Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Judgment reserved on: 04.02.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 01.07.2026
W.P.(C) 6723/2017
ASHOK KUMAR YADAV & ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr Manish K Bishnoi with Mr
Khubaib Shakeel, Advs.
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
Through:
+
.....Respondents
Mr Jitendra Kumar Tripathi, Mr
Sumit Kumar Raj & Mrs Anjali
Dwivedi, Advs. for R-1.
Mr. S.M. Arif with Ms.
Shabnam Perween, Advs. for
R-2 to R4.
W.P.(C) 6744/2017
GYANANDRA MUNI TYAGI & ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr Manish K Bishnoi with Mr
Khubaib Shakeel, Advs.
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. S.M. Arif with Ms.
Shabnam Perween, Advs. for
R-2 to R4.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
JUDGMENT
AMIT MAHAJAN, J.
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 6723/2017 & W.P.(C) 6744/2017
16:05:45
1.
W.P.(C) 6723/2017 is filed by the Petitioners against the order
dated 01.04.2015 (hereafter ‘impugned order dated 01.04.2015’)
passed by the learned Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal
Bench, Delhi in O.A. 1861/2014, whereby the learned Tribunal
allowed the OA filed by the Petitioners and directed the Respondents
to grant the benefit of higher scale of ₹5000-₹8000/- w.e.f. 01.01.1996
only on notional basis to the Petitioners.
2.
W.P.(C) 6744/2017 is filed by the Petitioners against the order
dated 24.05.2016 (hereafter ‘impugned order dated 24.05.2016’)
passed by the learned Tribunal in OA No. 1858/2015, whereby the
learned Tribunal noting that the said OA was squarely covered by the
order passed on 01.04.2015 in O.A. 1861/2014 (the same has also
been challenged before this Court by way of the impugned order dated
01.04.2015) had directed the Respondents to grant the benefits of
higher scale of ₹5000-8000 on notional basis to the Petitioners therein
if similarly placed.
3.
The Petitioners (66 in total) in the two writ petitions are stated
to be working as Technicians/ Senior Technicians/Engineering
Assistant working in Prasar Bharati. Although the respective Original
Applications were allowed by the learned Tribunal after appreciating
that Technicians and Sr. Technicians are to be treated at par with
Lighting Assistants as far as pay is concerned, the Petitioners remain
aggrieved by grant of benefits of higher scale only on notional basis
without consequential relief of grant of arrears of pay.
Historical Backdrop
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 6723/2017 & W.P.(C) 6744/2017
16:05:45
4.
Till the year 1983, there had been a parity in the pay scale of
Technician and Senior Technician with that of Lighting Assistants.
However, this pay parity was disturbed when various categories of
Staff Artists of Doordarshan (which included Cameraman Grade-II,
Sound Recordists and Lighting Assistants) approached the Hon’ble
Apex Court and claimed parity in pay scale with their counterparts in
Film Division. The Hon’ble Apex Court thereafter in the case of Y.K.
Mehta and Others v. Union of India : 1988 (Supp) SCC 750, by
judgment dated 28.08.1988, directed that Lighting Assistants were to
be given the pay scale in parity with their counterparts being Assistant
Cameraman in the Film Division with effect from 01.12.1983. On that
occasion, the Hon’ble Apex Court also deprecated the discrimination
in pay and held that the Petitioners therein were entitled to substituted
scales of pay and consequential benefits including arrears of pay.
5.
Now, while the pay was revised for Lighting Assistants in the
aftermath of the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Y.K. Mehta
and Others v. Union of India (supra) and they were placed on parity
with Assistant Cameraman, the same benefit was not extended to
Technicians/Senior Technicians, who, prior to the judgment of the
Hon’ble Apex Court, were always in pay parity with Lighting
Assistants. So, while the pay of the Lighting Assistants was enhanced,
the pay scale of Technicians/Senior Technicians was not revised and
they continued to be in the lower pay scale. Consequently, several
representations were given by the Technicians and Senior Technicians
to the Respondents to extend pay parity to them at par with the
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 6723/2017 & W.P.(C) 6744/2017
16:05:45
Lighting Assistants.
6.
