Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
1. CWP-28189-2025 (O&M)
Surinder Kumar
....Petitioner
Versus
Union of India and others
....Respondents
Sr Case No.
Petitioner(s)
No.
CWP-10061-2026 Dalip Kumar
CWP-10084-2026 Abhiman
Banewal
CWP-10165-2026 Sohan Singh
CWP-10198-2025 Devi Singh
CWP-10254-2026 Hawa Singh
CWP-10260-2026 Prithvi Raj
CWP-10308-2026 Naresh Dutta
CWP-10974-2026 Baghrawat Mal
10 CWP-10975-2026 Surjeet Singh
11 CWP-10991-2026 Dalip Singh
12 CWP-10994-2026 Jeet Singh
13 CWP-11668-2026 Ranbir Singh
14 CWP-12292-2026 Parladh Singh
15 CWP-12760-2026 Shinder
Pal
Singh
16 CWP-12847-2026 Rawait
Singh
Gabbi
17 CWP-12849-2026 Bhagwant Singh
Brar
18 CWP-13094-2026 Rakesh Chander
19 CWP-13193-2026 Inder Pal Singh
20 CWP-13240-2026 Mohinder Kumar
21 CWP-13748-2026 Raj
Kumar
Sharma
22 CWP-13815-2026 Surinder
Pal
Singh
23 CWP-14960-2026 Subhash Chander
24 CWP-15980-2026 Balwant Singh
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
Respondent(s)
Union of India and others
Union of India and others
Union of India and others
Union of India and others
Union of India and others
Union of India and others
Union of India and others
Union of India and others
Union of India and others
Union of India and others
Union of India and others
Union of India and others
Union of India and others
Union of India and others
Union of India and others
Union of India and others
Union of India and others
Union of India and others
Union of India and others
Union of India and others
Union of India and others
Union of India and others
Central Provident Fund
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
and another
Commissioner and others
CWP-16523-2022 Rajesh
Kumar The Employees Provident
Ghai and others
Fund Organization and
others
CWP-167-2026
Surinder Kumar Employees
Provident
and others
Fund Organization and
others
CWP-1804-2026 Mohan Lal and Union of India and others
others
CWP-20543-2025 Aseem
Kumar Union of India and others
Agarwal
CWP-2573-2026 Rajesh Kumar
Union of India and others
CWP-2575-2026 Megh Raj and Union of India and others
others
CWP-2580-2026 Satinder Singh Union of India and others
Chattha
CWP-303-2025
Raman Kaplish
Union of India and others
CWP-310-2026
Baur Singh
Union of India and others
CWP-3137-2026 Karamjit Singh Union of India and others
Sidhu and others
CWP-31618-2024 Rajesh
Union of India and others
Chaudhary
CWP-31854-2025 Sajjan Kumar
Union of India and others
CWP-31916-2025 Shisupal Singh Union of India and others
and others
CWP-32519-2025 Raghubir Singh
Union of India and others
CWP-32522-2025 Sajjan Kumar
Union of India and others
CWP-32935-2025 Zora Singh and Union of India and others
others
CWP-33105-2024 Rajender Singh The Employees Provident
Malik and others Fund Organization and
others
CWP-33143-2025 Jagpal Singh
Union of India and others
CWP-33173-2025 Balraj Rahej
Union of India and others
CWP-33335-2025 Dalbir Singh
Union of India and others
CWP-34409-2024 Shiv Kumar
Union of India and others
CWP-34624-2025 Ajmer Singh
Union of India and others
CWP-34655-2025 Raghbir Singh
Union of India and others
CWP-34973-2025 Mahabir Singh
Union of India and others
CWP-3513-2026 Hardip Singh
Union of India and others
CWP-35927-2025 Tarsem
Singh Union of India and others
and others
CWP-37188-2025 Krishan Kumar
Union of India and others
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-37230-2025 Jai Bhagwan and Union of India and others
others
CWP-38264-2025 Sanjay Dewan
The Employees Provident
Fund Organization and
others
CWP-4125-2026 Sanjay Garg and Union of India and others
others
CWP-4169-2025 Amarjit
Singh Union of India and others
Sekhon
CWP-4174-2025 Jai
Bhushan Union of India and others
Chandan
CWP-5280-2026 Sanjeev Kumar
Union of India and others
CWP-56-2026
Jaila Ram Swan
Union of India and others
CWP-5695-2026 Raj Kumar
Union of India and others
CWP-576-2026
Gurskander
Union of India and others
Singh and others
CWP-6404-2026 Mahavir Parshad Union of India and others
and others
CWP-6494-2026 Sanjiv
Kumar Union of India and others
and others
CWP-7681-2026 Jaswant
Singh Union of India and others
and others
CWP-7686-2026 Makhan Singh
Union of India and others
CWP-8160-2025 Neelam Chopra Union of India and others
and another
CWP-8612-2024 Shree
Krishan The Employees Provident
Sharma
and Fund Organisation and
others
others
CWP-8943-2026 Devinder Kumar Union of India and others
CWP-8944-2026 Gurdip Singh
Union of India and others
CWP-9028-2026 Ajay
Kumar Union of India and others
Sharma
CWP-9099-2025 Chander
Bosh The Employees Provident
Kaushik
and Fund Organization and
others
others
CWP-9129-2026 Surinder Singh Union of India and others
Grewal
CWP-9182-2026 Satish Kumar
Union of India and others
CWP-9585-2026 Surjan Singh
Union of India and others
CWP-9633-2026 Garib Dass
Union of India and others
CWP-9974-2026 Subhash Chander Union of India and others
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
1.
Date(s) when
reserved
judgment
was 25.03.2026,
07.05.2026,
25.05.2026
2.
Date of pronouncement of
judgment
Date of uploading judgment
27.05.2026
3.
4.
5.
27.05.2026
Whether operative part or full
Full
judgment is pronounced
Delay, if any, in pronouncing of
Not Applicable
full judgment and reasons thereof
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARPREET SINGH BRAR
Present:
Mr. Ankit Midha, Advocate for the petitioner(s)
in CWP-28189-2025, CWP-310-2026, CWP-56-2026,
CWP-9182-2026, CWP-9129-2026, CWP-8944-2026
CWP-8943-2026, CWP-9585-2026, CWP-9633-2026,
CWP-10165-2026, CWP-10308-2026, CWP-12760-2026,
CWP-12847-2026, CWP-12849-2026, CWP-13094-2026.
Mr. Himanshu Chhabra, Advocate
for the petitioner in CWP-576-2026.
Dr. Sumati Jund, Advocate with Mr. Rahul Saini, Advocate
for the petitioner(s) in CWP-2573-2026, CWP-2575-2026
and CWP-2580-2026.
Mr. Hitesh Pandit, Advocate
for the petitioner in CWP-6404-2026.
Mr. Abhijeet Singh Rawaley, Advocate
for the petitioner in CWP-4125-2026.
Mr. Mahabir Singh Tanwar, Advocate
for the petitioner(s) in CWP-31854-2025,
CWP-32519-2025, CWP-32522-2025, CWP-33143-2025,
CWP-33173-2025, CWP-33335-2025, CWP-34624-2025,
CWP-34973-2025, CWP-37188 -2025, CWP-5695-2026,
CWP-5280-2026, CWP-14960-2026, CWP-9974-2026,
CWP-10061-2026, CWP-10084-2026, CWP-10254-2026,
CWP-10260-2026, CWP-10974-2026, CWP-10975-2026,
CWP-10991-2026, CWP-10994-2026, CWP-11668-2026,
CWP-12292-2026, CWP-13193-2026, CWP-13240-2026,
CWP-13815-2026 and CWP-13748-2026.
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
Ms. Pooja Chopra, Sr. Advocate
with Mr. Tapish Gupta, Advocate
for the petitioner in CWP-167-2026.
Mr. Jai Bhagwan Sharma, Advocate
for the petitioners in CWP-8612-2024, CWP-33105-2024,
CWP-16523-2022 and CWP-38264-2025.
Mr. Amit Sharma (Kanav), Advocate
with Mr. Deepankur Sharma, Advocate
and Ms. Jaskiran Kaur Bassi, Advocate
for the petitioners in CWP-37230-2025.
Mr. Ashutosh Kaushik, Advocate
for the petitioner(s) in CWP-9099-2025.
Mr. A.S. Walia, Advocate
for the petitioner(s) in CWP-9028-2026, CWP-7681-2026,
CWP-7686-2026, CWP-1804-2026, CWP-3137-2026,
CWP-31916-2025, CWP-32935-2025, CWP-35927-2025.
Mr. Raman Kaplish (petitioner in person)
in CWP-303-2025.
Mr. Prateek Pandit, Advocate
for the petitioner in CWP-3513-2026.
Mr. Om Parkash Sharma, Advocate
for the petitioner in CWP-31618-2024.
Mr. Amit Sharma, Advocate
for the petitioner in CWP-15980-2026.
Mr. Shiv Kumar, Advocate (petitioner in person)
in CWP-34409-2024.
Mr. Raman Kaplish, Advocate (except in CWP-303-2025)
and Mr. Lovedev Singh, Advocate
for the petitioner(s) in remaining cases.
Mr. H.S. Gill, Advocate for
respondent No.1 in CWP-576-2026.
