Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CWP-29326
326-2025 and connected matters
IN THE
TH HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB
NJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGA
DIGARH
105+246(6 cases)
Date of decision:10.02.2026
1.
CWP-29326-2025(O&M)
Rupinder
er Ku
Kumar and others
.....Petitioner
ioners
VERSUS
SUS
State off Punja
Punjab and others
.....Responden
ondents
2.
CWP-37868-2025
Amandeep
eep Si
Singh and others
.....Petitioner
itioner
VERSUS
SUS
State of Punjab
Punja and others
.....Responden
ondents
3.
CWP-15849-2025
Chander
er Bha
Bhan and others
.....Petitioner
ioners
VERSUS
SUS
State of Punjab
Punja and others
.....Responden
ondents
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.02.19 18:22
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-29326
326-2025 and connected matters
4.
CWP-30027-2025
Rakesh Kuma
Kumar and others
... Petitioners
ioners
Versus
State off Punja
Punjab and others
...Respondents
dents
5.
CWP-37528-2025
Gurjeett Singh and others
...Petitioners
ioners
Versus
State off Punja
Punjab and others
...Respondents
dents
6.
CWP-31231-2025
Rajpal Singh and others
...Petitioners
ioners
Versus
State off Punja
Punjab and others
...Respondents
dents
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE
E HA
HARPREET SINGH BRAR
Present :
Mr. R.S. Sohi, Advocate for the petitioners in CWP-37528
75282025 and 31231-2025.
Mr. Parveen K. Saini with Mr. Ashutosh Bhardwajj and
Mr.Budhadev Maity, Advocate
vocates for the petitioners in CWP
Nos.15849, 29326, 30027 & 378
37868 of 2025.
Mr. Vikas Sonak, AAG, Punjab
unjab-State.
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.02.19 18:22
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-29326
326-2025 and connected matters
Mr. Vikas Chatrath, Sr. Advoca
dvocate with Mr. Abhishek Sharma,
arma,
Mr. Anirudh Malhan and Ms. Navdita Rathore, Advocate
te for
respondent No.5-PSTCL inn CWP
CWP-29326 & 15849 of 2025.
Mr. Sapandhir, Advocate for re
respondent No.4 in CWP-37528
75282025.
Mr. Hridyavans S. Randhawa
awa wi
with Mr. Opinderpal S. Walia
ia and
Mr. R.P.S. Bara, Advocate for re
respondent-PSPCL.
Mr. Jastej, Advocate for respond
spondent No.4 in CWP-29326-2025.
025.
Mr. Vansh Malhotra, Advocate
ocate for respondent No.4 in CWPCWP
15849-2025.
cate for respondent No.4-PSPCL
CL in
Ms. Kavita Joshi, Advocate
CWP-31231-2025 (throughh V.C)
Ms. Priyanka Malik, Advocate
ocate for respondent No.4 in CWPCWP
30027-2025.
Mr. Anurag Mor, Advocatee for M
Ms. Palika Monga, Advocate
ate for
respondent No.4 in CWP-37868
37868-2025.
HARPREET
REET SINGH BRAR, J. (Oral)
CM-15470--CWP-2025 in CWP-29326-2025
The present application has be
been filed under Section 151
51 of
CPC for
or pla
placing on record the instruction
uctions dated 03.10.2025 (Annexure
exure
P-37) for
or proper
pro
adjudication of the present
sent ccase.
In view of the grounds mentione
tioned in the application, the same
ame is
allowed
d as p
prayed for. Annexure P-377 is oordered to be taken on record.
ecord.
Registry
ry is directed
di
to place the same att an ap
appropriate place.
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.02.19 18:22
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-29326
326-2025 and connected matters
MAIN
1.
This order shall dispose off the above-mentioned writ petitions
titions
as they arise from a similar factual matrix.
trix. H
However, for the sake of brevity,
revity,
the facts
ts are taken
t
from CWP-29326-2025.
025.
2.
