The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. The impugned order at Annexure-C and order passed by the revisional authority suffers from patent illegality, and warranting interference by this Court. The ratio laid down in the case of Vyshali Mahila Samaj aptly applies to the facts of the present case and the point framed for consideration is answered accordingly. Hence, this Court pass the following; - 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:25 WP No. 106786 of 2015 HC-KAR i) The Writ Petition is allowed. ii) The resolution/ recommendation dated 22.12.2012 allotting the civic amenity site dated 22.12.2012 allotting the civic amenity site bearing plot No.69, block No.345 of Gamanagatti village in favour of respondent No.4 is hereby quashed and the order dated revisional
16. 05.2015 authority by passed by the dismissing the petitioner’s revision petition is also hereby set aside. iii) The matter is remitted back to the respondent No.1 for fresh consideration, and pass appropriate order strictly in accordance with Rule of the Karnataka Urban Development Authorities (Allotment of Civic Amenity Sites) Rules, 1991 and as per the - 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:25 WP No. 106786 of 2015 HC-KAR law laid down in Vyshali Mahila Samaj case after affording the opportunity to all the eligible applicants, such consideration shall be completed within a reasonable period that is preferably three [3] months from the date of receipt of copy of this order, till such consideration, the respondents shall not take any coercive action against the respondent No.4. iv) All the conditions of the parties are kept open. Sd/JUSTICE K.S.HEMALEKHA PJ/ Ct:VH List No.: 1 Sl No.: 34
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:25
WP No. 106786 of 2015
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 5TH DAY OF JANUARY 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE K.S.HEMALEKHA
WRIT PETITION NO. 106786 OF 2015 (LB-RES)
BETWEEN:
GRAMEENA ABHIRUDDHI AND SAMUHA
SIKSHANA SAMITHI, R/BY ITS TRUSTEE,
MAHESH BELLAD S/O. SHIVAPUTRA BELLAD
AGE: 70 YEARS,
R/O. “GOURI KRUPA”,
MARATHA COLONY ROAD, DHARWAD.
…PETITIONER
(BY SRI. RAMACHANDRA V.BHAT, ADVOCATE FOR
SRI. F.V.PATIL, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
THE PRESIDENT
HUBLI-DHARWAD URBAN DEVELOPMENT
AUTHORITY, SUB-COMMITTEE FOR
DISTRIBUTION OF CIVIC AMENITY SITES,
NAVNAGAR, HUBBALLI, DIST: DHARWAD.
2.
THE COMMISSIONER
HUBLI-DHARWAD URBAN DEVELOPMENT
AUTHORITY, NAVNAGAR, HUBBALLI,
DIST: DHARWAD.
3.
THE PRESIDENT
HUBLI-DHARWAD MAHANAGARA PALIKE,
HUBBALLI, DIST: DHARWAD.
MANJANNA
E
MANJANNA E
Location: HIGH COURT OF
KARNATAKA DHARWAD
BENCH
Date: 2026.01.29 10:13:41
+0530
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:25
WP No. 106786 of 2015
HC-KAR
4.
THE PRESIDENT
REVIVAL FOUNDATION SIKSHANA SAMITHI,
NO.37, RUDRAGANGA LAYOUT,
DOLLARS COLONY, AIRPORT ROAD,
POST BOX NO. 415, HUBBALLI,
DIST: DHARWAD.
5.
THE SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT
OF KARNATAKA URBAN DEVELOPMENT
MULTI STORAGE BUILDING,
AMBEDKAR VEEDHI,
BANGALORE-560001.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. G.I.GACHCHINAMATH, ADVOCATE FOR R1 TO R3;
SRI. B.SHARANABASAWA, ADVOCATE FOR R2;
SRI. VEERESH R.BUDIHAL, ADVOCATE FOR C/R4;
SRI. ASHOK T.KATTIMANI, AGA FOR R5)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND
227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE
IMPUGNED ORDER DATED 16.05.2015 PASSED BY THE 5TH
RESPONDENT
IN
REVISION
PETITION
NO.2013
(UDD257
BeMaPra2013) VIDE ANNEXURE-G AND ETC.
