Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CR-9304-2025 (O&M)
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
CR-9304-2025 (O&M)
Date of decision: 02.07.2026
Gurdwara Sri Sukhmani Sahib
....Petitioner
Versus
Jagdev Singh
....Respondent
CORAM : HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE HARSH BUNGER
*****
Present:
Mr. Rajesh Punj, Advocate, and
Mr. Sahaj Punj, Advocate, for the petitioner.
*****
HARSH BUNGER J. (ORAL)
1.
Prayer in the present civil revision petition is for setting aside
the order dated 21.11.2025 (Annexure P-1) passed by the learned Civil
Judge (Junior Division), Ludhiana, whereby an application submitted by the
petitioner for directing the Civil Ahlmad to trace out the document
Ex.PW1/4 i.e. a Three-Members Committee Report; has been disposed of by
observing that the same is to be proved by way of secondary evidence.
2.
Briefly, petitioner-Gurdwara Sri Sukhmani Sahib filed a suit for
recovery of Rs.32,08,327/- alongwith pendente-lite and future interest
against the respondent herein (Shri Jagdev Singh), inter alia on the plea that
Shri Jagdev Singh was the President of Gurdwara Sri Sukhmani Sahib,
DINESH
2026.07.08 10:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CR-9304-2025 (O&M)
-2-
Urban Estate, Phase II, Ludhiana; from the year 2004 up to 2013 and in
April 2013, the elections were held wherein one Arvinder Singh Sandhu was
elected as the President of the aforesaid Gurdwara. It is pleaded that when
Shri Arvinder Singh Sandhu sought accounts/records from Shri Jagdev
Singh, he did not give the records/documents to the plaintiff and postponed
the matter on one pretext or the other. However, subsequently after repeated
requests, only some of the records were given. It is further pleaded that the
Executive Committee of the petitioner-plaintiff constituted a ThreeMembers Committee on 16.06.2018 to check account records given by Shri
Jagdev Singh. The said Sub-Committee is stated to have submitted its report
on 06.07.2018 from which it was revealed that huge embezzlement of funds
had been done by Shri Jagdev Singh (as detailed in para 6 of the plaint).
Accordingly, the aforesaid suit for recovery was filed.
2.1.
The aforesaid suit was contested by respondent-Jagdev Singh
by filing his written statement/amended written statement, to which the
petitioner-plaintiff filed its replication.
3.
From the pleadings of the parties, the issues have been framed
and the evidence was led by the petitioner-plaintiff.
4.
It appears that during the course of trial, the petitioner- plaintiff
submitted an application before the learned trial Court for issuing directions
to the Civil Ahlmad to trace out the document Ex.PW1/4 i.e. a ThreeMembers Committee Report, which was constituted to ascertain the
embezzlement during the tenure of Shri Jagdev Singh. The said application
DINESH
2026.07.08 10:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CR-9304-2025 (O&M)
-3-
has been decided by the learned trial Court vide the impugned order dated
21.11.2025 (Annexure P-1), the relevant extract of which reads as under:“9.
Since, the concerned the then Civil Ahlmad Sh.
Balwinder Kumar, has already stated that he tried his best to
trace out Ex.PW1/4, but document could not trace out.
Therefore, I do not deem it fit to issue further directions against
him to trace out the said document. Accordingly, the present
application
stands
disposed
of,
with
the
liberty
to
applicant/plaintiff to prove the allege document Ex.PW1/4 i.e.
three members committee report, by way of secondary evidence
or by placing on record original document. Separate letter to
Ld. District & Sessions Judge, Ludhiana be also written
regarding loss of abovesaid document from the judicial file. The
case now stands adjourned to 01.12.2025 for plaintiff’s
evidence.”
5.
Feeling aggrieved against the aforesaid order dated 21.11.2025
(Annexure P-1), the present civil revision petition has been filed before this
Court.
6.
I have heard the learned counsel for the petitioner and perused
the paper-book with his able assistance.
7.
