Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
$
%
&'
& (
"
"
!#
"
%
)*
&
)
+
!
"
#
Digitally signed
by SHIVALEELA
DATTATRAYA
UDAGI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
#
$
##
"
%
$
&
&
!
'%
(
)
"
%
#
-2-
(
%
%%
$
)
!
"
!*
" $
'
(
%
%$
$
%
(
%
")
!
*!
! !!
"
$
,
$
#!#
$
%
(
)
%
+
!)
$
%
%
!
$
! !!
%
$
$
, ( )
%
$$
$
" #
$
$ %
$
%
$
"
.
/01 23404056 01 70839 :693;
=?=;0@
:;=@1/=
=6/04=
3<4056
! !#
!
133@06?
2;5<33906?1 =?=0614 4/3 234040563;1 =<<:139
"5B36
*!
! !! ( ;0B3
%580<3
2:601/=C83 :693;
4=4056
3<4056
/=;=40>=
A:=1/
51 ! 45
! !!) ;3?0143;39 C>
=8=C:;=?0
, ( )
75;
#!#
4/3
57736<31
-
, ; D
-3-
3<4056 #
57 4/3 %
:9?3 =69
$
!
/3
;312569364
=4
236906? 56 4/3 7083
0E08
=8=C:;=?0
=C;09?39
7=<41 57
4/3
<=13
=;3
4/=4
5 ! 859?39 4/3 <5B28=064 C375;3 ;312569364
F%580<3
*
- ! !!
B=;;0=?3 D04/ =<<:139
!
9904056=8
=883?06?
F 5/9
4/=4
=743;
/3;
=1/=@ 06 4/3 >3=;
=1 23; 4/3 <:145B1 2;3E=0806? 06 4/3
:180B ;380?056
1/3 14=;439 ;310906? =856? D04/ /3; /:1C=69 =69 /3; 06
8=D1 0 3
234040563;1 06 4/3 B=4;0B560=8 /5B3
743;
15B340B3 4/3> /=;=1139 /3; C54/ 2/>10<=88> =69 B364=88>
75; =9904056=8 95D;>
=43; 234040563;1
=69 ! =856?
D04/ /3; /:1C=69 =815 B=93 =6 =443B24 45 <5BB04 /3;
B:;93; C> 25:;06? @3;51363 56 /3;
31<=239 7;5B 4/30; <8:4</31
5D3E3;
1/3
312043 4/3> <56406:39 4/30;
/=;=11B364 =?=0614 /3; C54/ 2/>10<=88> =69 B364=88>
/5:?/
1/3
=22;5=</39
<5B28=064 =<<:139
4/3
%580<3
75;
859?06?
4/3
45 # =11:;39 /3; 4/=4 4/3> D5:89
855@ =743; /3; 2;523;8>
1 1:</ 1/3 909 654 859?3 4/3
<5B28=064
5D3E3; =<<:139 <56406:39 4/30; /=;=11B364
-4-
1 1:</
8374 D04/ 65 54/3; 524056
<5B28=064 C375;3 ;312569364
1/3 859?39 4/3
%580<3 56
D/0</ <=B3 45 C3 ;3?0143;39 4/3 <=13 06
;0B3
*
- ! !!
! !!
=?=0614 4/3 234040563;1 =69 54/3;1 75; 4/3 =75;3B36405639
57736<31
=139 56 4/3 <5B28=064 ;312569364
F%580<3
06E3140?=439 4/3 <=13 =69 8=09 </=;?3 1/334 =?=0614 4/3
234040563;1 =69 =654/3; C> =;;=>06? 4/313 234040563;1 =1
=<<:139
51 !
/3
<5?60G=6<3 57 4/3 57736<31
=<<:139
51 ! 45
#
3=;9
83=;639
0?/
83=;639
=?014;=43
455@
/3 2;31364 23404056 01 70839 C>
45 A:=1/ 4/3 2;5<33906?1
83=;639
5:;4
<5:6138
75;
4/3
234040563;1
5E3;6B364 %83=93; 75; ;312569364
F 4=43 =69 83=;639 <5:6138 75; ;312569364
5!
