Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:19049
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CRMP No.8 of 2026
in Cr.A.(C-DB) No.4 of 2026
a/w CRMP No.6 of 2026
in Cr.A.(C-DB) No.2 of 2026
& CRMP No.7 of 2026
in Cr.A.(C-DB) No.3 of 2026
Reserved on: 08.05.2026
Date of decision: 22.05.2026
Uploaded on : 22.05.2026
1.
CRMP No.8 of 2026 in Cr.A.(C-DB) No.4 of 2026
Gurpreet Singh.
...Appellant/Applicant.
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh.
2.
…Respondent.
CRMP No.6 of 2026 in Cr.A.(C-DB) No.2 of 2026
Amreek Singh.
...Appellant/Applicant.
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh.
3.
…Respondent.
CRMP No.7 of 2026 in Cr.A.(C-DB) No.3 of 2026
Dilpreet Singh.
...Appellant/Applicant.
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh.
…Respondent.
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Vivek Singh Thakur, Judge.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ranjan Sharma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?
For the appellant(s)/ :
applicant(s)
Ms. Sheetal Vyas, Advocate, in all
applications/appeals.
Whether the reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment? Yes
-2-
For the respondent(s) :
2026:HHC:19049
Mr. Raj Negi, Deputy Advocate General,
in all applications/appeals.
Vivek Singh Thakur, Judge
These applications, being identical in nature and to be
adjudicated on the basis of common facts and evidence available on
record as well as similar submissions made by the parties, are being
decided together by this common order.
2.
Applicants-appellants (Gurpreet Singh, Amreek Singh and
Dilpreet Singh), along with co-convict Yashwant Singh, have been
convicted under Sections 302 and 120B of the IPC. Co-convict
Yashwant Singh has also been convicted under Section 30 of the Arms
Act, in addition to his conviction under Sections 302 and 120B of the
IPC.
3.
Applicants have been awarded sentence to undergo life
imprisonment and to pay fine of Rs.30,000/- each and in default of
payment of fine to further undergo simple imprisonment for four months
each for commission of offence punishable under Section 302 IPC.
They have been further sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment
for seven years and to pay fine of Rs.10,000/- each and in default of
payment of fine to further undergo simple imprisonment for 1½ months
each for commission of offence under Section 120B IPC.
-3-
4.
2026:HHC:19049
Prosecution case is that on 01.04.2021, deceased-Vipan
Kumar was harvesting crops in the land with the help of migrant
labourers, along with his brothers, namely, Gurcharan Singh (PW-7)
and Sanjay Kumar (PW-15). Sanjay Kumar (PW-15) had arranged the
migrant labourers and brought them to the spot and thereafter left for
his home, whereas, after some time, Gurcharan Singh (PW-7), on the
direction of Vipan Kumar, left the field on a motorcycle to bring tea from
home. At that time, a green-coloured Gypsy bearing registration No.HP
20-6188, driven by appellant convict-Gurpreet Singh, reached the spot,
in which co-convict-Yashwant Singh, along with applicants-appellants
Dilpreet Singh and Amreek Singh, was also travelling. Yashwant Singh
alighted from the vehicle carrying a 12 bore double-barrel gun in his
hand and loudly proclaimed that he would finish Vipan Kumar. Other
occupants of the Gypsy also came out of the vehicle and asserted that
they were owners of the land in question and asked Yashwant Singh to
kill Vipan Kumar, whereupon Yashwant Singh @ Bittu fired at Vipan
Kumar with his gun, which hit him on left side of his chest, resulting in
his death.
5.
Accused persons, namely, Yashwant Singh, Dilpreet
Singh, Amreek Singh and Gurpreet Singh, also threatened the
labourers present at the spot, warning them that they would also be
killed, due to which they fled towards the Swan River.
-4-
6.