Thereafter, pursuant to the constitution of Prasar Bharti, by
Office Memorandum dated 05.12.1997, once again parity was restored
and the pay scales of Technicians/Senior Technicians amongst other
employees was upgraded and they were placed in the same pay scale
as Lighting Assistants. However, this parity was only brought upon
from 01.01.1996 and not from 01.12.1983 (as was given to the
Lighting Assistants in accordance with the Hon’ble Apex Court
judgment). According to the Technicians/Senior Technicians, by not
extending pay parity to them for the period between 1983-1995 at par
with the Lighting Assistants, the Respondents had discriminated
against the Technicians/Senior Technicians. Consequently, the quest
of the Technicians/Senior Technicians to seek pay parity for the years
between 1983-1995 continued.
7.
In that regard, the following litigations ensued:
7.1.
OA No. 164/1996 was preferred by the Association of Radio &
Television Engineering Employees before the learned Tribunal, Delhi
demanding parity of pay between Technicians/ Senior Technicians
and Lighting Assistants w.e.f. 01.12.1983, which was dismissed on
the grounds of acquiescence. A writ petition was preferred against the
said order before this Court, being W.P.(C) No. 3787/2000, and the
same was also dismissed by order dated 08.07.2011. By order dated
27.04.2012, SLP (C) No. 14381/2012 filed against the said order
dated 08.07.2011 was also dismissed by the Hon’ble Apex Court.
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 6723/2017 & W.P.(C) 6744/2017
16:05:45
7.2.
Another association of employees had filed OA No. 390/2006
before the Chennai Bench of the Tribunal claiming notional fixation
of pay scale w.e.f. 01.07.1983 for Technicians/Senior Technicians at
par with Lighting Assistants, which was also dismissed. However,
while considering a challenge to the dismissal in W.P. No.
27155/2009, by order dated 24.11.2010, the Madras High Court, after
noting that the petitioners therein were not claiming arrears, had
granted benefit of notional fixation of pay scale from 01.07.1983
finding denial of such benefit without assigning any reasons to be
violative of principles of natural justice. The Hon’ble Apex Court, by
order dated 10.01.2013, dismissed the SLP (C) No. 33048/2011 filed
against the said order by the Union and upheld the decision of the
Madras High Court granting notional revision of pay.
8.
Due to the inconsistency in the decisions which emanated from
Delhi and Chennai proceedings, a Review Petition also came to be
filed against the dismissal of SLP (C) No. 14381/2012 (whereby the
Hon’ble Apex Court had upheld the denial of parity in pay to the
Technicians/Senior Technicians in the Delhi proceedings). As
similarly situated persons had been granted relief in terms of the order
passed by the Madras High Court, the Hon’ble Apex Court recalled its
earlier order dated 27.04.2012 and directed the Union of India to grant
similar relief to the Petitioners therein in terms of the earlier order
dated 10.01.2013 passed by the Hon’ble Apex Court thereby
approving the direction given by the Madras High Court.
9.
Thereafter, vide order dated 11.03.2014, the Union of India
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 6723/2017 & W.P.(C) 6744/2017
16:05:45
implemented the directions and the Technicians/Senior Technicians
were granted the benefit of notional fixation of pay at par with
Lighting Assistants without payment of arrears for the period between
01.07.1983 – 31.12.1995. Quietus was thus put to the long quest of the
Technicians/Senior Technicians and they achieved pay parity for the
period between 1983-1995.
Another spell of litigation pertaining to fixation of pay with effect
from 01.01.1996
10.
The pay scales were further revised w.e.f. 01.01.1996, when the
recommendations of the Fifth Pay Commission were implemented.
11.
Now, as noted above, the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of
Y.K. Mehta and Others v. Union of India (supra) had already settled
that Lighting Assistants were to be given the same pay scale as their
counterpart in the Film Division being Assistant Cameraman.
However, when the pay scales were revised, Lighting Assistants in
Doordarshan were once again placed in a grade lower than Assistant
Cameraman. Inter alia, aggrieved by the same, Lighting Assistants
once again preferred W.P. (C) 6544/2007 before this Court. By
judgment dated 15.12.2010, this Court directed UOI to extend the
benefit of similar pay scale of ₹5000-8000/- (pre-revised) to the
Lighting Assistants as given to Assistant Cameramen in the Film
Division w.e.f. 01.01.1996 or their date of regularisation.
12.
The benefit of upgradation of pay as granted to Lighting
Assistants by the aforesaid decision was not extended to the
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 6723/2017 & W.P.(C) 6744/2017
16:05:45
Technicians/Senior Technicians. Consequently, the subject O.A.
