Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
132571
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR_THE
STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYOERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
WEDNES-DAY, THE FOURTEENTH
DAY OF OCTOBER
TWO THOUSAND AND WVCNTV
Sri''""'
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE
Between:
JUWADT SRIDEVI
WRITP ETITION NO: 30 703 0 F 2026
Gujjala Venugopal Reddv. S/o. Keshava
Reddy, Aged About. 2g years, Occ.
Unemptoyed, R/o. H.No 9441,
of Bandarachatam
Mandal, Bhadradri Kothagudem District.
Bil;ra;ffi#^fi;s"
...PETITIONER
AND
1. The State of Telanoana, Rep..by ils principal
Famity Wetfare DR.ER Amoeor<jr.
Secretary, Health, Medical and
s""ot"ili'e;;iing, Ftyoerauao.
2. KNR University of Health.sicences,(KNRUHS),
Rep by its Registrar, Auto
Nagar Road, Warangar, rer"ns"n"_siiboi;i-"",""
3. The Prinicpal, Eshwari Bai, Memorial College
of Nursing
H.No.10_1_b/C, Road
"'
N o. 04, West Marredpalti,
SecunOeri iao--sO'fi
ib.'
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Articre 22-6 0t the constitution
of rndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit
iii"o ih"r"*it'nl'ih" u,gt Court may be pteased
to issue a writ or order, more particurarry
one- rn tne nature of wRrr oF
yl|-DtMys'. decraring the action bt tn" LSpo-na-"nt authorities,
parricurarrv 03d
respondent'
in not takinq-action, not^ietrrrrnj-i"titior"i
iiitiiri'"r''ffi!ilt,y""
certificates i.e. SSC, lnteinediate and
B.Sc. Nuisiig Graduation certificate,
Mark
Memos and Bonifides and rc, which
*"[-"irorii"i'',
*"oa-.
respondent
corege
at the time of admission in MSc Nursint
2019, despite the comoeilin! th" ic"rr,ii,itv'ir"arth Nursing) in the year of
;i"#onouraote court in w.p.No.
2204312024' Dated 18.O9 2oz+'as.
rtbg;t, ;i.o-nrtiiriron"l and consequentrv
direct
the 03'd respondent to rerurn the origina"r
;uaiiii;;iioit"rtiri."t", of the petitioner.
Counsel for the petitioner: SRI yEDOU
DIVAKAR
;;;
Counsel for the Respondent No.1:
Gp FOR MEDICAL, HEALTH & FW
Counsel for the Respondent No.2: SRt
The Court made the following:
ORDER
T. SHARATH, SC FOR KNRUHS
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE
STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HO N' BLE SMT- JUSTIC E JUW
ADISR IDEVI
WRIT PETIT ION No .30703 ot 2026
CNR No .HBHC 0't 0628 922026
DATED 1 4rH oc TOBER 2026
Between:
Gujjala Venugopal Reddy
Petitioner
lhe state of reranqana
I"p,.?V
AND
rts Principai Secretary.
Ig_"lllr l/ledicat and Famity Wetfare,
BR Ambedkar, Secretiriat Buitjing,
PR,
Hyderabad and others.
Respondents
:ORDER:
This Writ petition is filed seeking
the following relief
lo /ssire a Wtl or oder more panicularty
one n the
natL,te ot WR:T OF MANDAMUS
o"",r,,ng- ti"-
t a utho rt E s p a i rcu a rt y OS:i ", i uitio,n,'Jf
riJi, i,
not lakt,tg aclrcn nol
rettr
petitonet"r. arignal
quatificatoin
.
,':'"t{!^
B s,. rvur srns "ei,ncrtu"'
e,i o
#::;.frii i::" Z:i
Bontftde.s and TC whrch"lrr""#
,^/ere subm led
in the 03d
,^1"!?:1":, cottege at rhe ttme - "ri.,","j,2i",,
oi
tvt ac t\turstng (Conmuniv
Heal,
.utg despite rhe comoerino,n"''^-!ltt''9!
.'n the year of
orders ot Hon
bte coun n
w p uo z2oiiti;;"'';;i,':; ''
o'ol
u
L, c o n s t t t i o n a
o i i, *, ! r?i' u ",, " ,rlu
r.espon.dent to rs7a,,
", 111. ongtnatl,quaiticatton
",
",,,
Lh e, r e.spo n de n
I
riii,
t
tt
t
the petittaner and pass
2.
