Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:HHC:3285
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
Cr. MP (M) No. 2954 of 2025
Reserved on : 06.01.2026
Decided on : 09.01.2026
Gurwinder Singh
....Petitioner
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh
.…Respondent
Coram
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sushil Kukreja, Judge
Whether approved for reporting?1
_______________________________________________________
For the petitioner:
Mr. Karan Kapoor and Mr. Nitish,
Advocates.
For the respondent:
Mr. Ankush Thakur, Deputy Advocate
General.
________________________________________________
Sushil Kukreja, Judge
The instant bail application has been filed by the
petitioner under Section 483 of Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha
Sanhita (for short “BNSS) for grant of bail in case FIR No.
321/2022, dated 06.12.2022,
registered at Police Station
Nalagarh, Police District Baddi, H.P., under Sections 302, 323,
504 read with Section 34 of Indian Penal Code ( for short “IPC”).
2.
Brief facts of the case, as per the status report filed
by the respondent-State, are that on 06.12.2022, one Nand Lal,
1. Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
( 2026:HHC:3285
Chairman, New Serenity Home Center, Nalagarh, made a
complaint to the police, stating therein that a quarrel took place
in the Center and a person, who sustained injuries in the
quarrel, was taken to PGI Chandigarh for treatment. Later on,
the police was informed that Deepak Kumar who sustained
injuries died in PGI. Thereafter, during the course of
investigation, police recorded statement of one Vikram Singh
under Section 154 Cr. P.C., who stated that as he was a drug
addict so he was admitted in the Serenity Home Center on
20.11.2022. He further stated that during intervening night of
5/6.12.2022, at around 01:30 a.m., Sandeep Kumar, Gurwinder
Singh (petitioner herein), Imran Khan and Hardeep Singh came
inside the Center and Sandeep Kumar shouted the names of
Sumit, Ashok, Deepak, Shivam and Amrit Pal.
Accused
Sandeep along with other accused persons slapped Deepak
and they also took off the clothes of Sumit Kumar, Ashok,
Deepak, Shivam and Amrit Pal and thereafter for about three
hours, with intervals, the accused persons gave beatings to the
above persons. Accused Hardeep Singh gave beatings with the
help of bamboo stick. Later on, the accused persons left the
( 2026:HHC:3285
spot, however, at around 07:00 a.m., in the morning, they again
came back and gave beatings to the above five persons.
Deepak was lying on the floor, who asked for water, so Vikram
Singh and others gave him water and he fell unconscious.
Thereafter, the accused persons came inside and made Deepak
to wear clothes and took him outside. After half an hour,
accused persons also took other injured persons out of the
room. In his statement, Vikram Singh further disclosed that
while the accused persons were giving beatings, they were also
using abusive language and saying “how dare you brought
chitta (heroin) inside.”
Injured Deepak was shifted to PGI,
Chandigarh for treatment, but later on he succumbed to the
injuries. On the basis of the aforesaid statement of Vikram
Singh, police registered the case and the investigation
commenced.
3.
The police during the course of investigation,
collected scientific samples, effected relevant recoveries and
recorded the statements of the witnesses.
Postmortem
examination on the corpse of the deceased was conducted.
Accused Imran and Hardeep were arrested on 07.12.2022. On
( 2026:HHC:3285
19.01.2023, accused Sandeep @ Kola surrendered himself
before the police. On 14.12.2022 the petitioner was arrested.
4.
As per the prosecution story during interrogation,
accused Hardeep got recovered the chappals and bamboo
sticks, with which, he alongwith Goni @ Gurwinder Singh
(petitioner herein), Imran and Happy @ Sukhwinder Singh gave
beatings to Sumit, Ashok, Deepak, Shivam and Amrit Pal on
5/6.12.2022 in New Serenity Home, Nalagarh.
interrogation,
petitioner Gurwinder Singh
During
disclosed that on
5/6.12.2022, at about 1:30 A.M., he alongwith Hardeep, Imran,
Happy @ Sukhwinder Singh gave beatings to Sumit, Ashok,
Deepak, Shivam and Amrit Pal with chappals and bamboo
sticks at Serenity Home, Nalagarh.