Mr. Prince Singh, Advocate
with Ms. Navya Jindal, Advocate for respondent No.4
in CWP-31854-2025 and CWP-38264-2025
and for respondent No.5
in CWP-34973-2025 and CWP-31618-2024.
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
Mr. Deepak Goyat, Advocate for respondent No.5
in CWP-33143-2025, CWP-33173-2025,
CWP-33335-2025
and for respondent No.4 in CWP-10260-2026,
CWP-12292-2026, CWP-13240-2026, CWP-14960-2026
and for respondent No.5 in CWP-9974-2026,
CWP-10061-2026, CWP-10084-2026, CWP-10254-2026,
CWP-10974-2026, CWP-10975-2026, CWP-10991-2026,
CWP-10994-2026, CWP-11668-2026
and CWP-13193-2026.
Ms. Monika Sharma, Advocate for respondent No.5
in CWP-7681-2026 and CWP-310-2026
and for respondent No.4 in CWP-1804-2026.
Mr. V.P. Malik, Advocate
for respondent No.6 in CWP-34973-2025.
Mr. Yash Garg, Advocate
with Mr. Shailesh Aggarwal, Advocate
for respondent No.4 in CWP-167-2026 (through V.C.)
Ms. Gehna Vaishnavi, Advocate
for respondent No.4 in CWP-16523-2022.
Ms. Nikita Goel, Advocate
with Ms. Naina Ranot, Advocate
for respondent No.4 in CWP-5695-2026.
Ms. Anjali Singh, Advocate
for Mr. Rajesh Gaur, Advocate
for respondent No.5 in CWP-8612-2024
and for respondent No.3 in CWP-33105-2024.
Mr. Subhash Ahuja, Advocate
for respondent No.4 in CWP-5280-2026.
Mr. Rahul Verma, Advocate
for respondent No.4 in CWP-9129-2026
and CWP-3137-2026
and for respondent No.5 in CWP-12849-2026, CWP12847-2026 and CWP-13094-2026.
Mr. Samir Rathaur, Advocate for respondents No.2 and 3
in CWP-31854-2025 and CWP-32519-2025
and for respondent/EPFO
in CWP-9585-2026 and CWP-12847-2026
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
and for respondents No.2 and 3
in CWP-34409-2024 and CWP-3137-2026.
Mr. Rajesh Hooda, Advocate
for respondents No.2 and 3 in CWP-303-2025,
CWP-4169-2025, CWP-4174-2025, CWP-6494-2026,
CWP-8160-2025, CWP-10198-2025, CWP-20543-2025,
CWP-31618-2024, CWP-32935-2025 and CWP-34655-2025
and for the respondent/EPFO in remaining cases.
Ms. Vaishali Jain, Advocate
for respondent-Housefed in CWP-33335-2025,
CWP-31854-2025, CWP-32519-2025, CWP-32522-2025,
CWP-34624-2025, CWP-37188-2025
and CWP-5695-2026.
Mr. Arun Gosain, Advocate
with Mr. Ramandeep Singh Sandhu,
Advocate for respondent No.5 in CWP-576-2026.
Mr. Himmat Singh, Advocate
and Mr. Bhanu Singh Rohilla, Advocate
for respondent in CWP-6404-2026 and CWP-7686-2026
for respondent No.5/PWRMDC in CWP-12760-2026,
CWP-9585-2026, CWP-10165-2026, CWP-10308-2026,
CWP-13094-2026 and CWP-9633-2026.
Mr. Gaurav Tangri, Advocate
for respondents No.2 and 3
in CWP-34409-2024 and CWP-3137-2026.
Ms. Navyug Geet Brar, Advocate
for respondent No.4 in CWP-10198-2025,
CWP-8160-2025, CWP-4169-2025, CWP-4174-2025 and
CWP-20543-2025.
Mr. G.S. Khokhar, Advocate
for respondent No.4
in CWP-32935-2025 and CWP-31916-2025.
Ms. Hanima Grewal, Advocate
for respondent No.4 in CWP-34409-2024.
Mr. Ankit Kumar, Advocate
for respondent No.4 in CWP-303-2025 (through V.C.)
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
HARPREET SINGH BRAR J. (Oral)
1.
With the consent of all the parties, the aforementioned writ
petitions are taken up together and are being decided by this common
judgment. However, for the sake of brevity, the facts are taken from
CWP-28189-2025.
PRAYER
2.
The writ petition (CWP-28189-2025) has been filed under
Articles 226/227 of the Constitution of India seeking the following
reliefs:
a. Issuance of a writ in the nature of Certiorari quashing the
Circular dated 18.01.2025 (Annexure P-8) regarding
computation of pension on pro-rata basis for pensioners
whose pension is calculated on higher wages as well as the
instructions issued vide e-mail dated 14.02.2024 (Annexure
P-7) outlining the method for calculating pensions on
higher wages.
b. Issuance of a writ in the nature of Certiorari for quashing
Conditions No.6 and 7 of the Joint Declaration Form
prescribed by the respondents as a pre-condition for
exercising joint option under Para 11(4) of the Employees
Pension Scheme, 1995, being ultra vires the scheme and
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Employees
Provident Fund Organisation v. Sunil Kumar B. 2022(4)
SCT 674.
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
c. Issuance of a writ in the nature of Mandamus directing the
respondents to:
i.
Calculate pension of the petitioner on the basis of
Para 11(4) read with Para 12 of Employees' Pension
Scheme, 1995, on actual wages without pro-rata
reduction and to pay all consequential arrears;
ii.
Pay interest at least at the rate of 8% p.a. on all
arrears of pension from the date of retirement till
actual realization, as well as for the specific period of
delay in issuance of the revised Pension Payment
Order (PPO);
iii.
Recalculate the arrears of pension by ensuring parity
between the wages on which additional contribution
was collected and the wages reckoned for pension
fixation, along with interest at the rate of 8% p.a.;
and
iv.
Refund the excess interest collected from the
petitioner on the contribution on salary exceeding the
wage ceiling.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER(S)
●
The application of pro-rata formula in ‘Higher Wages’ cases
is illegal and arbitrary
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner(s) inter alia contended
that on 04.03.1952, the Employees’ Provident Funds and Miscellaneous
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
Provisions Act, 1952 was enacted and brought into force for the
institution of provident funds, pension fund and deposit-linked
insurance fund for employees in factories and other establishments.
Subsequently, on 16.11.1995, under Section 6A of the aforesaid Act, the
Employees’ Pension Scheme 1995 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘1995
Pension Scheme’) was notified so as to provide for monthly pensions
payable post retirement. The purpose behind setting up the said scheme
was to create a pension fund whereby employees could receive pension
as a social security measure meant to assist them in their old age.
3.1
It was submitted that the petitioner joined service of Punjab
Water Resources Management and Development Corporation Limited,
as a Clerk on 09.10.1980 and was promoted as Senior Assistant on
04.06.1985 and further as Divisional Accounts Officer on 21.09.2001.
The petitioner retired from the service of the Corporation on 31.08.2019
(Annexure P-1).
3.2
Learned counsel argued that the petitioner was a member of
the 1995 Pension Scheme since its inception. The Scheme provides for
grant of pension to employees/members who superannuate after
attaining the age of 58 years and upon completion of 10 years of
service. The formula for computation of the quantum thereof is also
provided in Paragraph 12 of the 1995 Pension Scheme. Furthermore,
Paragraph 11 of the Scheme deals with the determination of
‘Pensionable Salary’. At that point of time, maximum pensionable
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
salary was ₹5,000/- and this sum was subsequently enhanced to
₹6,500/- and further, vide notification dated 22.08.2014, to ₹15,000/-.
3.3
It was contended that w.e.f. 16.03.1996, a proviso was
inserted in Paragraph 11(3) of the Scheme, enabling both the employer
and the employee to exercise an option for contribution on salary
exceeding the prescribed ceiling of ₹6,500/- (which was ₹5,000/- per
month prior to 08.10.2001 and ₹15,000/- per month with effect from
01.09.2014), so as to retain entitlement to pension under the Scheme. In
this regard, it was provided that 8.33% of the employer’s contribution,
calculated on the employee’s salary (being the deductible amount
towards the Provident Fund), was required to be remitted to the Pension
Fund. As noted above, the Scheme was further modified vide
notification dated 22.08.2014, w.e.f. 01.09.2014.
3.4
Learned counsel submitted that, in terms of Paragraph
11(4) of the 1995 Pension Scheme, members who were in service as on
01.09.2014 and who, at the option of both the employer and the
employee, had been contributing on salary exceeding ₹6,500/- per
month, are entitled to exercise a fresh joint option to continue
contributing on salary exceeding ₹15,000/- per month. It was further
submitted that, in such cases, the pensionable salary of these members is
required to be determined on the basis of their actual higher salary. The
petitioner duly exercised the aforesaid Joint Option under Paragraph
11(4) on 11.03.2023 (Annexure P-2).
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
3.5
Accordingly, the pension of the petitioner under the 1995
Pension Scheme was sanctioned by the respondents as Rs.24,511/- per
month with effect from 12.08.2019 vide letter dated 23.12.2024
(Annexure P-4). However, the name of the petitioner was wrongly
written on the Pension Payment Order (PPO) as ‘Surinder Singh’
instead of ‘Surinder Kumar.’ The PPO, as such, was revised vide letter
dated 18.02.2025 (Annexure P-5).
