Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT GWALIOR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE SUNITA YADAV
ON THE 8th OF JANUARY, 2024
CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 269 of 2008
BETWEEN:GUDDIBAI W/O SHRI BALKISHAN, AGED
ABOUT 45 YEARS, R/O VILLAGE
BADARWAS, THANA PICHHOR, DISTRICT
SHIVPURI (MADHYA PRADESH)
….....APPELLANT
SHRI
ADVOCATE)
(BY
SANJEEV
AGRAWAL
-
AND
STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH
POLICE STATION PICHHORE, DISTRICT
SHIVPURI (M.P.)
….....RESPONDENT
(BY
SHRI
APS
PROSECUTOR)
TOMAR
-
PUBLIC
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------This appeal coming on for hearing this day, the court passed the following:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------JUDGMENT
This appeal has been filed by the appellant under Section 374(2)
of Cr.P.C. being aggrieved by the judgment dated 26/02/2008 passed by
Additional Sessions Judge Pichhore, District Shivpuri in S.T.
No.202/2003 whereby, appellant has been convicted under Section 304B of IPC to undergo Seven Years R.I. and under Section 201 of IPC to
Signed by: VIPIN KUMAR
AGRAHARI
Signing time: 12-01-2024
10:06:55 AM
undergo One Year R.I. with fine of Rs.1,000/- with default stipulations.
2.
As per prosecution story, short facts of the case leading to filing
of this criminal appeal are that deceased – Rachna was married to Azad,
son of appellant Guddibai 13-14 months before her death. After
marriage, Rachna went from her in-laws' house to her parents house and
when she used to come, she used to tell her parents that her husband and
in-laws beat her and asked her to get a motorcycle or fifty thousand
rupees. On date 17.07.2003, Rachna's brother Pragilal (PW-5) due to
birthday of his five year old son, brought Rachna from her in-laws'
house. On the next day, co-accused Balkishan came and while taking
Rachna away said that they would be able to see her face only if give
him a motorcycle or fifty thousand rupees. About ten days later, on
30.7.2003, Rachna's husband Azad informed that Rachna had been
bitten by a snake. After receiving the information when the parents of
Rachna went to her in-laws' house to see her, they met the accused, his
son and other persons near the village Jarai and the body of Rachna was
kept in a jeep. Co-accused Balkishan as well as his son Ajad told that
Rachna had been bitten by a snake and thereafter they went to village
Himmatpur for taking the medicine of snakebite where this fact was
revealed that the death of Rachna was not on account of snake bite,
rather she died by hanging. After this, Rachna was taken to Hospital and
thereafter, the matter was informed to the police. On this information,
merg was registered and after investigation and recording of statements
of the relatives of the deceased, on the basis of merg enquiry and
circumstantial evidence a case was registered against the husband,
mother-in-law & father-in-law by the Police Station Pichhore at Crime
No.176/2003 for the offences punishable under Sections 304-B, 201 of
Signed by: VIPIN KUMAR
AGRAHARI
Signing time: 12-01-2024
10:06:55 AM
IPC. After completing the due investigation, charge-sheet was filed
before the competent court having criminal jurisdiction for the aforesaid
offences.
3.
Learned trial Court after hearing learned counsel for the rival
parties and after appreciating the evidence available on record,
convicted the appellant/accused under Section 304-B of IPC to undergo
rigorous imprisonment of Seven Years and under Section 201 of IPC to
undergo rigorous imprisonment of One Year with fine of Rs.1,000/with default stipulation. Being aggrieved by the impugned judgement of
conviction and order of sentence dated 26-02-2008 passed by
Additional Sessions Judge, Pichhore, District Shivpuri (Madhya
Pradesh) in S.T. No.202/2003, the accused / appellant has filed the
instant criminal appeal.
4.
Learned counsel for the appellant / accused argued that learned
trial Court has wrongly convicted the appellant ignoring the fact that the
father of deceased (PW-3) Harcharan, mother (PW-4) Smt. Benibai,
brother (PW-5) Pragilal, independent witness (PW-7), sister-in-law
(PW-9) Savita have not supported the case of prosecution and turned
hostile in respect to allegations of cruelty or harassment for demand of
dowry. It is further argued that the learned trial Court merely on the
basis of evidence of (PW-12) Suresh, convicted the appellant. Further
argument is that (PW-12) himself admitted that he has separate living
with the family of deceased, in these circumstances, when (PW-12) has
separate living and has nothing to day to day affairs by the family of
deceased, merely on the basis of evidence of this witness, learned trial
Court has wrongly convicted the appellant that soon before the death of
deceased, she was subjected to cruelty for demand of dowry. It is
Signed by: VIPIN KUMAR
AGRAHARI
Signing time: 12-01-2024
10:06:55 AM
submitted that the appellant has already suffered almost nine months of
incarceration out of total jail sentence awarded to her. It is further
submitted that the prosecution has failed to bring any cogent evidence
against the appellant with regard to demand of dowry, therefore, the
impugned judgment passed by trial Court be set aside and the appellant
be acquitted from all the charges.
5.
On the other hand, learned counsel for respondent/State submitted
that after due appreciation of evidence, learned trial Court has found the
offence proved against the appellant which requires no interference. He
has further submitted that there is ample evidence to show that the
deceased was subjected to mental and physical cruelty soon before her
death which is supported by the evidence of (PW-12). Hence, the appeal
filed by the appellant be dismissed.
6.
Heard learned counsel for the rival parties and perused the
material available on record.
7.