On 25.02.2023 accused
Sukhwinder Singh joined the investigation and disclosed that on
05.12.2022 he, alongwith Hardeep, Goni @ Gurwinder Singh,
Imran, Arman and Jagota were sleeping in the upper floor of
New Serenity Home Nalagarh. On that day, there was recovery
party of Imran and after cutting cake at about 12:00 midnight
they went to sleep. Around 1:30 A.M., in the hall where patients
were sleeping, he heard loud noise. He went near window and
( 2026:HHC:3285
heard other persons stating that Amit, Ashok and Deepak were
sniffing some substance. He disclosed this fact to Sandeep and
thereafter, Sandeep dislosed the same to Gurwinder. Sandeep
and Imran went to the hall and personally searched Amit, Ashok
and Deepak and recovered chitta from Deepak and on asking,
Deepak disclosed that he was having chitta and he gave it to
Amit, Ashok, Shivam and Amrit Pal. Thereafter, Hardeep went
outside and brought a stick with him and gave blows to them
with bamboo stick and chappals. Sandeep and Gurwinder also
gave beatings to them with bamboo stick. He also slapped them
as he was directed to do so by Gurwinder being their Manager.
Hardeep, Gurwinder and Sandeep also asked all five boys to
open their clothes and they were made to sit naked near the
wall. All five boys were beaten for upto two hours and blood
started oozing out from the ear of Deepak. Around 7:45 A.M.,
Sandeep told him that there is no movement in the body of
Deepak and was taken to PGI Chandigarh, however, he
succumbed to the injuries.
5.
The bail application has been filed by the petitioner
on the ground that he is innocent and has been falsely
( 2026:HHC:3285
implicated in the present case. Learned counsel for the petitioner
contended that the petitioner is in judicial custody since
14.12.2022 and the trial is not going to be completed in near
future, as out of total 35 witnesses cited by the prosecution, till
date, only 05 witnesses have been examined, therefore, the
petitioner deserves to be released on bail, as no fruitful purpose
would be served by keeping him behind the bars for an unlimited
period. He further contended that there is inordinate delay in
conclusion of trial, which infringes upon the right of speedy trial of
the petitioner, as such, he is entitled to be released on bail on the
ground that his right of speedy trial has been violated.
6.
Per contra, the Deputy Additional Advocate General
opposed the bail application on the ground that the petitioner
does not deserve to be released on bail as he has been found
involved in a serious offence of murder and in case he is
released on bail, he may tamper with the prosecution evidence
or may also flee from justice. He further contended that the
present bail application filed by the petitioner is the successive
one, which is liable to be dismissed as there is no change in
circumstances after the dismissal of the earlier bail applications.
7.
( 2026:HHC:3285
I have heard learned counsel for the petitioner as
well as learned Additional Advocate General for the State and
also carefully gone through the material available on record.
8.
Pertinently, the present is the successive bail
application filed by the petitioner. Earlier, the petitioner had
preferred bail applications being Cr. MP(M) No. 2125 of 2023,
which came to be dismissed vide order dated 12.12.2023 and
Cr. MP(M) No. 953 of 2024, which came to be dismissed vide
order dated 02.08.2024.
9.
It is a well settled principle of law that when the
successive bail application comes before the Court, the Court
would be very conscious while considering the same. As held by
the Hon’ble Apex Court in State of Maharashtra Vs. Captain
Buddhikota Subha Rao, AIR 1989 SC 2292, that successive
bail application can be entertained by the Court when
substantial change is established by the accused, which would
entitle him for getting bail in successive bail application. The
Court should not pass the order of releasing the accused on bail
in successive bail application merely establishing some
cosmetic change between time gap of two applications. There
( 2026:HHC:3285
should be drastic change during the period between two
applications, which would entitle the accused for bail.
10.
In State of M.P vs. Kajad (2001) 7 SCC 673 Hon'ble
Supreme Court categorically considered that when there are
no changed circumstances, the successive bail application is
nothing but review of the earlier application which cannot be
maintainable. The relevant portion of the aforesaid judgment
reads as under:
“8. It has further to be noted that the factum of the
rejection of his earlier bail application bearing Misc. case
No. 2052 of 2000 on 5.6.2000 has not been denied by the
respondent. It is true that successive bail applications
are permissible under the changed circumstances. But
without the change in the circumstances the second
application would be deemed to be seeking review of the
earlier judgment which is not permissible under criminal
law as has been held by this Court in Hari Singh Mann v.
Harbhajan Singh Bajwa ((2001) 1 SCC 169) and various
other judgments.”
11.