The petitioners have approached
oached this Court by filing the present
resent
writ petition
tition under Articles 226 of the Consti
Constitution of India on the following
owing
prayers:<a)
Praying for issuan
suance of a writ in the naturee of
certiorari for quashing the
he instructions dated 17.07.2020
(Annexure P-6) and letter date
dated 11.06.2021 (Annexure P-18)
18)
and letter dated 21.09.2021
021 (Annexure P-20) issued by
respondent No.2 and order date
dated 14.03.2022 (Annexure P-17)
17)
and order dated 22.04.2025
025 (Annexure P-34) issued by
respondent No.5 and circular
lar ddated 17.08.2022 (Annexuree PP
19) issued by respondent No.4
o.4 qqua the petitioners whereby the
petitioners have been grant
ranted pay scale of Rs.19900
Consolidated (on the basiss of Grade Pay of 1900) as per
Central Pay Commission instea
stead of Punjab Pay Scale/Pattern
ttern
i.e. 10900-34800 with Gradee Pa
Pay 3400, which has been granted
nted
to the ALMs and ASSAss w
who were appointed prior to
17.07.2020.
b)
Further prayingg fo
for quashing the Regulation
n 2
Sub-Rule 2(b) of the Punjabb Sta
State Power Corporation Limited
ited
(Revised Pay) Regulations,
ns, 2021 (Annexure P-8, dated
ated
17.11.2021) whereby the above
ove said regulations have not been
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.02.19 18:22
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-29326
326-2025 and connected matters
made applicable to the petit
petitioners or PSPCL employees
yees
recruited on or after 17.07.2020
020 which is against the trite law.
c)
Further praying
ng ffor issuance of a writ in the
nature of mandamus directing
ing tthe respondents to grant the pay
scale to the petitioner/ASSAs/A
As/ALMs and ALMs as per Punjab
njab
Pay Scales/Regulation i.e. 1090
10900-34800 with Grade Pay 3400
which has been granted to A
ALMs and ASSAs, who were
ere
appointed prior to 17.07.202
.2020 and also granted all the
allowance, including dearness
ess allowances, during the 3 years
ears
of probation also and also trea
treat such probation period towards
ards
permanent service for all intents
tents and purposes.
d)
Further prayingg fo
for directing the respondents
ts to
take into account the statutory
tory pay scale of Rs.10900-34800
Grade Pay Rs.3400/- with furthe
urther pay revisions from the date
te of
o
their direct appointment along
ng w
with arrears and interest at 12%
per annum thereon keeping
ng iin view the fact that similar
ilar
question of law has already bee
been decided by this Court as well
as Division Bench of this Cour
ourt and upto the level of Hon9ble
9ble
Supreme Court.
e)
Further prayingg fo
for directing the respondents
ts to
grant pay scale of Rs.3540
35400 (level 6 of Central Pay
Commission as per Pay Grade
ade of Rs.3400 Grade Pay) instead
tead
of Rs.19900/- (as per Pay Grad
Grade 1900) due to the reason that
the persons appointed on thee po
posts of ALMs and ASSAs priorr to
issuance of instruction dated
ted 17.07.2020 were getting pay
grade of Rs.3400 as per revised
ised pay scale.=
3.
Short reply on behalf of respond
espondent No.4 in CWP-37528-2025,
2025,
reply by
y way of affidavit on behalf of respon
respondent No.4 in CWP-29326-2025
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.02.19 18:22
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-29326
326-2025 and connected matters
and reply
ply on behalf of respondent No.4
o.4 in CWP-31231-2025 filed in the
Court today d
during the course of hearing,
ing, wh
which are ordered to be taken
en on
record.. Registry
Regis is directed to place the same at an appropriate place.
4.
Learned counsel for the petition
etitioners, inter alia, contends that
at the
petitioners
ers are
ar working on the posts of As
Assistant Line Man (ALM)) and
Assistant
nt Sub Station Attendants (ASSA)
SA) iin the respondents-Corporation.
ration.
The primary
imary grievance of the petitioners
ers is rregarding arbitrary reduction
ion of
the pay-scale
scale of the petitioners from 109
10900-34800 with Grade Pay
ay of
Rs.3400/- to Rs.19,900/- (consolidated)) on th
the basis of lower grade pay
ay i.e.
