Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:JHHC:20002-DB]
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
F.A. No. 52 of 2021
1.
Gunadhar Singh, aged about 45 years, son of Late Bhola Nath Singh,
resident of Village-Phutabandh, P.O. and P.S. Bindapathar, DistrictJamtara, Jharkhand.
… … Appellant/Respondent
Versus
1. Dhonibala Singh, wife of Gunadhar Singh, Daughter of Babulal Singh,
resident of Village-Phutabandh, P.O. and P.S. Bindapathar, DistrictJamtara, Jharkhand at presently residing at village Punasia, P.O. & P.S.
Bindapathar, District-Jamtara, Jharkhand.
… … Respondent/Petitioner
2. Shantibala Singh, wife of Bijen Singh, resident of village Phutabandh,
P.O. & P.S. Bindapathar, District-Jamtara, Jharkhand.
… … Respondent/Respondent
------CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SUJIT NARAYAN PRASAD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE PRADEEP KUMAR SRIVASTAVA
------For the Appellant
: Mr. Lalit Yadav, Advocate
For the Respondent : Mr. Aniket Jaiswal, AC to Mrs. J. Mazumdar, Adv.
---------------------------CAV/Reserved on 25.06.2026
Pronounced on: 07.07.2026
Per Sujit Narayan Prasad, J.
1.
The instant appeal under Section 19 of the Family Courts Act, 1984 is
directed against the order/judgment dated 28.06.2021 and decree signed on
09.07.2021 passed by the learned Principal Judge, Family court, Jamtara in
Original Suit No. 29 of 2026, whereby and whereunder, the learned court
has allowed the suit filed under Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955
by petitioner(respondent wife herein) for restitution of conjugal rights
against her husband (appellant herein) and her gotni Shantibala Singh
(respondent no.2 herein).
Factual Matrix
2.
The brief facts of the case as per the original matrimonial suit needs to be
referred herein which is as under:-
3.
The case of the petitioner (respondent no.1 herein) as pleaded in the plaint
is that the appellant and respondent no.1 are husband and wife and
[2026:JHHC:20002-DB]
respondent no. 2 is elder gotni. The respondent no.1 was married with the
appellant Gunadhar Singh about 18 years ago as per Hindu rites and
customs with dowry in the presence of members of both the parties,
Brahamin, Barber and Priest etc at the residence of respondent no.1’s (wife)
parents in village Punishia with observance of the Hindu rites and customs
of kanyadaan, sindurdaan and saptpadi. After the marriage the respondent
no.1 stayed at the house of her parents up to three years because of there
not being second marriage (dwiragaman).
4.
It has further been pleaded that the parents of the respondent no.1 had given
Rs. 51,000/- cash and golden ring, golden chain, wrist watch, clothes etc, to
the appellant. The ritual of dwıragaman was solemnized three years after
the marriage in which the parents of the respondent no.1 had gifted almirah,
two big boxes full of things, golden bracelet, golden ring, ear ring, nose ring
and payal, sarees and other clothes as well as the other house hold utensils,
like bed, table, chair, dressing table etc. total amounting to Rs. 3,33,500/and the respondent no.1 came to her matrimonial home and started leading
her conjugal and worldly life happily with her parents-in-law, bhaisur, gotni
and husband. The husband of the respondent no.1 gradually got entangled
in illicit relationship with the respondent no.2. The respondent no.1 and her
parents used to give instruction to keep distance from such relation but all
went in vain and both of them continued the illicit relationship as the
husband of the respondent no. 2 works outside.
5.
In these circumstances, the respondent no.1 spent her life anyhow under
assault and abuse. The panchayat was also held several times but to no avail.
Meanwhile on 15.05.2015, the appellant herein and respondent no.2
tortured the respondent no.1 physically, mentally and economically and
drove her out of her matrimonial home and therefore, being compelled with
the same the respondent no.1 lodged a complaint case no. 98/15
corresponding to G.R case No. 767/15 which was pending before the Court
of C.J.M Jamtara and in that case the respondent no. 2 was arrested by the
police and produced before the Court and the anticipatory bail petition of
the appellant was rejected up to the Hon'ble High Court of Jharkhand,
Ranchi.
[2026:JHHC:20002-DB]
6.
The respondent no.1 had also lodged another case being D.V case no. 06/15
under the Domestic Violence Act 2005 before the Court of C.J.M Jamtara.
It has further been pleaded that the appellant who is a government teacher
in primary school Gourisol, District-Jamshedpur and is earning about
Rs.50,000/- per month and has also much movable and immovable
properties in his share, big house in village Phutaband and about 10 acres
landed property in his share and also a house in New Town Jamtara which
has been captured by the respondent no. 2 because of illicit relationship.
The respondent no.1 cannot remarry and therefore, tolerating all the pains
she has filed the original suit for restitution of conjugal rights before the
learned Family Court.
7.
It has been pleaded before the learned Family Court that the cause of action
for the suit arose on 10.04.2016 on Sunday, when the respondent no.1 and
her relatives, brother and members of the society requested the
appellant/husband to keep the petitioner/wife with him and lead conjugal
life by compromising the above two cases but both the appellant and
respondent no.2 and the husband of the respondent no.2, replied that they
would not keep the respondent no.1 at their house at any cost nor she will
get the status of wife and then all of them decided for the institution of the
suit to get the right.
8.
On the basis of the aforesaid, the respondent no.1/petitioner/wife had filed
suit for restitution of conjugal rights before the learned family Court under
Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act 1955.
9.
The respondent no. 2 did not appear before the Court but the appellant who
is the main contestant being husband of the respondent no.1 herein-wife
appeared before the Court and filed his written statement pleading therein
that the case filed by the petitioner/respondent no.1 is all false and
motivated and not maintainable in law and so fit to be dismissed.
10.
