Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CMPMO No. 778 of 2025
Date of Decision: 11.09.2026
____________________________________________________
Hader Ali
...Petitioner.
Versus
Mohammad Rafik
...Respondent.
Coram
Hon'ble Mr. Justice Romesh Verma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the petitioner:
Mr. Jia Lal, Advocate, vice
Mr. G.R.Palsra, Advocate.
For the respondent:
Mr. Vijay Chaudhary, Advocate.
__________________________________________________
Romesh Verma, Judge (oral)
The present petition arises out of the judgment dated
28.10.2025 passed by learned District Judge, Mandi, District
Mandi, H.P., whereby the appeal filed by the present petitioner
was ordered to be dismissed and the order as passed by the
learned Senior Civil Judge, Court No. 1, Mandi, dated 23.05.2025,
whereby the application filed by the respondent/applicant under
Order 39 Rules 1 & 2 read with Section 151 CPC, was allowed.
2.
The facts as emerge in the present case are that the
respondent/plaintiff, Mohammad Rafik, filed a suit for permanent
prohibitory and mandatory injunction in the Court of learned Senior
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
Civil Judge, Court No. 1, Mandi. As per the case as set up by the
plaintiff, the land comprised in Khata/Khatauni No. 284 min/369
min, Khasra No. 1045, measuring 00-18-02 bighas, situated in
Mohal Dhaban/237, Tehsil Balh, District Mandi, H.P., was owned
and possessed by late Shri Gulam Kadar, who was father of the
plaintiff, defendant, and other co-sharers. Suit land was inherited in
the name of plaintiff, defendant, and other co-sharers vide
mutation No. 1683 dated 5th May, 2021. The plaintiff, defendant,
and other co-sharers had become joint owners-in-possession of
the suit land thereafter. The suit land, being valuable land, is
situated by the side of the road and it is an agricultural land. The
defendant, by taking advantage of the winter vacation in the Court
and without the consent and permission of the plaintiff and other
co-sharers, without getting the same partitioned, started occupying
the valuable portion of the suit land by raising construction thereon
since 13th January, 2022, which act on his part is wrong, illegal,
and unlawful.
3.
As per the plaintiff, though the defendant was
requested time and again not to do so and not to indulge in the
unlawful activities, however, the defendant refused to accede to
the request as made by the plaintiff. In case, the defendant is able
to encroach the best and valuable portion of the suit land/road
head during pendency of the suit by raising the construction, in
that event, the said construction be ordered to be demolished and
the suit land be restored to its original position. Therefore, under
such circumstances, the plaintiff/respondent filed a suit for
permanent prohibitory injunction restraining the defendant from
raising any construction on the suit land or to cause any unlawful
interference over the same in any manner till the land is partitioned
by metes and bounds, and by passing a decree of permanent
prohibitory injunction, or any other relief as the Court deems fit.
4.
The present petitioner, being defendant before the
learned trial Court, filed written statement to the suit as filed by the
plaintiff and refuted all the allegations as made in the plaint and
preliminary objections with regard to the maintainability, estoppel,
valuation, non-joinder, locus standi, etc., were raised by the
defendant. On merits, all the averments as made in the plaint have
been specifically denied. As per the case as set up by the
defendant, Khasra No. 1045 is in his
exclusive possession
through a family settlement made by late Shri Kader Ali, though
the land has not been partitioned by metes and bounds. It has
been contended by the defendant that in the year 2004, Gulam
Kadar, the father of the parties, in his lifetime, settled and put his
three sons in exclusive possession of different parcels of the land,
and thereafter, all the sons are in exclusive possession of different
parcels of the land as owners in possession of the same. It has
been vehemently denied that the suit land, that is Khasra No.
1045, is valuable land and situated by the side of the road.
