Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on
Pronounced on
Uploaded on
+
: 01.04.2026
: 26.05.2026
: 26.05.2026
FAO 348/2008
GYAN ANAND
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Ashutosh Dubey, Ms. Rajshri
Ashutosh Dubey, Mr. Abhishek
Chauhan, Mr. Amit P. Shahi, and Mr.
Rishabh Bhardwaj, Advocates.
versus
STATE OF N.C.T. OF DELHI & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Sarojanand Jha, Mr. Suraj Malik,
Ms. Rajreeta Ghosh, Mr. Rahul
Kumar, and Ms. Muskan Saxena,
Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
JUDGMENT
1.
The issue involved in the present appeal is the validity of the Will
dated 10/20.09.2004 (hereinafter referred to as the “Will”) stated to be
executed by the late Ved Ram Anand. The appellant propounded the said
Will by filing the underlying petition under Section 276 of the Indian
Succession Act, 1925 (hereinafter referred to as “ISA”), claiming himself to
be the beneficiary. Vide the impugned judgment, however, the Trial Court
dismissed the said petition by observing that the said Will was shrouded by
suspicious circumstances and that the petitioner had failed to prove that it
Digitally SignedPREM
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
21:54:29
FAO 348/2008
was duly executed as the last and final Will of the testator.
2.
Before proceeding further and for the sake of convenience, the
genealogical table of the testator is extracted hereunder:
FAMILY TREE
VED RAM ANAND
(Father)
Died on 28.11.2004
Krishan
Gyan
Kishore
Kumar
Anand
Son 1
Son 2
Krishna
Nirmal
Raj
Kumar
Kumari
Kumari
Son 3
Daugher 1 Daughter 2 Daugher 3
(Married)
(Married)
Died on
9.9.2010
R. No. 2
Appellant
R. No. 3
Died on
R. No. 5
R. No. 6
Died on
Proceeded
Proceeded
30.04.2021 29.10.2014
ex parte
ex parte
No Lrs.
Nirmala
Amit
Sandhaya
Anand
Anand
Anand
R. No. 4
No Lrs.
Digitally SignedPREM
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
21:54:29
FAO 348/2008
(Wife)
3.
(Son)
(Daughter)
Vide the Will, the testator bequeathed his sole property, i.e., property
bearing no. 109, Gagan Vihar, Delhi – 110051, in favour of the appellant,
with a right of residence to the testator‟s other son, i.e., Kishore Kumar @
Raju, in half portion of the ground floor of the said property. It was stated
that Kishore Kumar @ Raju would be entitled to use the same for residential
purposes and would not be entitled to sell or rent out the same. The testator‟s
moveable properties in the form of cash, bank account balance, receivables,
paintings, works of art, books, were also bequeathed to the appellant. It was
directed that the expenses to be incurred on the marriages of the testator‟s
two daughters, namely Nirmal Kumari and Raj Kumari, were to be met from
the funds realised from the sale of the terrace rights of the aforementioned
property. There is no mention of the testator‟s other children in the Will
other than the direction that his daughters and sons-in-law will not have any
right in any of his assets and the aforesaid property.
4.
Pertinently, the Will was preceded by another Will dated 12.07.1993,
wherein the testator‟s sole property was bequeathed to the appellant and
Kishore Kumar @ Raju in equal shares. The testator had specifically
excluded his eldest son, i.e., Krishan Kumar, and eldest daughter, Krishna
Kumari, from his estate.
5.
Respondent nos. 2 and 4, i.e., Krishan Kumar and Krishna Kumari,
are the only contesting respondents, the others having not filed any objection
either before the Trial Court or in the present appeal.
6.
The impugned judgment is contested by the appellant, who contends
Digitally SignedPREM
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
21:54:29
FAO 348/2008
that the Trial Court failed to appreciate that the Will was the testator‟s last
and final testament and was attested by two witnesses, i.e., Mahendra Pal
Rastogi and Dr. K.K. Rathi. The former of the two also appeared and
testified to its execution.
7.
As per the case of the appellant, the testator, after executing the first
Will whereby respondent nos. 2 and 4 were excluded from his estate, took
further steps towards expressing his intent by disowning respondent no. 2
vide a declaration executed on 05.07.1993. Another declaration was made on
20.04.2004 whereby the testator, in fact, reiterated his desire to disown
respondent no. 2 on account of misbehaviour and the ill-treatment meted out
to him. In fact, a public notice dated 17.07.2004 was also published in the
newspaper, namely Rashtriya Sahara, disowning respondent no. 2 as well as
his wife and two children from all of the testator‟s moveable and
immoveable assets. On being excluded from the bequeathment, respondent
no. 2 filed a suit for partition bearing CS No. 480 of 2004, wherein a
preliminary decree of partition was passed on 11.08.2006. The appellant, on
his part, sought propounding of the Will by filing the underlying probate
petition as well as by challenging the preliminary decree for partition by
way of RFA 569-71/2006. The impugned judgment having been passed in
the probate petition, the RFAs also came to be disposed of by observing that
the preliminary decree of partition would remain subject to outcome of the
present appeal.
