting in revisionary
jurisdiction, is not inclined to interfere with the decision taken by the
learned Principal District and Sessions Judge as nothing has been
brought out in the present Petition which would persuade this Court to
interfere with the Order passed by the learned Principal District and
Sessions Judge, which is a well-reasoned Order.
18. Accordingly, the Petition is dismissed, along with the pending
applications, if any.”
[Emphasis supplied]
2.8.
In the aforementioned background, of judicial orders recording
scathing remarks against the petitioner as regards his conduct of obstructing
the legal process, on 26.09.2024, notwithstanding the dismissal of the earlier
quashing petition CRL. M.C. No. 3870/2012 on 18.12.2012, the petitioner
instituted the present W.P. (CRL.) No. 3144/2024, once again seeking
quashing of the same criminal complaint and proceedings arising therefrom,
pending before the learned ACMM, New Delhi.
2.9.
The writ petition was drafted and filed by Ms. Kalpana, Advocate,
who had represented the petitioner in the defense of the criminal complaint
proceedings. She is his spouse as well as his SPA holder. Ms. Kalpana was
therefore completely aware about the history of the criminal complaint
proceedings. However, there was wilful suppression of CRL. M.C. No.
3870/2012 and the order of dismissal dated 18.12.2012. The prayers sought
in the present writ petition are as under: a) Call/ summon the trial Court record of case bearing CT
Case/463048/2016 titled as "Sonia Mendiratta Vs. Harjeet Singh
Mendiratta" from the court of Ms. Shilpi Singh, JMFC-02, South,
Saket Court, for examination in relation to the ongoing proceedings.
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
b) Quash the criminal proceedings from Ct. Case 463048/2016 titled
as "Sonia Mendiratta Vs. Harjeet Singh Mendiratta" arising from the
complaints dated 06.09.2006 & 21.03.2007, pending before the court
of Ms. Shilpi Singh, Ld. JMFC-02, South, Saket Court. As the said
complaints have already been destroyed and never examined in court,
should not form the basis of further prosecution against the Petitioner.
Any other relief(s)/order(s)/direction(s) in favour of petitioner as
this Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper in the interest of justice.
c)
[Emphasis supplied]
2.10. Respondent no. 2 entered appearance in these proceedings on 20.10.2024
and filed its reply. Respondent no. 2 took an objection as regards suppression of
the filing of earlier CRL. M.C. No. 3870/2012, the order of dismissal dated
18.12.2012 as well as order dated 10.07.2018 passed by learned Special
Judge dismissing the revision petition. Respondent no. 2 also filed CRL.
M.A. 34529/2024, on 16.11.2024, against the petitioner for the act of
perjury. Respondent also filed its reply to the petition on 16.11.2024.
2.11. Petitioner on 16.11.2024, e-filed additional documents vide diary no.
5277059 and included orders dated 08.12.2012 and 10.07.2018. The proof of
service of the documents on the respondent no. 2 is of 16.11.2024, however,
inexplicably the index bears the date of 12.11.2024. In the considered
opinion of the Court the date of 12.11.2024 on the index has been put
mischievously to antedate the filing.
2.12. The petitioner was undeterred by the submissions of the respondent
no. 2 evidencing the wilful suppression by the petitioner of the earlier
petition. Petitioner instead of conceding to the suppression, continued to
prosecute the present writ petition. In fact, petitioner filed a counter-blast
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
perjury application being no. Crl. M.A. No. 34579/2024 seeking initiation of
perjury proceedings against respondent no. 2 and her counsel.
This action of the petitioner and its filing counsel Ms. Kalpana, who is
the wife of the petitioner, evidences the wilful suppression, lack of contrition
and bullying of the respondent no. 2.
2.13. During the hearing held on 06.03.2025, learned counsel appearing for
respondent no. 2 reiterated that paragraph 46 of the writ petition contained a
false declaration that no earlier proceedings seeking the same relief had been
filed. Paragraph 46 reads as under: “46. That the Petitioner has not filed any other similar petition
seeking quashing of criminal proceedings arises from the
complaints in question either before this Hon'ble Court or before the
Hon'ble Supreme Court of India.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
It was brought to the notice of the Court that the petitioner had earlier
instituted CRL.M.C. No. 3870/2012 before this Court seeking identical
reliefs, which had been dismissed on 18.12.2012. It was submitted that the
non-disclosure of the earlier quashing petition and its dismissal constituted a
deliberate suppression of material facts.
2.14. It was contended that the false declaration contained in paragraph 46
of the underlying petition had been made despite filing advocate, Ms.
Kalpana possessing complete personal knowledge of the earlier litigation as
she is not only the petitioner’s counsel but is also his spouse and SPA
holder. It was stated that she had been representing the petitioner in the
complaint proceedings and was personally aware about the history.