Prosecution has examined as many as 13 witnesses i.e. (PW-1)
Gopaldas, (PW-2) Dr. Ajay Kumar Pathak, (PW-3) Harcharan, (PW-4)
Smt. Benibai, (PW-5) Pragilal, (PW-6) Komal, (PW-7) Jagdish, (PW-8)
Ramkishan, (PW-9) Savita, (PW-10) Om Prakash Dubey, (PW-11)
Pankaj Shrivastava, (PW-12) Suresh & (PW-13) C.P. Singh to prove its
case. It is not disputed between the parties that deceased was married to
co-accused Ajad, son of appellant. It is also not disputed that Rachna
had died within seven years of her marriage. (PW-2) Dr. Ajay Kumar
Pathak has been examined to prove the cause of death and according to
this witness, deceased died on account of asphyxia due to hanging.
Thus, the prosecution has proved that death of the deceased was within
seven years of her marriage due to hanging now it has to seen whether
Signed by: VIPIN KUMAR
AGRAHARI
Signing time: 12-01-2024
10:06:55 AM
appellant harassed the deceased soon before her death for demand of
dowry.
8.
Prosecution has examined (PW-3) Harcharan who is father of
deceased, (PW-4) Smt. Benibai who is mother of deceased, (PW-5)
Pragilal who is brother of deceased, (PW-7) Jagdish who is an
independent witness, (PW-9) Savita who is sister-in-law of deceased &
(PW-12) Suresh who is cousin of deceased to prove the factum of
cruelty or harassment on deceased by the appellant. (PW-3) Harcharan,
(PW-4) Smt. Benibai, (PW-5) Pragilal, (PW-7) Jagdish & (PW-9) Savita
have not supported the case of prosecution and turned hostile. Even the
independent witness (PW-7) Jagdish has not supported the case of
prosecution. Learned trial Court has convicted the appellant on the basis
of statement of (PW-12) Suresh who is cousin of the deceased.
According to this witness, appellant as well as co-accused persons have
demanded the motorcycle or fifty thousand rupees as dowry to the
father of deceased (PW-3) Harcharan, however, (PW-3) has not
supported the statement of this witness that appellant has demanded a
motorcycle of fifty thousand rupees. (PW-3) Harcharan has specifically
stated that no demand was made by the appellant or his family
members. In these circumstances when according to this witness (PW3), appellant has not demanded dowry from him, more so, father,
mother, brother as well as sister-in-law of the deceased have also denied
that any demand was made by the appellant or his family members, the
statement of (PW-12) Suresh who is cousin brother and living
separately does not prove beyond reasonable doubt that appellant
caused cruelty soon before her death for demand of dowry.
9.
Signed by: VIPIN KUMAR
AGRAHARI
Signing time: 12-01-2024
10:06:55 AM
(PW-12) Suresh is not an eye-witness of alleged act of cruelty or
harassment. This witness has admitted that he was residing separately
with the family of deceased. According to the statements of (PW-12)
Suresh, he met the deceased Rachna on the occasion of birthday of the
son of Pragilal (PW-5) and the deceased informed him about the
demand of dowry, however, there is omission in Police statement in this
respect, therefore, the statement of this witness cannot be relied upon.
This witness has admitted that Rachna informed him about alleged
demand of dowry, but he never lodged any report. In these
circumstances, merely on the basis of evidence of this witness which is
not supported by the statements of parents, brother as well as sister-inlaw of the deceased and there is material omission in respect to
allegations regarding demand of dowry between his court statement and
police statements, the statements of (PW-12) Suresh cannot be relied
upon and thus, learned trial Court committed error in relying upon the
testimony of (PW-12) Suresh.
10.
The appellant can be convicted and punished only when by
leading cogent evidence, the prosecution proved its case to the hilt. As
noticed above, the prosecution could not establish its case beyond
reasonable doubt. The evidence must be of sterling quality and should
be of a nature that a conclusion can be drawn that appellant and
appellant alone ‘must’ have committed the offence and not that
appellant perhaps/might have committed the offence. The prosecution
could not satisfy the aforesaid litmus test in the instant case.
11.
The order of conviction can be based only on legal evidence and
not on hypothetical propositions or unwarranted inference. A moral
conviction regarding the guilt of an individual has no place in criminal
jurisprudence. In this case, there is no satisfactory proof to make out the
Signed by: VIPIN KUMAR
AGRAHARI
Signing time: 12-01-2024
10:06:55 AM
charges against the appellant. Therefore, the appellant is entitled for
acquittal.
12.
After perusal of evidence on record, this Court is of the opinion
that the prosecution has utterly failed to meet out the essential
ingredients of Sections 304-B & 201 of IPC since the material witnesses
have turned hostile and the best evidence i.e. conversation of deceased
“soon before her death” nothing depicts any sort of demand of dowry
and cruelty thereof.
13.
Thus, considering the evidence which has been led by the
prosecution as the learned trial court committed grave error in ignoring
and glossing over various contradictions in the testimony of (PW-12),
this Court is of the considered opinion that the prosecution has failed to
establish any charge against the appellant, beyond reasonable doubt,
accordingly, she is acquitted of charges under Sections 304-B & 201 of
IPC. The appellant is also acquitted from all the charges appended
against her.
14.
Resultantly, the judgment and sentence dated 26/02/2008 passed
by Additional Sessions Judge Pichhore, District Shivpuri in S.T. No.
202/2003 is hereby set aside.
15.
The appellant is on bail. Her bail bonds and surety bonds stand
discharged and the fine amount paid, if any, be returned to the appellant.
16.
The appeal succeeds and is hereby allowed.
17.
A copy of this order is sent to the court below concerned.
18.
Record be sent back to the concerned trial court.
19.
Certified copy, as per rules.
(SUNITA YADAV )
JUDGE
Vpn/-
Signed by: VIPIN KUMAR
AGRAHARI
Signing time: 12-01-2024
10:06:55 AM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review