2026:HHC:19049
At the time of the aforesaid incident, Gurdial Singh (PW-
1), along with his cousin Satnam Singh (PW-3), was present in their
field adjoining the field where deceased-Vipan Kumar was harvesting
the wheat crop.
7.
Information regarding the incident was conveyed by
Satnam Singh (PW-3) to Sanjay Kumar (PW-15), brother of deceasedVipan Kumar, on his mobile phone. By that time Gurcharan Singh (PW7) also reached the spot, deceased Vipan-Kumar had already
succumbed to his injuries.
8.
These applications have been filed by the applicants-
appellants for suspension of sentence on the ground that their
conviction is based upon vague and inconsistent evidence, and solely
on the basis of mutually contradictory testimonies of prosecution
witnesses, as the Trial Court has failed to appreciate the material
contradictions, which go to the root of the case and render prosecution
story unreliable.
9.
It has been further submitted that it has come in evidence
that there was a property dispute between the parties and deceasedVipan Kumar was harvesting crops on the land which belonged to the
applicants-appellants.
-5-
10.
2026:HHC:19049
It has been further contended on behalf of the applicants-
appellants that there is no evidence of any prior meeting of minds and
that the prosecution has failed to establish any pre-planning before the
incident, as well as any overt act or conduct attributable to the
applicants-appellants depicting a shared intention to kill deceasedVipan Kumar.
11.
It has been further submitted that no specific role has been
attributed to the applicants-appellants, with the further submission that
they were not even named in the statement recorded under Section
154 Cr.P.C., and that even the rough site plan does not depict their
presence at the spot.
12.
It has been contended that no witness has consistently
stated the exact words allegedly spoken by applicants-appellants to
instigate co-accused Yashwant Singh, who allegedly fired upon
deceased-Vipan Kumar. It has been further submitted that the
allegations against applicants-appellants are general and omnibus in
nature, rendering their conviction highly arguable.
13.
It has been submitted that, in view of aforesaid lapses,
discrepancies and contradictions in the statements of the witnesses,
there is a fair chance of acquittal of the applicants-appellants and,
-6-
2026:HHC:19049
therefore, they are entitled to be enlarged on bail after suspension of
their sentence.
14.
Learned Deputy Advocate General has submitted that
applicants-appellants have committed a heinous crime by killing
deceased-Vipan Kumar in broad daylight with common intention and
pursuant to a prior conspiracy to commit his murder, as is evident from
the statements of spot witnesses, namely Gurdial Singh (PW-1) and
Satnam Singh (PW-3), who are independent witnesses and whose
statements stand corroborated by Gurcharan Singh (PW-7) and Sanjay
Kumar (PW-15), brothers of deceased Vipan Kumar. It has been further
submitted that the Trial Court, after appreciating the evidence on record
in its right perspective, has rightly convicted the accused persons and
there is no likelihood of acquittal, rather the appeals are likely to be
dismissed, therefore, there is no ground for suspension of sentence of
the applicants-appellants, as prayed.
15.
It has been further submitted that there is consistency and
corroboration in the material and evidence available on record and the
occurrence of death of deceased-Vipan Kumar, on account of firing
from the gun of Yashwant Singh, at the relevant point of time, has never
been disputed by accused persons at any stage. Therefore, it has been
submitted that present applications deserve to be dismissed.
-7-
16.
2026:HHC:19049
Learned Deputy Advocate General submits that even as
under-trial prisoners, applicants/appellants were not enlarged on bail,
and now they are under detention, being convicts after facing fullfledged trial, and therefore, on this count also, the prayer of
applicants/appellants for suspending their sentence, is liable to be
dismissed, as presumption of innocence in their favour as under-trial
prisoners has now been rebutted by conviction by the Trial Court.
17.
It has been submitted by learned Deputy Advocate
General that suggestion of accidental firing during scuffle also stands
refuted from the cross-examination of Dr. Tushar Saini (PW-10), who,
in his cross-examination, has unambiguously stated that, considering
the injury mentioned in the postmortem report, there are remote
chances of accidental firing, as the firing distance was between 1-2
metres, with further explanation that the manner in which fire was
opened, is the matter of investigation.
