Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[1]
SHOUGRA Digitally signed by
SHOUGRAKPAM
KPAM
DEVANANDA
DEVANAN SINGH
Date: 2024.01.16
DA SINGH 12:40:59 +05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
CRP(CRP Art. 227) No. 24 of 2012
Shri Heikrujam Kala Singh, aged about 77 years, son of late
H. Sanarik Singh, resident of Chingdong Leikai, P.O. and P.S.
Jiribam, Imphal East District, Manipur.
... Petitioner
-Versus1. Shri Arambam Gouramani Singh, son of late A. Netra
Singh, by occupation a Government employee serving as
Lineman under the Government of Manipur in the Electricity
Department, Manipur resident of Dibong Khunou, P.O. & P.S.
Jiribam, Imphal East District, Manipur, now dead by his L.Rs:(i)
Smt. Arambam Ongbi Panchabati Devi, aged about 58
years, wife of late Arambam Gouramani Singh.
(ii) Arambam Sunita Devi, aged about 35 years, daughter of
late Arambam Gouramani Singh.
(iii) Arambam Sataljit Singh, aged about 20 years, son of late
Arambam Gouramani Singh.
… All resident of Dibong Khunou, P.O. & P.S. Jiribam,
Imphal East District, Manipur.
2. The State of Manipur, represented by Secretary (Revenue).
3. The Deputy Commissioner, Imphal East, Government of
Manipur.
… Respondents
B E F O R E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH
For the Petitioner
::
Mr. Th. Henba, Advocate
For the respondents
::
Mr. T. Rajendra, Sr. Advocate,
Md. Shakir Khan, Advocate; &
Mr. Niranjan Sanasam, GA;
Date of Hearing
::
18-12-2023
Date of Judgment
::
16-01-2024
CRP(CRP Art. 227) No. 24 of 2012
Contd…/-
[2]
JUDGMENT
[1]
The present petition had been filed assailing the judgment
and order dated 23-07-2012 passed by the Revenue Tribunal, Manipur, in
Revenue Appeal Case No. 1 of 1992. By the impugned judgment and order
dated 23-07-2012, the Revenue Tribunal dismissed the appeal filed by the
present petitioner against the order dated 14-08-1991 issued by the Deputy
Commissioner, Imphal allotting two plots of land measuring an area of .61
acre and .37 acre in favour of the respondent No. 1 for agricultural and
residential purposes.
[2]
The case of the petitioner is that he is a poor and landless
cultivator whereas the respondent No. 1 is a Government employee serving
as a Lineman in the Electricity Department, Manipur as well as the owner
of a homestead land under Patta No. 3/96 at Dibong Khunou, Jiribam,
Manipur. According to the petitioner, on 02-04-1979, he purchased from the
respondent No. 1, two plots of land covered by C.S. Dag Nos. 163 and 164
of Village No. 14, Jiribam, measuring an area of .61 acre and .37 acre
respectively by executing a kachcha sale deed for a consideration amount
of Rs. 300/- only with possession thereof and since then, the petitioner
along with his family members have been residing therein by constructing
dwelling houses.
[3]
In the month of June, 1986, the petitioner filed an application to
the Deputy Commissioner, Imphal for allotment of the said two plots of
land to him for the purpose of residing and also for cultivation. While
the application for allotment submitted by the petitioner was pending
consideration, the petitioner learnt from reliable information that the
CRP(CRP Art. 227) No. 24 of 2012
Contd…/-
[3]
respondent No. 1 also filed an application for allotment of the said two plots
of land in his favour and that the Deputy Commissioner had already sent
his recommendation to the Government for allotment of the said two
plots of land in favour of the respondent No. 1 without considering the
application submitted by the petitioner. The petitioner, therefore, submitted
a representation dated 29-06-1987 to the Deputy Commissioner, Imphal, to
recall the said recommendation sent to the Government and to consider the
matter of allotment together with the case of the petitioner.