"u,iif,l"t"."r"or
Heard lVlr.yeddu Divakar, learned
l\4r.T.Sharath, Iearned Standing
University of Health Sciences
counsel for the petitioner,
Counsel for Kaloli Narayana
(KNRUHS), appearing
Rao
for respondent
lustlce luwadlSrlder
wp-30/03-2026
No.2 and tvlr.lvl V
Raj Kumar Gabriel' learned counsel
for
respondent No.3-College
Brief facts of the case:
3.1. At the time of his admission
course in
(Community Health Nursing)
into the tVlSc Nursing
respondent No 3-college
his original certificates'
2019, he submitted all
B'sc Nursing
lntermediate Marks Memos'
Certificates
[Iarks Memo and Bonafide
including SSC and
Graduation Certificate'
After attending classes
the college demanded
about one month' since
the first academic
balance tuition fee for
in
for
payment of the
year' without considering
scholarship under the
State
a
for
claim
his
EBC category' the
the course in view
from
discontinued
petitioner
of his financial
difficulties.
respondent
3.2. Thereafter, he approached
No 3-college in2021 '
his admission and return
of
cancellation
requesting
certificates
to return the
As the college refused
of his original
same' he filed Writ
order dated
by an
2024 and this Court'
Petition No 22043 ot
furnish a bond for
to
petitioner
the
directed
18.0g2024,
the
No 2-University in
respondent
of
Rs.1 ,00,0001 in favour
No 3which ' respondent
of
compliance
prescribed format' upon
to return
college was directed
his original certificates
.l
lustice luwadr 5ridevl
wp_10703-2025
3 3. Accordingry, the petitioner
wrth the order dated 1g.0g.2024
certificates after one (01) week.
furnished a bond in compriance
and was initially asked to collect
the
However, when he approached
the
college thereafter, he was asked
to return after one (01) month. ln
the meantime, as his wrfe was pregnant,
he could not approach the
college again
3.4. While so the petitioner has been
srnce 2024.|n view of the
working in a retail shop
notification issued by the Government
Terangana inviting apprications
for recruitment to the post of porice
Constable, for which he claims
respondent No.3-coilege in
to be eligible and approached
August, 2026 and requested return
his original certificates. However, respondent
dernanded a sum of Rs..10,00.000/_
certificates Hence, the present
requrres his original certificates
No.3-college
for release of his original
to
submits that the petitioner
pursue further career
submits that although the petitioner
complied with the order dated
1g.0g.2024 passed by
this Court.
respondent No.3 is withholding
the original certificates of
petitioner which js lllegal
of
writ petition.
Learned counsel for the petitioner
opportunities. He further
of
and arbitrary and would
the
seriously prejudice
lusnce luv!adr Sndevi
wP-30701 2026
Therefore, he seeks a direction
his future employment opportunities
to respondent No.3-college to return the
petitioner's original
certificates.
5.
for respondent No 3 submits
At this juncture, learned counsel
that the petitioner had executed
a bond in the prescribed format
favour of respondent No 2' which
respondent No.2. However' no
was subsequently forwarded to
instructions have been received
respondent No.2 regarding the
in
from
release of the petitioner's original
certificates.
6.
Learned Standing Counsel for
the present writ petition is not
respondent No 2 submits that
maintainable as the petitioner
had
No 22043 of 2024 before
this
in W'P
earlier sought the same relief
Court
7.
submits
Leaned counsel for the petitioner
petition is maintainable and relies
on the order passed by the High
WP
Court of Orissa at Cuttack in
06.01.2023, wherein, paragraph
that the present writ
(C) No 34606 of 2021' dated
No 5 reads as follows:
*{r;##F."j###r!':i:i
availabte at 2003 SC
lustrce_luwadr5r devi
wp 30703_2026
writ petition is vtftua y a petition
:5 lh:s
before thi.:
coud
for enforcement of ne'order p)is;";;';;,;;:;,,
Coy.r1 in- the eartier writ petitioi .O-";;;;i ,;;,;
petilton for enforcement
of'tni ia,rtiir ;r;;7'; ;:;,,
much
maintainabte.
h]:he case of Bibekananda Mondat
v State
teported n (2003) , waln'tcZit)'i,"so,
Y?*
tt
t'n t 'ut t Dre Ooutl sncctfically
held that withour
,:.:!::,:s a pro.ceeding for contempt
u:y otder or proceeding a"'r" iithe coun cat,
7:,?:,
diiis",i."r
?9.