1861/2014 was filed. Although the said original application was
allowed by the impugned order dated 01.04.2015, the learned Tribunal
only directed the Respondents to grant the benefits of higher scale of
₹5000-8000/- with effect from 01.01.1996 only on notional basis.
Review Application preferred against the said order also came to be
dismissed noting that no prayer for arrears was made before the
Hon’ble Madras High Court in WP No. 27155/2009 on the first
occasion. Aggrieved by the same, the Petitioners have filed W.P.(C)
6723/2017.
13.
Similarly, as noted above, W.P.(C) 6744/2017 is filed by the
Petitioners against the order dated 24.05.2016 passed by the learned
Tribunal in OA No. 1858/2015, which was disposed of in terms of the
impugned order passed on 01.04.2015 in O.A. 1861/2014 [also in
challenge before this Court].
Grievance of the Petitioners
14.
The limited grievance of the Petitioners herein is only that
while the learned Tribunal appreciated that the Technicians/Senior
Technicians are to be treated at par with the Lighting Assistants as far
as the pay scale is concerned, the benefit of higher pay ₹5000-8000/with effect from 01.01.1996 was only granted on a notional basis
without any award of arrears.
Submissions
15.
The learned counsel for the Petitioners submitted that the
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 6723/2017 & W.P.(C) 6744/2017
16:05:45
learned Tribunal erred in granting the benefits of higher scale of
₹5000-8000 w.e.f. 01.01.1996 only on notional basis to the
Petitioners. He submitted that vide order dated 15.12.2010, this Court
had directed revising the pay scale of Lighting Assistant to be kept at
par with their counterpart in the Film Division being the Assistant
Cameraman. He submitted that on this basis, revised pay scale of
₹5000-8000/- was granted to Lighting Assistants from the date of their
regularisation or 01.01.1996. He relied upon the due and drawn
statement of one of the Lighting Assistants to claim that the Lighting
Assistants were also paid arrears of pay. He consequently submitted
that the Petitioners herein also ought to be awarded arrears of pay with
effect from 01.01.1996.
16.
He submitted that on the earlier occasion when the pay was
revised for the period between 1983-1995 in accordance with the
implementation of the direction of the Hon’ble Apex Court in SLP (C)
No. 33048/2011 to grant benefit of notional fixation of pay to the post
of Technician and Senior Technician enhancing their pay scale at par
with Lighting Assistants Grade I & II, no arrears were granted because
the claimants therein had specifically pleaded that the concerned
employees would not claim any arrears. He submitted that no cogent
reason has been provided by the learned Tribunal in denying the
arrears of pay to the Petitioners when the same has been specifically
pleaded in the present case. He consequently prayed that the
Petitioners be paid the arrears of pay.
17.
Per contra, the learned counsel representing the Respondents
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 6723/2017 & W.P.(C) 6744/2017
16:05:45
submitted that the impugned order is correct and does not warrant any
interference by this Court. He submitted that on an earlier occasion as
well the Hon’ble Apex Court in SLP No. 33048/2011 while
dismissing the appeal preferred by the UOI had upheld the order
passed by the Hon’ble Madras High Court whereby the Court had
only extended the benefit of notional fixation of pay scale from
01.07.1983 without any award of arrears. He submitted that the claim
of the Petitioners herein is thus without any merit.
Analysis
18.
Before this Court adverts to delve into the question presented
for adjudication before it, it is pertinent to note that insofar as the
question of parity of pay between Lighting Assistants and
Technicians/Senior Technicians is concerned, the same has been duly
considered and settled by the Hon’ble Apex Court while disposing of
the SLP No. 33048/2011 preferred by UOI against the order dated
24.11.2010 passed by the Hon’ble Madras High Court, whereby pay
scale of Technicians/Senior Technicians was notionally fixed at par
with Lighting Assistants Grade I and II respectively from 01.07.1983
as they were being paid salary in identical pay scale before the said
date. The Hon’ble Apex Court noted as follows in its judgment dated
10.01.2013:
“Shri Rajiv Sharma, learned counsel for the petitioners argued that
the High Court committed grave error by ordering notional revision
of the pay scale of the Technicians at par with Lighting Assistants
ignoring that the two cadres are distinct and separate and there is no
similarity in the duties of the Technicians on the one hand and the
Lighting Assistants on the other. However, he could not draw our
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 6723/2017 & W.P.(C) 6744/2017
16:05:45
attention to any tangible evidence to substantiate the statement.