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
2.15. It was further brought to the notice of the Court that adverse
observations regarding the conduct of filing advocate, Ms. Kalpana had
already been recorded by the learned Special Judge in orders dated
28.05.2018 and 10.07.2018 passed in Crl. Rev. Petition No. 165/2018. The
relevant portion of the order dated 28.05.2018 reads as under:
“Present:
Counsel Sh. Satya Prakash Yadav and Ms. Kalpna for
petitioner.
Counsel Sh. J. P. Singh for respondent.
Fresh vakalatnama filed on behalf of respondent.
Counsel for respondent was present at first call when the reply
and contempt application were filed on record. It was submitted that
the petitioner has approached this court against the framing of charge
whereas order on charge had already been challenged by the petitioner
and revision petition had already been dismissed which fact has not
been mentioned in the present revision petition. Ld. Counsel for
petitioner, who has appeared now, seeks time to address the arguments
on the point of maintainability of present revision petition as well
respond to the contempt application filed by the respondent. Counsel
for respondent, as stated, has suddenly fallen ill, therefore, is not
present now. Copy of paper book filed by the respondent be placed on
record during the course of the day to be collected by the petitioner.
Be put up on 10.7.2018.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
2.16. As already noted above, ultimately on 10.07.2018 the learned Special
Judge dismissed the aforesaid writ petition with costs Rs 20,000/-, with the
observation that petitioner appearing through the advocate, Ms. Kalpana was
guilty of suppressing relevant earlier proceedings.
3.
This Court, by order dated 06.03.2025, recorded a prima facie opinion
that the subject writ petition had been drafted by the filing advocate, Ms.
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
Kalpana after deliberately withholding material facts from the Court.
Consequently, this Court issued a show cause notice to Ms. Kalpana
requiring her to explain why proceedings should not be initiated against her
under the Act of 1971, issued notice to the BCD and the President of the
Delhi High Court Bar Association, appointed Ms. Chand Chopra, Advocate,
as Amicus Curiae to assist the Court regarding the nature of proceedings
liable to be initiated against Ms. Kalpana, and also called upon Ms. Kalpana
to file her response to the show cause notice. The relevant portion of the
order dated 06.03.2025 read as under: “4. He states that the present quashing petition has been filed by the
same Advocate Ms. Kalpana. He states that at paragraph 46 of the
petition, the Petitioner, along with the counsel, Ms. Kalpana, who
personally possesses knowledge of the litigation, has made a false
declaration qua non-filing of prior proceedings on the same cause of
action and for the same relief. He states that for the identical reliefs
sought herein, the Petitioner, represented by the same counsel Ms.
Kalpana, had previously filed CRL.MC 3870/2012, titled S. Harjeet
Singh Mendiratta v. State and Others, before this Hon'ble Court,
which was ultimately dismissed by an order dated 18.12.2012. He
states that non-disclosure of the said previous proceedings and the
order on dismissal on merits is a fraudulent conduct by the Advocate
and the Petitioner.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
4.
Pursuant thereto, Ms. Kalpana filed a reply dated 15.04.2025. When
the matter was taken up on 30.04.2025, this Court noticed that the reply had
not been supported by an affidavit and directed that an affidavit be filed.
Also, the report submitted by the learned Amicus Curiae dated 03.04.2025
was simultaneously taken on record, and the matter was thereafter heard
extensively on the issue of contempt.
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
4.1.
In her report, the learned Amicus Curiae concluded that Ms. Kalpana
had appeared throughout the litigation in a dual capacity, namely as the
petitioner’s advocate and his SPA holder, while also being his spouse.
Consequently, she possessed direct and personal knowledge of the dismissal
of CRL.M.C. No. 3870/2012. The Amicus opined that the declaration made
in paragraph 46 of the underlying writ petition was demonstrably false, that
no satisfactory explanation had been furnished for the suppression, and that
the conduct disclosed on record warranted consideration not only under the
Act of 1971, but also under the disciplinary jurisdiction of the BCD under
the Advocates Act and the Bar Council of India Rules.
4.2.
The learned Amicus Curiae submitted that in the reply filed by Ms.
Kalpana there was no explanation whatsoever for suppression of the earlier
quashing proceedings despite Ms. Kalpana’s undisputed personal knowledge
thereof. She submitted that there was no apology tendered by Ms. Kalpana
in her reply.
4.3.
The learned Amicus Curiae, therefore, suggested that should this
Court find the explanation tendered by Ms. Kalpana to be unsatisfactory, it
may consider the statutory remedies available in law, including proceedings
contemplated under the Act of 1971, reference to the BCD under Section 35
of the Advocates Act, 1961, prosecution under Section 217 of the Bharatiya
Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, and the imposition of exemplary costs. These
recommendations are founded upon the statutory framework and judicial
precedents discussed in the report.
5.
During the subsequent hearings, respondent no. 2 also placed before
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
this Court, details of numerous proceedings instituted by the petitioner and
Ms. Kalpana against advocates representing respondent no. 2, Judicial
Officers, and witnesses connected with the litigation. By order dated
06.12.2025, this Court recorded that the material placed before it disclosed a
discernible pattern of filing proceedings intentionally against advocates and
other participants in the judicial process, apparently with a view to
discourage them from discharging their professional duties.