Accordingly to the defendant, Khasra No. 1045 is about 300
meters far away from the main road and is by the side of a Nullah,
and the defendant has spent lakhs of rupees to protect the land
and make it useful, whereas, out of the entire joint land described,
only Khasra No. 951, measuring 00-05-12 bighas, and Khasra
Nos. 1688/1587/915, measuring 02-02-03 bighas, is abutting to the
Dadaur-Dhaban-Diyargi road leading to Sundernagar, and is the
only valuable and commercial parcel of the joint land abutting to
the roadside. Further, it has been averred that during the lifetime,
the father of the parties had put the three brothers in exclusive and
separate possession, and thereafter they are enjoying the suit
property. It has been contended in the written statement that the
construction of a house by the defendant over Khasra No. 1045 is
less than his share and there is no ouster of the plaintiff from the
suit land in any manner. The defendant prayed for the dismissal of
the suit as filed by the plaintiff.
5.
The plaintiff/respondent, along with the suit, filed an
application under Order 39 Rules 1 & 2 CPC for the grant of
injunction. It was prayed that during the pendency of the suit, the
defendant be restrained to dig the suit land, to raise any
construction over the suit land, or to cause any unlawful
interference over the same in any manner by issuance of
temporary injunction order till the final disposal of the suit.
6.
The said application came to be resisted by the
defendant and all the allegations as made in the application were
denied.
7.
The learned trial Court, vide its order dated 23 rd May,
2025, allowed the application as filed by the plaintiff/respondent,
and the parties were directed to maintain status quo qua nature,
possession, and construction over the suit land comprised in
Khata/Khatauni No. 284 min/369 min, Khasra No. 1045, measuring
00-18-02 bighas, as per jamabandi for the year 2017-18, situated
in Mohal Dhaban/237, Tehsil Balh, District Mandi, H.P., till the final
disposal of the suit.
8.
Feeling
dissatisfied,
the
defendant,
Haider
Ali,
preferred an appeal in the Court of learned District Judge, Mandi,
on 5th June, 2025.
9.
The learned First Appellate Court, vide its impugned
judgment dated 28th October, 2025, dismissed the appeal filed by
the defendant/petitioner and affirmed the findings as returned by
the learned trial Court.
10.
Still feeling dissatisfied, the defendant has approached
this Court by filing the instant petition and invoking the provisions
of Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
11.
It is contended by Mr. Jia Lal, learned vice counsel, for
the petitioner that the impugned judgment and order as passed by
the learned Courts below are erroneous and liable to be quashed
and set aside. He submits that the learned Courts below have not
appreciated the point in controversy in hand and have wrongly
passed the order of status quo in favour of the respondent/ plaintiff
and against the petitioner/defendant. He further submitted that
after accepting the present petition, the application filed by the
respondent/plaintiff under the provisions of Order 39 Rules 1 & 2
CPC is liable to be dismissed.
12.
On the other hand, Mr. Vijay Chaudhary, learned
counsel for the respondent has defended the impugned judgment
and order as passed by the learned Courts below. He submits that
the Courts below have concurrently and rightly adjudicated the
case in hand and there is no scope of interference in the same. He
would submit that this Court, while exercising the power under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India, will not interfere in the wellreasoned judgment and order as passed by the learned Courts
below.
13.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and
gone through the case file.
14.
The plaintiff/respondent has primarily approached the
learned trial Court for the grant of permanent prohibitory and
mandatory injunction on the ground that the suit land bearing
Khata/Khatauni No. 284 min/369 min, Khasra No. 1045, measuring
00-18-02 bighas, situated in Mohal Dhaban/237, Tehsil Balh,
District Mandi, HP is joint inter se the parties. The plaintiff has
pleaded that after the death of their father, late Shri Gulam Kadar,
the plaintiff, defendant, and other co-sharers have become joint
owners-in-possession of the suit land. The defendant, taking
advantage of winter vacation and without getting the suit land
partitioned, started occupying the valuable portion of the suit land
by raising construction thereon since 13th January, 2022. It is the
case of the plaintiff that the defendant cannot be permitted to raise
the construction over the best and the valuable portion of the suit
land till the time formal partition takes place by metes and bounds.