Rs.1900/-.. The
T statutory pay-scale off the eemployees of the respondents
dentsCorporation
ation are governed by the Punjab
jab Sta
State Electricity Board Technical
hnical
Grade-III
III Service
Ser
Rules 1996, as is discern
iscernible from Annexure P-10.. The
pay-scales
ales we
were revised in the year 20099 whe
when the revised pay-scale off 2009
were implem
mplemented. In the meantime,, the Government of Punjab issued
instructions
tions d
dated 17.07.2020 (Annexure
re P
P-6) to implement 7th Central
al Pay
Commission
ission Pay Matrix which was initial
initially adopted by the respondent
ndentCorporation
ation w
without amending or repealing
aling tthe statutory rules, however,
er, on
22.04.2025
025 in fact the rules governing the pa
pay scales were amended only
nly on
22.04.2025
025 (Annexure P-34) on thee bas
basis of the instructions dated
17.07.2020
020 is
issued by the Government of Pun
Punjab. The petitioners challenged
enged
the revision
ision o
of the Rules to the extent that th
they have been made applicable
ble
retrospectivel
ectively. Further the amendment de hors the procedure prescribed
cribed
under Section 79(c) of the Electricity (Suppl
(Supply) Act 1948 is not sustainable.
nable.
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.02.19 18:22
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-29326
326-2025 and connected matters
The responde
spondent-Corporation cannot implem
plement the amendment carried
ed out
on 22.04.202
4.2025 (Annexure P-34) without
ut follo
following the drill of the procedure
edure
prescribed
bed u
under Section 79(c) thee Ele
Electricity (Supply) Act 1948.
Admittedly,
edly, the petitioners were appointed
inted in the year 2022 onwardss and
initially
y they were paid the pay scale
ale in terms of the statutory Rules
governing
ing the
th pay scale to the employees
yees ap
appointed prior to the impugned
ugned
amendment
ment w
which was carried out on 22.04.2
2.04.2025 (Annexure P-34). As such,
their pay-sca
scales are governed by the Pu
Punjab State Electricity Board
Technical
cal Services
Se
Grade-III Rules 1996
96 and the Revised Pay Scales Rules
2009. These Rules cannot be overridden
en by defeating the accrued right
ght of
the petitioner
itioners by carrying out the amendmen
ndment with retrospective effect.
t. The
impugned
ned ac
action of the respondents-Corpor
orporation by defeating the right
ght of
petitioner
er for equal pay for equal work
rk and they are being discriminated
inated
only on
n the b
basis of the date of appointmen
ntment. The aforesaid issue has been
considered
ered by this Court in CWP-7877-2024
2024 and connected cases, titled
led as
Amandeep
ep S
Singh and others Versus Pun
Punjab State Power Corporation
tion
Limited and others, decided on 17.09.2025
.2025 (Annexure P-36) and also
so the
judgment
nt rendered
ren
by this Court in CWP
CWP-28550-2025, titled as Lakhvir
hvir
Singh and
nd others Versus State of Pun
Punjab and others, decided
d on
23.09.2025.
025.
5.
Per contra, learned counsel
nsel ffor the respondent-Corporation
ration
submitss that the notification dated 17.07.20
.07.2020 (Annexure P-6) passed
ed by
Government
ment of Punjab has been adopted
pted bby the respondent-Corporation.
ration.
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.02.19 18:22
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-29326
326-2025 and connected matters
Furtherr the petitioners
p
cannot claim parity
arity w
with pay scale with those who
ho
were appoint
ppointed prior to the appointment
nt of ppetitioners. The petitioners were
never promis
promised or offered the higher pay--scales, the petitioners weree well
aware of the fact that they will be paid conso
consolidated pay for which they
y had
participated
ated in
i the selection process. Further
urther the appointment letters issued
to the respec
respective petitioners is self explanat
planatory and Clause-IV thereof,
f, the
emoluments
ents of the appointees have been
en cle
clearly set up. Further in terms
ms of
the notificatio
tification 17.07.2020 (Annexure P-6)
6) the respondent-Corporation
n has
not only
ly adopted
ad
the same but hass also carried out amendment
nt on
22.04.2025
025 (A
(Annexure P-34). The Board
rd of tthe Directors in its 70th Meeting
eeting
has adopted
dopted the instructions dated 17.0
17.07.2020 and carried outt the
amendment
ment iin terms of the instructionss (Ann
(Annexure P-6) regarding pay scale.