Learned counsel also failed to explain the rationale of denial of parity
in the matter of pay scales to the Technicians working in All India
Radio and Doordarshan vis-à-vis Lighting Assistants Grade-II and
Grade-I despite the fact that they were paid salary in the identical pay
scale till 01.07.1983 and that parity was restored after a gap of about
13 years with effect from 01.01.1996. In the absence of any cogent
explanation for differentiating the two cadres in the matter of
revision of pay scales, it is not possible to find any fault with the
direction given by the Division Bench of the High Court. Rather, it
must be held that by order revision of pay scales of the Technicians
at par with the Lighting Assistants, the High Court has acted in
consonance with the spirit of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution”
(emphasis supplied)
19.
Undisputedly, by Office Memorandum dated 05.12.1997,
Technicians/Senior Technicians had been granted pay parity with
Lighting Assistants w.e.f. 01.01.1996 and their earlier claims (both in
Madras and in Delhi) were for parity for the period between
01.07.1983 – 31.12.1995. Pay parity was granted only on notional
basis for the aforesaid period by the Madras Bench of the learned
Tribunal, which relief was upheld by the Hon’ble Apex Court and
subsequently extended to similarly situated persons.
20.
The balance was again disturbed when by judgment dated
15.12.2010 in W.P.(C) 6544/2007, this Court revised the pay scale of
Lighting Assistants and granted them the higher pay scale as given to
Assistant Cameramen w.e.f. 01.01.1996 (date of implementation of
recommendations of fifth pay commission) or their date of
regularisation.
21.
This disparity in pay scales from 1996 onwards was the subject
of dispute before the learned Tribunal in O.A. 1861/2014 [W.P.(C)
6723/2017]. Taking note of the observations made by the Hon’ble
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 6723/2017 & W.P.(C) 6744/2017
16:05:45
Apex Court as quoted supra, by the impugned order dated 01.04.2015,
the learned Tribunal granted benefit of the higher pay scale on
notional basis w.e.f. 01.01.1996 and noted as follows:
“12. It is clear that matter has been settled at the level of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court that Technicians and Sr. Technicians be
treated at par with Lighting Assistants as far as their pay scales
are concerned. Once this matter is settled, in our opinion, whether
or not the applicants were or were not before the Hon’ble High
Court in Writ Petition No.6544/2007 is not relevant. The Hon’ble
High Court had enhanced the scale of Lighting Assistant to
Rs.5000/- to 8000/- and, therefore, following the judgment of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court and Madras High Court this scale of
Rs.5000-8000 cannot be denied to Technicians/Sr. Technicians.
The OA is, therefore, allowed and the respondents are directed to
grant the benefits of higher scale of Rs.5000-8000/- w.e.f.
01.01.1996 on notional basis to the applicants.”
(emphasis supplied)
22.
The Review Application being RA 148/2015 in OA 1861/2014
also came to be dismissed by order dated 15.02.2016.
23.
In a similar fashion, the learned Tribunal allowed the O.A. No.
1858/2015 filed by the Petitioners [W.P.(C) 6744/2017] by impugned
order dated 24.05.2016 with the following directions:
“In our opinion, since the issue had been raised in the OA in which
the Tribunal has given a finding regarding fixing of the pay on
notional basis and the RA had been also dismissed giving specific
reasons as mentioned above, this OA is also squarely covered by
our order dated 01.04.2015. Therefore, this OA is also disposed of
with a specific direction to the respondents to grant the benefits
of higher scale of Rs.5000-8000 on notional basis w.e.f.
01.01.1996 to the applicants in this OA, if they are similarly
placed as the applicants in OA No. 1861/2014.”
(emphasis supplied)
24.
Pertinently, the Respondents have not challenged the finding of
the learned Tribunal in the impugned orders that the Technicians and
Senior Technicians are to be treated at par with Lighting Assistants
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 6723/2017 & W.P.(C) 6744/2017
16:05:45
insofar as their pay scales are concerned or the notional fixation of
pay.
25.
The Petitioners have now approached this Court with a limited
grievance that the Petitioners also be granted arrears of pay. The short
question before this Court is only as to whether the Petitioners are
entitled to retrospective fixation of pay along with consequential relief
of grant of arrears of pay.
26.