[4]
It is also the case of the petitioner that after the cases filed by him
before the SDC, Jiribam and the SDO, Jiribam for allowing mutation of
his name in the Dag Chitha in respect of the said two plots of land
were dismissed, he filed an application dated 19-11-1986 to the Deputy
Commissioner, which was registered as Revenue Misc. Case No. 30 of
1986, requesting for correction of the land records in respect of the said
two plots of land by recording his name in the relevant Dag Chitha book
after cancelling the name of the respondent No. 1. In the said Revenue
Misc. Case, the Deputy Commissioner passed an order dated 05-06-1989
directing the SDC, Jiribam to verify personally as to whether the petitioner
or the respondent No. 1 was in possession of the disputed lands and for
how long and that the names of the persons in possession of the disputed
lands shall be recorded in the Dag Chitha. The Deputy Commissioner also
observed that if the respondent No. 1 was found occupying the lands in
question, the case shall be disposed of in his favour, however, if in the event
the petitioner was found occupying the lands, the Government should be
moved for allotment of the lands in his favour.
CRP(CRP Art. 227) No. 24 of 2012
Contd…/-
[4]
[5]
The petitioner's case is that pursuant to the aforesaid order of the
Deputy Commissioner, Imphal, the SDC carried out verification on the spot
on 06-12-1990 in the presence of the petitioner, the respondent No. 1 and
some local villagers and submitted a report dated 11-04-1991 to the Deputy
Commissioner, Imphal, stating that the petitioner has been in physical
possession of the aforesaid two plots of land since 1979 by constructing
dwelling houses, shops, etc. and to take into consideration the report
while issuing allotment order in respect of the said lands. However, quite
surprisingly, the petitioner received an order/ notice dated 11-02-1992 from
the SDC, Jiribam, stating, inter alia, that the said two plots of land have
been allotted to the respondent No. 1 and that the petitioner encroached
upon the said lands by constructing houses and directing him to remove the
construction voluntarily within ten days from the date of receipt of the
said notice failing which, the petitioner would be evicted by force. On
receiving the said notice, the petitioner went to the office of the Deputy
Commissioner, Imphal and verified that the said plots of land have been
allotted to the respondent No. 1 by an allotment order dated 24-08-1991.
[6]
Feeling aggrieved, the petitioner approached the Revenue
Tribunal, Manipur by filing a Revenue Appeal No. 1 of 1992 challenging
the said allotment order. Before the Revenue Tribunal, it was, inter alia,
submitted on behalf of the petitioner that the petitioner submitted an
application in the month of June, 1986 to the Deputy Commissioner, Imphal,
for allotment of the said two plots of land in his favour, however, without
at all considering the said application, the Deputy Commissioner issued
the allotment order in favour of the respondent No. 1 and that such action
of the Deputy Commissioner amounts to violation of the equality clause
CRP(CRP Art. 227) No. 24 of 2012
Contd…/-
[5]
under Article 14 of the Constitution of India. Another point raised on behalf
of the petitioner before the Revenue Tribunal was that the notice dated
11-02-1992 issued by the SDC, Jiribam, to the petitioner asking him to
demolish the structures standing on the lands in question obviously
revealed that the petitioner was actually in possession of the said lands and
as such, the petitioner is entitled to allotment of the lands.
[7]
Rejecting the contentions raised on behalf of the petitioner, the
Revenue Tribunal dismissed the said appeal by passing the judgment and
order dated 23-07-2012, which is impugned herein. The relevant portion of
the judgment are reproduced hereunder for ready reference:“16. In my considered view, both the points raised by the Ld.
Counsel for the appellant have no peculiar aspects requiring
serious consideration of any of the points because of the
following reasons that:
1. The allotment in question was processed pursuant to the
application filed by the respondent No. 3 to the Ld. Deputy
Commissioner, Imphal, for allotment of the abovementioned
lands in his favour. It was not a case that the claim of the
appellant also found running parallel with the claim of the
respondent No. 3 and such claim was either ignored or
overlooked later by the competent authority arbitrarily in
order to give preference to the claim of the respondent
No. 3.