3.6
Learned
counsel
vehemently
contended
that
the
respondents have wrongly and illegally applied a pro-rata formula
while computing the pension of the petitioner, despite the undisputed
position that petitioner’s case squarely falls under Paragraph 11(4) of
the 1995 Pension Scheme. Further, the petitioner retired from service on
31.08.2019 and thus, the entire period of 60 months, relevant for
determining the pensionable salary under Paragraph 11(4) falls
subsequent to the said amendment dated 01.09.2014. In the said period,
the contribution of the petitioner continued to be deducted from his
actual salary. It was further argued that the petitioner had never opted
for or availed the wage ceiling limits under Paragraph 3 or Paragraph
11(3) of the 1995 Pension Scheme, and therefore, the application of a
pro-rata formula is wholly unjustified and contrary to the Scheme.
3.7
Learned counsel argued that at the stage of determination
of pensionable salary, the respondents have unlawfully applied a prorata bifurcation (pre/post 01.09.2014) by importing conditions
applicable under Paragraph 11(1) of the 1995 Pension Scheme. As a
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
consequence, the petitioner’s pension has been artificially reduced
despite having made contributions on a higher salary. It was submitted
that Paragraph 11(1) of the Scheme governs the determination of
pensionable salary for wage-ceiling contributors and provides for
calculation on the basis of the average monthly pay of the last 60
months, subject to a pro-rata application of the ceiling limits of
₹6,500/- up to 01.09.2014 and ₹15,000/- thereafter. In contrast,
Paragraph 11(4) specifically deals with cases where both the employer
and employee have opted to contribute on salary exceeding the
prescribed ceiling, and clearly stipulates that, upon exercise of such
option, the pensionable salary shall be based on the actual higher salary.
Significantly, Paragraph 11(4) contains no reference to any pro-rata
computation or wage-ceiling bifurcation. It was further contended that
Paragraph 12(2) of the Scheme prescribes the formula for determining
the monthly pension, and its proviso refers to pro-rata pensionable
service only in the context of wage-ceiling cases (₹6,500/- or
₹15,000/-). Thus, the concept of pro-rata calculation is confined to
Paragraph 11(1) and the proviso to Paragraph 12(2), and finds no
application to cases falling under Paragraph 11(4).
3.8
Learned counsel submitted that the respondents issued
Circular No. Pension/SC/Higher Pension/2022/1357 dated 01.06.2023
(Annexure P-6), laying down the methodology for computation of
pension in “higher wages” cases. The circular bifurcates the method into
two parts, of which the second part pertains to cases found eligible for
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
pension on higher wages where the date of commencement of pension is
post 01.09.2014. It was contended that the petitioner’s case squarely
falls within this category. It was argued that the said methodology is in
consonance with Paragraph 11 of the 1995 Pension Scheme, as
amended. The circular clearly provides that, for such cases, the average
salary of the last 60 months is to be taken into account for the purpose
of computation of pension, and the pensionable service is to be
reckoned as a single continuous period from 16.11.1995 till the date of
retirement.
3.9
Thereafter, on 14.02.2024, the respondents circulated an
internal e-mail (Annexure P-7) to all Regional Offices of the
Employees’ Provident Fund Organisation across the country, setting out
a methodology for computation of pension on higher wages, along with
illustrative examples. The said e-mail, marked “for Internal Circulation
only,” is wholly inconsistent with and contrary to the provisions of the
earlier circular dated 01.06.2023 (Annexure P-6).
3.10
Furthermore, the aforesaid e-mail dated 14.02.2024
(Annexure P-7) introduces a method of calculating pensionable salary in
higher-wage cases by bifurcating the service period into pre-01.09.2014
and post-01.09.2014 segments and by adopting concepts such as
“highest monthly salary” for each period, which is wholly alien to the
Scheme. It was further argued that the 1995 Pension Scheme clearly
defines “pensionable salary” as the average monthly pay drawn during
the contributory period of service in the 60 months immediately
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
preceding the date of exit. While the pensionable salary is to be
determined on a pro-rata basis in terms of Paragraph 11(1) for cases
governed by the wage ceiling, as far as cases involving higher wages are
concerned, Paragraph 11(4) mandates that the pensionable salary be
computed on the basis of the actual higher salary. Accordingly, the
methodology introduced through the e-mail is inconsistent with the
statutory scheme and impermissible in law.
3.11
Subsequently, the respondents issued another circular dated
18.01.2025 (Annexure P-8), providing clarifications on various policy
issues relating to the processing of pension in higher-wages cases. The
relevant extract of the said circular is reproduced hereunder:
“Certain policy issues were raised by the field offices
related to processing of pension on higher wages cases.
These issues were subsequently taken up with the Ministry
of Labour & Employment (MoL&E) for consideration and
approval.
2. The following clarifications are issued that have the
approval of the Hon'ble Minister of Labour &
Employment:
Issue
Clarification/Approval
Pension Computation The pro-rata calculation
on pro-rata basis.
of
pension is provided in Para 12 of
the EPS and is equitable, treating
both categories of pensioners i.e.
pensioners under wage ceiling
and those with higher wages on
equal
footing.
Further,
the
Hon'ble Supreme Court had also
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
not found the same ultra vires.
Accordingly, MoL&E has agreed
with the computation of pension
on pro-rata basis for the pension
on Higher Wages cases.”
(Emphasis added)
3.12
Learned counsel submitted that, by way of the aforesaid
clarification, the respondents are seeking to impermissibly redefine the
concept of pro-rata computation. It was contended that pension on
higher wages and pension under wage-ceiling cases are fundamentally
distinct categories, which are treated separately under the 1995 Pension
Scheme. The application of a pro-rata formula is envisaged only where
wages vary across different periods, and not in cases governed by
higher-wage contributions. It was further argued that the assertion in the
circular dated 18.01.2025 (Annexure P-8), to the effect that the Hon’ble
Supreme Court did not find the treatment of both categories of
pensioners on an equal footing to be ultra vires, is misconceived. In
fact, the Hon’ble Supreme Court did not adjudicate on the methodology
of pension computation, and the issue was neither raised nor decided in
Sunil Kumar B. (supra). The stand taken by the respondents is thus
erroneous, arbitrary, and contrary to the law declared by the Hon’ble
Apex Court.
3.13
Learned counsel also submitted that the pro-rata method
for computation of pension in higher-wage cases was not even in
existence when the matter in Sunil Kumar B. (supra) was under
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
consideration before the Hon’ble Supreme Court and, therefore, did not
form part of the controversy. It was pointed out that higher pensions had
been disbursed without applying any pro-rata reduction for nearly 09
years following the amendment in September 2014. The subsequent
reduction of pension by applying pro-rata norms has, in fact, been
stayed by various High Courts. In this regard, reliance was placed on the
order dated 05.02.2025 passed in WP(C) No. 4717 of 2025 titled as ‘S.
Kalyanakrishnan vs. Union of India’ by the High Court of Kerala
(Annexure P-9), wherein it was directed that the higher pension being
received by the petitioners shall not be curtailed without further orders
of the Court.
3.14
It was argued that the norms governing the computation of
pension on higher wages cannot be introduced or altered by way of an
executive circular, particularly when such methodology finds no place
in the 1995 Pension Scheme. It is submitted that any modification to the
Scheme must be effected in accordance with law i.e. through statutory
amendment. It was further contended that the reference in the circular
dated 18.01.2025 (Annexure P-8) to the approval of the Ministry of
Labour for the implementation of the pro-rata method in higher-wage
cases is also misconceived and appears to be an attempt to create
confusion, as no such approval can override or substitute the statutory
scheme.
3.15
Additionally, it was contended that the said clarification,
being in the nature of an executive instruction, cannot override or
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
amend the statutory provisions of the 1995 Pension Scheme framed
under Section 6A of the Employees’ Provident Funds and Miscellaneous
Provisions Act, 1952. Any amendment to the Scheme can only be
effected by the Central Government through a notification published in
the Official Gazette. Administrative circulars or clarifications, therefore,
cannot introduce new conditions, such as the application of a pro-rata
formula in higher-wage cases, which are not contemplated under the
Scheme.
3.16
Learned
counsel
emphatically
contended
that
the
employees who had exercised the higher-wage option and made
additional contributions had a legitimate expectation that their pension
would be computed on such higher wages, based on their average salary
from the last 60 months preceding retirement. The impugned
clarification/e-mail (Annexure P-7), it is submitted, defeats this
expectation and operates retrospectively to the detriment of the
pensioners, including the petitioner. It was further argued that the 1995
Pension Scheme is a beneficial legislation and, thus, must receive a
liberal construction so as to advance the interest of pensioners and not
curtail them. The impugned clarification (Annexure P-8), however,
seeks to restrict pensionary entitlements, thereby frustrating the very
object of the 1995 Pension Scheme.
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
●
The petitioner(s) are entitled to interest on delayed payment
of arrears of pension
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner drew the attention of this
Court to Conditions No.6 and 7 of the Joint Option Form under
Paragraph 11(4) of the 1995 Pension Scheme, which are reproduced as
under:
“6. I hereby agree to pay due contribution in a single
tranche as specified by EPFO, along with interest at rates
declared under Para 60 of EPF Scheme, 1952 or at the
rate declared by the concerned Trust of such establishment,
from time to time, whichever is higher, if any.