In this respect, the sole argument agitated by the Respondents is
that when the pay scale of the Technicians and Senior Technicians had
been enhanced on an earlier occasion in terms of the direction of the
Hon’ble Apex Court in SLP No. 33048/2011 for the period between
1983-1995, only notional pay fixation was granted and no arrears
were awarded to the concerned employees. It has thus been
emphasised that any claim for arrears on this occasion as well is
without any merit.
27.
In that regard, it is pertinent to note that on an earlier occasion,
the Hon’ble Madras High Court vide order dated 24.11.2010 in Writ
Petition No. 27155/2009 had allowed the claim of the concerned
employees (Technicians and Senior Technicians) of notional fixation
of pay scale with effect from 01.07.1983 being weighed by the
submission that the petitioners therein were not claiming any arrears.
It was noted as under:
“In the above facts and circumstances, as the counsel for the
petitioners, after instructions, submitted that the petitioners are
not claiming any arrears, we consider it appropriate that
extending the benefit notional fixation of pay scale to the
petitioners from 01.07.1983 is sufficient. Accordingly, the order
dated 10.07.2008 in O.A. No. 390 of 2006 passed by the Central
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 6723/2017 & W.P.(C) 6744/2017
16:05:45
Administrative Tribunal is set aside. The respondents are directed
to extend the benefit of notional fixation of pay scale with effect
from 01.07.1983, conferred on the post Transmission Executive, as
evident from paragraph No.2(iv) of the order dated 25.02.1999, to
the petitioners also, within a period of eight weeks from the date of
receipt of a copy of this order, without awarding any arrears, from
01.07.1983.”
(emphasis supplied)
28.
The Hon’ble Apex Court while considering a challenge to the
said order in SLP No. 33048/2011 had also taken note of the fact that
the concerned employees were not claiming arrears. It was noted as
under:
“The Division Bench of the High Court then took cognizance of the
statement made by the counsel for respondent No. 1 that the
concerned employees will not claim arrears and directed that their
pay scales be revised notionally with effect from 01.07.1983.”
29.
Upon a careful examination of the observations as quoted
supra, it is apparent that the concerned employees therein were only
extended the benefit of notional fixation of pay without the award of
arrears for the period between 1983-1995 considering the peculiar
factual concessions made on that occasion.
30.
As quoted above, on that occasion, the Hon’ble Apex Court had
specifically taken note of the fact that the Division Bench of the High
Court had taken cognizance of the categorical submission of the
counsel that the concerned employees would not be claiming arrears
and had thus directed that the pay scale be revised notionally with
effect from 01.07.1983. It was in this specific backdrop that the relief
was confined to only notional fixation of pay. Consequently, in the
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 6723/2017 & W.P.(C) 6744/2017
16:05:45
opinion of this Court, mere non-payment of arrears on an earlier
occasion cannot ipso facto crystallise into an immutable rule.
31.
Reliance was sought to be placed by the Petitioners on the
decision of the Madras Bench of the Tribunal in O.A. 310/01667/2015
titled R. Varadharajan and Ors. v. Union of India & Ors. where
higher pay grade was awarded along with consequential benefits to
similarly placed applicants, however, as pointed out by the
Respondents, the said decision is under challenge before the High
Court of Madras. Perusal of the order of the Tribunal in that case also
reflects that though the decision was based on the observations in
impugned order dated 01.04.2015, no particular reason was given
therein for differing from the Principal Bench and granting
consequential benefits instead of awarding the higher pay grade on
notional basis.
32.
Even so, though scope of judicial review in matters pertaining
to determination of pay scale is limited as the same involves complex
considerations, including fiscal feasibility, the present case is one
where it has already been settled that Technicians/ Senior Technicians
and Lighting Assistants are at par as far as their pay scale is concerned
since there is no cogent explanation for differentiating between them.
Once there is no dispute in relation to parity of pay scales between the
two cadres, the benefit of the enhancement of the pay to ₹5000-8000/from 01.01.1996 cannot be denied to the Petitioners herein, especially
when such benefit has since been extended by the Respondents to the
Lighting Assistants.
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 6723/2017 & W.P.(C) 6744/2017
16:05:45
33.