As such
h prays
pray for dismissal of the writ petitio
petitions.
6.
I have heard the learnedd coun
counsel for the parties and gone
through
h the ccase file with their able assistan
ssistance. It transpires that the entire
argument
nt of the petitioner hinges upon
on the instructions dated 17.07.2020
.2020
(Annexure
ure P-6)
P
adopting the 7th Central
tral Pa
Pay Commission Matrix for
or the
employees
ees of the respondent-Corporation.
ion. Th
There is no denial to the fact
ct that
the petitione
titioners were appointed in thee yea
year 2022, as such, prior to the
amendment,
ment, and the pay fixation of the em
employees were governed by
y the
statutory
ry rule
rules as it existed at time of their
eir ap
appointment. Incontrovertibly
ly the
amendment
ment w
was carried out in terms of th
the aforesaid instructions in the
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.02.19 18:22
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-29326
326-2025 and connected matters
Punjab State Electricity Board Technical
al Serv
Services Grade-III Rules 1996
6 only
on 22.04.202
4.2025 (Annexure P-34).
7.
The question regarding retrospe
trospective effect of an amendment
ent is
no longer
ger res integra. A Two Judge Bench
nch of the Hon9ble Supreme Court
urt in
V. Vincent
nt V
Velankanni vs. Union of India
dia and Others 2024 SCC OnLine
Line
SC 2642 while
wh
speaking through Justice
stice Sandeep Mehta
observed
ed as
under:<43.
3. IIf a Government Order is trea
treated to be in the nature of a
clarific
arification of an earlier Governm
ernment Order, it may be made
ade
applica
plicable retrospectively. Conversely
rsely, if a subsequent Government
ent
Order
rder is held to be a modificatio
ication/amendment of the earlier
rlier
Govern
overnment Order, its application
ation would be prospective as
retrosp
trospective application thereoff wo
would result in withdrawall of
vested
sted rights which is impermissible
ible in law and the same may also
entail
tail recoveries to be made. The
he pprinciples in this regard were
ere
culled
lled out by this Court in a recent
nt ju
judgment of Sree Sankaracharya
arya
Univer
niversity of Sanskrit v. Dr. Manu 35
35, in the following terms:4
<52. From the aforesaid autho
uthorities, the following principles
iples
cou be culled out:could
i) If a statute is curative
ive or merely clarificatory of the
previous law, retrospect
pective operation thereof may be
permitted.
ii)In order for a subsequent
uent order/provision/amendmentt to
be considered as clarific
rificatory of the previous law, the
pre-amended law ough
ought to have been vague or
ambiguous. It is onlyy w
when it would be impossiblee to
reasonably interpret a pr
provision unless an amendment
nt is
read into it, that the am
amendment is considered to be a
clarification or a declar
claration of the previous law and
therefore applied retrospe
ospectively.
iii) An explanation/clarificat
fication may not expand or alter the
scope of the original prov
provision.
iv) Merely because a pprovision is described ass a
clarification/explanation,
tion, the Court is not bound by the
said statement in the sta
statute itself, but must proceed
d to
analyse the nature off the amendment and then conclude
lude
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.02.19 18:22
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-29326
326-2025 and connected matters
whether it is in reality
lity a clarificatory or declaratory
tory
provision or whetherr it is a substantive amendment
ent
which is intended to cha
change the law and which would
ould
apply prospectively.=
8.
Further, a Two Judge Bench
ch of tthe Hon9ble Apex Court in Sree
Sankarachar
charya University of Sanskrit v. M
Manu, (2023) 19 SCC 30 while
speaking
g thro
through Justice. B.V. Nagarathna
thna ob
observed as under :
38.4. Merely because a pr
provision is described ass a
clarification/explanation, thee C
Court is not bound by the said
statement in the statute itself,
lf, bbut must proceed to analyse the
nature of the amendment and then conclude whether it is in
reality a clarificatory or declar
claratory provision or whether it is
a substantive amendment which
hich is intended to change the law
and which would apply prospect
spectively.
9.
