Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on: 29th January, 2026
Pronounced on: 13th April, 2026
+
RSA 23/2026, CM APPL. 6232-6234/2026
GULSHAN KHURANA
C/o Shop No.3517/11 & 3517/12
Kumar Building, Qutub Road,
Sadar Bazaar, Delhi.
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Sumit Goswami, Advocate
versus
MANJU MONGA
W/o Sh. Rajender Monga
R/o A-14, Church Compound, Bajoria Road,
District Saharanpur, U.P.
.....Respondent
Through: Ms. Anju Lal and Ms. Shalu Lal,
Advocates
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
This Regular Second Appeal has been preferred under Section 100 of
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC), assailing the Judgment and
Decree dated 31.10.2025, passed by the Ld. District Judge-12 (Central), Tis
Hazari Courts, Delhi in RCA No. 119/2024, whereby the learned First
Appellate Court has upheld and affirmed the Judgment and Decree dated
19.07.2024, passed by the Ld. Civil Judge-08 (Central), Tis Hazari Courts,
Delhi in Civil Suit No. 3629/2019, vide which the suit of the
Plaintiff/Respondent for possession, recovery of arrears of rent and mesne
profits has been decreed.
KUMAR BHATT
18:24:35
RSA 23/2026
2.
The brief facts, as emerging from the record, are that the
Plaintiff/Respondent filed Civil Suit No. 3629/2019, for ejectment and
recovery of mesne profits/rent. The Defendant was inducted as a tenant in
the year 2001 in respect of Shop No.3517/11 and 3517/12 situated on First
Floor, Kumar Building, Qutub Road, Sadar Bazar, Delhi (hereinafter
referred to as the ‘Suit Property’) on a monthly rent of Rs.13,500/- besides
electricity and water charges. The rent was payable in advance on the
commencement of each calendar month.
3.
The Defendant failed to pay rent for the month of August and
September, 2019 despite repeated requests. A Notice dated 19.09.2019 was
sent to the Defendant terminating his tenancy and seeking recovery of
peaceful and vacant Possession. He was also asked to pay the arrears of rent.
4.
The Notice was duly served upon the Defendant/Appellant on
23.09.2019 and the one sent through Speed Post was served upon him on
25.09.2019, but he failed to comply with the same. The Suit for Possession,
Recovery of Arrears of Rent/Mesne Profits @ Rs.40,500/- was thus filed by
the Plaintiff/Respondent.
5.
The Appellant/Defendant had contested the Suit and filed his
Written Statement, wherein he had asserted that the Plaintiff/Respondent
had suppressed material facts. It was admitted that the Plaintiff was the
owner of the property and the Defendant was a tenant. It was clarified that
in respect of Suit Shop bearing No.3517/11, the rent was Rs.1200/- per
month while for the Shop No.3517/12 the rate of rent was Rs.1800/- per
month.
6.
It was further submitted that since the rent was less than Rs.3,500/-,
the Suit for Recovery of Possession was barred under Delhi Rent Control
KUMAR BHATT
18:24:35
RSA 23/2026
Act,1958 and the Suit is liable to be rejected under Order VII Rule 11 CPC.
7.
On merits, all the averments made in the Suit with regard to the rate
of rent were denied. It was also denied that the rate of rent was Rs.13,500/per month.
8.
The Defendant admitted receiving the Legal Notice, but asserted that
he thereafter had a talk on telephone with the husband of the Plaintiff who
assured him that there was nothing to worry and that the Notice got issued
due to a misunderstanding.
9.
It is further submitted that in the year 2018 the Suit property required
repairs as the Plaintiff along with her brother from the roof damaged the
ceiling. The Defendant had requested the husband of the Plaintiff for repairs,
but the husband refused to do so. The water was leaking from the roof
because of which the goods of the Defendant worth more than one lakh got
damaged. The Defendant, therefore, stopped paying the rent and no money
Decree can be passed against him.
10.
The Defendant further asserted that the brother of the Plaintiff was the
owner of one shop in the same building and had sold it for Rs.5 lakhs in the
year 2016. It was at the same time that the Defendant had requested the
Plaintiff to sell the Suit property to the Defendant and the Plaintiff along
with her husband had agreed to sell the Suit Property for a total sale
consideration of Rs.10 lakhs.
11.
