Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
107 (02 cases)
CRM-M-68811
68811-2025(O&M)
CRM-M-74041
74041-2025 (O&M)
Date of decision: 12.03.2026
1.
CRM-M--68811-2025 (O&M)
Harinder Singh Sodhi
...Petitioner
VERSUS
State of Haryana
2.
...Respondent
CRM-M--74041-2025 (O&M)
Ishminder Singh Sodhi
...Petitioner
VERSUS
State of Haryana
...Respondent
CORAM : HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VINOD S. BHARDWAJ
Present :-
Mr. Puneet Sharma, Advocate for the petitioner
petitioner(s)
in both the petitions.
petitions
Ms. Chhavi Sharma, Asst.
As t. AG, Haryana with
ASI Ravi, No.147/SPT.
No.147/SPT
Mr. Sumeet Jain, Advocate for the complainant.
*****
BHARDWAJ J. (Oral)
VINOD S. BHARDWAJ,
Both these petitions, seeking anticipatory bail in case bearing
FIR No.0263 dated 31.08.2025 registered under Section
Sections 61, 318(4), and
316(2) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 at Police Station Sector-27,
District Sonipat,
Sonipat are being decided by a common order as they have been
filed by different accused in the same FIR.
FIR
2.
The
he FIR in the present case has been registered on the
complaint of Kapil Arora, Partner of OM Consultancy Engineering. The
same reads thus:
SUMIT SINGH GUSAIN
2026.03.17 18:17
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
107 (02 cases) CRM-M-68811-2025 (O&M);
CRM-M-74041-2025 (O&M)
“I, Kapil Arora, Partner of OM Consultancy Engineering, R/o
F-137, Ground Floor Jindal Global City, Sonipat do hereby
lodge this criminal complaint against 1. M/s Welkin India
Incorporate, GST No.08AAFW1433H1ZD having its office at
Oppst. Sabji Mandi, Bansur Road, Village Basdi, Kotputli
Jaipur Rajasthan-303108. (hereinafter referred to as "the
Accused No. 1"), and
2.
Mr. Ishminder Singh Sodhi, Mob: 9815400069 Partner of
the above-named firm, residing at 37/K-18 Green link Quenue
Road Sec-84 Gurugram, (hereinafter referred to as "the
Accused No. 2")
3.
Mr. Harinder Singh Sodhi, Mob: 9815722944 Partner of
the above-named firm, residing at, Sodhi Estate, Near
Kotkapura Bypass, G.T. Road, Moga, Punjab. (hereinafter
referred to as "the Accused No. 3") For the commission of
cognizable offences punishable under Sections 406, 417, 418,
420 read with Section 120-B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.
Brief Facts
1.
That our firm is engaged in the business of building
construction and aggregate material supply, including but not
limited to 10mm 20mm aggregates, stone dust, GSB, M-Sand,
and WMM. Our firm enjoys a sound market reputation for
consistent and high-quality service delivery.
2.
That in or about March 2023, the Accused, persons
conspired with each other and Mr. Ishminder Singh Sodhi,
acting in collusion with other co-accused contacted the
undersigned in his capacity as a partner of M/s Welkin India,
stating that they had been awarded a government contract for
the construction of flyovers along the Delhi-Jaipur National
Highway. Relying on this representation, and in good faith, we
agreed to commence material supply. Recently complainant
learnt that this is the modus-operandi of the accused persons to
lure the victim initially. There are other victims also who have
been cheated by the accused persons herein.
SUMIT SINGH GUSAIN
2026.03.17 18:17
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
107 (02 cases) CRM-M-68811-2025 (O&M);
CRM-M-74041-2025 (O&M)
3.
Initially, a trial consignment worth Rs. 76,328/- was
supplied to the Accused. Thereafter::
*On 26.04.2023, a formal quotation was issued by us.
*On 28.04.2023, a work order was issued by the Accused firm
confirming agreed rates and terms for delivery at various
project locations.
4.
Pursuant to the above, we undertook regular and large-
scale supply of construction materials to various project sites as
designated by the Accused. Each consignment was delivered
under proper documentation, including all Tax Invoices.
Financial Details of Transactions:
5.
That during the course of the commercial relationship
with the Accused firm, OM Consultancy Engineering diligently
supplied various construction materials including aggregates,
stone dust, GSB, M-Sand, and WMM, strictly in accordance
with the terms agreed upon in the issued work orders and
confirmed delivery schedules
6.