It has been stated that the petitioner/respondent no.1/wife is about 10 years
older than this appellant and she is women of questionable character and
she has been set up by some interested persons to rope this appellant for
extorting money from him. The malafide object behind this false case will
be apparent from the mysterious impleadement of respondent no. 2 Smt.
[2026:JHHC:20002-DB]
Shantibala Singh who happens to be a lady aged about 50 years and the
mother of the two adult sons aged about 30 years and 25 years and her
împleadement in this case u/s 9 of Hindu Marriage Act is beyond
understanding.
11. It has further been pleaded that the respondent no.1 Dhonibala Singh is not
the wife of this appellant and they were never married with each other. No
marriage ceremony according to law and custom was ever performed
between the appellant and the respondent no.1 at any time and up till now
she never lived with this appellant anywhere at anytime. So far the
allegation of paragraphs 14 and 15 of the plaint are concerned, the appellant
submits that it is true that the respondent no.1/wife had filed a case u/s 498A
of I.P.C against the appellant/husband in which he was in custody for some
time and in spite of allegation of torture committed upon her by the
appellant she did not file any case against him for a long period of about 18
years but just when the appellant got a government job, the case and two
other cases were filed against him simultaneously only with malafide object
of pressurizing him and extorting money from him and she was set up to
file this case by someone of locality connected with the Court work. The
actual fact is that the respondent no.1 when became young, fell in love with
next door neighbour Bhola Singh and continued her illicit relationship with
him although he was married and such illicit relationship caused family
feud in Bhola's family which is known to everyone in the locality. Due to
such illicit relationship, she could not be married with anybody and is still
living in her father's house.
12. It is evident from the factual aspect as referred hereinabove which led to
filing of the present appeal that, as per the Original Matrimonial Suit, the
appellant and respondent no.1 are husband and wife and respondent no. 2
is elder gotni. The respondent no.1 was married with the appellant
Gunadhar Singh about 18 years ago as per Hindu rites and customs. After
the marriage the respondent no.1 stayed at the house of her parents up to
three years because of there not being second marriage (dwiragaman). It
has further been pleaded that the parents of the respondent no.1 had given
Rs. 51,000/- cash and golden ring, golden chain, wrist watch, clothes etc, to
the appellant. The ritual of dwıragaman was solemnized three years after
[2026:JHHC:20002-DB]
the marriage in which the parents of the respondent no.1 had gifted almirah,
two big boxes full of things, golden bracelet, golden ring, ear ring, nose ring
and payal, sarees and other clothes as well as the other house hold utensils,
like bed, table, chair, dressing table etc. total amounting to Rs. 3,33,500/and the respondent no.1 came to her matrimonial home and started leading
her conjugal and worldly life happily with her parents-in-law, bhaisur, gotni
and husband. It has been alleged that the husband of the respondent no.1
gradually got entangled in illicit relationship with the respondent no.2. The
respondent no.1 and her parents used to give instruction to keep distance
from such relation but all went in vain and both of them continued the illicit
relationship as the husband of the respondent no. 2 works outside.
13. The panchayat was also held several times but to no avail. Meanwhile on
15.05.2015, the appellant/husband and respondent no.2 tortured the
petitioner/respondent no.1/wife physically, mentally and economically and
drove her out of her matrimonial home and therefore, being compelled with
the same the respondent no.1 lodged a complaint case no. 98/15
corresponding to G.R case No. 767/15 which was pending before the Court
of C.J.M Jamtara and in that case the respondent no. 2 was arrested by the
police and produced before the Court who was sent to jail and the
anticipatory bail petition of the appellant was rejected up to the Hon'ble
High Court of Jharkhand, Ranchi.
14. The respondent no.1 had also lodged another case being D.V case no. 06/15
under the Domestic Violence Act 2005 before the Court of C.J.M Jamtara.
It has further been pleaded that the appellant who is a government teacher
in primary school Gourisol, District-Jamshedpur and is earning about
Rs.50,000/- per month and has movable and immovable properties in his
share, house in village Phutaband and about 10 acres landed property in his
share and also a house in New Town Jamtara which has been captured by
the respondent no. 2 because of illicit relationship. The respondent no.1
cannot remarry and therefore, tolerating all the pains she has filed the
original suit for restitution of conjugal rights before the learned Family
Court.
[2026:JHHC:20002-DB]
15. The cause of action for the suit arose on 10.04.2016 on Sunday, when the
respondent no.1 and her relatives, brother and members of the society
requested the appellant to keep the petitioner with him and lead conjugal
life by compromising the above two cases but both the appellant and
respondent no.2 and the husband of the respondent no.2, replied that they
would not keep the respondent no.1 at their house at any cost nor she will
get the status of wife and then all of them decided for the institution of the
suit to get the right.
16. On the basis of the aforesaid, the respondent no.1/petitioner/wife had filed
suit for restitution of conjugal rights before the family Court under Section
9 of the Hindu Marriage Act 1955.
17. On being noticed, the respondent no. 2 did not appear before the Court but
the appellant appeared before the Court and filed his written statement
pleading therein that the case filed by the respondent no.1 Dhonibala Singh
is all false and motivated and not maintainable in law and so fit to be
dismissed. The respondent no.1 is about 10 years older than this appellant
and she is women of questionable character. She has been set up by some
interested persons to rope this appellant for extorting money from him. The
malafide object behind this false case will be apparent from the mysterious
impleadement of respondent no. 2 Smt. Shantibala Singh who happens to
be a lady aged about 50 years and the mother of the two adult sons aged
about 30 years and 25 years and her împleadement in this case u/s 9 of
Hindu Marriage Act is beyond understanding. It has further been pleaded
that the respondent no.1 Dhonibala Singh is not the wife of this appellant
and they were never married with each other. So far the allegation of
paragraph 14 and 15 of the plaint are concerned, the appellant submits that
it is true that the respondent no.1 had filed a case u/s 498A of I.P.C against
the appellant in which he was in custody for some time and in spite of
allegation of torture committed upon her by the appellant she did not file
any case against him for a long period of 20 years but just when the
appellant got a government job, the case and two other cases were filed
against him simultaneously only with malafide object of pressurizing him
and extorting money from him and she was set up to file this case by
someone of locality connected with the Court work. The actual fact is that
[2026:JHHC:20002-DB]
the respondent no.1 fell in love with next door neighbour Bhola Singh and
continued her illicit relationship with him although he was married and such
illicit relationship caused family feud in Bhola's family which is known to
everyone in the locality. Due to such illicit relationship she could not be
married with anybody and is still living in her father's house.