15.
It is the case of the respondent/plaintiff that, in order to
earn his livelihood, he is residing in Saudi Arabia, and taking
undue advantage of his absence, the petitioner/defendant started
raising construction over the best and valuable portion abutting the
road by raising forcible construction to the detriment of the rights of
the respondent.
16.
Though the said fact has been denied by the
defendant/petitioner in the written statement, the only stand taken
by the defendant is that in the year 2004, late Shri Gulam Kadar,
father of the parties, during his lifetime, put his three sons into
exclusive possession and family arrangement took place between
the parties. Thereafter, on the basis of the same, Khasra No. 1045
came into the exclusive possession of the defendant. It is further
the case of the defendant that though the land has not been
partitioned by metes and bounds, on the basis of the family
settlement, Khasra No. 1045 is in exclusive possession of the
defendant and he is raising construction only on his own share. It
is pleaded that the construction being raised over Khasra No. 1045
is less than his share and there is no ouster of the plaintiff from the
suit land in any manner, therefore, no question of injunction arises
in the present proceedings.
17.
The copy of the Jamabandi placed on record by the
plaintiff for the years 2017–2018 shows the parties to be joint
owners of the suit land. The said fact was required to be rebutted
by the defendant by placing on record relevant material. In the
present case, save and except the bald statement made in the
written statement that on the basis of a family settlement the
defendant is in exclusive possession of the suit land, no reliance
can be placed on his bald statement in the attending facts and
circumstances of the case. The plea of family settlement/family
arrangement has to be determined by the learned Courts below by
affording opportunity to the respective parties to adduce evidence
in support of their contentions. At this stage, and that too while
adjudicating an application under Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 of the
Code of Civil Procedure, this fact can not be finally decided as no
material has been placed on record to demonstrate that on the
basis of the family arrangement, the entire Khasra No. 1045 is in
the exclusive possession of the present petitioner.
18.
The defendant has primarily relied upon the plea of
family arrangement and asserted that by virtue of a Will, father of
the parties had separated the total land and the respective parties
were put in
separate possession thereof. However, learned
counsel for the petitioner has not been able to establish that there
is any reference to Khasra No. 1045 in the said Will. In order to
dislodge the case of the respondent/plaintiff and to rebut the
presumption of truth attached to the copy of the Jamabandi for the
years 2017–2018, the defendant has not been able to establish
and prove anything on record.
19.
The learned Courts below have rightly determined the
point in controversy and arrived at the conclusion that till the suit is
finally decided, the suit land has to be preserved, otherwise, the
very purpose of filing the suit as well as the application under
Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 CPC shall stand defeated. The parties
shall be afforded an opportunity by the learned trial Court to lead
evidence in support of their contentions, and in case any of the
parties succeeds in doing so, the learned trial court shall pass
appropriate orders in accordance with law.
20.
At this stage, in the considered opinion of this Court,
and based upon the presumption of truth attached to the
Jamabandi for the year 2017–2018, the land is joint inter se the
parties. In view of the allegations levelled by the respondent that
the defendant is trying to encroach upon and occupy the best and
most valuable portion adjacent to the road, the defendant cannot
be permitted to take undue advantage of the absence of plaintiff. In
case defendant is permitted to raise construction, it is the plaintiff
who shall suffer huge and irreparable loss.
21.
The plaintiff has successfully satisfied the tripartite test
of prima facie case, balance of convenience, and irreparable loss.
On the strength of the material placed on record in conjunction
with the Jamabandi, the plaintiff has a prima facie case in his
favour, the balance of convenience also lies in his favour, and in
case the defendant is permitted to raise construction, the plaintiff
will certainly suffer irreparable injury. The Courts below have
rightly adjudicated and determined the point in controversy, and
this Court finds no infirmity in the impugned judgment and order.
22.
The Hon’ble Apex Court has repeatedly held that the
scope of interference in a petition filed under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India is very limited. The Hon’ble Apex in Civil
Appeal No(s).13801 of 2025, titled as Shri Digant vs M/s P.D.T.