However, the Defendant was not having total sale consideration
amount and thus, it was agreed between both the parties, that Defendant
shall pay Rs.10,000/- per month to the Plaintiff and Rs.3,500/- as a rent for
the Suit Property. The total amount of Rs.13,500/- was thus, agreed to be
paid by the Defendant through transfer in the Account of the Plaintiff and
KUMAR BHATT
18:24:35
RSA 23/2026
since then Defendant has been regularly transferring the amount in the
account of the Plaintiff.
12.
It is further submitted that in the year 2018 the Defendant was ready
to pay the consideration amount to the Plaintiff, but the Plaintiff refused to
take the amount. Despite there being oral talks between the parties in the
year 2016 about the sale of the property and it was agreed that the
consideration amount shall be paid by the Defendant in three years. The
Defendant thus, claimed that he was always ready and willing to pay the
consideration amount encashing his FDR from the Bank in November and
December, 2018. It was thus, submitted that the Suit of the Plaintiff was not
maintainable and liable to be dismissed.
13.
The Plaintiff in the Replication reaffirmed his case as stated in the
Plaint and denied the allegations made in the Written Statement.
14.
Issues on the pleadings were framed on 24.03.2023, as under :
(i)
Whether the Plaintiff is entitled for decree of
ejectment of defendant from the suit premises, as prayed
for? OPP
(ii)
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to recovery of
money in the sum of Rs.40,500/- towards arrears of rent/
mesne profits for the period from 01.08.2019 till
31.10.2019, as prayed for? OPP
(iii)
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to mesne profits
for unauthorized use and occupation of the suit premises
by the defendant from the institution of the suit till
recovery of possession? If so, at what rate? OPP
(iv)
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to pendent lite
and future interest? If so, at what rate and for which
period?
(v)
Whether any agreement to sell qua suit premises
was entered into between the parties for a total sum of
Rs.10,00,000/- in the year 2016? OPD
KUMAR BHATT
18:24:35
RSA 23/2026
(vi)
Whether the defendant was paying a sum of
Rs.10,000/- per month to the plaintiff since 2016 towards
part payments of sale consideration of the suit premises?
OPD
(vii)
Whether the defendant was paying a sum of
Rs.3500/- per month towards rent to the plaintiff? OPD
(viii)
Relief.
15.
The Plaintiff in support of her case examined herself as PW1 and
tendered her evidence as Ex.PW1/A.
16.
The Defendant appeared as DW1 and deposed on similar lines in his
Affidavit of Evidence as his defense.
17.
The learned Civil Judge on appreciation of the evidence observed that
the Defendant/Appellant had failed to prove any Agreement for Purchase of
the property. It was further held that the Defendant had admitted in his
Evidence that he was initially paying Rs.12,000/- as rent to the Plaintiff
which was revised in the year 2016-17 to Rs.13,500/-. His claim of there
being an Agreement to Sell or that the sale consideration was to be paid in
monthly installments of Rs.10,000/- was not believed. The Defendant had
even failed to even aver the existence of any Agreement to Sell executed
between the parties, nor any details were forthcoming. Hence, it was
disbelieved that there was Agreement to Sell between the parties.
18.
It was further observed that the Defendant had admitted the Plaintiff
to be the owner of the Suit property. From the admissions of the Defendant
and the Statement of Account dated 01.11.2019, Ex.PW1/2 which reflected
the payment of rent by the Defendant established the relationship of
landlord-tenant between the parties. Moreover, the Defendant in his Written
Statement as well as during the trial had admitted the relationship of
KUMAR BHATT
18:24:35
RSA 23/2026
landlord-tenant, which stood established.
19.
The tenancy was terminated by a Legal Notice under Section 106 of
the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, the service of which had been admitted
by the Defendant. Furthermore, the Defendant had also admitted that he had
stopped making payment of rent to the Plaintiff since August, 2019, thereby
admitting that he was in arrears of rent. From the admissions of the
Defendant/Appellant, the rate of rent was held to be proved as Rs.13,500/and the Defendant was held to be in arrears of rent for the month of August
and September, 2019.
20.
Thereafter, the Mesne Profits were also granted @ Rs.13,500/- per
month w.e.f. 01.10.2019, till the date of handing over of Possession along
with future interest @ 8% per annum from the date of Judgment till actual
realization. The pendente lite interest @ 8% per annum was directed to be
aggregated on the annual rent i.e. from December, 2019 to December, 2020
on the annual rent of each year till the Possession was handed over by the
Defendant.
21.