6.
By a detailed order dated 20.12.2025, this Court further recorded that
the petitioner had admittedly failed to disclose the earlier quashing petition.
The Court also took note of observations made by a Co-ordinate Bench in
CRL.M.C. 6487/2024, filed by the petitioner, that the petitioner had
repeatedly filed transfer petitions against different judicial officers, which
appeared to be an attempt to exert pressure upon the judiciary. Upon
considering the cumulative record, this Court observed that the conduct of
the petitioner and Ms. Kalpana disclosed a glaring pattern of resorting to
unfair practices in judicial proceedings. Pending consideration of the show
cause notice, Ms. Kalpana was cautioned against acting or filing pleadings
on behalf of the petitioner as his Advocate, after observing that her personal
interest in the litigation had resulted in interference with the administration
of justice and fomenting of litigation. The relevant paragraphs of the order
dated 20.12.2025 reads as under: “……..
12. Learned counsel for the petitioner concedes that the order
dated 18.12.2012 passed in CRL.M.C. No. 3870/2012 was not
disclosed in the petition. She states that this was an error and
seeks to tenders an apology on behalf of the petitioner.
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
13. This Court will on the next date of hearing will examine the issue
of making a reference to Bar Council of Delhi as well as the issue of
nature of contempt.
14. This Court however takes note of the observations made by the
Co-ordinate Bench in CRL.M.C. 6487/2024 filed by this petitioner
along with Ms. Kalpana Advocate impugning an order passed by the
District Judge dismissing an application seeking transfer of its case.
The observations at paragraph 8, 16 to 18 are relevant.:
“8. A perusal of the abovementioned table shows that the
Petitioner has filed transfer petitions seeking transfer of cases
from the Court of five different judges. It cannot be said that
every judge, against whom transfer petitions were filed by the
Petitioner, is biased against the Petitioner.
…….
16. Mere perception of suspicion or apprehension of bias is
not sufficient to entertain a plea of transfer. A perusal of the
grounds raised by the Petitioner for transfer of the case or in
the present Petition, does not show that the Judge overseeing
the proceedings was biased in any manner against the
Petitioner. This Court is of the opinion that the present
Petition is only a method to put pressure on the Judge
hearing the case of the Petitioner. This Court cannot ignore
the fact that Order transferring a case from one Court to
another or from one Judge to another casts an aspersion on the
Judge and on his/her reputation. Withdrawing cases from a
Judge on mere allegations of biasness without there being a
reasonable belief will be prejudicial to the independence of
judiciary. Learned Principal District and Sessions Judge is the
best person to take a decision as to whether the case should be
transferred or not and after looking into the facts and
circumstances of the present case, the conduct of the
Petitioner, the allegations made by the Petitioner and the
Order sheets of the Magistrate Court, the learned Principal
District and Sessions Judge has come to the conclusion that
the Magistrate is not acting in a biased manner and the
apprehension of biasness claimed by the Petitioner is
completely unwarranted.
17. In view of the above, this Court, while sitting in
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
revisionary jurisdiction, is not inclined to interfere with the
decision taken by the learned Principal District and Sessions
Judge as nothing has been brought out in the present Petition
which would persuade this Court to interfere with the Order
passed by the learned Principal District and Sessions Judge,
which is a well-reasoned Order.
18. Accordingly, the Petition is dismissed, along with the
pending applications, if any.”
(Emphasis supplied)
15. The aforesaid order of the Co-ordinate Bench records that
petitioner along with Ms. Kalpana, Advocate has filed five (5) transfer
petitions, which were all dismissed.
16. This Court in its order dated 06.03.2025 has already noted that
even while filing this petition, petitioner and Ms. Kalpana, Advocate
made a false non-filing declaration at paragraph ‘46’.
17. These facts bring out a glaring pattern of the conduct of the
petitioner and his wife Ms. Kalpana, who acts as his Advocate in
this litigation that they have been casually restoring to unfair
practices. Further action on the show cause notice dated 06.03.2025
and reference to Bar Council on the next date, Ms. Kalpana, Advocate
is put to notice on the said issue as well.
18. In the meantime, having regard to the aforesaid Rules of Bar
council of India, Ms. Kalpana is cautioned against undertaking
any filing of petitions/pleadings or making any representation on
behalf of the petitioner before any Court as an advocate. This
Court further notes that Ms. Kalpana being the wife of the
petitioner is directly interested in the outcome of the litigation
pending between the petitioner and respondent no. 2, which as is
evident from the facts of this case has resulted in interference with
the administration of justice and has fomenting litigation.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
7.
On 15.05.2026, arguments on the show cause notice were concluded.
Ms. Kalpana, represented through her counsel, Ms. Kajal Chandra stated
that there had been an inadvertent error in not making a disclosure of
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
CRL.M.C. No. 3870/2012 and the dismissal order dated 18.12.2012. She
offered a verbal apology on behalf of Ms. Kalpana. She, however, stated on
instructions that Ms. Kalpana is unwilling to file a written unconditional
apology and pay costs to purge the contempt.