Trading Co. & others, has discussed the scope of interference
while exercising the power under Article 227 of Constitution of
India. The relevant paragraphs thereof read as under:“22. The scope of High Court’s jurisdiction under Articles
226/227 fell for consideration before a threeJudge Bench
of this Court in Radhey Shyam & another v. Chhabi Nath
& Ors. 1 This Court held that judicial orders of civil courts
are not amenable to a writ of certiorari under Article 226,
though they may be questioned in the supervisory
jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 227 of the
Constitution. The power under Article 227 is intended to
be used sparingly and only in appropriate cases for the
purpose of keeping the subordinate courts and tribunals
within the bounds of their authority and not for correcting
mere errors. The power may be exercised in cases
occasioning grave injustice or failure of justice such as
when (i) the court or tribunal has assumed a jurisdiction
which it does not have, (ii) has failed to exercise a
jurisdiction which it does have, such failure occasioning a
failure of justice, and (iii) the jurisdiction though available
is being exercised in a manner which tantamounts to
overstepping the limits of jurisdiction.”
23. In the case on hand, the appellate court had
considered whether the proceeding in detail the issue as
to court was justified in trial with the case, without further
notice to the defendants, after submission of pursis
(Exh.42) by defendants’ counsel, claiming no instructions.
After a threadbare analysis and taking into consideration
surrounding circumstances, the appellate court held that
the trial court had committed no wrong proceeding with
the matter court representing with noticed the the that
defendants matter. The appellate Court noticed tht the
advocate representing the defndants had claimed no
instructions but not sought withdrawal of his Vakalatnama
and the matter thereafter remained pending for over three
months till it was decided in March 2015. In between no
effort was made by the defendants to engage another
lawyer. Moreover, the defendants did not come up with a
case that their lawyer’s notice was not served on them
therefore, they could not engage another counsel Besides
that, the record also indicated that the intention of the
defendants was to delay the proceedings because earlier
also the suit had proceeded ex parte against them though,
later, those orders were recalled. Therefore, in our view,
once the appellate court took into consideration all
relevant aspects including the fact that pursis (Exh.42) did
not seek withdrawal of the Vakalatnama, and withdrawal
was not even permitted, there was no such jurisdictional
error which warranted exercise of powers under Article
227 of the Constitution of India. The High Court without
any justification procedure went consider the procedure
prescribed for withdrawal Vakalatnama when neither
withdrawal of Vakalatnama was permitted by the Trial
Court nor the pursis prayed for its withdrawal. In such
circumstances, the entire exercise of the High Court was
misconceived. More so, when the view taken by the
appellate Court that defendant cannot take advantage of
his own wrong was a plausible view based on materials
available on record. Hence, in our view, appellate court’s
order was not amenable to interference in exercise of
jurisdiction under Article 226/227 of the Constitution of
India. The High Court clearly exceeded its jurisdiction
under Article 227 of the Constitution in interfering with well
reasoned order of the appellate Court.”
23.
The Hon’ble Apex Court in M/S GARMENT CRAFT
Vs. PRAKASH CHAND GOEL, (2022) 4 SCC 181, decided on
11.01.2022, has held that High Court while exercising
Supervisory Jurisdiction will not act as a Court of First Appeal to
reappreciate, reweigh the evidence on facts upon which the
determination under challenge is based. The Hon’ble Supreme
Court has held as follows:15. Having heard the counsel for the parties, we
are clearly of the view that the impugned order is
contrary to law and cannot be sustained for
several reasons, but primarily for deviation from
the limited jurisdiction exercised by the High
Court under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India. The High Court exercising supervisory
jurisdiction does not act as a court of first appeal
to reappreciate, reweigh the evidence or facts
upon which the determination under challenge is
based. Supervisory jurisdiction is not to correct
every error of fact or even a legal flaw when the
final finding is justified or can be supported. The
High Court is not to substitute its own decision
on facts and conclusion, for that of the inferior
court or tribunal.1 The jurisdiction exercised is in
the nature of correctional jurisdiction to set right
grave
dereliction
of
duty
or
flagrant
abuse,1Celina Coelho Pereira (Ms) and Others
v. Ulhas Mahabaleshwar Kholkar and Others,
(2010) 1 SCC violation of fundamental principles
of law or justice. The power under Article 227 is
exercised sparingly in appropriate cases, like
when there is no evidence at all to justify, or the
finding is so perverse that no reasonable person
can possibly come to such a conclusion that the
court or tribunal has come to. It is axiomatic that
such discretionary relief must be exercised to
ensure there is no miscarriage of justice.