For each supply transaction, our firm raised proper GST-
compliant tax invoices and regularly discharged our statutory
obligations under the Goods and Services Tax (GST) regime, by
duly paying the applicable taxes to the government against
every invoice, irrespective of whether the payment for such
invoices was received from the Accused or not. These
transactions were reported in our regular GST returns filed
with the relevant tax authorities.
7.
That in the course of the ongoing business relationship
with the Accused firm, our firm regularly raised invoices
corresponding to the supply of construction materials. The
details of the invoices raised, payments received, and
outstanding dues are summarized below, segregated by
financial year: 1. Financial Year 2022-2023 Total Invoice
Amount Raised: ₹76,328/- Payment Received from Accused: Nil
Outstanding Balance (Carried Forward): ₹76,328/- GST
liability was duly paid on the invoices. 2. Financial Year 2023SUMIT SINGH GUSAIN
2026.03.17 18:17
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
107 (02 cases) CRM-M-68811-2025 (O&M);
CRM-M-74041-2025 (O&M)
2024 Total Invoice Amount Raised: ₹3,33,19,767/-Total
Payment Received: ₹1,42,21,210/- Balance Outstanding:
₹1,91,74,885/- The unpaid amount was carried forward to the
subsequent financial year. All applicable GST liabilities were
timely discharged by our firm. 3. Financial Year 2024-2025
Total Invoice Amount Raised: ₹95,61,915/-Payment Received:
₹1,02,00,000/- Adjusted Outstanding Receivable (after partial
offset):
₹1,85,36,800/-
Once
again,
OM
Consultancy
Engineering fulfilled its tax obligations by paying GST on all
invoiced supplies.4. Financial Year 2025-2026 Supply of
Material: Nil Payment Received: 15,00,000/- (toward past
dues) Final Outstanding Balance as on Date: ₹1,70,36,800/Despite continuous reminders, verbal assurances, and our
goodwill in continuing the supply based on trust, the Accused
did not discharge their legal and financial obligations, and
willfully failed and neglected to honor the same leading to
accumulation of significant dues, which are recoverable from
the Accused who continued to benefit from the materials
supplied while dishonestly withholding payment, thereby
causing substantial financial injury to our firm.
8.
It is also important to mention that our firm has suffered
double jeopardy having paid GST on supplies for which no
consideration has yet been received further amplifying the
extent of our losses and establishing our good faith and
compliance with the law at all times.
9.
The Accused initially made partial and regular payments,
thereby inducing our firm to trust them and continue supplying
materials on credit. However, from the month of April 2024, the
Accused willfully defaulted on payments, even as deliveries
continued and were acknowledged by their staff as explained in
above stated financial transactions.
10.
In furtherance of their representations and to allay our
concerns about mounting dues, the Accused Person issued
multiple cheques towards part payment of outstanding invoices.
SUMIT SINGH GUSAIN
2026.03.17 18:17
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
107 (02 cases) CRM-M-68811-2025 (O&M);
CRM-M-74041-2025 (O&M)
11.
However, upon presentation, the said cheques amounting
to Rs. 75,00,000/-were dishonored as the same were issued by
the accused from "Closed Account dated 16.11.2024". This
fraudulent Act evidences and substantiate the criminal intent of
the Accused Person, who knowingly issued cheques from a nonoperational bank account.
12.
The issuance of such cheques, with full knowledge that
the account had been closed, constitutes a clear instance of
fraudulent misrepresentation and deliberate deceit to induce
our firm to either continue the business relationship or delay
legal action.
13.
The Accused persons persistently gave false assurances,
and delayed payments on flimsy grounds, and misrepresented
their financial condition and contractual obligations. It is now
evident that the Accused had no genuine intent to pay the dues
and acted with the fraudulent intent to procure goods without
making corresponding payments.
14.
The overall conduct of the Accused persons demonstrates
clear criminal intent. Accused misused our trust, induced us to
part with materials worth crores of rupees, and dishonestly
retained the same for their own benefit without payment.
15.
The accused persons in conspiracy with each other
deceitfully and fraudulently represented that they had a valid
government contract, which they used as a pretext to gain our
trust and dishonestly induced the delivery of goods worth crores
of Rupees, while never intending to make full and final payment
thus, committed cheating.