II.
REPLY FILED BY MS. KALPANA TO THE SHOW CAUSE NOTICE
8.
In response to the show cause notice dated 06.03.2025, Ms. Kalpana
submitted that the allegations levelled against her were misconceived and
sought discharge of the notice. At the outset, she stated that any omission in
the writ petition was wholly inadvertent and attributable to lapse of memory,
as the earlier quashing petition, CRL.M.C. No. 3870/2012, had been filed
nearly twelve years prior. According to her, there was no deliberate
suppression of facts or intention to mislead the Court. She further alleged
that the Court had been misled by the submissions of respondent no. 2’s
counsel, whom she accused of acting out of personal vendetta against herself
and her husband.
8.1.
Ms. Kalpana also contended that the present writ petition was
fundamentally distinct from the earlier quashing petition. She submitted that
CRL.M.C. No. 3870/2012 sought quashing of the summoning order dated
08.06.2007 and the complaint itself, whereas the present writ petition sought
quashing of the continuing criminal proceedings on the ground that the
original complaints had allegedly been destroyed and were never exhibited
before the Trial Court. She asserted that the reliefs, factual foundations,
nomenclature and circumstances in the two proceedings were materially
different, and therefore the present petition could not be regarded as a
repetition of the earlier proceedings.
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
8.2.
She also asserted that the orders dated 18.12.2012 (dismissing the
earlier quashing petition) and 10.07.2018 had already been placed before the
Court by way of additional documents e-filed on 16.11.2024 under Diary
No. 5277059/2024 as well as through Crl. M.A. No. 34579/2024 under
Section 340 CrPC. According to her, since these orders already formed part
of the judicial record, the allegation of deliberate suppression was
unfounded.
8.3.
Ms. Kalpana also disputed the reliance placed upon the orders dated
28.05.2018 and 10.07.2018 passed by Court of the Special Judge in Crl.
Rev. Petition No. 165/2018. She contended that those orders did not contain
any adverse findings against her personally. She submitted that the counsel
appearing for the petitioner in the proceedings culminating in the order dated
10.07.2018 was Mr. Satya Prakash Yadav, Advocate, and that the
observations recorded therein were not directed against her. Likewise, she
asserted that although her name appeared in the order dated 28.05.2018, no
adverse observations had been recorded against her conduct. She further
stated that she had been in legal practice since the year 2010 and had
maintained an unblemished professional record.
8.4.
In answer to the allegation of deliberate suppression, Ms. Kalpana
questioned the very motive attributed to her, contending that there was no
conceivable advantage in concealing the earlier proceedings, particularly
when the respondent was fully aware of the litigation history and would
inevitably bring the same to the notice of the Court. She maintained that the
omission, if any, could not be construed as wilful or intentional.
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
8.5.
A substantial portion of the reply was devoted to alleging personal
bias and professional misconduct on the part of Mr. Joginder Pal Singh,
Advocate, appearing for respondent no. 2. Ms. Kalpana alleged that he had
instigated the present contempt proceedings to settle personal scores and to
divert attention from complaints and criminal proceedings allegedly pending
against him. In support of these allegations, she furnished an extensive list
of litigation involving Mr. Joginder Pal Singh before the Supreme Court, the
BCD, the Bar Council of India, various criminal courts and the Delhi High
Court, contending that he had himself faced allegations of professional
misconduct, forgery, cheating and unethical conduct in several matters.
III.
FINDINGS AND ANALYSIS
9.
Upon hearing all parties, this Court reserved judgment on the show
cause notice issued to Ms. Kalpana and on the question whether proceedings
under the Act of 1971, and disciplinary proceedings before the BCD ought
to follow.
10.
As noted above, it was brought to the notice of this Court that the
petitioner, represented by Ms. Kalpana, Advocate, had earlier filed
CRL.M.C. No. 3870/2012 seeking quashing of the same criminal complaint,
which was dismissed on 18.12.2012, but the said fact was not disclosed in
the present petition. It was stated that the declaration of non-filing at
paragraph 46 of the subject writ petition was therefore false. Taking note of
the alleged suppression of material facts, this Court, by order dated
06.03.2025, issued a show cause notice to Ms. Kalpana to explain why
proceedings under the Act of 1971 and reference to BCD for initiation of
disciplinary proceedings should not be made. The Court appointed an
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
Amicus Curiae to examine the record and assist the Court. In response, Ms.
Kalpana denied any deliberate suppression, attributing the omission to
inadvertence, also contending that the earlier and present petitions were
distinct in nature and reliefs sought, and asserted that the earlier proceedings
had been subsequently brought on record.
11.
It is pertinent to note that at the first hearing of the CRL.M.C. No.