7. I hereby jointly opt along with my employer to pay full
amount 'of contribution on salary exceeding wage ceiling
under erstwhile Para 11(3) (since deleted) and Para 11(4)
of EPS, 1995 alongwith interest upto the last date of the
month in which payment is made, in accordance with the
judgment dated 04.11.2022 of the Hon'ble Supreme Court
through my last employer within such period as may be
directed by EPFO after verification of my joint option. If
the full amount payable is not deposited by my last
employer within such period as may be directed by EPFO
after verification of my joint option, this joint option shall
be liable to be treated as null and void.”
4.1
In this regard, it was contended that Paragraph 11(4) of the
1995 Pension Scheme merely requires the exercise of a joint option by
the employer and the employee, and does not empower the respondent–
EPFO to impose additional conditions, such as the levy of interest with
retrospective effect. It was argued that, by introducing such stipulations,
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
the respondent–EPFO has effectively sought to legislate through
administrative instructions, which is impermissible in law. Reliance was
placed on the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Sunil Kumar
B. (supra), wherein the EPFO was directed to afford an opportunity to
eligible employees to exercise a joint option. It was submitted that the
Hon’ble Supreme Court did not authorise the imposition of onerous
conditions, such as the recovery of interest retrospectively. The
impugned stipulation, therefore, travels beyond the mandate of the said
judgment.
4.2
It was further contended that the petitioner has been
compelled to accept arbitrary conditions, lacking the force of law,
including the payment of interest from a past date. It is a settled
principle of law that there can be no estoppel against statute, and thus,
any declaration obtained under compulsion for availing a statutory
benefit cannot operate as a valid waiver of statutory rights.
4.3
Learned counsel submitted that the arrears of pension,
representing the difference between the pension payable on higher
wages and the pension initially sanctioned to the petitioner upon
retirement, became due immediately after his retirement. However, an
amount of ₹13,33,882/- was released to the petitioner only in January
2025. It was contended that, as per settled law, pensionary benefits are
required to be disbursed within a reasonable period, ordinarily within
one month from the date of retirement, whereas, in the present case, the
payment has been made after an inordinate delay of more than 05 years
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
and 03 months. It was further argued that, while the respondents have
recovered the differential contribution along with interest, the arrears of
pension have been paid to the petitioner after a substantial delay without
any corresponding interest, which is arbitrary and inequitable. The
petitioner is entitled to interest on the delayed payment of pension
arrears and denial thereof is illegal and contrary to the constitutional
principle of fairness.
4.4
It
was
contended
that
the
respondents,
vide
circular/clarification dated 18.01.2025 (Annexure P-8), have clarified
that interest on EPF dues arising on account of wage arrears payable
retrospectively may be recovered up to the date of retirement or
cessation of membership under the 1995 Pension Scheme, whichever is
earlier. The relevant extract of the said circular/clarification dated
18.01.2025 (Annexure P-8) is reproduced hereunder:
Issue
Clarification/Approval
Reckoning
arrears
wage The revision of wages with retrospective effect
that
are were not deliberate or wilful default on part of
payable
the employers. Therefore, such wages should
retrospectively
be accounted for against the respective months
for which the arrears were meant. In such
cases, it would not be appropriate to recover
damages under section 14-B. However, the
interest on such dues (either from EPF
Contribution or through Demand Letters)
may be recovered up to the date of
retirement/cessation of membership of EPS95, whichever is earlier.
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
It may be reiterated that no damages may be
imposed in such cases.”
(Emphasis added)
4.5
Learned counsel argued that a perusal of the aforesaid
clarification makes it evident that, in cases where the delay is not
attributable to any deliberate default on the part of the employer, interest
on EPF dues is recoverable only up to the date of retirement or cessation
of membership under the 1995 Pension Scheme, whichever is earlier. In
the present case, the petitioner retired on 31.08.2019. However, the
respondents have recovered interest on the differential contribution
towards higher pension up to the date of actual payment. It was
submitted that the demand was raised vide letter dated 24.06.2024, and
the petitioner deposited the amount on 25.06.2024 along with interest
calculated up to the date of payment. Consequently, an additional sum
of ₹6,22,297/- has been recovered from the petitioner towards interest
beyond the date of retirement. Such recovery is stated to be erroneous,
illegal, and contrary to the respondents’ own clarification dated
18.01.2025 (Annexure P-8). Accordingly, it is contended that the excess
amount of interest so recovered is liable to be refunded to the petitioner,
along with interest.
4.6
Moreover,
learned
counsel
emphasised
that
upon
deposit/transfer of the differential contribution towards higher pension,
the respondents were required to issue the revised Pension Payment
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
Order (PPO) within 15 days. In the present case, the demand was raised
by respondent No. 3 vide letter dated 24.06.2024, and the petitioner
deposited the requisite amount on 25.06.2024 (Annexure P-10).
Accordingly, the revised PPO ought to have been issued on or before
10.07.2024. However, the same was issued only on 23.12.2024,
resulting in an inordinate delay of approximately five and a half months.
It was further pointed out that, vide e-mail dated 15.02.2024 (Annexure
P-14), the respondents themselves had directed all concerned officers
that, wherever demand letters had been issued and due amounts had
been deposited by pensioners, the revised PPO must be issued within 15
days from the date of such deposit. It was contended that while the
respondents have recovered the differential contribution along with
interest, the petitioner has not been compensated for the delay in
issuance of the revised PPO. The petitioner is, therefore, entitled to
interest on ₹13,33,882/- i.e. the arrears of pension, for the period of
delay.
●
There is a disparity between wages considered for
contribution and wages adopted for pension computation
5.
Learned counsel invited the attention of this Court to the
wage details (calculation sheet) obtained from respondent No. 3 under
the Right to Information Act, annexed as Annexure P-10. It was
contended that, while calculating the amount payable by the petitioner
towards differential contribution, the respondents adopted higher wages,
including arrears of Dearness Allowance and pay revisions, however,
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
for the purpose of determining pensionable salary, the respondents have
taken a lower wage figure, thereby creating a clear inconsistency.
5.1
Learned counsel submitted that the total salary drawn by
the petitioner during the last 60 months preceding retirement was
₹49,91,902/-, whereas the respondents have reckoned the same as
₹48,99,902/-. The discrepancy arises from the failure of the respondents
to apportion arrears of D.A. and pay revision benefits to the respective
months to which they pertain. While such arrears were considered for
computing the differential contribution, they have been excluded from
the calculation of pensionable salary.
5.2
It was further submitted that, upon correctly apportioning
the arrears to the relevant months, the petitioner has recalculated the
pension payable under both methods, i.e., with and without applying the
pro-rata formula. The monthly pension, if computed without applying
the pro-rata principle, works out to ₹28,212/-, whereas under the prorata method, it comes to ₹24,623/-. In contrast, the pension sanctioned
under PPO No.3122 (Annexure P-4) is ₹24,511/- per month.
Accordingly, a shortfall of ₹3,701/- per month is payable to the
petitioner, along with interest. The relevant calculation sheets and
details of wages, including apportioned arrears, are annexed as
Annexure P-11.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENTS
6.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents, at the
outset, submitted that the petitioner had never exercised any joint option
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
under the erstwhile Paragraph 11(3) of the 1995 Pension Scheme before
the cut-off date of 01.09.2014. It was only by virtue of the indulgence
granted by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Sunil Kumar B. (supra)
while exercising its powers under Article 142 of the Constitution of
India, that the petitioner was given a belated opportunity to submit a
joint option. The petitioner availed of this benefit, submitted the joint
option along with the requisite undertaking to pay the differential
contribution with interest, and only thereafter was granted higher
pension. Having accepted the conditions and reaped the benefits, the
petitioner is now estopped from challenging the very same conditions,
including the pro-rata fixation of pension and Conditions No.6 and 7 of
the Joint Declaration Form.
●
The methodology of pro-rata computation flows directly from
the statutory scheme and has been upheld by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court
7.
Learned counsel for the respondents submitted that the
Central Government, vide notifications dated 22.08.2014 (Annexures
R/1 and R/2), amended the Employees’ Provident Fund Scheme, 1952
and the 1995 Pension Scheme,
respectively, with effect from
01.09.2014 and the statutory wage ceiling was enhanced from ₹6,500/to ₹15,000/- per month. Consequently, the proviso to Paragraph 11(3) of
the 1995 Pension Scheme was deleted and a new Paragraph 11(4) was
inserted specifically for those employees who were already contributing
on higher wages. Additionally, a new proviso was added to Paragraph
12(2) of the 1995 Pension Scheme mandating that monthly pension
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
shall be determined on a pro-rata basis for pensionable service up to
01.09.2014 at the maximum pensionable salary of ₹6,500/- per month
and for the period thereafter at ₹15,000/- per month.
7.1
Learned counsel highlighted the specific language of
Paragraph 11 and 12 of the 1995 Pension Scheme and contended that
the petitioner has misconstrued the applicable pension formula.
According to learned counsel, the petitioner seeks computation of
pension at a flat rate by taking the average salary of the last 60 months
preceding retirement, without applying the pro-rata principle for the
periods before and after 01.09.2014. It was contended that, under the
amended provisions, the pension is required to be computed by dividing
the service into three distinct segments: (i) service up to 16.11.1995,
i.e., prior to the introduction of the 1995 Pension Scheme; (ii) service
from 16.11.1995 to 01.09.2014; and (iii) service from 01.09.2014 up to
the date of retirement. Accordingly, the benefit of past service is first
determined for the period up to 16.11.1995, followed by computation of
pension for the period from 16.11.1995 to 01.09.2014, and thereafter for
the period from 01.09.2014 till retirement. It was thus argued that the
pension is to be calculated on a pro-rata basis in accordance with the
Scheme, and not on a flat-rate method as suggested by the petitioner.