18. The learned Family Judge framed altogether seven issues which are as
follows:
(1)
Whether the suit is maintainable in its present form?
(2)
Whether there is any cause of action for the suit?
(3)
Whether the petitioner and respondent are legally marriage wife
and husband?
(4)
Has the petitioner ever lived with the respondent as his wife?
(5)
Whether the respondent has any reasonable cause for withdrawing
himself from the society of the petitioner and refused to perform
his marital obligation?
(6)
Whether the petitioner is entitled to get a decree for restitution of
conjugal rights?
(7)
Whether the petitioner is entitled to get any other relief or reliefs?
19. The evidences have been made on behalf of both the parties. Thereafter, the
judgment has been passed allowing the suit by holding that the appellant
has withdrawn himself from the society of the respondent no.1/wife
without any reasonable excuse, as such, the respondent no.1 is entitled to
get a decree for restitution of conjugal rights and therefore, the suit has
been decreed against the appellant and has been directed to take the
respondent no.1 back from her parent’s house, live with her and to continue
conjugal relationship at her matrimonial home within two months from the
date of the order, which is the subject matter of the present appeal.
Submission of the learned counsel for the appellant/husband:
20. It has been contended on behalf of the appellant/husband that the factual
aspect which was available before the learned court supported by the
evidences adduced on behalf of the appellant/husband has not properly been
[2026:JHHC:20002-DB]
considered and as such, the judgment impugned is perverse, hence, not
sustainable in the eyes of law.
21. It has been submitted that the learned family court has not considered the
fact that the appellant has never solemnized marriage with the respondent
no.1 at any time which has been supported by the witnesses being R.W.
No.1, R.W. No.2 and R.W. No.4.
22. Learned counsel for the appellant/husband, based upon the aforesaid
grounds, has submitted that the judgment impugned suffers from perversity,
as such, not sustainable in the eyes of law.
Submission of the learned counsel for the respondent no.1/petitioner/wife:
23. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent no.1/wife, while defending
the impugned judgment, has submitted that there is no error in the impugned
judgement.
24. The learned Family Judge has considered the issues in its entirety and based
upon the cogent evidences has concluded that the appellant husband
without any reasonable excuse has withdrawn himself from the society of
the respondent wife.
25. Learned counsel, based upon the aforesaid ground, has submitted that if on
that pretext, the judgment has been passed allowing the original suit filed
for restitution of conjugal rights, the impugned judgment cannot be said to
suffer from an error, as such, the present appeal is fit to be dismissed.
Analysis:
26. This Court has heard the learned counsel for the parties and gone through
the finding recorded by the learned Family Judge in the impugned
judgment.
27. The case has been heard at length. The admitted fact herein is that the suit
for restitution of conjugal right has been filed by filing an application under
Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 and accordingly, issues have
been framed by the learned Family Court wherein primarily issue nos.(3),
(4) and (5) pertains to whether the parties are legally married husband and
wife and have lived together as also whether the appellant-husband has any
[2026:JHHC:20002-DB]
reasonable cause for withdrawing himself from the society of the
respondent no.1 and refused to perform his marital obligation.
28. Now adverting to the factual aspect of the case.
29. It is evident that the evidences have been led on behalf of both the parties
before the Family Court. For better appreciation, the evidences led on
behalf of the respondent no.1/wife are being referred as under:
(i)
P.W-1, Subal Singh has deposed that the respondent no.1 and
appellant got married about 19-20 years ago as per Hindu rites and
customs and rituals as well as observing the ritual of saptpadi in the
presence of the family members of both the parties and Late Som
Nath Pandey was working as priest and Late Jatal Bhandari had acted
as barber and the father of the respondent no.1 had given Kanyadaan
and thereafter the respondent no.1 stayed at the house of her parents
up to three years and thereafter dwıragaman ceremony was
performed and she went to her husband's village and started living
there. Sometimes thereafter her husband got job of para-teacher. She
had no knowledge that her husband had illicit relation with the
respondent no. 2 and gradually the appellant started ignoring the
respondent no.1 and torturing mentally, physically and economically.
On enquiry he started beating her. Later on, appellant took the
respondent no.1 and the respondent no. 2, at the house of New Town
Jamtara and started behaving her like maid servant. She was kept
confined in a room and the appellant and respondent no. 2 used to
establish physical relation and on protest she was beaten. A
panchayat was also held but again thereafter they started repeating
the same and in the year 2015 she lodged a case of torture, a case
under DV Act and the present one.
In cross-examination he has stated that the respondent no.1
is his elder sister. He has three brother and three sisters. The
respondent no.1 was married prior to the marriage of this witness and
in her marriage Som Nath Pandey was priest and Jatal Bhandari was
barber. He has further stated that the respondent no.1 petitioner
stayed two three years quite well at the house of her husband but
[2026:JHHC:20002-DB]
ultimately in the year 2015 she was driven out because of dispute. He
has denied the suggestion that there is difference of ten years in the
age of Dhonibala Singh and Gunadhar Singh and that both were
never married nor lived together.
(ii)
P.W.-2, Lakhan Pal has also deposed that the respondent no.1 and
appellant got married about 19-20 years ago as per Hindu rites and
customs and rituals as well as observing the ritual of saptpadi in the
presence of the family members of both the parties and Late Som
Nath Pandey was working as priest and Late Jatal Bhandari had acted
as barber and the father of the respondent no.1 had given Kanyadaan.