Despite sufficient opportunity, it has not been contested by the
Respondents that the Lighting Assistants were not paid the arrears of
pay upon the enhancement of their pay scale. Furthermore, a “due and
drawn” statement of one Lighting Assistant showing arrear payment
has also been relied upon the Petitioners. When such arrears on
refixation of pay appear to have been paid to the Lighting Assistants,
this Court is persuaded that benefit of retrospective fixation of pay
along with ensuing arrears ought not to be unjustifiably denied to the
Petitioners either.
34.
When the aim is to restore parity in pay scales and no
waiver/relinquishment of arrears of pay has been pleaded, the
Petitioners cannot be deprived of the benefit of consequential benefits
that flow from such restoration. Depriving the Petitioners from grant
of arrears entirely will be manifestly unjust.
35.
There are sufficient precedents which support the course of
restoring parity in pay scales of similarly placed categories by
awarding benefit of higher pay scale from the same date from when
the parity is disturbed. In this regard, reference can be made to the
case of Union of India & Ors. v. D.G.O.F. Employees Association
and Anr.: 2023 INSC 995 where the Hon’ble Apex Court was dealing
with a challenge to grant of higher pay scales to Assistants and
Personal Assistants of Ordnance Factory Board, Headquarters as had
been given to similarly placed employees of Central Secretariat
Service and equivalent posts in Armed Force Headquarters Civil
Service Cadre, New Delhi. The High Court had directed the Union
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 6723/2017 & W.P.(C) 6744/2017
16:05:45
authorities to upgrade the pay scale of the Assistants working in
Ordnance Factories from the same date as their similarly placed
counterparts with consequential pay fixation. The Hon’ble Apex Court
upheld the said decision on finding that the High Court had merely
rectified the error on noting discrimination despite historical
similarity.
36.
In Union of India & Ors v. Sanjoy Kor and Ors and connected
matters : 2025:DHC:10661-DB, although the core issue was
different, another Division Bench of this Court was specifically
dealing with challenge to grant of arrears of upgraded pay scales w.e.f.
01.01.1996 by the Tribunal. In that case, dispute arose due to
anomalies in implementation of recommendations of 5th CPC wherein
the Accounts Department was not given pay structure commensurate
with similarly placed staff. Revised pay scale was only notionally
granted from 01.01.1996 and effective date of grant of higher scale
was determined to be 19.02.2003 (when the proposal for allotment of
improved pay was approved). This was set aside by the Tribunal
which granted upgraded pay on actual basis w.e.f. 01.01.1996. The
Court dismissed the petitions after observing that several litigations
had been instituted in this regard where multiple Courts had
consistently held that grant of only notional benefits from 01.01.1996
with actual monetary benefits being granted from 19.02.2003 was
discriminatory as other categories of employees had been granted
appropriate pay scales from 01.01.1996 itself.
37.
It is however imperative to note that Courts have also resorted
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 6723/2017 & W.P.(C) 6744/2017
16:05:45
to restricting the grant of arrears to a specific period in some
instances. In Y.K. Mehta and Others v. Union of India (supra) itself,
when the Hon’ble Apex Court intervened to restore parity in pay
scales of different cadres which had previously received equal
treatment, such pay scales were granted with effect from the first day
of the month of the year in which the respective writ petition was
filed. The only exception was carved out in the petition pertaining to
the Lighting Assistants [that is, Writ Petition (C) No. 1756/1986] who
were awarded benefit of the higher pay scale with effect from
01.12.1983. The Hon’ble Apex Court was of the opinion that the
aforesaid relief would satisfy the ends of justice.
38.
In the present case, considering that Lighting Assistants have
been granted the benefit of higher pay scale from 01.01.1996 itself
and that the Petitioners approached the Tribunal promptly (after
Supreme Court recalled its earlier order wherein it had denied parity
in pay to the Technicians/Senior Technicians in the Delhi
proceedings), this Court is of the opinion that there is no cause to
grant higher pay scale to the eligible Petitioners from a prospective
date.
39.
The Respondents are therefore directed to extend the benefit of
pay scale of ₹5000-8000 to the eligible Petitioners from the same date
as was given to the Lighting Assistants (that is, 01.01.1996) along
with consequential benefits arising out of such pay fixation, including
the arrears of pay within a period of 3 months from the date of this
judgment.
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 6723/2017 & W.P.(C) 6744/2017
16:05:45
40.
The present writ petitions are allowed in the aforesaid terms.
41.
A copy of the judgment be placed in both the matters.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
JULY 1, 2026
“SK”
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 6723/2017 & W.P.(C) 6744/2017
16:05:45
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review