Reliance in this regard may
ay be placed on the judgements
ments
rendered
ed by the
t Hon9ble Supreme Court in U
Union of India v. Martin Lottery
ttery
Agenciess Ltd
Ltd., (2009) 12 SCC 209 and Hiten
Hitendra Vishnu Thakur v. State
te of
Maharashtra
shtra, (1994) 4 SCC 602.
10.
Admittedly the right of thee peti
petitioners to be paid according
ing to
the statutory
atutory rules prevailing at thee tim
time of their appointmentt had
crystallized
lized upon
u
their appointment.
11.
The aforementioned position
ion of law has also been approved
ed by
a Full Benc
Bench of this Court in Kaka v. Hassan Bano, 1998(1) RCR
CR
(Criminal)
al) 4
484. Speaking through Justice
tice S
Swatanter Kumar, the following
owing
was held:
<28.
8.
&This rule is however,
ver, subject to a well recognised
ised
princip
inciple that the benefits acquiredd un
under the existing rules cannott be
taken
ken a
away by an amendment withh ret
retrospective effect, that is to say,
there
ere iis no power to make such a rule under the proviso to Article 309
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.02.19 18:22
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-29326
326-2025 and connected matters
which
ich affects or impairs vestedd ri
rights. Therefore, unless itt is
specifi
ecifically provided in the rules,
s, th
the employees who are already
eady
promo
omoted before the amendment of th
the rules cannot be reverted and
their
eir p
promotions cannot be recalled.
d. In other words, such rules laying
ying
down
wn qualifications
q
for promotion mad
made with retrospective effect must
necess
cessarily satisfy the test of Articles
les 114 and 16(1) of the constitution
tion
: State of Mysore v. M.N. Krishnaa M
Murty, (1973) 2 SCR 575 : AIR
73 Supreme
S
Court 1146, B.S. Yada
Yadav v. State of Punjab, (1981)
1) 1
SCR
R 1024
: AIR 1981 Supremee Co
Court 561, State of Gujaratt v.
Raman
manlal Keshavlal Soni, (1983)) 2 SSCR 287 : AIR 1984 Supreme
eme
Court
urt 161 and KC Arora v. State
te of Haryana, (1984) 3 SCR 623:
84 Lab.
L IC 1015.=
12.
Reference in this regard may aalso be placed on a judgement
ement
rendered
ed by another
a
Full Bench of this Court in Parshotam Dass v. State
te of
Haryana 2003
200 (4) RCR (Civil) 73.
13.
In the present case, the amendm
mendment carried out on 22.04.2025
.2025
(Annexure
ure P-34)
P
cannot be applied retrospe
trospectively to the detriment of the
petitioners.
ers. The
T petitioners were appointed
inted in 2022, at which time their pay
ay
was governe
overned by the existing Punjabb Stat
State Electricity Board Technical
hnical
Services
es Grade-III
Gra
Rules 1996 and the
he Re
Revised Pay Scales Rules 2009.
Their right tto be paid according to those sstatutory rules had crystallized
llized
upon their
eir appointment.
ap
The subsequent ame
amendment in 2025, which seeks
eks to
revise the pay scale downwards based on the instructions dated 17.07.2020,
.2020,
is not merely clarificatory but a substantive
antive change to the pay structure.
ure. It
alters the
he sco
scope of the original rules and
nd adv
adversely affects the vested rights
of employees
loyees who were already appointed.
inted. Such a substantive amendment
dment
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.02.19 18:22
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-29326
326-2025 and connected matters
can only
ly hav
have prospective effect and cannot be used to defeat the accrued
crued
rights off the p
petitioners who were appointed
inted pprior to the amendment.
14.
Consequently, all the present
nt w
writ petition(s) are allowed.. The
respondent/C
dent/Corporation is directed to fix
ix the pay of the petitioners strictly
ctly in
terms off the applicable
a
Rules as on the date oof their appointment and release
elease
the conseque
sequential benefits including arrears
rears w
within a period of three months
onths
from date
ate of receipt of certified copy off this oorder.
15.
Registry is directed to place
ace a photocopy of this order on
n the
paper-books
ooks of the connected matters.
(HARPREET SINGH BRAR)
RAR)
JUDGE
February
ary 10
10, 2025
P.C
Whether speaking/r
king/reasoned. : Yes/No
Whether Reportable
ortable. :
Yes/No
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.02.19 18:22
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review