16. Explaining the scope of jurisdiction under
Article 227, this Court in Estralla Rubber v. Dass
Estate (P) Ltd.2 has observed:“6. The scope and ambit of exercise of power
and jurisdiction by a High Court under Article
227 of the Constitution of India is examined and
explained in a number of decisions of this Court.
The exercise of power under this article involves
a duty on the High Court to keep inferior courts
and tribunals within the bounds of their authority
and to see that they do the duty expected or
required of them in a legal manner. The High
Court is not vested with any unlimited
prerogative to correct all kinds of hardship or
wrong decisions made within the limits of the
jurisdiction of the subordinate courts or tribunals.
Exercise of this power and interfering with the
orders of the courts or tribunals is restricted to
cases of serious dereliction of duty and flagrant
violation of fundamental principles of law or
justice, where if the High Court does not
interfere, a grave injustice remains uncorrected.
It is also well settled that the High Court while
acting under this article cannot exercise its
power as an appellate court or substitute its own
judgment in place of that of the subordinate court
to correct an error, which is not apparent on the
face of the record. The High Court can set aside
or ignore the findings of facts of an inferior court
or tribunal, if there is no evidence at all to justify
or the finding is so perverse, that no reasonable
person can possibly come to such a conclusion,
which the court or tribunal has come to.”
19. The factum that the counsel for the appellant
had applied for the certified copy would show
that the counsel for the appellant was aware that
the ex-parte decree had been passed on the
account of failure to lead defence evidence. This
would not, however, be a good ground and
reason to set aside and substitute the opinion
formed by the trial court that the appellant being
incarcerated was unable to lead evidence and
another chance should be given to the appellant
to lead defence evidence. The discretion
exercised by the trial court in granting relief, did
not suffer from an error apparent on the face of
the record or was not a finding so perverse that it
was unsupported by evidence to justify it. There
could be some justification for the respondent to
argue that the appellant was possibly aware of
the ex-parte decree and therefore the
submission that the appellant came to know of
the ex-parte decree only on release from jail on
6th May 2017 is incorrect, but this would not
affect the factually correct explanation of the
appellant that he was incarcerated and could not
attend the civil suit proceedings from 6th
October 2015 to 6th May 2017. If it was felt 30
that the application for setting aside the exparte
decree was filed belatedly, the court could have
given an opportunity to the appellant to file an
application for condonation of delay and costs
could have been imposed. The facts as known,
equally apply as grounds for condonation of
delay. It is always important to take a holistic and
overall view and not get influenced by aspects
which can be explained. Thus, the reasoned
decision of the trial court on elaborate
consideration of the relevant facts did not
warrant interference in exercise of the
supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the
Constitution.”
24.
Consequently, in view of the observations made here-
in-above, this Court is of the considered view that the Courts
below have concurrently passed orders in favour of the plaintiff
after duly appreciating the material placed on record. This Court
finds no perversity, illegality, or jurisdictional error in the
impugned judgment and order.
Consequently, the present petition being devoid of any
merit deserves to be dismissed.
However, it is made clear that observations as made in
the present case will not have any bearing on the merits of the
main case.
All the pending miscellaneous application(s) if any,
shall also stands disposed of.
(Romesh Verma)
Judge
September 11, 2026
(Nisha)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review