18.
Perusal of the record indicates that FIR was registered on
the basis of statement recorded under Section 154 Cr.P.C. made by
Gurdial Singh (PW-1), who had witnessed the entire incident being
present at the spot and working in his field. Deceased-Vipan Kumar
was present in the adjoining field for harvesting the wheat crop with the
help of migrant labourers. In his statement recorded under Section 154
-8-
2026:HHC:19049
Cr.P.C., as well as in his deposition before the Court, Gurdial Singh
(PW-1) has categorically stated that Yashwant Singh and applicantsappellants came to the spot in a Gypsy being driven by Gurpreet Singh,
and Yashwant Singh alighted from the Gypsy carrying a 12-bore
double-barrel gun in his hand and started shouting at Vipan Kumar,
proclaiming that he would kill him on that day. By that time, applicantsappellants (Amreek Singh, Dilpreet Singh and Gurpreet Singh) also
came out of the Gypsy and proclaimed that the land belonged to them
and asked Yashwant Singh to kill Vipan Kumar on the spot, whereupon
Yashwant Singh fired at Vipan Kumar with his double-barrel gun,
causing him to fall down. It has further come in the statement of Gurdial
Singh (PW-1) that the labourers present at the spot were also
threatened by Yashwant Singh and his companions to run away from
the spot, failing which they would also be killed, due to which the
labourers fled from the spot. Thereafter, Yashwant Singh and his three
companions also fled away from the spot.
19.
Information regarding the incident was given by Satnam
Singh (PW-3) to Sanjay Kumar (PW-15), brother of deceased-Vipan
Kumar, and by that time, Gurcharan Singh (PW-7), another brother of
deceased Vipan Kumar, had also reached the spot.
-9-
20.
2026:HHC:19049
There is no contradiction between his (PW-1) statement
recorded under Section 154 Cr.P.C. and his deposition before the
Court. He (PW-1) has clearly mentioned the names of all four accused
persons in his statement recorded under Section 154 Cr.P.C., on the
basis of which FIR came to be registered with the same averments. In
his deposition before the Court, he has reiterated the said version.
21.
Satnam Singh (PW-3) has corroborated the version of
Gurdial Singh (PW-1). There is nothing on record to suggest that
Gurdial Singh (PW-1) and Satnam Singh (PW-3) were related to
deceased-Vipan Kumar, except that they were co-owners of the
adjoining field. Though suggestions were put to both these witnesses
that the field belonged to Yashwant Singh and that it was Yashwant
Singh, who was present in the field, and deceased-Vipan Kumar had
quarrelled with him and tried to snatch the gun, due to which gun
accidentally opened during the scuffle.
22.
In cross-examination, nothing has been brought on record
to impeach veracity of statements of PW-1 and PW-3.
23.
Gurcharan Singh (PW-7) has stated that deceased-Vipan
Kumar had asked him to arrange tea, whereupon he went to his home
on his motorcycle. While proceeding towards his home, he noticed a
green-coloured Gypsy being driven by Gurpreet Singh and occupied by
-10-
2026:HHC:19049
Yashwant Singh, Dilpreet Singh and Amreek Singh, all of whom were
residents of his village and were well known to him. On reaching home,
he requested his mother to prepare tea and sent the same to the field
through another person, whereafter he started returning to the field.
When he reached near the tubewell of Bhanjan Dass, he saw Yashwant
Singh standing near the Gypsy holding a gun in his hand, and Dilpreet
Singh, Amreek Singh and Gurpreet Singh were also standing near him.
On seeing them, Gurcharan Singh (PW-7) stopped his motorcycle near
the tubewell. Upon noticing him, Yashwant Singh shouted loudly, “Aaja,
terko bhi goli marta hu”, and Dilpreet Singh, Amreek Singh and
Gurpreet Singh also started shouting, “Mar, mar, ise bhi goli mar.”