3870/2012, the High Court had recorded that there was delay and laches on
behalf of the petitioner in approaching the Court. The relevant order dated
07.11.2012 read as under:
“1. This is a petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C. by virtue of which the
petitioner is seeking quashing of a complaint in complaint case
bearing No.1440/1/2007 titled Ms. Sonia Mendiratta Vs. Harjeet
Singh Mendiratta initiated by the respondent no.2, who happens to be
the sister of the petitioner on the ground that the dispute between the
parties is essentially civil in nature.
2. On enquiry, the petitioner has pointed out that though the complaint
was filed in the year 2007 and the petitioner had put in appearance
before the Court for the first time on or about 8.6.07, however, the
petition is being filed now when the counsel was engaged, there is
inordinate delay and laches in approaching the Court for quashing.
3. The learned counsel for the petitioner seeks time to satisfy this
Court that the delay and laches are not a ground for not entertaining
the petition.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
Thereafter, the High Court vide order dated 18.12.2012 dismissed the
petition and the said order reads as under:
“This is a petition filed under Section 482 Cr.P.C. for quashing of the
summoning order dated 8.6.2007 as well as for quashing of the
criminal complaint titled Sonia Mendiratta vs. Harjeet Singh
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
Mendiratta bearing No. 1440/1/2007 pending before the Metropolitan
Magistrate, Saket Courts, for an offence under Sections
323/341/451/506/509 IPC.
The ground for quashing which has been set up by the learned counsel
is that the dispute between the petitioner and the respondent No.2 is
essentially a civil dispute in respect of the property purported to have
been left by their deceased mother. The learned counsel was granted
time to satisfy this court as to why there was a delay in approaching
this court for quashing of the summoning order dated 8.6.2007 as well
as the complaint. The learned counsel has not been able to give any
cogent explanation for the same.
The order of summoning is an order against which revision would lie.
Since the revision itself has to be filed within a period of 90 days,
which period has already expired long back, the petitioner under the
garb of the present petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C., cannot be
permitted to assail the order of summoning.
So far as the quashing of the complaint is concerned, the ground
which has been set up, is that the dispute between the petitioner and
the respondent No.2 is essentially a civil dispute. With regard to the
filing of the petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C., this court has already
held in Criminal M.C. No.1656/2011, titled Rajesh Chetwal Vs. State
that although no period of limitation is prescribed for invoking the
jurisdiction of this court under Section 482 Cr.P.C. but it must be
invoked within a reasonable time. The reasonable time though has not
been prescribed but obviously the delay of more than five years as in
the instant case, for which no explanation has been furnished, can
hardly be considered to be reasonable. On the contrary, the learned
counsel for the petitioner has drawn the attention of the court to the
list of dates in the case, detailed at page No. 115, wherein it is clearly
reflected that the trial court has already recorded some part of the precharge evidence.
That being the position, I feel that this petition is hit by inordinate
delay and latches in approaching the court only with regard to
foreclose the learned trial court to decide the question of the guilt of
the petitioner on merits. I feel that the petition is totally
misconceived, hit by delay and latches and deserve to be
dismissed.
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
The petition is accordingly dismissed.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
12.
In view of the filing of Crl. M.C. No. 3870/2012 and the order and
order of dismissal dated 18.12.2012, the present writ petition could not have
been filed and maintained by the petitioner. The petitioner therefore wilfully
suppressed this fact and filed a false declaration at paragraph 46 of the writ
petition. The relevant paragraph 46 reads as under:
“46. That the Petitioner has not filed any other similar petition
seeking quashing of criminal proceedings arises from the
complaints in question either before this Hon'ble Court or before the
Hon'ble Supreme Court of India.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
13.
The explanation tendered by Ms. Kalpana for the non-disclosure has
to be examined in light of the obligations cast upon an advocate appearing
before a Constitutional Court. An advocate occupies a dual position. While
representing the interests of the client fearlessly, an advocate simultaneously
functions as an officer of the Court and is under an equally compelling
obligation to assist the Court by making a full, fair and accurate disclosure
of all fact material to the adjudication of the lis.
14.
It would be relevant to refer to the statutory framework governing
professional conduct of advocates. Section 49(1)(c) of the Advocates Act,
1961, wherein in accordance with the powers vested on Bar Council of India
to make Rules, it has framed ‘Standards of Professional Conduct and
Etiquette’ under Bar Council of India Rules [‘BCI Rules’] at Chapter II of
Part VI, which emphasise that an advocate shall not employ improper means
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
to influence judicial proceedings, shall exercise independent professional
judgment, shall prevent the client from adopting unfair practices, and shall
refrain from fomenting litigation. Departure from these standards constitutes
professional misconduct attracting the disciplinary jurisdiction of the Bar
Council under Section 35 of the Advocates Act, 1961. The relevant BCI
Rules read as under: “3. An advocate shall not influence the decision of a court by any
illegal or improper means. Private communications with a judge
relating to a pending case are forbidden.
4. An advocate shall use his best efforts to restrain and prevent his
client from resorting to sharp or unfair practices or from doing
anything in relation to the court, opposing Counsel or parties which
the advocates himself ought not to do. An advocate shall refuse to
represent the client who persists in such improper conduct. He shall
not consider himself a mere mouth-piece of the client, and shall
exercise his own judgment in the use of restrained language in
correspondence, avoiding scurrilous attacks in pleadings, and using
intemperate language during arguments in court.