8.
Learned counsel for the appellant contends that the Trial Court failed
to appreciate that the Will in question was duly proved, having regard to
Section 63 of the ISA read with Section 68 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872
Digitally SignedPREM
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
21:54:29
FAO 348/2008
(hereinafter referred to as the “Evidence Act”), as the execution of the Will
was proved by one of the attesting witnesses, namely Mahendra Pal
Rastogi. Although the second witness initially could not appear, an
application filed seeking his examination through Local Commissioner was
dismissed by the Trial Court on 06.08.2007 without assigning any cogent
reason. It is also contended that the exclusion of respondent nos. 2 and 4
from the bequeathment is justified and sufficiently explained. In this regard,
learned counsel has referred to the earlier Will dated 12.07.1993, the
disownment declarations dated 05.07.1993 and 20.04.2004, as well as public
notice dated 17.07.2004 published in Rashtriya Sahara newspaper. The
testator has not only mentioned about the ill-treatment meted out to him at
the hands of respondent no. 2, but also went on to bar respondent no. 2 from
conducting the testator‟s final rites.
9.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents contended that, firstly,
Dr. K.K. Rathi has been wrongly mentioned as an attesting witness. In fact,
he had only certified, and could only be considered to have certified, that the
testator was in good health and mind. Secondly, even the attestation by
Mahendra Pal Rastogi does not establish the due execution of the Will in
question. Section 63 of the ISA requires attestation of a Will by at least two
witnesses. Further, Section 68 of the Evidence Act, which provides the
mode of proof for the execution of a document required by law to be
attested, stipulates that the document cannot be used as evidence unless one
of the attesting witnesses is called to prove its execution. In terms of Section
71 of the Evidence Act, in case the attesting witness denies or does not
recollect the execution of the document, its execution would need to be
Digitally SignedPREM
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
21:54:29
FAO 348/2008
proved by other evidence.
10.
To say that a Will has been duly executed, the requirements
mentioned in clauses (a), (b), and (c) of Section 63 of the ISA are to be
complied with, i.e., (a) the testator has to sign or affix his mark to the Will,
or it has to be signed by some other person in his presence and by his
direction; (b) the signature or mark of the testator, or the signature of the
person signing at his direction, has to appear at a place from which it could
appear that by that mark or signature the document is intended to have effect
as a Will; and (c) the most important point with which we are presently
concerned in this appeal, the Will has to be attested by two or more
witnesses, and each of these witnesses must have seen the testator sign or
affix his mark to the Will, or must have seen some other person sign the
Will in the presence and by the direction of the testator, or must have
received from the testator a personal acknowledgement of his signature or
mark, or of the signature of such other person, and each of the witnesses has
to sign the Will in the presence of the testator. (Ref: Janki Narayan Bhoir
Vs. Narayan Namdeo Kadam1.
11.
From the above, it is crystal clear that one of the requirements to
establish the due execution of a Will is its attestation by at least two more
witnesses. In Janki Narayan (supra), the Supreme Court further explained
how a document required by law to be attested can be proved. The relevant
paras are extracted hereunder:
“10. Section 68 of the Evidence Act speaks of as to how a document
required by law to be attested can be proved. According to the said
section, a document required by law to be attested shall not be used as
(2003) 2 SCC 91
Digitally SignedPREM
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
21:54:29
FAO 348/2008
evidence until one attesting witness at least has been called for the
purpose of proving its execution, if there be an attesting witness alive, and
subject to the process of the court and capable of giving evidence. It flows
from this section that if there be an attesting witness alive capable of
giving evidence and subject to the process of the Court, has to be
necessarily examined before the document required by law to be attested
can be used in an evidence. On a combined reading of Section 63 of the
Succession Act with Section 68 of the Evidence Act, it appears that a
person propounding the will has got to prove that the will was duly and
validly executed. That cannot be done by simply proving that the signature
on the will was that of the testator but must also prove that attestations
were also made properly as required by clause (c) of Section 63 of the
Succession Act. It is true that Section 68 of Evidence Act does not say that
both or all the attesting witnesses must be examined. But at least one
attesting witness has to be called for proving due execution of the will as
envisaged in Section 63. Although Section 63 of the Succession Act
requires that a will has to be attested at least by two witnesses, Section 68
of the Evidence Act provides that a document, which is required by law to
be attested, shall not be used as evidence until one attesting witness at
least has been examined for the purpose of proving its due execution if
such witness is alive and capable of giving evidence and subject to the
process of the Court. In a way, Section 68 gives a concession to those who
want to prove and establish a will in a court of law by examining at least
one attesting witness even though will has to be attested at least by two
witnesses mandatorily under Section 63 of the Succession Act. But what is
significant and to be noted is that one attesting witness examined should
be in a position to prove the execution of a will. To put in other words, if
one attesting witness can prove execution of the will in terms of clause (c)
of Section 63, viz., attestation by two attesting witnesses in the manner
contemplated therein, the examination of the other attesting witness can be
dispensed with. The one attesting witness examined, in his evidence has to
satisfy the attestation of a will by him and the other attesting witness in
order to prove there was due execution of the will. If the attesting witness
examined besides his attestation does not, in his evidence, satisfy the
requirements of attestation of the will by other witness also it falls short of
attestation of will at least by two witnesses for the simple reason that the
execution of the will does not merely mean the signing of it by the testator
but it means fulfilling and proof of all the formalities required under
Section 63 of the Succession Act. Where one attesting witness examined to
prove the will under Section 68 of the Evidence Act fails to prove the due
execution of the will then the other available attesting witness has to be
called to supplement his evidence to make it complete in all respects.