THIS WRIT PETITION COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY
HEARING IN ‘B’ GROUP THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN
AS UNDER:
CORAM:
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE K.S.HEMALEKHA
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:25
WP No. 106786 of 2015
HC-KAR
ORAL ORDER
The petitioner has approached this Court calling in
question
resolution/recommendation
dated
22.12.2012,
whereby the civic amenity site bearing plot No.69, block
No.345 of Gamanagatti village, came to be allotted in
favour of respondent No.4 and the consequential order
dated
16.05.2015
passed
by
the
revisional
authority
dismissing the petitioner’s revision petition.
2.
Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner and
the learned counsel appearing for the respondents and
perused the material on record.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner contends that
the petitioner is a public charitable educational trust and
was an eligible applicant for civic amenity site. Learned
counsel for the petitioner submits that the competent
authority while considering multiple applications including
that of the petitioner, has failed to apply the mandatory
parameters
under
Rule
of
the
Karnataka
Urban
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:25
WP No. 106786 of 2015
HC-KAR
Development Authorities (Allotment of Civic Amenity Sites)
Rules 1991 (for short ‘Rules 1991’) which prescribed the
selection criteria governing allotment of civic amenity site.
It is further contended that the resolution dated 22.12.2012
is a cryptic and does not disclose comparative assessment.
Further that the revisional authority has failed to examine
the statutory valuation and has dismissed the revision
petition by a non speaking order. Learned counsel for the
petitioner places reliance on the decision of the coordinate
Bench of this Court in the case of Vyshali Mahila Samaj,
by its President Vs. State of Karnataka, by Secretary
to Government, Housing and Another1 (Vyshali Mahila
Samaj).
4.
Learned counsel for the respondents in support
of their objections filed, have contended that, the allotment
was
made
by
a
duly
constituted
Committee
after
considering the applications received and that respondent
ILR 2004 Kar 2297
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:25
WP No. 106786 of 2015
HC-KAR
No.4 was found suitable for allotment and the decision is an
administrative one, not warranting any interference.
5.
Learned counsel appearing for respondent No.4
in support of his objections specifically contends that, the
petitioner/institution has been allotted civic amenity sites
through other institutions of the petitioner, and that the
petitioner is not entitled for further allotment. This Court
vide order dated 04.11.2025 directed the petitioner to file
an affidavit.
6.
Pursuant to the order dated 04.11.2025, the
petitioner has filed affidavit categorically stating that it has
no connection whatsoever with the institutions referred to in
Exs.R.1 to R.4 of the statement of objections.
7.
This
Court
has
carefully
considered
the
contentions urged by the learned counsel for the parties and
perused the material available on record.
8.
Having heard the learned counsels, the point that
would arise for consideration is;
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:25
WP No. 106786 of 2015
HC-KAR
Whether
the
allotment
of
civic
amenity site in favour of respondent No.4 is
sustainable in law having regard to Rule 7 of
the Rules, 1991 and as per the law laid down
by the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in the
case of Vyshali Mahila Samaj ?
9.
Rule 7 of the Rules 1991, which reads as under;
“7.
Principles
of
selection
of
Institutions for leasing out Civic Amenity
Sites.-(1) The Authority shall consider the case
of each institution on its merits and shall have
special regard to the following principles in
making the selection(a) The objectives and activities of the institution
and public cause served by it since its
establishment;
(b) The financial position of the institution;
(c) The present location of the institution;
(d) The benefit likely to accrue to the general
public of the locality by allotment of the civic
amenity site;
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:25
WP No. 106786 of 2015
HC-KAR
(e) The bona fide and genuineness of the
institution as made out in the annual reports,
audit report etc.;
(f) The need of the civic amenity site by the
institution for providing the civic amenity in
question.