……
9. An Advocate should not act or plead in any matter in which he is
himself pecuniarily interested.
Illustration:
I. He should not act in a bankruptcy petition when he himself
is
also a creditor of the bankrupt.
II. He should not accept a brief from a company of which he is a
director.
.…..
13. An advocate should not accept a brief or appear in a case in which
he has reason to believe that he will be a witness, and if being engaged
in a case, it becomes apparent that he is a witness on a material
question of fact, he should not continue to appear as an Advocate if he
can retire without jeopardising his client's interests.
………
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
15. It shall be the duty of an advocate fearlessly to uphold the interests
of his client by all fair and honourable means without regard to any
unpleasant consequences to himself or any other. He shall defend a
person accused of a crime regardless of his personal opinion as to the
guilt of the accused, bearing in mind that his loyalty is to the law
which requires that no man should be convicted without adequate
evidence.
…….
18. An advocate shall not, at any time, be a party to fomenting of
litigation.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
15.
Section 2(c) of the Act of 1971, which define criminal contempt to
include acts which prejudice or interfere with the due course of judicial
proceedings or obstruct the administration of justice. In this Court’s opinion,
where pleadings are drafted, by the filing advocate, with deliberate
suppression of material judicial proceedings known to the advocate, such
conduct may have the tendency to interfere with the proper administration of
justice by preventing the Court from considering the matter in its correct
factual and procedural perspective.
16.
The legal principles governing the duties of advocates have repeatedly
been emphasised by the Supreme Court. In Pandurang Dattatraya
Khandekar v. Bar Council of Maharashtra1, the Supreme Court observed
that it is professionally improper for an advocate to prepare pleadings
knowing the allegations contained therein to be untrue and that conduct
diminishing public confidence in the legal profession may amount to
professional misconduct. The relevant paragraph reads as under: -
(1984) 2 SCC 556, at paragraph no. 10.
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
“10. Nothing should be done by any member of the legal fraternity
which might tend to lessen in any degree the confidence of the public
in the fidelity, honesty and integrity of the profession. For an advocate
to act towards his client otherwise than with utmost good faith is
unprofessional. It is against professional etiquette for a lawyer to give
improper legal advice with an ulterior object. It is unworthy that an
advocate should accept employment with such motive, or so long as
his client has such understanding of his purpose. It is professionally
improper for a member of the bar to prepare false documents or
to draw pleadings knowingly that the allegations made are untrue
to his knowledge. Thus, the giving of improper legal advice may
amount to professional misconduct. That however may not be so by
the giving of wrong legal advice.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
Similarly, in Saumya Chaurasia v. Enforcement Directorate2, the
Supreme Court reiterated that every advocate, being an officer of the Court,
is expected to diligently verify material facts and fairly assist the Court in
the administration of justice. The relevant paragraph read as under: “14. It cannot be gainsaid that every party approaching the court
seeking justice is expected to make full and correct disclosure of
material facts and that every advocate being an officer of the court,
though appearing for a particular party, is expected to assist the court
fairly in carrying out its function to administer the justice. It hardly
needs to be emphasized that a very high standard of professionalism
and legal acumen is expected from the advocates particularly
designated Senior advocates appearing in the highest court of the
country so that their professionalism may be followed and emulated
by the advocates practicing in the High Courts and the District Courts.
Though it is true that the advocates would settle the pleadings and
argue in the courts on instructions given by their clients, however
their duty to diligently verify the facts from the record of the case,
using their legal acumen for which they are engaged, cannot be
obliviated.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
(2024) 6 SCC 401, at paragraph no. 14.
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
The recent decision of the Supreme Court in Jitender @ Kalla v. State
of GNCTD & Ors., SLP (Crl.) 4299/2024, while dealing with the conduct
expected from an Advocate on Record, is also relevant as it would directly
apply to the filing advocate, Ms. Kalpana, the relevant extract at paragraph
44(i) reads as under:
“44(i)…... Therefore, when incorrect facts are stated in the
petition/appeal/counter affidavit or when material facts or documents
are suppressed, the advocate-on record cannot shift the entire blame
on either the client or his instructing advocates. Therefore, it is his
duty to be cautious and careful. His duty is to file proper
proceedings and affidavits before this Court to assist the court in
dispensing justice. He must always be fair to the Court and
effectively assist the Court in deciding cases. The duty of the
advocate-on-record does not end after filing a case or a counter...”
[Emphasis Supplied]
17.
The issue before this Court is not merely whether the petitioner
possessed a legal right or an independent cause of action for maintaining the
present writ petition. Equally important is whether there existed a duty to
candidly disclose the complete history of prior litigation concerning the
same criminal proceedings so as to enable this Court to evaluate the
maintainability and merits of the petition with the benefit of the entire
factual background. The obligation of disclosure is foundational to the
exercise of writ jurisdiction, where relief is discretionary and premised upon
utmost good faith by the litigant and counsel alike. This obligation is equally
upon the filing advocate who has knowledge of the litigation.