He has further stated that the father of the respondent no.1 and father
of this witness are friends and on that account this witness was also
invited and present.
In cross-examination he has admitted that his village
Saluka is situated at a distance of 5 kilometers from the village
Phutabandh and at a distance of about 15 kilometers from the village
Radha Balbhavpur. When the respondent no.1 was married, this
witness was aged about 18 years. He had seen the respondent no.1
and the appellant about one and half year ago at the house of
Dhonibala and at that time their relation was good.
(iii)
P.W.-3, Bhishmdev Singh is the elder brother of the respondent no.1
and he has deposed that the respondent no.1 was married with the
appellant as per Hindu rites and customs during childhood by
observing saptpadi and sindurdaan ritual and after being adult she
went to her sasural about 18-19 years ago and started leading
conjugal life with her husband. The appellant had illicit relation with
the respondent no. 2. The appellant because of the relation with his
bhabhi, drove the respondent no.1 out by beating and torturing.
In cross-examination he has admitted that the respondent
no.1 was driven out about 2 years ago. Appellant has his house at
Phutabandh. This witness was married about 25 years ago and he
cannot tell as to how many years ago of his marriage, the respondent
no.1 was married. He has also denied the suggestion that the
[2026:JHHC:20002-DB]
respondent no.1 was never married with the appellant nor they lived
with each other.
(iv)
P.W.-4, Sarweshar Hansda is the villager of the father of the
respondent no.1 and he has deposed that the respondent no.1 was
married with the appellant as per Hindu rites and customs during
childhood by observing saptpadi and sindurdaan rituals and after
being adult she went to her sasural about 18-19 years ago and started
leading conjugal life with her husband. The appellant had illicit
relation with the respondent no 2. The appellant because of the
relation with his bhabhi, drove the respondent no.1 out by beating
and torturing.
In cross-examination he has admitted that Gunadhar Singh
is younger to him in age. This witness had not seen the bhabhi of the
appellant.
(v)
P.W.-5, Rathin Singh is cousin of the respondent no.1 and five six
years elder to her. He has deposed that the respondent no.1 was
married with the appellant as per Hindu rites and customs during
childhood at the age of 12, by observing saptpadi and sindurdaan
rituals and after being adult she went to her sasural about 18-19 years
ago and started leading conjugal life with her husband. The appellant
had illicit relation with the respondent no. 2. The appellant because
of the relation with his bhabhi, drove the respondent no.1 out by
beating and torturing.
In cross-examination he has deposed that he has two sisters
and three cousin sisters but he cannot tell the year of marriage of any
one of them. About 31 year ago Dhonibala had gone first time at the
house of her husband and she was 18 years old at that time. The
respondent no.1 lives with her parents and brother. In the marriage
of the respondent no.1 Som Nath was purohit and Jatal Bhandari was
barber but there was no barber or purohit from the side of the
husband. He has denied the suggestion that Dhonibala was never
married as per Hindu rites and customs nor she has ever lived at her
matrimonial home.
[2026:JHHC:20002-DB]
(vi)
P.W.-6 Nidra Bala Singh has deposed that she is the elder sister of
the respondent no.1 and she has also been married in the same village
i.e. phutaband and after the marriage and dwiragaman ceremony she
continuously lives at the house of her husband and the sasural of this
witness as well as that of the respondent no.1 falls in the same area.
She has further deposed that the respondent no.1 was married with
the appellant as per Hindu rites and customs during childhood at the
age of 12, by observing saptpadi and sindurdaan rituals and after
being adult she went to her sasural and started leading conjugal life
with her husband. The appellant had illicit relation with the
respondent no. 2 and because of the same, he drove the respondent
no.1 out by beating and torturing.
In her cross-examination she has stated that she has
deposed as witness three times from the side of the respondent no.1
and against the appellant. She cannot tell how many years after the
marriage of this witness, the marriage of the respondent no.1 was
solemnized. As per the custom and rites in his family the girls are
married after being adult. She has also denied that the respondent
no.1 and the appellant were never married nor they have ever lived
together as husband and wife.
(vii) P.W.-7 is the respondent no.1 (petitioner before the learned Family
Court) herself and she has deposed that she is the wife of the
appellant Gunadhar Singh and she was married with him about 22
years ago as per Hindu rites and customs by observing the rituals of
saptpadi and sindurdaan in presence of her relatives, Bhrahamin,
Barber and three years thereafter her dwiragaman ceremony was
performed and she started leading conjugal life at the house of her
husband as well as her parents-in-law, bhaisur, gotni etc. at village
phutaband and while residing in her sasural her name was entered in
the voter list along with her husband Gunadhar Singh, father-in-law
Bhola Nath Singh, Bhaaisur and Gotni in the same house number in
village phutaband P.S Bindapathar District Jamtara in the year 2009,
2010, 2014 and 2015 and she has filed the certified copies of the
same. She has further stated that her Bhaisur Bijan Singh was
[2026:JHHC:20002-DB]
working in railway and constructed a house in Jamtara New Town
Mohalla where her gotni Shanti Devi was also living with whom her
husband got physical relation and when she caught and protested and
complained to her father, brother and parents-in-law, quarrel started
in the family. Panchayat was also held but her husband abused and
beat her and drove her out four and half years ago and since then she
is residing at the house of her father. She also filed a case against her
husband u/s 498A I.P.C as well as another case under D.V Act in
which she has been granted Rs. 4000/- per month as maintenance
allowance and Rs. 5000/- for expenses of the proceeding and she is
legally married wife of appellant and she has the legal right to lead
conjugal life with her husband.