<5B28=06=64
2=;4 7;5B :;?06? 13E3;=8 <5643640561 83=;639
<5:6138
75;
4/3
234040563;1
<56436939
4/=4
234040563;1 =<<:139
51 ! 45
=;3 65 D=> <5663<439 45
4/3 =883?39 06<09364
<<:139
5 ! 01 4/3 C;54/3; 06 8=D 57
-5-
;312569364
5!
5 ! =69 =<<:139
=<<:139
;312569364
5 ! =69 =<<:139
57 =<<:139
=69
132=;=438>
5 # 01 D073 57 =<<:139
B5;3
C;54/3; 06 8=D
01 4/3 9014=64 ;38=40E3
/:1C=69 57 ;312569364
234040563;
5!
51 # =69
<<:139
=;3 ;310906?
<<5;906? 45 /0B 3H<324 5B60C:1 =883?=40561
B=93 =?=0614 4/313 234040563;1 =C158:438> 65 1:</
B=43;0=81 28=<39 45 1:C14=640=43 4/=4 4/3> =<40E38>
2=;40<02=439 06 4/3 =883?39 57736<3
<<5;906?8> /3 2;=>1
45 =885D 4/3 23404056
83=;639 <5:6138 75; ;312569364
<56436939 4/=4 =<<:139
51 ! =69 # 0 3
=69
=856?
! D3;3 ;310906?
;312569364
5!
<<:139
234040563;
D04/ =<<:139
5!
=69
45 # /=;=1139 ;312569364
5 ! C54/ 2/>10<=88> =69 B364=88> 75; =9904056=8 95D;>
<<5;906? 45 /0B =6 =443B24 D=1 B=93 C> =<<:139
45 # 45 <5BB04 4/3 B:;93; 57 ;312569364
4/5:?/ 1/3 859?39 4/3 <5B28=064
5!
1 1:</
4/3 1=B3 D=1 654
;3?0143;39 06 E03D 57 4/3 =11:;=6<3 ?0E36 C> 4/3 =<<:139
-6-
312043 4/3> <56406:39 4/30; 0883?=8 =<4
36<3 /3 2;=>1
45 901B011 4/3 23404056
-
3=;639
0?/
=223=;06? 75; ;312569364
5:;4
5E3;6B364
%83=93;
4=43 5225139 4/3 23404056
=69 2;=>1 45 901B011 4/3 1=B3
*
4/3
/=E3 ?0E36 B> =6H05:1 <561093;=4056 C54/ 56
1:CB0110561
B=93
C>
83=;639
<5:6138
75;
4/3
;3123<40E3 2=;4031 =69 23;:139 4/3 95<:B3641 B=93
=E=08=C83 56 ;3<5;9
1 <5:89 C3 ?=4/3;39 7;5B ;3<5;91 56 23;:1=8
57 4/3 <5B28=064 =E3;B3641 04 01 14=439 4/=4
=743; 4/3
B=;;0=?3 57 ;312569364
5 ! D04/ =<<:139
14=;439 ;310906? 06 4/3 /5:13 57 =<<:139
=<<:139
51 ! =69 # D3;3 ;310906?