2. Notice to the appellant dated 11-2-1992 issued by the Ld.
S.D.C., Jiribam, came subsequent to the allotment of the
land in question to the respondent No. 3. Even in case of
assuming that the appellant was in possession of the
disputed land at that relevant time either as an encroacher
or otherwise, the said notice appears to be a material
document or a piece of evidence emerging post facto
thereby showing the appellant as a person unlawfully
occupying the said land. Therefore, it cannot be the basis
for setting aside the impugned order of allotment as
violative of section 14(1) of the MLR & LR Act, 1960 and the
corresponding allotment of land rules framed in this regard.
CRP(CRP Art. 227) No. 24 of 2012
Contd…/-
[6]
For the above said reasons, the impugned order is
hereby made affirmed and the appeal is dismissed. Send the
lower Court record back to its office.”
In the said impugned judgment and order, the Revenue Tribunal
also gave the following findings:“12. However, the report of the Ld. S.D.C., Jiribam, dated 11-4-1991
is not available on record. I have also unfolded the record of
the Court below so as to ascertain existence of such report by
considering that it will be the most essential element in coming
to the decision as to who has actually been in possession of
the dispute lands but the same was not found in the said
record. Other documents, as I saw all of these, are not helping
the case of the petitioner.”
[8]
Mr. Th. Henba, learned counsel for the petitioner raised the same
points, which were submitted before the Revenue Tribunal. It has also
been submitted by the learned counsel that the Deputy Commissioner had
knowledge about filing of the application by the petitioner for allotment of
the said two plots of land in the month of June, 1986 and the Deputy
Commissioner also passed an order dated 05-06-1989 in Revenue Misc.
Case No. 30 of 1986 directing the SDC, Jiribam to verify personally as to
who was in actual possession of the said lands and also observed that
if the petitioner is found occupying the lands, the Government shall be
moved for allotment of the lands in favour of the petitioner and that
despite such factual position, the Deputy Commissioner issued the
allotment order in favour of the respondent No. 1 without considering the
case of the petitioner. According to the learned counsel, such action of the
Deputy Commissioner violates the Fundamental Right of the petitioner
guaranteed by Article 14 of the Constitution of India. The learned counsel
also submitted that as there were two applications filed by the respondent
No. 1 and the petitioner before the Deputy Commissioner, the Deputy
CRP(CRP Art. 227) No. 24 of 2012
Contd…/-
[7]
Commissioner was duty bound to consider the said two applications jointly.
The learned counsel also submitted that had the Deputy Commissioner
jointly considered the case of the petitioner along with the case of the
respondent No. 1 at the time of issuing the allotment order, the petitioner
will be in a better position to get the allotment in terms of the provisions
under Rule 6 of the Manipur Land Revenue and Land Reforms (Allotment
of Land) Rules, 1962. In support of his contention, the petitioner relied on
the judgment and order passed by a Single Bench of the Gauhati High
Court, Imphal Bench in the case of "Achom Angou Singh & ors. Vs.
State of Manipur & ors." reported in 2000 (3) GLT 224 (paras. 8, 11 - 14
and 20).
[9]
The respondent No. 1 contested the appeal filed by the petitioner
before the Revenue Tribunal by filing his written objection and by denying
all the averments made by the petitioner in his memorandum of appeal.
The stands taken by the respondent No. 1 before the Tribunal are,
inter alia, that the petitioner is the owner in possession of the homestead
covered by Dag No. 14/190 comprising an area of 5.76 acre and also
the co-owner of the agricultural land covered by new Dag No. 14/51
(New) corresponding to old Dag No. 19, both situated at Chingdong Leikai,
Jiribam. The respondent No. 1 also stated that the petitioner is a migrant
from Bangladesh who took shelter in the house of one Dorjoi, at Refugee
Colony, Chingdong Khunou Leikai, Jiribam and he later on claimed physical
possession over the new land covered by Dag No. 14/190 and get his
name recorded in the Dag Chitha of the said land and he has been residing
there by constructing dwelling house of his own. The respondent No. 1 also
stated that the petitioner was permitted to use and occupy the northernmost
CRP(CRP Art. 227) No. 24 of 2012
Contd…/-
[8]
room of the respondent No. 1’s residential house constructed on the lands
in question so as to facilitate the petitioner in running his business there as
a licensee on payment of rent and that the respondent No. 1 never executed
a Kachha Deed of Sale of the lands in favour of the petitioner.