In cross-examination she has admitted that she has filed
three cases against the appellant. Subal Singh is her brother but she
does not remember if he is elder or younger than her. She cannot tell
the age of her elder sister Nidra Singh. She does not remember if she
has filed all the three cases against the appellant prior to his getting
job. He has driven her out of her matrimonial home by beating about
4 and half years ago and prior to that she was living with her husband
in phutaband and thereafter she was living with him at New Town
Jamtara and that house is in the name of all the three brothers namely
Gunadhar Singh, Bijay Pad Singh and Bijan Singh. She has further
stated that while filing this case she has got her age mentioned as 40
years in the affidavit of the plaint and at the time of filing her
evidence on affidavit she has mentioned her age as 42 years. She has
denied the suggestion that she is at least 10 years older than the
appellant and that she has not been married with him and after he got
the job she falsely implicated him in this case under the plan.
30. The evidences led on behalf of the appellant/husband are being referred as
under:
(i)
R.W.-1, Fatick Singh who is the brother-in-law of the appellant and
he has deposed that the respondent no.1 was never married with the
respondent no.1 as per Hindu rites and customs and rituals nor he has
[2026:JHHC:20002-DB]
ever seen the respondent no.1 living in the house of the appellant.
After the appellant got the job, some villagers only to extort money
from him, set up the respondent no.1 who started claiming to be his
wife and lodging false cases. He has further stated that the appellant
has no house at Jamtara. He always used to reside in the village and
when got job he resides in Jamshedpur.
In cross-examination he has admitted that he is the brotherin-law of the appellant and he is 61 years old but he cannot say his
age at the time of his marriage. He also cannot say at which age
Gunadhar Singh was married. He has denied the suggestion that he
is falsely deposing being brother-in-law of the appellant.
(ii)
R.W.-2, Vikash Chandra Singh is the nephew of the appellant and he
has deposed that the respondent no.1 was never married with the
appellant as per Hindu rites and customs and rituals nor she has ever
lived in the house of the appellant. After the appellant got the job,
some villagers only to extort money from him, set up the respondent
no.1 who started claiming to be his wife and lodging false cases. He
has further stated that the appellant has no house at Jamtara he always
used to reside in the village and after he got job, he resides in
Jamshedpur.
In cross-examination, he has admitted that Gunadhar
Singh has three brothers and two others are Bijan Chandra Singh and
Bijay Pado Singh and this witness is the son of Bijay Pado Pado
Singh though they live separately. This witness has his name in the
Voter list. He has cast his vote three four times. He has further
admitted that the name of Gunadhar is also in the voter list on Sl.No.
272 and the name of Dhonibala, wife of Gunadhar Singh is on Sl. No.
269 in the voter list.
(iii)
R.W.-3 Sandhiya Rani is the bhabhi of Gunadhar Singh and she has
deposed that the respondent no.1 was never married with the
appellant as per Hindu rites and customs and rituals nor they ever
lived together as husband and wife. After the job of appellant became
permanent, some villagers only to extort money from him set up the
[2026:JHHC:20002-DB]
respondent no.1 who started claiming to be his wife and lodging false
cases. She has further stated that the appellant has no house at
Jamtara and he always used to reside in the village and when his job
became permanent, he went to TATA and resides there.
In cross-examination she has admitted that the name of her
father-in-law is Bhola Nath Singh who has three sons and first one is
her husband Vijay Pado Sigh, second one is Bijan Singh and third
one is appellant Gunadhar Singh. She has further stated that her name
is in the voter list in house no. 51 and the names of her dever and
gotni are also in the voter list but she knows nothing about Dhonibala
and at last she has denied the suggestion that she is falsely deposing
because of being bhabhi of the appellant.
(iv)
R.W.-4 Gunadhar Singh is the appellant (respondent no.1 in the
original suit) and is the main contestant in the case. He has deposed
that Dhonibala Singh is ten years older than him and she has been set
up by some of his villagers for extortion of money from him. The
case has been filed for restitution of conjugal rites and therefore,
there is no reason for pleading his bhabhi as a party. He has further
stated that he has never married with Dhonibala as per Hindu rites
and customs nor she has ever lived with him together as husband and
wife He has admitted that Dhonibala has filed a case of torture due
to Dowry which is false and baseless. It is remarkable that she has
been tolerating the alleged torture for about 20 years but has not
complained anywhere and as soon as he got a permanent job of
teacher, she filed several cases mislead by others for extorting
money. She is taking maintenance allowance in domestic violence
case from him. She is not his legally married wife therefore, there is
no justification to keep her with him.
In cross-examination he has admitted that he is a
government teacher posted at Primary School Kuldiha, district
Jamshedpur. His parental house is situated in village phutaband. He
does not remember the house number of his parental house. He does
not have his name in voter list. He does not know if the names of his
[2026:JHHC:20002-DB]
brothers are in the voter list. He has denied that his name is mentioned
in the voter list of 2014 with his wife Dhonibala. He has also denied
that in the voter list from 2007 to 2014 his name along with the name
of his wife Dhonibala and the name of his other brothers is mentioned
in house no. 51. He has further denied that Dhonibala is not his
legally married wife and as he does not like her, he has falsely
deposed.
31. The learned Family Judge has appreciated the evidences led on behalf of
the parties as also the submission made in the pleading, i.e., plaint and
written statement, and on consideration of the aforesaid, has allowed the
suit filed by respondent no.1/wife for restitution of conjugal rights by
holding that the appellant has withdrawn himself from the society of the
respondent no.1 without any reasonable excuse, as such, the respondent
no.1 is entitled to get a decree for restitution of conjugal and therefore, the
suit has been decreed against the appellant-husband herein and has been
directed to take the respondent no.1 back from her parent’s house, live with
her and to continue conjugal relationship at her matrimonial home within
two months from the date of the order.
32. The learned counsel for the appellant/husband has argued that the evidence
led before the learned Family Court has not properly been considered and
as such, the judgment suffers from perversity, hence, not sustainable in the
eyes of law.
33. While on the other hand, argument has been advanced on behalf of the
respondent no.1/wife that the judgment is well considered one, as such, the
judgment impugned passed by the learned Family Court may not be
interfered with as the same has been passed after consideration of all the
aspects of the matter and material, evidences and exhibits placed on record.