Where one attesting witness is examined and he fails to prove the
attestation of the will by the other witness there will be deficiency in
Digitally SignedPREM
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
21:54:29
FAO 348/2008
meeting the mandatory requirements of Section 68 of the Evidence Act.
11. Section 71 of the Evidence Act is in the nature of a safeguard to
the mandatory provisions of Section 68 of the Evidence Act, to meet a
situation where it is not possible to prove the execution of the will by
calling the attesting witnesses, though alive. This section provides that if
an attesting witness denies or does not recollect the execution of the will,
its execution may be proved by other evidence. Aid of Section 71 can be
taken only when the attesting witnesses, who have been called, deny or fail
to recollect the execution of the document to prove it by other evidence.
Section 71 has no application to a case where one attesting witness, who
alone had been summoned, has failed to prove the execution of the will
and other attesting witnesses though are available to prove the execution
of the same, for the reasons best known, have not been summoned before
the court. It is clear from the language of Section 71 that if an attesting
witness denies or does not recollect execution of the document, its
execution may be proved by other evidence. However, in a case where an
attesting witness examined fails to prove the due execution of will as
required under clause (c) of Section 63 of the Succession Act, it cannot be
said that the will is proved as per Section 68 of the Evidence Act. It cannot
be said that if one attesting witness denies or does not recollect the
execution of the document, the execution of will can be proved by other
evidence dispensing with the evidence of other attesting witnesses though
available to be examined to prove the execution of the will. Yet another
reason as to why other available attesting witnesses should be called when
the one attesting witness examined fails to prove due execution of the will
is to avert the claim of drawing adverse inference under Section 114
Illustration (g) of Evidence Act. Placing the best possible evidence, in the
given circumstances, before the Court for consideration, is one of the
cardinal principles of Indian Evidence Act. Section 71 is permissive and
an enabling Section permitting a party to lead other evidence in certain
circumstances. But Section 68 is not merely an enabling section. It lays
down the necessary requirements, which the court has to observe before
holding that a document is proved. Section 71 is meant to lend assistance
and come to the rescue of a party who had done his best, but driven to a
state of helplessness and impossibility, cannot be let down without any
other means of proving due execution by “other evidence” as well. At the
same time Section 71 cannot be read so as to absolve a party of his
obligation under Section 68 read with Section 63 of the Act and liberally
allow him, at his will or choice to make available or not a necessary
witness otherwise available and amenable to the jurisdiction of the court
concerned and confer a premium upon his omission or lapse, to enable
him to give a go-by to the mandate of law relating to proof of execution of
a will.”
Digitally SignedPREM
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
21:54:29
FAO 348/2008
12.
Admittedly, in the present case, only one of the witnesses, namely
Mahendra Pal Rastogi, appeared and testified. A perusal of his deposition
would show that, on account of business relations, he deposed that he was
called by the testator on 20.09.2004 and informed that the Will in question
had been executed on 10.09.2004 in favour of the present appellant. The
testator further requested the witness to put his signature on the Will. On
being explained the contents of the Will in vernacular, the witness put his
signature on the Will. On the next day, i.e., 21.09.2004, he along with the
testator and the testator‟s grandson, Amit Anand, went to the office of the
other witness, i.e., Dr. K.K. Rathi, and on the said date, the second witness
also put his signature on the Will in the presence of the first witness. In
cross-examination, he admitted that the signatures of the executant
appearing at points „A‟ to „G‟ were not put in his presence. One and a half
pages of the Will were already written, and the remaining part of the Will
was written in his presence on 20.09.2004. He also admitted that at the time
of execution of the Will on 10.09.2004, he was not present.