16.
The issuance of dishonored cheques, by accused persons
knowing full well the accounts were closed, constitutes a
separate and independent offence and also substantiates the
dishonest intent.
17.
The Accused persons in having received goods in trust
with an implied duty to make timely payment, failed to fulfill
their obligation, thereby dishonestly misappropriating or
SUMIT SINGH GUSAIN
2026.03.17 18:17
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
107 (02 cases) CRM-M-68811-2025 (O&M);
CRM-M-74041-2025 (O&M)
converting the goods supplied for their own use without
payment thus committed breach of trust.
18.
The Accused persons in conspiracy with each other by
willfully giving false assurances and concealing material facts
regarding their intention or ability to make payment,
dishonestly induced our firm to supply valuable goods.
The Accused persons being fully aware that non-payment would
cause wrongful loss to our firm, and still dishonestly induced us
to continue supply, thereby breaching a duty of care and
fiduciary obligation.
In light of the above facts and circumstances, the accused has
committed offences. Your good office is requested to register
FIR against M/s Welkin India, Mr. Ishminder Singh Sodhi and
Mr. Harinder Singh Sodhi under Section 406, 417, 418, 420 and
120-B IPC corresponding Sections 316, 318 and 61 of BNS and
apprehend them for the recovery of cheated sum i.e. Rs.
1,70,36,800/- and further prevent them from cheating other
persons and misappropriation or alienation of assets.”
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioners contends that the petitioners
are working partners of firm-M/s Welkin India Incorporate, which is
engaged in the execution of Government and private contractual works,
including
construction,
supply,
manufacturing
and
transport
of
materials/goods. He contends that the partnership deed was executed on
01.07.2018, and the firm was later merged and reconstituted as a private
limited company on 01.04.2025. He further contends that the petitioners,
being associated with the company, have been carrying out construction
work for more than 03 decades and have a presence across multiple States.
National Highways Authority of India had awarded the project for the work
of “Construction of Additional Structures on Six-Lane Gurgaon-Jaipur
Section of NH-48 between Km 42.700 to Km 273.000” vide letter of
SUMIT SINGH GUSAIN
2026.03.17 18:17
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
107 (02 cases) CRM-M-68811-2025 (O&M);
CRM-M-74041-2025 (O&M)
acceptance dated 03.08.2022. The joint venture of M/S Pawan Kumar with
OJSC Euro-Asian Construction Corporation (EVRASCON) issued a
communication dated 21.09.2022, offering to subcontract 49% of the
contract value to M/S Welkin India Incorporate in terms of Clause 4.2 of the
Contract Agreement. The said subcontract was later approved by the NHAI
in favour of M/s Welkin India Incorporate vide communication dated
07.10.2024. He further contends that the complainant-Company had
approached the petitioners/firm in March-April, 2023, offering to supply
construction material for NH-48, Gurgaon-Jaipur Project and a work order
was formally issued on 28.04.2023 to the complainant-Company, i.e. M/s
Om Consultancy Engineering, for the supply of bulk materials, including the
aggregates, M-Sand, GSB and Dust for certain sections of the aforesaid
work. The NHAI issued numerous communications raising concerns
regarding the quality of material used at the site. The details of certain
correspondences have been mentioned in paragraph No. 2 (V) of the
petition. He further contends that, as a result of non-conformance by the
complainant/Company, the NHAI imposed restrictions on the running
account bills, and they were also adversely affected. The prejudicial
reflection of the running account bills submitted by the petitioners has been
extracted in Para No.2(VI) of the petition. It is contended that the petitioners,
through their partners, sent numerous messages through WhatsApp
photographs, highlighting concerns with respect to the quality of the material
supplied and informing about the hardships caused to them. He further
contends that the accounts were sought to be reconciled and certain postdated cheques were issued by the firm from its account on the HDFC Bank,
SUMIT SINGH GUSAIN
2026.03.17 18:17
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
107 (02 cases) CRM-M-68811-2025 (O&M);
CRM-M-74041-2025 (O&M)
unaware that the said account had been rendered non-operational in
November, 2024 due to RBI-mandated directives. Upon realizing in
February, 2025 that the cheques had been mistakenly issued on a closed
account, the petitioners instructed their officials to inform the complainant to
return the said cheques and thereafter, cheques drawn on another Bank were
issued. Notwithstanding the same, various payments were still issued to the
complainant in February, March and April, totalling to the tune of nearly
Rs.27.00,000/-.It is contended that notwithstanding the same, the complaint
was made levelling frivolous allegations to arm-twist the Company’s
directors to extract the entire payment to which the complainant would not
be entitled on account of substandard material having been supplied by him.