On 11.12.2025, a co-ordinate Bench of this Court directed the
learned Civil Judge (Junior Division), Ludhiana to make earnest and
thorough efforts to trace the document Ex.PW1/4 (Three-Members
Committee Report) and further to determine the responsibility of the official
who was the custodian of the document, prepare a detailed report in that
regard, and furnish the same to this Court. It appears that in compliance of
the aforesaid direction issued by this Court vide order dated 11.12.2025, a
DINESH
2026.07.08 10:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CR-9304-2025 (O&M)
-4-
report was received from the learned District & Sessions Judge, Ludhiana,
which stands recorded in the order dated 28.01.2026 and the matter was
adjourned to 07.04.2026.
7.1.
On 07.04.2026, the following order was passed:“Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that he is not
aware of any order passed by the learned District & Sessions
Judge, Ludhiana, regarding the reconstruction of the document.
Accordingly, the learned District & Sessions Judge,
Ludhiana, is once again directed to submit a report within a
period of two months from today with regard to the
reconstruction of the document, in terms of the earlier order
passed by this Court. It is further directed that upon receipt of
the report from the concerned officer, a copy thereof shall also
be supplied to the learned counsel for the petitioner.
Awaiting the further report, adjourned to 02.07.2026.
Interim order to continue.”
8.
Now, the learned District & Sessions Judge, Ludhiana has
forwarded the report dated 29.05.2026 submitted by the learned Judicial
Magistrate 1st Class, Ludhiana, vide her letter No. 2416/G, dated 01.06.2026,
the relevant extract of which reads as under:“Subject: Loss of document from civil suit titled as
“Gurudwara Sri Sukhmani Sahib Sewa Society Vs.
Jagdev Singh” bearing CIS No.CS/4882/2018,
pending in the Court of Sh. Rajan Aneja, CJJD,
Ludhiana.
Re:
Report in CR-9304-2025 pending for 02.07.2026.
Sir,
Kindly refer to Hon’ble High Court letter
No.CIVIL/69277/2026 dated 17.04.2026 w.r.t. order dated
DINESH
2026.07.08 10:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CR-9304-2025 (O&M)
-5-
07.04.2026 passed by the Hon’ble High Court in CR-93042025, whereby undersigned is directed to submit a report within
two months from order dated 07.04.2026 with regard to
reconstruction of document i.e. Three Members Committee
Report Ex.PW1/4 from the file titled as “Gurudwara Sri
Sukhmani Sahib Sewa Society Vs. Jagdev Singh”, in civil suit
bearing CIS No.CS/4882/2018 pending in the Court of Sh.
Rajan Aneja, CJJD, Ludhiana.
2.
I have the honour to submit herewith a report bearing
No.216 dated 29.05.2026 as submitted by Sh. Rajan Aneja, Civil
Judge (Jr. Divn.), Ludhiana, in compliance with order dated
07.04.2026 passed by the Hon’ble High Court in CR-93042025, wherein the Officer submitted that statements of the then
Ahlmad Sh. Balwinder Kumar, previous Ahlmad Ms. Chanpreet
Kaur, present Ahlmad Ms. Shubhangi, plaintiff representative,
previous counsels, Local Commissioner and other concerned
persons were recorded.
The Officer has reported that the plaintiff had tendered
as many as 194 documents in evidence, all of which were
photocopies and even in the statement recorded at the time
when document in question was tendered, it was mentioned that
original seen and returned. As such stand taken by plaintiff
during reconstruction that original of lost document was
exhibited seems highly improbable.
It is further submitted by the Officer that earlier counsel
for appearing on behalf of plaintiff as well as the Local
Commissioner had categorically stated that the original
document was produced at the time of evidence and was
returned to the plaintiff, after comparison of same with a
photocopy tendered in evidence. However, despite stand taken
by his own counsel and specific query put by the Court in this
DINESH
2026.07.08 10:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CR-9304-2025 (O&M)
-6-
regard, in pursuance of directions of the Hon’ble High Court,
the plaintiff failed to produce either the original document or
even a photocopy thereof. Further, even the members of the
committee whose report was allegedly exhibited as Ex.PW1/4
expressed their inability to produce any copy of the same.
The officer has concluded that despite exhaustive and
sincere efforts made to reconstruction of the ibid document from
all available sources, neither the original document Ex.PW1/4
(Three Member Committee Report) nor photocopy, draft,
duplicate or any other secondary material thereof could be
procured for its reconstruction.