A Regular Civil Appeal DJ No.119/2024, was filed by the
Defendant/Appellant wherein the learned District Judge upheld the findings
of the learned Sr. Civil Judge on the arrears of rent as well as the findings in
regard to there being no Agreement to Sell. The Judgment of Eviction/
Mesne Profits was therefore, upheld.
22.
Aggrieved by the Judgment, the present Regular Second Appeal has
been filed.
23.
The grounds of challenge are that the Plaintiff had not been able to
prove that she was the sole owner of the Suit property as no document in this
regard had been filed on record. Further, as per Section 17(1)(d) The
KUMAR BHATT
18:24:35
RSA 23/2026
Registration Act,1908, it is compulsory to register any Lease of immovable
properties if it is for a term exceeding 12 months. In the case, the Appellant
was carrying on business as a tenant in the Suit property since 2001.
24.
The Plaintiff filed the Rent Agreement between Manoj Kumar and
Gulshan Khurana. The Trial Court has failed to consider that Rs.1,00,000/had been paid by the Appellant to the Respondent for the execution of
Agreement to Sell in respect of the Suit property to determine and identify
which has not been considered. The Statement of Account Ex.PW1/2 shows
some payment made in the Account of the Appellant. The Respondent has
failed to place any other document on record to prove that Appellant had
been paying the rent @ Rs.13,500/- per month.
25.
The Respondent/Plaintiff had admitted in the cross-examination that
Appellant had given the rent either to her brother in cash or to her in the
account in Punjab National Bank. The documents that Respondent has
exhibited shows the Statement of Account of Bank of Baroda and no other
statement or document relating to Respondent’s Bank Statement has been
filed or exhibited. There is lack of documentary evidence in support of the
case of the Respondent. A prayer is, therefore, made that the Judgment and
Decree dated 19.07.2024 of learned Senior Civil Judge and the Judgment in
First Regular Appeal dated 31.10.2025 upholding the Judgment of Senior
Civil Judge be set aside.
Submissions heard and record perused.
26.
First and foremost, the Defendant in the Written Statement had not
denied
the
relationship
of
landlord-tenant
between
the
parties.
Overwhelming evidence had been produced by the Respondent to show that
the rate of rent which was last paid was Rs.13,500/-. In fact, the Defendant
KUMAR BHATT
18:24:35
RSA 23/2026
had also admitted paying this amount but claimed that Rs.10,000/- were
towards monthly installment and the rent was only Rs.3,500/- per month.
27.
Therefore, there was admission of relationship of landlord-tenant
between the parties and of the rent. The Defendant further admitted the
service of Legal Notice of Termination. Therefore, all the ingredients for
Suit for Possession, Mesne Profits, and Arrears of Rent were proved and had
been rightly so held by the learned Senior Civil Judge and these findings had
been upheld by the learned Appellate Court.
28.
A plea had been taken by the Appellant that there was an
understanding in 2016 that the property would be purchased by the
Defendant/Appellant for total sale consideration of Rs.10 lakhs to be paid in
a period of three years and that it was further agreed that Rs.10,000/- would
be paid by way of monthly installment.
29.
However, both the learned Senior Civil Judge as well as the
Appellate Court had held that there was no specific Deed or any document
in support of Agreement to Sell and even the Bank Statements did not reflect
that any amount of Rs.1 lakh towards the execution of the Agreement to Sell
was ever given by the Appellant/Defendant. It was also held that the
monthly payment being made were towards the monthly rent and not as
installment towards the sale consideration.
30.
In the end, the Appellant has also asserted that the Respondent had
not placed on record any document of ownership. However, Section 116 of
Indian Evidence Act, 1872, provides that where a person who takes a
property on rent from a landlord, he is estopped from challenging the Title
of the landlord. Herein, admittedly the Appellant had entered the property as
a tenant from the Respondent. Therefore, he cannot now challenge the
KUMAR BHATT
18:24:35
RSA 23/2026
ownership of the Respondent in the Suit property.
31.
In the end, it may be observed that there is no Substantial Question of
Law, which has been raised in the present Regular Second Appeal. The
grounds of appeal reflect that challenge is only to the facts of the case,
which is beyond the scope of the Regular Second Appeal. There is no merit
in the present Appeal, which is hereby, dismissed.
32.
The Appeal stands disposed of along with the pending
Application(s).
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
APRIL 13, 2026/va
KUMAR BHATT
18:24:35
RSA 23/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review