[10]
Mr. T. Rajendra, learned senior counsel appearing for the
respondent No. 1 submitted that the respondent No. 1 submitted an
application to the Deputy Commissioner, Imphal, for allotment of the said
two plots of land in his favour and after due consideration, the Deputy
Commissioner made a recommendation to the State Government for
allotting the said land in favour of the respondent No. 1. It has also been
submitted that at the time of sending the said recommendation, there
was no other application before the Deputy Commissioner for allotting
the said plots of land except the application submitted by the respondent
No. 1 and as such, there was no question of considering the application
submitted by the petitioner. The learned senior counsel further submitted
that after considering the application submitted by the respondent No. 1
and the recommendation made by the Deputy Commissioner, the State
Government conveyed its sanction for allotting the said lands in favour of
the respondent No. 1 under a letter dated 07-08-1987 and pursuant to the
convey letter of the State Government, the Deputy Commissioner, Imphal,
issued the allotment order dated 24-08-1991 allotting the said lands in
favour of the respondent No. 1 and thereafter, the respondent No. 1 duly
paid the premium of the allotted lands and also executed the deed of
allotment and as such, he had become the owner of the said lands. The
learned senior counsel strenuously submitted that the present petition is
devoid of merit and the same is liable to be dismissed.
CRP(CRP Art. 227) No. 24 of 2012
Contd…/-
[9]
[11]
I have heard the rival submissions of the counsel appearing for
the parties at length and also carefully perused the impugned judgment and
order passed by the Revenue Tribunal. I have also carefully examined all
the materials available on record. The main point raised by the counsel for
the petitioner is that as there were two applications, one submitted by the
petitioner and another submitted by the respondent No. 1 for allotment
of the lands in question before the Deputy Commissioner, the Deputy
Commissioner was duty bound to consider both the application jointly and
the act of the Deputy Commissioner in allotting the lands in favour of
the respondent No. 1 without considering the application submitted by the
petitioner violates the Fundamental Right of the petitioner guaranteed by
Article 14 of the Constitution of India. On the other hand, the stand of
the respondent No. 1 is that he submitted an application to the Deputy
Commissioner for allotting the said lands in his favour and that the Deputy
Commissioner after due consideration made the recommendation to the
State Government for allotting the said lands in favour of the respondent
No. 1 and that at the time of making such recommendation, there was no
other application except the application submitted by the respondent No. 1
and as such, there is no question of considering both the application
submitted by the petitioner as well as by the respondent No. 1.
[12]
In the impugned judgment and order, the Revenue Tribunal
clearly held that it was not the case of the petitioner that his claim was
also found running parallel with the claim of the respondent No. 1 and such
claim was either ignored or overlooked later by the authorities arbitrarily
in order to give preference to the claim of the respondent No. 1. On the
basis of such findings, the Revenue Tribunal refused to interfere with the
CRP(CRP Art. 227) No. 24 of 2012
Contd…/-
[10]
impugned allotment order. On careful examination of the record, this court
did not find any material warranting interference with the findings of the
learned Tribunal.
[13]
In the judgment passed by the Gauhati High Court, Imphal Bench
in the case of Achom Angou Singh (Supra) relied on by the counsel for
the petitioner, the Hon’ble Court interfered with the impugned allotment
order in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case and the Hon’ble
Court did not laid down any principle of law, having universal application
that if different applications are filed before the competent authority for
allotment of the same plots of land, all such applications should be
considered jointly by the authority irrespective of whether such applications
are filed at different point of time. In my considered view, the said judgment
relied on by the counsel for the petitioner is not applicable in the present
case as the facts and circumstances of the two cases are completely
different.
In the result, this court did not find any ground or reason for
interfering with the impugned judgment and order passed by the Revenue
Tribunal and the impugned allotment order issued by the Deputy
Commissioner and accordingly, the present petition is hereby dismissed,
however, without any order as to cost.
JUDGE
FR / NFR
Devananda
CRP(CRP Art. 227) No. 24 of 2012
Contd…/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review