7.2
Learned counsel further relied heavily on the judgment of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Sunil Kumar B. (supra) and submitted
that the very same amendments to Paragraphs 11 and 12 of the 1995
Pension Scheme were challenged before the Hon’ble Supreme Court,
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
and in Paragraph 36 of the judgment, the Court unequivocally upheld
the change in methodology for computation of pensionable salary.
Paragraph 44(i) and (viii) of the said judgment expressly declare that the
provisions contained in Notification dated 22.08.2014 (Annexures R/1
and R/2) are legal and valid, and that no flaw was found in altering the
basis for computation of pensionable salary. Therefore, the pro-rata
formula stands judicially affirmed and cannot be re-agitated in these
proceedings.
7.3
It was further submitted that, on this very issue, various
Regional Offices had sought clarification from the Head Office
regarding the manner in which higher pension in post-2014 retirement
cases was to be fixed and the method for computation on a pro rata
basis. In response, the Head Office, vide e-mail dated 14.02.2024
(Annexure R/4), clarified that the same pro-rata formula is to be applied
even in higher pension cases and also provided an illustrative example
for guidance. The position was subsequently reiterated by the Head
Office through Circular dated 18.01.2025 (Annexure R/5).
●
The claim of petitioner for refund of interest charged for
grant of Higher Pension and also to pay the interest on arrears
of higher pension is not legally tenable
8.
Learned counsel submitted that the petitioner became
entitled to higher pension only after the judgment in Sunil Kumar B.
(supra) allowed him to submit the joint option. Prior to that, the
petitioner had no vested right to a higher pension. Learned counsel
argued that the petitioner made contributions to the Pension Fund on the
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
basis of the wage-ceiling before exercising the said joint option; as such,
the amount which ought to have been contributed on the basis of the
petitioner’s
actual
salary
from
16.11.1995
till
the
date
of
superannuation- 31.08.2019, was never so deposited. The contribution
made by the petitioner, in fact, on the wage-ceiling, remained in his
Provident Fund account, where it continued to earn interest until its
withdrawal upon retirement. Consequently, the Pension Fund was
deprived of the interest that would have accrued on the contributions
corresponding to the actual salary of the petitioner, while the petitioner
derived the benefit of interest on the same amount in his Provident Fund
account.
8.1
It was submitted that, in order to neutralise this imbalance,
the petitioner was required to deposit the differential contribution along
with applicable interest, which merely represented the interest
component already earned by him on the said amount while the same
remained in the Provident Fund. It was emphasised that the petitioner
has not paid any additional interest from his own funds, but has only
refunded what he had earlier received as interest. In these
circumstances, it was contended that the petitioner’s claim for interest
on delayed payment of pension arrears is wholly untenable. Having
already enjoyed the benefit of interest on the same corpus during its
retention in the Provident Fund, the petitioner cannot claim a second
round of interest upon its conversion into pension. Granting such a
claim would amount to conferring multiple interest benefits on the same
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
amount, which is neither equitable nor permissible under the statutory
scheme.
8.2
Moreover, the petitioner submitted the joint option only in
the year 2023, and thereafter, the respondents processed his case.
Therefore, there is no delay attributable to the respondents in releasing
the arrears of pension.
8.3
In response to the petitioner’s claim regarding disparity
between wages considered for contribution and wages adopted for
pension computation, learned counsel submitted that the wage details
were taken on the basis of the member ledger, which reflects monthwise details as deposited by the employer. No bifurcation or details of
arrear payment or abnormal increase in wages in any particular month
was provided by the employer to the EPFO. Therefore, it was submitted
that the respondents have correctly calculated the pensionable salary
from the member ledger based on the increasing order of wages.
●
The pro-rata formula is actuarially sound and prevents
inequitable cross-subsidization
9.
Lastly, learned counsel for the respondents submitted that
the department’s position is founded on sound actuarial principles and
considerations of equity. It was contended that, in cases of pension on
higher wages, the total pension payout over the lifetime of a beneficiary
substantially exceeds the actual contribution made by the individual
member, even after accounting for transfers from the Provident Fund
along with accrued interest. If pension were to be computed entirely on
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
higher wages without any pro-rata adjustment, the Pension Fund, which
is primarily structured on contributions up to the statutory wage ceiling,
would be subjected to a disproportionate financial burden. Such an
approach, it was argued, would lead to impermissible crosssubsidisation, effectively shifting the financial liability of higher-wage
beneficiaries onto ordinary members contributing within the prescribed
ceiling. Learned counsel submitted that the pro-rata principle is
inherent in the framework of the 1995 Pension Scheme, and does not
require any separate or additional authorisation. Neither the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Sunil Kumar B. (supra) nor the amended provisions
of the 1995 Pension Scheme mandate a uniform recalculation of the
entire pensionable service on higher wages.
10.
It was further contended that Courts ought not to direct
pension computation in a manner that disrupts the actuarial balance of a
statutory pension scheme, particularly where the Scheme itself
prescribes a specific methodology. The application of the pro-rata
principle in higher-wage cases, therefore, is not a curtailment of benefits
but a necessary safeguard to preserve the financial sustainability of the
Pension Fund. Any deviation therefrom would result in inequitable
enrichment of a limited class of beneficiaries at the expense of the
broader body of members contributing within the statutory framework.
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
OBSERVATION & ANALYSIS
11.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and after
perusing the record of the case with their able assistance, the following
questions arise for adjudication:
1.
Whether the application of the pro-rata formula for
computation of pensionable salary in ‘Higher Wages’ cases
is legally valid?
2.
Whether the petitioner(s) are entitled to interest on
delayed payment of arrears of pension?
3.
Whether there exists any disparity between the wages
considered for contribution and the wages adopted for
pensionable
salary,
entitling
the
petitioner(s)
to
recalculation of their pension?
ISSUE 1: The application of the pro-rata formula for computation
of pension in ‘Higher Wages’ cases
12.
At the outset, this Court considers it appropriate to advert
to the genesis and statutory object underlying the introduction of the
pro-rata method for the computation of “pensionable salary.” The said
method, incorporated through the 2014 amendment to the 1995 Pension
Scheme, was intended to address a specific regulatory transition,
namely, the enhancement of the statutory wage ceiling from ₹6,500/- to
₹15,000/-. In cases where a member’s contributions were confined to
these statutory ceilings, the pro-rata principle serves an actuarial
function by ensuring that the pension payable for a particular segment
of service bears a rational nexus to the quantum of contributions made
during that period.
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
13.
Paragraph 11(1) of the 1995 Pension Scheme explicitly
mandates the pro-rata computation for ‘wage-capped’ members,
directing that the pensionable salary be determined separately for
service up to September 1, 2014 (capped at ₹6,500) and for service
thereafter (capped at ₹15,000). The logic is anchored in the principle of
‘quid pro quo’: since the employee/member and employer only remitted
contributions on the lower ceiling for the pre-2014 period, the member
cannot legitimately expect a pension payout based on a higher figure for
that segment. In this narrow context, pro-rata computation prevents an
un-funded ‘windfall’ and preserves the actuarial balance of the pooled
fund.
14.
It is settled law that beneficial statutes must receive a
liberal construction. In fact, the Constitution Bench of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in D.S. Nakara v. Union of India, 1983(1) SCC 305 has
clarified that the Courts may not interpret provisions regarding pension
or a statute introducing a pension scheme in a manner that renders them
inane. The relevant part thereof is reproduced hereunder:
“28. Pensions to civil employees of the Government and the
defence personnel as administered in India appear to be a
compensation for service rendered in the past. However, as
held in Dodge v. Board of Education, (1937) 302 US 74 :
82 Law Ed 57 a pension is closely akin to wages in that it
consists of payment provided by an employer, is paid in
consideration of past service and serves the purpose of
helping the recipient meet the expenses of living. This
appears to be the nearest to our approach to pension with
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
the added qualification that it should ordinarily ensure
freedom from undeserved want.
29. Summing-up it can be said with confidence that
pension is not only compensation for loyal service
rendered in the past, but pension also has a broader
significance, in that it is a measure of socio-economic
justice which inheres economic security in the fall of life
when
physical
and
mental
prowess
is
ebbing
corresponding to ageing process and therefore, one is
required to fall back on savings. One such saving in kind
is when you gave your best in the he day of life to your
employer, in days of invalidity, economic security by way
of periodical payment is assured. The term has been
judicially defined as a stated allowances or stipend made
in consideration of past service or a surrender of rights or
emoluments to one retired from service. Thus the pension
payable to a Government employee is earned by rendering
long and efficient service and therefore can be said to be
a deferred portion of the compensation for service
rendered. In one sentence one can say that the most
practical raison d'etre for pension is the inability to
provide for oneself due to old age. One may live and avoid
unemployment but not senility and penury if there is
nothing to fall back upon.
30. The discernible, purpose thus underlying pension
scheme or a statute introducing the pension scheme must
inform interpretative process and accordingly it should
receive a liberal construction and the Courts may not so
interpret such statute as to render them inane (see
American Jurisprudence 2d. 881).”