34. This Court while appreciating the argument advanced on behalf of the
parties on the issue of perversity needs to refer herein the interpretation of
the word “perverse” as has been interpreted by the Hon'ble Apex Court
which means that there is no evidence or erroneous consideration of the
evidence. The Hon'ble Apex Court in Arulvelu and Anr. vs. State
[Represented by the Public Prosecutor] and Anr., (2009) 10 SCC 206
[2026:JHHC:20002-DB]
while elaborately discussing the word perverse has held that it is, no doubt,
true that if a finding of fact is arrived at by ignoring or excluding relevant
material or by taking into consideration irrelevant material or if the finding
so outrageously defies logic as to suffer from the vice of irrationality
incurring the blame of being perverse, then, the finding is rendered infirm
in law. Relevant paragraphs, i.e., paras-24, 25, 26 and 27 of the said
judgment reads as under:
“24. The expression “perverse” has been dealt with in a number of
cases. In Gaya Din v. Hanuman Prasad [(2001) 1 SCC 501] this Court
observed that the expression “perverse” means that the findings of the
subordinate authority are not supported by the evidence brought on
record or they are against the law or suffer from the vice of procedural
irregularity.
25. In Parry's (Calcutta) Employees' Union v. Parry & Co. Ltd. [AIR
1966 Cal 31] the Court observed that “perverse finding” means a
finding which is not only against the weight of evidence but is altogether
against the evidence itself. In Triveni Rubber & Plastics v. CCE [1994
Supp (3) SCC 665 : AIR 1994 SC 1341] the Court observed that this is
not a case where it can be said that the findings of the authorities are
based on no evidence or that they are so perverse that no reasonable
person would have arrived at those findings.
26. In M.S. Narayanagouda v. Girijamma [AIR 1977 Kant 58] the
Court observed that any order made in conscious violation of pleading
and law is a perverse order. In Moffett v. Gough [(1878) 1 LR 1r 331]
the Court observed that a “perverse verdict” may probably be defined
as one that is not only against the weight of evidence but is altogether
against the evidence. In Godfrey v. Godfrey [106 NW 814] the Court
defined “perverse” as turned the wrong way, not right; distorted from
the right; turned away or deviating from what is right, proper, correct,
etc.
27. The expression “perverse” has been defined by various dictionaries
in the following manner:
1. Oxford Advanced Learner's Dictionary of Current English, 6th
Edn.
“Perverse.—Showing deliberate determination to behave in a way
that most people think is wrong, unacceptable or unreasonable.”
2. Longman Dictionary of Contemporary English, International
Edn.
Perverse.—Deliberately departing from what is normal and
reasonable.
3. The New Oxford Dictionary of English, 1998 Edn.
Perverse.—Law (of a verdict) against the weight of evidence or the
direction of the judge on a point of law.
4. The New Lexicon Webster's Dictionary of the English
Language (Deluxe Encyclopedic Edn.)
Perverse.—Purposely deviating from accepted or expected
behavior or opinion; wicked or wayward; stubborn; cross or petulant.
5. Stroud's Judicial Dictionary of Words & Phrases, 4th Edn.
[2026:JHHC:20002-DB]
“Perverse.—A perverse verdict may probably be defined as one that is
not only against the weight of evidence but is altogether against the
evidence.””
35. Herein, it would be appropriate to discuss the object and scope of decree of
restitution. The object of restitution decree was to bring about cohabitation
between the estranged parties so that they could live together in the
matrimonial home in amity. The leading idea of Section 9 was to preserve
the marriage. For ready reference Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act is
being referred as under:
9. Restitution of conjugal right.—When either the husband or the wife
has, without reasonable excuse, withdrawn from the society of the
other, the aggrieved party may apply, by petition to the district court,
for restitution of conjugal rights and the court, on being satisfied of the
truth of the statements made in such petition and that there is no legal
ground why the application should not be granted, may decree
restitution of conjugal rights accordingly. [Explanation.—Where a
question arises whether there has been reasonable excuse for
withdrawal from the society, the burden of proving reasonable excuse
shall be on the person who has withdrawn from the society.]
36. From perusal of the aforesaid provision, it is evident that if either the
husband or the wife has, without reasonable excuse, withdrawn from the
society of the other, the aggrieved party may apply, before the court
concerned, for restitution of conjugal rights and the court, on being satisfied
with the statements made in such petition and further taking into
consideration the legal ground that why the application should not be
granted, may decree restitution of conjugal rights accordingly.
37. Further in explanation part of the said provision, it has been prescribed that
when a question arises whether there has been “reasonable excuse” for
withdrawal from the society, the burden of proving “reasonable excuse”
shall be on the person who has withdrawn from the society.
38. It needs to refer herein that conjugal rights may be viewed in its proper
perspective by keeping in mind the dictionary meaning of the expression
"Conjugal" wherein the meaning of 'conjugal' as "of or pertaining to
marriage or to husband and wife in their relations to each other" is given
(Shorter Oxford English Dictionary, 3rd Edn. Vol. I page 371).
[2026:JHHC:20002-DB]
39. In the Dictionary of English Law, 1959 Edn. at page 453, Earl Jowitt defines
'conjugal rights' thus:
"The right which husband and wife have to each other's society and
marital intercourse. The suit for restitution of conjugal rights is a
matrimonial suit, cognizable in the Divorce Court, which is brought
whenever either the husband or the wife lives separate from the other
without any sufficient reason, in which case the court will decree
restitution of conjugal rights (Matrimonial Causes Act, 1950, s. 15), but
will not enforce it by attachment, substituting however for attachment,
if the wife be the petitioner, an order for periodical payments by the
husband to the wife (s.22). Conjugal rights cannot be enforced by the
act of either party, and a husband cannot seize and detain his wife by
force (R.V. Jackson [1891] 1 Q.B. 671)".