13.
The appellant also examined himself as PW-2 and deposed about the
execution of the first Will in the year 1993, as well as the execution of the
Will in question on 10.09.2004. The Will in question was exhibited as Ex.
PW-1/A. The witness further deposed that the Will was handwritten in the
handwriting of the testator. He, however, did not state in detail about the
attestation by the two witnesses. In cross-examination, he denied the
suggestion that the Will was not executed in his presence. He stated that the
signatures appearing at points „E‟, „F‟, and „G‟ of page 2 of the Will were
made on 20.09.2004.
Digitally SignedPREM
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
21:54:29
FAO 348/2008
14.
Amit Anand, the grandson of the testator, appeared as PW-3 and
admitted that the Will was not executed in his presence, however, he stated
about his presence at the time of the attestation of the Will by the second
witness, i.e., Dr. K.K. Rathi.
15.
The appellant also summoned one Ashok Kumar, a clerk from Canara
Bank, 74, Janpath, New Delhi, as PW-4 to place on record the Account
Opening Form of the testator‟s bank account. The witness, in his crossexamination, admitted that the signatures at point „A‟ on the said document
were not put in his presence.
16.
The above would show that the Will in question was executed in two
parts. The first part, whereby the testator had bequeathed his estate for the
benefit of the appellant and Kishore Kumar @ Raju, was executed on
10.09.2004. The testator had put his signatures on both the pages at points
„A‟ to „G‟. While the first attesting witness, i.e., Mahendra Pal Rastogi, had
appended his signature on 20.09.2004, the second witness appended his
signature as well as a certification of the testator‟s good health and mind.
There is no dispute that Mahendra Pal Rastogi had signed as an attesting
witness, the status of Dr. K.K. Rathi as the second attesting witness is
doubted.
17.
Two questions arise for consideration: first, whether Dr. K.K. Rathi
can be considered an attesting witness; and second, whether the execution of
the Will stands proved in terms of the deposition of the attesting witness,
i.e., Mahendra Pal Rastogi. The mere signing of a document does not
amount to attestation within the meaning of Section 63 of the ISA. The word
„attestation‟ means to bear witness to a fact. The essential conditions of a
Digitally SignedPREM
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
21:54:29
FAO 348/2008
valid attestation are: (i) two or more witnesses have seen the testator sign the
instrument; and (ii) each of them has signed the instrument in the presence
of the testator. The witness putting his signature has to append the same with
animus attestandi, which is the necessary ingredient to prove the factum of
attestation. The appending of the signature by Dr. K.K. Rathi does not
satisfy the requirement of proving either the attestation or the execution of
the document. The said witness merely appended his signatures certifying
that the testator was in good health. Needless to observe, the appending of
his signature was done on 21.09.2004.
Coming to the second issue, concededly, Mahendra Pal Rastogi had
attested the Will on 20.09.2004. In his evidence, he admitted that he was not
present at the time of the execution of the Will on 10.09.2004. The
execution and attestation having been done on different dates, the attesting
witness not being present at the time of execution, cannot be held to satisfy
the requirement of proof of execution. Even the appellant‟s reliance on
Section 65(c) of the Evidence Act is misplaced, as neither the appellant nor
his son have stated to be present at the time of execution. Though the
appellant in his examination-in-chief did not state of his being present at the
time of execution, however, in cross-examination he stated otherwise. The
Will is an unregistered document.
18.
The Trial Court noted that the appellant‟s deposition in cross-
examination is contradictory not only to Mahendra Pal Rastogi‟s
examination-in-chief but also to the record. The Trial Court also noted a
contraction in the statement of the appellant, as he had stated that the
signatures at points „E‟, „F‟, and „G‟ at page 2 of the Will were put on
Digitally SignedPREM
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
21:54:29
FAO 348/2008
20.09.2004, whereas the same were actually put on 10.09.2004.
19.
As noted above, respondent no. 2 had filed a partition suit, in which
the statement of the appellant was recorded, wherein the appellant had
admitted that the Will in question was not written in his presence. The Trial
Court, on an overall assessment, reached the conclusion that not only was
the Will shrouded by suspicious circumstances, but the alleged Will is also
not in conformity with the requirements of Section 63(c) of the ISA.
20.
In the considered opinion of this Court, even on a re-appreciation of
the facts and the evidence on record, there is no reason to differ from the
conclusion reached by the Trial Court. Accordingly, the impugned judgment
is upheld, and the present appeal is dismissed.
(MANOJ KUMAR OHRI)
JUDGE
MAY 26, 2026
na
Digitally SignedPREM
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
21:54:29
FAO 348/2008
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review