(Emphasis added)
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
15.
Against this backdrop, this Court proceeds to examine the
relevant provisions of the 1995 Pension Scheme. Paragraph 11 and 12
of the Scheme, as they presently stand, are reproduced hereunder for
ready reference:
“11. Determination of Pensionable Salary. - (1) The
pensionable salary shall be the average monthly pay
drawn in any manner including on piece rate basis
during contributory period of service in the span of sixty
months preceding the date of exit from the membership of
the Pension Fund and the pensionable salary shall be
determined on pro-rata basis for the pensionable service
up to the 1st day of September, 2014, subject to a
maximum of six thousand and five hundred rupees per
month, and for the period thereafter at the maximum of
fifteen thousand rupees per month:
Provided that if a member was not in receipt of full pay
during the period of sixty months preceding the day, he
ceased to be the member of the Pension Fund, the average
of previous sixty months full pay drawn by him during the
period for which contribution to the pension fund was
recovered, shall be considered as pensionable salary for
calculating pension.
(2) If during the said span of 60 months there are noncontributory periods of service including cases where the
member has drawn salary for a part of the month, the total
wages during the 60 months span shall be divided by the
actual number of days for which salary has been drawn
and the amount so derived shall be multiplied by 30 to
work out the average monthly pay.
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
(3) The maximum pensionable salary shall be limited to
fifteen thousand rupees per month.
(4) The existing members as on the 1st day of September,
2014, who at the option of the employer and employee,
had been contributing on salary exceeding six thousand
and five hundred rupees per month, may on a fresh
option to be exercised jointly by the employer and
employee continue to contribute on salary exceeding
fifteen thousand rupees per month and the pensionable
salary for the existing members who prefer such fresh
option shall be based on the higher salary:
Provided that the aforesaid members have to contribute at
the rate of 1.16 per cent. [***] on salary exceeding fifteen
thousand rupees as an additional contribution from and
out of the contributions payable by the employees for each
month under the provisions of the Act or the rules made
thereunder:
Provided further that the fresh option shall be exercised by
the member within a period of six months from the 1st day
of September, 2014:
Provided also that the period specified in the second
proviso may, on sufficient cause being shown by the
member, be extended by the Regional Provident Fund
Commissioner for a further period not exceeding six
months:
Provided also if no option is exercised by the member
within such period (including the extended period), it shall
be deemed that the member has not opted for contribution
over wage ceiling and the contributions to the Pension
Fund made over the wage ceiling in respect of the member
shall be diverted to the Provident Fund account of the
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
member along with interest as declared under the
Employees' Provident Funds Scheme from time to time.
12. Monthly Member's Pension. - (1) A member shall be
entitled to: (a) superannuation pension if he has rendered eligible
service of 10 years or more and retires on attaining the age
of 58 years;
(b) early pension, if he has rendered eligible service of 10
years or more and retires or otherwise ceases to be in the
employment before attaining the age of 58 years.
(2) In the case of a new entrant, the amount of monthly
superannuation pension or early pension, as the case may
be, shall be computed in accordance with the following
factors, namely: Monthly member's pension =
Pensionable salary x Pensionable service
Provided that the members' monthly pension shall be
determined on a pro-rata basis for the pensionable service
up to the 1st day of September, 2014 at the maximum
pensionable salary of six thousand and five hundred
rupees per month and for the period thereafter at the
maximum pensionable salary of fifteen thousand rupees
per month…”
(Emphasis added)
16.
Paragraph 11(1) governs the computation of pensionable
salary in cases where contributions are restricted to the statutory wage
ceiling. It provides that pensionable salary shall be determined on the
basis of the average monthly salary drawn during the last sixty months,
with the wage ceiling of ₹6,500/- being applicable up to 01.09.2014 and
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
₹15,000/- thereafter on a pro-rata basis. Paragraph 11(4), however,
operates in a distinct field. It specifically applies to cases where both the
employer and employee have exercised the option to contribute on
wages exceeding the prescribed ceiling. In such circumstances, the
Scheme expressly provides that pensionable salary shall be computed
on the basis of the actual higher salary. Significantly, this provision
contains no stipulation regarding pro-rata computation or bifurcation
based on wage ceilings.
17.
Likewise, Paragraph 12(2), which prescribes the formula
for calculation of monthly pension, refers to pro-rata pensionable
service only through its proviso and only in the context of wage-ceiling
cases. Thus, the statutory framework indicates that the concept of prorata computation is confined to cases governed by Paragraph 11(1) and
the proviso to Paragraph 12(2), and does not extend to cases falling
under Paragraph 11(4). This Court is of the considered view that a
fundamental distinction must be drawn between members governed by
Paragraph 11(1) and those governed by Paragraph 11(4). The latter
category represents a distinct class of ‘Higher Wage’ contributors who
have historically remitted, or have retrospectively remitted (with
interest), contributions on their actual salaries without regard to the
statutory wage ceilings.
18.
Significantly, the respondents themselves issued a circular
dated 01.06.2023 (Annexure P-6), prescribing the methodology for
computation of pension in “Higher Wages” cases. The circular classifies
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
such cases into two categories, the second category pertaining to
members whose pension commenced after 01.09.2014 and who were
found eligible for pension on higher wages. The circular specifically
provides that, in such cases, the pensionable salary is to be determined
on the basis of the average monthly pay drawn during the contributory
period of service falling within the 60 months preceding the date of exit
from membership of the Pension Fund. Notably, the circular contains no
reference whatsoever to the application of any pro-rata methodology.
The relevant portion of the circular dated 01.06.2023 (Annexure P-6) is
reproduced hereunder for ready reference:
“Please
Circular
No.
Pension/SupremeCourtjudgement/POHW/2022/143
dated
09.05.2023
refer
regarding
to
the
"Deposit
/
Transfer
of
due
contribution with interest into Pension Fund" wherein It
was informed in Para 14 that the method of computation
of Pension will follow through subsequent circular.
2. In this regard, the matter of method of computation of
Pension has been considered and it is informed that, as
for now, the computation of pension shall be in
accordance with the provisions of Employees' Pension
Scheme (EPS), 1995 as follows: i. Cases found eligible for pension on higher wages
where date of commencement of pension is prior to
01.09.2014: Pension shall be calculated based on
average monthly pay drawn during contributory
period of service In the span of 12 months preceding
the date of exit from the membership of the pension
fund.
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
ii. Cases found eligible for pension on higher wages
where date of commencement of pension is post
01.09.2014: Pension shall be calculated based on
average monthly pay drawn during contributory
period of service in the span of 60 months
preceding the date of exit from the membership of
the pension fund.”
(Emphasis added)
19.
Rather, it appears that the application of the pro-rata
formula to “Higher Wages” cases was introduced for the first time vide
e-mail dated 14.02.2024. A copy of the said e-mail, marked “for Internal
Circulation only,” is annexed as Annexure P-7, and the relevant extract
thereof is reproduced hereunder:
“2. Requests have been received from various Zonal and
Regional Offices to provide an example of calculation of
pension on higher wages where date of commencement of
pension is post-01.09.2014 i.e. pro-rata calculation is to be
done.
3. Accordingly, it is once again clarified that as per
provisions of EPS, 1995, pro-rata calculation is being done
since 01.09.2014 in normal pension cases (please refer
Circular
No.
Actuarial/18(2)/2008/Vol.III/7738
dated
29.08.2014). Now, after implementation of judgment of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court, in eligible cases, the normal
pension earlier given has to be enhanced to pension on
higher wages. Since, there is no separate formula in EPS,
1995 for calculation of pension on higher wages in respect
of ordinary EPS members, therefore, in higher wages cases
also, as per provisions of EPS, 1995, calculation shall be
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
done similarly, where date of commencement is on and
after 01.09.2014:
(a) Calculation of Pension in Higher Wages Cases will be
on pro-rata basis as per provision of EPS, 1995:
Monthly Member's Pension = Pensionable Salary x
Pensionable Service/70.
Pro-rata calculation will entail separate calculation for
pensionable service prior to 01.09.2014 and pensionable
service post-01.09.2014.
(b) Calculation of Pensionable Salary in Higher Wages
Cases:
(i). For pensionable service prior to 01.09.2014: Pro-rata
pensionable salary i.e. highest monthly salary prior to
01.09.2014 or 60 months' average of salary preceding the
date of exit from the membership of the Pension Fund,
whichever be less.
(ii). For pensionable service post-01.09.2014: Pro-rata
pensionable salary i.e. highest monthly salary post01.09.2014 or 60 months' average of salary preceding the
date of exit from the membership of the Pension Fund,
whichever be less.
(c) Two years weightage, where due, is to be added to
pensionable service prior to 01.09.2014 i.e. in (b)(i)
above.”
(Emphasis added)
20.
The respondents further sought to justify the application of
the pro-rata formula to “Higher Wages” cases through the issuance of
yet another clarification/circular dated 18.01.2025 (Annexure P-8).
However, this Court finds substance in the contention advanced by
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
learned counsel for the petitioner that the e-mail dated 14.02.2024
(Annexure P-7) and the subsequent clarification dated 18.01.2025
(Annexure P-8) mark a clear departure from the methodology earlier
prescribed vide Circular dated 01.06.2023 (Annexure P-6) and are not in
consonance with the amended provisions of the 1995 Pension Scheme.