18.
The subsequent production of documents on 16.11.2024 after the
issue was brought to the notice of the Court by respondent no. 2 does not, by
itself, answer the concern which prompted the issuance of the show cause
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
notice on 06.03.2025. The relevant question is whether the material facts
were fairly disclosed at the time the extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court
was invoked and whether the pleadings, as originally presented, accurately
reflected the earlier judicial proceedings. Similarly, the plea that the earlier
petition of the year 2012 was drafted by another advocate does not, by itself,
resolve the issue, particularly when Ms. Kalpana has acknowledged her
close involvement in the litigation, both as the petitioner's spouse, his SPA
and as the advocate handling the present proceedings.
19.
Having perused the entire record, this Court is of the considered
opinion that the conduct of filing advocate, Ms. Kalpana cannot be viewed
as a mere error or an inadvertent omission. Ms. Kalpana is the spouse of the
petitioner and his SPA holder. The declaration contained in paragraph 46 of
the present writ petition, asserting that no earlier proceedings seeking
identical relief had been filed, was therefore made despite her direct and
personal knowledge to the contrary. Such a false declaration strikes at the
foundation of the administration of justice, as the Court proceeds on the
basis that the statements made in pleadings, particularly mandatory
declarations, are true, accurate and complete. The pleadings are
accompanied by affidavits.
20.
The bald explanation offered by Ms. Kalpana does not inspire
confidence. In fact, it shows lack of candour. Although, learned counsel, Ms.
Kajal Chandra, tendered an oral apology on behalf of Ms. Kalpana before
the Court, as recorded in the order dated 20.12.2025, she expressly declined
to tender a written apology. No unconditional apology was ever tendered by
Ms. Kalpana. Despite sufficient opportunity, she neither accepted
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
responsibility for the false declaration nor expressed any remorse. On the
contrary, in her reply to the show cause notice, she sought discharge on
merits and attempted to justify the conduct in question. In these
circumstances, this Court finds no expression of genuine contrition or
acceptance of responsibility that would warrant taking a lenient view for Ms.
Kalpana. In fact, this Court gets a distinct impression that Ms. Kalpana even
now does not accept the responsibility for the misconduct and does not even
realise that it is her obligation as an advocate to make full disclosure. In fact,
this Court finds from the demeanour of Ms. Kalpana that she has little or no
regard for her conduct of wilful suppression and interference with
administration of justice. This Court is of the considered view that Ms.
Kalpana fails to realise her obligation towards her duty as an officer of the
Court and the duty to make a fair disclosure.
21.
This Court also cannot ignore the broader factual matrix emerging
from the record. The material placed before this Court, including the
tabulated statement of proceedings furnished by learned counsel for
respondent no. 2 detailing the multiple proceedings instituted by the
petitioner and Ms. Kalpana against advocates representing respondent no. 2,
Judicial Officers and witnesses connected with the litigation; (i) the
observations recorded by the learned Special Judge in Criminal Revision
No. 165/2018 by order dated 10.07.2018 noticing suppression of the
dismissal of the earlier revision petition and dismissing the revision with
costs; (ii) the findings of the learned Principal District & Sessions Judge,
South District, Saket Courts, in Criminal Revision No. 95/2023 by order
dated 18.03.2023 recording that the petitioner had instituted as many as
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
seven (7) revision petitions in the same complaint case and holding such
conduct to be an abuse of the process of law; (iii) the order dated 27.07.2024
dismissing the petitioner’s transfer petition and; (iv) the observations of the
Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in CRL.M.C. 6487/2024, which noticed
that the petitioner had repeatedly instituted transfer petitions against
different judicial officers without any reasonable basis and observed that
such petitions appeared to be a method of exerting pressure upon the
judiciary; collectively disclose a consistent pattern whereby the petitioner,
assisted by Ms. Kalpana, has repeatedly instituted proceedings against
advocates representing respondent no. 2, judicial officers and witnesses
connected with the litigation, with an intent to obstruct the legal
proceedings. The present false declaration is therefore not an isolated
incident but forms part of a continuing course of conduct by the petitioner
and the filing advocate, Ms. Kalpana which tends to obstruct and interfere
with the due administration of justice.
22.
Equally significant is the dual role assumed by Ms. Kalpana
throughout the litigation. She has simultaneously acted as the petitioner’s
advocate, his SPA holder and, being his spouse, possesses a direct personal
interest in the outcome of the dispute. The record demonstrates that this dual
role has blurred the distinction between an advocate’s professional
obligations and her personal interest in the litigation. An advocate is under a
duty not merely to advance the cause of a client but also to act as an officer
of the Court, to ensure fairness in judicial proceedings, to prevent resort to
unfair practices and to refrain from fuelling litigation.
23.