(2) For the purpose of sub-rule (1), the
authority may constitute a separate committee
to
be
called
"Civic
Amenity
Site
Allotment
Committee" consisting of three Official members
and three non-official members. The Chairman of
the Authority shall be the chairman of the civic
amenity site allotment Committee.
(3)
Subject
to
the
approval
of
the
authority, the decision of the Civic Amenity Site
Allotment Committee shall be final.”
10.
Rule 7 of the Rules 1991 mandates that the
authority shall consider the case of each of the institution
on its merits, having special regard to the six enumerated
criteria namely the objectives of the institution, the financial
position, the present location, benefit likely to accrue to the
general public, bonafides and genuineness of the institution
and the need of civic amenity site by the institution. The
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:25
WP No. 106786 of 2015
HC-KAR
use of expression “shall” make the provisions mandatory to
be followed. This Court in the case of Vyshali Mahila
Samaj has held at paragraph Nos.7 and 8 as under;
“7. I have carefully examined the order under
review with reference to the aforesaid rules and the
provisions of the Act. By a careful reading of Rule
3(3) of the Rules. It is clear that due publicity has to
be given in respect of allotment of civic amenity site
which
is
earmarked
in
the
layout
plan.
The
2nd respondent has not produced any material to
show that the said statutory requirement has been
complied with. By a perusal of Annexure-F, it is clear
that the authority has considered the application of
the
petitioner
and
the
3rd respondent
and
recommended for allotment of civic amenity site in
question in favour of the 3rd respondent without
following the principles enumerated under Clauses
(a) to (f) of Rule 7(1) of the Rules for the purpose of
allotting the civic amenity site. Therefore, there is
blatant violation of the above said Statutory Rules by
the
2nd respondent
in
passing
the
impugned
resolution at Annexure-F which resolution has been
approved by the first respondent though, it is not
necessary under law. The Supreme Court in the case
reported in BABU VERGHESE AND OTHERS vs BAR
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:25
WP No. 106786 of 2015
HC-KAR
COUNCIL OF KERALA AND OTHERS considering the
Privy Council Judgment in NAZIR AHMAD vs KING
EMPEROR and its earlier judgments reported in RAO
SHIV
BAHADUR
CHAND vs STATE
SINGH vs STATE
OF
OF
U.P. DEEP
RAJASTHAN and STATE
OF
U.P. vs SINGHARA SINGH has at paragraphs 31 and
32 clearly held as follows:—
“31. It is the basic principle of law long settled
that if the manner of doing a particular act is
prescribed under any statute, the act must be done
in that manner or not at all. The origin of this rule is
traceable,
to
the
decision
in TAYLOR vs TAYLOR which was followed by Lord
Roche
in NAZIR
AHMED vs KIND
EMPEROR who
stated as under:
“Where a power is given to do certain thing in a
certain way the thing must be done in that way or
not at all.”
(32) This Rule has since been approved by this
Court in RAO SHIV BAHADUR SINGH vs STATE OF
U.P and
again
in DEEP
CHAND vs STATE
OF
RAJASTHAN. These cases were considered by a
Three Judge Bench of this Court in STATE OF
U.P. vs ZINBHARA SINGH and the rule laid down in
NAZEER AHMED CASE was again upheld. This Rule
has since been applied to the exercise of jurisdiction
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:25
WP No. 106786 of 2015
HC-KAR
by Courts and has also been recognised as a salutary
principle of administrative law.”
8. In the absence of producing any material
documents by respondents 1 and 2 to show that the
2nd respondent before passing the resolution at
Annexure-F,
has
complied
with
the
mandatory
requirement of due publicity as required under Rule
3(3) of the Rules, it amounts that it has not complied
with the mandatory requirements as provided in the
said Rule. Therefore, the action of passing the
resolution by the 2nd respondent is contrary to the
statutory and mandatory duty by it as held by the
Supreme Court in the case referred to supra.