Another payment (Rs.10,00,000/-) was made to the complainant on
08.07.2025. He further contends that, notwithstanding the complainant being
aware of the closure of HDFC Bank, from where the earlier cheques had
been issued and despite taking fresh cheques of another Bank, i.e. Yes Bank,
the old cheques were presented, thus resulting in registration of the FIR.
4.
The matter had come up for hearing before this Court on
05.12.2025, when the following order was passed in CRM-M-68811-2025:
“Learned Counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner(s) inter
alia contends that the dispute in the present case does not have
any nexus with the allegations that have been levelled. He
contends that in fact the parties had long standing commercial
transactions, however, on account of the sub-standard material
having been supplied, the payments of the petitioner got delayed
from National Highways Authority of India thus cascading into
delayed payment to the complainant. He contends that even
though the cheques towards partial liability of the petitioner
had been issued in favour of the complainant, however, on
SUMIT SINGH GUSAIN
2026.03.17 18:17
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
107 (02 cases) CRM-M-68811-2025 (O&M);
CRM-M-74041-2025 (O&M)
account of certain communication by the Reserve Bank of India
owing to certain bank mergers being undertaken, the operations
of the account had been stopped. He submits that the petitioner
had made a call to the complainant not to present the said
cheques and had instead issued fresh cheques drawn on Yes
Bank. He contends that notwithstanding the issuance of fresh
cheques, yet, the complainant presented the said cheques
against the account that had been frozen in view of the circulars
issued by the Reserve Bank of India pending merger of
operations of account. Hence, the petitioner issued instructions
to the Yes Bank to stop payment of the cheques. He submits that
the said instructions were not on account of any bad intent of
the petitioner but on account of the circumstances as aforesaid
and that the petitioner does not dispute his liability or his
willingness to pay the undisputed sums to the complainant.
Counsel further contends that the petitioner has clean
antecedents and is not involved in any other case.
Notice of motion.
Dr. (Ms.) Malvika Singh, DAG, Haryana, enters
appearance and accepts notice on behalf of the respondentState.
Mr. Sajal Bansal, Advocate, enters appearance and files
power of attorney on behalf of the complainant.
List on 10.04.2026.
In the meantime, the petitioner is directed to join
investigation as and when required by the Investigating Agency.
In the event of petitioner joining investigation, he shall be
admitted to interim bail by the arresting officer/investigating
officer on furnishing of bail bonds to the satisfaction of the
arresting officer/investigating officer. The petitioner shall also
abide by the conditions as specified under Section 482 of the
BNSS, 2023.”
SUMIT SINGH GUSAIN
2026.03.17 18:17
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
107 (02 cases) CRM-M-68811-2025 (O&M);
CRM-M-74041-2025 (O&M)
5.
On resumed hearing, learned State Counsel on instructions,
contends that pursuant to the order dated 05.12.2025 passed by this Court,
the petitioners have joined investigation and their custodial interrogation is
not required for the purpose of investigation.
6.
Mr. Sumeet Jain, Advocate enters appearance on behalf of the
complainant and files his Power of Attorney in both the petitions. The same
are taken on record. Registry is directed to tag the same at an appropriate
place.
7.
Counsel for the complainant raises the following submissions:
(i)
That the post-dated cheques on HDFC bank were issued
by the petitioners/firm, notwithstanding the petitioners/company
itself having submitted a request for closure of the account in
November, 2024, and the same was thus an act of fraud on the
part of the petitioners.
(ii)
That even though the petitioners/firm claim(s) that it had
merged in 2025, yet the cheques in question have been issued
for and on behalf of the Company, which, as per their own
claim, had not been incorporated. Hence, there was an act to
defraud the complainant.
(iii)
That even the cheques issued by the petitioners/firm
drawn on Yes Bank were subsequently dishonoured.
(iv)
That an amount of Rs.1.70 crore still remains outstanding
against the complainant.