40. In India it may be borne in mind that conjugal rights i.e. right of the husband
or the wife to the society of the other spouse is not merely creature of the
statute. Such a right is inherent in the very institution of marriage itself.
Thus, the restitution of conjugal rights is often regarded as a matrimonial
remedy. The remedy of restitution of conjugal rights is a positive remedy
that requires both parties to the marriage to live together and cohabit.
41. Thus, the requirements of the provision of restitution of conjugal rights are
the following:
(i)
The withdrawal by the respondent from the society of the petitioner.
(ii)
The withdrawal is without any reasonable cause or excuse or lawful
ground.
(iii)
There should be no other legal ground for refusal of the relief.
(iv)
The court should be satisfied about the truth of the statement made in
the petition.
42. The Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Suman Singh v. Sanjay Singh,
(2017) 4 SCC 85 has categorically observed that when there is evidence
establishing that it was respondent husband who withdrew from appellant's
company without any reasonable cause, appellant is entitled to decree for
restitution of conjugal rights. For ready reference the relevant paragraph is
being quoted as under:
[2026:JHHC:20002-DB]
“24. In our considered view, as it appears to us from perusal of the
evidence that it is the respondent who withdrew from the appellant's
company without there being any reasonable cause to do so. Now that
we have held on facts that the respondent failed to make out any case
of cruelty against the appellant, it is clear to us that it was the
respondent who withdrew from the company of the appellant without
reasonable cause and not the vice versa. 25. In view of the foregoing
discussion, the appeals succeed and are allowed. The impugned
judgment [Suman Singh v. Sanjay Singh, 2013 SCC OnLine Del 2138 :
(2013) 136 DRJ 107] is set aside. As a result, the petition filed by the
respondent (husband) under Section 13(1) of the Act seeking dissolution
of marriage is dismissed. As a consequence thereof, the marriage
between the parties is held to subsist whereas the petition filed by the
appellant against the respondent under Section 9 of the Act seeking
restitution of conjugal rights is allowed. A decree for restitution of
conjugal rights is, accordingly, passed against the respondent.
26. We hope and trust that the parties would now realise their duties
and obligations against each other as also would realise their joint
obligations as mother and father towards their grown up daughters.
Both should, therefore, give a quiet burial to their past deeds/acts and
bitter experiences and start living together and see that their daughters
are well settled in their respective lives. Such reunion, we feel, would
bein the interest of all family members in the long run and will bring
peace, harmony and happiness. We find that the respondent is working
as a “Caretaker” in the Government Department (see Para 4 of his
petition). He must, therefore, be the “Caretaker” of his own family that
being his first obligation and at the same time attend to his government
duties to maintain his family.”
43. Thus, on the basis of aforesaid settled position of law, it is evident that the
court will grant a decree for restitution of conjugal rights when one spouse
has withdrawn from the other's society without reasonable excuse. This
means if a husband or wife leaves the marital home or refuses to live with
their spouse without a justifiable reason, the other spouse can file petition
before the court for this remedy. The court, if satisfied with the truth of the
petition and finding no legal barrier, may order the withdrawing spouse to
return and resume cohabitation.
[2026:JHHC:20002-DB]
44. In the backdrop of the settled position this Court is now re-adverting to the
factual aspect of the instant case.
45. It has been contended by the learned counsel for the appellant that the
learned family court has not considered the fact that the appellant has never
solemnized marriage with the respondent no.1/wife at any time which has
been supported by the witnesses being R.W. No.1, R.W. No.2 and R.W.
No.4.
46. In order to appreciate the aforesaid contention we have ventured into
impugned judgment wherefrom it is evident that the learned family court
has taken note of the fact that there are several other documentary evidence
from the side of the petitioner (respondent no.1/wife herein) viz., Ext.2/1
which is CC of voter list of the year 2010, Ext.2/2 which is CC of voter list
of the year 2014, Ext.2/3 which is CC of voter list of the year 2015, Ext.3
which is Aadhar card of the petitioner (respondent no.1/wife herein) and
Ext.4 which is voter ID card of Dhonobala Singh (respondent no.1/wife
herein) which also corroborate the marriage between petitioner and
respondent no. 1 (appellant/husband herein) because in all these documents
the name of the respondent no. 1 (appellant/husband herein) has been
mentioned as husband of the petitioner (respondent no.1/wife herein) in the
same house no. 51 of village Phutabandh which is parental house of the
respondent/appellant/husband and all these documents are prima facie
evidence of the relationship of marriage and have corroborative value
though not conclusive one and to rebut the same no cogent evidence has
been adduced from the side of the respondent/appellant/husband rather he
has taken the stand that the petitioner/respondent no.1/wife has been set up
by some of his villagers which is very vague and general in nature and not
proved by any evidence as to who are those villagers/persons and Ext. 1 and
1/1 which are purcha of agricultural property do not appear to have any
relevance in this case.
47. Further it is evident from impugned order/judgment that the learned Family
Court has also taken note of the fact that the petitioner (respondent no.1
herein) is the legally married wife of the respondent no. 1 (appellant herein)
and she has also lived with him at her matrimonial home together up to
[2026:JHHC:20002-DB]
2015 just before she was driven out of her matrimonial home by the
respondent no. 1 (appellant herein).