By introducing a bifurcation of service into periods prior to and
subsequent to 01.09.2014, and by employing notions such as “highest
monthly salary” for the respective periods, the respondents have
adopted concepts which find no place in the Scheme itself.
21.
As noted above, the 1995 Pension Scheme unequivocally
defines “pensionable salary” as the average monthly pay drawn during
the contributory service period comprised within the 60 months
immediately preceding the member’s exit. While Paragraph 11(1)
contemplates pro-rata computation in cases where contributions are
subject to the statutory wage ceiling, Paragraph 11(4), which governs
higher-wage cases, specifically envisages computation on the basis of
the actual higher salary.
22.
It is settled law that executive or administrative
instructions cannot amend or override statutory rules, nor can any such
instructions be issued in derogation of the statutory framework. This is
for the reason that administrative directions, being non-statutory in
character, do not carry the force of law. On the contrary, statutory rules,
framed under the authority of an enabling statute, have the binding force
of law, provided they are consistent with and not repugnant to the parent
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
Act. Thus, while statutory rules occupy the field with statutory force,
mere executive instructions cannot operate to curtail, modify, or expand
their scope. Reliance in this regard can be placed on the judgments of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Yash Charitable Trust vs. Union of
India, 2026 INSC 96; Paluru Ramkrishnaiah vs. Union of India, AIR
1990 SC 166; State of U.P. vs. Babu Ram Upadhyaya, AIR 1961 SC
751; Swapan Kumar Pal vs. Samitabhar Chakraborty, 2001(2) SCT
1104 (SC); and Ram Ganesh Tripathi vs. State of U.P., 1997(1) SCT
494 (SC).
23.
Furthermore, this Court is unable to accept the contention
of learned counsel for the respondents that the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in Sunil Kumar B. (supra) had upheld the applicability of the pro-rata
formula for computation of pensionable salary in “higher wages” cases.
A careful reading of the said judgment reveals that the issue concerning
the application of the pro-rata methodology in such cases was neither
raised before nor adjudicated by the Hon’ble Apex Court. Rather, as
noticed hereinabove, the said methodology appears to have been
introduced for the first time through the e-mail dated 14.02.2024
(Annexure P-7), and therefore, was not even in existence at the time
when the matter was under consideration before the Hon’ble Supreme
Court.
24.
Accordingly, this Court is of the considered opinion that
the pro-rata methodology for “Higher Wages” cases sought to be
introduced through the e-mail dated 14.02.2024 (Annexure P-7) and
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
clarification dated 18.01.2025 (Annexure P-8), travels beyond the
statutory framework of the 1995 Pension Scheme and cannot be
sustained in law. In such cases, the pensionable salary is required to be
determined based on average monthly pay drawn during contributory
period of service in the span of 60 months preceding the date of exit
from the membership of the pension fund. Accordingly, the first issue
stands answered in the aforesaid terms.
ISSUE 2: The petitioner(s)’ entitlement to interest on delayed
payment of arrears of pension
25.
Conditions No. 6 and 7 of the Joint Option Form under
Paragraph 11(4) of the 1995 Pension Scheme required the petitioner to
deposit the full amount of contribution on salary exceeding the wage
ceiling under erstwhile Paragraph 11(3) (since deleted) and Paragraph
11(4) of the Scheme, together with interest up to the last date of the
month in which the payment was made. In this regard, this Court finds
substance in the contention advanced by learned counsel for the
petitioner that Paragraph 11(4) merely contemplates the exercise of a
joint option by the employer and employee and does not confer any
authority upon the respondent–EPFO to impose additional stipulations,
such as the levy of interest with retrospective effect. Furthermore, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Sunil Kumar B. (supra) had also not
authorised the imposition of any such condition.
26.
Upon deposit of the contribution amount of ₹20,29,275/-
by the petitioner, along with interest calculated up to the date of
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
payment vide cheque dated 25.06.2024, the respondents issued the
revised PPO on 23.12.2024 (subsequently revised vide letter dated
18.02.2025 available at Annexure P-5), sanctioning his pension at the
rate of ₹24,511/- per month with effect from 12.08.2019. Thereafter, an
amount of ₹13,33,882/- towards arrears of pension, representing the
difference between the pension payable on higher wages and the
pension originally sanctioned upon retirement, was released in January
2025, i.e., after a lapse of more than five years from the date of
retirement of the petitioner. Furthermore, as is evident from the e-mail
dated 15.02.2024 (Annexure P-14), the respondents were required to
issue the revised PPO within 15 days of the deposit/transfer of the
differential contribution towards higher pension. However, in the
present case, the revised PPO was issued only on 23.12.2024, i.e., after
an inordinate delay of approximately five and a half months.
27.
It is trite law that pension is neither a bounty, nor a matter
of grace, but a vested right. The State is under a legal obligation to
ensure timely disbursement of pensionary and retiral dues as and when
they become payable. Failure to discharge this obligation entitles the
retiree to seek compensation in the form of interest for the delayed
payment. The entitlement to such interest is intrinsically linked with the
right to pension and other retiral benefits, and constitutes an integral
facet thereof. Reliance in this regard can be placed on the judgment of
the Full Bench of this Court in A.S. Randhawa vs. State of Punjab,
1997(3) SCT 468.
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
28.
Thus, where a statutory benefit is withheld for reasons not
attributable to the employee, the concerned authority is under a legal
obligation to compensate the employee by payment of interest. In the
present case, the delay was occasioned directly by the restrictive
interpretation of the 1995 Pension Scheme adopted by the respondent–
EPFO, which ultimately came to be corrected by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Sunil Kumar B. (supra). Consequently, the petitioner cannot
be made to suffer the erosion of the value of his pension due to the
administrative or legal errors of the respondents.
29.
Furthermore, this Court is unable to accept the argument
put forth by the respondents that the petitioner is not entitled to interest
because he had already benefitted from interest on the differential
amount during the period it remained in his Provident Fund account.
Admittedly, the respondents themselves have recovered the differential
contribution from the petitioner along with interest to “neutralize” this
very imbalance. Having charged the petitioner interest at a specific rate
for the period where the funds remained with him, the respondents
cannot now use the same logic to deny him interest for the period his
pension arrears were unduly retained by the department. This Court is of
the considered view that, in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the
present case, principles of equity and fairness demand reciprocity. If the
respondents have levied interest upon the petitioner for delayed deposit
of the amount of contribution on salary exceeding the wage ceiling, they
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
cannot escape liability to pay interest for the corresponding delay in
release of arrears of pension.
30.
Reliance in this regard can also be placed on the judgment
of the Division Bench of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh in
Employees Provident Fund Organisation vs. Achyut Bhoraskar W.A.
No.1441 of 2019, decision dated 16.12.2019, wherein, while dealing
with a similar controversy, the following was observed:
“5. The learned Single Judge keeping in view the identical
issue decided by the Division Bench has dismissed the writ
petition. The three writ appeal preferred by the Employees
Provident Fund Orders have been dismissed by this Court
vide a common order dated 23.08.2018 i.e. W.A.
No.766/18, W.A. No.887/18 and W.A. No.973/18. The
Division Bench has dismissed the writ appeal keeping in
view the judgment delivered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court
in the case of R.C. Gupta and others v. Regional
Provident Fund Commissioner, Employees' Provident
Fund organization and others (SLP No.33032/2015). The
Division Bench of this Court in paragraph Nos.2 to 15 has
held as under:"2. This intra court appeal under Section 2 (1) of
Madhya Pradesh Uchcha Nyalayaya (Khand Nyay
Peeth Ko Appeal) Adhiniyam, 2005 has been filed by
the
appellant
Organization
(Annexure
/
Employees'
against
A/2)
order
passed
Provident
dated
in
Writ
Fund
03.01.2018
Petition
No.4979/2017 by which the learned Writ Court
allowed the writ petition filed by respondent No.1
(writ petitioner) and directed the appellant to accept
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
the amount from respondent No.1, which he
withdrew and revise his pension, as per the
directions given by Hon'ble the Apex Court on
04.10.2016 in the case of R.C. Gupta and others v.
Regional
Provident
Fund
Commissioner,
Employees' Provident Fund Organization and
others (SLP No.33032/2015). It is also observed by
the learned Single Judge that since appellant was
also not at fault and Hon'ble the Apex Court in the
year 2016 has directed them to give benefit of the
scheme without applying cut off date, hence the
appellant is also not liable to pay interest on the
arrears of pension to respondent No.1.
xx
xx
xx
9. Contention of the learned counsel for respondent
No.1 before the Writ Court was that appellant is
wrongly demanding interest on the amount so
deposited by respondent No.1. If respondent No.1 is
liable to deposit interest, then he is also liable to get
interest on the arrears of pension payable to him in
compliance to order of Hon'ble Supreme Court.
Therefore, in order to maintain equity and balance,
the appellant be restrained to claim interest from
respondent No.1and he shall not claim interest on
the arrears of pension and the appellant is demand
interest, then respondent No.1 is also entitled for
interest on arrears of pension.