In State of Tamilnadu vs. S.A.Raja (2005) 8 SCC
380 Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that:
“9. When a learned Single Judge of the same Court had
denied bail to the respondent for certain reasons and
that order was unsuccessfully challenged before the
appellate forum, without there being any major change of
circumstances, another fresh application should not
have been dealt with within a short span of time unless
there were valid grounds giving rise to a tenable case for
bail. Of course, the principles of res judicata are not
applicable to bail applications, but the repeated filing of
the bail applications without there being any change of
circumstances would lead to bad precedents.”
12.
( 2026:HHC:3285
In the case of Kalyan Chandra Sarkar,vs Rajesh
Ranjan (2004) 7SCC 528 Hon'ble Supreme Court held as
follows:
“20. "Before concluding, we must note though an
accused has a right to make successive applications for
grant of bail, the Court entertaining such subsequent bail
applications has a duty to consider the reasons and
grounds on which the earlier bail applications were
rejected. In such cases, the Court also has a duty to
record what are the fresh grounds which persuade it to
take a view different from the one taken in the earlier
applications………."
13.
In Virupakshappa Gouda & another vs. State of
Karnataka and another (2017) 5 Supreme Court Cases 406
Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that:
“12. On a perusal of the order passed by the learned trial
Judge, we find that he has been swayed by the factum
that when a charge-sheet is filed it amounts to change of
circumstance. Needless to Say, filing of the charge-sheet
does not in any manner lessen the allegations made by
the prosecution. On the contrary, filing of the chargesheet establishes that after due investigation the
investigating agency, having found materials, has placed
the charge- sheet for trial of the accused persons. As is
further demonstrable, the learned trial Judge has
remained absolutely oblivious of the fact that the
appellants had moved the special leave petition before
this Court for grant of bail and the same was not
entertained. Be it noted, the second bail application was
filed before the Principal Sessions Judge after filing of
the charge-sheet which was challenged in the High Court
and that had travelled to this Court. These facts,
unfortunately, have not been taken note of by the learned
trial Judge……….”
14.
A perusal of the aforementioned judgments indicates
that successive bail applications are permissible under the
( 2026:HHC:3285
changed circumstances, but the change of circumstances must
be substantial one, which has a direct impact on the earlier
decision and not merely cosmetic changes which are of little or
no consequence. Without the change in the circumstances, the
subsequent bail application would be deemed to be seeking
review of the earlier rejection order, which is not permissible
under criminal law. While entertaining such subsequent bail
applications, the Court has a duty to consider the reasons and
grounds on which the earlier bail application was rejected and
what are the fresh grounds which persuade it warranting the
evaluation and consideration of the bail application afresh and
to take a view different from the one taken in the earlier
application. There must be change in the fact situation or in law
which requires the earlier view being interfered with or where
the earlier finding has become obsolete.
15.
In the instant case, after the dismissal of the earlier
bail applications, learned counsel for the petitioner has failed to
point out any substantial change in the circumstances which
would entitle the petitioner to file the present application.
( 2026:HHC:3285
Therefore, in absence of any changed circumstances, the
present successive application for bail cannot be entertained
16.
Learned counsel for the petitioner next contended
that the petitioner is in custody since 14.12.2022 and the trial in
the case is not likely to be concluded in near future, therefore,
he deserves to be released on bail on the ground of delay in
trial. However, mere fact that the petitioner is in custody for the
last more than three years is no ground to grant him bail, as the
allegations against the petitioner are serious and grave in
nature.
Although, Article 21 of the Constitution of India
guarantees speedy trial and an under trial prisoner cannot be
detained in jail/custody for an indefinite period, but, mere period
of incarceration or the fact that the trial is not likely to be
concluded in near future cannot entitle the petitioner to be
enlarged on bail, as the petitioner is prima facie found involved
in a serious offence of murder.
17.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case reported in
Chenna Boyanna Krishna Yadav Vs. State of Maharashtra
and another (2007) 1 SCC 242 has held that when the gravity
of offence alleged is severe, mere period of incarceration or the
( 2026:HHC:3285
fact that the trial is not likely to be concluded in near future
cannot entitle the petitioner to be enlarged on bail. The relevant
portion of the aforesaid judgment reads as under:"16……………It is true that when the gravity of the offence
alleged is severe, mere period of incarceration or the fact
that the trial is not likely to be concluded in the near future
either by itself or conjointly may not entitle the accused to be
enlarged on bail. Nevertheless, both these factors may also
be taken into consideration while deciding the question of
grant of bail."