SUMIT SINGH GUSAIN
2026.03.17 18:17
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
107 (02 cases) CRM-M-68811-2025 (O&M);
CRM-M-74041-2025 (O&M)
8.
On a pointed query, counsel for the complainant acknowledges
that a sum of Rs.2.50 crores of the amount against the invoices raised by the
complainant has already been paid.
9.
I have heard counsel for the parties and have gone through the
documents appended along with the present petitions.
10.
Insofar as the argument of the complainant that the post-dated
cheques were issued in January 2025 despite the account being closed is
concerned, the letter dated 14.11.2024 relied upon by counsel for the
complainant shows that the said request was for the closure of account
No.50200075498297, whereas the cheques in question had been issued
against account No.00568730000022. It is thus evident that the argument
advanced by counsel for the complainant is misleading since the closure
request for the account was for an altogether different account, viz. HDFC
Bank and not the account against which the cheques in question had been
issued. At this juncture, counsel for the complainant again reiterates the
argument that the cheque dishonour memo refers to the request dated
14.11.2024. The repetition and insistence on such an argument
notwithstanding that the request had been made in reference to a different
account is deprecated.
11.
The next submission made by counsel for the complainant is
that the post-dated cheque had been issued against an account of M/s Welkin
India Incorporate in January 2025, whereas the Company was formed in
April 2025. Hence, the juristic entity of the Company had not come into
existence at that point.
SUMIT SINGH GUSAIN
2026.03.17 18:17
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
107 (02 cases) CRM-M-68811-2025 (O&M);
CRM-M-74041-2025 (O&M)
12.
The said argument is also misleading since M/s Welkin India
Incorporate was the name of the partnership firm, and that it was eventually
retained as M/s Infracon Pvt. Limited, which is a separate Private Limited
Company w.e.f. 01.04.2025. The cheque in question was issued against the
account of M/s Welkin India Incorporate and not against the Private Limited
Company.
13.
Similarly, the name and the use of the word “Incorporate”
would make the firm a corporate entity as its juristic status as a Private
Limited Company, viz. M/s Infracon Pvt. Limited is separate from the name
of the partnership firm. Thus, the partnership firm continued to exist till its
incorporation as a Private Limited Company.
14.
Besides, the present case is based upon financial transactions in
the normal course of business with the petitioners herein, and there are
arguable issues with respect to the quality of material supplied by the
complainant and the cascading effect on the liquidity of the petitioners
herein. It would thus be arguable as to whether the necessary ingredients for
commission of an offence under Section 318(4) BNS would be made out in
the present case or not. It is also worthwhile to note that the petitioners had
already paid a sum of Rs.2.50 crores and that a sum of Rs.10,00,000/- and
other various amounts had been paid even after the issuance of post-dated
cheques. Every breach of commercial transactions or undertakings/
assurances may not necessarily make out sufficient ingredients for culpable
criminal liability under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023. Undisputedly,
the complainant has already filed a complaint under Section 138 of the
Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, for dishonour of the cheques. Thus, so far
SUMIT SINGH GUSAIN
2026.03.17 18:17
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
107 (02 cases) CRM-M-68811-2025 (O&M);
CRM-M-74041-2025 (O&M)
as the issue of criminality/dishonour of cheques is concerned, the
complainant has already taken recourse to the remedy available to him in
accordance with law. The issue as to whether the proceedings under Section
420 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 and 138 of the Negotiable Instruments
Act, 1881, are to be initiated alternatively or at the same time is already
pending before the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Criminal Appeal No(s).
1678/2022 titled as “J.Vedhasingh vs R.M. Govindan and Others”. The
case is based upon documentary evidence, which is corroborated by
transactions duly reflected in the account maintained in the normal course of
business for which custodial interrogation of the petitioners is not necessary
and is also not sought for by the respondent-State.
15.
Consequently, the present petitions are allowed, and the interim
orders dated 05.12.2025 and 12.01.2026, respectively, are made absolute.
16.
However, if required, the petitioners shall continue to join
investigation as and when required to do so and shall abide by the terms and
conditions, as laid down under Section 482 (2) BNSS.
(VINOD S. BHARDWAJ)
JUDGE
12.03.2026
Sumit Gusain
Whether speaking/reasoned
Whether reportable
SUMIT SINGH GUSAIN
2026.03.17 18:17
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
:
:
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review