48. Further the learned Family Court has taken into consideration the testimony
of the respondent no.1/wife and has found that the wife has very clearly
deposed that after her marriage, she went to her sasural and started living
with respondent no.1/husband at the matrimonial home but because of illicit
relation with the respondent no. 2, the respondent no. 1/husband started
torturing her in different ways and ultimately respondent no. 1/husband
drove her out of her matrimonial home by beating her in the year 2015 and
thereafter she came to the house of her parents and is residing there and this
portion of evidence has been corroborated by the evidence of P.W.-1 to
P.W.-6. Accordingly, the learned Family Court has finally reached to the
conclusion that the respondent no. 1/husband (appellant herein) has
withdrawn himself from the society of petitioner(respondent no.1/wife
herein) without any reasonable cause and accordingly, this issue is decided
in
favour
of
the
petitioner/respondent/wife
and
against
the
respondent/appellant/husband. For ready reference the relevant paragraph
of the aforesaid order of learned Family Court are being quoted herein
which reads as under:
“14.Not only this, there are several other documentary evidence from
the side of the petitioner namely Ext.2/1 which is CC of voterlist of the
year 2010, Ext.2/2 which is CC of voter list of the year 2014, Ext.2/3
which is CC of voter list of the year 2015. Ext.3 which is Aadhar card
of the petitioner Dhonibala Singh and Ext.4 which is voter ID card of
Dhonobala Singh which also corroborate the marriage between
petitioner and respondent no. 1 because in all these documents the
name of the respondent no. 1 has been mentioned as husband of the
petitioner in the same house no. 51 of village Phutabandh which is
parental house of the respondent and all these documents are prima
facie evidence of the relationship of marriage and have corroborative
value though not conclusive one and to rebut the same no cogent
evidence has been adduced from the side of the respondent rather he
has taken the stand that the petitioner has been set up by some of his
villagers which is very vague and general in nature and not proved by
any evidence as to who are those villagers/persons. Ext. 1 and 1/1
[2026:JHHC:20002-DB]
which are purcha of agricultural property do not appear to have any
relevance in this case.
23. Thus, on the basis of the above discussions, it is held proved that
the petitioner is the legally married wife of the respondent no. 1 and she
has also lived with him at her matrimonial home together up to 2015
just before she was driven out of her matrimonial home by the
respondent. Accordingly, both these issues are decided in favour of
petitioner and against the respondent.
24. Now, as regards Issue No. 5 which is " Whether the respondent has
any reasonable cause for withdrawing himself from the society of the
petitioner?" on this point, PW7 Dhonibala Singh has very clearly
deposed that after her marriage with the respondent no. 1 she went to
her sasural and started living with him at the matrimonial home but
because of illicit relation with the respondent no. 2, the respondent no.
1 started torturing her in different ways and ultimately he drove her out
of her matrimonial home by beating her in the year 2015 and thereafter
she came to the house of her parents and is residing there and this
portion of evidence of this witness has been corroborated by the
evidence of PW1 to PW6 and in such circumstances it is held proved
that the respondent no. 1 has withdrawn himself from the society of
petitioner without any reasonable cause and accordingly, this issue is
decided in favour of the petitioner and against the respondent.
26.Now as regards Issue no. 6 "Whether the petitioner is entitled to get
a decree for restitution of conjugal rights? as it has already been
decided in favour of the plaintiff and against the respondent on the basis
of the evidences of both the sides that the respondent who is legally
married husband of the petitioner, has withdrawn from the society of
the petitioner without any reasonable excuse and so she is residing at
the house of her parents for more than 5 years and therefore, the
petitioner has every right and valid cause of action to file the present
suit and has filed this suit accordingly which well maintainable under
the provision of section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act 1955, the
petitioner automatically gets entitled to a decree for restitution of
conjugal rights and so in view of all these facts , circumstances and
evidence, this issue is also decided in favour of the plaintiff and against
the respondent.
29.Thus, on the basis of the above appreciation of the evidence led on
behalf of both sides I find and hold that the petitioner has been able to
[2026:JHHC:20002-DB]
prove that her husband (respondent No. 1) has withdrawn himself from
the society of the petitioner without any reasonable excuse and so she
is entitled to get a decree for restitution of conjugal rights -----,
49. It is evident from impugned judgment that the learned Family Court has
placed its reliance upon the documentary evidence, viz., Ext.2/1 (certified
copy of voter list, 2010), Ext.2/2 (voter list, 2014), Ext.2/3 (voter list, 2015),
Ext.3 (Aadhar card of Dhonibala Singh), and Ext.4 (voter ID card of
Dhonibala Singh) which have been produced by the petitioner/respondent
no.1/wife. In all these documents, appellant is shown as the husband of the
respondent no.1 residing in house no. 51, village Phutabandh, which is the
parental house of the appellant. These documents, though not conclusive,
constitute prima facie corroborative evidence of marriage. The appellant
has failed to rebut them with cogent proof.
50. Further, Dhonibala Singh/wife deposed that after marriage she resided at
her matrimonial home, but due to appellant’s illicit relationship with
respondent no. 2, she was subjected to cruelty and ultimately expelled in
2015. This testimony is corroborated by P.W.-1 to P.W.-6. It is thus proved
that appellant withdrew from the society of the respondent/wife without
reasonable cause. The issue is decided in favour of the petitioner.
51. From the foregoing paragraphs of the impugned judgment/order, it is
manifest that the learned Family Court has meticulously scrutinized each
document as well as the oral testimonies adduced on behalf of both parties.
Upon such comprehensive appraisal, the learned Family Court has
conclusively determined that respondent no. 1/husband (the appellant
herein) withdrew himself from the society of the petitioner/respondent
no.1/wife without any reasonable cause.
52. This Court, therefore, is of the considered view that the said finding, being
based on cogent appreciation of evidence, does not suffer from perversity.
53. Accordingly, the order/judgment dated 28.06.2021 passed by the learned
Family Court, Jamtara in Original Suit No. 29 of 2026 whereby the suit
filed by the petitioner/respondent wife under Section 9 of the Hindu
Marriage Act, 1955 for restitution of conjugal rights against her husband
[2026:JHHC:20002-DB]
(appellant herein) and her gotni, Shantibala Singh (respondent no. 2 herein),
was allowed, warrants no interference.
54. Accordingly, the instant appeal fails and is dismissed.
55. Pending interlocutory application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
I agree
(Sujit Narayan Prasad, J.)
(Pradeep Kumar Srivastava, J.)
(Pradeep Kumar Srivastava, J.)
07th July, 2026
Saurabh
/A.F.R.
Uploaded on 09.07.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review