(Emphasis supplied)
18.
In the case of State of Bihar and another Vs. Amit
Kumar alias Bachcha Rai (2017) 13 SCC 751, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court has reiterated that where there is seriousness
of the offence, the mere fact that the accused is languishing in
jail during trial should not be the concern of the courts. The
relevant portion of the aforesaid judgment reads as under:"8. A bare reading of the order impugned discloses that the
High Court has not given any reasoning while granting bail.
In a mechanical way, the High Court granted bail more on the
fact that the accused is already in custody for a long time.
When the seriousness of the offence is such the mere fact
that he was in jail for however long time should not be the
concern of the courts. We are not able to appreciate such a
casual approach while granting bail in a case which has the
effect of undermining the trust of people in the integrity of the
education system in the State of Bihar."
19.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case reported in
(2004) 7 SCC 528 (Kalyan Chandra Sarkar Vs. Rajesh
Ranjan alias Pappu Yadav and another) has held that three
( 2026:HHC:3285
years incarceration would not itself entitle the accused-applicant
to be released on bail nor the fact that the trial is not likelihood
to be concluded in near future would be sufficient for enlarging
the accused-applicant on bail considering the gravity of offence.
Paragraph-14 of the said judgment, which is relevant, is
extracted hereunder:"14. We have already noticed from the arguments of learned
counsel for the appellant that the present accused had
earlier made seven applications for grant of bail which were
rejected by the High Court and some such rejections have
been affirmed by this Court also. It is seen from the records
that when the fifth application for grant of bail was allowed by
the High Court, the same was challenged before this Court
and this Court accepted the said challenge by allowing the
appeal filed by the Union of India and another and cancelled
the bail granted by the High Court as per the order of this
Court made in Criminal Appeal No. 745 of 2001 dated 25-72001 [Rajesh Ranjan v. State of Bihar, (2000) 9 SCC 222] .
While cancelling the said bail this Court specifically held that
the fact that the present accused was in custody for more
than one year (at that time) and the further fact that while
rejecting an earlier application, the High Court had given
liberty to renew the bail application in future, were not
grounds envisaged under Section 437(1)(i) of the Code. This
Court also in specific terms held that the condition laid down
under Section 437(1)(i) is sine qua non for granting bail even
under Section 439 of the Code. In the impugned order it is
noticed that the High Court has given the period of
incarceration already undergone by the accused and the
unlikelihood of trial concluding in the near future as grounds
sufficient to enlarge the accused on bail, in spite of the fact
that the accused stands charged of offences punishable with
life imprisonment or even death penalty. In such cases, in our
opinion, the mere fact that the accused has undergone
certain period of incarceration (three years in this case) by
itself would not entitle the accused to being enlarged on bail,
nor the fact that the trial is not likely to be concluded in the
near future either by itself or coupled with the period of
incarceration would be sufficient for enlarging the appellant
( 2026:HHC:3285
on bail when the gravity of the offence alleged is severe and
there are allegations of tampering with the witnesses by the
accused during the period he was on bail."
20.
Thus when the gravity of the offence alleged is
severe, mere long incarceration in jail as under-trial is not
sufficient ground to enlarge an accused on bail if the facts &
circumstances of the case and interest of the society do not
warrant for enlarging the accused-applicant on bail. In the
instant case, the trial is in progress and the case is being listed
for recording the statements of the prosecution witnesses and
there is every likelihood of the trial being concluded in near
future, therefore, mere fact that the petitioner is in custody for
the last more than three years is no ground to grant him bail.
21.
Hence, in view of the facts and circumstances of the
present case, this Court is of the view that after the dismissal of
the earlier bail applications, there is no substantial change in the
circumstances which would entitle the petitioner to file the
present application. Therefore, in absence of any changed
circumstances, the present successive application for bail
cannot be entertained.
22.
( 2026:HHC:3285
Hence, for the reasons mentioned above, the bail
application filed by the petitioner is dismissed. However, since
the petitioner is behind the bars since 14.12.2022, the learned
trial Court is directed to conclude the trial as expeditiously as
possible.
23.
Be it stated that any expression of opinion given in
this order does not mean an expression of opinion on the merits
of the case and the trial Court will not be influenced by any
observations made therein.
January 09, 2026
(raman)
( Sushil Kukreja )
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review