Being afraid, Gurcharan Singh (PW-7) left his motorcycle there and ran
towards the fields to protect himself. Thereafter, Yashwant Singh, while
signalling with his hand, shouted that they had killed his brother and he
should go and collect his body. Gurcharan Singh (PW-7) ran towards
the field and, upon reaching the spot, found deceased-Vipan Kumar
lying in the field with a bullet injury on the left side of his chest and blood
oozing from the injury. Thereafter, with the help of Satnam Singh (PW3) and Gurdial Singh (PW-1), he brought his brother near the road. By
that time, Sanjay Kumar (PW-15) had also reached there and
thereafter, along with Sanjay Kumar (PW-15) and other local persons,
-11-
2026:HHC:19049
they took Vipan Kumar to the Regional Hospital, where he was
declared dead.
24.
Sanjay Kumar (PW-15) has corroborated the versions of
Gurdial Singh (PW-1), Satnam Singh (PW-3) and Gurcharan Singh
(PW-7) by stating that he had arranged migrant labourers from Una for
harvesting the crop and had left them with his brother, deceased-Vipan
Kumar, and his brother Gurcharan Singh (PW-7), whereafter he
returned to his house as he had to go to Una for some work. At about
8:30 AM, he received a phone call from Satnam Singh (PW-3),
informing him that Yashwant Singh, Dilpreet Singh, Gurpreet Singh and
Amreek Singh had shot dead his brother-Vipan Kumar. Upon his return
to the spot, he noticed that his brother had sustained a bullet injury and
many persons had assembled there. Thereafter, with the help of other
persons and his brother-Gurcharan Singh (PW-7), he placed Vipan
Kumar in a vehicle and took him to the Regional Hospital, where he
was declared dead.
25.
From the statements of aforesaid spot witnesses, no
inconsistency or material contradiction is depicted so as to arrive at a
conclusion that there is a fair chance of acquittal of the applicantsappellants at the time of final hearing of the appeals.
-12-
26.
2026:HHC:19049
Relevant witnesses have clearly stated that applicants-
appellants had come to the spot along with Yashwant Singh and had
asked him to kill Vipan Kumar, which, according to learned Deputy
Advocate General, clearly depicts a prior conspiracy to kill Vipan
Kumar, who, at the relevant point of time, was serving in the ITBP in
Chhattisgarh.
27.
Plea of applicants-appellants that their names do not find
mention in the statement recorded under Section 154 Cr.P.C. is also
incorrect. It is true that in the rough site plan (Exhibit PW-11/D), the
names of the applicants-appellants have not been mentioned, however,
it is also a matter of record that the names of none of the persons,
including Yashwant Singh, deceased Vipan Kumar, Gurdial Singh (PW1) and Satnam Singh (PW-3), have been mentioned in the said rough
site plan, wherein only the spot of occurrence/quarrel has been
depicted. Therefore, omission on the part of the Investigating Officer to
depict presence of applicants-appellants in the rough site plan by
mentioning their names therein does not create any circumstance to
construe that there exists a fair chance of acquittal of the applicantsappellants. No other point was urged.
28.
In view of above discussion and consideration of the points
raised for suspension of sentence, we are of the considered opinion
-13-
2026:HHC:19049
that, at this stage, applicants-appellants have failed to establish, prima
facie, any fair possibility of acquittal on the basis of the grounds urged
on their behalf. Accordingly, these applications are dismissed.
Needless to say, the aforesaid observations made in the
29.
applications, shall not have any bearing on the final adjudication of
the appeals, as these observations are preliminary in nature by
considering the material on record, prima facie, for purpose of
suspension of sentence of the applicants-appellants.
(Vivek Singh Thakur)
Judge
22nd May, 2026
(Pardeep)
(Ranjan Sharma)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review