10. Learned Writ Court relying on paragraph No.11
of the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case
of R.C. Gupta and others v. Regional Provident
Fund Commissioner, Employees Provident Fund
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
Organization (supra) has held that the Hon'ble
Supreme Court has permitted the Provident Fund
Commissioner to seek return of such amount which
the employees have withdrawn from the Provident
Fund Account; and has directed the Provident
Fund Commissioner not to claim interest along
with such amount of PF. It was also observed by the
Writ Court that by order dated 17.10.2012, the
appellant has rejected the claim of respondent No.1
for re-fixation of pension on the basis of actual
salary exceeding wage limit, but now the appellant
permitted to revise pension of respondent No.1 after
the judgment of the Supreme Court; and as he was
not at fault to withdraw the amount of PF,
therefore, he is not liable to pay interest on such
amount which he withdrew from his PF Account
and deposit it for the revision of pension.
xx
xx
xx
13. On due consideration of the arguments of the
learned counsel for the parties,
so also the
reasoning assigned by the learned Writ Court in the
impugned order, we are of the view that there is no
legal flaw in the order passed by the learned Writ
Court. Judgment dated 22.09.2014 passed in Writ
Petition (C) No.12999/2014 T.V. Joseph and others
v. Union of India and others of the High Court of
Kerala at Ernakulam cited by the learned counsel
for the appellant will not be applicable in the
present facts and circumstances of the case."
xx
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
xx
xx
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
6. In light of the Division Bench order passed by this
Court as the controversy involved in the present case has
already been concluded, the present writ appeals also
stand dismissed.”
(Emphasis added)
31.
Moreover, learned counsel for the respondents could not
controvert the fact that vide circular/clarification dated 18.01.2025
(Annexure P-8), it has been clarified that interest on EPF dues arising
on account of wage arrears payable retrospectively may be recovered up
to the date of retirement or cessation of membership under the 1995
Pension Scheme, whichever is earlier. However, in the present case, the
respondents have recovered interest on the differential contribution
towards higher pension up to the date of actual payment.
32.
Additionally, it must be pointed out that this Court vide
order dated 22.04.2026 in CWP No. 34409 of 2024 titled as Shiv
Kumar vs. Union of India and others, directed the respondents therein
to file an affidavit indicating the exact amount of interest imposed upon
the actual due amount and to place on record the details of interest
charged upon the petitioners from the year 1995 till the issuance of the
demand notices. In compliance with the aforesaid order, an affidavit
dated 14.05.2026 was filed in Court and the relevant portion thereof is
reproduced hereunder:
“3. That the present affidavit is being filed in compliance of
the above- mentioned direction of this Hon'ble Court. The
deponent after scrutiny of the records in the office of
Employees' Provident Fund Organisation, submits that on
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
the deposits made by the petitioners for the purpose of
grant of enhanced pension, the interest rate charged on the
differential contribution (the 8.33% employer share plus
the 1.16% additional contribution) is the ‘statutory rate of
interest’ declared by the Government of India for the
Employees' Provident Fund (EPF) for the respective
financial years. A table indicating the rate of interest along
with the respective years is reproduced herein below for the
kind perusal of this Hon'ble Court:
Year
Rate of Interest
1995-96 to 1999-2000
12%
2000-01
(12%
for
1st
12% and 11%
Quarter and 11% 2nd to 4th
Quarter)
2001-02 to 2004-05
9.5%
2005-06 to 2009-10
8.5%
2010-11
9.5%
2011-12
8.25%
2012-13
8.5%
2013-14
8.75%
2014-15
8.75%
2015-16
8.8%
2016-17
8.65%
2017-18
8.55%
2018-19
8.65%
2019-20
8.5%
2020-21
8.5%
2021-22
8.1%
2022-23
8.15%
2023-24 to 2025-26
8.25%
4. That the above-mentioned interest was charged on
compound basis.”
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
32.1
Therefore, it is an admitted position that the respondents
have levied interest at varying rates on a compound basis. Consequently,
this Court holds that the petitioner(s) shall likewise be entitled to
interest, computed on a compound basis and at the corresponding
applicable rates, on the delayed payment of arrears of pension. The
second issue stands answered accordingly in the aforesaid terms.
ISSUE 3: Disparity between the wages considered for contribution
and the wages adopted for pensionable salary
33.
It is a fundamental principle of any contributory pension
scheme that there must be a parity between the wages on which an
employee pays their share and the wages used to determine their
eventual benefit. Any divergence between these two figures, where the
department accepts contributions on a higher wage but calculates the
pension on a lower one, is inherently discriminatory and legally
unsustainable.
34.
In the present case, the petitioner has demonstrated a clear
mathematical inconsistency. While the respondents calculated the
differential contribution payable by the petitioner by including higher
wages, such as arrears of Dearness Allowance (DA) and benefits from
pay revisions, curiously, they excluded these very elements when
determining the pensionable salary. Learned counsel for the petitioner
had contended that the petitioner’s total salary during the relevant 60month period was ₹49,91,902/-, yet the respondents reckoned it as
₹48,99,902/-. This discrepancy of nearly ₹92,000 arose solely from the
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
respondents’ failure to apportion arrears of D.A. and pay revisions to the
specific months to which they relate.
35.
The defence raised by the respondents that they are bound
by the ‘member ledger’ provided by the employer and that no
bifurcation of arrears was available, cannot be accepted by this Court.
The respondent-EPFO is a statutory body tasked with the correct
administration of a social security fund, therefore, it cannot be allowed
to hide itself behind administrative bookkeeping oversights or the
failure of an employer to provide month-wise bifurcations. Once the
respondents verified the higher wages for the purpose of collecting
money from the petitioner, they were effectively estopped from
claiming that those same wages could not be verified for the purpose of
paying the pension.
36.
The petitioner has provided detailed calculation sheets
(Annexure P-11) showing that if the arrears are correctly apportioned
and the pro-rata principle is excluded (as held by this Court under Issue
No. 1), the monthly pension ought to be ₹28,212/-, instead, the
petitioner was sanctioned a pension of only ₹24,511/- per month. This
results in a significant monthly shortfall that deprives the retiree of his
rightful dues. Consequently, this Court finds that there exists a clear and
unjustified disparity between the wages considered for contribution and
the wages adopted for pensionable salary. Issue No.3 is answered,
accordingly.
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
CONCLUSION
37.
In view of the foregoing discussion, all the captioned writ
petitions are disposed of in the following terms:a. The Circular dated 18.01.2025 (Annexure P-8) and the
internal e-mail dated 14.02.2024 (Annexure P-7) are
hereby quashed to the extent they prescribe the pro-rata
methodology for calculation of pensionable salary in
“Higher Wages” cases. Consequently, the respondents are
directed to forthwith recalculate the pensionable salary of
the petitioner(s) on the basis of the average monthly pay
drawn during contributory period of service in the span
of 60 months preceding the date of exit from the
membership of the pension fund, without applying the
pro-rata formula or bifurcating the service period.
b. The respondents shall ensure complete parity between the
wages taken into account for recovery of differential
contribution and those adopted for determination of
pensionable salary, including due apportionment of
arrears of Dearness Allowance and pay revision benefits
to the respective months to which they relate. The
consequential arrears of pension arising therefrom shall
also be recalculated and released to the petitioner(s).
c. The respondents are directed to pay simple interest at the
rate of 8% per annum on the aforementioned arrears of
pension arising from the recalculation of pensionable
salary without application of the pro-rata formula and
from the rectification of disparities between the wages
considered for contribution purposes and those adopted
for pension fixation. Such interest shall be calculated
from the expiry of 15 days from the date of submission of
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
the joint option forms by the petitioner(s) until the date of
actual disbursement of the arrears.
d. Furthermore, admittedly, the petitioner(s) were not paid
any interest on the delayed release of arrears representing
the difference between the pension payable on higher
wages and the pension originally sanctioned upon
retirement, even though such amounts had become due
immediately upon retirement. For instance, with regards
to the petitioner in CWP-28189-2025, an amount of
₹13,33,882/- towards the difference between the pension
payable on higher wages and the pension originally
sanctioned upon retirement was released in January 2025
without any interest. Accordingly, the respondents are
directed to pay interest on the delayed release of the
aforesaid arrears, computed on a compound basis and at
the same rates at which interest had been charged from
the petitioner(s). Such interest shall be calculated from
the expiry of two months from the date of retirement of
the respective petitioner(s) till the date of actual
disbursement of the arrears.
e. The entire exercise of recalculation, release of arrears,
and payment of interest shall be completed within a
period of twelve weeks from the date of receipt of a
certified copy of this order.
f. It must be clarified that the present judgment is a
judgment in rem, intending to give benefit to all similarly
situated persons, whether they have approached this
Court or not. Reference in this regard must be made to
the judgment rendered by a two-Judge Bench of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in State of Uttar Pradesh vs.
Arvind Kumar Srivastava, 2014(4) SCT 648. Therefore,
the respondent authorities shall be duty-bound to extend
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-28189-2025 & CONNECTED CASES
the benefit of this judgment to all similarly situated
persons. Such persons ought not to be compelled to
approach this Court for the aforesaid reliefs and shall be
at liberty to submit appropriate representations to the
respondents/competent authority within a period of three
months
from
today.
Needless
to
say,
the
respondents/concerned authority shall process these
claims expeditiously.
38.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand
disposed of.
39.
A photocopy of this order be placed on the file of other
connected cases.
(HARPREET SINGH BRAR)
JUDGE
27.05.2026
yakub
MOHD YAKUB
2026.05.27 19:30
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
Whether speaking/reasoned:
Yes/No
Whether reportable:
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review