Further, the 2nd respondent has not complied with
Rule 7(1) in not examining the claim of the petitioner
and the 3rd respondent keeping in view the guiding
principles enumerated under Clauses (a) to (f) of the
above said Rule. This is also one more error which
has crept in, in the impugned order passed by the
2nd respondent which important aspect of the matter
has not been taken into consideration by the first
respondent at the time of approving the resolution of
the 2nd respondent Though, non-compliance of Rules
3(3) and 7(1) of the Rules was not urged in the Writ
Petition,
this
Court
should
have
examined
the
legality and validity of the order from the record of
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:25
WP No. 106786 of 2015
HC-KAR
the respondents 1 and 2 while exercising its writ of
certiorari
jurisdiction
keeping
in
view
the
law
applicable to the case on hand. However, this Court
has not noticed the above said provisions of the Act
and Rules referred to supra which is one of the
ground for reviewing the impugned order in this
petition as it has rendered the impugned order voidab initio in law for non-compliance of the mandatory
statutory duty by respondent No.2.”
11.
This Court has categorically held that the non-
consideration of the parameters under Rule 7 of the Rules
1991 vitiates the allotment and renders such allotment void
ab initio, being arbitrary and contrary to the statutory
mandate. In the present case, on perusal of the resolution
dated
22.12.2012,
it
is
evident
that
the
allotment
committee has not recorded even a semblance of reasoning
nor has it demonstrated consideration of Rule 7 of the Rules
1991 parameters. The resolution merely states that the
respondent No.4 is suitable, however, without disclosing as
to why the petitioner was found unsuitable and how the
statutory parameter was satisfied. The revisional authority
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:25
WP No. 106786 of 2015
HC-KAR
who is the appellate authority, instead of rectifying the
illegality that has been passed in the resolution dated
22.12.2012, has dismissed the revision petition by a cryptic
order without addressing the statutory violation pointed out
by the petitioner.
12.
This Court also takes note of the affidavit filed by
the petitioner pursuant to the order dated 04.11.2025,
wherein the petitioner had categorically stated that it has no
connection whatsoever with the institution preferred in any
of the Annexures [Exs.R.1 to 4].
13.
The impugned order at Annexure-C and order
passed by the revisional authority suffers from patent
illegality, and warranting interference by this Court. The
ratio laid down in the case of Vyshali Mahila Samaj aptly
applies to the facts of the present case and the point
framed for consideration is answered accordingly. Hence,
this Court pass the following;
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:25
WP No. 106786 of 2015
HC-KAR
ORDER
i)
The Writ Petition is allowed.
ii)
The
resolution/
recommendation
dated 22.12.2012 allotting the civic amenity
site dated 22.12.2012 allotting the civic
amenity
site
bearing
plot
No.69,
block
No.345 of Gamanagatti village in favour of
respondent No.4 is hereby quashed and the
order
dated
revisional
16.05.2015
authority
by
passed
by
the
dismissing
the
petitioner’s revision petition is also hereby
set aside.
iii)
The matter is remitted back to the
respondent No.1 for fresh consideration, and
pass appropriate order strictly in accordance
with
Rule
of
the
Karnataka
Urban
Development Authorities (Allotment of Civic
Amenity Sites) Rules, 1991 and as per the
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:25
WP No. 106786 of 2015
HC-KAR
law laid down in Vyshali Mahila Samaj
case after affording the opportunity to all the
eligible applicants, such consideration shall
be completed within a reasonable period
that is preferably three [3] months from the
date of receipt of copy of this order, till such
consideration, the respondents shall not take
any coercive action against the respondent
No.4.
iv)
All the conditions of the parties are
kept open.
Sd/JUSTICE K.S.HEMALEKHA
PJ/ Ct:VH
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 34
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review