The conduct noticed in the present case is wholly inconsistent with
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
these obligations and prima facie discloses violations of standards of
professional conduct expected of an advocate and embodied in Part VI,
Chapter II of the Bar Council of India Rules, 1975, particularly Rule 5
which obligates an advocate to prevent unfair practices, exercise
independent professional judgment and refrain from making improper
pleadings, as well as Rules 6 and 7, which require an advocate to act only by
fair and honourable means and prohibit fomenting of litigation. Such
conduct may attract disciplinary action under Section 35 of the Advocates
Act, 1961.
24.
In the opinion of this Court, the acts attributed to Ms. Kalpana are not
confined to professional misconduct alone. Deliberately filing a petition
containing a false non-filing declaration with knowledge of the earlier
proceedings, thereby attempting to invoke the jurisdiction of this Court on a
fundamentally misleading premise, constitutes conduct having a direct
tendency to interfere with and obstruct the due course of judicial
proceedings and the administration of justice. Such conduct squarely falls
for consideration within the ambit of criminal contempt under Section 2(c)
of the Act of 1971.
25.
Since criminal contempt, other than contempt in the face of the Court,
is required to be dealt with by the Division Bench in accordance with the
Act of 1971 and Contempt of Courts (Delhi High Court) Rules, 2025
governing contempt jurisdiction, and is required to be tried as such.
Accordingly, this Court considers it appropriate to direct the registry to
place the matter before Hon’ble the Chief Justice for appropriate orders, to
place the matter before the concerned Division Bench.
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
26.
Simultaneously, the material on record discloses a strong case
warranting examination by the disciplinary authority under the Advocates
Act, 1961. Whether the conduct of Ms. Kalpana amounts to professional
misconduct in violation of the Bar Council of India Rules, 1975 is a matter
falling within the statutory jurisdiction of the BCD. The disciplinary process
under the Advocates Act, 1961 operates in a distinct field and is independent
of proceedings under the Act of 1971. Consequently, a reference to the BCD
is both necessary and appropriate.
27.
Further, this Court is satisfied that permitting Ms. Kalpana to continue
representing the petitioner in these proceedings or in any proceedings arising
out of Complaint Case No. 463048/2016, or any other legal proceedings
between the parties herein, would seriously undermine the fairness of the
judicial process. Having regard to her admitted personal involvement, her
status as the petitioner’s spouse and SPA holder, the repeated findings
recorded by various Courts regarding the vexatious conduct of the litigation,
and the findings recorded herein, it is imperative to ensure that the inter-se
proceedings are insulated from any further interference. Accordingly, in
order to protect the purity of judicial proceedings, Ms. Kalpana is restrained
from acting, appearing, filing pleadings or otherwise representing the
petitioner as an advocate in the present proceedings or in any proceedings
arising out of or connected with Complaint Case No. 463048/2016, leaving
it open to the petitioner to engage any other Advocate of his choice.
28.
In view of the foregoing discussion, the following directions are
issued:
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
28.1 The Registry is directed to forward, within two weeks, a copy of this
judgment along with the complete record of the present proceedings to the
BCD for consideration of initiation of disciplinary proceedings against Ms.
Kalpana, Advocate, under Section 35 of the Advocates Act, 1961.
28.2 The Registry is further directed to register a suo moto criminal
contempt proceeding and place the present matter, together with this
judgment and the relevant record, before Hon’ble the Chief Justice for
obtaining appropriate orders for placing the matter before the appropriate
Division Bench, on 01.09.2026.
This judgment is pronounced in the open Court and hence the
petitioner is aware of this direction for appearing on 01.09.2026.
28.3 Till the conclusion of the aforesaid proceedings and subject to any
orders that may be passed by the competent forum, Ms. Kalpana, Advocate,
shall not act, appear, file pleadings, sign Vakalatnama or otherwise represent
the petitioner in any proceedings arising out of or connected with the
petitioner herein, in her professional capacity as an Advocate. The petitioner
shall, however, remain at liberty to engage any other Advocate of his choice.
29.
This Court will now deal with the writ petition. The petitioner
instituted the present writ petition with material facts having been
suppressed and thereby abused the process of this Court. The subsequent
dismissal of the impugned complaint, rendering the writ petition infructuous,
cannot have the effect of effacing or overlooking such conduct. The
invocation of the jurisdiction of this Court by withholding material facts is a
serious matter and cannot be permitted to be swept under the carpet merely
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
because the substantive proceedings have subsequently become infructuous.
Such conduct warrants appropriate costs. Accordingly, the petitioner is
imposed with costs of Rs. 1 lakh to be paid to Delhi High Court Bar Clerk’s
Association3 and Rs. 1 lakh to be paid to Shaurya Foundation Trust4 within a
period of two (2) weeks from the date of this judgment.
30.
With the aforesaid observations and directions, the writ petition stands
dismissed.
31.
Pending applications, if any, stands disposed of.
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J
AUGUST 14, 2026/rhc/AM/IB
A/c No. 15530100006282
C/A 15530210000793 UCO BANK, Delhi High Court
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
19:02
W.P.(CRL) 3144/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review