=<<:139
1/3
D/3;3
<<5;906? 45 /3;
45 # /=;=1139 /3; C54/ 2/>10<=88> =69
B364=88> 75; =9904056=8 95D;> C> D=> 57 ?589 =69 <=1/ =69
4/3> =815 B=93 =6 =443B24 45 <5BB04 /3; B:;93; D/0</
;31:8439 06 859?06? 4/3 <5B28=064 C> /3; C375;3 4/3
-7-
;312569364
%580<3
5D3E3;
4/3 1=B3 D=1 654
;3?0143;39 06 E03D 57 4/3 =11:;=6<3 ?0E36 C> 4/3 =<<:139
4/=4 4/3> D088 855@ =743; /3; 2;523;8>
312043
4/3>
<56406:39 4/30; /=;=11B364
,
"1
6 23;:1=8 57 4/3 14=43B364 57 630?/C5:;1 0 3
=88 4/313 D04631131 /=E3 <=43?5;0<=88> 14=439
4/=4 =<<:139
=69 4/=4
45 # =;3 ;310906? 06 4/3 1=B3 /5:13
=88 57 4/3B /=;=1139 ;312569364
5 ! C54/
2/>10<=88> =69 B364=88>
5D3E3; 56 23;:1=8 57 4/3 3640;3
</=;?3 1/334 B=43;0=81
234040563;
=<<:139
=69
9014=64
51 # =69
=69
C306? 4/3 C;54/3; 57 =<<:139
;38=40E3
=<<:139
D3;3
132=;=438> =69 4/3;3 =;3 65 1:</
;310906?
=883?=40561
=;3 75;4/<5B06? =?=0614 4/3B
6 1:</ <0;<:B14=6<3 4/3
56.C83
23H
5:;4 06
4/3 <=13 57
;325;439 06
! "# $ %&
=4 2=;=?;=2/
-8-
5 - /389 4/=4 4/3
5:;4 1/5:89 C3 <=;37:8 06 2;5<33906?
=?=0614 4/3 9014=64 ;38=40E31 06 <;0B31 23;4=0606? 45
B=4;0B560=8 9012:431 =69 95D;> 93=4/1
/3 ;38=40E31 57
4/3 /:1C=69 1/5:89 654 C3 ;5239 06 56 4/3 C=101 57
5B60C:1 =883?=40561 :68311 123<070< 0614=6<3 57 4/30;
06E58E3B364 06 4/3 <;0B3 =;3 B=93 5:4
4 01 =815 1344839
25104056 57 8=D 4/=4 07 = 23;156 01 B=93 45 7=<3 = <;0B06=8
4;0=8 56 15B3 ?363;=8 =69 1D33206? =883?=40561 D04/5:4
C;06?06? 56 ;3<5;9 =6> 123<070< 0614=6<31 57 <;0B06=8
<569:<4 04 01 654/06? C:4 =C:13 57 2;5<311 57 4/3
/3
5:;4
5:;41 2513 = 9:4> 45 1:CI3<4 4/3 =883?=4056 83E38839 06
4/3 <5B28=064 45 = 4/5;5:?/ 1<;:406> 45 7069 5:4 D/34/3;
4/3;3 01 =6> ?=06 57 4;:4/ 06 4/3 =883?=40561 5; D/34/3;
4/3> =;3 B=93 568> D04/ 4/3 1583 5CI3<4 57 06E58E06?
<3;4=06 0690E09:=81 06 = <;0B06=8 </=;?3 B5;3 2=;40<:8=;8>
D/36 = 2;513<:4056 =;013 7;5B = B=4;0B560=8 9012:43
$:;4/3; 4/3
' (
#
56JC83
23H
5:;4 06 4/3 <=13 57
-9-
;325;439 06
) *
$$ +*) /389 06 2=;=
51 !
=69 !
=1 :693;
)
!
"
#
$
%
&
$ '
$ '
$ %
, )
(
!
*+,
#
!
(
- 10 -
. !
*+,
#
/ .
"
!
*+,
.
.
-
#
!
#
.
#
!