3::f:
orler which may atso taitamount
lu,ch
tne relevant
portion from t
,;-";;;;;;:.
pagment is qii:;;';"i;;;i;!"7:"nraph 6 or the said
".€
B therefore. setued
thal the second
1t appltcaton ,s taw
natntainabb ir
A -.,1t
tmple.mentaton ol an eartar
"ne
oi
*", t
Coutl This Coud must issue oroe,
proper direclions
to, pt \.) pe r i m ple me nt a i
o n of p revt otis
;, ;;;;;;;
Where there has been an
oider, m" irarr,iri,t
t
be comptied wfth. An
dtsobedience ot u ciun'"Jro!?,i.,:^,*!:,i,,.
cantempt. but atso.
,teg"iino"inrJiaZll
t:-e
used
Antcb zza,
t ..tanguage
,,
n
onshtu.ton ot
J ii"
tndia is
camprehensive phraseology
coucne-i ri,
and the saia Articte
recognizes a very wde
c o u i s ro o
ai,!, i, i,iu :iy:',
*
"?
i,,,:fr ,:;q
n
Supreme Courl in rhe case
:l^^:!" Prasad
ot
tuandan
v. Statc of Ain", ,upo,tZd Devaki
\r"'it|
7983 SC 1134 enteftarneJ
a.
"
"rZ
u n ct e r A r t c t e
tr ; ;' i;
{':, "f:J,;,:.rZ
p.a.ss,ed speciftc
order ctuecting the authorily
O dZ
y/::: was earter directed ny tie Supremi d.;;;;
tne
:
r
hrst writ appltcation.
B
rt is not in dispute that
M -sc Nursing (community
,
the petitioner secured admission
Hearth Nursing) course in
No.3-College, discontinued
certiflcates are prei;ently
to the
respondent
his studies, and that his original
in the custody of respondent
not n dispute that the petitioner
18.09 2024 passed in
;:;;,:
No.3. rt is arso
has complied with the order
W.p.No.22 043 of 2O2a
dated
by furnishing the
lusnce luwad 5r devr
wp 30703-2026
requisite bond. However, despite such
compliance' respondent No 3
has failed to return the original certificates
contrary to the orders
demanded Rs.10,00,000/- for their release'
passed by this Court' The said certificates'
personal and academic credentials' cannot
Even assuming that respondent No
against the petitioner, it is open to
and has allegedly
being the petitioner's
be withheld indefinitely'
3 has any monetary claim
the College to pursue appropriate
remedies in accordance with law'
but it cannot withhold the
petitioner's original certificates to recover
Therefore, the continued retention
the alleged dues
of the petitioner's certificates is
unjustified and the petitioner is entitled
for immediate return of his
certificates
9.
For the foregoing reasons' this Writ
directing respondent No'3 to return
the original certificates referred
period of
to above to the petitioner within a
date of receipt of a copy of this
Petition is disposed of'
one (01) week from the
order' No costs'
Pending miscellaneous applications'
closed
if any' shall stand
SD/- P.C. SULEKHA DEVI
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
,ITRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To,
The Principal Secretary, Health, Medical
& Family'.Welfare The State of
4-'
Hy.derabad
i"["g;";iDn.BR Ambedkar Secretariat Building'
;-i;'lth Sicenies'(Kt'tRUHS)' Auto Nagar
2 The Registrar, xnn univ#iti
Road, Warangal, Telangana-506002
The-Prinicpal, Eshwari Bai, Memorial College of Nursing H.No.10_1_5/C,
Road
No. 04, West Marredpalli, Secunderabad_SO-0026.
4 One CC to SRt YEDDU DIVAKAR, Advocate IOPUCI
5 One CC to SRt T. SHARATH, SC FOR KNRUHS
tOiUCl
6 Two CCs to GP FOR MEDICAL, HEALTH & FW, High dourt
for the State of
Telangana, at Hyderabad [OUT]
7 Two CD Copies
BN
M,
CC TODAY
HIGH COURT
DATED: 1411012026
SlATE OF
(
(
ORDER
l-
0(
WP.No.30703 of 2026
)
o
o
\5 s$
1$l$
r oE6'' rJ.(
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
t ,\
b
\
tt,
C
o
!
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review