3.
Copy of report submitted by the Officer annexed herewith
for kind perusal of Hon’ble High Court.
Submitted please.
Yours faithfully,
9.
District & Sessions Judge,
Ludhiana”
Today, the aforesaid report(s) were shown to the learned
counsel for the petitioner in the Court itself and the matter was passed-over.
9.1.
When the matter was taken up in the second round, learned
counsel for the petitioner submits that in view of the aforesaid report(s), this
Court may pass an appropriate order.
10.
I have perused the paper-book as well as report(s) placed on the
record.
11.
It is apparent from the report that the concerned officer has
submitted the statements of the then Ahlmad Sh. Balwinder Kumar, previous
Ahlmad Ms. Chanpreet Kaur, present Ahlmad Ms. Shubhangi, representative
of the plaintiff, previous counsels, Local Commissioner as well as other
DINESH
2026.07.08 10:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CR-9304-2025 (O&M)
-7-
concerned persons. It is reported that the petitioner/plaintiff had tendered as
many as 194 documents in evidence, all of which were photocopies and
when the aforesaid documents were tendered, at that time the statement was
recorded that the original have been seen and returned. In this view of the
matter, it has been reported that the stand taken by the petitioner that the
original of the lost document was exhibited is highly improbable.
12.
That
apart,
even
the
counsel
appearing
for
the
petitioner/plaintiff as well as the Local Commissioner had categorically
stated that the original document was produced at the time of evidence and
was returned to the petitioner/plaintiff, after comparison of same with the
photocopy tendered in evidence. It has also been reported that despite the
aforesaid stand taken by the petitioner’s own counsel and also a specific
query being put by the Court, the petitioner-plaintiff failed to produce either
the original document or even a photocopy thereof. Furthermore, even the
members of the committee, whose report was allegedly exhibited as
Ex.PW1/4, are also stated to have expressed their inability to produce any
copy of the same.
12.1.
It is thus apparent that despite sincere efforts made by the
concerned officers/Court to reconstruct the document Ex.PW1/4 (a ThreeMembers Committee Report) from all available sources, the same could not
be procured for its reconstruction.
13.
During the course of hearing of this petition, a specific query
was raised to the learned counsel for the petitioner-plaintiff as to whether he
has any photocopy of the so-called Ex.PW1/4 (a Three-Members Committee
DINESH
2026.07.08 10:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CR-9304-2025 (O&M)
-8-
Report), however, he has responded that they have not kept any photocopy
of the original with them. The aforesaid stand taken by learned counsel for
the petitioner-plaintiff appears to be doubtful as no prudent person would
tender/submit any document to any person/authority, let alone the Court,
without keeping a copy thereof for his own records.
14.
Be that as it may, in the attending circumstances, I see no error
in the impugned order dated 21.11.2025 whereby the petitioner-plaintiff has
been granted liberty to prove the alleged document Ex.PW1/4 (a ThreeMembers Committee Report) by way of secondary evidence or by placing
on record original document. Resultantly, the instant civil revision petition is
dismissed.
15.
Before parting with this order, it is required to be noticed that
going by the statements which have been recorded by the concerned
Courts/officers to the effect that the original of the document in question i.e.
Ex.PW1/4 (a Three-Members Committee Report) was seen and returned to
the petitioner-plaintiff and only a photocopy of the same was retained on the
file, it would still be a matter of concern as to why the said photocopy of the
said document is missing from the record. The said lapse is required to be
enquired into; therefore, let a fact finding enquiry be got conducted by the
learned District & Sessions Judge, Ludhiana, in this regard, so as to fix the
responsibility of the official(s) responsible as regards the missing document
(Ex.PW1/4) and submit a report to the Registrar General of this Court within
a period of three months from today.
DINESH
2026.07.08 10:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CR-9304-2025 (O&M)
16.
-9-
A copy of this order be also forwarded to the Hon’ble
Administrative Judge of District Ludhiana.
(HARSH BUNGER)
JUDGE
02.07.2026
dinesh
Whether speaking/reasoned:
Whether reportable:
DINESH
2026.07.08 10:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review