6 4/3 0614=64 <=13 = C=;3 23;:1=8 57 </=;?3
1/334 B=43;0=81 <83=;8> 1/5D1 4/=4 4/3 =883?=40561 B=93 C>
4/3 <5B28=06=64 ;312569364
=69
5 ! =?=0614 234040563;
=;3 E=?:3 =69 5B60C:1
4/3 /:1C=69 0 3
B364=88>
=<<:139
/=;=1139
;312569364
/3;
D04/
51 #
4/3; 4/=6 <8=0B06? 4/=4
=69 /01 7=B08> B3BC3;1
=
93B=69
75;
95D;>
5 ! /=1 654 2;5E0939 =6> 123<070< 934=081 5;
931<;0C39 =6> 2=;40<:8=; 0614=6<3 57 /=;=11B364
/3 /=1
654 B36405639 4/3 40B3 9=43 28=<3 5; = B=663; 06 D/0</
4/3 =883?39 /=;=11B364 5<<:;;39 5; 4/3 934=081 57 4/3
- 11 -
6=4:;3 57 93B=69 5; 041 2=;40<:8=;1
/3;375;3 4/3 </=;?3
1/334 8=<@1 <56<;343 =69 2;3<013 =883?=40561
/3 43;B
K<;:384>L <=6654 C3 314=C801/39 D04/5:4 123<070< 0614=6<3
/3 1=B3 D3=@361 4/3 <=13 57 4/3 2;513<:4056 =69 <=141
13;05:1 95:C4 56 4/3 2;5C=C0804> 57 4/3 E3;1056 57 4/3
<5B28=06=64
/3 B3;3 ?363;=8 =883?=40561 57 /=;=11B364
D04/5:4 2506406? 5:4 4/3 123<070< 934=081 D5:89 654 C3
1:770<0364 45 <56406:3 <;0B06=8 2;5<33906?1 =?=0614 =6>
23;156
#
4 01 1344839 25104056 57 8=D 4/=4
5:;41 /=E3 45
C3 <=;37:8 =69 <=:405:1 06 93=806? D04/ <5B28=064 =69 B:14
4=@3 2;=?B=40< ;3=804031 0645 <561093;=4056 D/083 93=806?
D04/ B=4;0B560=8 9012:431 D/3;3 4/3 =883?=40561 /=E3 45
C3 1<;:4060G39 D04/ ?;3=4 <=;3 =69 <0;<:B123<4056 06 5;93;
45 2;3E364 B01<=;;0=?3 57 I:140<3 =69 =C:13 57 2;5<311 57
5:;4
6 5E3;=88 23;:1=8 57 4/3 B=43;0=81 56 ;3<5;9
=B 57 4/3 <561093;39 E03D 4/=4 4/3 <56406:=4056 57 <;0B06=8
- 12 -
2;5<33906?1 =?=0614 234040563;
=69
51 # =69
01 654/06? C:4 =C:13 57 2;5<311 57
=<<:139
5:;4 106<3 4/3
1=B3 01 B=6073148> 7;0E585:1 E3H=405:1 =69 061404:439 D04/
4/3 :843;05; B540E3 75; D;3<@06? E36?3=6<3
=883?=4056 06 4/3 $
7=<3 E=8:3
/3 3640;3
=69 </=;?3 1/334 =<<32439 56 4/30;
3E36 4/36 4/3 1=B3 95 654
<561404:43 57736<31 </=;?3 1/33439 =?=0614 234040563;
51 # =69
=<<:139
=69
5D3E3; 106<3 4/3;3
=;3
B=43;0=81 28=<39 =?=0614 234040563;
=69 ! =<<:139
51 ! =69 # 4/3 2;5<33906?1 =?=0614 4/3B
<=6654 C3 A:=1/39
<<5;906?8>
2;5<339 45 2=11 4/3
75885D06?
/3 23404056 01
/3 23404056 06 ;3123<4 57 234040563;
=69
#
!
-
=<<:139
51 !
=69
/3 23404056 06 ;3123<4 57 234040563;
=69
=<<:139
=69
51 #
-
- 13 -
0E
/3 2;5<33906?1 =?=0614 234040563;
=69
=<<:139
*!
( ;0B3
! !!
;3?0143;39
C>
"5B36
=8=C:;=?0
75;
4/3
:693;
3<40561
=69
! !!)
%580<3
4=4056
57736<31
, ( ) #!#
3<4056 #
57 %
9904056=8
0E08 :9?3 =69
51 #
2:601/=C83
-
, ; D
236906? 56 4/3 7083 57
$
=8=C:;=?0
01 /3;3C> A:=1/39
,*
&
"
)
"
"
#
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review